We're joined by the engaging historian Dr. Eleanor Janega to talk about how the people of Europe considered demonic sex during the medieval period of history. This episode is in two parts, and both are explicit. Presenter on the History Hit channel - https://www.historyhit.com/ Blog - https://going-medieval.com/ Medievalist, author, blogs about medieval history, pop culture, and swearing Author of: The Once and Future Sex: Going Medieval on Women's Roles in Society Article: “On sex with demons” - https://going-medieval.com/2020/07/30/on-sex-with-demons/ Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Monster House Presents.
Speaker 2It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.
Speaker 3A giant, very creature party part.
Speaker 1In Luckness, a twenty four a mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland.
Speaker 3It's a creature known as the Luckness Monster. Monster Talk.
Speaker 1Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. Hey, they're Monster Talkers. It's been another rough week here at Monster House Manor. Last week we said goodbye to our friend and colleague Joe Nickel, and this week it turns out that my beloved doggie, Smokey, does not have a simple paw infection, but rather terminal bone cancer.
Speaker 3And she's had a very good life and it has been a very good.
Speaker 1Girl and I am going to miss her a lot. So it's been a lot to handle this week. And that's just inside my house, not even getting into the tumultuous world of academia where university funding is being attacked by vindictive and petty billionaires and no, I'm being serious and not getting into it, but it is going to impact us all, even if.
Speaker 3You don't know it yet.
Speaker 1And then there's the sad changes happening to the systems and software that I used to make the show possible. My Macintosh has become unstable, and rather than give in to the corporate four stopso lessons that Apple and Microsoft are trying to force feed us all, I switched to a Linux box for recordingting that has been more challenging than I expected. I'm almost done, and this episode was fully recorded and edited.
Speaker 3On free, open source software.
Speaker 1I'm using a five year old PC that's still plenty powerful enough, and I've always been a multi os person, you know, a technology person who wants to be able to use any machine I come across. But for the first time in decades, I used a shell command and accidentally wiped out an entire episode of the show instantly.
Speaker 3Wow. That sucked anyway, So there's a missing episode.
Speaker 1But fortunately we have this episode in the can and ready to go. So I'd have to say, though, if there was a religion of technology that I think losses like that would count as sacrifices to the tech gods. But in my case, it was just a stupid and irrevocable.
Speaker 3Mistake that I should have known better than making. Anyway, I'm not.
Speaker 1Here to bring you down far from it, because what we have here is part one of a two part interview with medieval historian Eleanor Yanaga, and she was an absolute pleasure to talk with, and we went so long that I'm breaking this into two half hour episodes. And because we're going to be talking about sex with demons in both parts of this interview, both haves will be getting an explicit tag, and Part one ends with what will likely be the most controversial cliffhanger question in the history of our show. So buggle up for some mobs trutle.
Speaker 2Well, welcome to the show, Doctor Eleanor Jannago.
Speaker 4Thank you so much for having me.
Speaker 2I said that correctly, you nailed it.
Speaker 5IM about to congratulate you for being able to pronounce a Slovak name.
Speaker 4You know it's not easy.
Speaker 2So oh well, I've got to unwield the European name myself. But I came across an article of yours years ago. I was writing a piece about sex with demons and ghosts and angels and all kinds of paranormal and supernatural creatures, and I came across as.
Speaker 4You do yeah, well, yeah, typical.
Speaker 2Sunday afternoon, and I came across your blog Going Medieval and your excellent article on sex with Demons. So that's how I first found you. And then I am a history buff. I watch a lot of stuff on YouTuber on history, and I came across the History Hit Channel, and I really love your shows and your fun and enthusiastic approach to medieval history and History Hit, in my opinion, is a better alternative to the History Channel, and so
Speaker 2I want to put that out there for our listeners if you haven't heard of History Hit, So we wanted to bring you on the show, I guess ostensibly to talk about medieval demons, but also more so, I don't know if you like to tell us a little bit more about yourself too, because you do so many things.
Speaker 5Oh yeah, absolutely, you know, in the way that we all are, I wear a number of hats. But yeah, I'm a medieval historian by training in trade and by that, you know, I covered just a pretty chill eleven hundred years of history, no big deal, you know.
Speaker 4Like from the Fall of Rome quote unquote.
Speaker 5I don't believe in the Fall of Rome, but that's another story for another time. In four seventy six to ah, you know this sixteenth century sometime. That is my stomping ground in general. And the joke that I always tell people when they ask what I work on is I say I work on sex and death, because they're the only two things that matter. I do a lot of work on sexuality, and I do a lot of work on apocalyptic thinking and propaganda.
