Send us Fan Mail The brain's mysterious claustrum region, its role in cognitive flexibility, and how substances like alcohol and psychedelics affect neural circuits and behavior. Not medical advice. TOPICS DISCUSSED: Cerebral cortex structure: Described as a six-layered structure with pyramidal neurons and inhibitory interneurons; information flows between layers and regions to process sensory input and enable complex behaviors. Claustrum anatomy & connectivity: A sheet-like subcortical structure embedded in white matter, bidirectionally connected to cortical areas, especially prefrontal regions in rodents, with broader connections in primates and humans suggesting an integrative role. Claustrum function in cognition: Experiments show claustrum activation during task switches from easy to demanding modes, synchronizing cortical networks via inhibition and rebound excitation, potentially enabling flexible behavior. Mouse models in neuroscience: Mice are used for genetic tractability to manipulate and monitor specific circuits, revealing claustrum’s role in vigilance tasks but not simple ones. Alcohol’s effects on brain circuits: Chronic alcohol promotes inflexible behaviors by altering striatal interneurons and inhibitory inputs, leading to compulsive drinking despite aversive consequences. Psychedelics & brain networks: Psilocybin disrupts default mode and other networks, inhibits claustrum via serotonin 1B receptors, with effects persisting 24 hours, possibly contributing to therapeutic benefits. Evolution of claustrum: Connectivity expands from rodents to humans, shifting from cognitive-specific to broader network control, including anti-correlated states like default mode versus task-engaged. Integration of claustrum & basal ganglia: Claustrum funnels prefrontal signals to basal ganglia for action selection; alcohol may impair this, exacerbating inflexibility in addiction. ABOUT THE GUEST: Brian, PhD is a professor in the Department of Pharmacology and Physiology at the University of Maryland School of Medicine, where he leads a neuroscience lab studying brain circuits underlying flexible and inflexible behaviors using mouse models, with a focus on alcohol use disorder. Support the show Support my work: Good Chemistry: Personalized, science-based health consulting. Work with Dr. Nick Jikomes directly. Affiliate Partners: Visit this link to see my affiliate partners and get discounts codes for products & services to support health. For all the ways you can support my efforts.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Nick Jikomesfood, drugs, or ideas, what you consume influences who you become. On the Mind & Matter podcast, we learn together from the best scientists and thinkers alive today about how your mind-body reacts to what you feed it. Before starting Mind & Matter, I spent 10 years in academia doing scientific research. I got a PhD in neuroscience, where I focused on neuroendocrinology and the neurobiology of behavior, and before that, I specialized in molecular, developmental, and evolutionary genetics. I use my scientific background to help parse and translate the information that guests share on the podcast. In addition to the podcast, I write long-form, written content inspired by the show, where I integrate what I've learned across episodes. I also have a free weekly newsletter where I provide you with upcoming guests, share links and provide commentary on scientific studies and research that I'm reading, and more. Visit mindandmatter.substack.com to find all of my content.
Nick JikomesYou are about to listen to the full episode, but there will be one to two short ads immediately following this before the conversation. If you would like to hear ad-free episodes and get early access before they release more widely, become a paid subscriber at the Mind & Matter substack at mindandmatter.substack.com. Becoming a paid subscriber is a way to directly support my efforts, allowing me to make more episodes and higher quality episodes. and also helping to free up my time so that I can spend more of it on doing research and synthesizing results from the podcast and from the literature so that I can do more things like writing on the Substack, putting more content into the newsletter, and getting these things out more frequently. So if you want to support the show and get ad-free episodes, go to mindandmatter.substack.com. Hey everyone, I'm going to take just a minute to tell you about SporesMD, your trusted source for premium mushroom products designed for research and educational purposes. At sporesmd.com you can discover pharmaceutical grade mushroom liquid cultures featuring dozens of unique strains of psilocybe mushroom species ideal for microscopy studies and mycology enthusiasts.
Nick JikomesThey also offer culinary liquid cultures for gourmet mushroom enthusiasts plus innovative options like nootropic scummies and amanita muscaria tinctures, all produced in ISO 7 certified clean rooms with rigorous testing for viability, sterility, and purity. With a 100% satisfaction guarantee, SporesMD ensures high-quality products free from contaminants and without traces of controlled substances. Whether you're interested in scientific exploration or simply curious about the fascinating world of fungi, SporesMD provides reliable tools to support your interests, always in compliance with applicable laws. Head to sporesmd.com today and use the discount code TRICOMES, T-R-I-C-O-M-E-S, for 20% off your purchase today.
Nick JikomesSo go to sporesmd.com check out what they have. Thanks for having me, Nick. Do you want to start off by just telling everyone a little bit about who you are and what your lab studies?
Brian MathurSure. I'm a professor in the Department of Pharmacology and Physiology at the University of Maryland School of Medicine in Baltimore. And I run a basic neuroscience lab. where we use mice as an animal model to study how aberrations in different circuits give rise to flexible versus inflexible behavior in different contexts. And those contexts typically are in health and in the context of alcohol use disorder.
Nick JikomesCan you just talk a little bit about, at a pretty high level, why do you use mice in a neuroscience lab like this, especially when you're interested in things like alcohol use disorder, which are going to be applied to humans at the end of the day? What is good about mice in terms of how useful they are and why they're a preferred model organism for some people?
Brian MathurYeah, before I go into that, I should say that we collaborate with human neuroimagers too, which we'll probably get into a bit later. But yeah, it's important that we study mice and we do that for a very specific reason. They are proven to be more genetically tractable than other model organisms, mammalian model organisms. And because they are mammals, they have circuitry that looks very similar to human brains, as far as we know how that's constructed.
Brian MathurAnd they can perform tasks, not quite as well as some other mammals like rats or monkeys, but we can do a lot more in terms of neurons specifically going in and targeting, manipulating, and monitoring specified circuits to relate that activity to behavior.
Nick JikomesYeah, so people might actually be a little surprised. Mice can do fairly sophisticated things. They can figure stuff out, everything from navigating mazes to solving fairly simple puzzles. But they can do fairly cognitively sophisticated things. And as you said, They're genetically tractable, so we can manipulate their neurons. We can look at individual neurons in certain parts of the brain. You can manipulate those neurons, control what they're doing. And so you can really go in and tinker with the system in ways that help you disentangle what it's actually doing.
Nick JikomesThat's exactly right. And we're going to talk about the cerebral cortex and some interesting and maybe special parts of the cortex in mammals. But let's give people a sense for the cerebral cortex and its sort of canonical structure. So you mentioned that mice have circuits and structures in their brains that look very similar to ours and other mammals. Can you paint a basic picture for us of the basic cytoarchitecture of the cerebral cortex, in particular, the sort of layered structure it tends to have. So people have a sense for just what that basic structure looks like and what we generally think about in terms of like the basic information flow within the cortex.
Brian MathurSure, so the isocortex, also called neocortex, is a six-cell layered structure in both mouse and human brains. And it has specific inputs and outputs from that structure and also specific connections within the cortex and across different areas of cortex. There are both projection neurons that are the so-called pyramidal neurons because they have a pyramidal shape, but also inner neurons as well. And these inner neurons are typically GABAergic in nature, so they inhibit other neurons, including these pyramidal neurons.
Brian MathurAnd the projection neurons themselves are glutamatergic, so they'll activate other cell types within the cortex and outside of the cortex.
Nick JikomesYeah, so the cerebral cortex, so the wrinkly, when you look at the human brain, the wrinkly outer part, if you were to look at that and zoom in, there are literally like layers to it. I guess maybe a crude analogy would be like, if you think about the soil outside, you've got the topsoil and then you keep going down and it kind of changes in terms of the size of the layers, how thick they are. the density and the pattern of connections of the cells within that layer, but there are literally six layers that we often refer to in the cerebral cortex and information flows within and between these layers and characteristic ways based on, you know, the, the anatomical pattern of the cells within that layer.
Brian MathurAbsolutely. And I think importantly, uh, different areas of cortex have different functions. Um, that a wide variety of functions anywhere from processing different sensory modalities like vision or audition or somatosensation to more higher order, more complex encoding of rule sets in variables that seem more abstract that allow us to perform complex things.
Nick JikomesYeah. And so is the basic sort of crude idea here that know, information's being sent from one part of the brain to another, maybe one part of the cortex to another part of the cortex, and that's flowing within and between these layers in a given brain region. And the basic, basic idea, I guess, would be that some information, say, about the visual world goes into the visual cortex, might go into one layer and that layer might do a particular transformation. Maybe it filters some stuff out and then it goes to the next layer. And then maybe that layer does a different transformation. Like maybe it exaggerates or increases the gain on certain features it might care about like edges or something like that and so on and so forth. So as you go between regions and between the layers within one region, these different sort of computational transformations happen that end up being important for stitching together what we ultimately perceive in our conscious awareness.
Brian MathurAbsolutely. Yeah. I couldn't have said it better.
