Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mind & Matter

Mind & Matter artwork

Elephants May Call Each Other by Name | Mickey Pardo | 217

Mar 27, 20251 hr 40 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Short Summary: Do elephants and other animals have language-like abilities, such as the ability to use individual names to refer to themselves and others? About the guest: Michael Pardo, PhD studies animal behavior at Cornell University, where he focused on animal communication and cognition. His work includes extensive field research with African elephants in Kenya. Note: Podcast episodes are fully available to paid subscribers on the M&M Substack and everyone on YouTube. Partial versions are available elsewhere. Full transcript and other information on Substack. Episode Summary: Michael Pardo, PhD talks about his research on animal communication, focusing on whether African savanna elephants use vocal "names" to address each other. They explore the broader context of vocal communication across species like dolphins, parrots, and marmosets, discussing how these systems compare to human language and what they reveal about its evolution. Dr. Pardo shares details of his fieldwork in Kenya, elephant social structures, and their behaviors like mourning the dead, while also touching on the challenges and joys of studying animals in their natural habitats. Key Takeaways: Elephants may use unique vocal rumbles to address specific individuals. Dolphins use signature whistles as "calling cards," sometimes imitating others’ whistles to get their attention, hinting at a form of naming. Elephant society features female-led family groups and dispersing males. Elephants show intriguing behaviors like visiting carcasses and covering them with dirt, suggesting an awareness of death uncommon in most animals. Human language evolution may have evolved gradually from simpler communication systems, as seen in various species, rather than emerging suddenly. Studying less charismatic animals like chickens could uncover surprisingly complex communication, broadening our understanding of cognition in nature. Related episode: M&M #20: Language, Symbolic Cognition, Evolution, Origins of the Human Mind | Terrence Deacon *Not medical advice. Support the show Support my work: Good Chemistry: Personalized, science-based health consulting. Work with Dr. Nick Jikomes directly. Affiliate Partners: Visit this link to see my affiliate partners and get discounts codes for products & services to support health. For all the ways you can support my efforts.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Nick JikomesWhether food, drugs or ideas, what you consume, influences, who you become. On the mind and matter podcast, we learn together from the best scientists and thinkers alive today about how your mind body reacts to what you feed it before starting mind and matter, I spent 10 years in academia doing scientific research. I got a PhD in neuroscience, where I focused on neuro endocrinology and the neurobiology of behavior, and before that, I specialized in molecular developmental and evolutionary genetics. I use my scientific background to help parse and translate the information that guests share on the podcast. In addition to the podcast, I write long form written content inspired by the show, where I integrate what I've learned across episodes. I also have a free weekly newsletter where I provide you with upcoming guests, share links and provide commentary on scientific studies and research that I'm reading, and more, visit Mind and matter.substack.com. To find all of my content you Nicky Pardo, thank you for joining me. Thanks so much for having me. Do you want to start off by just telling everyone a little bit about who you are and what type of researcher you are. You're a little, you know, you're a little deviant from the average person I have on here, because you have an interesting and probably underappreciated field for a lot of people in my audience. But what do you

Michael Pardodo? Yeah, sure. So I'm a biologist. I'm currently a postdoctoral researcher at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, and I have a PhD in animal behavior, also from Cornell University. Most of my work focuses on animal communication and cognition, as well as using animal sounds as a tool for conservation. I'm also an outspoken advocate for animal rights, for an end to the exploitation of animals in agriculture and other realms, largely because of my knowledge about animal cognition, and you know, like sort of the overwhelming evidence that many animals are highly sentient individuals with complex internal lives. Oh, yeah. I also have a very fledgling YouTube channel and Instagram account, both of which are called inside animal minds, where I post videos about animal communication and cognition, that kind of thing. And

Nick Jikomesat least a big component of what you do is field research, right? So you're not, you're not a bench scientist mixing, you know, mixing things together in test tubes. You're out in the field in places like Africa, yeah.

Michael PardoSo, yeah. So I recently my in my previous postdoc, I did some work with African elephants, which I hope to go back to at some point in the near future. So I spent a good amount of time out in Kenya following elephants around. Yeah,

Nick Jikomesand one of the reasons I was interested to talk to you is because I saw some of the research you had done on animal communication, in particular, some of the work you've done recently on elephants. And a long standing interest of mine has always been the the development and the evolution of language and and vocal communication more broadly, and how those things tie together. You know, to what extent is communication, you know that we see in, you know, song birds and other mammalian species, cetaceans, elephants. You know, to what extent is that language like, or sort of like, a, you know, a primordial version of human language. And what can, what can comparative biology in looking across species, tell us about the origins of language in humans. Let's, you know, maybe start here, very high level, from your perspective as an animal biologist and as a field researcher, what you know? I'll keep this sort of intentionally vague and let you kind of take it where you will. But you know, what is human language in contrast to the more widespread forms of vocal communication we see among other species.

Michael PardoIt's a really good question, and if you ask different experts, you'll get different answers to that, because the truth is that the way we define language is not universally agreed upon, and often people use that term without having a clear definition for it, which I think sometimes leads to a lot of confusion. So if you ask a linguist, and I have talked to some linguists about this, you know what? How would you define language? Often they don't give you an actual definition. What they give you is a list of characteristics that typify human language, but those characteristics, it's not clear if all of those characteristics are necessary for something to be a language, or if they just happen to be the features that are shared in common by all human languages, right, right? And, and so, you know, there's in Ling, in linguistics especially, but also in biology, there's a very clear distinction. Between language and other forms of communication, but it's not always clear what that distinction is, and so personally, I would define language as opposed to other forms of communication, as a system of communication that can be used to communicate about virtually any topic, including abstract ideas and things that are moved from the from the present moment in space or time? Yes, and I think that's so that's kind of my working definition. But not everybody can necessarily agree with that, right? Yeah,

Nick Jikomesit's definitely one of those things where, you know, everyone's got a different definition. And also, you know, if we think about this as populate like population biologists, for example, you know, instead of getting stuck in the trap of thinking language must have this pre specified set of things that everything either does or does not completely conform to, that, you know, just like anything else in biology, if we think about species concepts or what is or is not, say, a mammal, there are things that are going to generally be true that generally sort of fit, fit all the criteria, or most of them, but There's always, you know, exceptions on the margins to things, right? And I think that's important to keep in mind. But, you know, I want to, I want to really focus on what you said about, you know, a core aspect of language, in my view, from talking to people on the podcast, doing my own own reading, is that it requires symbolic cognition. And the use of symbols is where the sort of the sort of infinite or unlimited capacity of language comes from because it allows something to stand in for anything, right? So, so the whole point of symbolic cognition underlying language is that you know your name is Michael, and I associate you with the name Michael, but I could just as easily use any other sort of word or vocal sound. I could call you Peter or Paul, or some sound I've never even heard before, and I would still be able to communicate with you, just as I am now, knowing that your name is Michael or Mickey. And so there's this arbitrary quality that symbols allow that sort of unlocks this communicate about anything potential which is much more unlimited than the scope of vocal communication we see in other animals is that roughly how you see it? Yeah,

Michael Pardofor the most part, that's true. I think there's a really interesting field of research that is trying to probe exactly you know, to what degree is language uniquely human? Is it entirely uniquely human? Is it sort of a like a Saltatory leap in evolution from all other animals. That's a recent innovation in our lineage, or is it something that has evolved more gradually, and there's a lot more features of it that are shared with other species, and potentially even, I mean, frankly, we don't know for sure that light that that there are no other species on Earth without language, yeah, like it's, you know, there's a lot of animals, especially especially cetaceans, which have very large and complex brains, where we barely study their communication systems at all. So I think we have to be open to possibility that we may discover actual language in other species, which is really fascinating. Yeah, no evidence for that currently. Yeah,

Nick JikomesI think two, two related things that come up here for me are, on the one hand, you know, the species that are living today that we know about on Earth are oftentimes understudied. So cetaceans clearly have complex communication, and it remains to be determined exactly how complex and sophisticated it is, simply because it's so hard for us to really study it in depth. Maybe it's language like maybe it's not. That's an open question. But another thing that's even easier to forget, in my opinion, is that most of the species that have ever existed and communicated aren't with us anymore. So there could be more gradations in terms of the types of communication and language, like communication, that have been around historically. It's just that they were being used by now extinct species that we don't have access to. And so while it can seem like there's this discontinuous leap between humans and other species. That might be, that might be, we might be being deceived by the extinction of species that have more intermediate forms of communication, especially

Michael Pardosince we're now the only species of hominid that's left,

Nick Jikomesyeah, when there used to be probably dozens, right? I mean,

Michael Pardounless you can some people would argue that that, like, the division between Hominidae and ponga day, like, you know, how many day being humans and pocket A being the other great apes is sort of an artificial one that that, you know, phylogenetically, we ought to be considered a single family, but, but when I say hominids, I mean, like, you know, more recent human cousins,

Nick Jikomesright? Australopithecus and Homo Yeah? And this is always a question we think about comparative biology, right? It's the lumper versus splitter debates. And because evolution is a continuous process, you know, there's never going to be an ultimate, final answer to where some of these dividing lines get put, yeah. So, so, anyways, going back to this idea that so, so, to the extent that something is language, like when we're thinking about vocal community or auditory communication and other animals, one of the properties that is is a core part of language is is like my ability to name something, to come up with either a novel name for something, or to use names in an arbitrary or semi arbitrary fashion. So going back to the. Little question of names we mentioned before, like, your name is Michael. I know I could call you Mickey. Your name could have been any number of other things, but, you know, in one shot, I learned what your name is, and now I can use it. I know the names of a bunch of other people, and I have these unique symbols, these unique vocalizations that I associate, or semi unique that I associate it with different people, and I can call them by their name? Do any other species do any kind of naming like that? Yeah,

