Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mindful Shape

Mindful Shape artwork

191 All-or-Nothing Thinking Trap Unveiled

Aug 31, 202615 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

If you think of yourself as someone who ‘once I start I can’t stop’ when it comes to your favorite foods, this is the all or nothing thinking trap. In this episode I’ll give you tools to avoid it so you can enjoy 1 cookie without eating 5. Get the Reset Ritual Instagram: @mindful_shape Get the FREE Building Momentum 4 Part Video Training Free Self Coaching Resources Interested in getting coached by me? Go to my website mindfulshape.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hi, and welcome to the Mind Bull Shape Podcast. I'm Paula Parker, and my work is here to offer you specialized mind and body tools, practices, and frameworks to shift into the next version of you. All right, so today we are going to be talking about how to avoid the all or nothing thinking trap. So, as you can probably hear in my voice, I still have this cold and we are about to leave on vacation. If you were listening to this in real time, it's summertime.

SPEAKER_00And I think, you know, for many of us, summertime can be a very challenging time just because our routine is so different. I know for me, it definitely is. The for some of you, I know the kids are home. The kids are home right now for us, and that just changes our dynamic and our routine. And of course, there's so many vacations and holidays and seeing friends and that kind of thing during the summer. And I think it can be really easy to fall into this all or nothing thinking trap because we might be out of rhythm or we might feel like we were out of sync.

SPEAKER_00And I know that for me, if I had to choose just one thinking pattern or line of thinking that has made the biggest difference for me when it comes to my eating behavior, it's all or nothing for sure. So I talk about it as all or nothing thinking. You might think of it as black and white thinking, black or white thinking. You're either like all in or all out with your thinking, with your motivation, and your actions. And I call it a trap, especially for this episode, because I really do see it as one.

SPEAKER_00If you're not aware of it, it's so easy to fall into it and it can be hard to get back out. But of course, if you can spot it, you can see the trap, you know what it is, then you can avoid it or pivot quickly if you do find yourself, you know, falling into it. So let's talk about how this shows up so that you can recognize if it's slowing you down, if it's an obstacle for you, and preventing you from feeling in charge around food, no matter what time of year, no matter what you're doing, the situation, or anything else, so that you can really feel good in your body, because that's what we're all about here.

SPEAKER_00And also what's cool about this is that once you start noticing it in this realm of life, like with food and your weight and moving your body, you will also be able to spot how it shows up in other areas in your hobbies, in work, just everywhere. And then you can start, you know, noticing it and avoiding it in those areas as well. Okay. So the most obvious one is when we go off our plan a little bit or we indulge, and our brain goes into all or nothing thinking.

SPEAKER_00So you must really be onto your brain when this happens because there are going to be times when maybe you want to have a glass of wine, or you want to have pizza, or you want to go for ice cream, or you skip your workout, or you get sick, like me, right? So this has been a big thing that I have been reflecting on since being sick, because I'm not able to work out in the same way. I just don't have the energy. I'm napping every day. I'm, you know, I think of having a cold as almost like a cleanse, like I'm letting my body heal.

SPEAKER_00I'm restoring my body. It's like a clearing that's happening. So I don't want to stress my body out even more by doing heavy weights or something like that. I'm still being active, but it's just not the same. It would be very easy for me, like let's rewind, say 10 years in this kind of situation. I definitely would have gone into the nothing camp, right? If I can't work out, I'm not feeling as good. I just want to eat food that's quick and easy and convenient and highly palatable. And I'm not feeling good. So I want to comfort myself that way.

SPEAKER_00Be very easy for me to do that like 10 years ago. Now, this is why I've been reflecting on this topic because I just have not fallen into the all or nothing trap. I feel much more balanced, I feel much more in control, and I want to share with you some of how I've been able to get here. So, again, so you can replicate it. Also, if you hear my kids in the background, they are home with my husband, but you might hear them calling. All right. Okay, so again, you must be onto your brain when this happens.

SPEAKER_00It's why so many of my clients say it's easier to have zero of something than a few bites or a reasonable amount. Because once you get started, it can be really hard to stop. Why? There's a couple of reasons for this. One, you need to know it's how we are wired. Once you taste a cookie right out of the oven, your brain is a bit hijacked. Because it was my son's last week of preschool. I baked cookies for the class.

