Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mind & Matter

Mind & Matter artwork

Oxidized Seed Oil Fats May Matter More for Heart Disease Than LDL | Tucker Goodrich | 244

Aug 7, 20251 hr 39 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail Overview and alternative interpretation to the mainstream view on how dietary fat and cholesterol relate to cardiovascular disease. Episode Summary: Tucker Goodrich is an engineer by training who has become a prominent independent researcher and blogger on nutrition and metabolic health, focusing on the harms of seed oils and polyunsaturated fats. About the guest: Nick Jikomes and Tucker Goodrich explore atherosclerosis and heart disease, critiquing the standard model that blames high LDL cholesterol while highlighting how oxidized LDL - driven by dietary linoleic acid from seed oils - plays a key role in plaque formation and inflammation; they discuss historical shifts in heart disease rates, genetic factors like familial hypercholesterolemia, the limitations of animal studies, and why reducing seed oil intake could prevent issues more effectively than just lowering cholesterol. Discussion Points: Atherosclerosis involves plaque buildup in arteries, often leading to heart attacks, but plaques contain oxidized fats and cholesterol, not just native cholesterol. Dietary cholesterol has little impact on blood levels or heart disease in humans, unlike in rabbits used in many studies. High LDL may not be inherently bad; oxidized LDL from polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) like linoleic acid causes macrophages to overeat and form harmful foam cells. Familial hypercholesterolemia patients only show higher heart disease rates in modern, industrial diets high in seed oils, not historically. Populations like the Kitavans and Tsimané have high apoB but no heart disease on traditional diets low in industrial foods. Fried foods are oxidized seed oils, explaining why they're unhealthy despite omega-6 fats being labeled "heart-healthy." Omega-3 fats can displace omega-6 in cells, reducing oxidation risk. Reference Papers: Witztum & Steinberg (1991) Boren et al. (2022) Related episode: M&M 136: Seed Oils, Omega-6 PUFAs, Inflammation, Obesity, Diabetes, Chronic Disease & Metabolic Dysfunction | Chris Knobbe *Not medical advice. Support the show Support my work: Good Chemistry: Personalized, science-based health consulting. Work with Dr. Nick Jikomes directly. Affiliate Partners: Visit this link to see my affiliate partners and get discounts codes for products & services to support health. For all the ways you can support my efforts.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Nick JikomesWhether food, drugs or ideas, what you consume, influences, who you become. On the mind and matter podcast, we learn together from the best scientists and thinkers alive today about how your mind body reacts to what you feed it. Before starting mind and matter, I spent 10 years in academia doing scientific research. I got a PhD in neuroscience, where I focused on neuro endocrinology and the neurobiology of behavior, and before that, I specialized in molecular developmental and evolutionary genetics. I used my scientific background to help parse and translate the information that guests share on the podcast. In addition to the podcast, I write long form written content inspired by the show, where I integrate what I've learned across episodes. I also have a free weekly newsletter where I provide you with upcoming guests, share links and provide commentary on scientific studies and research that I'm reading, and more visit mind and matter.substack.com. To find all of my content.

Nick JikomesYou you rich. Thank you for coming back on the podcast.

Tucker GoodrichIt's a pleasure, and you know, it's kind of funny. I I really wasn't aware of your work before you reached out to me to do the previous podcast, and since then, I've become a big fan of your podcast. Yeah, great. And I've learned a lot of stuff that I haven't seen anywhere else. So let me give you a shout out for doing fine work.

Nick JikomesThank you. Thank you. Yeah, I mean, you're, you know, you're one of probably a handful of people on the internet where you know you're not a professor at a university. You're not calling in from your lab right now, but I immediately noticed like, oh, this, you know, this guy is plugged into a lot of really interesting research. You're very well read, and you it's, it's always funny when I say this out loud, you actually clearly read the papers and read things carefully. And you might be surprised at how often people in certain fields don't actually read the literature that carefully. Sometimes,

Tucker Goodrichwell, that was, that was one of the best tips I ever got from Stefan DNA, is that he was talking about Ray Pete, and he said, I don't agree with a lot of what he a lot of his conclusions, but his references always say what he says. They say, yeah. I was like, what? That's not normal,

Nick Jikomesyeah, yeah. Well, I mean, I just, I put up an article. The last article I did in my sub stack was all about, I had a guest on, and I don't want to derail where we're going, but I'll briefly describe this. I had a guest on, and I were talking about diet, microbiome stuff. It's a hot field. He just had a Nature paper come out. You know, you would think it had all the markers of, you know, very good scholarship at first blush. But, you know, I asked him about the diet, and I didn't get certain answers. I was curious about I really just wanted to know, like, what, what exactly is in it, how does, like, it's a paper about diet, what's in the diet? Couldn't quite get the answer I wanted. So then I went back to the paper, and I looked up the diet, and there's a reference. And the reference goes to one of his own papers from several years ago, and I go to it, which is typical, yep. And and I noticed that the paper that's referenced has a different diet printed than the one I'm just read. And I was like, oh, that must be a typo in a table. And then I looked at the paper more closely the one that was referenced, and Nope, it's repeated. Clearly it's actually, they essentially brag about what turned out to be the False nutrient content as a strength of that study. And I went down this rabbit hole. Long story short, apparently nobody who read the first paper, which would include the scientists who did the work, the senior author on that paper, who is the senior author, the one who's supposed to send it into the journal, the journal editors who are supposed to read it and approve it and look for sanity checks, and then, and then, the the reviewers who ostensibly carefully read it in their peer review, this was such like a blatant error that was so fundamental to the paper that it must mean that just no one read it carefully, and I'm talking about the people who put the work together,

Tucker Goodrichright, Right? Well, probably, you know, whoever the first author was, was a student, and the senior author just assumed they did it right. And, yeah, put their name off it and send it off to the publisher. Yeah.

Nick JikomesI mean, I think the point, the point people take away, is the currency for success in science is papers published. It's not truth per se. It's not, you know, cross. Telling your T's and dial your eyes. It's, it's getting the paper out there and getting excited. And the paper I just referenced was cited over 100 times in the last

Tucker Goodrichfive years. So, big win, big win. No, it's not a very helpful paper, apparently.

Nick JikomesSo anyways, we're going to talk about heart disease, cardiovascular health stuff connected into dietary fats, and how you think about that, and how you know, sort of the textbooks would would think about this. But let's just start very basic for people, when we talk about heart disease, cardiovascular disease, a term that comes up here, is atherosclerosis. Let's just break that down for people. What is atherosclerosis?

Tucker GoodrichSo atherosclerosis probably, I think, the simplest way to describe how it's thought of in standard Cardiology is imagine you have an infection, a pus filled infection on the inside of your artery, right? That infection, if it gets bad enough, I think that the old term used to be a boil, right? The old a boil is like in, you know, if you can imagine a zit that goes horribly wrong, the boil can become, becomes inflamed. I mean, that's sort of what makes a boil. A boil is an inflammation process, and the boil and the oil can burst. The athero, sclerotic lesion can burst and send stuff out into your bloodstream, which can block blood flow through the heart, causing a heart attack, myocardial myocardial infarction. There are other ways you can have a heart attack, there are non atherosclerotic heart attacks and blah, blah, blah, but we won't go over that, because the majority of it is this atherosclerosis leads to a heart attack process.

Nick JikomesYep. So when you test so cardiovascular disease, heart disease, these terms cover a lot of there's a lot of different ways for things to go wrong in your cardiovascular system. This is one of the major killers of people, and has been for some time, and it's the number one killer, yeah. And so different forms of heart disease have sort of waxed and waned to different degrees over time, but atherosclerosis makes up a big chunk of this. And so things can go wrong. Your blood vessels little, little bubbles of stuff can form on the edge with plaque and get inflamed, and stuff these things can grow. They can burst and at a very, very high level, right? This is what we're going to be talking about. How do these things form? What can go wrong? How do they get worse? And then, how does that tie into diet? So, right? What are these plat when people talk about plaques and their arteries getting filled with plaques, what are these plaques? What are they made out of?

Tucker GoodrichThey're made out of cholesterol, primarily, and fats. They have other components in them, dead cells, typically the, you know, obviously the cells that make up the lining of the artery. Those include endothelial cells, smooth muscle cells. They also typically include a lot of macrophages, right which are white blood cells. The macrophages have two roles in the body. They obviously protect from infection. They do this macrophage, the word means big eater, so they clean things up by ingesting them and digesting them, right? But not only do they do that to bacteria or anything causing an infection in your body, but they will also do that to damaged parts of your body. So if you fall and you get a scrape, the white blood cells will go there, both to eat the bacteria, but also to dispose of damaged tissue so that your body can, you know, heal that wound. So clean up. Crew, yeah, exactly. So they so those that's, you know. And again, I'm going to skip over lots of stuff that's going on here, just to move this conversation around. Because, like everything we're going to discuss, you could probably spend the rest of your life reading papers about it, right, right?

