Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MonsterTalk

MonsterTalk artwork

S03E46 Darren Naish pt 1: The Dogman

Aug 12, 202439 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Part one of a two-part discussion with paleontologist Darren Naish about the history of Dogman lore. Next week in part two, we discuss the current state of cryptozoology. Darren's Dogman Article (TetZoo) STM - Beast of Bray Road (YouTube) Drive down Bray Road on your computer (Google Maps) Linda Godfrey's Obituary Beast of Bray Road (wiki) Dogman (wiki) Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You're listening to an air wave media podcast, Monster House Presents.

Speaker 2It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.

Speaker 3A giant, hairy creature. Part eight parts in Luckness, a twenty four mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland. It's a creature known as the Luckness Monster.

Speaker 2Monstert Welcome to It's a Monster Talk the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. Hey, they're Monster Talkers. Karen's away on business for a bit and I had a chance to snag an interview that couldn't wait. So she's not going to be in the next couple of episodes, but she will be back soon now. What follows is the first of a two part chat with friend of the show, palaeontologist Darren Nash. Darren hosts the Tetrapod Zoology blog and he just dropped a really great comprehensive wrap up of the dog Man phenomenon. You'll

Speaker 2want to read the whole thing, of course, and I've linked to it in the show notes. Also, the indie monster movie company Small Town Monsters has released their twenty eighteen documentary The Beast of Bray Road on YouTube, so you can check that out for free as well, and we'll talk about that in the interview, and that's linked in the show notes. Darren and I were able to talk for a full hour this week, so first we'll be looking at dog Man and next week we'll continue the conversation and look at the state of the whole field of cryptozoology. This conversation with Darren is what I've been having with multiple people online, and I hope to

Speaker 2evente do some kind of roundtable. But I really appreciate Darien taking the time to share his thoughts, so tune in for that next week.

Speaker 3More instrutal.

Speaker 2Well, Darien, I know we have limited time. That's my fault for having a day job. You've got one too, Now, is that something you can talk about or is that a secret?

Speaker 3I work for the Natural History unit at the BBC, which is a fantastic job, and I've worked since about twenty eighteen making TV shows. Can't say what I'm doing right now, but in the past I've made I've been involved in the making of a Prehistoric Planet, which was released on Apple TV Plus. So get to hang out with Sir David Attenborough and John Favreau and many other people. That's fantastic doing that.

Speaker 4That's my full time job.

Speaker 3But then in the background, like an idiot, I try and do research and publish books and get technical papers out there, and obviously still blog a techable zoology.

Speaker 2Yeah, well that's actually while we're talking today. Now, dog Man's been on my radar for a while and I've been meaning to do something deep on it, but you beat me to it, and I thought how efficient I could have you on and we could talk about the same stuff I wanted to talk about. But you've done all the hard work.

Speaker 3That's very special. The surface really well it.

Speaker 2You know, it's interesting because there's so many different ways to slice this up in the part of what I want to talk about today is, you know, the different sort of categories and ways to approach this topic. But yeah, I've been following dog Man for a while and I've met I got to meet Linda Godfried, and you know, I just I got a real sort of vibe. In fact, if you think about it, our shows started kind of as a response to Monster Quest, and Monster Quest sort of ended famously with a dog Man episode, which actually

Speaker 2I think is one of their best episodes, which is kind of sad, but let's talk about it. So dog Man currently having a real surgeon popularity. What's going on with dog Man?

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I've been thinking for a long time that you can't move within monster Research or cryptos Orgy without like hearing people talk about dog Man. As you know, if you are in the right Facebook groups and if you interact with the right or inverted commons scare quotes around right people on social media, then yeah, it's there all the time. And I've been saying for a while to colleagues who aren't in this world that you do

Speaker 3realize that it's not okay. The cryptos orgy Monster research these days is yeah, bigfoot yetti NeSSI that they're popular as ever, But then math Man is in the top five and dog Man, and then you have to explain to people what dog Man is, and it's like, yeah, this is the thing that a section of the community is thinking about a lot, talking about a lot, and I get the impression that, you know, this might be way off, but it's something like something that's surprising me hard,

