Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mind & Matter

Mind & Matter artwork

Sweden Avoided Lockdowns and Saw Lower Excess Mortality | Martin Kulldorff | 210

Feb 26, 202538 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Short Summary: Insider’s look at the COVID-19 pandemic response from a seasoned epidemiologist, unraveling myths and lessons with straightforward science. About the guest: Martin Kulldorff, PhD is an epidemiologist and biostatistician with decades of experience in infectious disease monitoring and vaccine safety. He was formerly a professor at Harvard Medical School. Note: Podcast episodes are fully available to paid subscribers on the M&M Substack. Partial versions are available elsewhere. Full transcript and other information on Substack. Episode Summary: Dr. Martin Kulldorff discusses the COVID pandemic response, reflecting on the controversial Great Barrington Declaration, which opposed lockdowns in favor of protecting the vulnerable. They explore the virus’s fatality rates, asymptomatic spread, and vaccine efficacy, contrasting textbook epidemiology with real-world decisions. He critiques institutional failures, like the CDC’s misleading claims. He shares optimism for future pandemics with better leadership and public awareness. Key Takeaways: Lockdowns ignored basic public health principles, causing collateral damage like missed cancer screenings, while Sweden’s focused protection approach led to lower excess mortality. Early data showed COVID’s risk was 1000x higher for older people, yet lockdowns didn’t prioritize them, unlike textbook strategies. Asymptomatic spread made containment impossible, unlike Ebola, where isolation works due to clear symptoms. Natural immunity was downplayed despite 2500 years of evidence, leading to wasted vaccines on those already immune. CDC falsely claimed vaccines stopped transmission, eroding trust when people got sick anyway, fueling vaccine skepticism. mRNA vaccine boosters lack proper trials, and their long-term effects need rigorous study, not assumptions. Kulldorff’s new Journal of the Academy of Public Health pushes open peer review to rebuild trust in science. Related episode: M&M #100: Infectious Disease, Epidemiology, Pandemics, Health Policy, COVID, Politicization of Science | Jay Bhattacharya *Not medical advice. Support the show Support my work: Good Chemistry: Personalized, science-based health consulting. Work with Dr. Nick Jikomes directly. Affiliate Partners: Visit this link to see my affiliate partners and get discounts codes for products & services to support health. For all the ways you can support my efforts.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Drugs or ideas, what you consume influences who you become. On the Mind and Matter Podcast, we learn together from the best scientists and thinkers alive today about how your mind body reacts to what you feed it.

Before starting Mind and Matter, I spent 10 years in academia doing scientific research. I got a PhD in neuroscience where I focuseded on neuroendocrinology and the neurobiology of behavior and before that I specialized in molecular, developmental and evolutionary genetics. I use my scientific background to help parse and translate the information that guests share on the podcast. In addition to the podcast, I write long form written content inspired by the show where I integrate what I've learned across episodes. I also have a free weekly newsletter where I provide you with upcoming guests, share links and provide commentary on scientific studies and research that I'm reading and more.

Visit Mind and Matter.subst야지 Welcome back to the podcast for the second time.

Thank you so much. It's the great pleasure. Yeah, I really wanted to talk to you again. I talked I talked to you back in early 2022, I believe, which was very much the before we've all lived through the COVID era.

We're in the sort of new phase of the pandemic and how we deal with it and people have had three more years of experience, personal experience and lots of new evidence, lots of new things to discuss. But I just wanted to touch base at first. Do you want to remind people who you are to get us started and just talk a little bit about your background as an epidemiologist? Well, I'm an epidemiologist and a three years ago.

And at that time for those who don't remember, at that time, and maybe even today, still to this day for some people, you were kind of considered a controversial character. Will you talk a little bit about why that was and why people perceived you to be somewhat controversial at the time? Well, I think that's true. Maybe not so much anymore, but I so in I think we're back five years in 2020 where the country was closing schools and doing lockdowns and people weren't going to the hospitals when they were supposed to, because they were afraid of COVID etc. That was not done according to the basic principles of public-the-cels or just the way they were.

So most of my colleagues that I worked with the epidemiologist, they did not agree with those lockdowns that Anthony Fauci and Barbara Brooks and others in post-d this. So most of your colleagues, most of the people with your background, epidemiologists who studied this stuff, didn't agree with the way-things were going even though they weren't, a lot of people weren't saying that publicly though, right? That's true and I tried to say I was able to do so in my native Sweden, I published in the major daily newspapers there, but in the US I was, I failed until August when I finally was I was able to publish something about school closures, CNN, but not the CNN that you think, it's CNN Espanol, I know how to write Spanish after you're okay.