Nick JikomesAnd so there's different parts of the brain, visual cortex, auditory cortex. There's other parts that probably handle more sophisticated or abstract things. We can talk about the frontal cortex or the parietal cortex, thinking about where things are in space, all of these things. And then obviously there's parts like the motor cortex that are going to handle the outputs that go to our muscles to control the body. There's a number of regions we could talk about, but you study a region that's sort of really interesting and I think probably relatively poorly understood and maybe a little bit more exotic in terms of the fact that most people haven't heard about it, I don't think. And that's called the claustrum. So where is the claustrum in the head? Let's just start there.
Nick JikomesWhere in the brain is the structure?
Brian MathurVery simply, it's right in the middle, but it's in the telencephalon, which is the forebrain, right? And it sits subcortically. So it's underneath these layered cell structures that we were just talking about and resides in a very difficult to access part of the brain. So essentially this is a subcortical region, a gray matter structure, which means it has cell bodies to it. that lies within white matter structures. So it's embedded within axon tracks that are going to and from the cortex. And so it's this sheet of brain matter sort of centrally sitting in the telencephalon that connects to many different areas of the cortex, projecting to different areas of the cortex, but also receiving projections from different areas of the cortex. And it's long been thought to Well, it's been a very mysterious structure, and the reason for that is this weird anatomy that I was just referring to.
Brian MathurIt's hidden within these white matter structures, and that has led to technical issues with determining its function. So it's shaped like a sheet, like I mentioned. It's not spherical in its shape like other brain regions, like the amygdala, for instance. So that's made it very difficult to go in and lesion this structure and say, what happens to the brain? What happens to behavior when we don't have the claustrum? Because when you go in and you lesion, it makes a spherical hole in the brain. And that hole will incorporate white matter structures that are surrounding the claustrum. which may be projecting to different areas of the cortex or subcortical regions or brainstem that have nothing to do with the claustrum at all.
Brian MathurSo it's been very difficult to interpret lesions of the claustrum as relates to behavior. The data is kind of all over the place. But with the advent of modern neuroscience techniques that really started to take off in the early part of the century, 2005 really, we've been able to tease apart these different circuits that are coming into and out of the claustrum using modern approaches and come to a better understanding of what the structure does.
Brian MathurSo the brief history of the claustrum is that we knew that it was connected to the cortex and lots of areas were connected to it. And that gave rise to several functional hypotheses of this structure that didn't really have functional data to back it up. And so that brought us to about 2005 when a very influential paper came out by Francis Crick, the co-discoverer of the structure of DNA. He later became a very influential theoretical neuroscientist in the latter part of his life.
Brian MathurAnd going off the principles in biology of structure leads to function or form follows function, he hypothesized that because the claustrum is sort of centrally located in the telencephalon and has these connections out to many parts of the cortex and many parts of the cortex projecting it, that it could be subserving a sensory integration role and might be solving this quote, binding problem that exists in the brain. How do we stitch together information from different sensory modalities to make sense of the world, to make a unified conscious perception of the world? And so that's what his idea was.
Brian MathurAnd he had this very influential paper with co-author Christophe Koch. And the idea there was that the classroom is involved in the generation of conscious percepts. So that ignited the field, or reignited the field, but at the same time it tagged the claustrum with the c-word, consciousness, which has led to both interest and dismay in the neuroscience field, because understanding consciousness is equivalent to understanding the universe. It's very difficult to tackle and conceptualize.
Nick JikomesRight, right. So a few important things going on here. One, the Klaustrum has been famous for some time because Francis Crick was talking about it. He was talking about it in very, you know, he thought it might be a very important structure for some of the more, you know, sexy parts of the brain that people want to understand consciousness being one of them. It's got this really interesting anatomical connectivity pattern. It's connected to lots of different structures. So this automatically makes one think, okay, if it's connected to many different things, maybe it's got some sort of integrative role. It's binding things together.
Nick JikomesThere's lots of things you might theorize from that kind of anatomical structure, but at the same time, It's at kind of this weird and awkward location in the brain. It's a subcortical structure, so it's beneath the cortex as you travel outside into the brain. It's tucked down there. It's not a well isolated little sphere or circle that you can go in and perturb and break to see what goes wrong. It's surrounded by all of these axons and pathways connecting all sorts of other parts of the brain that may or may not even be directly connected to the claustrum. So people really haven't been able to use what are normally sort of like the first set of tools you would use to discern basic function, which is to go in and lesion, as you said, go into this structure, break it without breaking anything else and see what goes wrong. That really hasn't been possible because of this sort of awkward anatomical location and form that this brain structure has had.
Nick JikomesYeah. Terrific summary. Exactly right. And so can you talk a little bit more about its connectivity pattern with the cortex and other structures? It sounds like at a crude level, it's sort of connected to everything or at least many things. And to what extent is that true? Is it connected to all parts of the cortex truly? And are those bi-directional? What does that connectivity really look like at more of the cellular level?
Brian MathurWell, it really depends on what species you're looking at. And, you know, most of the work has been done in rat and mouse up until now, doing classical track tracing experiments. Does, you know, cortex area A connect to the claustrum? Does it project there? And does the claustrum project back to that region? As a general rule, the connections are bidirectional like that. In the mouse and in the rat though, it's not the case that every cortical region is equivalently connected bidirectionally to the claustrum. So there's a bias in the rodent claustrum.
Brian MathurAnd the bias is that the strongest connections to the claustrum and from the claustrum back to cortex are to the prefrontal or frontal cortices. like medial prefrontal cortex, like prelimbic prefrontal cortex, anterior cingulate cortex, retrosplenial cortex, sort of midline cortical structures. In the human, we were able to use functional magnetic resonance imaging, fMRI, to look at resting state functional connectivity. And using that data, it appears that the claustrum is much more widely quote, functionally connected to different areas of cortex than in the rodent.
Brian MathurAnd then in the monkey, we knew a lot less until this past year, where this tour of force study came out in cell by a group in China, that basically did everything we've done in rodents over the past 20 years in a single study. So they did classical track tracing studies, to look at many, many different areas of cortex and how it's connected to the classroom bidirectionally. And it looks like the connectivity has expanded widely compared to rodents towards more of what we see in humans with functional connectivity in the scanner.
Nick JikomesSo basically over time, it used to take dozens and dozens of studies to figure out sort of piece by piece, these cells project to this area, these cells project to this area. Modern techniques were sort of used and they could map sort of all of the connections in the rodent claustrum. And indeed, they confirmed all in one shot, sort of all in one paper, all of the ways that we can look at these things today, what connects with the CloudStrom, and it's connected to all sorts of things in both directions. So it's sending projections to places and then also receiving projections from those same places it's sending its own projections to.
Brian MathurRight, exactly. I think an important point to be made here is that right where we stand, right what you just summarized, is basically our understanding up until, you know, five years ago, a lot's going in and a lot's going out of the cloud stream. And that sort of like, opens up the doors quite widely to functional hypotheses, right? What we didn't know was, what is the input output map?
Brian MathurLike, so imagine the classroom is like Grand Central Station. where you have a lot of trains coming in, you have a lot of trains going out. But the fact is that with a train station, some trains go into the station and go out to a specific target. And now, what we know now after a couple of studies that were performed in mouse, there's a specific pattern to the inputs and outputs. The inputs don't go to the classroom and then go everywhere. They go to specific places.
Nick JikomesGot it, got it. Okay, so it has this really interesting anatomical pattern in terms of its connections. They're often bi-directional. They're going to many places, but there's a method to the madness. It's not going literally absolutely everywhere. There's a more refined anatomical logic there. These things have been unpacked pretty recently in terms of our ability to really see this at a finer grain scale. This activity pattern, again, it really suggests lots of interesting ideas because we can talk about multimodal integration and the binding problem and all these things.
Nick JikomesIt is connected to a lot of places. The connections are bi-directional. And so it immediately suggests that something important is probably going on here. And it's probably not just like one transformation or one sensory modality or one thing. There's probably some higher order, more integrative function here. But of course, the anatomy itself can't tell you that. You have to start taking the anatomy and then doing functional tests.
Brian MathurYeah, that's exactly right. And it goes back to something I said earlier, And then the rodent, the connections that predominate are those arising from, you know, higher order cortical regions, those regions that are processing really complicated things. Yeah, yeah, lines are, but rather variables, rules,
Nick JikomesRight, right, right. So maybe, you know, an animal might be figuring out a maze or something and it's using its visual cortex to handle the visual information. The stuff, you know, visual stuff comes into the retina, it goes to the visual cortex, the first parts of it, and it gets sort of like processed and elaborated on until more abstract things come from that, and they get integrated with other sensory modalities, with what we like to think the mouse is thinking about, or what we might call the rules the mouse is starting to discern. And basically, those higher order things that get computed, that's more the stuff that's going to the claustrum, not the low-level, more basic sensory information.