Speaker 3Like one in every twenty kind of North American monster reports of the sort of Bigfoot type genre are dog Man reports if you listen to the you know, the sort of podcasts, you know, look at what YouTubers put out who cover this stuff, and yeah, dog Man is like that is there all the time. It started out as the Michigan dog Man obviously, you know, kind of related to the phenomenon in Wisconsin as well, so it's an animal of the creature of the Midwest. But yeah,

Speaker 3then it kind of expanded to be all North America, and then such as the popularity of monster research these days, that it doesn't take long for Spanish speaking people to start reporting it from the Spanish speaking parts of the world, which kind of makes sense. You know, if there's a thing in North America, it's going to be in Spanish speaking North America, and then Central America and South America and then the Peans. You know, we love getting another stuff. We love pretending that we've got big foot here in the bas Uk and elsewhere in Europe. And likewise, for dog Man, dog Man is now believe it or not,

Speaker 3or maybe this is not surprising at all that there's now kind of like a British bunch of people that are claiming that we're the sightings in the UK.

Speaker 2Well, I think he's equally biologically plausible there as here. That's so, what are we talking about? What does a dog man for listeners who somehow have managed to listen to this show and night hear of it before.

Speaker 3Yeah, so I've just published this article where I decided in the end to use the term werewolf in the title of the articles as a kind of hook to get people in because basically, we are talking about the dog headed humanoid of popular lore. We are talking about an animal the size of a large person, you know, maybe six foot tall, and with a human like physique, maybe with a tail, maybe with dog like feet, so

Speaker 3with the ankles hype off the ground, not flat on the ground like in animals like us. And you're talking about a giant head, so a giant dog like head. You really are talking about the the werewolf of yeah, popular cinematic Yeah, yeah, cinematic type. Yeah. And on the one hand, so we do have this idea. It is mentioned every time the topic of dog man slash American werewolf is discussed. People say, well, you know, this idea has been around since forever. The sin of cephally the

Speaker 3dog headed monster or creature of mythology.

Speaker 2Has been around Chris, right, Yeah, but there's a whole bunch of exactly among others.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I mean they go all the way back into like you know, Greek and Roman mythology. There are there are many tales of dog headed humanoids that are sometimes connected to the underworld. And in the broadest take on on this kind of discussion, you could argue that this goes hand in hand with the entire concept of theory anthropy, the whole idea that that humans can transmography,

Speaker 3can turn into other animal forms, and that we've always, you know, for as long as humans have existed, we've had this idea of hybrids or sort of intermediates between humans and other animals. And I say that we've had this forever because of course we've actually got you know, claimed pieces of rock art from you know, Paleolithic era rock art tens of thousands of years old that that depicts.

Speaker 4Human non human animal you know, mix and.

Speaker 2Match kind of messa.

Speaker 3Yeah. So, so on the one hand, it's like has the has the concept always been there? It's not an invention of you know, twentieth century cinema or whatever is It's always been there. But then we have this very surprising modern resurgence in the American Midwest, but starting in Wisconsin, thanks to the efforts of researcher, author, artist, cartoonist Linda Godfrey. And yeah, I think that's kind of where we should

Speaker 3where we should concentrate. That's like kind of your grounding. That's your flag pointing.

Speaker 2Yeah, yes, there's your ground zero for dog Man. So let's talk about Linda and she started collecting these stories. What would we say is case zero here, What are our early sort of dog man sightings that bring this into modernity.

Speaker 3Yeah, so we should say to start with Linda sadly died in twenty twenty two, And she was she was very very well liked. Seems I never.

Speaker 4Met her or corresponding with her.

Speaker 2Yeah, she was very likable. She was just a very friendly, likable lady.

Speaker 3Yes, so rip Linda Godfrey. But at some point I'm no expert on her life history, but I believe she was working as a journalist and or cartoonist for local newspapers in Wisconsin, in the vicinity of a town called elk Corn, which is not too far from Milwaukee and Chicago, ABO one hundred ish miles from both of those cities, and she, I don't know, I can't remember how or I don't know how she picked up on this set

Speaker 3of stories. This is late nineteen eighties where people were claiming to have seen a dogheaded humanoid, the kind of creature we've been describing. The reports all came from the vicinity of Bray Road, which is a long road in the town of Elk Corn.