If I can't publish in English, I leave it in Spanish. So it has been in Spain published a piece where I was arguing that Sweden did the right to go to school, so we should open all the schools. CNN in English were not interested in it. In October of 2020, together with Dré J. Barachaya at Stanford University and Dr. Sunateguk, at Oxford University, and at the time I was a professor at Madison at Harvard University, we wrote one page thing that's called the great, great-barring to declaration, where we argue that we shouldn't have done society, we should do much more to protect older people because they are the high risk of dying from COVID, so we didn't, you were not doing enough to protect our all people, but then we were closing schools, which is very harmful貌 for we were closing down society, which people are not getting the cancer treatment or cancer streaming they need.

They were increased problems with cardiovascular disease, that were not properly treated, people were dying at home instead of going to the hospitals, probably with diabetes care, mental health, of course very much so the list is sort of long of all those other aspects of our country that we ignored to our detriment. The only country that sort of opposed these lockdown philosophy was Sweden and we now know that during the pandemic Sweden had the lowest excess mortality among major western countries, so it's clear that Sweden's the right approach to focus protection on all people by letting children go to schools and having younger kids. That is literally textbook epidemiology, even though you are in the world of the pandemic, that was basically what people were recommending, you can't just close down society because it has such enormous negative consequences for collateral damage on public health.

When I think back to the early pandemic the first year or two, one of the things, so obviously when this, at the very very beginning, everything was mysterious, this new virus was spreading, I remember that people thought it could be potentially quite deadly.

I think the World Health Organization was saying the IFR, was 3, 4, 5%, maybe even higher. At some point, a man who at least you're familiar with John Ionitis, very well, well known in the Commission, he had a paper come out, he predicted the IFR was actually much, lower, and that caused a lot of controversy at the time. Do you remember that episode and do you talk a little bit about how deadly the virus is and what we know about that right to date?

That's called infection fatality rate, which means, if that is your infection, it was the probability of dying. It's true that in the early pandemic, there were uncertainty about that. But what was not uncertainty about was the relative risk, comparing different people. So, so back in February March of 2020, I did some calculations just by hand based on the Wuhan data.

We could see them that who died and there was mostly older people. So, but these calculations then I found that the risk of dying, for anybody can get infected, so from the very, very, very beginning we knew that one, there was a huge difference in risk by age, so that was the most important risk factor. And two, two children and young people, and you write that John Y. Y. D. as well as Dr. J. Bonachaya and Stanford did what's called a zero prevalence study.

They knew how many people had died, but they didn't know how many people were infected. So they did a survey where the take a blood test to look at the zero prevalence to see, have you been infected or not? To find out what the risk was of dying. And for some very strange reason that became extremely controversial, with volunteers and all kinds of things. But that was the job of CDC to quickly do that surveys in different parts of the country and do it like, week by week and month by month to see how many people were affected.

And they completely completely failed in their time. So I mean, you would have expected the CDC to do a big study like that because there was uncertainty. And this major pandemic we were going through, you would think, just come and sense that they want to get very robust, very robust data from a large-scale study. And then I call when some of the things that were coming out, they were saying infection fatality rate was lower than many, and they were already been coming out. And for some reason, this was causing controversy.

People didn't, some people didn't like the idea that the number they were coming up with was much lower. In other words, that the pandemic was going to be less deadly for most people than other estimates were implying. So the only thing that was going to happen is that some of these studies were not taken to account that there were many asymptomatic people who were infected but we didn't realize it because they.

Can you talk a little bit more about how prevalent asymptomatic spread of this virus actually is? 100% correct. So people were mixing mixing up infection fatality rate versus case fatality rate. So if you have a case means that you are diagnosed, you have some symptoms that may be serious enough to go see the doctor. And they have some symptoms but they never go see the doctor.

So they never a official case of the disease. So obviously the case fatality rate is always larger than the infection fatality rate. And they was sort of confusing these two numbers and treating the case fatality rate as the risk of dying from this disease if you were infected, which was not the case. So that's why there was a confusion we know that there are asymptomatic infections and there are more among young people people. But I haven't seen that reliable number exactly how much time.