Speaker 4And as a part of that, there's a lot of.
Speaker 5Working on the monstrous and working on kind of demons and the way that medieval Christians organize their world and the supernatural ways that they thought about the world in general. And so for me, this is kind of what is most interesting about people because you learn a lot about what makes them tick and it's just fun. Also, like, let's be honest, come on, you know, the work that I'm interested is the equivalent of blockbuster movies. You know,
Speaker 5I want to see a pair of titties in a monster and you know, we'll get in and out, and you know, like that's that's what everybody wants in their heart of hearts. You know, is a little bit of a you know, science fiction double features.
Speaker 3Roger Korman's presentation of history right.
Speaker 5Exactly exactly, and you know, I will go to the mat on this one. It is a genuine field of a study and inquiry because we're interested in this because that is what it is to be human.
Speaker 4So if you really want to.
Speaker 5Get down into people's psychees and you look at this stuff and that's how you will understand.
Speaker 2Them, fantastic. No, you're definitely a good company. We're in a good company to have you on the show because, yeah, a lot of this stuff we've talked about over the years haven't wed.
Speaker 1Like oh yeah, oh yeah, and we probably will continue to talk for years to come because these are topics that are, as you say, core to our humanity, and you know, a thousand lenses to look at them through.
Speaker 3So yeah, this is really well.
Speaker 1You talked about the challenges with defining periods of history, and that's one of the things I thought maybe you could sort of give us a brief permar on, is the difference between Middle Ages, Medieval Times, the Dark Ages, and why these are sometimes angry topics for historians.
Speaker 3Or why they get muddied up in pop culture.
Speaker 5Yeah, I think in the first place, just to start with the last question first, the reason they get muddy up in pop culture is that they aren't taught broadly, and the Middle Ages simply is not taught widely or broadly because it's messy and it's complex, and you know, I'm a Europeanist, there is a global Middle Ages. You know, China is doing something completely different than Europe is. You know, Africa's doing very very different things. And so you don't end up learning a lot about Middle Ages in general
Speaker 5history instruction because if you're going to do it, it would.
Speaker 4Just be so complex.
Speaker 5You know, what's happening in France is not the same thing that is happening in Scandinavia, what's happening in Ireland is not the same thing that is happening in Italy, and they're completely different to what is happening in Japan or India or Baghdad, you know, which isn't to say that these places aren't interconnected, because they absolutely are. But we don't get to learn about this because it's just super super messy. And we use the term medieval incorrectly, so it gets used as a pejorative in order to mean backward or stupid or wrong thinking. And this has
Speaker 5rather a lot to do with Voltaire, who I will see in Hell. But you know, people tend to kind of write it all off because this is a stupid time when people were stupid in bad right.
Speaker 4And I was always quite interested in history.
Speaker 5So by the time I got to university and I was learning history more in depth, I ended up falling in love with medieval history because I've literally just never been presented with it in depth before that point in time, and it was so interesting and complicated. But yes, you're right, the term medieval is a really difficult one, but it's kind of an annoying one because it's sort of predicated on what it is not, so it is again very Europeanist in purview. So we begin it by saying the fall of Western Rome is what begins the medieval period,
Speaker 5and that is messy in and of itself, because if you went to anyone in Constantinople in the year of Our Lord for seventy six, they feel like, what are you talking about? I live in Rome right now, you know, I live in one of the biggest cities on the planet other than Beijing, and I have no idea what it is you mean by that. And we don't really have a comfortable cut up point for the end of the medieval period. But fundamentally. One of the reason why it's called the Middle Ages or the Medieval period is the idea is that it's between two worlds. There's the ancient world, which is most of human history, so Sumeria, Babylonia,
Speaker 5Ancient Egypt, Ancient Greece, Rome, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, the Aztecs, so all these things, all these very interesting things that are going on. And then there is the modern world. And how you want to define the modern world is really a difficult one and it really depends on where you are. But what I tend to say from a European perspective is if you can see Protestants, you've gone too far right.
Speaker 4If Protestants exist, you're in the modern period, right, then that's and that's kind of how it works.
Speaker 5And so the Middle Ages is just everything that isn't ancient and is it modern. And this can be really really difficult for us because there's also periodizations within that because again, you know, it's a lot of history.
Speaker 4It's eleven hundred years, give or take.