Nick JikomesEspecially this area. This area. This is, you know, because this is such a relevant health issue, there's been a lot of attention. There's a lot of literature that goes back decades on some of this stuff, right,

Tucker Goodrichright, right. So then what happens, typically, the first sign of atherosclerosis is what's known as a foam cell. Okay, so, a foam cell is a macrophage that has ingested so much fat and cholesterol that it basically the fats and cholesterol. It looks like this little foamy particle, right? I mean, a macrophage. Age typically looks like an amoeba. If people remember that from high school science, it's ingested a lot, yeah, so much so that it basically can die and burst, right? It goes through a process called necrosis. Now that's not what's supposed to happen. That macrophage is supposed to take up the damaged particles, digest them, maybe take them out of that area of the body, so that, you know, they can be cleaned up and liver, or wherever else

Nick Jikomesthat happens, it would literally digest stuff into smaller pieces, and those that stuff can be moved elsewhere, used for other purposes. But the macrophage can eat so much, so fast, or it somehow, somehow malfunctions, because it's of what it's eating or whatever, and then it bursts, so it's going to leak in completely digested stuff that it had begun to be filled with,

Tucker Goodrichright? And this is what is, you know, you get enough of this happening in the wall of the artery, and you get what's known as gruel, which is a pretty gross way to describe it, and it's the pus, right? It's known as gruel in the literature. I prefer to call it pus, because I think that's more accurately describing what it is. And it's a blend of cholesterol, fats, dead cells, dead, you know, undigested components of LDL and other lipoproteins that are in the business of delivering fats and cholesterol around the body and tend to accumulate in these areas. Now this gets in us, into the whole Why does this happen? Part of the conversation, if that's, I think enough of a overview for this section of it, unless you have

Nick Jikomesfurther No, I mean, yeah, let's just start. Yeah, no, no, let's, um, pause on some of that for a minute. So the plaques, so there's a lot of cholesterol in them. Let's so. So, on the topic of what they're made out of, there's a lot of cholesterol. And this, right? This is probably where just the idea originally came from. Ah, there's plaques. Clearly, these plaques are bad, and they build up over time. They cause problems for cardiovascular health. What are the plaques made out of cholesterol? Ah, okay, well, cholesterol must be bad. It must be causing, causing the plaques to form, and it's what we should minimize or get rid of, because it is such a prominent component of these plaques. Just talk a little bit about that idea and where it comes from. And then, you know how you start to think about

Tucker Goodrichit, yeah. So that's, that's basically, you know? I mean, it's not a dumb idea, right? You see this damaged thing, and it's full of something. Well, the first thing you should think is, okay, maybe this something has a relationship to this, right? And it turns out that, as the famous cholesterol researcher Ansel keys put it, you know, if you are a rabbit or a chicken, then ingesting cholesterol will cause atherosclerosis. So in some species, there is a direct relationship between, you know, and that's the basis of a lot of our dietary guidelines, the recommendations that

Nick Jikomesgo ahead. But for historical perspective here, the reason you just said rabbit is they used to do a lot of studies on rabbits, including these types of heart related, heart health related studies, and still do, and they still do. And I mean, as many people hopefully realize, you know, rabbits are very different than us. They are herbivores. They are literally not meant to eat basically any cholesterol, and so they very quickly will get their cholesterol level spiked by eating cholesterol. And then

Tucker Goodrichit's it's important, it's important to note there right that the distinction in the atherosclerotic effect of cholesterol, a broad distinction, is that cholesterol is made in animals and plants use things called phytosterols, which are similar to cholesterol but not exactly the same. So it shouldn't surprise somebody that an animal that's not eating, you know, much in the way of animal matter wouldn't be as good at processing cholesterol as, say, a carnivore. Carnivores don't get atherosclerosis from eating cholesterol. Yeah. Yeah.

Nick JikomesSo, anyways, a lot of a lot of work that informed the way people to this day think about atherosclerosis and heart health was done in creatures like rabbits. So, right? Anyways, nonetheless, you know, plaque is made out of cholesterol. There was some indications that cholesterol ingestion in some species is related to cholesterol levels in the body. What kind of comes next in this story?

Tucker GoodrichYeah, so it's been known since, I mean, I have, you know, Ansel keys, the famous cholesterol researcher, said in 1952 that dietary cholesterol doesn't have any relationship to. Atherosclerosis, right? And he repeated that in 1997 saying, you know, unless you're a rabbit or a chicken, no relationship, right? There are some people where, if they eat a little bit more cholesterol, their cholesterol levels and blood will go up. But it's not very material. And there was a famous case of a man who was institutionalized, and one of his mental problems was that all he would eat was eggs. And there's a great research paper out there called The Man Who ate 25 eggs a day. And you know, the cardiologists were thrilled to find this guy, but dismayed to discover that his cholesterol levels were quote, unquote, normal, right? And aside from his mental issues. So note to the listeners, don't eat 25 eggs a day. Maybe it will drive you crazy. He complained about it, but it didn't give him heart disease,

Nick Jikomesright? So their expectation was, ah, well, eggs have quite a bit of cholesterol. So if you're eating a bunch of eggs and not much else, you should have very high cholesterol. They didn't see that in this patient, and that fits with everything I know from the literature today, which is cholesterol ingestion has some relationship to cholesterol levels in the body, but actually, the more you eat, the smaller the move and your cholesterol levels will be. I know that in other animals, they've explicitly identified hormones in the body that form a negative, basically a negative feedback loop mechanism, where the more you ingest, the less your body makes, right? The less you ingest, the more your body makes. Because your body just like the Yeah, just

Tucker Goodrichjust like blood glucose, right, right? You'll have a variation, and eating it will cause your blood glucose to go up a little bit or a lot. I mean, it's not a perfect analogy, but you know, ultimately, your liver is going to make less blood glue, make less glucose to put into your blood if you're eating more of it. It's a you know, your body wants to keep levels of these things roughly stable, because too much in either direction can be a problem. Yeah. Now, cholesterol, it's often noted, is an essential component of the human body, and if you have one of these genetic conditions where your body either can't make or can't transport cholesterol, you're going to have all sorts of unpleasant consequences of that severe retardation, you know? Yeah, yeah. I haven't spent out, I haven't spent a ton of time going through all the symptoms of not having enough cholesterol. Because,

Nick Jikomesyeah, well, I would imagine a bad thing. Yeah, I would imagine, right? It's, I mean, it's almost like saying, I mean, it's such a basic thing that, like so much could go wrong. I mean, this is a precursor to all of the steroid hormones. It's a major structural piece of membranes, which, you know, every single cell in your body is going to have cholesterol levels regulated in the membrane to determine, you know, exactly what the fluidity of that membrane is, which has biophysical and biochemical consequences for all of the proteins in that membrane. It's, you know, it's a very, very basic building block,

Tucker Goodrichright, right? And, you know, interestingly, the reason it's used as a basic building block is because it's what they call neutral. It doesn't really react to other things, right? So, you know, kind of, kind of a leading comment here, yeah, is that you don't want to build your system out of things that are going to either degrade or cause harm to other parts of the system, right? So the body uses cholesterol because it's pretty neutral, harmless lipid. It is a fat. It's so fat, like saturated fat, but it is in the same family.

Nick JikomesSo you mentioned that Ansel keys himself said that the relationship between dietary cholesterol, intake and and atherosclerosis was, you know, not not there or not there strongly in humans, alluding to the fact that a lot of the studies that he and others did were done in creatures like rabbits. Unpack that a little bit more for us, because the standard way to think about cholesterol is, you consume cholesterol. Your cholesterol grows up. The cholesterol is what makes the plaques. Therefore that's going to drive plaque formation. Let's go through, like, the standard way of thinking about atherosclerosis and plaque and cholesterol from the standpoint of mainstream cardiology today.

Tucker GoodrichYeah, so I Yeah, mainstream cardiology today is a bug bear of mine, but let's go through the intellectual process a little bit. Right? The initial thought was that it was cholesterol. They didn't really understand what that was in the blood, and as time went by, they were able to understand the components of cholesterol, right? Cholesterol in the blood is packaged into a protein called a lipoprotein lipid, carrying protein along with fat, right even for an LDL molecule, most of the payload is fat, and fat is carried around the body and often bound to cholesterol in what. Yeah, it's called a cholesterol ester. So cholesterol ester is a molecule of cholesterol and a molecule of any of a variety of types of fat, right? And they are packaged up into these proteins, lipoproteins. And cells can basically take the payload out of the lipoprotein. And so, you know, they started, they started giving people treatments to lower their cholesterol levels, and they noticed that it didn't really have much of an effect on heart disease rates, right? And I don't remember off the top my hand what they are, because I haven't spent an enormous amount of time looking at those, but, but very basic. So then they started saying, okay, maybe it's one of the other components in the lipoprotein, right? There's not much of a relationship between LDL and heart disease, despite what modern cardiology will tell you in 2013 I think it was, they were actually talking about removing LDL from the risk calculators and not no longer making LDL levels a target of treatment. And some of the other cardiologists who disagreed with that point of view had a fit over it. But some of the risk calculators that are used to predict your rate future rate of heart disease. Actually don't use LDL.

