Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mind & Matter

Mind & Matter artwork

Male Testosterone Fell About 20% in 17 Years. What It Means | Charles Cornish-Dale | 238

Jul 8, 20251 hr 34 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail A blend of biology, philosophy, and history exploring how hormones and endocrine disruptors affect social behavior and society. Episode Summary: Dr. Charles Cornish-Dale discusses the decline of masculinity in modern society, linking it to falling testosterone levels, environmental endocrine disruptors, and the limitations of liberal democracy. Drawing on Francis Fukuyama’s “End of History & the Last Men” and historical perspectives, Cornish-Dale argues that biological and societal factors, including diet and hormonal interventions like birth control, are reshaping male and female behaviors, with profound implications for health and social structures. About the guest: Charles Cornish-Dale, PhD is a medieval historian and anthropologist with a PhD from Oxford. His new book is, “The Last Men: Liberalism and the Death of Masculinity.” Discussion Points: Thymos & Masculinity: Cornish-Dale uses the ancient Greek concept of thymos, meaning spiritedness, to explain male drives for recognition and distinction, which he ties to testosterone-driven behaviors. Testosterone Decline: Studies like the Massachusetts Male Aging Study show a ~20% drop in male testosterone levels over 17 years, correlating with reduced reproductive health and social withdrawal. Endocrine Disruptors: Chemicals in plastics, pesticides, and soy products mimic estrogen, disrupting hormonal balance and potentially causing developmental and behavioral issues. Diet & Behavior: Historical shifts to grain-based diets, as noted by Plato, and modern plant-based trends may suppress thymos and alter hormonal profiles, impacting societal dynamics. Hormonal Contraceptives: Birth control can thin the ventromedial prefrontal cortex in women, affecting emotional regulation, especially if taken during teenage years, with potential permanent effects. Fukuyama’s End of History Framework: Cornish-Dale critiques liberal democracy’s inability to satisfy megalothymia (the desire to be better), contributing to a crisis of purpose for men. Related episode: M&M 193: History of Diet & Food, Population Density & Social Stability, Psychological Pandemics, Physical & Mental Health in Civilizational Cycles *Not medical advice. Support the show Support my work: Good Chemistry: Personalized, science-based health consulting. Work with Dr. Nick Jikomes directly. Affiliate Partners: Visit this link to see my affiliate partners and get discounts codes for products & services to support health. For all the ways you can support my efforts.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Nick JikomesWhether food, drugs or ideas, what you consume, influences, who you become. On the mind and matter podcast, we learn together from the best scientists and thinkers alive today about how your mind body reacts to what you feed it. Before starting mind and matter, I spent 10 years in academia doing scientific research. I got a PhD in neuroscience, where I focused on neuro endocrinology and the neurobiology of behavior, and before that, I specialized in molecular developmental and evolutionary genetics. I use my scientific background to help parse and translate the information that guests share on the podcast. In addition to the podcast, I write long form written content inspired by the show, where I integrate what I've learned across episodes. I also have a free weekly newsletter where I provide you with upcoming guests, share links and provide commentary on scientific studies and research that I'm reading and more visit mind and matter.substack.com. To find all of my content.

Speaker 1You an

Charles Cornish-Daleabsolute pleasure to speak to you, Nick, thank you. You wanted to start

Nick Jikomesoff by telling everyone a little bit about your academic background and what your training looks like, as it informs the book that you're coming out with.

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, of course. So, I mean, academically. So I started out, I was an historian as an undergraduate. I did postgraduate work, then in anthropology and social anthropology, and then I did a, I did my PhD at Oxford. I was at Cambridge. Before that, I did my PhD in ox at Oxford, in medieval history. So I'm, I'm a medievalist, historian, anthropologist by training, but I'm also, I mean, I'm famous as the or semi famous, infamous, whatever you want to call it as the raw egg, nationalist, you know, writing about health and fitness, in particular, politics, culture, the kind of intersection of all of these things. I mean, I've had a lifelong interest in in health and fitness and sport, you know, as a sportsman, as a as a child and teenager at school, and, you know, I've kept myself in good shape ever since. So my background is actually pretty dive, pretty diverse. But then the book itself, actually, I think really is quite diverse, and it mixes a lot of a lot of different topics, and it's quite different from a lot of the books on sort of masculinity that you'd find on the market today.

Nick JikomesYeah, yeah, no, no, the book is interesting. It came it came to me recently, and it's an interesting synthesis of science, hormone, biology, diet, together with things like politics, philosophy and so forth. So you cover a lot of ground here in 200 pages or so. One of the concepts you introduced early on, I think, is informed by your background in medieval history and and languages. It's the concept of thymos, which comes, I believe, from the ancient Greeks. So what is this concept, and what does it mean? What did it mean to them, and what does it maybe mean for us

Charles Cornish-Daletoday? So it's kind of, I mean, the ancient Greeks were very, very astute, I think observers of human nature. And thymos is basically a kind of biological, psychological concept, a more it's a moral concept as well. And what it basically means is something like spiritedness. So thymos is kind of this, this kind of set of attributes, of virtues, of dispositions, whatever you want to call them, that kind of rooted in biology that animates man, and particularly men to be spirited. So Plato, for example, I think, in the Republic, talks about thymos as making men like a sort of like a fearsome dog. You know, like a man becomes like a fearsome dog defending his city. That's thymos That drives man to do that. And there are, there are particular sort of sub variants or different kinds of thymos that the Greeks talk about. But I mean, I draw, I draw, my use of the term, mainly from Francis Fukuyama, the, you know, the famous kind of philosopher, social theorist, whatever, whatever you call him who wrote The End of History and the Last Man, which is this, you know, this book that he was very famous for, for writing at the end of the Cold War, where he talks about thymos as the desire for recognition. That's how he describes it. Uh, it's thymos. Is what drives people to seek, and men, in particular, to seek different kinds of recognition. So on the one hand, there's what he calls and what the ancient Greeks called isothymia, which is a desire to be seen as equal with one's peers. And that's one of the sort of foundational, I suppose, drives that is satisfied by Democracy, by modern liberal democracy, is this demand to be recognized as equal. But then there's another kind of phymos called megalothymia, which is the desire to be well, the desire to seek distinction, and is the desire to be recognized as better than one's peers. So that's slightly different. That's a different kind of desire for recognition, where, rather than just wanting to be to have the same rights and to be recognized as equal with all your peers, you actually want to be recognized as better because, because you are, perhaps, you know, because you're, you're have greater physical capabilities, or because you have greater intellectual capabilities, or whatever, or both, you know, or various different things. So, I mean, thymos is this kind of, yeah. It's like an, it's like an animating set of drives and dispositions that push, that push man to strive in particular ways. That's a, that's like a basic, I suppose, kind of nutshell. That's thymos in a nutshell. Yeah,

Nick Jikomesyeah, yeah. And so these are, these are two different but related things, and I think we can all relate to this at an intuitive level. Everyone wants to be part of the group, part of the crew. We want to belong. We don't want to be exiled or ostracized. Humans are very sensitive, sensitive to that. We want to be seen as CO equals with others in that way. At the same time, everyone does seek distinction. We want to fit into some kind of niche and be, you know, known for something, or contribute something unique from others to to the group. And so these two things can exist the different degrees, degrees I would imagine, in different societies and individuals. You may you mentioned Francis Fukuyama. Many listening this podcast may not know who he is, but why don't you briefly state because you know his his work is sort of central. Of central to what your book is about. Who was Fukuyama and what is this concept of the end of history that's attached to his name?

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, so Francis Fukuyama is a kind of political theorist, philosopher. He became very famous at the end of the Cold War. In 1989 he wrote an essay called The End of History, where he basically, I mean, he's like a he was kind of informed by Hegel, by Hegel's notion of historical progress, through kind of dialectical movement between opposing principles in society and history more broadly, but he wrote this. He wrote this essay called The End of History. I can't remember which journal it was in, but it was in quite a quite a big journal. It kicked up a big fuss where he basically said that the fall of the Soviet Union, the the coming down of the Berlin Wall, was the end of history with a capital H. Now his argument has been, has been much sort of parodied and misunderstood. What he was really saying was that kind of history had ended. We'd ended up in this situation with a kind of final political synthesis. There are no alternative, no really viable alternative political systems to liberal democracy to liberal capitalism, right? So capitalism, liberal capitalism, has triumphed over communism, and we've arrived at this sort of end stage of history where actually there's no further movement for evolution of of the political form. You know, like this is the the best that we can do in political and social terms is to have a liberal democracy.