Michael Pardoso actually, the some of the work that I did with African elephants was a study where we were explicitly trying to test if elephants have something like, like, personal names they use to address each other, and we found evidence that they do and publish that but, but we weren't the first study to investigate that kind of thing in non human animals. So I think probably this species where the there's the best evidence for it is in bottom those dolphins, they have signature whistles, which are basically a highly stereotyped, so, you know, very consistent and distinct whistle pattern that each individual develops when they're young, and they use that as their calling card, like the usually they use they produce their own signature whistle to announce their presence to others, but every once in a while, a dolphin will imitate somebody else's signature whistle to effectively call them by name, Right, to get their attention, refer to them and and so that's it's best understood in bottles dolphins, because that's where it's been best studied. But there's also some evidence for similar behavior in some species of parrots, whether that is analogous to a name or whether it's something slightly different. Kind of depends on which parrot researchers you ask. But regardless, everybody agrees that some parrots will imitate each other's calls as a method of addressing them. And then shortly after, our elephant study came out. A few months later, another study showing something very similar in common, marmosets, was published as well. So so now we have evidence for this kind of behavior in dolphins, parrots, African savannah elephants and common Marvis

Nick Jikomesand so. So, I mean, clearly there are many species of animals where individuals are recognized by other individuals. They can they can learn that you're one individual versus another. They remember you. They treat individuals differently from one another based on their behavioral characteristics, of their personality, so to speak, what you're talking about is then this additional ability to actually vocalize in a way that either, you know, would either announce my presence as an individual, if I was a dolphin, say, I have this unique whistle, and I can effectively say I'm here. I'm here, not someone else. I am here, and then you're saying that in these other species, other members can imitate the sound that said individual makes to to identify them. You know, to what extent is that a name? What's important here, in terms of the dependency on imitation here?

Michael PardoSo um, in in human language, there's this concept called like arbitrary is arbitrariness versus iconicity. So most symbols in human language, especially in spoken human languages, this is less this is less true in signed languages, but even in side languages, it's true to a large extent that symbols are essentially arbitrary. There's no inherent connection between the sound of a word and the thing that that word refers to. And that's important because it allows us to communicate about things that don't make any imitable sound, like if there's no sound that can be imitated, that a thing makes, or no sound that's obviously connected to a way

Unknown Speakerwe can talk about empty

Michael Pardospace. Yeah, right. Like, how do you refer How do you, like, make the sound of a rock to refer to it in an iconic way? Right? You can't, right? So we need arbitrary symbols in order to communicate about a wider range of objects. Yes. Um, now in the dolphin system, whether or not that system is arbitrary, kind of depends on what angle you look at it from, so, from the perspective of the individual making their their own signature whistle to identify themselves to others, that is unquestionably an arbitrary symbol, right? If we accept that it's a symbol, it's unquestionably arbitrary, because their their whistle is not something that they're born with, they have to invent it. They create their own Whistle by listening to the whistles of other individuals around them and kind of combining them together and modifying it in some way, and and so that's that's an arbitrary identifier for themselves. But then when you think about other individuals calling someone by name by imitating their signature whistle, then it's a little bit, it's a little bit debatable whether that's arbitrary or iconic. Because, yeah, maybe they're perceiving this as an arbitrary label that they're using to identify the other dolphin. But maybe they're just it, or I shouldn't say just but they're, maybe what they're doing is, um. And is essentially labeling another dolphin or naming them by imitating the sound that is most often associated with,

Nick Jikomesyes, yes, yes. So I guess, yeah, one way to start to think about this would be, um, if I needed to hear you say your first name in order to know your first name, versus, you know, the way I actually learned it. I read it on a page. I didn't hear anyone else say it. I need you to be present or hear you to know what your name is. I guess that hasn't been disproven in dolphins. I would suppose it's just really hard to know if that is what's going on in cognitive terms, because you probably don't have a situation where you can observe dolphins, and one of them is, like, deaf, and the other ones have the opportunity to, like, make up a name for that third dolphin and then teach someone else about it. Yeah,

Michael Pardoright. So, so we don't, so I think it's not, I think both in the case of humans and in the case of dolphins, you know, if we take writing out of the picture, because writing is, you know, only something that a handful of human languages have done throughout history, and even today, many languages are not really written. So like, generally speaking for humans, we need to hear somebody's name either from the speaker, from the owner of the name, or from somebody else, in order to learn it. And the same is true for dolphins too. I guess the the potential point of distinction here is, how often is the name said by the owner? Like, is it? Yes, you know, we don't say our own names that often, so it's not really something that we could say. Is the typical sound that that we make? Whereas, with dolphins, they make their own signature whistles so often that it Potentially, it could be seen as, like, the typical sound associated about individuals, yeah? Like, instead of saying the word be like, I might just make a buzzing noise, right, right, right, yes, I guess. But we're doing it by imitating the sound of the beam. Yeah.

Nick JikomesSo, so the mystery and the potential thing here, that's that's unknown to us as researchers, is so these dolphins are making a characteristic sound. It's characteristic of themselves that they invented. They're making it frequently. And so the question is, is the sound they make, the auditory stimulus that is, the sound it's always associated with, say, the visual presence of the thing? Is this what we would call a simple sensory association, the sound that individual makes, plus I see them. So it's like a visual auditory Association, or is it something more language, like in the sense that it's arbitrary, and the reason we don't know that, again, is just because it's hard to make the relevant observation. So one would be that, if you know if, if you and I are dolphins, and there's a third dolphin over here, if I could say that dolphins name is, and then I made a whistle, and you could know that and remember that independent of ever having heard that sound or that label from that dolphin themselves. That's the type of observation we would need, but, but we probably just can't make that

Michael PardoYeah, so, so one just like, one tiny correction, I guess I, I wouldn't say that the dolphins are potentially just producing the whistle through like simple associative learning. I think there it's it does seem pretty clear that there's a fair bit of intentionality involved, because they use it in very specific ways to get the attention of a particular individual. Every time they see that individual, they make that sound. It depends on the context, right? Right?

Nick JikomesNow, I guess what I'm saying, though, is like when the other dolphins hear that sound, it's hard to know right now, if they're, if you know, let's let, I'm just gonna refer to it as the name or the whistle of the dolphin. So if the sender sends their name, their whistle out into the world, the other dolphins are always hearing that sound, or mostly hearing that sound in association with the seeing the other dolphin there. So when they learn the name, so to speak, is it just this sensory association, or do they have a more symbolic representation of that dolphin that isn't strictly tied to the auditory stimulus always being present when that individual is visually present,

Michael Pardoyeah, yeah, potentially. I think the key issue here is more like is more one of how the how the names work. Like are, do they rely on imitation or not? Rather than necessarily, what the implications would be about the cognitive representation? Because I think it's possible to have symbolic cognitive representation, with or without any way that you know, like we could use a buzzing sound as a symbol to refer to bees. We just don't, yeah,

Nick Jikomesokay, okay, I get that. Can you? Can you give us a little bit more of a sense for how people have observed these dolphins using these whistles. So, for example, you know, dolphins live in pods. You know, I know the very basics here, dolphins live in pods. So they're social. There's many of them. You know, maybe one dolphin swimming over here by himself, and he comes back into the group. Are there clear instances of the dolphin? You know, I could imagine that the dolphin might announce the surprise. To the group generally, or whoever happens to be around, versus, say, trying to communicate specifically with an individual by saying, Hey, you I am here, and, you know, I want to get your attention, as opposed to everyone else's. What sort of, you know, in the natural ecology of the organism, how are they using these whistles? So

Michael Pardodo you mean when they're producing their own signature, copying somebody else's signature. Well, let's take those one

Nick Jikomesat a time. But I was thinking, when they produce their own, how are they tending to use it?

Michael PardoThat's a good question, you know, I don't, I don't know, because I haven't ever actually been in the field with dolphins, you know, studying them. Yeah, I only know about this from the from the scientific literature, but my, my sense is that it's typically you're going to have in the wild, you're going to have more than two dolphins interacting, yeah, so it might be a little hard for researchers to to be able to tell, like, who a particular whistle is, is directed towards their signature whistle. I know that dolphins make these whistles when they meet at sea, so So especially when they encounter another individual, not not as often when they're just together with another dolphin who've been together for a while, they they're more likely to make it when they meet another dolphin. And it could be something they already know, of course. But just like you know, after some period of separation and in in captivity. And when dolphins are temporarily captured at sea, they very often make their signature whistle, kind of as a distress call. Like to let other dolphins know where they are and and you know, potentially, that they're in trouble. And this is kind of how signature whistles were originally discovered, that you know, when people would capture or or temporarily restrain dolphins and record them, they found that they were making these highly stereotyped whistles. So

Nick Jikomesthey were not just they were not merely just yelling out, like, Oh my God. They were making sounds that were seem to be unique dolphin to dolphin, like, I am over here,

Michael Pardoyelling out their own name, yeah, to let other dolphins know, not just that there was an individual in distress, but specifically who it was

Nick Jikomesinteresting. So let's get to the field work that you've done with elephants. Because I imagine you know this is probably where some of the most the richest information you have is. Let's just give people a general sense before we get to like the paper that you've published recently, you know, what can you give us just a kind of crash course on what we know and what we've learned, you know over the past few years and decades about vocal communication in elephants? Clearly, they do it. Everyone knows that elephants make these you know, the characteristic trumpeting sounds, but you know what sort of the spectrum of sounds that they make for the purpose of social communication. And what have we sort of learned? Um, learned about that leading up to your, your recent paper,

Michael Pardoyeah. Um, so it's, it's a little hard to summarize it all in a short sound bite. I actually wrote a whole book chapter about it, even that had to leave a lot of stuff out. But, um, basically. So they, they make a really wide spectrum of sounds in terms of frequency. So all elephants have, I guess you could say kind of four ish basic sounds that they make, like very broad category. So rumbles, which are harmonic sounds that are very low in frequency, where the fundamental frequency of the rumble, at least for adult elephants, is typically below the limit of human hearing and but the higher harmonics are audible to us. Then they make roars, which are these really loud, broadband sounds that span a wide range of frequencies. They make trumpets, which are the classic sound that everybody knows elephants make. And then they make shorter calls called barks. Or in African savanna elephants, sometimes they make these more harmonic bark like calls that are called cries, um, and those are like roars, but basically shorter in duration. And then Asian elephants also have um, two entirely separate classes of vocalizations, which are much higher in frequency. And African elephants don't make those at all. And then all elephants will also sometimes combine calls into these vocalizations that we call combination calls, where it's typically a rumble and then like some kind of roar or bark. And they can be in any order, although certain orders are preferred over others

Nick JikomesI see. So there's a there's a handful of classes of sounds that elephants make. They often make one sound or another, but they can also combine them into pairs or sequences. Yeah.