Nick JikomesI mean, some of the calculators used by physicians in clinics today, right? Do not use LDL, right? Other calculators presumably do. So there's, well,

Tucker Goodrichyeah, I mean, if you have, if you have an element that doesn't have it's like, you know, I mean zero to your formula. Yeah, I didn't

Nick Jikomesknow this at all. So okay, but this is, this is where a lot of people and this is an area where I don't know so much, so I can, I can sort of ask my questions naturally and honestly here, because this is not an area of expertise for me. So, but what this is gonna be surprising to a lot of people, right? Because isn't the whole right? Isn't the whole story that most of us have been told that LDL is the bad cholesterol. LDL being high is what drives heart disease. You just said that some cardiologists use calculators to calculate heart disease that don't take LDL into account. What's what's going on here?

Tucker GoodrichWell, I use, again, I've, you know, I've not looked at these calculators in a number of years because I find the top, you know, it's just not an area of my interest. But, so, yeah, it's just not a good predictor. And you can find plenty of studies that are, you know, will say no relationship was found between LDL and cardiovascular rates. I know the Jupiter study was a major one, and that was one of its conclusions. So, you know, a colleague and friend of mine, Ivor Cummins, Cummings, has done a lot of work on this and drilled through, you know, what are the, you know, he has a list of, yeah, a list of these types of studies, and he and I did a little bit of work on one point. And think so. LDL is a lip type of lipoprotein is, you know, the protein part of it is a lipoprotein called APO, B, right? Apocalyptic protein type B. Okay, there are so APO B is often used now as a better marker for cardiovascular disease than LDL. Yep. 95% of the APO B in your bloodstream are LDL particles, right? So the risk is probably coming from the other 5% if LDL doesn't have much of an effect. So what's the other 5% Yeah, there are two types of APO B molecules. There's apo b1 100,

Nick Jikomesyeah. So hold on. I just want, okay, going visual for people. So your blood, right? You can't mix oil and water. Fatty stuff doesn't mix well with watery stuff. So obviously, you've got your cardiovascular system, it's a series of tubes through which your blood flows. And so the body has to have a way to transport fatty stuff through the aqueous environment of the blood. What Tucker's talking about here is, if you imagine, just like a bubble or a sphere of fat, it is being transported around. It's got certain proteins like APO B embedded in it, and it's a structure for moving these fatty stuff around the body. And your body has different reasons for doing that. It might use some of those fat molecules for energy somewhere else it might use some of the stuff in there are structural components. What you're saying is one of these little transporters has APO B lipoprotein in it. It's 95% LDL, low density lipoprotein, a component, and then there's other stuff in it. But. People mostly have focused on the LDL part, because it's a huge component of it, and maybe have overlooked what what else is in this stuff,

Tucker Goodrichright? Well, again, we've, you know, we started off looking at atheromas and finding they have cholesterol in them. Okay, so we research cholesterol doesn't seem to have quite the relationship that we thought it was going to and then we discovered that there's more than cholesterol at play. There are these lipoproteins, right? And 95% of that is LDL. So we've, you know we're going going along a low hanging fruit, right, investigating each fruit on the tree, yeah, as they're more obvious, which is not an unreasonable thing to do. I mean, it's the preferred analytic technique, yeah, some fancy name for the Pareto Principle,

Nick Jikomesyeah. But I think, you know, part of what, part of, part of what you're doing here is, you know, some of the stuff that I read and some of the papers you shared with me are that there's just extreme variability in clinical expression of cardiovascular disease with respect to LDL. So even if you took, say, a family that has a genetic disorder giving them very, very high cholesterol levels, hypercholesterolemia, there is striking diversity in when they get heart disease, and the relationship to the specific cholesterol levels is much, much more variable than you would expect if there was a straight line that connects cholesterol to heart disease in in the simplest way you might imagine,

Tucker Goodrichright? That's exactly right. And you know, again, we were discussing what an atheroma is. Well, an atheroma is the wall of the artery, right? And familial hypercholesterolemia, FH is a disease in which you are unable to get cholesterol and lipoproteins into the wall of the artery. Okay? Now we have a treatment called PCs, canine inhibitor. Okay, so cholesterol gets into your artery wall by something called the LDL receptor. And there's some other receptors, but we're going to start with that one in FH, the LDL receptor is dysfunctional. Okay, genetically dysfunctional, so it is unable to bring cholesterol and the LDL particle into the wall of the artery in the normal frequency. So these

Nick Jikomespeople have high cholesterol levels in the blood because they have a dysfunctional LDL receptor, which is preventing their body from taking it out of the blood.

Tucker GoodrichBingo, exactly right. PCs, canine is an enzyme in the cell wall, and its job is to break down the LDL receptor. Okay, so people who have low activity of that enzyme have very high levels of PCS canine in the cell wall, which means they have lots of LDL, or, I'm sorry, they have very high levels of LDL receptors in the same wall, and they have low serum levels of LDL, therefore cholesterol, because they are taking more of it out now, they also tend to have just like people in a modern environment, and we'll get into that. Who have FH have higher rates of heart disease. People with this PCs, canine mutation tend to have lower rates of heart disease.

Nick JikomesSo two different genetic conditions, one that's going to get a result in high blood LDL levels, the other one results in abnormally low levels. Both of them are associated with higher rates of heart disease.

Tucker GoodrichNo, no, the PCS canine mutation is lower rates of heart disease. Oh, I see. Okay, got it. So the treatment, the pcsk Nine inhibitor, increases the number of LDL receptors, right? Yeah. But then to think about this, I'm an engineer, so to think about this as an engineer would. So what this means is that in the wall of the artery, people with FH have less LDL and cholesterol, and people with the PCS canine mutation have more LDL and cholesterol, yet they have lower rates of heart disease, right? So it's

Nick Jikomesa distinction between, is the cholesterol high in the blood, or is it high somewhere else? Is it high where the problem starts? Yes, yes. And normally, when we think about these things, this is a more general problem, but for this issue, right? When we talk about high cholesterol, when you hear the term high cholesterol, high LDL, what that almost always refers to is high levels in the bloodstream,

Tucker Goodrichright, right? But I'm interested in what's causing the problem in the wall, because that's what's going to burst and going to kill

Nick Jikomesyou, yes, so that that's what we talked about, atherosclerosis. This is the sclerotic little growth. Is this thing in the wall of the. The blood vessel. And okay, I'll let you

Tucker Goodrichgo from here. Yeah, so you have this inversion, right? What we would expect if LDL and cholesterol are causing the problem, we would expect the FH people who have less of it in the artery wall, to have lower rates of heart disease, and PCs, canine mutation people to have higher rates of heart disease. But we see the reverse of that. So what's going on? Yeah. Now there's a great paper, and the author of this, John Castellane, who's a smart cardiologist, although constrained by the disciplines of his field, wrote a really interesting analysis of FH families in Europe, and it turns out that we have records for mortality for them going back into the pre modern era. And it turns out that, and there are other epidemiologists who've what's his name? Davey Smith, I can't remember his first name. He's another famous epidemiologist, and his observation was people in people with FH only suffer increased levels of heart disease in high fat diets. And Castellane wrote this paper showing that people with FH only show increased levels of heart disease in the modern era in industrial countries, right? So something changed. So

Nick Jikomeshe went back into these historical records, and these people were not dying at higher rates, as you would expect, if this was just a pure like genetic problem that was impervious to an interaction with the food environment in this case,

Tucker Goodrichexactly, exactly. Now, why could that be the case? Well, LDL has, you know, and I'm going to spend most of my time talking about LDL here, just because, you know, it is 95% and it is the main part of their, part of the story, in the common model that I'm gonna critique here, LDL has other roles. Okay, it's a antibiotic. Okay, so when you get an infection, one of the things that the bacteria try to do is form a colony, right? Biofilms. People have heard about an LDL particle can be oxidized in the bloodstream by another type of white blood cell called a neutrophil, and an oxidized LDL particle is able to prevent these bacteria from functioning normally. It interferes with what's called their quorum sensing mechanism, and that helps prevent the body from an infection. When you get bacteria into the bloodstream, right?

Nick JikomesIt's messing with the ability of the bacteria to coordinate with each other, which would result in a worse infection,

Tucker Goodrichexactly, exactly. So that's a you know, neutrophils, these white blood cells do what's known as an oxidative burst, where they basically use their mitochondria, ramp up. Their mitochondria, produce a lot of very toxic molecules and spew those out at the damage, at the bacteria, right? That's all great. So there's you could see then, if you have FH and you're living in, you know, dirty medieval Europe, right, right, having high levels of LDL could be beneficial to you, okay, withstand infections, yeah. So interesting. Anyway, so you know then, so we we've identified two problems with the model, as they're describing it, right?

Nick JikomesWhen you say the model right, the idea here is, okay, we've got these plaques. They're made out of cholesterol. If someone has high cholesterol, maybe that's making more plaque and then driving heart disease. But what you told us a few moments ago was, well, actually, in these people with genetically high levels of cholesterol, familial hypercholesterolemia, they've got a deficit in the LDL receptor, and so even though their cholesterol levels are high in the bloodstream, they actually aren't getting into right, the plaques, which is the opposite of what you would expect in the sort of naive model, right, right? So

Tucker GoodrichI to keep this down to a reasonable amount of reading for Nick. Over the weekend, I sent him two papers, and the first paper was by two authors, wisdom and Steinberg, cardiologists and scientists, right? And they reference just, just to keep it simple, the article I sent was kind of a review article, and so in the effort to try and elucidate exactly what mechanism is going on, specifically in FH people, a couple of scientists prior. To this paper, but discussed in this paper, brown and Goldstein discovered the LDL receptor. Okay, they got a Nobel Prize for doing that and what? And then the first thing that they did is they took LDL and they put it in a vial with, this is the in vitro study, right? They put it in a vial with macrophages, and they waited for the macrophages to be converted into foam cells, right? Because that's the first part of atherosclerosis, is the appearance of foam cells.