Nick JikomesThat would be the So, so the idea would be in the war of ideas, liberal democracy beat communism and other ideologies, and this will be the new steady state. People will live and die. Stuff will happen, but it will be in this general liberal democratic form,

Charles Cornish-Daleright? Exactly. Yeah. So he's not saying like Time has stopped or anything like that. He's just saying, look like, you know, human societies follow this, this path, and, you know, they end up at liberal, liberal democracy in the end. That's the, that's the kind of triumphant system, and we can't go beyond that. So he wrote that as an SN, 89 and then he he turned that into a book in, I think, 90 or 91 The End of History, and the last man, and that really kind of So, I mean, my book is about, my book is about masculinity. It's called the last men liberalism and death of masculinity. And it is. It's a, it's, it's an entry in this sort of broader literature about the decline of masculinity, you know. So you have all sorts of different people, people like Jordan Peterson, Richard Reeves, who wrote a book called of boys and men. You know, it's quite a big topic. Now, what's happened to masculinity? You know, why aren't men? Anymore. Why are young men dropping out of university and school? Why are they dropping out? Why are they dropping out of society more broadly, you know, why? Why aren't Men Dating? Why aren't men sort of pursuing women anymore? All sorts of, you know, all of these sort of related kind of trends that all suggest that actually, you know, there is this kind of fundamental crisis for men in the modern Western

Nick Jikomesworld. Yeah, there's many different takes on this, of course, and many but, but it's clear, right? There's, there's something major happening. Men and women are behaving differently than they once did, in many different ways. Men in particular seem to be dropping out in various ways that we can talk about, that we'll probably get to. And yeah, and you just have, you have your particular take on this, which, even though we're starting out the discussion on the philosophy and theory side here, it actually is rooted in biology and hormones.

Charles Cornish-DaleYes, yes. I mean, what I'm trying to do, really, is I'm drawing together quite a lot of different threads, so we've got this philosophical account of modernity from an historical account of modernity from Fukuyama, where he talks about the triumph of liberal democracy, but he frames it in terms of thymos. So he talks about, and this is the part of the of the book, actually, that gets lost is that, although, you know, people remember The End of History stuff, the stuff that they can parody very easily, where they say, oh, Francis Fukuyama, he was that guy who thought that history came to an end when the Berlin Wall came down. But the full title of the book is actually The End of History and the Last Man. And the final quarter of the book is about this last man. Now, who is the last man? The last man is this creature, first described by Nietzsche. He is, He is the kind of, he's like a kind of, like a kind of degenerated man who only kind of, sort of, sort of emerges in in modernity, with the death of God, with the triumph of industrial capitalism, you get this kind of person who is like, not really good for anything other than consuming basically, he's like, he's like, a shadow, a shadow of what a man really ought to be. He's, you know, he's like, has no high aspirations, no goals, doesn't believe in anything, just, just consumes products that are created for him by other people.

Nick JikomesYeah, striking. Striking nature is writing about that, you know, well over a century ago, and yet we can immediately call to mind, you know, the 25 year old in his mother's basement who just plays video games.

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, exactly. And also, and also, you know, you've got other people as well, at the time writing about very similar things. Dostoevsky, for example, if you read, if you read Notes from the Underground, or Notes from Underground, you know, I mean, that's like the first INCEL novel. It's an, it's an incredible, it's an incredible, an incredible first person kind of account of this kind of crepuscular existence, basement dwelling, kind of existence really driven by resentment and a kind of lack of identification with any kind of real morality or values or anything like that. Totally unmoored, directionless, resentful, spiteful, all this kind of stuff. But, yeah, so, I mean, so Francis Fukuyama is presented as a triumphalist, right? He's presented as as, as the kind of hubristic most, or almost like the most kind of hubristic representative of liberal democracy, you know? And he Oh, he's the great champion of liberal democracy. He thinks it's amazing. Well, actually, no, he actually presents the victory of liberal democracy as a kind of hollow victory, where he says, look like we've ended up with this political form that's triumphed over all of the others. But actually, it can't satisfy many of man's most fundamental needs, wants and desires. So this is where thy moss comes in. So with liberal democracy, you can satisfy man's isothermia, which is the desire to be recognized as equal. So we all participate in liberal democracy as equals, but what it can't satisfy, which previous political systems could is megalothymia. Is this desire for for something more, the desire to be better, the desire to struck, to really, to strive to be better than others, to assert yourself and not just be part of the herd. So that's the kind of fit, that's the kind of philosophical background that I'm or the framework that I'm trying to fit my account of, let's say, the crisis of masculinity into. But what I do from there is I say, well, actually, look, if you look at thymos and in particular behaviors associated with megalothymia, you. So that's actually, it's testosterone, basically thymos, I think, in many respects, is a proxy, is a kind of philosophical, psychological, biological proxy for talking about testosterone and the kinds of behaviors that testosterone, you know, makes men, makes men prone to, makes the things it makes men do. And so what I'm really trying to do, I suppose, is to say that, actually, you know, the crisis of masculinity, this kind of decline in masculine behavior, is a biological crisis. It's a crisis of famous and it's a crisis of testosterone in particular. And that's a very different emphasis, I think, from a lot of the a lot of the literature. Now, I'm not saying that all of it is, is testosterone, and in fact, what I'm what I'm saying is that actually, you know, there are environmental issues and there are all sorts of issues on the biological level, but there's also an issue with the political system itself, as described by Fukuyama, which is that actually it only allows particular, a particular narrow vision of phymotic behavior, basically. So you know, you can be equal, but you can't be better. And actually, testosterone is associated with behaviors that make us competitive, that make us strive, that make us want to assert ourselves over others. And so there's this whole dimension of masculine behavior and masculine striving and wanting that just can't be for, that just can't be satisfied, I think, within liberal democracy. So it's like my fundamental emphasis is biological, but it's also it's also political, it's also historical, it's also philosophical, which I think is, which I think is, what makes it very different from other, from other kind of entries in the in the kind of crisis of masculinity, sort of literature,

Nick Jikomesyeah. And one of the things that's lurking here that I want to bring out for people is something that's it's axiomatic in the West, at least, that that's where I'm speaking from. So that's a perspective I can speak about. It's something that we take for granted, which is dualism. People tend to think that the the realm of the mind and the realm of the body are are two separate things, two separate substances, however you want to put it. You know, the spirit world and the physical world are separate and and that's been around for a long time, and many people just sort of implicitly act and believe as if this type of thing is true. You know, your spirit or your mind, your consciousness, is separate from your body, but the perspective you take here and emphasizes that, no, no, these things are all they're all integrated as one, that the mind body is one unit, and you can't have a deterioration of mind or spiritedness or social tendencies without having something going on on the biological side. How do you sort of think about the dualistic nature of people's thinking in the West generally, and where does that actually come from?

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, that's a very good question. I think that's, that's a pretty that's a very good, really, summation of what I'm trying to get at. So I mean, the the source of the of the Mind Body dualism, where does it come from? Well, I mean, fairly recently, in the sort of beginning of the modern period, we have someone like Descartes, the Rene Descartes, the French philosopher, you know, who famously entered into this sort of radical skepticism in order to find the basis of knowledge and of belief and of certainty about the world, the cogito, Cogito ergo sum, I think, therefore I am right. And so he after, after doing this sort of radical thought experiment about, you know, what can I be, what, what is the basis of knowledge, he came to the conclusion that it was just the certainty that you are a thinking thing, basically. So that's one source, definitely of, I think modernities dualism in particular, is this belief that that actually at base. But base, you know, there is this thinking matter that is totally set. There's this thinking thing that is totally separate from from matter, hard division between the two. But I think if you, I think if you push back further in time, then you would probably look at things like the Christian conception of the soul for it, right, the enduring soul, you know, that lives on beyond death. That is, that is

Nick Jikomesthis thing that possesses the body. That is, yes, it possesses it, but it's not of it,