Speaker 4Elk Coons, a small town.

Speaker 3I think it's less than ten thousand people live there. It's a relatively rural areas or farms, pretty open landscape. I don't mean open desert like I mean, you know, not hilly and not mountains.

Speaker 2Yeah, Uken and I have done this many times. You can go to Google Maps and sort of virtually drive down the road there and see what we're talking about.

Speaker 3I haven't done it many times, done it once. Maybe I shouldn't should do that.

Speaker 2It is, as you say, flat and open.

Speaker 3So yeah, right, And she somehow picked up on them. The initial story I think it's nineteen eighty nine, and it came from well, she actually got it. Linda got it off another freelance journalist, a woman called Linda Callum, who has sometimes been mentioned as an anonymous source, but in other things that small town Monster's made a movie about the Beast of Bray Road or the Brairoad Beast this year, and she was mentioned by naming that, so I think it's fair to put her on record. She

Speaker 3had found from a local bus driver, I assume of a school bus, a woman called Pat Leicster of these, yeah, like dog man type creatures. Leicester was relaying accounts that came from her daughter, Lourie and Dreasy And basically that is your ground zero report. That's where it starts. I think this is nineteen eighty nine. There's a suggestion of a couple of other accounts that come from maybe eighty

Speaker 3seven eighty eight. Then Andreasey's neighbor we're talking about teenage kids here, Yeah, Andrez's like next door neighbor also has a sighting and it's from Halloween nineteen ninety one. And this is one where I first started. This is when I've read about this sighting. This is the one where I'm thinking, I'm not sure this is entirely zoologically her.

Speaker 2Well, it's a quandary on Halloween. You have, on the one hand, the night when it's so easy for the spirits and the supernatural to come into our world, and also when a lot of people who were night spirits dress up as though they were, so it's very confusing for everyone.

Speaker 3I'm sure, totally for sure, did I say? Doris Gibson, that's the teenage neighbor of Laurie and Drezy, So Andreezi has a sighting herself. Teenage neighbor Doris Gibson also has citing this Halloween nine ninety one. One involves thinking that she has hit a creature with a car.

Speaker 4And is pursued by it.

Speaker 3And this actually happens supposedly at two different points during that Halloween nights. So we've got a small number of reports that involve a school bus driver who learns about this off like school kids, and school kids say that other school kid friends of theirs are seeing this creature, and the other accounts moving forwards into the early nineties nineteen literally up to ninety one ninety two. They also all involve young people. They sometimes involve group kids, some

Speaker 3as young as ten or eleven. There's this nineteen ninety two sighting by a high school student called Tom Brichter, who again has got one of these scary stories involving thinking he's hit a creature with his car and he then sees the animal moving around among corn, which is you know, that's a useful guide. How tall is you know, ripe corn to the creature's head is above the height of the corn. Oh, that's quite cool.

Speaker 2Yeah, if the rain's been good, yeah.

Speaker 3Exactly, so we're talking of So that's that's our initial set of reports. School kids Bray Road latest eighties, early nineties. Now, part of the story that Linda Godfrey like to tell is that she spoke to I think Bray Road is in a part of Wisconsin called Walworth County. She talks to the Walworth County Animal Control officer of guy called John Frederickson. He's aware of these reports. She's doing her due diligence as a reporter, I guess, and Frederickson had

Speaker 3got this is the famous part of the story has been re enacted in all the documentaries that cover this. He's got a little you know, card Manila envelope folder rather that says werewolf on it, and he's written about these these werewolf sightings. And as God for herself said, you know many times when a you know, a county official has got a file that says wherewolf on it. Waltz that in itself is is news. And I want to say two things about John Frederickson's involvement, because of course, when we hear that a county official, someone working for

Speaker 3the government has got like a werewolf folder, say, oh man, this is serious. Is this got this has got real? Right? That's the that's the kind of spin on it that you know, godfree, you know, sort of conveyed in her writings and interviews. But in the New Small Town Monsters movie, they have some really nice interview with Frederickson, and with all due respect to him, he actually comes across as he does come across as the.

Speaker 4Most skeptical guy.