Nick JikomesYep. So the macrophages are somehow getting sick, let's say, or not quite doing

Tucker Goodrichover consuming, over consuming, right? The problem is it didn't work, right? Macrophages, with what they started calling native LDL, do not become foam cells, right? So then they tried, I forget exactly why they did this, but they came up with a, what they referred to as a modified LDL. It was acetylated, right? Which is not a process that happens in the body, just to note, but, but it did have the effect of causing the macrophages to gorge on modified LDL and become fun cells. So this starts

Nick Jikomesto tell us, okay, when the LDL is modified in certain ways that can induce over consumption by the macrophages,

Tucker Goodrichexactly. But they didn't know what it was, because they knew that the acetylated LDL that they were using doesn't appear in the

Nick Jikomesbody, right? So there could be some other way that LDL is modified naturally in in a body in vivo, that would cause the same effect, right?

Tucker GoodrichSo Stein wisdom and Steinberg and this other paper, they're the guys who figured out what was going on, and brown and Goldstein wrote in very nice paper, acknowledging that they had discovered it and solved the problem that they had found. And this is a later paper in a series of papers from wisdom and Steinberg discussing what's going on, right? So it turns out that the oxidized LDL that I mentioned, if you incubate macrophages with oxidized LDL, they will ingest enough of it to become foam cells. So

Nick Jikomesoxidizing LDL is one way to modify the LDL to induce the macrophages to overeat, which is going to end up causing us problems and oxidation, as opposed to the acetylation experiment you mentioned a moment ago. This does happen inside of us, right?

Tucker GoodrichIt does happen inside of us, and particularly it happens inside of the artery, although it happens in other places as well, and

Nick JikomesI would imagine it's because, right? We're talking about blood flow through the cardiovascular system, there's lots of oxygen, so you're going to get oxidation,

Tucker Goodrichright, right, right, right. So what's getting oxidized is the next question, right, right, right. And to the payload of a LDL particle, as I said, cholesterol and fats. The largest part of the fat that's in the particle is a fat called linolenic acid, right? The other particle, the other fats, tend to be fats that you your body can make, okay? Linoleic acid is unique in the payload and that your body can't make it it has to be consumed.

Nick JikomesSo LDL particles tend to have disproportionately high amount of linoleic acid, ie, they tend to have disproportionately high levels of fatty acids that your body cannot synthesize itself,

Tucker Goodrichright, right? And they also have things. They also have a lot of anti oxidants that can linoleic acid is very fragile fat. It's very susceptible to oxidative damage, which is, you know, the oxidation in the oxidized in the oxidized LDL, it's oxidized linoleic acid.

Nick JikomesAnd this, this tells us, primarily, this is a general pattern. Whenever you have something that's easily oxidizable, like linoleic acid in nature, whenever you look at where this stuff shows up, whether it's in a seed or in a fish or in what Tucker talking about right now, when biology is doing it on purpose, so to speak, the easily oxidizable polyunsaturated fatty acid is almost always packaged with antioxidants, right? And the way you interpret that is, it's the biology is trying to prevent oxidation of this thing. Well, it's trying to control it, to control it, yeah, contain it, regulate it, right? Because, you know, one of the other fats that's in, you know, we get, again, this distinction between animal lipids and plant lipids, one of the other fats that's excuse me, found in Iraq in the LDL particle, is arachidonic acid, which is another polyunsaturated fat from the Omega six family, and

Tucker Goodrichthat comes from animals. Yes, right? Linoleic acid primarily. The primary source of that in our diet is from plants. Although, if you eat a cow, you will get some amount of linoleic acid, because they eat plants. And, you know, blah, blah, blah, we don't need to go through that whole pathway, okay,

Nick Jikomesso, so you can modify LDL particles, and the macrophages will then overeat, and this will end up causing problems. One way to do to modify the LDL is to induce that effect is to oxidize them. Oxidation is happening in our bodies all the time, because it's an oxygen rich environment, and linoleic acid is present at particularly high levels in these LDL particles. That's right. So yeah, keep us going down this chain here. So

Tucker Goodrichin this I love this paper because of their sentence. Here we go. So Steinberg and wisdom in this 1991 paper, conclude the nature of the substrate for lipid peroxidation, meaning the oxidation that's going on in the LDL, mainly the polyunsaturated fatty acids in lipid esters and cholesterol is a dominant influence in determining susceptibility to atherosclerosis, as noted by Esther Bauer, there's a vast excess of polyunsaturated fatty acids in LDL in relationship to the content of natural endogenous antioxidants, right?

Nick JikomesSo you've got more polyunsaturated fatty acids in these particles than than is than the antioxidants can handle. So then they're easily oxidized, and then that is what's going to cause the macrophage overeating problem,

Tucker Goodrichexactly. So they did, you know, and it's described in this paper. They did some experiments with the poor rabbits, again, and with people, importantly, where they demonstrated that if you alter the fat ratio in the diet, lowering linoleic acid, that it lowers. Again, as I said, linoleic acid can only be acquired through the diet the body can't make it and replace it with the laic acid, which is more stable fat that the LDL particles stop becoming so susceptible to oxidation.

Nick JikomesSo now, now we're sort of, this is giving us a dissociation here. So to me, this is where we start to explain why. So the thing that should matter here is oxidized LDL, and the extent to which the macrophages overeat is going to depend on how much oxidized polyunsaturated fatty acid is in an LDL particle. This starts to explain why you can dissociate LDL levels from the problem. Because, you know, LDL levels will correlate with the problem insofar as you've got this modified, you know, polyunsaturated fatty acid thing going on, but you could also have relatively high LDL levels without that going on.

Tucker GoodrichSo, yeah, exactly as in the case in Castle lanes paper of the FH people who didn't have higher rates of heart disease, right? So, so what happens here, right? I mean, looking at FH specifically, I mentioned before that there's the LDL receptor, but that there are also other receptors. Well, there are a class of receptors that are known as scavenger receptors. Okay, scavenger receptors are basically, you know, they're in, I think all cells, but they take up fats, right, not just through LDL. And it turns out that this is what happens in the macrophage, right? A regular, native LDL particle is taken up into the macrophage via the LDL receptor. That's a regulated pathway, so it won't make the macrophage sick, right? It won't become a foam cell. The scavenger receptor, however, is basically the cleanup pathway and is unregulated. Okay, so you take it will take up as much as is available, because it's recognizing something that needs to be taken out of the circulation, right? And that could be free fatty acids, with too much of which can be harmful, and it's oxidized fats, right, which, under the normal course of business, as I mentioned, the body will create to as part of its infection prevention system via the LDL. So if you get, say, sepsis, right, a severe bacterial infection, the macrophages or the Neutrophils are going to create a lot of oxidized LDL and. Yeah, you will then become systemically insulin resistant, right? And the higher insulin levels will cause all of your cells to start up regulating, cleaning these oxidized lipids out of the system. Because the key thing to understand about these oxidized lipids is they are toxic, right, right, right? They are toxic to the bacteria and they are toxic to your body, right?

Nick JikomesSo just, they're just toxic to cells, basically, of any kind,

Tucker Goodrichexactly. So while the body uses them and uses them both as signaling molecules and as a defense, too, much of it is a problem, and it has this system to dispose of them as crazy.

Nick JikomesIt's like, I've, you know, there's toxic stuff underneath my sink, and I use a little bit of it sometimes to clean up stuff in my house, but, but that's it, right?