Speaker 5So there is the term the Dark Ages, and people misunderstand the term the Dark Ages. They think dark Ages means bad or again it's a pejorative way of looking at things. The Dark Ages was initially coined just to talk about what we call the early Medieval period, so kind of like from the Fall of Rome to about the year one thousand, so you know, five hundred to one thousand, something like that, And we call it the Dark Ages because we don't have great source survival and so we mean dark as in included, like we can't quite peer in there and see what's going on, like what's happening, what's happening with that?
Speaker 4And modern people have a difficult time understanding that.
Speaker 5So if I say that's modern people, they always say, oh, yeah, well what happened to the sources? And the implication sometimes is that like the church air quotes burnt the sources, which I'm like, wow, that's wild, When what I tend to say is, you know, like when you move house and you like throw away all your telephone bills, like that happened repeatedly over fifteen hundred years, which is a really long time. So it's just like a really long time ago, and we didn't save those things, right, so we don't know that much what's going on there. And
Speaker 5then you have the high Medieval period, which is like eleven hundred to about thirteen hundred, and then you have the Late Medieval period, and like, these are these are the periods that we're working with. So there's periods upon periods upon periods, and they're annoying because they're shorthand for experts to talk to other experts, and then no one is taught about these things, and then everyone is confused, and then I'm yelling at people online because they're saying that the witch Panics are medieval when they are clearly modern, you.
Speaker 4Know, and nobody knows what that that is.
Speaker 5So, you know, it's these kind of knock on things, which I think are quite ironic because what ends up happening is we want to cast the past as a particularly ignorant or stupid period of time, and actually that just makes us look stupid because it shows you don't know anything about the.
Speaker 4Period that you're talking about.
Speaker 5And I'm like, maybe we just need to be nicer to people in the past and recognize that they're they're quite clever and doing the best they can in difficult circumstances.
Speaker 2Really, yeah, that was an amazing overview. Thank you so much.
Speaker 4I do go on I'm sorry. I'm sorry.
Speaker 2No, that really encapsulated a lot. And so you've got a podcast too. Well, we're not so different, and I'm wondering if in a nutshell this is a broad question or a broad yeah, broad question, But can you tell us a little bit about how we're not so different from our medieval ancestors.
Speaker 5Well, this is the thing that I think is really important, and one of the reasons why I get annoyed when people use the word medieval's pejorative or use the term dark ages, is that it really separates us from people in the medieval period, and actually they're really clever and interesting and smart, and probably smarter than I am, because I don't know if you made me do subsistence farming how well I would do right now personally, you know, I come from a long line of peasants quite proudly, and I you know, the best I can do is gardening at this point in time.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 5I think that medieval people are really clued in to each other, and they are very good at doing analysis of things like texts and propaganda, and they understand that when they're being told various things that it isn't necessarily on its face true, and I think that they're very similar to us in that respect, in a lot of manners where you know, oftentimes what survives to us historically
Speaker 5are things that come from, yes, the Catholic Church, or things that come from kings, things that come from the rich and powerful, right, because the rich and powerful are the ones who are able to write things down, and also they're the ones who are able to store documents, and so as a result, it paints a picture of the Middle Ages as quite rigid and quite there are a lot of rules that people followed, but actually the thing that ends up happening is that medieval people don't care not any of that, because they're really smart and
Speaker 5they don't believe that everything necessarily the Church tells them that is true, or even if they do, they're like, yeah, but I'm still a human being and I'm going to have premarital sex behind this barn right now, you know. And they're going to behave in the ways that they're going to behave one way or another.
Speaker 4And I think that they're quite astute.
Speaker 5And when we do get to hear from ordinary people, we hear them criticizing governments, criticizing the Church. We see them try to start their own religious movements. When we get to hear gossip from them, it's really fun. They're like fighting each other in the street and like pulling hair after like getting too drunk. The reason that they're going to get mad at you is that you're cheating them out of the correct weight of bread or you brew really bad beer. You know, they have fun and they're festive, and they are just really a lot like us,
Speaker 5but in very very different circumstances.
Speaker 4And I think that's gorgeous.
Speaker 2Really.
Speaker 3So we you know, the.
Speaker 1Show's monster talks we should talk about and I wanted to ask you a little bit about medieval demons and how they're represented, how are they similar to modern beliefs about demons. But I guess we should also answer two extra questions, which are what do you mean by demons? And what are the sources for these stories? Because I kind of suspect that there's going to be some kind of content bias based on who's telling the story.