Brian MathurIn the rodent, that is correct, yes. But even in the monkey, one striking thing that came out of that tour-de-force study that came out last year was that even though there are a lot of connections to the claustrum, one that's surprisingly missing is connections from the visual cortex, like primary visual cortex to the claustrum. That's just an example that perhaps this pattern has, you know, stayed the same through evolution, that it's more, the claustrum is more involved with cognitive connect connections rather than primary sensory or primary motor connections.
Nick JikomesGot it. Got it. So it's in this interesting location. It's got all these connections, but they're more of these higher order connections that we think are going to underlie more abstract things, more cognitive things, not lower level sensory things like the basics of, you know, low level visual processing or whatever. And so We've got these tools that allow us to make these anatomic maps in certain species like rodents. And now we're going to think about like, OK, what's actually going on here and what's actually happening functionally? How do you guys start to approach a problem like this in rodents today with the technology that we have? How can you actually discern and manipulate and watch what some of these neurons in the claustrum are doing?
Brian MathurYeah, so to pick up from what you just said, It started with a hypothesis, as most studies probably do, and that was that the classroom is probably doing something with higher order levels of cognition, right? So we had animals perform a task, mice perform a task that's very difficult for them. And I'll get into, like, how we manipulate the circuitry in a second. But what we had them do was basically look at five different holes on a wall.
Brian MathurImagine, like, five different elevators. And one of those holes will light up for literally a half a second, like the ding on an elevator. And then the animal is tasked to go poke their nose into that hole that lit up very briefly for a reward. didn't poke the nose hole within a very short time window, they didn't get their reward. So they really had to, you know, maintain vigilance on this panel of holes in order to get their reward. And so we hypothesize that the cloud stream was involved in doing something difficult like this. And so what we did to the circuitry, the first thing we did was to target the largest the primary input to the claustrum, and that is from a cortical region called the anterior cingulate cortex. So what we did was to express a light-sensitive protein in that pathway so that when we shine light specifically on this pathway, we could turn off the activity of this pathway.
Nick Jikomesuh that normally excites the claustrum and when we did that animals started to perform significantly worse on this task um so they weren't poking the right holes anymore they were poking holes they were just poking the wrong holes got it got it so so so these are mice they've got sort of five doors or five things to look at one of the five in any given trial of this task will light up briefly and that tells the animal they can go to that door but not other doors and get a reward So there's a sensory component here. They have to see what's going on and detect using their eyes, this brief light pulse.
Nick JikomesThere's a memory component here because then they have to remember which one the light was just on and go to it. And then obviously there's a motor component. They have to move their body over there. And while this might not seem terribly difficult to us, this is pretty darn difficult for a mouse to do. And importantly, it's not just a visual thing. It's sort of integrating motor, sensory, and visual in this case. And so it's higher order in that sense. These things have to be integrated. And that's also probably why, in addition to the anatomy, you were looking at the anterior cingulate. It's sending strong connections to the claustrum. And I presume, I don't know much about the cingulate, but it's probably getting information from visual areas and memory areas and so forth.
Brian MathurExactly. Yeah, I just wanted to highlight how difficult this task is for a mouse. That would be an extremely easy task for us. But it takes at least a month to train mice to do this task. So it's very demanding. And you're right. It has a lot of different components to it. And we performed a really important control, I think. So instead of the controls for all those other components, we tried to isolate the cognitive load aspect of the task. So instead of having them choose from five different holes that can randomly light up, we only presented them with one hole that lit every single time. So it was a very simple stimulus response based task. I see the light.
Brian MathurI'm just going to poke that hole. There's no other variables like four other holes that might have gone off. Animals were able to perform that quite well. And when we inhibited this pathway from the anterior cingulate cortex to the claustrum, they performed that just the same. So it seemed like that pathway was not being recruited for the simpler task where you have all the same sensory integration components involved.
Nick JikomesGot it. So if you've got two tasks, they both involve looking at something, remembering something, and then moving your body towards something. You have to integrate all of these things. If it's really easy to do that, you've just got one place that lights up, and then you go to that every time. You inhibit the anterior cingulate projection to the claustrum, nothing happens. So whatever information is going from the cingulate to the claustrum doesn't really seem to matter much for an easy task like that. But then if you just make the task harder, so it's essentially the same task, it's got the same features, but it's much more demanding because now you've got one out of five that might light up and it changes each time. This more demanding task, as soon as you inhibit the cingulate to the claustrum information path, now the animals don't do as well.
Nick JikomesSo something important is being carried from the cingulate to the claustrum, this mysterious area that is important for demanding tasks that are difficult to do and to learn.
Brian MathurExactly, yeah. We also monitored that pathway using a technique called fiber photometry. So instead of expressing a light-sensitive opsin that will hyperpolarize or silence those neurons, when these neurons activate normally during the task, calcium comes into these neurons and binds to this molecule, GCaMP, and that releases a photon that we can detect using a fiber in the brain. So we also detected the activity of this pathway during performance, and the activity of that pathway increases right before the light goes off.
Brian MathurSo there's some preparatory signal, some predictive signal coming from the anterior cingulate cortex to the claustrum that we saw during that complex five-choice version of the task, but we saw a much lower signal on that simpler one-choice version. So that told us both that the manipulation experiment tells us that there's something causally involved with this pathway, but also there's activity that seems to be associated with the performance of the complex task versus the simpler task.
Nick JikomesGot it. And so just to be clear for people, what they literally do literally is you can engineer mice, and this is what we talked about earlier. They're genetically tractable. You can do these types of things. You can engineer the mice so that literally the neurons that go from the cingulate to the claustrum, and not other neurons in other parts of the brain, those neurons will light up. Literally, they will light up. when they become active. And they can stick a fiber optic, a tiny little fiber optic into, physically into the brain of the mouse, right above that circuit.
Nick JikomesAnd it can be sensitive to those photons that get emitted from that circuit. And now you can measure the light and thereby estimate how active that circuit is in just that part of the brain. What you're saying is when you did that, you had them do this demanding task. They got to keep track of which of the five doors the light goes on for. They've got to remember that and then get their reward. this circuit from the cingulate to the claustrum lights up, literally lights up when the light over the door, door with a reward goes off. So it very much looks like the type of signal where the, that part of the brain is sort of thinking, um, okay, that's where the light was. I have to remember that and go to that one.
Brian MathurYeah. Something along those lines. Yeah. It's difficult to interpret exactly what the signal is encoding. Um, but it seemed associated with. you know, the cue that that initiates the motor response responsible for the animal ultimately getting its reward.
Nick JikomesYeah, yeah. So you see, you see that signal in that circuit for the difficult task, you can inhibit that circuit, you can sort of turn it down or turn it off, and the animals don't behave as well. So it sort of lights up at this interesting time in the difficult task, but not the easy task. And if you mess with that signal, the animal's behavior is messed with as well. So it seems to be functionally relevant. So the cingulate seems to be sending something to the claustrum that's important for the animal to do a cognitively difficult task.
Brian MathurThat's exactly right. And I think where we went from that study was to ask the question, well, if this major pathway is doing this, sending a signal or this preparatory signal to the claustrum, Is the classroom itself responding in that way? Because, you know, like I said earlier, that receives a lot of different inputs. So what is the classroom itself doing? So we did basically the same thing as I just described, but instead of monitoring and manipulating this major input to the classroom, we monitored and manipulated the classroom itself. And we were able to do that using a genetically engineered mouse that expressed an enzyme Cree recombinase specifically in the claustrum. And then we're able to express the options that allowed us to inhibit claustrum neurons and allowed us to monitor the activity of those neurons selectively during the same task.
Nick JikomesYeah. And so what did you guys find there? What is the claustrum doing in this context?
Brian Mathurwe found it was doing exactly the same thing as the other in the other context. So there was greater activity of the claustrum in the complex five choice version of the task, diminished activity in the simpler version. When we inhibited the activity of the claustrum in the complex version, they started to not perform as well. But when we inhibited the claustrum during the simpler version of the task, they did just fine. So That really pointed us in the direction that the claustrum has something to do with complex cognitive load-related tasks. And based on its connectivity, we started to think about more broadly, more globally about the brain and how the claustrum might be organizing or orchestrating different areas of the cortex for complex cognitive load-dependent tasks And, you know, with some other ideas that were out there in the field, we really centered on this idea that the claustrum is performing a cortical network organizing function that might be necessary for mammals or any other species to perform complex tasks. And that is something, it became a question that was amenable to human experimentation.
Brian MathurSo at that point, we really start to endeavor to study the claustrum in human brains and have people in the scanner perform similar easy versus complex tasks while monitoring the structure.
Nick JikomesYeah, so if we step back for a sec, and connect this to everyday life. Everyone's got experiences where we might do something that's very easy or that we're highly skilled at, that we've done a thousand times before. And we can do those things on autopilot. They're no longer demanding for us. If I'm driving my car through my own neighborhood, I know the streets already. I can have a conversation with someone and operate the vehicle at the same time. But if I go to the highway and there's more traffic and I'm in a new city I've never been in before, it's much harder for me to have that conversation or do something else, like change the radio. I have to really pay attention to the road.