SPEAKER_00And I love homebade cookies. I grew up on them. They are something that I could have easily overindulged on. Okay. But now it's just like my relationship with them is so different. And so I'm going to use this as an example. But if cookies don't do it for you, you just use anything, substitute your food of choice, your drink of choice. It doesn't matter. Okay, so let's just say that you have your food. For me, it's the cookie right out of the oven, and I taste it, and my brain is going to be, of course, flooded with neurochemicals and the neuromodulator dopamine that drives me to want to have another bite, have another, have another, have another.

SPEAKER_00I recently learned that our brain hasn't been updated in 250,000 years. So imagine if we could just, you know, go back in time, back to the first humans 250,000 years ago, and give them a warm chocolate chip cookie. They would go crazy, right? They have no context. So their brain is saying, just give me more, give me more, give me more. At any cost, probably. Now, of course, it might be silly to think about that example, but I mention it because I often hear clients tell me that they just really love food so much and that's a problem.

SPEAKER_00It's not. It's just your brain. Food kicks off those neurochemicals for you, whereas other things like gambling or maybe video games don't. I wonder though, and I'll use myself as an example, if I didn't have screens, if I didn't have other dopamine-inducing things, like no concentrated pleasure. I call these things concentrated pleasures. Like pleasure on tap. So no highly palatable food, no shopping, no entertainment, no sex, drugs, or alcohol. And then every day I played a video game.

SPEAKER_00Just like every day now, we eat. I bet it could easily become a compulsive behavior. It could become something that is maybe not a compulsive behavior for me because I have a bunch of tools, but it could become something that is um stimulating a lot of dopamine, right? And driving me to want to do more. Very understandable. Okay, but today we're not going to be so focused on the physiological part of over-desire. We're going to be more focused on the psychological overdesire.

SPEAKER_00But I just wanted to mention it because it is part of the overall explanation here. Okay. The psychological part is when we have a cookie and then a bite of another one. We feel the desire for more. And we think, well, you know what? We've already gone off plan. Or it tastes so good, I can't stop. Or we're all in now, anyways. What's the difference? One more cookie is not going to be that much of a change. And then we feel really permissive, and then maybe we have two or we have three.

SPEAKER_00That's the all-or-nothing trap. You eat something highly palatable, you engage in some concentrated pleasure, and then you feel the desire for more. Your brain offers up an all or nothing thought, such as, well, you've already gone off track, so why not? We can start over tomorrow, right? This line of thinking is very familiar to most of us. Then you overeat, and of course, no difference is made. You still have all that overdesire for food, that emotional psychological attachment to food, and the scale stays the same.

SPEAKER_00So the trap is really the line of thinking, the thought, well, might as well eat it now. It's okay that your brain goes there. But now, going forward, after listening to this, you just want to call it out. You just want to be aware of it. You want to spot it and say, oh, this is all or nothing thinking. Categorizing it can be very helpful because awareness leads to choice. When you have no awareness in that moment, you will simply act on that permissiveness and overeat.

SPEAKER_00So when you can spot it, then you can make a conscious choice. And this will require some effort on your part. Okay. The effort is really to feel that desire, maybe that permissiveness, and hold that feeling and pack up the cookies or continue baking them in my case, right? You might call that deprivation, that feeling that you experience, based on how you're thinking about it. Based on how you're thinking about it's going to create deprivation. Or you might call it power based on how you're thinking.

SPEAKER_00If you're thinking, I want more and it's not fair, I can't have more, you will likely feel deprived. If you are thinking, wow, I really enjoyed that one cookie. That was super satisfying. If I eat more, I probably won't feel that great. And also, how cool is it that I am the kind of person who can stop at one homemade cookie, especially when they are all right here in front of me. And I can feel relaxed and in control. So you might be thinking, uh, nope, I would not feel relaxed and in control, and that's fine.

SPEAKER_00It's hard at first. Okay? It's hard at first. So lean into that discomfort. We are not trying to avoid that discomfort. But you'll notice the more that you soften, the more that you give consent to whatever you are feeling, that desire, maybe some self-pity, that deprivation, and you label, oh, this is all or nothing thinking, and you can observe your thoughts in that moment, it does feel easier.

SPEAKER_00And then you build evidence, your identity starts to change. And that really is your experience by default. Like I just described for you my experience, which is a miracle. Like I consider it a miracle. Your brain can change. You can also think of this as the dark in-between of your new identity, the breaking part of a breakthrough. The breakthrough happens at the end, but of course, in the meantime, it just feels like you're breaking. It just feels hard. It's uncomfortable. And maybe, you know, you can think of it as that part of you is breaking. That's the old identity.