Although it's not as dangerous. But so somebody can be asymptomatic the first time but then have symptoms the second time or so on. Yeah and you know one of the things I think you emphasized well is the fact that you get that A, this virus is quite contagious but also that it can spread it from asymptomatic people right. I might have the virus. I don't have symptoms and then you know you catch it from me but neither of us realizes that I'm even sick because I don't have symptoms. It's actually that reason why your position and the position that you that it's a lot of to be able to check it. And that meant that it was very obvious to me and to other infectious diseases that it was impossible to contain this disease. It was spread sooner or later to all parts of the world which is exactly what happened. And that's not strange because influenza is the same. It's sort of spread throughout the world and it's impossible to sort of contain.

But some cases of Ebola in the US and that's a very serious disease and people have symptoms when they get infected. So there is a situation where you want to isolate those people who have a ball so they don't spread it to others and then you do what's a contact tracing you see who did they meet with you have want to check if they were infected and then if they are infected you want to isolate them too. So contact a contact tracing and isolation of individuals is important and so, so contact tracing and isolation of individuals is important for a disease like Ebola because it's very symptomatic and it's very deadly because it's very symptomatic and it's very deadly. Yeah, but to do contact tracing and isolation for COVID is hopeless because so many people without symptoms.

Yeah symptoms are very mild symptoms. So just like influenza we cannot sort of suppress it. There was a movement like called it zero COVID. We wanted to eliminate COVID. But that's impossible. So that just create a lot of collateral damage without any any the prospect of success. Yeah, so because it's not possible to contain and get down to zero for something that contagious that can spread asymptomatically.

And because it's inevitable that there will and it's not something comes you hanker down during a few days and then the hurricane is over and you can come up and the resume normal life.

But the infectious disease doesn't operate that if you hanker down for a while it might maybe it could hold it off for a while but as soon as you just come up again and it was spread. Yeah, the hurricane is going to come up in a matter of what you're not that preventive. Yeah, another thing I want to ask you about in terms of like textbook epidemiology and immune biology is like historically. So so obviously what, what happened with this pandemic is the virus started spreading.

And then we introduced these new COVID vaccine like technologies, these new mRNA shots during the pandemic while we were still in the midst of a pandemic. Historically, is that the way that that things have been done when we come up with vaccines where historically what happens when you have a new vaccine, do you want to or is it advisable to do that during a pandemic or do you normally wait until after the pandemic has stopped spreading on its own. No, if you can get a vaccine during the pandemic best good. Okay, so I think there were every reason to try as hard as possible to develop vaccines.

No, there are problems with how that how that happened, but the principle of just trying to get a vaccine better think is is good and you want to do this quickly as possible. Some people have argued that when you roll out a vaccine like that in the midst of a pandemic that spreading very widely, it creates evolutionary pressure for novel variance of the virus to evolve that can escape the vaccine induced immunity.

Do you have do you have thoughts on that and whether or not that can happen. I think that could potentially happen, but I don't think it's an argument against trying to develop a vaccine. And so obviously the lockdowns also can change those things because that can sort of force mutations to new mutations and sort of new mutations of the new variants of the vaccine or the virus. So lockdowns can also have that impact on the virus.

The other thing I want to talk about is natural versus vaccine induced immunity and obviously we can talk about COVID stuff, but I want to ask you about this in more general terms. Can you talk just a little bit about the difference between natural and vaccine induced immunity. What are those two things and in general, do most vaccines produced an immune response that's very comparable-c? What you to have on infection acquired immunity or national immunity for about 2,500 years since 430 BC during the Athenian play is described.

So that's about the same amount of time as we have known, there's not flat but like a sphere around. This is all knowledge that we have immunity to disease once we have recovered. Now, the vaccine is sort of trying to mimic that natural immunity without having to have the disease without risk of dying.

So it's sort of mimic your, it's triggering your own immune system through reacting great immunity. Yeah, and I suppose I mean it makes a lot of sense. To the extent you can mimic that response, you'll get immunity which is good and you're also, you don't have the downside risk that a disease can have which is that it could really, really permanently damage or even kill you. Right. And a good vaccine will give you almost as good immunity as infection acquired immunity.- Samar close, fall from close but you would never expect infection acquired immunity or vaccine acquired immunity to to be superior to infection and acquired immunity. That will be astonishing if that happened.

That makes, that makes, that makes, that makes, that should make intuitive sense, right? Because you know, the way that vaccines work once you dig into the details, they're rarely going to expose you, to all of the antigens and components of the natural bug and therefore their immune response would never be expected to to exceed the what you would get from a natural infection. Is that the idea? So, and among the vaccines that we have, some of them are good and some of them are less as less efficacy.