Tucker GoodrichExactly, exactly. Um, so now that gets us into this thing called sterile inflammation. Okay, so anyway, all of this is pretty much standard in the cardiovascular literature, right? I mean, the second paper that I sent to Nick is born 2020 which was this article by the European atherosclerosis society. It was second part of a two part series. First one came out in 2017 and the first one pretty much discussed a lot of associations and correlations between LDL levels and heart disease. And one of the critiques of that paper noted that while they they mentioned X number of articles discussing LDL levels and cardiovascular disease, the only ones that they included in their graph produced this positive slope, showing that LDL was positively related with increased levels of heart disease. But if you added all the rest of the papers that they mentioned in the slope was flat, the relationship disappeared. Okay, so I guess this group got a lot of pushback on the 2017 paper, because then they came out with this 2020 paper, and they discussed actual mechanisms, why is what is happening in the body, right? And the title of it is,

Nick Jikomeslow density lipoproteins cause atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, pathophysiological, genetic and therapeutic insights, right? A

Tucker Goodrichconsensus statement from the European atherosclerosis society consensus panel. This is a paper we were talking before about references that don't exactly say what you would think they would say. Yeah, as an example, they break down. There's a variety of different oxidized LDLs, pretty complicated particle. There are lots of states of oxidation. Oh, the point that I wanted to mention. So, for instance, the native non oxidized LDL particle will go into the LDL receptor when they get a little oxidized, what's known as a minimally modified LDL particle, they will still go into the LDL receptor right when they get too oxidized, the LDL receptor stops recognizing them, and the scavenger receptor starts

Nick Jikomesrecognizing I see, and this also right so the LDL particle can become oxidized, modified to a degree where the normal LDL receptor just doesn't recognize it anymore. It's not the same thing effectively,

Tucker Goodrichright, right? So now one of the things that will cause an LDL particle to come oxidized is just the normal business of circulating through your bloodstream. So if you have familial hypercholesterolemia and you are not able to remove these LDL particles at the normal rate, you're going to wind up with more oxidized LDL if you're eating the fats that are susceptible to oxidation,

Nick Jikomesbecause you're going to have enough oxygen around, because that's just an obligate part of being us. But what you can control, what may or may not be present, is you have the substrate. Do you have? In this case, the linoleic acid, the polyunsaturated fat that can be oxidized in these LDL particles,

Tucker Goodrichexactly, and that would explain caste lanes paper, where in the late 1800s the mortality rate started going up in these FH populations because people are shooting more PUFAs. Yes, you're eating more of the stuff that is the substrate for excess oxidation in the body. And when the same time

Nick Jikomeswhen that happens, I'm just trying to connect it out here. So when that started. To happen. You've got this subset of people with very high cholesterol levels, high LDL levels, for you know, familiar, familial hypercholesterolemia, people start eating more polyunsaturated fatty acids, and therefore that high amount of LDL circulating in their body starts to get filled with more readily oxidizable linoleic acid, and therefore becomes more oxidized then it stops being recognized by the LDL receptor, goes through these scavenger receptors, and then that gives you to the macrophage over feeding problem. And that's heart disease. Is the next step.

Tucker GoodrichThat's exact, that's exactly right, and that same period of time is when heart disease started a problem. Now, heart disease is something that's probably always been with us. Atherosclerosis is definitely something that's always been with us. But there is what I like to call non pathological atherosclerosis, right? There was a neat study done by George Mann, who is a skeptic of this whole model, looking at the Maasai, a population in Africa who go through a period where they eat exclusively animal products, right, milk, blood and beef, and they had massive atherosclerosis, but no heart attacks.

Nick JikomesSo they had, like the little boils, the little plaques in there.

Tucker GoodrichThey had arteries lined with fat, really, right? But one interesting trait is that their arteries would expand so that even though they were lined with fat, they had the same level of blood flow. They didn't have ischemia. They didn't have the blockage of blood flow to the heart. Causes the heart heart attack.

Nick JikomesBasically, their vessels were still flexible and pliable. They weren't

Tucker Goodrichexactly, okay, exactly. So there is the possibility of non pathological atherosclerosis, as he demonstrated, right? So there were a number of papers that were written back in the night, middle of the 20th century, looking at the increase in atherosclerosis and heart disease, not just in the United States and England, but around the world. And what they discovered was massive discrepancies between I'll summarize it as industrial level, societies that are eating large amounts of industrial foods, one of them being seed oils and heart disease rates. Right? The nice thing about from a epidemiological perspective, is that a heart attack leaves a mark on the heart that's permanent. It's permanent damage, the scarring that occurs. So if you are hit by a bus when you're 85 you're dead. They can go,

Nick Jikomesyeah, doing the number of Yeah,

Tucker Goodrichright. They can do an autopsy and look at your heart and tell that you had not a heart attack at some point in the past prior to getting hit by the bus, because it was healed, right? Yeah. So they did a number of epidemiological studies looking at via autopsy, heart attack rates, mi rates, and they discovered massive discrepancies, both within the United States over time and between different countries. And my favorite paper, they looked at different genetic groups in the United States and in their native countries, right? To see if there was a difference in the immigrant population between you know,

Nick Jikomesright? So the idea would be, you've got a population living somewhere in the world, some of them butt off and go to the US, and it's the same genetic population. But now, do now, do the Harvard environment? Yeah, do the heart disease rates differ,

Tucker Goodrichright? So, fascinatingly enough, I mean the people in the united states with the highest rate of heart disease, you know, to make my point about longitudinal changes inside the United States, the people with the highest rates of heart disease in the United States now is are African Americans. In the 1960s they had half the rate of white Americans, right? Half. But what's fascinating was that when they went to Africa, they did 4500 autopsies, and they found a single heart attack. Right in the US, that rate was 12 and a half percent. For Africans, for white Americans, it was like 21% in Africa, it was effectively zero, right? Wow. Okay, so Africa, you know, to my point of what I think is causing this, Africa, to this day, is still has the lowest rate of seed oil consumption because it's the poorest continent, right? Seed Oil is a highly processed industrial food, right? Um, I got that from Tony Albert's book. I don't know if you've talked to him yet,

Nick Jikomesbut no, I haven't say that book for for people, though. What's the title? It's

Tucker Goodrichcalled the Omega balance. And he's looking at the rate of omega six and Omega three, yeah, balance in the diet and in our membranes. Wow. Great book. So while cardiologists will often say, for instance, they'll, you know, there was a, there was just a study that looked at Egyptian mummies, and they found that the mummies had atherosclerosis. Okay, fine.

Nick JikomesAnd just just remind people, you've already told us the observation from the Messiah that George Mann made, where you could have atherosclerosis without heart disease. So, right? Just showing that atherosclerosis is there is not a guarantee that that meant heart disease, right? But let's say that.

Tucker GoodrichYou know, not every Egyptian was mummified, right, right, right? Let's say that we did just basic study design nowadays. We did a study. And the only people we're trying to figure out what causes heart disease in the United States, and the only people we looked at were billionaires and their families,

Nick Jikomesright? The only we only looked at members of the current presidential administration, like, the most important people get, like, the right? That's who got memorable. Trump's not a billionaire, although he'd like you to think he is. But, I mean, the point is, who got mummified. It was basically important, like, powerful people, yeah, the presidential right? It was the royalty. Yeah, they're not going to be necessarily representative of what's going on in general, right

Tucker Goodrichnow. If you went to any epidemiologist nowadays and said, Oh, I have this study, you know, in your peer review process, and I'm only looking at billionaires, and I'm asking you to extrapolate this out to the entire population of the United States, they would never stop laughing, right? It's a ridiculous idea, right? The better approach now, we can't do epidemiology in ancient Egypt because, you know, they're all dead and long gone, and we have only a tiny sample. So that's not a that's not a valid sample, either of size or of type relative to everybody else. But much more informative is looking at modern populations, where we can apply modern methods and get modern numbers, you know, of statistical samples, and that clearly shows that there was a massive increase occurring in the 20th century in the rates of heart disease, and that it started in the industrial countries and then spread out across the rest of the world, right? And it's still going on, right? Here's the important point. You can still find, well, as of say, 20 years ago or 10 years ago, you could still find populations on earth that had no heart disease,

Nick Jikomesright? And I think what you're about to tell us is they had no heart disease because the seed oils hadn't gotten there yet.

Tucker GoodrichWell, that's what I think, right, but Right, the important thing to note is there are two of these populations, the Kitavans and the chimanei, and I'm sure I'm not pronouncing that correctly, who had no heart disease. They tovens like to smoke. The Chi Minh ate a lot of carbohydrates. They both ate a lot of carbohydrates, right? But neither one of them ate industrial foods, yeah, okay. They didn't have obesity, they didn't have diabetes and they didn't have heart disease. Right now, they're starting to change their diets. I mean, there was a famous case of katavan who moved to a neighboring diet, or a neighboring island. That's a South Pacific Island. He moved to a neighboring island. Started eating an industrial diet, and he got fat, just like anybody else would, right? So it's, again, not a genetic right protection that they have, it's the environment, right? Yeah. So sorry, that was very long but very important detour, and I forgot where I was trying to go in that in that, right? So, oh. So the the interesting thing about both the Catawbas and the chimame is their APO, apo B levels, on average, are higher than that of Americans, and yet their heart disease level is goose egg,

Nick Jikomesyes, so that, I mean, which is exactly the opposite of what you would expect from what's commonly believed April B is supposed to be. You would expect April B levels to correlate tightly with levels of heart disease, right,

Tucker Goodrichright, right. And there's lots of papers about the Chi Minh a and what they eat, and, you know, as they're getting, I mean, one of the funniest correlations I ever saw when they were researching this group is they discovered that in the chime, a obesity was correlated with motor boats. Right? Why? Well, because if you have a motorboat and you live in the Amazon jungle, you can get to a store and. Right by industrial foods, right? And that's what causes obesity, is industrial foods. And then you'll go back to your little village. You know, there are lots of papers done in that, done with them, looking at neighboring groups who had different diets and higher rates of obesity and diabetes and everything else. So, I mean, in my view, it's there's no possibility there are genetic instances of heart disease, no question, yeah, but there's no argument that it's generally a genetic problem, which is ultimately

Nick Jikomesenvironmental, that it's generally an environmental problem.

Tucker GoodrichNo, there's no there's no indication that heart disease is generally a genetic Oh,

Nick Jikomesyeah, it's not, right? It's generally not, yeah, okay, right? Because

Tucker Goodrichgenetically, everybody has APO B, right? And, but not everybody has cardiovascular disease, right?