Michael PardoSo the combinations are most often two sounds, but sometimes they can be longer than that. So you know, the most common combinations would be roar, RUMBLE, RUMBLE, roar, and rumble, roar, Rumble. But there are, there are others as well,

Nick Jikomesand and, you know, I'll let you direct where, where to go. But like, if we just think about these classes of sounds, they make one at a time. What are the types of things that each one is used towards? Where do they have this sort of distinct things they refer. Or two. Does one of them refer to an action another one refers to, like, you know, announcing your presence. Or how are they using these things? Yeah.

Michael PardoSo an analogy I often give is like, if a, if an, I think, by classifying these sounds into such broad categories, if we think of them as as single call types, like we think of rumbles as just one type of call, we're missing all of the interesting stuff. So, like, for example, if an alien scientist came down to earth and was studying human communication, they might reasonably, reasonably divide human vocalizations up into a handful of categories, you know, screaming, crying, laughing, and then this other one called speech, right? But that's missing all the interesting, right, right? And I think it's similar with the elephants, like the rumbles are where a lot of the interesting stuff is going on. And they're, they're by far the most common call type that they make. And they're really variable, both in their their acoustic structure, and in the context in which, okay, so that was the call type that I focused on. Okay, so let's, let's actually

Nick Jikomesput a pin on that. Let's, let's come back to rumbles in a minute, because it sounds like the one that's gonna spend the most time on, I would imagine that some of these calls are pretty just basically emotive, like, it's a way to express a basic emotion the same way that, you know, crying or yelling, or, you know, you know, animals Express basic emotions with characteristic types of calls. For some of these other calls, what are some of the, you know, basic of things that are emoting with these.

Michael PardoSo they're basically all the non rumble call types are associated with some form of emotional arousal, and there seems to be a fair bit of overlap in how they're used. And there's also differences among the three elephant species, so African savanna elephants, African forest elephants and Asian elephants. So trumpets are often used in Asian elephants, especially they they're particularly associated with agitation and and aggressive or fearful context in although the calves do also produce them in play, especially in captivity,

Nick Jikomesyeah, but, I mean, yeah, but it's like, it's like in humans, right? Like little kids scream all that time, yeah,

Michael Pardoyeah. In African elephants, they also produce them, maybe a little bit more frequently in in social context. Is like non non fearful social context as well when there's a great deal of excitement about something, yeah. But they also, of course, use them in disturbance context as well. Roars generally express some kind of negative emotion, so calves very often make them when they're denied access to to their mom's breast. So when they're like trying to nurse and mom's taking them away, the roar Asian elephant seem to use roars as contact calls, sometimes to to basically stay in touch with with social affiliates at a distance. Was African elephants only use rumbles in that context. So

Nick Jikomesit's kind of interesting. Is it because, like, the Asian elephants are in the jungle, so they might be relatively close by, but you can't see them through all the trees, and they just want to know, like, Hey, are you still there?

Michael PardoPotentially, we have no idea. The roars travel quite a fair bit of distance, as well as as the rumbles. And as far as I know, there's no evidence that African forest elephants, which also live in a forest environment, use roars as contact calls. So I don't know, I don't know why, okay, but very often, like they'll make, they'll also make a roar. Sometimes, if they're they experience aggression from another individual. They're protesting that um, barks and cries. So cries are have only been described in African savanna elephants. They're basically just like harmonic barks. So they're these sort of shorter broadband calls, and they're produced by calves. You know, when the calf is distressed about something, often related to milk, the barks are produced kind of in opposite context, by African savanna elephants and Asian elephants. So Asian elephants mostly make barks when they're being aggressive to somebody else, whereas African savannah elephants mostly make BARTs when they're receiving aggression, but in both cases, they're associated with some kind of, you know, emotional outbursts in the context of aggression. And then the squeaks and squeals that Asian elephants make are usually associated with with some kind of disturbance or agitation.

Nick JikomesYeah, so all of those classes of sounds and their variations are pretty clearly even, even if we don't understand the details. They're all associated with high states of arousal or emotional arousal of some kind, yeah, yeah. And so, and then we've got these roars that are potentially more interesting here, and what might be more language like rumbles. Sorry, the rumbles. Rumbles, yes, yes. So just starting with their acoustic characteristics, what are these rumbles? What do they look like, bio acoustically, as opposed to these other types of sounds? Do they are they clearly distinguished in any way in terms of the actual acoustics that are emitted? Yeah.

Michael PardoSo the two defining characteristics are, they're they're highly harmonic, so they're not they're not very noisy compared to the other call types. So rather like when you look at them in a spectrogram, which is like a graphical representation of the sound, you see these very clear harmonic stacks where you have the fundamental frequency and then the harmonics like layered on top of it. So it looks like a stack of curved lines and and they're also much lower in frequency. So the fundamental frequency of rumbles is for, for adult elephants, like typically around maybe, like 15 hertz for females can be down to 10 hertz for some of the male rumbles, calf rumbles will be higher in pitch. Obviously, as you know, they get bigger. Their vocal cords get more massive, but, but they're much, much lower in pitch than than all the other

Nick Jikomestypes. So, so the so they're lower in pitch, but they also have a different structure. Is it fair to say? Is it too simplistic to say that they're just generally more ordered in terms of their acoustic properties? Or

Michael Pardoyeah, I think that. I think that's fair. Yeah, because the other calls tend to have more more noise and more chaos in them, in whereas these are much more harmonic. And I think you can, you can think of, you know, harmonic versus noisy vocalizations as more versus less ordered in a sense, so that, yeah, I think that makes sense.

Nick JikomesAnd what would I mean? Is there some kind of analogy here? It's like, I want to give people a sense for what harmonic means too. Is there some kind of analogy here we can draw with music or something. Yeah.

Michael PardoSo if you hear like a, if you hear a sound that, like most sounds that we think sound nice or not unpleasant, are often harmonic sounds. So they're so, so there's kind of, there are pure tones, which is, like, you know, actually doesn't sound that nice. It just sounds like a beep. And then a harmonic sound is like a pure tone with which is at a particular frequency, that's the fundamental frequency, and then the harmonics are whole integer multiples of that fundamental so, so like, let's say you have the fundamental frequencies at 100 Hertz. That's like 100 cycles of the sound wave per second. The second harmonic that is the next one after the fundamental would be 200 hertz, and then the next one would be, you know, 300 hertz, or, I guess, yeah, I guess we'd be 300 hertz, and then 400 hertz, etc. So you're basically the step between harmonics is equal to the fundamental frequency and and so it sounds kind of like, I mean, most sounds that that mammals make, are harmonic. Our speech sounds are highly harmonic. A lot of musical instruments will be harmonic, whereas, like a noisy sound would be something like a drum beat or or just, you know, heavy metal screaming. I see right where it's just, it's, it's the it's a cacophony, periodic vibration of focal cords. Instead, it's just vibrating chaotically. And, yeah, if you look at it in a spectrogram, it just like, it looks like a smear across the frequency spectrum. Okay,

Nick Jikomesso, so these elephants make this type of this, this class of sounds give us a sense of the Behavioral Ecology here. What are the contexts? I mean, is there a particular species you want to focus on? But like, what are the contexts they're used in most frequently? What do they seem to When, when, and how do they seem to be using these types of sounds? So the interesting,

Michael Pardothe interesting thing about rumbles is that they're made in almost every context, which makes them a lot harder to understand what they're for, but also more interesting because human speech is also used in pretty much every context, and so that suggests that there's a lot of interesting and variable things that they can communicate about. So for example, some of the more people have tried to divide rumbles up into different subtypes based on both their acoustic structure and the context in which they're used, but there's a lot of variability, and they kind of grade from one subtype into another. So it's not like you can divide them into very neat categories that always look and sound a certain way. So one very common context in which rumbles are used is this contact calls where the the caller and the intended recipient are out of sight of one of each other, and the caller is trying to reinitiate contact with the, you know, their social affiliate who's out of sight. And so those rumbles often tend to have kind of a slightly arched pattern. They tend to be quite loud because they're produced at a distance. Another common context is, let's go rumbles, where an elephant who wants the group to initiate movement in a particular direction will stand, kind of at the periphery of the group, facing in the direction that he or she wants to go. And they make these, these, let's go rumbles, which are sort of flatter in frequency profile and a little bit longer than contact rumbles typically. And then that often precipitates like a back and forth exchange of rumbles among several individuals in the group. And then the group will either move off in a particular direction or not move off, sometimes

Nick Jikomesso superficially. And you know. This is a subject where it's hard, it could be very hard not to anthropomorphize, and we could even, you know, argue about whether the extent to which that's appropriate. But what you just described naively sounds like someone says, Let's go this way, and then the group deliberates, and then does it or doesn't? Yeah,

Michael Pardoit's possible that that's actually what they're doing. It seems like there's some form of negotiation, you know whether that's that's actually analogous to like a human conversation negotiating something. We don't know but, but it seems that there is some kind of back and forth exchange of information that influences whether or potentially, where the group moves. But we don't really understand a lot about what kind of information is encoded in those rumbles. Other than that, they are used in this context where somebody is trying to initiate group