But during the pandemic it was very strange to have the CDC director or colleagues or minor at Harvard who were questioning infection acquired immunity, who basically' who were basically questioning 2.5 thousand years of science to acknowledge, and to claim that the vaccine and claims that vaccine provided superior immunity. So this whole idea or that those who had that had recovered in this very strange.

If you have a vaccine, let's say you are the biggest vaccine supporter in the world. Then you don't want to vaccinate the people, the all that have acquired immunity because you want to use those vaccines for people, actually need it. So we were basically wasting, vaccines, vaccines, but by mandating vaccines to people, what all of the had, COVID, we were wasting vaccines so people didn't need it for just an inefficient use of resources.

Yeah, well there were people like including my 87 year old neighbor who had been vaccinated, many other older Americans as well as older people around the world, India, Nigeria, Mexico, Brazil and so on, who had not had it because there were short supply of vaccines. So we were not distributing the vaccines using them in an ethical manner, and I would argue that if you already had the COVID, it was an ethical to force them to be vaccinated.

Because it meant less vaccines for those who really needed it. I'm not sure if you're going to be able to do that. Yeah, so not only is there an opportunity cost there, you are giving vaccines to people who already have natural immunity, who�have a lot of things.

For example, I will be able to do that. But I have not received the meatless vaccine ever. The reason is I had meatless as a child before the vaccine was available. So there's no reason for me to be vaccinated. And then I was established medical knowledge for a long time, but then during the pandemic, we suddenly forgot about evidence based medicine or some people that had CDC and FDA the FDA and the FDA and the Anthony Fauci and so on.

So I was like, well, I'm not sure if I was able to do that. I was like, well, I'm not sure I was able to do that. We're already well established. They clearly knew this thing because this is basic science.

I think the argument was different opinions in that group, but I think the argument was that the public is too stupid to understand these things. So it's better to tell everybody to get vaccinated. I think that's actually counterproductive because people are actually smart. When they saw that they were managing vaccine to people who clearly didn that has generated an enormous hesitation and skepticism towards other vaccines that are recommended.

If the CDC and NIH can't get this one right about the COILA vaccine, which is-very simple forcing people to take the vaccine when it is not needed, how can you trust them about other vaccines? That's a very national thing to ask.

So by not talking to the public in real terms, by not saying, hey, this is what we actually know.

That messaging approach may-have inadvertently generated more skepticism and more distrust than just being being open and honest would have. I definitely think so. They are the vaccine specialists. Those are the cause, I think, of the vaccine hesitancy that we see now. I don't blame people who start questioning what CDC have said about other vaccines because they clearly lied about the COIL vaccine. Of course, people should be skeptical about other things that CDC says.

But not the mean that CDC is always wrong because, for example, when CDC says you shouldn't smoke, well, that's very very wise. Just very wise advice.

I'm thinking in new ways and questioning what we've been told and what's going on and what's true and what's not true is, you know, I actually got, you know, at the time in 2021, I decided to get the first to COVID shots. I got the two dose Pfizer shots. I had not been sick. I knew already. And that was just the decision I made at the time for better or for worse. But then just if you know, when my view started to- when I started to have questions and really start thinking in a different way was just a few months months I mean, I remember very clearly people on the news, the CEO of Pfizer, people at health institutions saying, you know, this vaccine is highly effective at stopping infection.

nd you definitely won't get infected if you get it. And then I got it anyway. And so I thought, huh, why did that happen? No, you're right. The CDC director of Russian level, I was saying very clearly that if you take the vaccine, you can look at COVID and that was not true. And they also said that if you take the vaccine, you can spread COVID and that's not true either. So those were an untruthful statement that CDC told the public. But at that time did they know that wasn't true and they said it anyway, or did they they think it might be true based on the evidence at the time?

When early 2021, we did not know whether the COVID would, to what extent the COVID would prevent the disease. We actually knew very little from the randomized trials, which is the gold standard of scientific or medical research. We knew that it reduced symptomatic infection by 95% of the disease. But the randomized trials, which is the gold standard of scientific or medical research, we knew that it reduced symptomatic infection by 95% during the first few months after vaccination.