Charles Cornish-Daleno, exactly that, that, and also kind of that, that is you. You are the soul you know you have this. You have this temporary sort of meat Marionette that you or meat machine that you inhabit. But actually you are an immaterial thing. You're an immaterial essence in some sense. Yes, so I think, I mean, I think really, we're pushing back. We're pushing back 1000s of years, really. I mean, I think this is a deep tendency in western in Western thought, Western philosophy, Western theology, religion. But when we get back to the ancients, when we get back to ancient the ancient Greeks and the ancient Romans, you know, we start to see a different conception, I think, of the relationship between mind and body. So you have this very, very famous dictum, men's sauna in corporate Sano, healthy mind in a healthy body. You know, it's a sense that you are an inter you are an integrated whole. You know, the two, whatever the two things are. And maybe you could say there's even a division back then. Nevertheless, there's a sense that they are, they are integrated, perhaps in a way that we have, over time, forgotten. And you know, people do, I think, today, behave as if you know you can, you can be a healthy person, if you mentally, you know, if you have an unhealthy lifestyle, we don't tend, you know, when we look at, I think, mental diseases, for example, and mental instability, depression, all these kinds of things we we tend not to look at the body, perhaps in a way that, in A way that the ancients would, you know, it would have been, I think, very obvious to an ancient person that you know, somebody sitting around all day, eating junk, not moving, you know, is overweight, is probably going to be mentally unhappy as well. But actually, you know, for for, you know, for modern physicians and for ordinary people, then it's just a sort of like, oh well. It's, you know, it's imbalances in the brain, or it's something like that. There's no kind of deeper sense of an integration between the physical and the mental. So it's, I mean, it's a pervasive, it's a pervasive tendency, I think, and certainly, you know, within this literature about the about the kind of crisis of masculinity, then what you really get is, you get people talking about, they'll talk about values, and they'll talk about, let's say, like structural problems. They'll talk about, you know, the way that workplaces are structured now. They'll talk about, you know, the education system. They'll talk about cultural values, and you know, like that. We live in a culture that promotes, let's say, you know, different alternative vision of masculinity to the traditional patriarchal vision of masculinity. But very few people will touch on the biology. Very few people will actually beyond, for example, so someone like Richard Reeves, who wrote of boys and men, which is an attempt to argue, I think, the case for the case for masculinity, or a particular vision of masculinity. You know, he'll talk about testosterone, but only very briefly, just to say, look, men have testosterone, and it doesn't make them bad. Testosterone doesn't just well actually, what he says is, we aren't governed by our hormones. That's what he's trying to say, basically, but which I think is very wrong, actually. And I do say in the book, Look, you know, we are our hormones in a very, in a very, very fundamental way. And if you

Nick Jikomeswrite the dualistic thing is lurking there in that type of statement, yeah,

Charles Cornish-Daleyeah, exactly yes. It is, yeah. It comes back again and again. It's sort of like, actually, we can radically divorce ourselves from our biology and these big aggregate changes, and we can talk about the the big aggregate changes, you know, to testosterone levels. They don't really matter, you know, like, either way, it doesn't matter of testosterone levels, of going off a cliff, because all we need to do actually, is have the right social structures in place and the right values. And, you know, men can be men again. Well, I'm not entirely sure about that. I think it's, I think it's more complicated than that. Obviously you have to structure society in the right way. And that's why I'm that's why I talk about Fukuyama, that's why I take the framing from Fukuyama, because I think that, you know, we've created a particular kind of system that actually doesn't even allow fundamental expressions of masculinity to take place.

Nick JikomesYeah, yeah. And, you know, I think we'll come to some of this. But, you know, my background is in neuroendocrinology, and, you know, point blank, you know, the perspective you just articulated from the other guy just doesn't make a lot of sense. We know that changing hormones is sufficient to change change the behavior of animals. It will change their orientation to other animals. And you know, when we talk about humans, that that's going to have consequences and implications for social structures, and the type of social structures that people will fit into, well or. Want, and then the influence goes in the other direction as well. This is a bi directional thing, the social relations one has the structures in place that that mold and bias, you know, how you interact with fellow humans, is going to have hormonal effects as well. With this stuff in mind, I want to get into some of the hormone biology here, and I want to start with testosterone and what it does, and really emphasize misconceptions that are out there about how testosterone and other sex hormones work. I think one of the cartoons that people often have in their mind around testosterone is okay, testosterone is high in men, estrogen is high in women. Sometimes they forget that both are critically important at precise ratios in both of the sexes, and then the cartoon for testosterone in particular is, oh, testosterone promotes aggression and bad behavior. Basically. What do we know about the behavioral effects of high and low testosterone in humans and other animals?

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, well, I mean, so we get our understanding of testosterone from a variety of different sources, you know? I mean, there's, I go into in the book, I go into the kind of deep history of Endocrinology, the study of hormones, right? You know? I mean, the first, the first experiments in endocrinology were castration in the ancient world. And we know that castration has a deep, deep history, not only castration of animals, bulls for domestication, geldings, etc, but also castration of humans, slaves, eunuchs in harems, you know, just in war as a punishment. So I mean, humans have had an understanding that there is something in the male testes that governs male behavior, and that it can be manipulated by the kind of gross, blunt act, actually, of just severing the testes, or indeed, the entire, the entire, you know, male genitalia, penis as well. So, you know, like we've, we've had a kind of blunt understanding of of something, of the something that there's some kind of substance, some kind of thing that governs masculinity, that originates in the testes, for a long time, even if we, you know, obviously weren't able to articulate it as hormones, or as a particular hormone. And, you know, it was only, it was only really at the end of the 19th century, and then in the early 20th century, in the 1930s that the actual substance that was, that was then called testosterone, was first isolated and its effects started to be studied. You know, this was the 1930s and then you had the first synthetic testosterone that was made in the late 1930s that's basically the beginning of the age of doping as well. You know, that's when steroids are first created. That's a kind of watershed in endocrinology as well. But so we have this kind of deep understanding of testosterone as a hormone, even though we didn't know what it was. But then, more recently, then we have all sorts of experiments. So we have experiments with animals in the lab and in the wild in other settings, you know, in zoos and observational studies. And then we have studies of human beings as well. And you know, people who take testosterone therapy. And actually, what we really have now is we have a much more nuanced view of what testosterone is and does. And yes, testosterone is involved in the regulation of aggression. And that's the, like you say, you know, that is the that's the real stereotype of testosterone is, you know, you roid rage. You know, you have too much testosterone. You're gonna, you're, you're pro wrestling, you're gonna go home and murder your family. You know? I mean, it's like roid rage, testosterone, whatever. It makes you aggressive, it makes you masculine, it makes you uncontrollable. It makes you anti social, it makes you a thoroughly unpleasant human being. And so, of course, you know, a regular refrain that you will hear is, you know, society would be better with less testosterone. And so, you know, any, any news of lowering testosterone levels is, also is welcomed. You know, it's like, oh, you know, we're all getting more civilized. And actually, there is, there actually is evidence, long term anthropological evidence, skeletal evidence, that suggests that actually maybe the dawn of civilization was actually associated with some kind of reduction in testosterone levels among men. So if you look at hunter gatherer skeletons from about 50,000 years ago, and then you know, 30, 40,000 20,000 10,000 years ago, what you see is, you see what's basically called. It's called something like Facio, cranial, facial, cranial. And. Masculinization decreases. So what that basically means is that, like brow

Nick Jikomesridges, robustness of the skull,

Charles Cornish-Daleand that's generally taken as an indication that actually testosterone levels were declining, you know, from 50,000 years ago to 10,000 years ago, the dawn of civilization. And paleo archeologists and anthropologists hypothesize, well, you know, maybe this was associated with the move from smaller bands of hunter gatherers to more complex, larger agricultural societies, where actually cooperation and intimacy larger numbers of people living together requires, let's say, like, greater cooperation and so less testosterone. Now, I mean, that's just, that's the hypothetical. That is a hypothetical. I mean, we don't, you know, it's one of these, just so stories that, right, right, yeah, can tell about human evolution. But actually, if you look at experimental evidence and other stuff, you see that actually testosterone, testosterone is involved in all sorts of behaviors. It's involved in what we might call anti social behaviors, maybe if we wanted to, but also pro social behaviors. So, I mean, I spend quite a lot of time in the book actually saying, look like this is a there are a series of myths that we need to dispel, and one of them is that just testosterone is about aggression. And actually, you look at a study of gerbils, for example, and you find that administering testosterone to gerbils, to male gerbils in particular situations, will make them behave in different ways. So it will either make them be more attentive to female gerbils and to look after them, or it will make them more aggressive to outside, you know, to like an A a gerbil that's been inserted into the into the gerbil mesh, or whatever. Outsider. Yeah, so it's kind of like it actually, it actually, in many respects, appears to be like a kind of context dependent, right hormone, and depending on in group, out group situation, it can, it can elicit different kinds of behaviors in animals. But one of the, one of the most important ways, actually, I think, that you can look at testosterone and its effects, particularly in humans today, is to look at what happens to men who have a diagnosis of low testosterone. And so an important part of the book is I actually talk about low testosterone, the symptoms of low testosterone. What does having low testosterone do to a man? Well, basically, it makes him totally useless. I mean, if you have, like, chronically low testosterone. If you have a low testosterone diagnosis, you will be anxious, depressed, without motivation, without libido. You'll probably put on weight. You might develop man boobs, gynecomastia. You might lose head. You lose your hair. You might, you know, all sorts of pretty you know, really awful things happen. And there are, there are sub forums on Reddit, low testosterone. Sub forums full of these kind of agonizing testimonials about, actually, what it's like to be a man with low testosterone. And I draw quite heavily on them in the book, basically to make the case that look, I mean, testosterone. Is. Testosterone is what makes men men. And yes, men need estrogen, and yes, women need testosterone, but it's specific ratios, and men need much more testosterone, estrogen, and women need much more estrogen and testosterone. One of