Speaker 5Oh yeah, so you're bang on here, Blake. One of the big issues that we tend to have in general with medieval sources, as I say, it's just like who can actually make a source who actually has the wherewithal to read and write. Because also when we are talking about medieval source survival, there is source work that happens in vernacular languages like you know, I don't know O Siton or Middle English and things like that. But for the most part, to be literate in the Middle Ages in Europe means to read and write in Latin, right,
Speaker 5So you have to have this other language altogether, and you have to be able to write with a quill, which is so hard I know if you've ever tried, but it's really not easy. It's not like picking up a pencil at all whatsoever. And they are documenting things not on paper because paper doesn't exist yet in Europe. It exists in China, but that's about it. It doesn't exist like even in very many places like China's kind of got a lock on that one. So you are writing on parchment, and parchment is animal skin, so you know,
Speaker 5you have to raise a sheep, kill a sheep, cure the sheep skin, scrape all the hair off of it, and then write on it using a goose feather and ink that you've made out of galls. Right, So this is an incredibly expensive hobby to get into.
Speaker 4So as a result, the people.
Speaker 5Who can do it are the people who have rather a lot of money and spend all their time doing it. So again we hear a lot from the Church, and we hear a lot from royalty and nobility.
Speaker 4Who hire people in to do this.
Speaker 5Because even if you're literate in the sense that you can read Latin, you may not be able to write physically, because writing with a is very difficult. So who's telling these stories. These stories are being told by the Church, and so the Church has a real definition for demons, and demons are fallen angels. And this is an idea that has been being built up very slowly, you know, like when Christianity is invented, the conception of hell doesn't exist.
Speaker 5That's something that's built up slowly over time throughout the late Antique period, so the very very end of the ancient period.
Speaker 4So this idea that there's a heaven and that there's a hell.
Speaker 5You can look to people like as Saint Augustine of Hippo or Saint Jerome to tell you a little bit more about the conception of hell, and they're doing this like living in Alexandria, and also like making the rules of Christianity right, and for them this kind of shuts down certain ways of looking at the world. So, for example, early Christians don't believe in ghosts, right because like you're either in heaven or you're in hell, Like your spirit can't go taken walk, that's not a thing that can happen. But spooky stuff can still happen as a result of
Speaker 5demons who are these fallen angels, and so there is a real, real definition of what they are and what they are capable of doing as a result of this. But interestingly, like there's a kind of overarching knowledge of demons, but it gets expanded over time. So for example, if you look at the Book of Revelation or simply the Apocalypse as it's called in Latin, for quite some time, there's a lot of monsters in there, all of whom
Speaker 5are demoniac in essence. You know, you have things like the Beast of the Abyss, who is also read as the anti Christ, and sometimes he is like a little beast with seven heads and little horns, and he's got all these crowns and things like this. But then you've also got Satan appearing as a multi headed dragon and then also you've got like the leopards with wings and the mouth of a bear, and they are all monsters, but they're also demons in that they are coming from Hell, emanating from Hell, and at one point in time some
Speaker 5of them were angels, or they've been brought into being by the devil himself, which is a very long winded answer, and I'm sorry that.
Speaker 2No, that was a brilliant answer, and what.
Speaker 3The Audius is looking for. That's why they come to us.
Speaker 2Yeah, for the deep dives, the quick deep dives. Well, could we get a little bit more granular about demons specifically, let's talk about the juicy topic of six demons. So could you tell us a bit about medieval six demons, Incubi and succuby, all that good stuff.
Speaker 5Yeah, so incubin and Succubi are two, those are two of the ones. They're still household names, aren't they.
Speaker 1You know.
Speaker 5One of the things I like about incubine and succubi is that, you know, we've still got bands like Incubis around the shop. If you say the word, everybody kind of like, no, that's a demon.
Speaker 4And that's bad. And incubuses and.
Speaker 5Succubises kind of exist throughout the medieval period. Like there is an argument to be made, for example, like the wizard Merlin was born as a result of a demon having sex with Merlin's mother, and so he is the son of an incubus.
Speaker 4Really when you think about it, and I.
Speaker 6Do, so.
Speaker 4They're around a lot.
Speaker 5But so an incubus is often kind of conceptualized as masculine, and it basically a demon who will have sex with you in your sleep and knock you up, all right, So that's the ink.
Speaker 4It's like incubate incubus.
Speaker 5Like, so that's going to essentially more or less have sex with you while you're asleep. A succubis is the opposite, that is conceptualized as a kind of feminine demon who is going to come to men and have sex with them. And this is a really important points. So the next things that I'm going to say come to us from the Malleus Malificarum or the Hammer of Witches, which is a witch hunting manual that's written at the very very
Speaker 5end of the medieval period, so the late fifteenth century, and it is really interesting for us because when it is written, it is not taken at all seriously. So when it's written by Heinrich Kreimer. It is written and everyone is like, Okay, cool guy. It seems like you're a psychosexual weirdo and you are taking that out on women, and this is an absolutely wild thing to write. Let's
Speaker 5never talk about this again. But then fifty years later, after we invent Protestants and every thing, everyone is like, wow, they were, they were on the real stuff back.