Nick JikomesSo you've got these examples of these traditional populations that don't have it, as long as they're on the traditional diet, but as soon as they get the industrial diet, they have it. You've got the example of, you know, you can go back and look at the FH families, and before we had these industrial dietary shifts, they weren't dying at higher rates either. So all of these genetic predispositions are really, you know, as with, as with almost anything in genomics, right? They're really defining gene environment interactions and what you see in different environmental contexts,

Tucker Goodrichright? Right. So back to the Boren low density lipoprotein 2020 paper low density lipoproteins cause atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. They also discuss native LDL in there, and how native LDL doesn't seem to be the problem. And they have a neat and

Nick Jikomesso native LDL means unoxidized LDL basically Correct, right?

Tucker GoodrichAnd how that doesn't seem to be the problem. And they have a neat little chart showing ox LDL as the initiating step of LDL. So this is the standard model of cardiology we're talking about here, right? Where I disagree with them is their conclusion, right? And one of the things that they do in this study, which I don't really like, is they so when they first figured out how to oxidize LDL, which is by this copper model in vitro, three things happened to the LDL. It acquired a it became oxidized. It acquired a negative charge, and it tended to clump together. It aggregated right. So they distinguish between those phenomena in here, right? And they had, they sent me down this rabbit hole into one of their citations, where they discussed how aggregated CL, aggregated LDL, is caused by saturated fats. And I was like, Really, let's go look. So they have a model where they can give this saturated component to an LDL particle, and it causes it to aggregate. Okay, fine. They show that. Then they say that this process can be modified. And if you modify the LDL, then it can no longer be aggregated through this saturated fat based lipokine, right lipid signaling model molecule, and you'll never guess what the modification is.

Tucker GoodrichThey take the linoleic acid out of the LDL.

Nick JikomesOh, I see you. This is and this is preventing aggregation. Preventing aggregation. Got it so they say linoleic acid out prevents the problem the aggregation. But you said a moment ago that they were saying that saturated fat was part of the problem here, right, right?

Tucker GoodrichAnd in their model, if you have an LDL particle with linoleic acid in it, and you give it this, you know, saturated fat based signaling molecule, it will aggregate. But if you replace the fats out of the LDL particle and just put oleic acid in there which is not subject to oxidation. That's a monounsaturated fatty acid, right? It will not aggregate, which is exactly the same thing that Steinberg and wisdom demonstrated in the

Nick Jikomesprevious presence of a polyunsaturated fatty acid which can be oxidized is necessary. And sufficient for this aggregation

Tucker Goodrichto happen, is required for the aggregation to happen, right? You can take it

Nick Jikomesout and doesn't happen. You can put it back in. It does happen exactly,

Tucker Goodrichexactly. So all of this, you know.

Nick JikomesSo why did, why did? Why were they saying that saturated fat was needed for the aggregation?

Tucker GoodrichWell, that's where we get into politics. I see right, and the Standard Model, Ancel Keys is proposed. Model is that saturated animal fats, and this is actually a great place to go next, right? Is that saturated animal fats is. So this is a fact. Saturated animal fats generally cause LDL levels to go up, yeah. And since in the 1950s and 1960s they were of the opinion that it was the cholesterol level that was causing this problem, that anything that would cause the cholesterol level to go up would be a be bad, and anything that would cause it to go down would be good, right? Well, it's a fact that, on average, saturated animal fats cause cholesterol levels to go up, and seed oils, polyunsaturated fats cause them to go down. Yes,

Nick Jikomesokay, I wanted to make sure we mentioned this. This is and this is why they're labeled as heart healthy, right. Omega six consumption is generally associated with bringing your LDL levels down,

Tucker Goodrichright, right, right. So why? Why does that happen? Yes, there's a wonderful paper. One of the co authors of boring 2020, Ronald Krauss, wrote a great review of this where you know an LDL particle is produced in the liver. Initially, it's what's known as a VLDL, very low density lipoprotein, and it's very low density because it's full of fat, right? The job of this particle is to liver fat from the liver to the body, right? And then cells take up the fat, use it for whatever they need. And then it becomes an LDL, and it can be taken up by other cells and degraded. You know, if the fat needs some protein, it might take it up and use the protein components. If it needs cholesterol, blah, blah, blah, or it can go back to liver and be disassembled in the liver. So what they discovered is that the reason polyunsaturated fats lower LDL levels is because they impair the production of VLDL right? Most LDL starts as VLDL, and why do they impair? Why do they impair that production? Because the liver won't produce a VLDL particle to send out to the body if it contains oxidized polyunsaturated fats. Right? We're back to the same problem, right? The reason LDL goes down is because the fats are oxidizing in the liver, right? So

Nick Jikomesagain, we're, it's, it's, we're interpreting. It's an interpret. The difference in interpretation here,

Tucker Goodrichoh, well, no, I'm saying I like to think of it as a difference in emphasis, right? Because all these papers present the same facts, right, right, right. It's just they don't emphasize, you know? And then we have the famous problem of emphasis in the cardiovascular cardiovascular literature, in my opinion, is the famous minutes Minnesota coronary survey. Right now, Ansel keys came up with this idea that you know, and convinced the American Heart Association in 1961 that everybody in the country should stop eating animal fats and start eating seed oils, because it lowers LDL. And we think they didn't know. They're quite clear that they didn't know they thought that that would reduce rates of heart disease, right? And then they started doing research projects to prove it right. The biggest research project was known as the National Diet Heart Study. And I mean this, they had the census involved. They had insurance companies involved. They had food companies producing Ultra processed foods where they would replace the animal fats with polyunsaturated fats, apparently, some of which are still on the market today. And the big nationwide study was a dud, right? It didn't produce any meaningful result, and it was hugely expensive, and they decided it wasn't worth continuing. But the most rigorous part of that study is what became the Minnesota coronary

Nick Jikomesexperiment. This is important, yeah, tell

Tucker Goodrichus about this. And it was designed by Ansel keys to prove his hypothesis. Okay, he and a fellow named Ivan France were the two principal investigators in this and it was done in hospitalized guys in Minnesota. Hence the

Nick Jikomesname, obviously. So their diets were controlled.

Tucker GoodrichThey were so well controlled that at the time in Minnesota, this is a great detail from the there's a podcast done on this called the Basement Tapes. It was illegal to serve margarine in a square Patty in Minnesota, right? Because to protect the dairy industry, you had to serve. Margarine as a triangular Patty, so that the person can tell if they were getting margarine or butter. Okay? So in order to do this, well, that would be an obvious break of the blind that they were trying to accomplish between the control arm and the intervention arm, right? So he actually got the legislature in Minnesota to change the law. Wow, that's a diligent study. Wow, right? So that they could have little square margarine patties to give to these guys

Nick Jikomesin the asylums. So anyways, they they're swapping out animal fats for polyunsaturated fats. What's What did they basically find?

Tucker GoodrichThey found that, I mean the most critical finding, and the one that correlates with all the data we've discussed so far, is they found that the greater the effect on lowering cholesterol, the worse the outcome of heart disease was.

Nick JikomesPeople died of heart disease more often, the more we lowered their cholesterol,

Tucker Goodrichthe more we lowered the cholesterol. Yeah, right. So we know from much later research that what polyunsaturated fats lower blood cholesterol because they get oxidized in the liver, and the liver will not secrete

Nick Jikomesthem. You know, to anthropomorphize liver, the liver, right? The Liver. Liver knows it shouldn't be exporting these oxidized LDLs, right,

Tucker Goodrichright? Because part of the liver job is to try, you know, it's to get rid of them. So what did they do with this information? They buried it. They buried it. Literally, literally. The paper was not published until this study ended in 1973 I believe the paper was not published until 19 8916 years later, Ancel Keys didn't sign the paper. He also didn't sign the final paper of his famed Seven Countries Study, one of the concluding sentences with of which was, it may be the oxidized lipids that are causing the problem here, because our hypothesis didn't pan out, because they saw right. He didn't sign that paper. He didn't sign this paper. But by the time that was released in 1989 it was dogma. Right? It was already part of the dietary guidelines. I mean, this

Nick Jikomesis this whole saga. I've written about this many other people have. There's book length treatments on it, like it's just such a good lesson in the human psychology of science and how, you know, at the end of the day, right? Science is not this. Scientists aren't saints, right? They aren't saints. They're human beings with career ambitions and all of the same biases that everybody else has exactly, exactly right? I want to ask you really quick about some stat and stuff to connect some dots, before giving us a few minutes to kind of just flesh things out and get to the one of the high points I want to reiterate, yeah, one point

Tucker Goodrichwe should mention is that the most successful dietary intervention in medicine was something called the Leone Diet Heart Study. And that was the he didn't they did a number of things to try and create a healthier diet, right, some of which have been done in other studies and were not effective. But the one thing he did, which no other study ever did, was reduce the content of linoleic acid in the diet and increase the content of an Omega three fat called alpha linolenic acid. Okay. Now the effect of that we know from later research is to increase the amount of omega three fats and LDL and decrease the amount of omega six fats in LDL, right, it increases the amount of an Omega three fat called EPA, right, which is now an FDA approved treatment called facepa to prevent heart disease, right? But you know that that is, in my view, the proof of concept here that the most successful diet modification for heart disease was lowering linoleic acid and in and that would have the effect of replacing Omega six fats in the particles with omega three fats, right? Which, for other reasons that are probably way outside the scope of this, tend to be less toxic in the body.