Speaker 3Put it that way. He two minutes into the interview, he's talking about the he is, he is putting the sightings that he's aware of. He's casting them immediately within the way that paranormalists kind of like to They like to imply that, or is this something to do with like the demonic, the satanic? Is it some kind of like connection to like other universes, you know, the dark spirits coming through He's got he's going there straight away. So I'm like John Frederickson, I'm not sure you were.

Speaker 3You know, maybe someone else in that position wouldn't necessarily be so quick to label a file were wolf.

Speaker 2Yeah, it is, there is. We've talked before on the show about how that the idea of government, big, big government is. It's it's sometimes treated as a monolith, but you know it's not. It's made up of people and they have all kinds of different interests. And this guy, I haven't seen the new documentary was Small Town Monsters did one a while back, and he was in that as well, so I don't know if this is new footage or the old, but but yeah, he comes across as being interested in occultism and it felt very satanic

Speaker 2panic to me. And you know, he's the right aides to have already been heavily influenced by that.

Speaker 3The Small Town Monsters movie I saw. The version I saw was uploaded to YouTube this year.

Speaker 2But oh, it might be the original Okay, yeah, which would have been I think from twenty seventeen to twenty eighteen.

Speaker 3Okay, I should check on that.

Speaker 4Yeah, I think you're.

Speaker 2Right because I think in my back channel conversations with other monster people, I think someone mentioned that he had put him out. We don't have to pay you could actually see these older movies, so that may be what this is. But you're right, and I think when I went, I was at Monster, I was at Crypticon with Jeb Card and golly was that must have been twenty eighteen. We watched that and we were both struck by the occult turn. It was like it was very surprising because up until that point I had not actually heard very much of the occult side of it, and seeing it

Speaker 2frame that way, well, it fits into Jeb's research quite nicely.

Speaker 3So exactly that that's where this goes. And I and I got some really great, really great take on this from from Jeb because part of my justification for writing about dog Man was you can't find many people that are interested in the more academic or scientific side of cryptos orgy that really find much interest in writing about dog Man, because it's it's obvious that I'm kind of paraphrasing an imaginary person here, but it's obvious this isn't

Speaker 3really a zoological mystery. But but I kind of like to approach these things as well. There are people that, you know, there are some people that are interested in this stuff that are framing it that way. They're saying, you know, maybe this is, you know, an undiscovered species. You know, maybe there are human sized bipedal, you know, cannid like animals. Maybe they're so kind of like ungodly hybrid or maybe there's you.

Speaker 4Know, mutant dogs.

Speaker 3I am not endorsing any one of those hypotheses, but you know, there are some people who literally are proposing those as possibilities, as possible explanations for it. As so we can evaluate all those ideas, we can show why they don't really stand up. And Godfrey herself, you know, put forward all of those ideas in the various books and articles that she published on dog Man. But what was favored by her and by most of the other people that have written about it and who talk about

Speaker 3dog Man at you know, the American welf in general, is they are generally pushing the idea that it is that it is paranormal, that it's satanic, and yeah, they're seeing there. I don't want to overuse the term framing, but they are framing this creature as if this is another one of these indications that all those science guys aren't seeing the big pitch here. They're not getting the fact that it's so much more to this world than we currently understand. There's portals where there's things coming through

Speaker 3from other realms. You know, that is clearly quite a popular idea among people who are interested in this stuff. Promote it as if it's real, reject much of the skeptical kind of pushback to these things. And it doesn't take much investigation for you to find links, yeah, that people are promoting. So, you know, Godfrey finds out. I'm

Speaker 3not sure exactly where she got it from. It's a really interesting case, this alleged story from the nineteen thirties, and this is another classic dog man Wisconsin dog man. I mean, technically the term dog man goes to the Michigan dog man, and the creature in Wisconsin is initially the beast of Brairoad or the Brainroad beast, but they do become conflated. They are regarded as kind of the same air quote species within a short time, and she

Speaker 3finds out about this alleged nineteen thirties Wisconsin account, which is reported by an author and editable Joe Shackleman, and he says that in nineteen fifty eight, his dad, Mark Shackleman, who is obviously no longer around, told him about this nineteen thirty six account, and this is the famous Goadara creature. So Mark Shackelman is working as a night watchman at I think it's called Saint coletta school of Exceptional Children.