Speaker 4Then at this.
Speaker 5Oh yeah, like oh wow, I can't believe that he realized all these things that are happening. But he writes at length about Incubi and Succuby because his idea, which will really take.
Speaker 4Off in the early modern period, is that Satan is.
Speaker 5Super interested in Incubi and Succuby because Incubi and Succuby are able to have sex with humans because God allows it.
Speaker 4And want to make that.
Speaker 5Super super clear, like demons kind of can't do anything in the medieval imagination without God's permission to do it, right, because God controls everything and ultimately God can order the universe. So demons certainly exist, and they certainly do bad things, but God is allowing them to do bad things as a sort of test of your faith and a test.
Speaker 4Of your ability to be a good Christian, right.
Speaker 5And incubi and succuby are even more powerful because they get to you through your junk, right, So they get to get to you through your genitals. And I think we can all agree that the genitals are very naughty, right, and problems with sexuality are one of the hallmarks of Christianity even now, right, And Saint Augustine writes about them really extensively. Like the problem with the fall of Adam and Eve isn't that they became smart when they ate
Speaker 5of the Tree of Knowledge.
Speaker 4They became horny.
Speaker 5When they ate the apple from the tree of which is a pomegranate in the medieval period.
Speaker 4But that's another point.
Speaker 5But when they eat this pomegranate, they suddenly realize that they're naked, and it makes them super super horny, and you lose control of your genitals and they're doing things and you never know what your drunk is going to do. And Saint Augustine is horrified by this and writes about this at length. So incubin and sunk youby get that, and they can get to you through your genitals, and they can get to you via being horny, and so Heine Kramer when he writes The Hammer of Witches has rather a lot to say about this because he's convinced that when one becomes a witch, one a witch like
Speaker 5you agree to become a witch, and then you go to an orgy with the devil, as as one does obviously and so like to.
Speaker 4Seal the deal, you celebrate with an orgy.
Speaker 3And celebrate, but not celebrate.
Speaker 5Absolutely right, it's one hundred percent what's thou live deliciously?
Speaker 4And he and then they're.
Speaker 5Like, and Hunter Kramer, as you know, a trained Benedictine monk, is like, but where does the jiz come from?
Speaker 1Right?
Speaker 5Like, you know, we we've got to ask ourselves the big philosophical questions, because demons can't make anything, right, only God can make things, and demons and the devil can't create things. They can only subvert things that God has already created. So where's the jins coming from in the orgy? And we've got to ask ourselves this question and the answer that he comes up with.
Speaker 1Mobsle you've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. Hey there, this was part one of our two part chat with Eleanor Yanaga. We will be back next week when you'll find out where the authors of the Malleus Maleficaram deduced that Satan got his supply of jiz and I have to say, even with all the challenges we face this year, this interview lifted my spirits. And after she's done, we'll be hearing from Adrian Shine. So we've got some really
Speaker 1good stuff lined up for you this year. We hope you enjoyed this episode of Monster Talk. Our goal here is to bring you the best in monster related content with a focus on scientific skepticism and critical thinking. If you enjoy our show and want to support our mission, start out by visiting monster talk.
Speaker 6Dot org ford slash support. That's monster talk dot org forward slash support. There you'll find links to our Patreon page, as well as a donate button if you'd like to just make a one time contribution. A great way to support the show is to buy books from our Amazon wish list.
Speaker 3These are books that directly help with our monster research.
Speaker 1We love used books very much, so don't feel compelled to buy new ones, and we're also very fond of kindle editions because of their easily searched content and without spending any money at all.
Speaker 3You can support and raise.
Speaker 1The profile of the show by leaving a positive review at iTunes or wherever you get your podcasts. Positive reviews help keep us visible in iTunes, which is a great way to help us.
Speaker 3Find new listeners.
Speaker 1Finally, remember to share episodes you really like with your friends and family. You can help make Monster Talk the nightlight that keeps monsters away from someone you love. Monster Talks theme music is by Peak Stealing Monkeys. Tune in next time for Part two, the exciting conclusion of our medieval demonic sex discussion.
Speaker 2This has been a Monster House presentation
Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...
Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...
Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...
🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...
Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...