Nick Jikomesmovement, okay, and then, and then, what are the other examples? Oh, there. I

Michael Pardomean, there's so many. So they use them as alarm signals. If they're threatened by by, you know, humans or lions. They use it like as in protest situations. So kind of, if a calf is is miffed that their mom won't let them nurse, typically, they'll start with rumbles, and then if they get really annoyed, they'll move into roars. And they they use rumbles in a greeting context as well. So when two individuals who are bonded to each other approach one another after some period of separation, they make these greeting rumbles in African in African elephants, at least especially African savannah elephants, it's, it's usually associated with, like a more elaborate, you know, behavioral display where they're they're being really exuberant. They make other highly emotional calls too. They kind of spin around. They urinate, defecate, there's, there's a lot of excitement. And then they also make them in, in what are sometimes called little greeting context, where two individuals who have been in the same group all day, but maybe one of them just approaches the other than touching distance, and then they'll make a rumble as well, but it's more subdued than these, like louder, exuberant reading displays. They also mothers and aloe mothers, so you know, non like females, other than the mother who helped take care of a calf, they'll produce rumbles called coup rumbles to the calf in kind of two different contexts. One is when they're comforting the calf after the calf has expressed distress about something, and the other is where they're basically touching or nursing the calf in a calm context with no apparent distress and and these, those two types of rumbles, like there's, it doesn't seem like they're acoustically distinct from each other, so we just call them a single type coup rumbles. And so they're, they're kind of like, I think I, in my paper, actually call them caregiving rumbles to give them a more, you know, functional description. But yeah, I think those are kind of some of the more common categories. And

Nick Jikomesso, yeah, I mean, these are, you know, a lot of social use here, clearly. And some of them, you know, start to imply that that, you know, it's not just sort of general vocalizations directed towards everyone. Some of these could be personal and even individual. And so where does this start to bleed into some of the research you've done on on you know, whether or not they're calling each other by unique names, yeah.

Michael PardoSo what we did basically is focused on rumbles, where we were able to identify the the individual who made the call, and also where we were able to identify a single, individual recipient of the call. So sometimes elephants will make a rumble and everybody in the group responds, but sometimes they'll make a rumble and only one specific individual responds, and sometimes they'll make a rumble in a context where it's clear that they're only communicating to a specific individual. So for example, with with greeting rumbles, it's very easy, you know, if it's especially little greeting rumbles where it's just two individuals. One individual approaches another, somebody makes a call, and then the other individual responds. It's very obvious. There's a caller, there's a receiver. Same thing with the coup rumbles to calves, like the caregivers making the call, and the intended recipient is obviously the calf, because just those two individuals interacting with contact rumbles. It's a little bit more challenging. You can't be in two places at once, and usually the receiver is outside of the line of sight of the caller. But sometimes we were able to figure out that contact call was directed to one specific individual. Typically this was in a situation where, for example, we had been following the group all day, so we knew everybody who was in the group that day, and everybody except for one individual, continued on. One individual was lagging behind the group, and then somebody in the main body of the group would make a contact call, often while facing in the direction of the individual who was lagging. So we could in that situation, we could reasonably infer that it was a contact. That call directed to that one specific individual. So, so basically, we gathered all of these calls where we where we were confident that they were dressed to just one individual. We knew who that individual was. And then we we measured a bunch of features of the the acoustic properties of these calls. And then we tried to use a random forest model, like a type of machine learning classifier, to assign those calls to the the to basically predict who a call was addressed to from the acoustic properties of that call. Yeah.

Nick JikomesSo at this point, let's do two things. So one, in essence, once you get to this point, you've identified these contexts in which it's quite clear that there's communication from an individual to another individual, even though this is like often in a group of context. So, so you've got contextual factors that are helping you discern when you can sort of isolate, you know, one on one conversation, so to speak, and the and so at that point you're basically saying, okay, are they are they saying, Hey, Mickey, like, come you're falling behind, keep up. Or are they just going, hey, hey, like, and so now you've got to distinguish if they're making the sort of general sound directed and individual, excuse me, at an individual, versus using a sound that is only directed at that individual, that would never be used to make the same kind of call to someone else? Exactly?

Michael PardoYeah. Now that was the big question, right? So my, my, you know, my post doctoral supervis supervisor and one of my collaborators had been studying, I mean, they've been studying elephants for for decades, and so over the course of their experience with elephants, they had observed a lot of situations where elephants were vocalizing and it seemed like just one individual responded. But we didn't know for sure if the if the calls had some information in them that identified a specific intended recipient, or if in those instances where just one individual responds, it was just because that was the only individual who felt like responding, right? So we needed to know if these calls actually contain some information that is specific to the intended receiver. Yeah.

Nick JikomesAnd before getting to some of the punch line here, the other thing I wanted to bring up at this point was, how are you making these measurements? You're out in the field following elephants. How close are you to the elephants? How are you literally making the acoustic measurements? How is all of this being measured?

Michael PardoYeah. So the nice thing about working with the population of elephants that I work with, which is in Samburu and buffalo springs, national reserves in northern Kenya, is that this population has been studied for decades. So the elephants are very habituated to researchers in a vehicle, and we can drive up pretty close to them. So I was making these recordings from, you know, anywhere from, like 25 to five meters away. I tried to be at least 20, like, no more than 20 meters from the elephants to get good quality audio and and they were fine with that. Like they just kind of treat you like a, you like a feature of the environment. And so we would just follow them around all day until they went into a place where we couldn't access with the vehicle. And basically, whenever the elephant stopped or were moving very slowly, we just turned off the car and recorded continuously. And then whenever an elephant vocalized, I use this trick that I learned from another elephant researcher, where I had this, this thing called a steno mask, which is something that court reporters sometimes use to basically whisper dictation into a record, an audio recorder that sound like being heard by into this dick

Nick Jikomesto phone. Yeah, you can annotate the recordings, yeah. And I would

Michael Pardoannotate the recordings in real time, and it my voice wouldn't get picked up by the microphone that was recording elephants, because it was this sort of, like soundproof device. Or,

Nick JikomesI see, I see, okay. So, okay. So, so there's technology that was developed for courtroom use, like, if someone wanted to take notes, like, yeah, for a court case. And it's not just going to disturb the actual court case, but they can still say something and record it. You can use that to annotate the stuff that you're measuring from the elephant. So, like, you know, so I imagine you're talking into this device, but when you're picking up sounds from the elephants at a distance, you've got some kind of directional microphone that you're just sort of pointing in their direction. How do you control like, you know, if you want to record from that elephant, but not that elephant, and they're both 25 meters away from you, how do you start to to record from Elephant by elephant here?

Michael PardoSo basically, you can't, okay, so my my understanding, I'm far from an audio engineer, my understanding is that when you're trying to record infrasound like really low frequencies, there basically aren't any commercially available microphones that are directional, but all the directional microphones essentially strip away those lower frequencies. And so we were using an omni directional microphone that that didn't uh. You know, decrease the sound pressure levels from any particular direction. So we were picking up everything. And basically what we would try to do is, is stay close to the individual that we were trying to record, so that when she vocalized, if there were no overlapping sounds, we would get a nice, clean recording, I see, but sometimes there were overlapping sounds, and unfortunately, we just had to not use those. And so I guess,

Nick Jikomesyeah, so I guess you're just sort of recording everything being emitted by the elephants. And there's a wide spectrum of literal like frequencies represented here, which is why you had to do it in the way you just described. But then sort of the the specificity that you can get, as good as it can get, it comes from your annotation. So I guess, you know, one point in the recording you can say, like, okay, that sound that you just heard was clearly coming from Jake the elephant. And that sound, we're not quite sure who's coming from, so we don't know. And then the next sound is coming from, you know, John the elephant or whatever. Yeah.

Michael PardoOkay, yeah. Okay, exactly, yeah. So, so basically, we would, we would use various techniques in the field to figure out who is calling sometimes, elephants have behavioral cues that are associated with with vocalizing, so that sometimes helped. And then also, if you're standing close, if you're close enough to the elephant, when they vocalize, you can tell that it's them, if they're the only individual who's that close, just based on how loud it is and what direction it's coming from, and that kind of thing, but sometimes we weren't able to tell. And so again, you know, we weren't able to use those calls. So it was, it was quite challenging to get enough recordings to do anything with it, just because most of the sounds that you record either it's, you know, you're too far away from the elephant and the recording is in good quality, or somebody else vocalizes at the same time, or you just can't tell who's making the sound. Or, you know, we don't know who they were calling to. That was very often the case as well. So yeah, so it kind of whittled down to a large extent the recordings we were able to use. So

Nick Jikomesobviously, you know, this field work is, I mean, you're describing how you can measure things and what the limitations are. It's very difficult to, you know, to control, you know, this is not a controlled laboratory setting, yeah, but you have ways of annotating the data. You know, you could sometimes tell using behavioral cues and just, you know, and annotating the data in the ways that you described. Obviously, you know, there's, there's, you know, there's only so much specificity you have in data set like this, but you know when, when it's all said and done, you know what were the types of things that you felt like you could confidently discern from this data in terms of anything akin to name calling.

Michael PardoSo one thing we were able to do is we were able to train a machine learning model to correctly predict, predict who a call was addressed to, just from the acoustic properties of that call, which was sort of a first step at suggesting that there might be something in these calls, like a name. But that wasn't, that wasn't conclusive evidence for names by itself, because there's a lot of other possibilities for how the model could have learned that. So for example, maybe it was just picking up on things like every caller has a unique voice. We know that to be the case in elephants and many other animals, and so maybe it was picking up on like the unique voice of the caller, and then guessing who the receiver was most likely to be simply based on the fact that some callers called more to certain receivers. Okay, so, so to rule out alternative explanations like that, we took advantage of a really nice property of random forest models, which is that they provide you with a measure of similarity between each possible pair of calls in the data set called proximity scores. And so we extracted these metrics of similarity from the structure of the random forest, and then we use those to show that calls from the same caller to the same receiver were significantly more similar, on average, than calls from the same caller to two different receivers. So basically, even when we held caller identity constant, we found that calls addressed to different receivers were distinct. And so that was, that was, I think, much stronger evidence that these calls contain some receiver specific information. And then the second piece of evidence is that we did an experiment in the field where we played back the calls to the elephants and recorded their responses.