But there were the studies, the randomized studies were not designed to determine whether it reduced mortality or not or whether it reduced hospitalization from COVID or not. So we didn't even know that and they should of been designed to evaluate mortality because to be quite honest, I think that the people who are the randomized trials, most young people survive whether they are vaccinated or not.

If they wanted to look at mortality, if this vaccine prevents mortality, they should have it reduced mostly older people. But they did not, they should have it reduced mostly young people. So the type of important lesson there is that the result you get in a study depends very heavily on how the studies is designed.

And so they should have continued the trials to see if what was the long terms, both long term, long term efficacy as well as the long term adverse reactions, all the the vaccine. So I don't think that the randomized, the randomized, which is good, that's very very good, but they were not properly designed to actually answer the important questions. And in fact, in others, we don't know if the vaccine could actually help prevent transmission, but they could also increase transmission actually.

So that's impossible to know ahead of time. For example, suppose you have a vaccine that just reduces the symptoms. Yeah. Well, then instead of staying at home in bed, you're going to be out and about at work or at the pub or of playing volleyball or whatever you do. other than that, you might actually spread it more because you don't have as many symptoms. So, so if the vaccine reduces symptoms, it could be theoretically that it spreads more because because you are out and about more rather than being.

that it would reduce transmission. And those claims were based on nothing. And it could go in either direction. So, so there was no evidence supporting that claim. It could have been true, but no one actually acquired the evidence that showed that. You can actually, you can actually study that because they could have looked at the so some people randomized to the placebo and some to the vaccine.

They could have looked at the spouses of them to what possible extent, but they affected or they could look at the neighbors or or work colleagues or or others. to to check transmission, but so it's it's possible to do that as part of the right on my my trial, but they decided not to study that question. What do we so what's your understanding like today based on all the evidence that we required so far about how effective the mRNA vaccines from Pfizer and Moderna, or substack or visit my YouTube page to get the full episode.

Hey everyone, I want to take just a minute to tell you about an app I am partnering with called Readwise. Readwise is an app that organizes and helps you get the most out of your digital highlights. I use it to organize all the highlights I make in my digital books on my Kindle. And so if you're like me and you make a lot of highlights and you like to revisit them often to refresh your memory, Readwise is the perfect app. You can also take photos of any physical books you've highlighted and upload those. It also has cool features that allow you to share your favorite highlights and quotes from books on social media and it syncs with note-taking apps like ever note, notion and Rome.

You can tag, search and organize your notes and highlights on Readwise and it helps you connect ideas in new ways and retain more of what you read. So if you click the link in the episode description, you can get Readwise for free for two months when you sign up for their annual plan. That plan is only $7.99 per month and it's a relatively new app. So they're adding new features often and if you sign up for the annual plan today, you can lock in that price, which will stay at $7.99 even if the price increases in the future as they add more. So if you do a lot of highlighting and note-taking and you want a good way to organize all that information, check out the link in the episode description.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Seed Oils, Omega-3s & Lessons From 93 Years of Life | Artemis Simopoulos | 313

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail At 93, Artemis Simopoulos explains why oils once used in paint now dominate the food supply, how a high omega-6 intake slows the making of EPA and DHA, and why cholesterol-lowering corn oil did not...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Tendons, Collagen, mTOR & Exercise Adaptation | Keith Baar | Episode 312

    Nov 10, 20262 hrAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Keith Baar explains why tendons stop adapting after 10 minutes of loading, why long low-load holds beat fast reps for connective tissue, and how vitamin C, collagen, caffeine and mTOR shape training....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. GDF15, Morning Sickness & Mitochondrial Stress | Stephen O'Rahilly | Episode 311

    Nov 3, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Dr. Stephen O'Rahilly explains GDF15, a stress hormone that makes us feel sick and eat less, and why morning sickness, and its severe form hyperemesis gravidarum (HG), comes from GDF15 made by the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Psilocybin vs. SSRIs for Depression, Emotional Blunting & How Psychedelics Work | Robin Carhart-Harris | 310

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 56 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Robin Carhart-Harris explains why his trial of psilocybin therapy vs. the SSRI escitalopram for depression missed one primary measure but favored psilocybin on almost everything else, and why SSRIs can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. This Animal Survives 18 Minutes Without Oxygen | Gary Lewin | 309

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 40 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Nick talks with Prof. Gary Lewin (Max Delbrück Center, Berlin) about naked mole-rats, which in lab tests survived 18 minutes in pure nitrogen by shutting down brain activity, keeping the heart beating,...

    Credit the people on this episode