Nick Jikomesthe things I wanted to emphasize here is, you know, the cartoon of testosterone is more testosterone is going to basically mean more aggression and anti social behavior. But as you said, as with anything else we could talk about biology, everything is context dependent. The testosterone levels will modulate behavior, including aggressive and social behaviors. But the way it does that, the direction it does that, is going to be highly dependent on social context, on the conspecifics or fellow animals that are around the the animal in question. And importantly, I want to emphasize for people, that you can actually increase aggressive behaviors by boosting estrogen. We know that's true. In animals, you can stimulate estrogen receptor neurons and the hypothalamus, and this will literally make mice attack other mice. It's probably involved in the transition to motherhood and females, right? Think of the concept of the Mama Grizzly becoming more aggressive. But also you have some interesting stuff you include in one part of the book around increasing the aggression in primates by changing their diet to estrogen them. Basically,

Charles Cornish-Daleyes, yeah. So that's a funny one. So basically, there was this great study that was done in 2004 of male macaques. And what they did was they fed them so they were observing them in their troops, you know, in their in their social groups, and they gave them a diet that that was high in soy isoflavones. And soy isoflavones are the Easter. Compounds that you find naturally, estrogenic compounds that you find in soy products. And what they discovered was that actually doing this basically made the mice into kind of like passive aggressive in cell monkeys, basically is maybe the kind of best way to describe it. It made them. It made the monkeys, the male monkeys simultaneously more withdrawn from the troop. So they kind of, you know, like became in cells. They sort of withdrew from the troop and didn't engage in social interactions as much, but it also made them more aggressive. So in the instances where they did interact with other macaques in the troop, they were bitchy and attack them. And, you know, so,

Nick Jikomesso they were more irritable and less assertive. Basically, they didn't go and interact with the group willingly, but when they had to interact with someone they were, they were basically more aggressive, yeah,

Charles Cornish-Daleand so this is, I mean, this is the, this is the complete opposite, really, of the testosterone as aggression hormone. Thesis, you can give male monkeys the soy compounds that, by the by the way, are in all of these sort of processed soy foods that people eat today. They're in, you know, these soy milk and all this kind of stuff, because modern soy products aren't fermented. And this is the difference between modern soy products and the consumption of soy historically, is that soy was consumed in small amounts in places like Japan, and it was always fermented because, because ferment. I mean, not that they knew that what they

Nick Jikomeswere doing right, right? But it turns out that pre digestion basically gets rid of the estrogen like compounds,

Charles Cornish-Daleyeah. And so actually, pretty much the only demographic that ever consumed unfermented soy were monks who were looking to, like Buddhist monks, who were looking to basically lower their libido levels and be in better control of their desires. Oh, wow, that Yeah, that's actually, that's actually true. That's actually true. So

Nick Jikomesthey would intentionally eat certain diets to basically try and reach Nirvana faster.

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, I mean, I mean a vegetarian diet does that anyway, and that's something that I talk about in the book too. But yeah, this estrogen thing, you know, is interesting, and it really does kind of, I think, in a funny way and in an engaging way, actually cut to the heart of the of this kind of testosterone myth. But what you also see, actually, that I think is interesting in a lot of these studies, is you see this there are built in biases, I think, in things like so a lot of the experiments are social psych psychology experiments, right? So you get groups of men, and you give them, you put either a testosterone gel, transdermal gel, on their arm, or you give them a control, you know, so it's a gel, but it's not testosterone. It's just something, something neutral, and then you get them to do some kind of task that illustrates, let's say, or that explores some kind of virtue or sort of social behavior, like a lot of them focus on fairness. So they'll do this. So they'll apply the gels, and then they'll say, you know, like you play a game where you have to allocate rewards to people, and you get to choose how to allocate the rewards. And so what they're trying to try to see, basically, is whether, if you, if you give someone a shot of testosterone, will they be more fair? Will they be less fair? Will they be more aggressive? Will they be less aggressive? Will they be more favorable to inequality and hierarchy, or will they be more egalitarian? But what, what you get with a lot of these studies, and particularly the ones that focus on fairness and egalitarianism, is that, yeah, you'll find that if you give men a shot of testosterone, they're happier with hierarchy. That that seems to be a major finding of a lot of these studies, is that actually, you know, you give men a shot of testosterone, and actually they're okay with some people getting bigger rewards than others, but what then happens is you get this kind of slight. It's not really a sleight of hand, but it's kind of these built in biases. I mean, we live in a democratic society, and so what do you do? Where you say, Okay, well, that's anti social. So testosterone is an anti social hormone because it makes men happy with hierarchy and inequality. Well, actually, the vast majority of human societies, I mean, like 99.9% of human societies have been rigidly hierarchical throughout history. So

Nick Jikomesyeah, well, it's like you can see this sort of thing creep in almost any field, but, but in this particular area, it's, you can really see it jump out. I mean, just to put put the similar spin on something from the animal world that I'm familiar with, again, let's, let's think of the concept of parental defensive aggression, which is perfectly natural and perfectly healthy, right? When a few. Male has babies, whether we're talking about a grizzly bear, a human being or a mouse, you know, she will become more defensively aggressive, right? She will. You know, famously, little animals will fight much bigger animals off if they've got their little cubs or nestlings to take care of. And no one would ever look at that and and properly understand it and say, Oh, that's a negative attribute, because aggression is bad. But effectively, what you're saying is that in some of these social psych experiments, that kind of thing is interpreted automatically in a negative way, even though there's probably a deeper and subtler understanding that should be had there.

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, precisely so then. But then you'll get much more interesting, more elaborate studies of testosterone in a social setting. Like for example, there's a study that I talk about where social psychologists went on a hunting trip in somewhere like the Amazon with a tribesman, right? And they measured levels of particular hormones at particular times before, during and after the expedition to hunt, right? And so they were able to track how during the hunt, testosterone levels rise, right? Because, among other things, you know, testosterone encourages competitiveness. It encourages, it does encourage aggression. It, you know, it enhances male attributes. It enhances strength, right? But then actually what happens is you have other hormones, oxytocin, which is called the love hormone, generally for its kind of role in social bonding. You know, when a mother gives birth to a child, her body is flooded with oxytocin, and that really kind of cements the bond between mother and child. Yeah.

Nick JikomesCoincidentally, that's another hormone where, yeah, that is everything you just said is true about oxytocin. But it also modulates things like this, in group out group distinction. And while it does promote things like bonding with the baby, it can promote this kind of defensive aggressiveness and modulate those sorts of those sorts of things in terms of how you behave towards others as well. So all of these hormones are, you know, they can't be caricatured as just the aggression hormone, the love hormone and so forth,

Charles Cornish-Daleno, and so in this study of these tribesmen, you know, like testosterone levels increase, but it also pushes at the same time, you see a corresponding increase in oxytocin. And then there's interesting things that happen when they get back to the village and they start dividing the spoils. So it's, it's some it's, it's much, much more complicated. And just trying to say, Oh, well, you know, testosterone is anti social. And look, 50,000 years ago, hunter gatherers had much, you know, more prominent brow ridges, and that was because they were that's because they were living in smaller groups. And now we've got this really complex civilization, and you know, we need to have lower testosterone, because otherwise it won't work, that that's just like a gross, really, a gross, gross parody, I think, of of how we should think about testosterone and its relationship to civilization, its relationship to society, and to sort of man's interaction with with his fellow man. And so, yeah, I mean, there's a there's a lot of, there's a lot of bullshit, really, to cut through. And I try, I try to do that with, you know, like a few really, really good, really clear studies, like the study of the male macaques, for instance, that shows like, actually, estrogen modulates aggression. And, you know, you can get people, you can get animals to behave really aggressively just by giving them estrogen. But, yeah, I mean, it's a lot of, a lot of bullshit to cut through, and it's, you know, these are tropes that are widely circulated throughout society. You know, they're very, very common, you know, if, I think, if you asked a sort of person of middling intelligence, you know about testosterone, they would probably tell, yeah, that's the, that's the aggression hormone, you know, makes men, makes men angry, makes men aggressive, and then they might have opinions about, you know, what to do about that to make society better?

Nick JikomesYeah, and you know, people have been talking for some time about the apparent drop in testosterone levels among males over time, over the course of last few decades. What do we actually know there about whether or not that's happening, the extent to which it's happening, and so forth. This might be a good place to talk about Massachusetts male aging study.