Nick JikomesIt's more demanding. You could imagine at a very, very high level that the more demanding task is naturally going to require more of my brain, more of the cortex needs to be pointed at that task, so to speak, than the one that has been learned over and over and over again and can be done on autopilot. So that's kind of sort of what we're talking about here. The classroom seems to be involved in these more cognitively demanding things that require more effort and attention, something that would be more difficult to do and just require more focus. It doesn't, it seems to be dispensable for more easy tasks that are just easier to perform and not as complicated. And at the same time, we've got this problem where, okay, you guys saw the signal from the cingulate coming to the claustrum. You saw this connection to the more demanding task.
Nick JikomesBut now the claustrum is this sort of weird structure that's connected to all these other places all over the cortex. How do you sort of study all those things at once? well, you might need to do something like imaging the entire cortex at the same time while doing a demanding task like this. And so I guess that's where you're going now. You could do an imaging study like that in humans where you're sort of making them do a demanding task that you think is going to involve the classroom that also allows you to see what's going on across the entire cortex at the same time.
Brian MathurExactly. Yeah, you got it. And so, yeah. So what did you guys start to see? So we collaborated with a neuroimager. His name's Dave Seminowicz. He's now at Western University in Canada. And we put people in an fMRI machine and had them perform something called the multisource interference task. This is a task where you have three buttons at your fingertips, and you can look at a screen, and the screen will show numbers in three different positions, left, middle, and right, which correspond to left, middle, and right fingers on the buttons. And so there are easy versions of this task where you might have like a star in the finger one position and like nothing in the other positions, and you're tasked to just hit the number one position with the number one finger. it's very easy. But then it gets really difficult.
Brian MathurSo that it might say like 131. And so that means you should press your middle finger, even though the number three is in the middle position, which corresponds to your third finger. So there's this interference component that you have to work through in order to perform the task correctly. And so what we found was, you know, our hypothesis was that the classroom is going to be activated with this more difficult version of the task than the sort of easier stimulus response version of the tasks.
Brian MathurAnd what we found was that when you have a block of easy task sessions, and then it switches to a block of difficult ones, that's where the CloudStream was activated. So it was activated at the switch from doing something very, very easy to something very, very hard. And what we found with the cortex at that point was, perhaps unsurprisingly to those people who do neuroimaging, was that the cortex went from one network state to another one. And it went from the so-called default mode network state to an extrinsic mode network state that involves different areas of cortex.
Brian MathurSo the default mode network involves things like medial prefrontal cortex, ventral ACC, anterior cingulate cortex, but also more posterior regions of the cingulate. And this sort of extrinsic mode network involves things like dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and posterior parietal cortex, things of that nature, frontoparietal cortex-like states. So that's where we saw when the classroom activated, it was the switch from default mode network to sort of extrinsic mode networks that always turn on when you're performing a cognitive task, no matter what that task might be.
Nick JikomesGot it. So basically, the basic result here is you're imaging people's brains. There's some pattern of basic activity that we call default mode activity patterns in their cortex. Then they have to do this more complex task. So they have to switch from sort of easy mode to hard mode. They have to really pay attention now. Things are becoming more cognitively demanding. The classroom lights up. in between those two states. So it's like, okay, I have to do something more difficult. I have to pay attention. It's at about that time, the claustrum seems to light up in people.
Nick JikomesAnd then after that, the cortex is now not in its default mode pattern of activity. There's this new pattern. And so it looks as if the claustrum might be a switch. It's sending out some kind of signal that flips the cortex in general from one activity pattern regime to another one.
Brian MathurThat's exactly the conclusion we came to, but I think there's an important point to be made here. The claustrum is a subcortical structure and it's not, it doesn't display this layered structure that the cortex does. And we know that layering is involved in very complex processing in the brain. The claustrum itself is not a layered structure. So the conflict here with a lot of neuroscientists is how could the claustrum be controlling Something that's more that's set up for a higher processing power than itself Is that if that makes sense? Um, yeah so I think the answer to that is that Another cortical structure tells the claustrum. Hey, it's time to switch now do your thing because you're set up like an internet router and I'm not, if that makes sense.
Nick JikomesRight, right. So it's got this, the CloudStream is set up like a router that gets back to what we were saying earlier about its connectivity. It's connected to lots of different areas bidirectionally. So it's kind of this hub that can talk to many different places. So it's set up anatomically to do just this type of thing. You see it light up. at the time the brain or the person needs to switch from easy mode to hard mode to do the more complex task, it certainly looks like this structure is lighting up as a way to flip the switch in the cortex somehow, potentially receiving an instruction from another part of cortex to do so.
Nick JikomesBut it's at this interface between easy mode and hard mode when the people have to do the more complex task. And do we know anything from animal studies about more specifics on the connectivity. So when you're looking at connection patterns from cells in the claustrum to the cortex, is there any sense for like what parts of the cortical microcircuit they're actually plugging into and what sort of activity is there? Is there some big burst of activity that comes out of these things in rodents that might literally kind of flip a switch into a different activity regime in the cortex?
Nick JikomesDo we know anything about the actual spiking activity in rodents from claustrum to cortex?
Brian MathurYeah, there was a study that came out a few years ago by Jesse Jackson, and he was at Janelia. Jesse's now in Canada, he has his own lab. He did this really influential study showing that when you activate the claustrum, inner neurons in the cortex are activated quite powerfully, particular parvalbumin inner neurons, which are known to inhibit these projection neurons in the cortex, and also they themselves are involved in certain, inducing certain frequencies in the cortex.
Brian MathurSo what he saw was when recording activity in the claustrum, or in the cortex, that was medial prefrontal cortex in rodent, when you activate the claustrum, you get this dip in cortical activity. So, you know, you can quite simply say the claustrum inhibits the cortex, but after that dip, something interesting happened. There was a rebound effect where firing of pyramidal neurons went above their baseline and then came back. And we think this is due to the fact that we and others have shown that the claustrum innervates the cortex, activates these inner neurons, but it also activates these pyramidal neurons.
Brian MathurSo I think there's a sort of a biphasic effect when you activate the classroom, the initial thing is activation of the inner neurons, that effect predominates, initially, you get the silencing, and then you get this overshoot activation effect. And this is different across different areas of the cortex. That's the general theme. And so I think we've interpreted this as the ability for the classroom to take different areas of cortex offline briefly at the same time and then allow them to come back online together.
Nick JikomesGot it, got it. So yeah, yeah. So the idea would be, so the classroom is projecting to inhibitory interneurons in different parts of the cortex. These are neurons that are inhibitory. So they're going to make other neurons more silent. If you transiently silence those and let them come back online, one way to start to think about that is it could be a mechanism to make different anatomically separate parts of the brain. act co-active together at the same time. Because when you flip the switch on the parvalbumin interneurons, you're dampening their activity and they rebound and come back online, that could be a way to synchronize which brain regions are on at the same time.
Nick JikomesAnd when you start to think about things like multimodal integration, and the binding problem and integrating different signals to execute a behavior based on when things are happening, at some level, that's going to have to involve synchronizing activity patterns in different regions.
Brian MathurExactly right. So whether that synchronization is involved in solving the binding problem or just organizing networks is unclear. But I think going back to the original idea of what of Crick's idea with the classroom is involved in generating conscious perceptions of the world. You know, when we inhibited the classroom, we saw in our own data, the animals were able to perform that simple task.
Brian MathurSo it's not as if sensory integration, sensory motor integration was affected greatly in that task. So I think the data point a little bit away from a binding solution and more towards a networking or brain state shifting solution to the classroom.
Nick JikomesRight. Basically what you're saying is the classroom is dispensable for doing easy tasks, but when we're doing relatively easy things in our lives, it's not like the screen goes black. We still have conscious perceptions and stuff. Sensory integration is still happening. It's only when we have these more demanding tasks that the classroom comes online. But in both cases, you still have the binding of sensory elements into one picture. So that can't be exactly what's going on here.
Brian MathurYes, that's the interpretation.
Nick JikomesExactly right. One thing that might be unclear for people that could be worth dwelling on for a second is we take it for granted because it's the normal way of just being alive and being awake and being conscious. What actually must go into creating these coherent scenes that we're so used to? Right now, I'm talking to you and I can see my lips moving on the screen. I can see your lips moving. It aligns with the sounds I'm hearing through my headphones. Everything lines up. It's not as simple and automatic as you might think from everyday conscious experience, because all of the signals that I get from you, Brian, when you speak, they're not all arriving in my brain at the same spot at the same time.
Nick JikomesThe visual signals and the auditory signals and other things are coming in to different places at different times. So somehow, all of that stuff needs to be aligned after it gets into my brain. And it's very tricky to think about exactly how that actually happens.
Brian MathurAbsolutely. I certainly don't have a solution for it.