Nick JikomesSo we said before, how? So you've got LDL particles, you've got the LDL receptor. You can take LDL out of the bloodstream via the LDL receptor and put it somewhere else. But then we also learned that you can modify LDL particles. You can oxidize them. At some point, they become oxidized enough that the LDL LDL receptor no longer recognizes them. They're recognized by these other scales. Receptors and that connects into the macrophage over feeding stuff that we discussed, I want to ask you about statins now with that in mind, because the way statins are supposed to work is they lower your LDL by changing LDL receptor stuff. But if the LDL receptor only recognizes unoxidized LDL and oxidized LDLs are actually the problem. How do we how do we think about statins here and what's going on? Well,

Tucker Goodrichso here's, here's a really interesting tie in to statins. Joseph Steinberg, who wrote that one of those two papers, or CO wrote one of those two papers that I sent to you, was at the time, one of the most influential cardiologists in the country, and this pharmaceutical company, Merck, sure everybody's heard of them, had this product that they were thinking of not selling into the marketplace. It was the first statin. It was the first statin, and he convinced them to put it on the market. Now, if you're Joseph Steinberg, and you've just demonstrated that the thing that's causing heart disease is a fundamental part of a, a fundamental part of the American diet at that point, and B, something that your profession has been promoting since the 1960s right? It's going to be kind of awkward to come out and say, Guys, we blew it right, but there's a pretty good argument that just lowering the levels of LDL will prevent that oxidation from happening. Right? I think that the reason these PCs, canine mutation people have higher levels of heart or lower levels of heart disease is because the LDL doesn't have the opportunity to become oxidized in the bloodstream, and the FH people have higher levels of heart disease because it does have the opportunity, more chances for that oxidation to happen exactly, exactly. So if you can lower the LDL, it's not an unreasonable thing. Again,

Nick Jikomesyeah, so you're also going to lower oxidized LDL, right?

Tucker GoodrichIt would all and additionally, statins, for reasons I've never seen explained coherently, tend to have an antioxidant effect, right? So it may be what's known as a pleiotropic effect of the drug. Is why it has, yeah, yeah, an effect of I, you know, statins and heart disease is definitely another topic. I would not take a statin

Nick Jikomesmyself, but, but my understanding is that the statins are working primarily by altering LDL receptors, and then they're going to allow LDL receptors to bind to unoxidized LDL and then pull it out of the bloodstream. And that's that's what we're talking about when we say that they lower your LDL levels. But

Tucker GoodrichWell, the only, the only thing that a statin does is it blocks the malevo pathway, which is a precursor to cholesterol production, right? So, or let me rephrase that, that's not the only thing that they do. That's the primary that's why you're given a statin, because it will lower your body's production of cholesterol, it apparently also has these antioxidant levels, antioxidant effects. Up regulating LDL receptors would be an antioxidant effect, got it? Yeah, right, just like with the PCS canine inhibition drugs. So I don't know if for sure, if that's, you know, the relevant pathway. I've done a lot of reading on statins, trying to figure that out, and just haven't really gotten anywhere.

Nick JikomesSo in in a little bit of time we have left, I want to reiterate some things for people and and just kind of get your your high level take on some of this stuff. So you would say it sounds like that. It's possible, it's possible to have high scare quotes, high LDL levels, and not be at greater risk for cardiovascular disease. The reason, I think you would say LDL levels, high LDL levels, can correlate with cardiovascular disease, depends on how much of that LDL is oxidized, right,

Tucker Goodrichright? But there's another component here that I haven't mentioned at all, and that's, or I mentioned briefly, there are two types of APO B, right? Apo b1, 100, which is made by the liver, apo B, 48 which is made in the gut. Okay, when you see a chart in college of the lipoproteins, you will see this big fat chylomicron At one end, and then all these smaller lipid proteins going across right. And they will say that this big one is the APO B 48 and all these other ones are APO B. You. 100 that's wrong. Frank Sachs, one of the most famous cardiologists in the country, wrote a paper looking at the lipoprotein system, and he found that all of those sections can have APO B 48 what right? What APO B 48 does is it delivers oxidized it delivers fat, including oxidized fat, directly from the gut to the body, okay, and the way this pathway works is that it comes, you know, your body absorbs fat in the intestine, it passes it into the lymph system. The lymph system flows through the visceral fat around your gut that I think acts as a filter. It then dumps all of this fat in these chylomicron particles into your circulation just upstream from your heart. So all of that fat is delivered into your heart. Okay? Atherosclerotic lesions can absorb APO B, 48 particles. This has been known for a long time. Rabbits do it too, right? So, I mean, we're going back decades, so we literally have a system. The big one of the big questions in cardiology, in this cardiological model, is, where do, where do the fats get oxidized? Right? Cardiologists will say it's in the atheroma, but there are clear demonstrations that that's not the case. For instance, if you have periodontal disease that will cause a high level of oxidized LDL, and treating the periodontal disease will cause oxidized LDL levels to go down, right? So it's clearly not happening. It's not starting there. But we also have this very important and under analyze pathway of direct production, direct injection of oxidized lipids from the diet into the heart muscle and into the general circulation. And if we go back to borens, 2020, paper, Boren specialty is looking at what he calls triglyceride rich lipoproteins. Those are these APO B, 48 particles that appear across the spectrum of lipoproteins and are delivering oxidized fats. And one of the conclusions of this paper is how that is a much bigger risk than has been realized. And I would say yes, of course, because you're delivering toxins directly into the heart muscle, right? Yeah, an interesting fact that I tried to look up for this and couldn't find the paper, is that most heart attacks occur after a meal post material, and it would make sense that if you go out and, you know, heat a big container of French fries, you're going to get a Big delivery of oxidized fats directly into your circulatory

Nick Jikomessystem, right, right? Wow. So a couple of things I don't think we've said explicitly, but I want to say them and just you can add to this. So everything that we've talked about depends on diet, the composition of your diet, the level of seed oils you're eating, basically the composition of polyunsaturated fatty acids in the LDL particles is going to be sensitive to dietary fat content. And then kind of related to that is we would expect people will say FH, familial hypercholesterolemia, that we should be able to see a very clear relationship between, say, PUFA intake in that particular population and rates of cardiovascular disease. Do we know either of those things? Like, what do we know about how sensitive the PUFA composition of LDL particles are to diet?

Tucker GoodrichIt's entirely controlled by diet? Yeah. I mean, that's, that's what that paper, the Steinberg and wisdom paper,

Nick Jikomesshows, because we can't, because our body can't endogenously produce it like that, right? Diet is the source of variation.

Tucker GoodrichYeah, right. It's the only place it can come from. Yeah. Now the components can vary a little bit, right? Because your body can convert linoleic acid into arachidonic acid, yep. But you know, the body can't make either arachidonic or linoleic acid, whereas it can make something like oleic acid, yeah, yeah, which is neutral fat.

Nick JikomesInterestingly, I just, I just thought of this. I didn't actually think of this ahead of time. So the rate at which people convert linoleic acid to arachidonic acid and longer chain, PUFAs. There's a lot of really interesting and clear genetic variation in the rate at which that happens. And you mentioned earlier that African Americans have a, you know, a very high rate of heart disease in the United States, right? They are, they tend to be, you. Slower converters of linoleic acid to longer chain polyunsaturated fatty acids. So those two things actually fit together. I think

Tucker Goodrichinteresting. Yeah, I know that's more your area of expertise than mine. I know you've got a academic background looking at that sort of thing. I've looked at a couple of different models,

Nick Jikomesbut yeah, there's basically two genotypes in humans, and they vary systematically. You know, based on where your family comes from, you can be a relatively what's called a ready converter of linoleic acid to longer chain PUFAs or or the opposite. It's a difference in rate. It's not like one does it completely and one doesn't do it. But I, for example, I'm like a super converter, I will very readily convert linoleic acid to to the longer chain fatty acids, and

Tucker Goodrichthat means your family has a long history of agriculture, yeah? Basically,

Nick JikomesI know for a fact from genomics that I'm I can trace my roots back all the way to the earliest farmers, right? So that's what you would expect,

Tucker Goodrichyeah, right, which also tells us there's a big selection press pressure. I mean, I know, I saw a paper in India where Indian women tend to have a higher ability to convert short chain polyunsaturated fats to the long chain polyunsaturated fats that are actually essential, and that's posited to be because of, you know, a lack of animal food in the Indian diet, going back 1000s of years, has put on a big selection pressure there.