Charles Cornish-DaleYes, yeah, that's the, that's the, that's the big one. So we have very, very good reason to believe that testosterone levels are actually falling precipitously. Now, first of all, we have experimental evidence. So the first big red flag about testosterone in the western world was this study called the Massachusetts male aging study that was carried out. It's it's like a gold standard study. I won't go into the boring details. It's like a but it's a really well constructed community study where. Of men of various different ages, from sort of like 18 to middle age in a community around Boston, ran totally random sample over a period of about 20 years. So what they did was they looked at they took a random sample of men from this community near Boston, and they measured biomarkers over time, various different biomarkers. But one of the one of the principal biomarkers they measured was testosterone. And what they showed over a period of about 20 years. So this was from, I think, 1987 until about 2004 I think that was the time frame. So it was like 1717, years. It was slightly just under 20 years. But what they showed was a year on year decrease of 1% in testosterone levels over that slightly more than 1% so it was like 20 a 20% decline in 17 years. So every year, 1% 1% 1% and so on. And, you know, you extrapolate that over a longer period, if that continues, you know? I mean, then we're, I mean, it's a bigger 1/5 is a, in a, in less than a generation is a, is a big decrease. And what they, what they showed as well, was not just that it was decreasing within the generations, but between them as well, you know. So it's like a 60 year old man, let's say in 1987 you know, has like, 20% more testosterone than a 60 year old man in in 2004 so that was so that was a big, that was a big sort of wake up call, I think, about testosterone levels. And it inspired some other studies that wanted to test the hypothesis of or the to test the findings and see and see whether, actually, you know, is this being repeated elsewhere in the Western world, or is this just something you know that's confined to America, or even just to Boston, right? So there was a so the the the analysis of the Massachusetts male aging study, I think that was kind of like 2007 I think that the testosterone paper came out, and then a year or two later, there was a paper out of Finland where they looked at Finnish men, and they actually had a longer, they had better, they had a longer data set, I think. But the hypothesis there was, okay, well, we're not going to see this in Finland, because generally, men in Finland score higher on tests of reproductive health, various different tests of reproductive health, than American men, you know, like, there are fewer instances of undescended testicles, of cryptorchidism, and there fewer men in Finland get prostate cancer than men In America. So they were like, okay, you know, we're not going to see this, but actually it was exactly the same over a longer period of time. In fact, actually, I think it was slightly, it was slightly worse, and that's why. So that was a, that was a big thing.

Nick JikomesYeah, there's been, there's been at least one or two more in other parts of the world, and I guess

Charles Cornish-DaleIsrael is, Israel is one of them. When they did one, we've been

Nick Jikomesseeing this for some time, different parts of the world, different cultures, you know, different populations. So it seems to be a general purpose phenomenon that's happening. This brings us to the question of what's what's driving it? It can't be something that's only in the US and not in Finland, because we're seeing the pattern in both places. Yeah, do you? You know, there's multiple things we could talk about here, but let's talk about biological, strict biological causes of what might be driving this. This gets us into the discussion of endocrine disruptors and food. Those two things go hand in hand the stuff we're putting on and in our bodies. What do we know? You know, just give us the broad strokes here about how that ties into some of the hormone biology.

Charles Cornish-DaleSo I suppose actually one thing, one thing I want to say about those studies is that there are various subtleties to measuring testosterone, right? And your testosterone levels as a man and testosterone as a woman will fluctuate over time, yes, not only during, not only during a day, but during a month, and actually even during a year. So you know, we've seen, we've seen studies that show seasonal variations according to levels of sunlight in male testosterone levels. So one of the principal criticisms of these studies by people who want to try and say, Well, okay, I actually know this isn't happening, is you haven't controlled for all of the variables in testosterone variation. So can you be certain that you were you know that even within the Massachusetts male aging study that over that period of 20 years, the values are comparable because you were taking testosterone levels readings at exactly the same time, right, right? And they're or in the same way. And, you know, there are all sorts of small things that can lead to quite significant variations in testosterone. So if you get, like, four or five days of bad sleep, your testosterone levels can come fall 15, 20% right? So. So that, yeah, there are, there are these variables, and it introduces certain amount of under 30, but, but what we also have is we also have a broader collapse of male

Nick Jikomesreproductive health, right, like sperm quality and things like this, sperm quality,

Charles Cornish-Dalewhich is how well sperm can swim, and you know, whether they can actually fertilize an egg. Sperm quantity as well. Sperm counts. That's just the sheer number of sperm that you know in a particular volume of semen. Yeah, male reproductive parameters, full stop across the board, have gone off a cliff. So we've, we've also got a corresponding nose dive of about 1% per year, cumulatively, year on year, in sperm counts as well. And so it's incumbent on the critics to explain why, if men's testicles aren't functioning properly, if men's testicles are breaking down at such an alarming rate not doing what they should be. Why that wouldn't also lead to a testosterone decline as well, right? And I think obviously it would. And so I think that, you know, I think that whatever uncertainties there might be about some of the measurement methods and whether you're getting like, the strictest possible, you know,

Nick Jikomesright? Did you measure it in the winter, early on in the study, in the summer, later and so

Charles Cornish-Daleforth? Yeah, yeah. Did you make sure? Did you make sure that they'd all had a good night's sleep and all this?

Nick JikomesBut the point is, all of these measures of male reproductive health are going the same direction, which is down. And you know, the Massachusetts study, for example. You know, barring some of the potential criticisms there. It's quite a drastic drop from the beginning of study to the end, so a number of confounders would have to line up in the right way to explain that. And also we can just sort of look around and also not, not, not forget to use our common sense here.

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah. Well, exactly. I mean, so I'll get, I'll get back to the endocrine disruptors in a second. But you know, I talk about this phenomenon of the hikikomori in Japan, right, which is extreme social recluses. Now, this is a huge thing in Japan right now, millions of men essentially are checking out of society and becoming recluses. They're, they're, they're basically just staying in their bedrooms all day, playing computer games and eating fast food, right? And it's, it's such a bad phenomenon that it has a name hikikomori. And, you know, the Japanese government talks about it. And there was a study that showed that, and I talked about this in the book, that these hikikomori, these extreme social recluses, are more likely to have low testosterone, right? So there is a correlation between social withdrawal in among Japanese men and testosterone levels. So yes, I mean, yeah, we can. We can open our eyes and look around as well, and what we see is we see, you know, proliferation of behaviors associated with low testosterone, including this, this kind of male withdrawal from society. You know, it's estimated that there are something like 6 million men in the US who have basically dropped out of society, and this is associated with low testosterone. And so I think that overall, the overall impression is, obviously that testosterone levels are declining. Now, the causes so endocrine disruptors. And endocrine disruptors are hormone disrupting chemicals. There are natural endocrine disruptors. I've you know, we talked about the male mechanics, we talked about soy isoflavones. There are natural endocrine disruptors, plant compounds, natural compounds in the world. But we've created a world now of industrial chemicals, plastics, deodorants, fragrances, pesticides, herbicides, and it turns out that a great many of these artificial compounds disrupt our hormonal systems. Basically, these compounds are ubiquitous. We can't, can't really get away from them, and this is something that we're learning with microplastics in particular, which is, you know, like an emerging field of study and or an emerging topic of study and an emerging threat. I mean, we're really starting to get worried about the extent of our exposure to plastics and our inability to get away from them, because they they fall in snow, and they're at the bottom of the ocean and they're floating around in the air, and, you know, they're in household dust and in the bottled water and food. But yeah, so, so we are, we are exposed in a in a pervasive way, in a way that has never, never without, basically without power. Well, in human history, we're exposed to these harmful hormone disrupting chemicals. And it seems to be a kink, a very strange and unfortunate kink of the modern world, that so many of these, maybe the majority of these hormone disrupting chemicals, mimic the the hormone estrogen, right? So they they interfere with the natural, the body's natural balance of hormones, testosterone to estrogen, and skew it in favor of estrogen. So that has all sorts of effects. I mean, it decreases testosterone, and it can have transient effects, but it can also have permanent effects. And so this is, this is what's so insidious and so bad about his chemicals, is that exposure to them at particular points in your life cycle, from from, you know, from the moment of conception, can actually have permanent effects. So you know, a mother with a mother who has higher levels of endocrine disrupting chemicals in her body when she's pregnant that can have serious developmental effects on her child. It can lead to things like reduced IQ. It can lead to a propensity for obesity. It can lead to developmental defects, you know, like so you have a boy who's born with a smaller penis or with undescended testicles. There are even suggestions that it could be linked, you know, because of it could actually be linked to the rise of transgenderism, for example. So I talk in the book about actually talking the book about the Alex Jones gay frogs conspiracy theory. You know, where he was. He was roundly mocked for suggesting that chemicals in the in the water, could, you know, turn amphibians, turn frogs gay. But actually, you know, we there are reams of evidence that actually link exposure to endocrine disruptors to serious reproductive defects and also even potentially gender dysphoria. And so, you know, I mean, it's, this is like a it's an emerging fit. It's really an emerging field. It's only something that we're really starting we've really started to take seriously, probably over the last sort of 20 or 30 years. But it's becoming very clear that actually we're swimming in a toxic soup, and it's having serious, serious effects on our health, and it's probably linked to every single one of the of the kind of prevailing chronic diseases of modernity, right, right? Probably linked, probably linked to heart disease, probably linked to dementia, yeah, probably linked to diabetes and obesity, but it's also linked to severe reproductive

Nick Jikomesproblems, right, right? And you know, part of the I mean, part of the point here, for me is, when we talk about hormone biology, what people need to understand is hormones, by definition, are substances that act throughout the body, and they they are specifically substances that coordinate changes and orchestrate coordinated change throughout tissue systems of the body. So you're not going to get isolated minor problems by messing with hormonal systems across development. The entire purpose of these substances is to orchestrate the, literally, the construction of the organism into its its natural form. And even though we can't study all of the 1000s and 1000s of endocrine disruptors, we know specific ones have very dramatic effects on sex, typical behavior, neural development and so forth and animals. And it's basically just impossible that these things aren't disturbing development of human beings, broadly speaking.