Nick JikomesUm, okay. So, so we're going to talk about the classroom a little bit more, but we're also going to talk about some other things that you study in the lab, including, you know, the effects of alcohol and psychedelics. Um, before we get there, is there anything you think we should discuss in terms of the classroom and our understanding of it that might be relevant to help us understand some of these other papers we'll talk about?
Brian MathurYeah, I, it gets a bit. wonky i'll try and explain it quite easily and it goes back to that what i was saying you asked me what is the connectivity like in of the claustrum as it relates to the cortex and it really depends on the species and in rodents it seems simpler than it does in monkey um so in the rodents uh major inputs and outputs are to higher order cognitive regions of the cortex like prefrontal cortex etc But it's certainly connected to many other areas of the cortex. In the monkey, we see that that has elaborated.
Brian MathurThere are many, many different connections to many different areas of the cortex, as well as some subcortical regions as well. And we can only suspect that it's even more complicated in the human brain. And that's reflected in our data showing that the claustrum is functionally connected to many different areas of cortex quite strongly. So there are differences between rodents and humans. And so our hypothesis of claustrum function shifts when we're thinking about rodents versus humans because of this elaboration of connectivity. And so the more recent human work that we've put out and are currently trying to get published posits or has posited or hypothesized that the claustrum may be involved in any switching of network states. And in that way, we can assign a role to the CloudStream, and that role is a cognitive control role. Because essentially, when you're controlling cognition flexibly, brain states are following that, right?
Brian MathurAnd so if the CloudStream is a sort of router that's involved in that process, it's a participant in cognitive control.
Nick JikomesYeah.
Brian MathurAnd so the hypothesis became that the classroom may not only be involved in difficult cognitive tasks, but a variety of different cognitive tasks, and maybe tasks that don't require you to interact with the external world, but rather internally as well.
Nick JikomesRight. So maybe it's not about difficulty per se, maybe it's more about switching between different regimes, which are important for different types of tasks. Sometimes they might be switching to the regime that's important for the cognitively demanding task, but maybe you might need to switch to a different regime. That's that's not right.
Brian MathurSo you can imagine if you're performing a task where somebody asks you, do you remember the word I said four words ago? That's a particular task where you're engaging with an external source. Like the experimenter and it's a working memory task. And what we find in that task is that the classroom is activating at the initiation. Of this working memory task, but comparing that to tasks where somebody has to just think internally about something where you're not engaging the extrinsic mode networks that allow you to engage with the external world, but you have a task to take care of just internally find the classroom is also activated in that case. So this would be like an autobiographical memory task. Can you remember Your route to the bus stop after leaving your home how do you get to the bus stop when you're in fourth grade something like that yeah.
Brian MathurGo through the the route in your head and you're not interacting with anything in the external world you're engaging a different network default mode network. So the idea is the classroom we activated when you're switching to this sort of task. an internal state task versus an external state task.
Nick JikomesAnd do we know that? Is that just hypothesized or have we seen that it's the classroom is active in those cases? We see that it's active in those cases.
Brian MathurYes.
Nick JikomesGot it. Got it. And so, you know, based on everything you've told me so far, Well, let me back up for a second. When we're awake and we're doing things like right now, we have this seamless experience that seems smooth and uninterrupted. But as soon as you start to look at the literature on brain activity and dig into the stuff in terms of what's measured as people do things and have experiences and go from one task to another, the brain does really flip pretty quickly and discreetly between different states. Perhaps the most obvious example of this would be like sleep state switching. You go from waking to being a non-REM sleep, and then deeper non-REM sleep, and then REM sleep. And you transition between all these different activity patterns in the brain that correspond to those states.
Nick JikomesBut the flips of the switch are quite abrupt. They're happening in a second or two. So you go from non-REM, and now you're all of a sudden in REM. And then all of a sudden, you're awake again. So there are these abrupt transitions. And it does kind of look like a switch somewhere has been flipped. Do we know... So based on those things, based on what you've told me about the claustrum so far and how it's active at the switch between a non-demanding and demanding task and these other things, is it also active at transitions from say sleep to wakefulness and those sorts of transitions where the global brain state is suddenly shifting from one regime to another?
Brian MathurYeah, this is a great question. And going back to the guy who discovered that the claustrum is activating these inner neurons, Jesse Jackson, he is uh sort of examining what the classroom is doing in sleep and uh we know that in sleep the cortex synchronizes uh sort of broadly right um in the you might you know based on what i told you that the classroom in waking states is synchronizing these different brain regions that sort of culminate in network states that the classroom might be involved in the synchronization of cortex during sleep states and and that's what you know, he's finding, and I, you know, he would argue that it's playing an important role in the processes that are involved in sleep, like memory consolidation.
Brian MathurSo I think there are transition states from wake to sleeping states that are noted. I think there's a lot more work to be done there to figure out what the role of CloudStorm is in mediating those transitions.
Nick JikomesYeah. Yeah. Interesting. And it's just worth saying for people explicitly, there's times when all of the parts of our cortex are in sync with each other. We fall asleep. And once you're in sleep deeply, most of the brain is asleep all at once at the same time. And then when you wake, depending on what you're doing and how you're doing it, different parts of the cortex might need to be awake or active at the same time. And other parts might need to be quiet or inhibited at the same time, right? If you're doing an auditory task, you might want to close your eyes and sort of tone down the visual parts of your cortex and vice versa. So you can start to imagine how you would need a structure like the claustrum to be hooked up to these different areas. And maybe when you're awake, it's getting one set of inputs from one set of areas and another from another set of areas so that it can turn up certain parts of the brain at the same time while turning down or off other parts of the brain at the same time.
Nick JikomesAnd then when everything is kind of disinhibited, you know, during sleep, you might get all of the parts of the brain and non-REM sleep at the same time. And blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. It gets really complicated really fast. But the basic idea is the brain is going to need to synchronize or turn on and turn off different parts of the brain in different patterns at different times according to what's needed in terms of behavior and the demands of whatever you might be doing. With that in mind, one experience that we often have is sometimes we ingest things and it kind of throws the ability of us and our brain to coordinate things off. And a really good example of that is alcohol. Many of us have had the experience of having one or two or a few drinks. And suddenly, things that we could do easily, seamlessly, and with good coordination become discoordinated.
Nick JikomesAnd we start to trip over our words. We can't quite control our motor skills as finely and in a patterned fashion like we could before. You've done a lot of work looking at what alcohol is actually doing in the brain. Before connecting it back to maybe Klaustrom stuff and microcircuit stuff, let's just step back and give people a basic sense of what is alcohol actually doing in the brain? What's actually happening when we get a little tipsy and a little buzzed after a couple of drinks?
Brian MathurYeah, this is a great question. Very complicated answer. I'll try and boil it down. A lot of people are interested in psilocybin because it activates serotonin receptors and quite powerfully changes the state of the brain. Alcohol, though, is equally as powerful. Maybe not working in therapeutic ways like psilocybin might be, but It has a host of different targets in the brain, molecular targets that depend on the concentration of alcohol that's in the system. And the way that we can sort of conceptualize how alcohol is modulating the brain is to think about what the results are of alcohol ingestion. So there are two different basic phases of alcohol effects.
Brian MathurOne is an acute effect. What happens when we're drunk? and the chronic effects, what happens after, you know, drinking a lot, and we're not necessarily drunk, right? We're sober again, but we have these like lasting effects to the circuitry in the brain that changes our behavior as it relates to alcohol and other things. So, you know, the effects, the acute effects of alcohol are quite widespread, affecting lots of different areas of the brain, you know, affects the cerebellum. That's why your coordination is off. It affects the prefrontal cortex. That's why your decision-making is impaired.
Brian MathurIt affects the basal ganglia. That's why you choose to drink more and more and more. So your action selection is off. You might disinhibit other emotional parts of the brain, so you don't feel fear as much like the amygdala. But then in the chronic phase, there are specific changes that happen to these different systems within the brain, specifically as they relate to alcohol. So George Koob, the director of the Alcohol Institute at NIH and Nora Volkow have put forth this idea about this tri-system effect of alcohol on the brain and other drugs, that number one, alcohol and other drugs impair decision-making, so they impair cognitive centers in the brain. like prefrontal cortex or maybe even the claustrum, impairing basal ganglia structures. So you go from inflexible to more, sorry, from flexible behavior to more inflexible behavior as it relates to that drug.
Brian MathurSo you see a cue for a particular drug or a drink and you act upon that cue. I see the pint, I will drink it. And then there's dysregulation in the emotional centers of the brain that increase anxiety and things like pain. that potentiate relapse and potentiate your ability to perform inflexible actions as it relates to those drug or alcohol cues, which ultimately culminates in what we view as substance use or alcohol use disorder.
Brian Mathurdrinking or taking drugs in the face of negative consequences.
Nick JikomesYeah, yeah. And for the acute effects of alcohol, is alcohol basically getting everywhere in the brain? It's just crossing the blood-brain barrier and going everywhere, more or less?