SPEAKER_00So notice that you don't necessarily have to feel positive. That's not what I'm talking about here. You might be feeling negative based on your line of thinking, but what I'm guiding you toward is to think in such a way that makes you feel more powerful. Powerful enough to decide one cookie is enough. Because when you feel powerful, you get the best of both worlds. You get to enjoy a cookie and then also feel great in your body.

SPEAKER_00Rather than all their nothing, which is overeating the cookies and feeling gross for a couple of days, or the opposite, like never allowing yourself to enjoy the pleasure of maybe a cookie if that's what you enjoy. Now, one caveat that I'll share here is you know yourself and you know your body. There may be certain foods that you decide that's a nothing, right? You're taking a short, extended, or potentially lifelong break from these foods. Nothing wrong with that either. As so long as you like your reasons, you know your reasons and you like them.

SPEAKER_00For me, there's this company called Sweet Smarts. I think I've mentioned it here before. And that food, for me, that might as well be crack. I don't mess with it. I just don't mess with it. One more tip that I'll give you here is to help you with this all or nothing after you have indulged or you've overindulged, and you're feeling intense desire for more, and you're in that battle in your head whether to have more or not, that can be so draining, such a draining experience energetically, especially if it's an impromptu situation.

SPEAKER_00So you've not made a plan ahead, you haven't made any decisions ahead of time. Here's what I really encourage you to do. And this is such a game changer. So please take this to heart. Go into your body. We eat and we forget there's food inside of us. There is still pleasure to be had, to you know, derive pleasure from the food you've eaten when you connect with your body. So let's say you've had one cookie and you feel that tug, you feel a pull for another, your brain starts to go into a bit of a battle.

SPEAKER_00See if you can sense that pleasure inside your body. This is a scale that can be cultivated. It's a deeper sense than I'm hungry, I'm full. When you pay attention to the satisfaction within your body, you'll remind your brain you have indulged and you can derive pleasure from that. Notice that it will soften the edges of that intense desire for more or any kind of like compulsive feeling.

SPEAKER_00So if you are interested in taking this work to the next level by making it very personal to you and your situation, and you really want to be in charge of your eating, your relationship with food, and feeling as amazing as possible in your body by doing this kind of work, like understanding yourself and using your brain and body to reach your goals. Then I want you to check out my group program. We start in September. It's called Together.

SPEAKER_00We're gonna coach together. And you can go to mindfulshape.com to learn more. All right, that's what I have for you today. Now I am posting this and packing up, and we are headed to the ferry. It's a gorgeous day today. Tomorrow is supposed to be sunny. We're gonna go to the lake because the next day it's gonna rain. We get the best of both worlds. We're gonna have some nice time in the sunshine, and then we will have some good, cozy days in the rain. Hopefully, I can read my book.

SPEAKER_00That would be so good. And I'll talk to you again next time. Okay, bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 200 The Most Underrated Key to Changing Anything Hard

    Nov 18, 202619 minAudio

    The standard process when we want to change anything whether it’s our weight or re-decorating our bedroom is to: Decide to change, make a plan or strategy, take action (follow through) and then evaluate to see if we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 199 Part 4 Alchemize Emotion - Your 12 Week Mind & Body Transformation

    Nov 13, 202629 minAudio

    Emotions drive our behavior, whether we follow through and do the hard thing or we distract ourselves with food, tv, our phone or a glass of wine. So we need to learn how to work with them rather than be at the mercy of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 198 Weight Loss Is a Spiritual Journey with Wendy Mader from Cahya Center

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 22 minAudio

    What does spirituality have to do with your relationship with food, your body, and your health? More than you might think. In this episode I’m joined by Wendy Mader, a spiritual coach, shaman, and death doula AND a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 197 Cravings Revisited - Going Deeper

    Nov 2, 202624 minAudio

    I’m revisiting one of my most popular episodes: #3 Cravings to give you a fresh take after years working with clients. If you have “food noise” and find yourself banning cookies from the house or trying to remember your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 196 Part 3 Aligned Action - Your 12 Week Mind & Body Transformation

    Oct 28, 202623 minAudio

    If you’re someone who can stick with it for a couple of weeks and then gets off track with your eating and fitness plan, this is for you. Conventional wisdom tells us to suck it up and try harder, which works for a...

    Credit the people on this episode