Charles Cornish-DaleYes, well, I mean, so, yes. I mean, so we've got population studies of humans where we can where we can see, you know, like correlations between, for example, levels of plasticizer chemicals like phthalates or BPA with obesity or diabetes or sperm count or testosterone levels in particular. But what we've also got as well is we've got these intervention lab studies, where you can actually, because obviously you can't administer these chemicals to people deliberately. You can study, you can study people out there in the wild, and you can see, see what level of these chemicals they have, or levels of these chemicals they have in their bodies. But you can't use people as lab rats. So you have to use lab rats, right? But you know, we have these intervention studies. We have these frog studies, for example, that famously showed that administering the herbicide atrazine, which is sprayed in, you know, millions of gallons a year all over the US applying Atrazine to the larvae of African clawed frogs, could make them switch gender. So you can, you can turn a male African clawed frog lava into a female African clawed frog, and it will then be able to mate with a male. Little frog. So you can, actually, you can literally switch a frog's gender simply by exposing it to Atrazine while it's while it's developing, and then it becomes a female rather than a male, and it can produce viable eggs that can be fertilized and produce other frogs. So we've, I mean, there are reams and reams of studies on this. I mean, there's 1000s and 1000s and 1000s. I mean, it's established beyond any credible doubt, that these chemicals in intervention studies have tremendously harmful effects on animals, and in these epidemiological population studies, that exposure to them is correlated with basically every single kind of chronic disease, right,

Nick Jikomesright, right, yeah. I mean, I've done a number of podcasts on some of these in particular, so there's lots of details we can point people to. You know, BPA in particular has been studied. We know it can lead to an exaggerated insulin response. We know it can disturb both the mother and the child when she's exposed during a pregnancy. And so we know this stuff is, is having profound metabolic and neurodevelopmental effects. What? What can you tell us about, sort of the history of how so, even before the advent of synthetic chemicals, and before you know, we had Dow, Dow Chemicals and entered the true the modern, modern era. Yeah, deeper back in history, what were some of the ways that diet was used to control people?

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, this is an interesting one. So I I talk in the book, I pick up some threads from my previous book, the eggs benedict option. I talk about there's this fascinating, really fascinating, short section of Plato's Republic Book Two of Plato's Republic, where Plato's Socrates basically says that you can create an ideal harmonious society that control perfectly if you just made everybody have a vegetarian diet, basically. So if you deprive the workers in a in a society of meat and animal products, you give them, you know, a grain diet and peas, and you can, they can have some cheese and olive oil, but, you know, no meat, no fish, then basically, they're, they're, they're perfectly happy with their lot. They won't rebel, you know, they'll be fearful of authority, and, you know, everything will be fine in society. But if you allow our society to have meat, then people's passions get inflamed. And what, what Plato is actually having Socrates say there is. He's saying, Look, meat encourages thymos. Basically, that's what he's saying. He's saying, you know, you eat meat, you get thymos, basically. So, you know, Plato was the very first social planner, you know, he's the, the earliest social planner that we really know of the, you know, Plato's Republic is really the first kind of detailed philosophical attempt to lay out a kind of utopian vision of society, right? And yet, you've got and you've got this, you've got Plato's Socrates actually saying, like, you know, if you want an ideal harmonious society, don't let people eat meat. And that's very striking. So, you know, it's two and 2300 years ago that there was a there was actually an understanding. And I don't, I don't think Plato was being ironic when he put those words in Socrates mouth. I think there was a genuine understanding that actually dietetics, that diet is, diet determines people's behavior. You can have profound effects on a society. You can create a different kind of society if you alter its alter its dietary habits. And you know, one of the, one of the kind of hallmarks of my work that I talk about a lot, that I talked about in the eggs benedict auction my previous book, and I talk about in a chapter in this book too, is that actually, you know, you really, you really can alter people's hormonal profiles and therefore their behavior simply by altering the amount of the amount and type of fat that they eat, whether or not they eat red meat, the kind of protein that they consume, whether they consume animal protein or plant protein. And of course, you know, today we've got this big plant based agenda where, you know, we're all being told we've got to abandon animal foods, we've got to give up meat, we've got to give up butter, we've got to give up all forms of dairy. You know, we've got to adopt a diet that's rich in grains and soy, soy protein and other legumes and stuff like that, and these alternative proteins that are being grown in bio reactors, lab grown meat, that kind of stuff, cultured, cultured and fermented foods. And you know this. Kind of stuff. And I think that's, that's just that is a contemporary illustration, really. It's a continuation, actually, of what Plato Socrates is saying in the Republic, which is that, actually, you know, you can, you want to make a fundamental transformation to society. Well, why don't you change the diet? And you know, there are all sorts of, there are, there are all sorts of studies that show, for example, you know, that height is correlated with the type of protein that people eat. So this is something that I talk about in the book. There's a, there's a worldwide study that shows that societies that eat red meat and drink milk, produce the tallest people in the world, right? And then societies that derive most of their protein from wheat. So that's like Middle Eastern societies in particular, and parts of North Africa, you know, they're they're shorter. And then societies that derive most of their protein from rice in particular. So it's tropical Asia. They're the shortest people in the world. And so, I mean, there's, there's, there's a there's a deep, there's a deep, deep history, I think going back to Plato, going back to, in fact, even going back even further, you could look at the agricultural revolution. You could look at the effects of the agricultural revolution. That's the transition from Hunter gathering to sedentary farming. You can look at the archeological records, skeletons. You can look

Nick Jikomesright, right. Yeah. It was, it was striking when I first learned that, you know when, when sedentary agricultural societies first developed, there were immediate changes in the skeletal morphology and the general health that we saw that those people have. And in general, they got smaller and sicker.

Charles Cornish-DaleYes, yeah. I mean markedly, you know, I mean the Yeah, the transition and so that actually, now that we kind of understand that a lot better. It throws the agricultural revolution into a new light, and it makes us ask different questions about the agricultural revolution, because, you know, we are as as a society, as a civilization. We are a product of the agricultural revolution. And so typically, we've looked back on the agricultural revolution as this great watershed moment in history made us who we are. It was the birth of civilization. It allowed the creation of complex culture, of urban centers, commerce, the arts. You know, all the great things that we take for granted were a product of the agricultural revolution. And that is true in some sense. That is true in some sense, but it makes us look at look back, you know, with hindsight, in in basically through the wrong end of the telescope, almost. And so what we what we end up doing is we end up saying, well, actually, of course, our ancestors wanted to transition from, you know, life as hunter gatherers to agriculturalists, because, of course, it's better look what it's brought us. But actually, if you look at the skeletal record, if you look at various forms of other evidence, it looks like life in early agricultural settlements was hell, and people were much, much worse off in in a number of different ways. They were less free and they were less healthy. And so then you have to ask, well, actually, so what? Why did they do it? Why did they do it? And the answer actually looks like, well, maybe they were coerced in various different ways. You know, maybe there was a confluence of various different things that all happened at once. So there's climactic data, for instance, that suggests that perhaps the kind of wild game and animals that hunter gatherers were hunting became less numerous, and maybe they were over hunted as well. But then you also have other evidence that suggests that maybe you know, like what you have is actually you have basically outside populations, enslaving groups of hunter gatherers and making them become agriculturalists. So there's abundant evidence that, you know, the first agricultural settlements were built basically on unfree labor, slavery in particular, and that actually, you know, the first forms of warfare between the early agricultural cities, the great cities of the of Mesopotamia or and Uruk and Lagash and all these other communities, you know, what they actually were was slaving raids. So these cities, you know,

Nick Jikomeswhen they waiting over people to use for slaves to do the farming, yes, yeah. And