Brian MathurAbsolutely. It's only two carbons. This thing will seep through membranes. I mean, it's probably getting into your bloodstream before it goes into your stomach just by seeping through the vasculature in your throat. Like, that's how fast it's getting up there.
Nick JikomesYeah. Yeah. Okay. And so, um, what sorts of things have you studied in the lab with regards to alcohol and what's doing to certain parts of the brain?
Brian MathurYeah. So we've been really focused on how alcohol is, um, resulting and the expression of inflexible behavior. And that has, you know, in the sort of first decade of, of of running this lab, we focused on the basal ganglia. And the basal ganglia was a series of subcortical structures in the brain that process cortical information to help learn and select for actions. And so after chronic alcohol use, those actions shift from one strategy that's flexible to another strategy that's more inflexible. And under normal conditions, these inflexible and flexible strategies are both adaptive. So we want to have flexible strategies every day. We don't want to go to the cafeteria if they like stop serving London broil or something, and we'll stop those actions.
Brian MathurBut inflexible actions are also very adaptive. Like I need to tie my shoe and I need to do that without a lot of cognitive oversight. I need to have a conversation while I do this.
Nick JikomesRight. You need to be able to do the same things over and over again. If they're adaptive, you need to be able to update your plans and change them accordingly if something comes up. I guess where you're probably going with this is the inflexible behaviors can become maladaptive if we stick with a plan that's hurting us and we're not, you know, going off of it at some point.
Brian MathurYeah, that's exactly right. And that's where people find themselves in this, you know, this cycle of performing actions that aren't good for them.
Nick JikomesRight. Right. Alcohol use disorder addiction. You keep doing the thing that's leading to the bad outcome over and over again. So you're inflexibly behaving, but it's maladaptive. It's not something you need to do all the time, like tie your shoe.
Brian MathurRight. So. What we've been looking at is how alcohol has been modulating the input structure to the basal ganglia. It's called the striatum. It's the area that receives the cortical input and then processes it through downstream signaling and then sends it back to cortex or down to brainstem for action expression. And the central idea here is that alcohol is actually allowing for inflexible behavioral learning. It's sort of a pro-learning substance in a way, that it's allowing for this lateral aspects of the striatum to learn how to perform these inflexible behaviors much faster than it should. And so the actions that it's allowing for to be learned so well are those that are associated when you're exposed to alcohol, which is drinking behavior.
Nick JikomesGot it. So the idea would be that that when an individual is drinking, they're actually messing with the striatum in a way that is causing it to sort of overlearn the behaviors associated with the consumption of the alcohol or the acquisition of that reward. And then you sort of get stuck in the inflexible state where you're just executing those behaviors over and over again, despite negative consequences later on.
Brian MathurExactly right. So we dove into the mechanisms there and it's really complicated. But to summarize, we've been looking at a particular neuron type that exists in this lateral part of the striatum that doesn't exist as much in sort of medial aspects of the striatum that are involved in flexible behaviors and looking to see what the effect of alcohol is on this particular inner neuron population. And so the first thing we did was something very simple. We asked, well, if these neurons are in the sort of inflexible part, in this part of the striatum that encodes inflexible behavior, alcohol must be acting upon them in a way to induce this inflexible behavior. So it must rely upon those neurons, right? So we selectively ablated these inner neurons.
Brian MathurAnd this only represents less than 1% of the neurons in this structure. So we're able to use a virus that induces apoptosis, essentially, in these neurons alone in mice. And then we had mice drink alcohol and we tracked their drinking. And then at the end of several weeks of drinking, had them perform this sort of, quote, compulsive drinking assay, where instead of just drinking straight alcohol, we put quinine into the alcohol, which is a bitterant.
Brian MathurIt's also the thing that's in tonic, tonic water. It's what makes a tonic water taste bitter, but there's no sugar in their alcohol. Like our gin and tonics are full of sugar. Um, so they don't like tonic, right? They don't like this bitterness. Um, so they'll stop drinking under normal circumstances, but the animals that were drinking for weeks, they don't care. They'll just sort of compulsively and flexibly drink through this quinine adulterated alcohol. The animals, that are lacking these inner neurons, they did not drink straight through that adulterant.
Brian MathurThey were able to flexibly say, hey, this is gross, I'm not gonna drink this anymore. So that's why these inner neurons were causally related to the inflexible drinking behaviors that arise after weeks of drinking alcohol.
Nick JikomesGot it. So there's particular interneurons in the striatum and they seem to be important for learning to be inflexible with respect to this behavior, to keep doing this behavior compulsively despite negative consequences. You can get rid of those neurons and you get rid of that behavior, which that's kind of what you want to do if someone is in the maladaptive state of continuing to do the compulsive behavior that's leading to too much drinking. Is there a way to keep those neurons intact and reverse this? Can you train animals or do some kind of functional manipulation that allows you to erase or diminish compulsive alcohol-seeking behavior without destroying the circuit?
Brian MathurYeah, so this is where it gets more complicated. I mean, you don't want to just ablate those neurons You probably will affect your ability to learn other behaviors that are adaptive, right? Like let's say playing a scale on the piano. Yeah. Yeah, we're going going to work every day or whatever Walking across the street and having a conversation. Um So we look deeper into what alcohol is actually doing to these neurons without, you know ablating them and what we found was something that we didn't expect. It was sort of outside our wheelhouse, so to speak. We looked at the inputs to these neurons to see if the activity that drive or inhibit these inner neurons is affected by chronic alcohol exposure.
Brian MathurAnd so these neurons, inner neurons, are activated by the cortex. And we found that that connection is unaffected. But what was affected was inhibition onto these inner neurons. And inhibition onto these inner neurons comes from two other parts of the brain. One within the basal ganglia and one within the thalamus. So the globus pallidus and the thalamic reticular nucleus respectively. And we found that these GABA inputs were essentially lost. They were just like dissociated from these from these inner neurons, which had a dramatic disruption of inhibitory control over these inner neurons.
Brian MathurSo, and that was mediated by this complex effect of alcohol on the things that surround these inner neurons in particular. So these like matrix of proteins that sort of solidify the inputs onto these neurons, and those were sort of dissolved after alcohol exposure, which led to this dissociation of these GABA inputs onto these interneurons. So really it's a circuit problem onto these interneurons where they're losing inhibitory control. So that's what we're looking into next.
Brian MathurWe have to fix that part or tackle this loss of matrix proteins around these neurons that help to keep those GABA inputs intact.
Nick JikomesYeah, yeah. So I guess in a sense, what this sort of implies is that one way to think about alcoholism or alcohol use disorder, the compulsive consumption of alcohol, is that you might naturally think, okay, why can't these people learn or unlearn to do this? But in a sense, it's almost like, well, maybe the circuit is sort of over-learning to do certain behaviors. The alcohol is, in other words, like you said, it's almost like a learning agent and a certain type of um, circuit that's involved in inflexible behavior and sort of locking you into doing something over and over again.
Nick JikomesIt's been over-trained actually. And you actually kind of want to run that back and reverse ultimately. It's not that necessarily learning has been disrupted, like you've been unable to learn something. It's that you've over-learned one thing and now it's just kind of really cemented into the, into the circuitry.
Brian MathurYeah.
Nick JikomesAnd into your life as a result. Interesting. I want to talk a little bit about psychedelics because you've done work that is interesting as well. And so to connect this back to some of the things we were talking about earlier, we talked about the colostrum and the idea that the brain has these different states that it goes into that are functionally distinct. You have the default mode network. You have other networks and other patterns of activity in the brain. You have different sleep and waking states. And the brain is constantly sort of flipping and flopping between these according to what the demands on the animal are, the types of tasks that need to be formed, how you need to behave, and so forth.
Nick JikomesAnd we mentioned the default mode network, and that's one that comes up a lot when we talk about things like psychedelics. So let's step back to that for a second. The default mode network, just describe for people one more time what that is and how people think about it. And what is the connection there with psychedelics? What have the observations been that have sort of linked those two things together so far in the literature?
Brian MathurYeah, so default mode network very simply is a brain state, or it's a network of cortical regions that activate when you're not Performing a task that requires you to interact with the external sensory world So we can see this activated when you're simply sitting in or laying down in a scanner staring at a plus sign just thinking about What you're gonna have for dinner or what happened to you earlier that day? Default mode network will turn on In its relation to psychedelics There there's work out there suggesting that because that when you take psilocybin there's a disillusion of of the default mode network and the interpretation there is that the default mode network because it's activated when you're sort of self-reflecting that it's sort of a sense of self network and that when you take the idea is that when you take psilocybin you sort of dissolve this sense of self in a way and open yourself up to other inputs or have you value things differently or consider the associations you have with certain things differently than you would have before? If that makes sense.