Nick JikomesSo roughly speaking, the idea is, if these things are something like a name, you would expect the elephant that that name is attached to to maybe orient towards you guys more than other elephants or something, yeah.

Michael PardoSo we expected them to respond more strongly, um, what is respond to major, yeah. Yeah, exactly. So it wasn't specifically um orienting because elephants, you know, they have, I mean, they do orient towards sounds, but sometimes it's not the most obvious response. And so we did measure that, but in addition that, we also measured their latency to approach the speaker. So how quickly they approach the speaker? In response to the playback, their latency to vocalize in response to the playback, so how quickly they they made a call of their own in response, and then also how many calls they made in response.

Nick JikomesAnd just to make sure I'm following, so when you are emitting This vocalization, are you? Are you emitting another? Is it like the sound of another elephant in the group saying their potential name, or is it just their potential name in some new voice?

Michael PardoNo, we used actual raw recordings of another elephant in the group saying their name because we I think the biggest limitation of this study is we don't yet know exactly how these these punitive names are encoded in the calls, yeah? So we can't yet synthesize a name,

Nick Jikomesyeah? You can't abstract artificial voice. Okay, I got it. I got it. Okay, yeah, I

Michael Pardowould love to do that in the future, that that would kind of next step, yeah, okay.

Nick JikomesBut so, so you're, you're playing back sounds that another elephant in the group of myths that might contain at least a portion of it, the potential name here, and you're saying, you're basically saying, Does that individual that we we think we're referring to, are they? Are they responding in some way more so than other other individuals?

Michael PardoExactly. Yeah. So the idea was that if we play back a call of, say, you know, elephant a calling to elephant B, then we would expect, and if this call is a name, as opposed to, say, just a generic call that they like hey, that they use to call everybody, then we would expect B to respond more strongly to that Call than to a different call from caller a that was originally addressed to somebody else. Yes, right. So by, by playing back every individual two two calls, one that was originally addressed to them and one from the same caller that was originally addressed to someone else, we basically control for the possibility that they might just be responding to the voice of the caller because they have a, you know, a stronger affiliation with that individual. Yep.

Nick JikomesAnd okay, so what's, what's, what's the punchline here?

Michael PardoSo we found that they they approach the speaker more quickly, they vocalize more quickly, and they produce more vocalizations in response to a call that was originally addressed to them, compared to a call from the same call addressed to somebody

Nick Jikomeselse. So the manager is consistent with the idea that something like a name is being used here Exactly,

Michael Pardoyeah. So so it suggests that they're able to determine just by hearing a call if it was intended for them or if it was intended for another individual. So that that kind of strength that combined with the analysis of the proximity scores, and you know, the fact that these calls contain some acoustic information that's specific to the individual receiver, that, combined with the playback experiment, strengthened our conclusion that these calls contain something like a name.

Nick JikomesAnd you know, I haven't, I haven't looked at the analysis myself, but can you give me a sense for like, the effect size here, is this a very clear, big effect, or is this kind of subtle and ambiguous a lot of the time? So

Michael Pardofor the for the playback experiment, it was quite a substantial effect, especially given the small sample size. We only had 17 individuals, and we had no idea if all the calls were playing back contain names like, it's quite possible that elephants have names they don't use them in every call. So there was a lot of noise in the state, and we still got a pretty, a pretty substantial effect for the analysis of the proximity scores. I'd say we had maybe a we so we did a couple analyzes with that. We certainly had, we had a stronger effect size for the finding that calls from the same caller to the same receiver were more similar than calls from the same caller to different receivers. Yeah. When we we also wanted to know if different callers use the same name for the same receiver, yeah. And so we, I was gonna ask that. Yeah, okay, so yes, well, we can talk about that next.

Nick JikomesOkay, so, so, in essence, like, one of, one of the tricky things here is, it's like, you have these record you're, you're making these playbacks. You've recorded vocalizations from elephants. You're playing them back now to to see what happens. And like, like, like, if I was trying to get your attention, and a group of us were hanging out, like a group of friends or family or whatever, and I wanted to get your attention, I could say, Hey Michael. I could say hey, but like, look at you. I could say, Hey Michael and others. Like, there's many different ways I could partially or completely try and get just your attention, or your attention plus other people's. And so when you have these recordings you're playing back, you guys don't actually know. Are they saying just, Hey, Michael, are they saying something similar, something that includes your name and other names or whatever? And so that's a tricky part of this. Yeah,

Michael Pardoexactly. And the challenge is that, you know, we wouldn't expect them to use names in every utterance, right, right? We didn't know a priority, which, you know. Which calls might contain something like a name and which might not? So, yeah, so, so again, like, for some of the analyzes that we did, the effect sizes were quite small. I think the ones where the effect size were were biggest is the two that I've talked about so far. Yeah. You know, like the evidence that the calls are specific to individual receivers and that the elephants respond more strongly to calls that were originally addressed to them.

Nick JikomesOkay, so, so, so now the question is, okay, if, if they are using something like a name, then if I'm trying to get Michael's attention, I'm gonna say, Hey, Michael. But if someone else needs to get Michael's attention, they're also gonna call out to Michael, as opposed to Pete or Dave. So are multiple individuals calling to the same elephant using the same sound? Yeah,

Michael Pardoso that that is a good question. So that's where, that's where we had slightly more ambiguous results. So using those same proximity scores that I talked about before, we found that calls from two different callers addressed to the same receiver were more similar on average, then calls from two different callers addressed to different receivers, but that effect size was relatively small. Was statistically significant, but relatively small. And then we tried to train a random forest to learn to predict the receiver of a call when it by training it on on calls from some callers and then testing it on calls, yeah, and it wasn't able to do that. Now, I suspect the reason it wasn't is because we had a limited sample size, especially when we partitioned the data out in this way, where we have, you know, we had relatively like if for the calls addressed to a given receiver, we might have most of them from from one particular caller and very few from other callers. So it's not too surprising the random cars wasn't able to learn this, but because it wasn't able to learn this, it makes our conclusions about whether different callers using the same name for the same receiver, somewhat inconclusive. So I think so it's fair

Nick Jikomesto say that these results, these results are interesting and suggestive and suggestive and consistent with the idea that something like names are used, but they're not totally definitive.

Michael PardoYeah, especially if you define names as as being like everybody's using the same label for the same receiver, that I'd say our results are far more suggestive than definitive. If you define names more broadly as any sort of call that is specific to a single individual receiver, then I think we have stronger evidence for that. But, but, yeah, it kind of depends, again, like, sort of like with the word language, you know, the word name can be defined in a broader sense, or right,

Nick Jikomesyou know, and of course, like, it's important to try and study these things as methodically as possible. And you know, on the one hand, you've got limitations in the field work that come from the fact that you're in the field rather than in the lab, right? You can't bring a group of elephants into the lab and control all the relevant things here that you might want to in principle, but, but on the other hand, you know, you're looking at real, naturalistic behavior in context, right? And you know, ultimately, that's, I think, what's interesting, right? Is, how does it work out in the real world, you know, so, so data is important, statistics are important, analysis is important, you know, you know, using reductionistic approaches like laboratory analysis, you know, all of these things are important. I'm a laboratory in the guy, that's how I was trained, right? But also, you know, we can't forget to just use common sense and your observations in the field. Can you just give us like your sense? You spent a lot of time with these elephants out in the field. You've done these types of studies, you've seen all the different types of things they do. Does it look like they're calling each other individually?

Michael PardoYeah, it kind of does. I mean, I'm always cautious about interpreting, you know, subjective experience and and anecdotal evidence like that, because it's so easy to just let your your bias, or what you hope is true, slip into it. Um, but, but, yeah, just from my, my personal observations of the elephants, there are a lot of instances where you'll see a group of elephants and somebody, somebody makes a call, and then one member of the group responds and nobody else does. And then the same individual might make a call in a different day and a different member of the group responds, yeah. Um, and and also, so, so in those instances, it really looks like they might be directing communication to one specific individual in the group and And yet, on other times, like, sometimes they'll make a call and everybody responds. So it seems like sometimes they might be using these name like calls, and sometimes they're not. And another thing is that often we would see individuals producing a call, like, like I described a little bit before where there would be, like a contact calling situation, where somebody's lagging behind the group. And then it was, it was very obvious that they were directing a call to that specific individual, because they'd be, you know, the rest of the group would have moved off a little bit, then one member of the group would kind of hang back and face in the direction of the lagging individual. Just call repeatedly until that lagging individual met up with her, and then she would immediately turn around and they would go together towards the rest of the group. So it's very obvious she was directing communication to that specific individual. So it's at least a situation where, in which I would expect them to potentially be using names, if that's something that they do?

Nick JikomesYeah, I want to back up for just a second and ask you some some very basic questions about elephants. So the elephants, the type of elephants that you study in Africa for these experiments about vocalization and communication, give us a sense. How big are these groups normally? How long are the elephants living? How long do they tend to have relationships for are they? They're living multiple decades, right? Yeah.