Charles Cornish-Daleso, yeah. So, I mean, like, you know, that's a that's a fundamental transition you go from a hunter gatherer, mode of living, groups of maybe 150 people, Max, moving through the landscape. They might be sedentary at some time, you know, like they might have camps where they wait for the migration of of gazelle or something, or some kind of. Animal, but they were moving and and you know, following their prey, multiple food webs, multiple ecosystems, and then you have a transition to fixed field farming, to a very to a much narrower diet, to a reliance, in particular, on grains, on cultivated, domesticated grains, small number of foodstuffs, and some domesticated animals. But that was a fundamental transition, and it had fundamental social and biological effects as well. So there's some very interesting stuff, very interesting research being done now into ancient DNA. And what they're doing is they're looking at the skeletons of the first farmers, the first people who lived in these agricultural settlements. And and they can extract their genetic data, you know, from the from the bones, and they're looking for particular genetic adaptations to life as a farmer, and, you know, comparing to hunter gatherer skeletons and seeing like, you know, what are the genetic differences? And what they're finding is that, you know, there are the kind of changes that we might expect. So there are changes, for example, to carbohydrate metabolism, yes, so you'll find the early farmers have these, you know, they might produce more amylase in their mouths, let's say, or something like that, or in their gut, or both, to help them digest the carbohydrate, because they're eating much more, a much more carbohydrate heavy diet. But then you're also seeing as well what's interesting, and I mean, this is only this is research that only just is really cutting edge, and it's only really just starting to be done, but you're also seeing that there are behavioral changes as well, or there are genetic changes that indicate behavioral changes. So there was a paper called something like genomics of Stone Age Eurasia, or something huge paper, and just in passing, it mentioned the fact that early agriculturalists appear to have possessed genes that are related to behaviors associated with anxiety, for example, yeah, and that might have something to do with, let's say, like the increased levels of conscientiousness that are necessary to live in a much larger scale civilization than before. So, you know, you go from living in a group of 100 people to living in a city like ur which has a population of 50,000 I mean, that's an in an enormous,

Nick Jikomesvery different psychosocial environment, in addition to a different food environment.

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, exactly. So, I mean, there's, it's, it's real, it's fascinating, yeah, and no doubt there will be, there will be a lot more papers on this kind of stuff that actually start to show the kind of biological, hormonal adaptations, physical adaptations, that took place as a result of this fundamental transformation in the way that people act.

Nick JikomesFor those who don't know, there's, I mean, you might say we're in kind of a golden age of ancient genomics, recent ancient genomics from the times that we're talking about now, the transition to agriculture, and afterwards, I've had people like SK biller sev on to talk about metabolic adaptations and things like that fascinating stuff. David Reich from Harvard. There's lots of studies out there. And I think the key thing here is when humans transition to agriculture, and then things kept going from there. It wasn't just that our carbohydrate and our seed oil metabolism genes changed. There are many, many genetic changes that were positively selected, meaning they had a survival advantage. Clearly, they had to do with everything from brain development and social behavior to hardcore metabolism and basically everything in the time we have left, Charles, I want to ask you to sort of tie some things together here for us. So we've got this, what we'll just call toxic environment that's having clear hormonal and biological effects, both from the diet, per se and the toxins and things we're exposed to in the food, in the water and all the rest. We've also got right psychosocial changes that have happened in concert which are giving rise to all these phenomena that you talked about, the, you know, the Japanese recluses, the INCEL phenomenon. Here we've got, you know, clear decreases in virtually every marker of reproductive health that you can imagine your focus is on men, but you also say that, you know, all this stuff is obviously impacting women as well. In just a couple minutes. Can you talk a little bit about female birth control and the effects that's had? Because people often don't appreciate that it's having very strong effects beyond what it's meant to affect.

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah, it is. I mean, the birth control thing is, again, it's, it's a live issue, and it's a hot issue, and it's one that people are scared to talk about. Actually, it's, you know, I mean, you, you know, if you go on Tiktok or whatever, then you'll see these sort of videos where girls say, look what happened to me when I went on birth control. Look how much weight I put on. Look how awful I looked. And. Um, and that's become quite a trend, but actually, there's been a lot of pushback against that in the media. So, you know, that's that's branded as a kind of toxic, toxic kind of health influencers trying to brainwash girls not to go on hormonal contraceptives. But there are, like, we look, we've, said already, like you interfere in people's hormonal systems. You have fundamental effects on their entire bodies, right? I mean, you have hormone hormone receptors on basically every cell in your body, testosterone, estrogen, right? So you don't just have localized effects taking a synthetic estrogen as a contraceptive, or, you know, synthetic female hormone isn't just going to have an effect on your womb, it's going to have effects throughout the body as a woman. So one of the studies, there's a very interesting study that I talk about in the book, which is a recent study that showed that girls, or the girls and women who go on hormonal contraceptive experience thinning of a particular part of the brain called the What's it? Called the prefrontal I think it's the ventromedial prefrontal cortex. Ventromedial prefrontal cortex, that's it, yeah. And so they did MRI scans, basically, and they showed that, yeah, if you go on the hormonal contraceptive, it thins the ventromedial prefrontal cortex. Well, what does the ventromedial prefrontal cortex do? It's involved in fear regulation and emotional processing. It's, it's involved in executive control, you know, related to emotions and what happens as well. What they also showed, I think, if I remember correctly, is that if you go on hormonal contraception as a teenage girl, as so many girls do now, and they go on it not only, you know, not to get pregnant, but also actually because for Acne Control, you know, it's a matter of course, millions of girls get put on hormonal contraceptives, as a matter of course, but what happens is, if you stay on them past a certain age, you can come off, and the thinning that's taken place in the brain never goes away. But what they showed is that actually, if you go on hormonal contraceptives, I think past the age of, let's say like 25 Yeah, you can come off them, and the brain will read that region will regain its mass, will be the same size as it

Nick Jikomesshould be. This is, to me, this is very unsurprising, and this is a common thing that you see in biology, if you, if you expose someone to such an intervention at a critical stage of development in a sensitive period, whether it's early childhood development or in utero, or even the pregnancy of a woman, the woman herself goes into a kind of reopened sensitive period. Things can get locked into place and become permanent, whereas if you wait until those sensitive periods are over or finish developing, then things can be reversible.

Charles Cornish-DaleSo look so 10s of millions of women, I mean, I like hundreds of millions of women worldwide, are on hormonal contraceptives and and they're thinning their brains. They're actually thinning this critical region that's involved with emotional processing and fear regulation and executive control. Surely, surely, we would expect there to be aggregate social effects as a result, right? But what happens? Well, actually, in the paper itself, the researchers say, Oh no, look, this is worrying, sure, but let's not jump to any conclusions about the potential social effects. Let's not, let's not get to worrying about, you know, whether, actually this, we might be creating a society of women, perhaps, who display aberrant behaviors. Maybe, you know, like, I mean, that's an obvious route to explore. Then it's like, what actually, how do women who have a thin or a thinned or thinner ventromedial prefrontal cortex. How do they behave like, you know, I mean, I would, I would anticipate, not only that they would behave different in a social setting, yeah, they would behave different sexually. Probably they might, they might have different sexual choices, and that they might even behave different politically, differently politically, you know, like we're talking executive function. I mean, emotional regulation is, is, is, that's not peripheral, that's,

Nick Jikomesthat's, in many ways, that's what this part of the brain does. I mean, the reason our prefrontal cortexes are famously enlarged in humans, a lot of it is tied up with the types of social cognition we need to live in social groups, as we do,

Charles Cornish-Daleyeah, so, so look, I mean, I, I would say, look like, yeah, we got to do some research on this. And actually, maybe, maybe we've got to caution certainly, teenage girls against taking hormonal contraception like this, because this is, this is really worrying. But. Life. It's a live issue, you know, it's a very live issue because it touches on, well, the hormonal contraceptive was, you know, a fundamental, it's a dis was a decisive intervention in endocrinology in the 20th century, and it is associated with women's liberation, right? It is a central, central plank of women's liberation, that they should have total control over their reproductive system, otherwise, they're enslaved to men. And, you know, they're, you know, enslaved by the patriarchy, whatever. So this is a very, very emotive issue, like telling women whether or not they should take the hormonal contraceptive, yeah, you know, depriving them of their reproductive freedom. But it's, I think it's

Nick Jikomesimportant just to recognize, like, we can be totally agnostic about what's good, what's bad, what we should or shouldn't do. This is a hormone therapy. I mean, we're disrupting the hormone system on purpose for its birth control effect. But to think it's very, very naive to think that it's not going to have other effects as well, and we should at least be mindful of