Nick JikomesYeah. So the default mode network, it's a pattern of activity across the brain. And you tend to see this network active when you are not engaged with the external world. I'm not engaged with an object outside of my body. I'm not engaged with a task where I'm looking at a screen out here. It tends to be active when we are thinking, daydreaming, thinking about ourself, our sense of self. We're engaged with our internal life, so to speak. Exactly. So psilocybin and psychedelics tend to disrupt that network. They tend to disrupt this default mode network. And people think that this has to do maybe with their therapeutic benefits. This might be one way that they're allowing people to re-evaluate their sense of self, to think about themselves in a new way, to consider and re-associate or disassociate different associations they might have in their mind.
Nick JikomesYou can immediately think about how that could be useful in a context of depression, or substance use disorder where certain associations are too strong and so on and so forth. But this one mode of the brain, the default mode, is what you see when people are not engaged with the external world and when they are engaged with the internal world. And this default mode network seems to be disrupted in interesting ways by psychedelics like psilocybin.
Brian MathurYes, but I will say that it's not just the default mode network. Basically, like all networks are disrupted by psilocybin, And then going back to the CloudStream, we found that the connectivity, the functional connectivity between the CloudStream and these different networks is also drastically altered in ways that are, you know, much different than what happens under normal conditions. So things like, you know, extrinsic mode networks, like frontal parietal network is also disrupted in addition to the default mode network. So, you know, a lot of things are happening when you're on psilocybin.
Brian MathurAnd I think that the default mode network interpretation of its explanatory value of what it's doing, perhaps therapeutically, has captured a lot of attention. because it's very intellectually engaging and has a lot of perhaps explanatory value to it.
Nick JikomesYeah. And I guess when you think about it, it is sort of captivating in the sense that people are like, oh, default mode network, the sense of self, I lose my sense of self on psychedelics. It feels nice that we might have an explanation there, but then if you stop and think about it, you're like, well, wait a minute. Psilocybin doesn't just change my sense of self. It changes everything. It changes the way I engage with the external world as well. What you effectively just told us is it's not just affecting the default mode network. It's affecting probably every network we could look at under any number of circumstances. And it is kind of like, well, duh, of course it does. It's getting into the brain and it's going to affect every type of processing we have. Certainly if you've ever experienced psilocybin, that's going to be a pretty unsurprising statement.
Brian MathurYeah, absolutely. Getting down in the pharmacology The active ingredient of psilocybin psilocin doesn't just activate, you know 5-ht2a receptors, right? In 5-ht2a receptors aren't just present within default mode network regions of the brain. So It's hitting activating lots of different serotonin receptors you know including 5-ht2a which exists in other systems outside of the default mode network and So just looking at, you know, psilocybin's effects through a 5-HT2A receptor lens, it has to be involving other networks and brain regions.
Nick JikomesRight, right, right. And have you looked at the effect of psychedelics with respect to the classroom specifically?
Brian MathurYes. So in collaboration with Dave Sminowitz and Fred Barrett at Hopkins, we imaged people in the scanner fMRI. and challenged them with relatively lower dose of psilocybin, 10 milligrams, and found that, you know, networks dissolve, but the functional connectivity of the classroom with these different networks was drastically altered. And the integrity of these different networks themselves was altered in a way that related to the functional connectivity of classroom to these different network regions in the cortex, And the other thing that came out of that study was, if we look at the claustrum in particular, using that imaging approach, we saw a decrease in these so-called amplitude of low frequency fluctuations in the claustrum, suggesting that what psilocybin is doing is having this inhibition effect on the claustrum itself.
Nick JikomesAnd isn't there, aren't there some observations, what are the observations out there generally in the literature from like the EEG and the fMRI literature on what psilocybin does to sort of global cortical brain activity? I've heard a lot of people say that in general, we sort of see a dampening or an inhibition of activity that overall activity seems to go down in the cortex. Is that generally true? And does that kind of start to fit with what we know about the claustrum and how it works through inhibition?
Brian MathurI think it's kind of all over the place, depending on what sort of data sets you look at. Some data suggests that what's happening is just an increase in chaos in the cortex, an increase in entropy. If you look at single cell results, like using electrophysiology and brain slice preparations, you'll see a dramatic increase in excitatory transmission onto neurons. um in the presence of a 5h like a serotonin receptor 2a agonist um activating serotonin 2a receptors will also lead to the um synthesis release of endocannabinoids which can have an inhibition effect in the brain by inhibiting glutamate inputs onto different cell types so it's extremely complicated yeah um yeah i think it's it's not so Simple to say whether it's turning things up or down. I think it's It's turning things In different directions, right?
Nick JikomesRight and presumably this all depends on context like it might turn things up or down in the context of you know The one study that finds that result but depending on what the people are doing and the state they're in and all that contextual information Things could go in any number of directions
Brian MathurYes, absolutely right.
Nick JikomesAnd in terms of the claustrum sensitivity to serotonin, does anything jump out about the claustrum in terms of the types of receptors it expresses or the density of certain serotonin receptors or anything like this?
Brian MathurRight, so great question. There are several studies showing that this one receptor that's responsible for the subjective effects of psilocybin or psilocin, 5-HT2A that I keep mentioning, is expressed in claustrum. But that's not the only serotonin receptor that's in the claustrum. There are certainly other receptor subtypes that are expressed there, like the 5-HT1 class of receptors, 1B in particular, which is something we've looked at.
Brian MathurSo based on that receptor expression profile, it's certainly possible that the claustrum is being affected by psilocybin. And it's connecting to different regions of cortex express these different serotonin receptors that can be activated by psilocybin slash psilocin as well. And of course, the classroom receives input from these regions that express these serotonin receptors that are targets of psilocybin. So there are many different possible ways the classroom might be affected by psilocybin.
Brian MathurAnd something we've looked at recently is how activity from the cortex might be changing its ability to activate the claustrum in the presence of serotonin or after psilocybin challenge itself. And we found something surprising there that serotonin and psilocybin both lead to an inhibition of of the anterior cingulate cortex ability to activate the claustrum.
Nick JikomesSo an inhibition of the anterior cingulus ability to activate the claustrum, that was the circuit you guys inhibited before, and it made it more difficult for animals to do the cognitively challenging task.
Brian MathurThat's exactly right. So it turned down the ability for the excitatory transmitter to come out of this pathway and activate postsynaptic cells in the claustrum. But it didn't do that through 5G2A, this 2A receptor that's responsible for the subjective effects, the trip of psilocybin. We found that it was responsible through this 1B receptor that sits on the axon terminals of these anterior cingulate cortex inputs to the claustrum.
Brian MathurAnd the really interesting thing we found there was that If you wash serotonin onto a slice, it depresses the ability for these ACC inputs to activate the claustrum. But if you simply inject animals with psilocybin and then make slices and look at the synapse, this activation is suppressed. But even 24 hours later, we found that this effect was still present, which suggests that this psilocybin modulation of glutamate release in this pathway is not simply an acute effect that might be longer lasting. And taken together with our results showing that the classroom may be involved in cognitive network effects, that perhaps this synaptic effect that we identified might be contributing to longer lasting effects on network states after you've taken psilocybin.
Nick JikomesRight. And that's interesting because, so what you're saying is, cingulate cortex goes to claustrum. That's the pathway that seems to light up and be important for the ability of an animal to do a cognitively demanding task where its brain needs to switch from one mode to another to do that more demanding task. That pathway, when you guys inhibit it, disrupt the ability of animals to do that more demanding task. You then do separate experiments and you found that psilocybin sort of dampens that pathway as well. That depends on the serotonin 1B receptor. So not the 2A, the so-called psychedelic receptor, but the serotonin 1B receptor. And that's not just an acute thing in the presence of psilocin in that circuit.
Nick JikomesYou see it even if you wait about a day and the psilocin is presumably no longer there, but that dampening of that cingulate to claustrum pathway that still persists a day later. And then of course, that immediately makes you think about the persistent therapeutic effects that psilocybin seems to have. The fact that you give it acutely, but people seem to be different chronically for longer periods of time.
Brian MathurYeah, that's exactly right. I mean, if I may, I want to go back to something you said earlier about, you were describing very well about how the classroom has evolved in changing these network states. And you can imagine that you might need to change these states all the time. And it seems very seamless, right? that might be your claustrum working properly. You can imagine that your claustrum is not working properly. Those transitions might be difficult and that might result in what manifests as cognitive dysfunction, which is present in a wide variety of neuropsychiatric disorders like depression, schizophrenia, addiction. So disruption in the claustrum might be contributing cognitive effects in these different neuropsychiatric disorders and the role for psilocybin then might be to help sort of reset what's going on in the cloud stream to enable more flexible control of network states.
Nick JikomesRight, right, right. And, you know, I'm speaking a little loosely here, but, you know, there's different states the brain can be in, roughly speaking, that corresponds to different chunks of the brain, the cortex being active or inactive at the same time. So presumably, certain combinations of regions being active in certain ways can be adaptive and behavior is sort of normal. We can perform tasks and do things in an adaptive fashion. But if those cords of the brain are out of sync with each other and being played in the wrong or inappropriate combinations, you might think, well, maybe that's what it is when someone has schizophrenia and they're hallucinating and that's interfering with their ability to adaptively perform their life. Maybe that's the difference between a pleasant and seamless, insightful trip and a bad trip where you feel completely disorganized and terrified. Perhaps it has something to do with a structure like the claustrum, either being able to coordinate different parts of the brain normally and seamlessly or however you want to describe it, and being more discordant and putting parts of the brain together that shouldn't be active at the same time or something like this.