Nick JikomesYeah, and yeah. So all of that fits. So, okay, so we know that variation in the fat composition of the LDL of the puvas has to come from the diet, because the body's not making these things. That's, that's where we get them. Do we know that? Has there been any work that you're aware of where they look at people with familial hypercholesterolemia and their dietary intake? And have we actually, I mean, there's

Tucker GoodrichDavies George Davies Smith's comment about how FH people have higher rates of heart disease in high fat societies. Yeah, so we don't have that level. Yeah, I haven't read that paper in Castle lanes, paper, you know, talking about the longitudinal difference in mortality, yes, yeah. So that historically doesn't you mentioned us the relationship to fat intake, yeah,

Nick Jikomesbut that historical data that you mentioned earlier, it tracks at that level, like the people with FH only start to tie at higher rates after industrial for

Tucker Goodrichthe same time that the people without FH do, yeah, yeah, yeah. So, yeah, probably the only so, you know, it's been demonstrated that the APO B 47 can go into the atherosclerotic plaque they found in humans, the UN digested April B, 47 molecule in the gruel, right? So that's, that's a clear pathway. That is my guess as to how this oxidation is happening. And, you know, yeah. And the other thing, you know, my emphasis on these points may be different from the average cardiologist, but every single thing is in one of these papers, right, right, right. So again, I don't need to go out to this outside of cardiological literature to make

Nick Jikomesthis emphasizing different components of the stuff that's in all of these papers that everybody looks at, and everybody in this field at least should be aware of, right? But different people have different emphases.

Tucker GoodrichAnd then the funny thing is, you know, your cardiologist won't tell you not to eat seed oils, but he will tell you that you shouldn't eat fried foods,

Nick Jikomesright, right? That's a, yeah, that's a good I've had this discussion with people before too, because every everybody, right? Literally, everybody in my life has always said, well, fried foods are terrible, okay, why? Why?

Tucker GoodrichThey're made from polyunsaturated vegetable oils. That's what you tell us we should eat, right? What happens? Yeah, they get oxygen, yeah. And, of course, for the audience, the answer is, they get oxidized.

Nick JikomesYep. So, so basically, is it fair to say that the mainstream? Let's just define mainstream right now. Let's just be a little careful. I guess the American Heart Association would say omega six polyunsaturated fats are good. They're heart healthy. They would also say omega threes are good, but they would, but they would also, I mean, as you just said, they would also say, Well, don't have fried foods because fried foods are bad, right? And, but that, like, just the if you think about it showing right, it doesn't make sense,

Tucker Goodrichright? Well, that's, that's the problem with the model, is, once you start rigorously trying to understand it, it's got holes and contradictions and inconsistencies in it that make, you know, a whole story fall apart, right? It's not a genetic disease. It's not controlled by APO B levels, it's not controlled by LDL levels. It's not even controlled by cholesterol levels. Oh, that was the thing that I wanted to mention. So. So in trying to re understand cholesterol, it turns out, you know, as I mentioned, cholesterol esters, right? Yep, cholesterol is neutral. Oxidized cholesterol is not neutral. It's toxic also, right? It serves a signaling function in the body, basically a repair function. Oxidized cholesterol is also found in atherosclerotic plaques, as are oxidized fats. So how does the cholesterol get oxidized? Well, the leading hypothesis is, since linoleic acid is 15 times as likely to become oxidized as cholesterol is and they are bound together, the primary cholesterol Ester in the blood is linoleic acid, and cholesterol that the linoleic acid is getting oxidized and is then oxidizing the cholesterol, yeah, yeah. And that's how you're seeing, you know, these oxidized, fat filled pussy lesions,

Nick Jikomesyeah, in your heart. So if oxidized LDL is bad. One would want to lower your oxidized LDL. There's two levers here we can think about one would be lowering the amount of oxidizable stuff, and that would be our dietary modification. Here you want less Omega six PUFAs in that LDL, because that's the thing that can be oxidized. The other level would be the oxidation environment itself. We can't not breathe oxygen. But is there any way? What are all the ways you would lower your oxidized LDL? In theory, one of

Tucker Goodrichthe things that will cause LDL to oxidize is smoking. Yep. Don't smoke,

Nick Jikomesyep. Smoking basically creates a more oxidizing environment, right?

Tucker GoodrichPollution will cause LDL to oxidize, right? Don't live in a polluted area. Lead a gasoline pumps lead into the environment, right? I mean, we don't do that anymore, but that's another way to create massive oxidative stress on your body via oxidized LDL.

Nick JikomesAnd so you mentioned, and I wonder, go ahead,

Tucker GoodrichI will point out that eating omega three fats will cause omega three fats to replace omega six fats in the membrane. So that is another pathway that everybody should pursue, yeah, solely long chain Omega six fats.

Nick JikomesYeah. We often think of the Omega six as the Omega threes. Long chain omega three fats. Sorry, I misspoke. Yeah, we often think about omega threes and Omega six is as separate. People talk about them as separate, but what you're getting at here is they, they interact in a way, like a changing just your Omega three intake or just your omega six intake will actually also affect the levels of the other one in your cells,

Tucker Goodrichto an extent. Yes, to an extent. But the first, the way it works, is the first intervention you need to do is lower Omega six right? That alone can increase omega three levels. Right? Shown in humans

Nick Jikomesand because so many, because of the environment we're in, the majority of people have an overwhelming amount of omega six compared

Tucker Goodrichto Omega three, unless you're trying hard not to Right, right? All right. Reminding me that we're getting to our

Nick JikomesYep, we're close. Let's just, let's just try and tie things together for people a little bit. What are some of the major points you think are worth reiterating here, and it's okay for us to be redundant, let's repeat some of the things that we touched on.

Tucker GoodrichCardiovascular Disease is not genetic primarily, right? Cardiovascular disease has had a massive increase over the 20th century across different countries, depending on how their diets changed and when. And the primary component of the industrial diet that's been shown, which is the diet that's been shown to increase heart disease, the primary component that has been shown to be involved in that increase in heart disease is the linoleic acid from seed oils. And so it would be who view, I think, to alter your diet accordingly.

Nick JikomesAnd because, you know, in the Standard Model of things, we think. I mean literally. People call LDL bad cholesterol and HDL good cholesterol. It sounds like your view would be, no, LDL is not bad cholesterol, period, oxidized LDL is bad cholesterol, that's

Tucker Goodrichright. And the role of HDL is, by the way, to protect us from oxidized LDL, right? It is effective to the extent that it is able to remove oxidized lipids. And if it loses that ability, then it loses its protective effect on the body. So that, you know, we didn't get into that at all, but that buys neatly into this whole system. All

Nick Jikomesright. Well, Tucker, thank you again for your time taking the time before your your trip. I got extra early so that we could do this.

Tucker GoodrichYeah, thank you so much for making this happen. I gotta go pack now. All right, tracking.

Nick JikomesI'll link people to the papers that you sent to me and and they should follow you on Twitter, I guess.

Tucker GoodrichYeah, great. Thanks. Nick, good talking to you. You

Nick Jikomes: visit mind and matter.substack.com. To find all of my content. Hey, everyone, I want to take just a minute to tell you about one of my cool new affiliate partners called Seed Oil scout. Seed Oil Scout has a really cool map feature that helps you find restaurants in your area where you can find seed oil free options. They also have a really cool product scanner, so you can take out the app and use the camera functionality of your phone to scan products in grocery stores and see what's actually in these things. Do they contain seed oils? Do they contain other things that you want to know about that aren't necessarily on the box? This will help you find places to eat and find foods to eat that actually have what you want in them, and help you avoid those that don't. So if you're looking to cut back on your seed oil consumption, or you just want to know more about what's in the foods on the shelves at the grocery stores, download seed oil Scout today. If you go through the link in the episode description, click into that and you'll see a link to the seed oil Scout app. If you go through that link on my support page, you'll be directly helping the podcast, and you'll be able to download this really cool, easy to use app that will help you find healthier food options. So go through the link in the episode description and download seed oil Scout today. Transcribed by https//otter.ai

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Seed Oils, Omega-3s & Lessons From 93 Years of Life | Artemis Simopoulos | 313

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail At 93, Artemis Simopoulos explains why oils once used in paint now dominate the food supply, how a high omega-6 intake slows the making of EPA and DHA, and why cholesterol-lowering corn oil did not...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Tendons, Collagen, mTOR & Exercise Adaptation | Keith Baar | Episode 312

    Nov 10, 20262 hrAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Keith Baar explains why tendons stop adapting after 10 minutes of loading, why long low-load holds beat fast reps for connective tissue, and how vitamin C, collagen, caffeine and mTOR shape training....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. GDF15, Morning Sickness & Mitochondrial Stress | Stephen O'Rahilly | Episode 311

    Nov 3, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Dr. Stephen O'Rahilly explains GDF15, a stress hormone that makes us feel sick and eat less, and why morning sickness, and its severe form hyperemesis gravidarum (HG), comes from GDF15 made by the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Psilocybin vs. SSRIs for Depression, Emotional Blunting & How Psychedelics Work | Robin Carhart-Harris | 310

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 56 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Robin Carhart-Harris explains why his trial of psilocybin therapy vs. the SSRI escitalopram for depression missed one primary measure but favored psilocybin on almost everything else, and why SSRIs can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. This Animal Survives 18 Minutes Without Oxygen | Gary Lewin | 309

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 40 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Nick talks with Prof. Gary Lewin (Max Delbrück Center, Berlin) about naked mole-rats, which in lab tests survived 18 minutes in pure nitrogen by shutting down brain activity, keeping the heart beating,...

    Credit the people on this episode