Charles Cornish-Dalethat. Yeah, well, and this is, this is the thing. I mean, this is what these Tiktok videos are about, of girls saying, you know, look how fast I've got it's they're, they're saying, Look, I thought I was taking this, this contraceptive pill, and that would all be great, and that I would just, you know, I wouldn't get pregnant, and I could just live my life and be happy, not worrying about being pregnant. But actually, it ruined my life. It ruined my health, and it ruined my happiness, and nobody told me. And so, yeah, I mean, that's that, I think, is the real crime is that actually, it's being treated like it's just, oh, it's just a pill, and you take it and everything's fine, and you don't get pregnant. No, it's, it is? It's a decisive intervention in your body's hormonal balance, and it, you know, I mean, it can have devastating effects and and effects that we don't even understand yet, because, actually, we haven't prioritized investigating them because we're because we're so drunk on, you know, this sort of language of personal freedom and personal liberation that we don't actually care to care to investigate it enough, and also because there are huge profits. I mean, you know, hormonal contraceptive are worth enormous amounts of money to pharmaceutical companies. So then you've, you've also got another vested interest, not only the sort of philosophical feminist vested interest, but also the, just the sheer profit motive, you know, like, there's huge money in this, so it's, but, yeah, I mean, I, I think that there, there's a very good, there's a very good book. I think it's called something like, this is what, this is what your brain is like on the pill. I think that's what the book's called. That's about, yeah, I think it's, this is what your brain is like on the pill. And it's, it's about all of the side effects of of and then there's another, and there's a another book, I think it's called the greatest experiment ever conducted on women, or something like that, Barbara, Barbara Seaman, and it's about the history of estrogen and estrogen therapy, and how estrogen therapy is, you know, like was presented as this panacea, and it would, it would make women's lives so much better. And actually, it's, it's done the opposite, and it's actually very dangerous. And, you know, I mean, we, we know it's linked to to various different forms of cancer, you know, particularly breast cancer. You have these estrogen sensitive breast cancers. But, you know, the story is, it's basically, again, women were kind of sold a lie, basically, about their health. You know, like, you shouldn't go through the menopause. You don't have to go through the menopause. You can take estrogen, you know, you can take hormonal therapy, and, you know, everything will be fine. But actually, that, that, actually, that has big risks associated with,

Nick Jikomesyeah, yeah. Well, this may be, you know, in a way, ties into you mentioned at one point William James, this famous psychologist from the early 1900s he had this notion of humanity being at war with nature. Can you talk about that and maybe try and connect it to fukuyamas thesis, and just sort of your general take on that to tie things together here?

Charles Cornish-DaleYeah. So, yeah. So the final chapter is, or it's like the Epilog of the book is just about, what can we do about so, you know, I've set out this. I've used Fukuyama as a framework, right? And I've said, you know, like, we've created this political system actually, that doesn't have satisfying outlets for thymos. So what can we do? What can we do about that? Like, you know, we can solve these biological problems, in some sense, we can clean the environment up. We can get rid of the endocrine disruptors. We can stop people eating processed food. We can get working out, and that will obviously improve, you know, male health, and it will make men more masculine. But what? What then can you do about the fact. That actually, you know, we live in a society that actually, in many ways, is fundamentally opposed to basic masculine tendencies and basic masculine desires. So I talk about this essay by William James. I think it's from about 1910 it's called the moral equivalent of war. And William James, who was the brother of Henry James, the famous novelist says, you know, I'm a socialist. I believe in progress with a capital P. I believe in the fraternity of man. I don't like war. I think wars are hugely destructive, and in the modern age, they're only getting more destructive, to the point where, actually, you know, we could, we could kill all, kill ourselves, you know, all of us. But nevertheless, he says, you know war is. War is the source of the great many virtues, a great many things that actually are useful to society, courage, the ability to to subordinate oneself to a greater purpose, the ability to work within a team towards a common goal. You know, like he says, The Origin of so many of the things that are not only created civilization, but are also necessary, even now, even in an advanced society, to its maintenance, have their origin in war. And so what happens if we outlaw war? What do we do? How do we how do we ensure that even if men aren't at each throat, at each other's throats, you know, killing one another for their nations, how can we still get people to develop courage? And you know, all of these, these, other virtues and patriotism. And so he comes up with this idea of, well, okay, we don't go to war with one another. We don't have wars between nations. But what we do actually, is we have this grand struggle against nature where we say, Okay, we're going to go to war with nature. We're going to master and tame nature. And, you know, we're going to send off young men, you know, to kind of get involved in industry and in progress, and get them to, you know, build railways and and, you know, do all these, these kind of great endeavors to further human civilization and develop, develop these virtues that are so necessary, you know, for civilization to function. And that's, I mean, I think that that is, that is the kind of, that's the kind of question that I, I mean, the book ends basically with an open question, you know, I'm like, Okay, well, what do we do? Okay, we can solve these biological program problems. But, but what do we do? Do we do? We have to have some great purpose, like William James suggests, in order actually to be fully masculine, you know, if we, if we want something more than just to, just to be consumers, because that's basically what the last man is. You know, the last man is just a consumer. He's just someone who is, who is, you know, happy being a sort of democratic, democratic man. You know, you watch your Netflix, you have DoorDash, you you know, you work. You work an office job. Life

Nick Jikomesis really just buy stuff, but you don't go out and distinguish yourself. Yes,

Charles Cornish-Daleyeah, exactly. Well, what happens then, for those of us who actually do want to distinguish ourselves, you know, what do we what do we do? Can we actually do that within a democratic system? And it's not, it's quite, it's quite a it's a disquieting thought, you know, and it's, and I mentioned the William James essay, because clearly it's bothered, it's bothered people before. You know, this isn't a question that, that I've just hit upon. This is actually, I think, a question that is fundamental, is, is sort of has fundamentally occupied philosophical minds like William James, you know, and, and Nietzsche and others, you know, what do we? What do we do? And, and for Yama to it's like, okay, we've, we've triumphed, you know, we've created this incredibly complex, advanced civilization.

Nick JikomesWhat's next? And if the answer is, nothing, what? Then,

Charles Cornish-Daleyeah, exactly, exactly, exactly. That's yeah, I couldn't have put it better than that.

Nick JikomesAny final thoughts you want to leave us with, Charles, or anything you want to reiterate from the discussion,

Charles Cornish-DaleI would just one thing I would like to reiterate again, if I haven't made clear, is that I'm not just saying that it's all about testosterone. I'm not just saying that testosterone is the, you know, is the only thing that matters here. What I think is that biology and hormones in particular have been parodied and neglected to such an extent that we need to reassert the fact that we are biological beings and that so much of so much of our existence is rooted in our physical structure and our makeup and things like our hormones and until we until we understand. And that we'll only have a very, very superficial understanding of what's wrong and something and something very clearly is wrong. I mean, that's, you know, that's, that's something I set out to establish in the book, is, look, something really is wrong and but we're also looking in the wrong places.

Nick JikomesAlright? Well. Charles Cornish Dale, thank you for your time. That was an absolute

Nick Jikomes: pleasure. Visit mind and matter.substack.com. To find all of my content. If you like to read like I do, then you should check out the read wise app. It's totally free to download, and if you go through the link in the episode description or on my support page, you can get a free 60 day trial for zero cost. Readwise is a really cool app that allows you to import digital highlights from over 30 different platforms, such as Kindle iBooks, PDFs and more. It makes it really easy for you to review and find and share excerpts and quotes from whatever it is that you're reading, whether it's PDFs of scientific papers or books that you're reading on your Kindle. And you can even save and use highlights from physical books. I read a lot of physical books before bed, for example, or when I'm traveling. And the readwise app actually integrates with the camera on your phone so that you can take a photo of a page that you're reading highlight a specific chunk of text from that page and export it to the app so that you can reference it or find it or share it later. They even allow you to export really cool looking graphics of some of the highlights that you have in the books or the papers you're reading, so that you can share them in an engaging way. So check out the readwise app today. If you are a reader and you like to reference and organize what you read, go through the link in the episode description or on my support page or in my free weekly newsletter@mindandmatter.substack.com and try the readwise app, 60 days free today. Transcribed by https//otter.ai

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Seed Oils, Omega-3s & Lessons From 93 Years of Life | Artemis Simopoulos | 313

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail At 93, Artemis Simopoulos explains why oils once used in paint now dominate the food supply, how a high omega-6 intake slows the making of EPA and DHA, and why cholesterol-lowering corn oil did not...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Tendons, Collagen, mTOR & Exercise Adaptation | Keith Baar | Episode 312

    Nov 10, 20262 hrAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Keith Baar explains why tendons stop adapting after 10 minutes of loading, why long low-load holds beat fast reps for connective tissue, and how vitamin C, collagen, caffeine and mTOR shape training....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. GDF15, Morning Sickness & Mitochondrial Stress | Stephen O'Rahilly | Episode 311

    Nov 3, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Dr. Stephen O'Rahilly explains GDF15, a stress hormone that makes us feel sick and eat less, and why morning sickness, and its severe form hyperemesis gravidarum (HG), comes from GDF15 made by the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Psilocybin vs. SSRIs for Depression, Emotional Blunting & How Psychedelics Work | Robin Carhart-Harris | 310

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 56 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Robin Carhart-Harris explains why his trial of psilocybin therapy vs. the SSRI escitalopram for depression missed one primary measure but favored psilocybin on almost everything else, and why SSRIs can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. This Animal Survives 18 Minutes Without Oxygen | Gary Lewin | 309

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 40 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Nick talks with Prof. Gary Lewin (Max Delbrück Center, Berlin) about naked mole-rats, which in lab tests survived 18 minutes in pure nitrogen by shutting down brain activity, keeping the heart beating,...

    Credit the people on this episode