Michael PardoSo they in the wild, they can easily live into their 50s or early 60s. Obviously, a lot of them don't make it that far, you know, because of, you know, disease, or, you know, being shot by humans or whatever. But, but, you know, there, there are a lot of individuals who make it into their 60s, so they're maintaining these relationships for life. In many cases, female elephants in African savannah elephants, they they basically stay with their their natal group, the group that they were born into, for life in the vast majority of cases, and they have this really complex society that's sort of structured with like nested groups, so that the tightest, the tightest Nick group is, you know, we call a family group, and then multiple related family groups form a more loosening bond group, and then multiple bond groups that are often unrelated to each other form a even more loosely knit affiliation that we call a clan. I see, okay, clan, yeah, yeah. It's like a human clan, yeah. So they have, you know, they have hundreds of relationships with other individuals,

Nick Jikomesbut it's, it's, you know, given how long they live, given their ability to remain, just given all the things that we know are true for elephants like, it would be shocking if they aren't recognizing in other individuals at an individual, for individual

Michael PardoExactly, yeah. I mean, individual recognition is super common in vertebrates, or at least social vertebrates, and it's, you know, it would be almost impossible to explain a lot of elephants behavior. They couldn't recognize each other individually, yeah, because we have direct experimental evidence that they do from from previous Yes. And can you

Nick Jikomestalk a little bit more about like, the social structure here? Like, how are the little family groups ordered, and how are the clans ordered? My rough understanding is that elephants are matriarchal, like the mother is a very important determiner of who related to who. So

Michael Pardothey're they're often described as matriarchal, and I don't know if that's necessarily the most appropriate way to describe their society, because matriarchal implies that that females are dominant to males, like in spotted hyenas, for example. But that's not the case in elephants. It's rather that they're sex segregated, so the males lead their natal group when they reach puberty, and they go off on their own, and then they form relationships with other males, I see, and they kind of have their own society, separate from the

Nick Jikomesfemale in that way. It's kind of like lions, is it not? Um, sort of, yeah, because don't they kind of kick the males out once they get old enough the Milo patriot male dispersal, yeah. Okay, okay. So, so a fam. So Alfred is born into a family, um, he's going to be surrounded by a lot of older women, including his mother, older female elephants. And eventually, if it's a if it's a male baby, when he grows up, hits puberty, he will have to leave, and then he'll go off by himself and maybe hang out some other males for some time. But if it's a female elephant, she will, if she'll stay and grow up and just stay with that family for life? Yeah, okay.

Michael PardoAnd then within those female groups, they're, they're led by the oldest female, who we call the matriarch, yeah, so, um, basically, the males and females just kind of do their own things, separately from each other. Occasionally, males will visit female groups for brief periods of time and hang out with them, yeah, but they're not leading those groups, and they're not really spending much time with those groups. And within those female groups, the they're They're led by the oldest female. So

Nick Jikomeshow is I want like? So the males leave when they hit puberty, and then like, do they frequently come back to like, their mother's family? Do they visit, you know, families where they've had they've had daughters and sons. What did or are the males just kind of like randomly meeting up with different groups of other elephants. It depends

Michael Pardoa lot on the individual. So there's some males who don't disperse very far from where they were born, like in the same blue population. We have some males who were born there and have and are there as adults, but we also have males who have come in from other populations, from really far away. And there are males who who disperse far away from Sambu too, presumably. So with those males who stick around in the general vicinity of their their mothers group, they do sometimes go back and visit them. Um. Um, we we know from from prior work that elephants can recognize their kin and their male elephants are much less likely to mate with Kin than with non kin, so they kind of avoid, like sexual interaction with their female relatives. And interestingly, they can do that for both maternal and paternal kin. The better recognizing maternal kin, obviously, because they grew up with them, right? But, but they have some mechanism of recognizing who their paternal kin are, even though, like they have no idea who the father is, right, right? It's just, you know, presumably you have no idea, because elephants are, are polygynous, so or polygendrus, right? Like everybody, kind of mates with females, mate with multiple males. Males mate with multiple females. There's no, like pair bonding, or anything like that. How

Nick Jikomesare so, so? So the males leave the family group, which is led by a group of adult females, led by a matriarch, Who's the oldest female. So when the males become reproductively mature, or probably just before that, I would guess they get, they get kicked out of the group, basically. But obviously mating happens, and so an adult male has to come and court and mate with a female at some point, who's part of this maternal group, this female group. How are mating decisions by females actually made? Are they made at an individual level, like, how do they allow adult males get close enough and do the courtship and all that. That's

Michael Pardoa really good question. So, so number one, I'm not sure if they get kicked out of the group. I it seemed to me just, you know, by observing this casually, that it was far more that the as males got older and older, they started spending more and more time apart from the group, until

Nick Jikomesthey just weren't as interested in hanging out. Yeah, and

Michael Pardothey started hanging out more with other males. I didn't really see a lot of aggression from from, you know, older females toward the adolescent males. They just seem to kind of

Nick Jikomeswander off. So it's not like, like, there's a period in my life where I had parakeets and they would lay eggs and and they had a couple batches of eggs, and the mother would basically, if the chick got old enough and didn't spontaneously leave the nest, eventually she would, she would really put them out. But this is it sounds like it's more more of the case that in the males, they just start hanging around less and less, because that's just what they're inclined to do.

Michael PardoYeah, that's what it looked like to me. You know, I wasn't explicitly studying that or measuring that, but, but I didn't see a lot of aggression towards those males.

Nick JikomesSo how do we know? Like, how does mating happen in elephants then? Like, what does the courtship phase look like?

Michael PardoYeah, so, so basically, female elephants only come into estrus, rarely there. The inner birth interval is like something like four years on average.

Nick JikomesWait four years of their entire life. No, like, like the inter birth interval. So the inter birth interval is 40

Michael Pardocalves, okay, is like 44 years. So they, so they come into estrus. They're typically in estrus for just a few days at a time. And males find them, presumably by smell, but also by sound. So females make calls when they're in estrus that are sort of typical of that, of that, you know, hormonal state, right? And males, males respond to those calls and move towards them. And females prefer to meet with males who are bigger, which means older, because male elephants grow continuously throughout their life, and also males who are in must. So male elephants go through this, this hormonal cycle every year, like once they hit their late 20s, they they start going or, you know, maybe like 30, they start regularly experiencing this period called must, where their testosterone peaks, and they they start ranging a lot further and searching for females and being a lot more aggressive and interested in sexual behavior in their 30s. Yeah, they're really late mature. So like, it depends on the population. Sure, sure, if there are no adult, if there are no really big mature bowls, males will enter must at a younger age, yeah, but, but typically, like when they first start, they'll go into must, very briefly, and it's not very profound, it's not very pronounced must. But then as they get older, the must periods get longer and longer, and usually, like, by the time they're going into must, regularly for like, a substantial period of time, they're in their late 20s, early 30s, and they so, like, when they're in must, they're a lot more attractive to females, and they're also dominant to other males. So a male will, a male who's not in must, will typically defer to a male who is in must, even if he's bigger, and then among must males, generally, the bigger, the bigger an individual is, the more dominant he is.

Nick JikomesBut like When, when, when actual courtship is happening from one between one female and one male, is it like a female is? You know. Know, in in estrus, and she just kind of goes off, kind of by her on her own for a while, and there's, like, this one on one, semi private interaction, or does, like, a male have to come up to the group and get, like, the matriarchs approval? Like, what is the oh, okay, yeah, that is

Michael Pardoa good question. So, so actually, this is why I don't think it makes sense to call elephants matriarchal, because the adult males are dominant to adult females, I see, don't live with adults, so

Nick Jikomeseven the families are led by this matriarch, the most senior mother. But it's not like she's calling all the shots on everything, right?

Michael PardoLike she called she She's the leader of her family. Yeah. But then if a male comes in from outside, the males just kind of come up to the females. And if the male is big enough, like he's dominant to those females, and you know, they will kind of like, defer to him and move out. I mean, he's not leading the group, but, yeah, but

Nick Jikomesthey are, I mean, sexually submissive to him if he inserts, yeah, yeah.

Michael PardoAnd males very often visit females, even when they're not in. Must to kind of check them and potentially see when they might be coming into estrus next. And it's very common for an adult male to hang out with a female group for a day and just, just like travel with them. And the females don't seem to mind it. They interact socially with the male. If a male is in must, they really are excited about it. So they vocalize a lot they everybody's kind of crowds around him. Everyone wants to smell him. They're really interested in males who are in must and when a female is an estrus, usually you'll get a lot of males, including multiple bust males, converging on that group all at once, because they can tell she's an estrus. And what will end up happening is she runs away, and they chase her, and they go in this, like, really long chase, where she's she's making these estrus roars the whole time, and this is kind of where the mate choice happens, right? So, like, the female has some ability to control copulation, because if she starts walking, the male can't really say mounted, because he'll just fall over. So she she basically can refuse a male by just not standing still.

Nick JikomesSo in essence, at the right time, multiple males will be literally chasing one female, and she can kind of pick who wins. Yeah,

Michael Pardoexactly. And the males will also, like fight it out amongst each other. So if, if there's one really big muscle there, the other guys are going to just hang back because they don't want to risk getting injured, and there will be some mate guarding that takes place as well. So the must bull will, who mates with a female, will often hang out with her for a while and chase away any other males. And the females seem to prefer that, because they get less harassed that way. So, you know, I it was really interesting. I saw this one, this one instance where we had, you know, like a big old must bull who had mated with a female in estrus, and then as soon as he mated with her, he just, like, like, milked out of there. He just left. And the the entire female group chased after him, calling after him, like, trying to get him, presumably, trying to get him to come back and make guard the female that he just made it with. And he's like, No, I'm done.

Nick JikomesWow. They're like, Hey, what are you doing? You're not. Your job isn't done here. Yeah, exactly.

Michael PardoHe's like, No, I made it. You know, I'm moving on to somebody else now, wow. Let's

Nick Jikomesleave it at that before we get in trouble. Okay, oh, so, I mean, it's just the I didn't really know anything about elephant social structure. You know beyond, beyond the fact that you know they're not, as you said, they're not matriarchal in the sense that the females are dominant to everyone and to the males, but the family groups, they're female LED. But then it sounds like the family they congregate into these larger groups that are basically clans, right?