Speaker 4Sounds like a X Men college or something.

Speaker 3It wasn't. I think it was mental health to the next tithing along those lines, And it's basically a story about mister Shackleman on two different occasions observing this creature that kind of, you know, conforms to the dog man descript It's large, six foot ish tall, it's got a dog like head, pointy ears.

Speaker 4This one doesn't have a tail.

Speaker 3And Joe so that's that the son Joe drew it based on his father's recollection, and Joe's obviously a pretty good artist. It's got some really interesting features. One of them is it's plant grade. It's got feet like a person, it doesn't have the dog like feet, so woh, this doesn't sound exactly the same as the dog Man encounters the other ones. And it's got strongly flexed wrists. Its hands are kind of like a ninety degree angle to its fore arms, which is an interesting trait, I think.

Speaker 3And it's supposed to be scratching at an indigenous burial mound. There are burial mounds created by the Hope well the Hope world culture, and supposedly the creature is heard to make an utterance, a kind of like growl, which Shackelman describe a sort of like it sounds like a proto language Goodara. And I think that if you hear a creature make a sound and it sounds like Goodara, that's

Speaker 3just the way that you might, like people describe frogs like the bullfrog saying jugger rum, jugger rum. It's kind of like it's just a way of describing the sound. It doesn't necessarily mean that frogs have got any connection with the history of alcohol and the Goodara term.

Speaker 4It could I reckonize the same thing.

Speaker 3It's just his if this really happened, because that's his best attempt to describe the sound. But because of course people of European ancestry are generally thinking of things in terms of you know, European culture, a Christian culture. Immediately, I think people Linda Godfrey and others have immediately recognized that Gadara that term is actually used in one of the Testament stories in the Bible. Kadara is a place

Speaker 3where Jesus Christ is meant to have performed in exorism. It's the story where the I think it's the gallery and swine where Jesus exercises these demons. They come out of people or a person I can't remember, and they go into the swine and leads.

Speaker 2And they go to a herd of swine.

Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah, and they and the swine then all leap into the river and drown themselves. And so the fact that a werewolf slash dog man type creature is saying something connected, according to this interpretation, connected to the Bible and to exorcism. Well, you know, you can imagine people have leapt all over this, they're like, ah, this is this confirms that there is this like connection to.

Speaker 4The Christian mythological.

Speaker 3View of the world that that you know, maybe maybe dog man is connected to the underworld and Satanism and de and is it is it actually a demonic entity? And it's the reason it was saying Goodara is is because it didn't want to be exercised itself.

Speaker 4I don't know, but but yeah, that is the connection.

Speaker 3That you've got pretty early on in the books and articles that talk about this.

Speaker 2So, as a paleontologist, science trained individual, why do you think it's fairly safe to dismiss the idea that dog Man could be a real biological entity.

Speaker 3Yeah, how do you? So? How do you put this? Because because in the article I read, I said that my bias is that I just can't believe that dog Man is real. But bias isn't the right term. It's we can be pretty confident if you accept a you know, a rationalized sort of scientific view of the universe, we can be pretty confident that all of us think there are new animals. She used to find. That's not controversial. We've all heard this many times before. But in a

Speaker 3stretch of the world like the whole of North America or even you know, if we just want to restrict it to the midwest of the United States, it's not.

Speaker 4Impossible that you're going to find a new.

Speaker 3Frog, new freshwater fish, possibly a new species of vole. But no, I'm sorry, it is absolutely not on the cards that there is a two meter tall dog headed humanoid, you know, an actual mammal awaiting discovery. You know, if we look at this in terms of what evidence we would want to sort of satisfy ourselves scientifically, Do we have anything that, yeah, like like lends credence to this

Speaker 3as a sort of scientific idea. Do we have any bones or scraps of skin or DNA. No, we have done of anything like that. We don't have any footprints that are unexplained from a big animal of this kind. We just don't have. We don't have any evidence of any kind. We don't even have any suggestive photos or they're actually a bit of a bit of a tangent. We could go on there, but yeah, there just isn't any evidence that would lead you to think that there's anything here, and there's certainly nothing in the way of

Speaker 3anything even mildly persuasive. So I think it's fair to say, I think it's too rejectiony, to knee jerky to say dog man ain't really.