Brian MathurI suppose these are all possibilities, but we definitely need to look more into it to see which one of those, you know, might hold some water, but certainly, you know, cognitive deficits are widespread in neuropsychiatric disorders as are network disruptions. And there's a strong, you know, association between what brain regions turn on and for normal cognition and those disruptions correlate with the degree of deficits in these different neuropsychiatric disorders. So figuring out what the circuit mechanisms are of network disruption in these different disorders is really important for us to be able to tackle cognitive deficits in these different disorders that are very poorly treated with current therapies.
Nick JikomesYeah. So you see this effect of psilocybin on the circuit linking the anterior cingulate to the claustrum. It depends on 5HT1B serotonin receptors, not the 2A receptors. And then you get this acute and chronic effect. So the effects outlast the presence of the drug acutely. What are the next experiments here? Where do you see this going from here in terms of disentangling what's going on here mechanistically for these circuits?
Brian MathurI think one of the most important things to understand is how the serotonin system is built to modulate the claustrum itself. That will give us insight into understanding how psilocybin is changing the system for potential therapeutic benefit. That's one thing. And that's a very complicated thing to tackle because serotonergic innervation of any brain region is super complicated.
Brian MathurIt's not a simple one-to-one create a post-synaptic anatomical microcircuit construction. So that's gonna take a lot of effort. The second thing we're really interested in tackling is under what conditions Can psilocybin provide therapeutic benefit in under different pathological states? So we can, and what receptors are being, are responsible for that effect.
Brian MathurSo the interesting thing about this 5-HT1B receptor finding that we had is that adds more evidence to this idea that it's not just activation of the serotonin 2A receptor, that might lead to therapeutic benefits. There might be other receptors involved, and they might be involved in different aspects of therapeutic benefit, right? So that's something that we're interested in taking forward.
Nick JikomesYeah, yeah. And so what are some of the next things you guys are investigating with respect to claustrum function, you know, whether or not they have to do with the experiments you're doing in alcohol and psychedelics? What are you doing to try and just disentangle the sort of natural endogenous function of this brain region?
Brian MathurWell, the thing we're concentrating on most right now is the effects of chronic alcohol on the claustrum, but we just started another study trying to understand some of the basics of the claustrum, and that goes back to this, you know, the clear difference that people see in the expression of these different network states in the brain. So what we had been talking about is, The default mode network turns on when you're in a scanner thinking about autobiographical things. When you perform a task, a different network will turn on.
Brian MathurAn extrinsic mode network, let's call it. And these two networks are strongly anti-correlated in the brain. So one will turn on, and the other one will turn off, and vice versa. And when that anti-correlation muddies, you get cognitive deficits. So, we think that the CloudStream might be built to allow for this anti-correlation effect. So, going back to the sort of earlier part of our conversation, let's conceptualize the CloudStream as receiving a routing signal from some prefrontal cortex region saying, let's turn on network A, let's turn on the default mode network. Right, right. You don't want to accidentally also activate the other network that should be turned off at that time.
Nick JikomesRight. You specifically want to ignore the stuff that's external to you and focus on the autobiographical component. Right.
Brian MathurExactly. So we think that there are some internal circuitry there that would allow for that shutting off of one network and allowing for the initiation or instantiation of the other network and vice versa. And so that's where it's really a Klaustrom microcircuit problem that because the advent of some really cool viral technology that has come out recently, we're able to start tackling this in mice.
Nick JikomesInteresting. Interesting. Yeah. So, so at the anatomic level and at the functional level, to the extent what you just said is true and you need to have these networks anti-correlated one off while one is on, the classroom needs to be sort of hooked up to all of them, but in different ways so that, you know, while it's having an excited net excitatory effect, say in one set of regions, it's having a net inhibitory effect in another set. And so it has to, it has to be connected to all of them, but in different ways so that you can sort of selectively turn on or turn up certain regions while you're doing the opposite to other regions.
Brian MathurYeah, exactly. This goes back to the train station analogy, where certain trains will go into the station, then go to certain destinations, not to every destination. Right, right, right. Let me tell you, that was a lot of work to figure that one out. A PhD student in my lab, Humain Qadir, performed a heroic study to figure that out. He recorded from 1050 neurons, one at a time, one at a time, twice. Yeah. After doing you know, selectively activating certain inputs optogenetically and recording from target specified neurons.
Brian MathurThat was a tour de force that came through despite COVID. So yeah. Yeah.
Nick JikomesYeah. And I guess it's just worth emphasizing for people, you know, we are now and have been for a little while in an age where, you know, people like Brian and other neuroscientists, they can go in and really look, literally look and literally disturb or activate different circuits sort of one at a time, specific cells and specific regions. And so. You know, neuroscientists are quite literally disentangling all of the gory details on how these very, very specific circuits and specific parts of the brain are actually behaving in real time, pretty much.
Brian MathurYeah, gory is a good word.
Nick JikomesYeah. Brian, this is fascinating stuff. I love kind of looking through your research and what you're doing. Is there anything that you want to reiterate from our discussion or any final thoughts you want to leave people with about the general subjects that we touched on today?
Brian MathurYeah, I'll just say that, you know, in the middle there, we talked about alcohol and the basal ganglia, and I think that the claustrum is related to basal ganglia function hierarchically. Just to bring it all together for your audience, it might seem that we had two different conversations, but they're actually pretty related. We talked about how the claustrum is involved in in performing cognitively difficult behaviors that recruit prefrontal cortices and networks involved with prefrontal cortex. But that all gets funneled down and processed in the basal ganglia.
Brian MathurAnd so the way we conceptualize this is that the classroom in rodents at least is involved in cognitively demanding tasks and performing action strategies that demand flexibility and that that process might be affected by alcohol, which would further contribute to the expression of inflexible behaviors, simple stimulus response behaviors that can be performed without the claustrum or in the face of claustrum dysfunction, secondary to alcohol exposure. So that's really what we're looking into now is basal ganglia mediated behaviors. while manipulating claustrum in the ways that alcohol does.
Brian MathurSo we're trying to model what's going on and come to a sort of broader systems interaction view of what's going on in health and in response to alcohol exposure. Yeah.
Nick JikomesAll right. Well, Professor Brian Mather, thanks again for your time. Fascinating stuff.
Brian MathurThanks, Nick. It was a real pleasure.
Nick JikomesHey everyone, a great way to support my efforts is to visit my support page at mindandmatter.substack.com. A link to that page is in the episode description, or you can search for it on the Substack page itself. The support page has an up-to-date list of my affiliate partners. These are companies I work with, and if you buy those products through those links or using the discount codes provided, those will get you a great deal on a variety of products related to optimizing physical, metabolic, or mental health and vitality. These are all products I use myself, and some of them are directly related to podcast episodes or formulated by Mind & Matter guests. For example, there's a great product called Keto Citra formulated by a kidney biologist who is on episode number 186. It contains the ketone body BHB together with several minerals in a precise ratio formulated with kidney health in mind. There are also links to products like physical technology devices to track your metabolic health, digital applications to help you find and learn about food and consumer products, and more.
Nick JikomesOne product I use every day is the AquaTrue water filter. I recommend this to everyone because it gets everything out of your drinking water, heavy metals, microbes, endocrine disruptors, microplastics, you name it. Other charcoal or gravity-based filters that a lot of people use don't get everything out, they just get some of the stuff out. So I really like the AquaTrue product. You can look for a link to my affiliate partners on my support page or directly in the episode description to this episode, or you can go to mindandmatter.substack.com to find it there.
Send us Fan Mail At 93, Artemis Simopoulos explains why oils once used in paint now dominate the food supply, how a high omega-6 intake slows the making of EPA and DHA, and why cholesterol-lowering corn oil did not...
Send us Fan Mail Keith Baar explains why tendons stop adapting after 10 minutes of loading, why long low-load holds beat fast reps for connective tissue, and how vitamin C, collagen, caffeine and mTOR shape training....
Send us Fan Mail Dr. Stephen O'Rahilly explains GDF15, a stress hormone that makes us feel sick and eat less, and why morning sickness, and its severe form hyperemesis gravidarum (HG), comes from GDF15 made by the...
Send us Fan Mail Robin Carhart-Harris explains why his trial of psilocybin therapy vs. the SSRI escitalopram for depression missed one primary measure but favored psilocybin on almost everything else, and why SSRIs can...
Send us Fan Mail Nick talks with Prof. Gary Lewin (Max Delbrück Center, Berlin) about naked mole-rats, which in lab tests survived 18 minutes in pure nitrogen by shutting down brain activity, keeping the heart beating,...