Michael PardoAnd that's that's somewhat seasonal as well. So, um, typically the wet season when more food is available, is available. Um, you'll get larger aggregations of elephants. Whereas in the dry season, when food is more scarce, they split up into smaller groups. And even sometimes, the family groups will split off into smaller units to forage.

Nick JikomesBut it sounds like that in terms of behavioral dominance and hierarchies. Here elephants are. They're obviously big animals, but they grow for life. They live a long time. And it sounds if I'm if I'm hearing you right, it sounds, in general, like the more the bigger the animal, the animal, the older the animal, the more dominant the animal, and they kind of just follow that logic,

Michael Pardoyeah, pretty much within so in between families of elephants, the the dominance of an individual relative to an individual from another family is determined based On the dominance of their matriarchs. So if matriarch A is dominant to matriarch B, then everybody in family a is dominant to everybody in family B within a family, it's it seems to be based entirely on size and age. So in a lot of social animals, like baboons, for example, animals inherit their social rank from. Their mother. So like the kid of like a high ranked female might be dominant to an adult from a lower ranked family within a baboon troop. But that's not the case in elephants. It's just everybody. Everybody's rank is just determined by their age, yeah.

Nick JikomesSo I mean, related to the subject of, you know, being a long lived species with with, you know, memories, and with the ability to know individuals, and with very sophisticated cognition, you know, whatever exactly that means. Clearly, it's very sophisticated compared to most other animals, right? This is why elephants are, you know, this is why elephants are famous and why they're interesting. One thing I wanted to ask you about, you know, maybe you haven't studied this specifically, but I'm sure that you know about it is, I've heard reports that elephants will actually mourn their dead, potentially even bury the dead, return to the sites of their bones and things like that. What do you know about that stuff and how they treat the death of members of their family.

Michael PardoYeah. So in so elephants show inordinate interest in the remains of dead elephants compared to the remains of other dead animals. So people have done some experiments where they presented elephants with bones of elephants versus the bones of other large, large animals like giraffes. And they they show no interest in the bones of other species, but they show a lot of interest in the bones of elephants. They'll pick them up, smell them, sometimes carry them for a distance. They also will routinely visit carcasses of elephants, both of their relatives and non relatives. So in the Samburu population, basically within protected areas. My My former postdoc supervisor, did a study where they looked at all the elephant carcasses that they that they could find, and every carcass within a protected area showed signs of of multiple, repeated visitation by elephants, and when they interact with like a very recently deceased or dying individual, they'll often show helping behavior. So you know, if an individual is is down and can't get up or is is is dying, they'll sometimes try to lift them up or try to support them so they so they can stand. They've occasionally been observed trying to lift up the bodies of very recently deceased elephants, but they don't do that with more like with older carcasses. So they seem to understand the difference between a carcass and somebody who might still be alive, which is intriguing because it suggests that they might have an awareness of like the finality of death in terms of burying carcasses. In African savanna elephants, they've been directly observed throwing dirt and branches on top of carcasses. They don't always do that, but they do that sometimes. In Asian elephants, there was an interesting paper that came out, I think, last year, where they found indirect evidence that elephants might be burying calves, like actually, actually burying them in the ground, but they didn't have direct observations of it. So basically, they found, like, some calves that had, I think it was like five or six calves that had been buried in drainage ditches where they were. They were part of their body was covered in dirt, but the legs were still sticking up above the ground. And based on several different indirect lines of evidence, the authors argued that they were, that they were had been buried by other elephants, but they didn't have direct observations of that, so I don't know if they actually buried those calves or not, but, but certainly in African elephants, people have observed them like putting debris and dirt on top of the body. And

Nick Jikomesyou know, it's it's not difficult. You know, elephants obviously could have a general interest in Dead elephants, because they recognize that it's elephants, but to the extent that they are family bonded, to the extent that they care about individuals and their family more, you know, akin to humans, right? Is Right? They you would so let's say an elephant dies, and I don't know, maybe, maybe there's multiple groups with overlapping territory, I would imagine. And maybe all the groups will stop at the the site of the carcass, or the bones, or whatever in general, have that tendency in general, but to the extent that they care about their family and their individuals, you would expect the family of the deceased elephant to go there more, to linger for longer, and so forth. Yeah. Is there any indication that that is happening

Michael Pardothat I don't know. I'm not sure if anybody has explicitly tested that. I know there was one study like the study I mentioned, that looked at at, you know, carcasses, whether carcasses were visited by other elephants. They found that elephants were, I think, if I remember correctly, I think they found the elephants were, were equally likely to visit the carcasses of relatives and non relatives. But I don't, I don't think they looked at how much time they. Spent to the carcass, or how they interacted with the carcass, and whether that differed between relatives and non relatives.

Nick JikomesSo, what like? So, so, and I'll let you take this where you want it, but like when, when it comes to your general observations of elephants, not just limited to the vocal communication stuff, what are some of the more sophisticated or impressive or human like, things that they do, that that you have studied or that you know about. Well, you know, what are things that you know, things that are impressive, but also things that might like people might be surprised that elephants do or they're not normally known

Michael Pardofor? Yeah, that's a good question. So I mean, I would, I would say, I think the the name, like halls is pretty cool, but obviously I'm biased, because that was my study. I think the the way that they react, that they interact with dead elephants, is pretty unusual in in the animal kingdom, and I think that's, that's pretty unique. And they're not the only species that have behavior like that, but they're, they're among the few, and it's so I think that's that's particularly interesting. I think like they're, they're generally like social cognition is, is where they shine the most, and where they they show a lot of similarities with humans and other highly social animals like they So, for example, they're in, you know, comparative language evolution research. One thing that people are often really interested in is intentionality in communication. Because one one of the key features of language is that it's intentional, where we're not just communicating out of a sort of emotional outburst, but rather we are intending to inform the individual that we're communicating with, which implies we have some understanding of what they know and what they don't know. And there's evidence for that in elephants. So for example, when elephants are communicating like with gestures they they, they tend to use gestures to combine with the vocalization. If the individual that they're trying to communicate with can't see them, but if the individual is facing them, then they'll often just use a gesture with no sound. So it implies some some understanding of what other individuals can see, right, and therefore whether they're likely to react to, you know, a particular signal, because it's, if it's a bit purely visual signal, they can't see you. There's no point. Yeah,

Nick Jikomesit implies that they have, they have ability to model another, right individuals mind, in some sense. Yeah,

Michael Pardoexactly. And they're so on the topic of self awareness in elephants. So this kind, you know that that thing with the gestures kind of implies awareness of what other individuals can see. But there's also some evidence that elephants may be aware of themselves, and this is, it's, it's, I say, some evidence, because it just hasn't been done with very many individuals and but the the classic test for self awareness in animals is the mirror mark test right where an animal you put a mark on a part of the animal's body they couldn't see without the aid of a mirror. And then if they touch that mark more in the presence of a mirror than in its absence, then that implies that they can recognize their reflection. What it may mean that they're self aware so that that study has been done with a few Asian elephants, and one, one of the Asian elephants convincingly passed the test, like it was, if you want the videos are available on the internet, if you watch those videos, I think it was happy at the Bronx Zoo, like she was very clearly responding more to the market in the presence of the mirror. The other elephants that that were that test was done with failed the test. But the problem with the mirror mark test is there's a lot of false negatives. So just because the animal doesn't touch the Mark doesn't mean they don't recognize their reflection. They may just not care about it, especially with elephants, because they're they're always covering themselves in dirt and debris. So right, right, right? They care about a mark on their face, right? So the fact that at least one elephant passed that test, I think, is, is highly suggestive evidence that at least Asian elephants are probably self aware.

Nick JikomesWell, what about one thing I wanted to ask you about on the vocalization side of it. So you were looking at whether or not you know they were naming each other. In essence, is there any indication? So you've studied them a lot. You've been with the same group of elephants a lot, I would presume. And you said they were very well habituated to humans. Habituated to humans. Is there any indication that, you know, when you guys show up, they're like, Oh, hey, Michael and the crew are here.

Michael PardoI never saw anything that, to me, was obvious, like they were reacting to our presence, which is a good thing. We don't really Yeah, by our presence, but yeah, I mean, there's so many rumbles that they make. We have no idea what those rumbles are about. Yeah, possible that that some of it was related to us, but hopefully not too

Nick Jikomesso I and I would imagine it so you guys are playing it low key on purpose, so that you are disturbing them as little as possible, and therefore seeing natural behavior. Yeah. Right, exactly, yeah. So you're just sort of like, it's like, if, like, a gazelle is walking by, or a little bird, you just want to be like this, this fly on the wall, yeah, exactly, yeah, yeah, yeah. How? When's the last time you were

Michael Pardothere? Last time I was there was in thing, March of 2023, so it's, it's been almost two years, or probably about two years at this point. And

Nick Jikomeshow many times have you been out there? Like dozens of times, just a few times? Well,

Michael PardoI'd more stayed out there for large blocks of time. So I spent a total of about 14 months in Kenya, and that was mostly broken up into two field seasons. So I had one of about four months and one of about 10 months.

Nick JikomesYeah, yeah. And how did you even like get into? How do you How did you even get into this is a pretty unique there's not a lot of probably elephant field researchers that do anything like this. Yeah,

Michael Pardoit's a good question. I don't know. I think I got lucky. Basically, I really wanted so I originally, when I started my PhD, I started working with Asian elephants, and I found a project that somebody else had started, and I started collaborating with them, and I did some field work with Asian elephants, but that I ended up not continuing that project, mostly for logistical challenges, and just like felt like I wasn't able to get the data that I needed with the resources that I had, so I ended up switching to A different species for my PhD. Finished my PhD on that, and then I really wanted to go and do a postdoc with elephants and go back to working with elephants, so I applied for an NSF postdoctoral fellowship and wrote a research grant proposal specifically to do this study on on names and elephants, and it got funded. So that's kind of then I went to Colorado State University, and I did a post doc on elephants there.