Speaker 2Well, it is funny because I mean Brian Regal, I think the first time he was on Monster Talk, which was fairly early, was he had been doing a lecture talking about how Darwin killed the werewolf, basically arguing that once you showed the progression of species over time, inspeciation over time and the fossil record, that the idea of something just shifting and becoming a different thing altogether made no biological sense, and it was a real big impact

Speaker 2on sort of science dismissing the idea of these transformations happening. And I don't, I mean, I'm not saying there's no people who were saying that dog Man is literally a werewolf, but where wolves have been part of culture, as we just covered in a reis of the episode, you know, for since Babylonian times for a long long time, or definitely since the Romans at least, because we have really good werewolf stories from Rome. But dog Man's new, and I don't, I guess it seems like it feels like

Speaker 2folklore can maybe be a better way of explaining this. We've talked about slender Man. Slender Man was made up. We know exactly where slender Man came from. It doesn't stop people from reporting slender Man's sightings and like life threatening implications they're from. And same thing with black eyed kids. We know where black eyed kids come from, and yet they spread and people report the men's having really seen them. And some of these seem to be people telling stories, which is the thing people do. Some people, I think really think they're seeing these things, which is not exactly

Speaker 2the same thing. But I think there's still natural explanations for that, and some people like make them ups. I think we have to admit that too.

Speaker 3I think, I think the same the same deal with with dog man. I think that so we've we've always got this idea with us, you know, throughout the whole of the twentieth century and beforehand, that they that such creatures are they're an idea nobody's taken seriously. Is the suggested that they really are. You know, dog headed humanoids are out there walking around, But the idea that they're a thing somewhere within, you know, our mythological view of the universe exists, and at some point if someone wants

Speaker 3to have some fun and start claiming that they've seen it, and then someone else does the same thing, it's sort of reinforced by the fact, you know, many people have made the point now that early two thousands you had a few werewolf movies that kind of sort of had fun with the idea that such creatures did exist. Dog Soldiers, I think is two thousand and two there's a movie called Ginger Snaps with a humanoid werewolf in it about two Well.

Speaker 2I love both those films.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, and then obviously in the eighties and nineties got The Howling and its various sequels. I think it's four sequels to the Howling or four Howling films. So yeah, I think it's some kind of like fun little bit of evolving folklore which is spreading around among young people in this part of the world where it feels kind of right, it feels kind of fun to have it. So yeah, in that way, is it is quite similar to slender Man and the fact that that people who

Speaker 3were already committed to belief in Bigfoot and related phenomena, the fact that they've started to yeah, those stories as well. I think sometimes that is because people have had unusual encounters, they have seen, you know, glimpses of weird things in the woods and have creatures like this on the brain has has fed into the phenomenon.

Speaker 2Yeah. I think we didn't talk about the Gable film, and I guess I would say refer listeners to read your article, which I think is going to be the overarching theme of this first half of this. If we get to keep talking for the rest of this, but I think read the article because your coverage of the Gable film is great. But as a wrap up to this first part, I want to ask, so, given that this is I always God, I don't know why, I'm always compelled to leave a little hole for possibility, but

Speaker 2it's you know, there's nothing one thousand percent against the idea of having an upright, you know, doglike creature, but that there's just no supporting evidence for it. But given all of that, that and the fact that it fits so much with folklore and psychology, and what do you think is the best way to academically approach a topic like this.

Speaker 3Yeah, that's a great question. Well, I guess you would. It would involve it would like so, yeah, it's okay. It's worth saying at this point that nobody has actually done the proper analytical work that you would need to do to really study a phenomenon like this, because that involves detailed interview, sit down, long term interview, the collection of interview data from the witnesses, their friends, their backgrounds,

Speaker 3you know, what were you thinking of, what inspired you to you know, not necessarily asking them specifically about their claim citing but what was sort of cultural setting that they were in at the time. Are we actually we know from a few cases around the world, there have been studies on people that believe in human wolf transitions in Mongolia. There's also some studies that have been done on the people that believe they turn into tigers in

Speaker 3parts of Southeast Asia, I think Sumatra, that has basically you are collecting like a very living folklore from people who truly believe that this is a valid part of like the way the world works. So, you know, are we actually seeing this is not a difficult idea for us to accept. This seems ridiculous to say this in twenty twenty four, but it's not a difficult thing for

Speaker 3us to accept that there might actually be people in modern day US and you know, other countries all around the world who really do believe that this is actually a valid part of the way the universe works. Those of us who come at things from you know, skeptical angle, we say, of course, it's silly. Nobody really believes in wowolves, nobody really believes in slender Man.