Nick JikomesWhat Are there any other species? I mean, you mentioned dolphins earlier. What are the species where we think something like name calling or this sort of, like individual, intentional type of vocal learning is happening?

Michael PardoSo the the species where we currently have evidence for it is bottlenose dolphins and to a lesser extent, many other dolphins that we we know they make signature whistles, although it hasn't been necessarily demonstrated that those dolphins use signature whistles as a way to address other individuals, but they probably do so so probably multiple species of dolphins, um, multiple species of parrots, um, African savanna elephants and common marmosets. That's those are the only ones that we actually have empirical evidence for this in currently. But I, I would be surprised if they were the only species that had this behavior. Yeah, I think a lot of the other there are a lot of other animals that have pretty sophisticated vocal learning abilities, and I would, I wouldn't be surprised if some of those also had had similar behavior.

Nick JikomesUm, I don't know if you've thought about this specifically, but, you know, in the realm of human the questions around human language evolution, you know, one of the big questions is, you know, when, when it actually arose. And the two basic schools of thought are that, you know, you know, on one, on one side of the spectrum is, it might be quite recent, you know, certainly under a million years old, even under half a million years old, potentially just 10s of 1000s of years old, that it's, you know, this quite recent, you know, very recent thing that's, you know, kind of really special in that sense, and unique to humans. I guess. Another point of view is that language didn't really pop out of nowhere all at once, or anything even close to that. It probably gradually was bootstrapped by increasingly sophisticated forms of non language and language alike, vocal communication, yeah, you know, potentially even, you know, a million or two years ago, there could have been more archaic species of Homo using something, something that was language, or at least, like a proto language. Has your comparative study of other species given you a particular perspective on human language evolution and sort of, which of those two molds might be more likely? Yeah,

Michael PardoI tend to favor the second view that it's not just a single trait that popped up fully formed, but rather that it's a gradual trait that evolved over time and got increasingly complex over a longer period of time. And the reason why I think that is because there is evidence for a lot of language like features in non human species. So for example, there's evidence of simple grammatical rules in some species of monkeys and birds. There's these name like calls in elephants and dolphins and parrots. Obviously, some of these instances are going to be independent origins, especially for mammals and birds that are very evolutionarily divergent, relatively speaking, but the fact that they occur in in so many species, including some including some primates, suggests to me that these language is not something that just arose all at once. I think my specific research on El. Elephants, it doesn't tell us much about when human language arose, because humans and elephants are basically as divergent as is possible for placental mammals to be right, like we're separated by like, 90 to 100 million years of evolution. But one thing it can potentially give us some insight into is the selection pressures that may have led to the development of language, like abilities that, you know, there's something that in the ecology of elephants and humans and parrots and dolphins that all in marmosets that all cause them to evolve this ability to address specific individuals. And maybe if we can identify what that is, we can get some insight into like, what the early environment of humans that cause them, of human ancestors, that cause them to develop language, might look like.

Nick JikomesAnd I mean clearly social structure, complex social behavior, and having a sophisticated social structure is key here. But do we know anything more specific than that? So like, if we consider sort of the full pool of social animal mammals out there, mammals and birds, let's say, are there particular types of social animals with certain types of social structures that tend to be more likely to have the more sophisticated forms of communication? I mean, is there? What do we know there? I don't know

Michael Pardothat. It's a good question. I'm I'm not sure if there is or if there is. I don't know if anybody has empirically identified it. Yeah, it's kind of weird, because we see some of these highly complex language, like systems of communication and species that you wouldn't necessarily think have, like the most complex social structure, like great examples, Japanese hits. So Japanese tits have they? They make alarm calls where it's been shown that individuals perceive the alarm calls as meaningful utterances. It's not just like a stimulus response. They react to it by fleeing. They act like when they hear a snake alarm call. They actually picture a snake, and are more primed to respond to snake like objects. They they have a simple grammatical rules and how they combine calls together, and they they'll combine different calls into phrase. The phrase has to be in a specific order, and it has a new meaning. That's kind of a composite of the meanings of the two calls that are combined and and I think this is just me speculating here, so, you know, take this with a grain of salt. But I think that it may be that some of these features are more common than we realize, and the reason why we see them in animals that don't necessarily seem like they have the most complex social structure is because those are the animals where people have chosen to study these

Nick JikomesI see we're most attracted to the social animals because it probably reminds us of US and other things like that, And therefore, yeah, study them more and notice these things more, right? But, but,

Michael Pardolike, like, for example, with the Japanese tits. I think the reason we know all this about Japanese tits is because a researcher named Toshi taka Suzuki has studied them for many years, and he's interested in these questions about language evolution, so he's investigated them in the tits, and then it turns out, lo and behold, they have these abilities, right, right? You know, I don't think anybody's ever studied that in many species, so maybe these abilities are a little bit more widespread than we realize, and it's just that nobody's studied them in a lot.

Nick JikomesYeah, yeah. So there's sort of a sampling bias and a research bias that makes it look like complex social structure might be necessary to develop these tours of traits, but that might not even that might not be the case at all. Potentially, yeah, potentially, yeah,

Michael Pardoyeah. I mean, obviously Japanese hits are, you know, highly social birds, but, but they don't have, I'm not a, yeah, I'm not aware of anything that's like, uniquely complex about their social structure. Yeah, interesting. I could be wrong, you know, I'm not an expert on Japanese tits, yeah, yeah. And

Nick Jikomesso many of these things are tough because, like to really, I mean, so many of these behaviors you sort of have to observe in the field, like you can bring animals into the lab, but it completely sort of takes them out of the context in which these traits evolve, and therefore, sort of it attenuates the expression of different behaviors. And so, right? And obviously, field work is tough to do. You got to go out to the field. You got to fund it somehow. You've got to spend hours and hours to even have the chance to see something if it's there. So, yeah, potential for not seeing things that are there is actually quite high.

Michael PardoYeah, exactly. I think that's sort of the challenge, but also the joy of field work that you're you're observing animals in their natural environment, and so it's in an ecologically and evolutionarily relevant context. And sometimes you get to see, you get to see things and appreciate them in a way that you really wouldn't if you were, if you were observing them in a much more controlled environment.

Nick JikomesYeah, yeah. So what do you what are you working on now? So

Michael Pardonow I'm actually branching out into something a little bit different. So I'm I'm using bio acoustics in a more applied way, as a tool to study population ecology and conservation. So what I'd like to do long term is kind of combine those two. I'd like to continue working on these, these interesting questions about language evolution and community. Communication in elephants and other animals. But also, I want to to have a more applied focus to my work where, you know, actually, like, hopefully, doing something useful in the world, and, you know, helping us preserve biodiversity by basically using bio acoustics as a tool to monitor wild animal populations. You

Nick Jikomesknow, we've covered a lot. We focus mostly on elephants. But, I mean, is there anything you want to reiterate, or any final thoughts you want to leave people with about vocal communication and social cognition in general, in terms of other species?

Michael PardoYeah. I mean, I guess in terms of broad, general statements, I think I I think we need to not underestimate um, how widespread some of these traits may be, and we shouldn't exclusively focus on studying like the big, charismatic um species like elephants and and whales and and chimpanzees, right? There's a lot of really interesting stuff going on in the species that often get overlooked, like Japanese tits, for example, or domestic chickens, right? Like chickens actually have a remarkably complex vocal communication system that's really fascinating, and is often quite cognitively complex as well, or at least it it seems to be. And so I think by studying like a wider range of species, we get a better appreciation for how how widespread these traits are, and then that can be really useful. You know, from just from the perspective of evolutionary biology, if we want to understand how these evolve, we really need to understand how widespread they are. We need to know not only which species have these traits, but also which species don't. And, you know, so I think, I think we just, we should, we should not underestimate species just because we don't canonically think of them as particularly complex or intelligent, because we may be surprised. Yeah,

Nick Jikomesand where can people find your stuff and read your work if they're interested?

Michael PardoYeah, so I have a YouTube channel. It's just, I just recently started posting on it regularly, so it's just getting off the ground. It's called inside animal minds. I also have an Instagram page by the same name, inside animal minds. So you can check me out on either of

Nick Jikomesthose places. All right. Mickey Pardo, thank you very much for your time. Thanks so much for having me visit Mind and matter.substack.com. To find all of my content.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Seed Oils, Omega-3s & Lessons From 93 Years of Life | Artemis Simopoulos | 313

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail At 93, Artemis Simopoulos explains why oils once used in paint now dominate the food supply, how a high omega-6 intake slows the making of EPA and DHA, and why cholesterol-lowering corn oil did not...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Tendons, Collagen, mTOR & Exercise Adaptation | Keith Baar | Episode 312

    Nov 10, 20262 hrAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Keith Baar explains why tendons stop adapting after 10 minutes of loading, why long low-load holds beat fast reps for connective tissue, and how vitamin C, collagen, caffeine and mTOR shape training....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. GDF15, Morning Sickness & Mitochondrial Stress | Stephen O'Rahilly | Episode 311

    Nov 3, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Dr. Stephen O'Rahilly explains GDF15, a stress hormone that makes us feel sick and eat less, and why morning sickness, and its severe form hyperemesis gravidarum (HG), comes from GDF15 made by the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Psilocybin vs. SSRIs for Depression, Emotional Blunting & How Psychedelics Work | Robin Carhart-Harris | 310

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 56 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Robin Carhart-Harris explains why his trial of psilocybin therapy vs. the SSRI escitalopram for depression missed one primary measure but favored psilocybin on almost everything else, and why SSRIs can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. This Animal Survives 18 Minutes Without Oxygen | Gary Lewin | 309

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 40 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Nick talks with Prof. Gary Lewin (Max DelbrĂĽck Center, Berlin) about naked mole-rats, which in lab tests survived 18 minutes in pure nitrogen by shutting down brain activity, keeping the heart beating,...

    Credit the people on this episode