Speaker 4But well that's not true.

Speaker 3There are there are people who, you know, there's no reason, there's no reason for us to regard it as a real thing, as a sort of flesh and blood thing in the world. But there could well be people who actually do believe.

Speaker 2You're talking about ethnography and religious religious studies and the you know, anthropological views, so not biology, you know, definitely not. But yet it's a valid part of the human experience to experience monsters. And so what does that mean? That's I guess that's what you're getting at that in this is where I increasingly land is only a multidisciplinary approach really captures the whole field. And you know, of course my dream is still to have some kind of multidisciplinary

Speaker 2academic conference on monsters at some point. Oh, I want that to be real.

Speaker 3Maybe one day. Yeah, that's that's exactly where I'm where I'm going with this. Yeah, you would need to collect all this ethnographic data to Yeah, there's definitely something worthy of analysis here, and it's.

Speaker 4Not a biological phenomenon.

Speaker 3But the way in which these people, these witnesses and these people sharing these stories, the way they're seeing the world, are they actually believing that it is that they are living in a world where dog man or slash were wolves are real.

Speaker 4So yeah, no, no one's done that work.

Speaker 3You know, there's no reason why it couldn't be the subject of a technical paper or a bunch of them. We're still in the early stages of people actually even studying, you know, subjects with a far longer pedigree like Bigfoot. There's still a lot of sociological, socio anthropological work that just hasn't been done yet. It's like the relevant people with the right way to approach it are only just getting invested in the study of it. It's funny.

Speaker 2I had occasion to pick up my copy of On the Track of Unknown Creatures by Nady of months and I was looking for something and I realized, wait a minute, you know, and this makes perfect sense. Why wouldn't it. But in the same way that dog men, you've got people trying to go back and find earlier cases because we all know monsters don't appear out of nowhere. They have to have like science is embedded enough that we go, oh, well, there has to be a longer history, because things don't just start appearing, right. But there's no Bigfoot in On

Speaker 2the Track of Unknown Creatures because it didn't exist yet. Like it's just not there. There's all kinds of really interesting missing animals, including the yetty, but there's no Bigfoot, and I find that really funny. It's just kind of one of those reminders that that pattern of seeing a monster having a flap and then people coming in and building the backstory, the rich backstory, is just part of the process.

Speaker 3So yeah, I agree. Yeah, which creatures he did and didn't include in that book is interesting given that in his nineteen eighty six list of cryptids, which we've spoken about before, it's by then, by nineteen eighty six, obviously bigfoot is on his list. Yes, a valid species awaiting discovery, but not in nineteen fifty.

Speaker 2Fifty I think, yeah, I think. I think the English version I have is like fifty seven or something like that, but yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah, fifty. Yeah, the French one is fifty five.

Speaker 2Yeah, there you go. So he just missed it, like if you'd waited a little longer. He's a guy, but yeah, that's the true monster. You've been listening to Monster Doc, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. You just heard part one of my two part conversation with paleontologist Darren Niche about dog Man. Be sure and tune in next week for the second half of this chat, where we'll be discussing the state of cryptozoology. Monster Talk theme music is by Peat Stealing Monkey. Hey, what's dog Man's favorite holiday? Poulloween.

Speaker 1This has been a Monster House presentation

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S06E07 Elizabeth Taylor and the Burton of Truth

    Nov 16, 202655 minAudio

    Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S06E06 🐈⬛Evil Cats and Revelatory Revenants👻

    Nov 9, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S06E05🎃 Live 2026 Halloween Show

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S06E04 🍿Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈 Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S06E03 🎥 Capturing Bigfoot 🫈with Marq Evans

    Oct 19, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...

    Credit the people on this episode