Fifty years ago, psychologist Robert Guthrie first wrote the book, "Even the Rat was White." It provided a nuanced, historical record of psychology, looked at the role that white supremacist bias played in the field and highlighted the critical work of Black psychologists. Tuesday on Midday Edition, we look at the legacy of the book. Guests: Ricardo Guthrie, professor of social justice, Fisk University Judy Sundayo, clinical psychologist, professor emeritus at Mesa College; president of Association of Black Psychologists, San Diego chapter
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome in San Diego. It's Jade Hindman on this episode of KPBS Midday Edition. It's been 50 years since Even the Rat Was White was written. We look at the book's impact on psychology and research. This is KPBS Midday Edition , connecting our communities through conversation. It's been 50 years since psychologist Robert Guthrie wrote the book Even the Rat Was White. It provided a nuanced historical record of psychology and looked at the role that white supremacist bias played in the field.
The book was also the first to highlight the critical work of black psychologists. Tonight , the San Diego State or the San Diego Central Library is hosting an event to discuss the book's legacy. I'm joined now by Ricardo Guthrie. He's a professor of social justice at Fisk University and Robert Guthrie's son. Professor Guthrie , welcome to the show. Oh , thanks for having me. Glad to have you here. Also with us is Judy Sando. She's a licensed clinical psychologist and professor emeritus at Mesa College. Currently , she's the president of the Association of Black Psychologists chapter in San Diego.
Professor Sandhya , welcome to you , too. Thank you so much , Jade. It's wonderful to be here. Glad to have you both here. Professor Guthrie , before we get into the book , I want to talk about your father , Robert. What kind of man was he? And how would you describe him? Well , my father was , I think , a maverick in many ways. He was a twin. So of the twins , his brother got the family name Paul Guthrie , and he got Robert. And so I feel like he was always trying to lead people in ways that were non-traditional.
And I say he's a maverick because he he was a musician. And when he got to Florida A&M , he switched over into psychology and I think midway through his his years , he decided to join the Air Force , much to the consternation of his father and also his twin brother. So he was always looking for something different to do , I would say. He went to my alma mater , of course. Well , yes. I am very much educated in that , in the tradition. Um , how were you reflecting on your father's legacy since the publication of the book?
Well , I thought that it's a bittersweet memory because he's put a lot of work into it. And 50 years later , I wanted to ask , is it still relevant? Are people still using it? And it's no surprise. Of course they are. And I've checked with many people at Fisk and in throughout the HBCU networks , the historically black college network , and it's still being used. And yet when I try to find it , it wasn't prominent on the Pearson Book Pearson book web page. So my goal this year was to try to revive , I think , the interest so that a new generation can learn it.
So the bittersweet part was like , how much has changed in 50 years and how much has stayed the same? Right , right. Well , Professor Robert Guthrie was a mentor and colleague of yours. How are you looking back on your own relationship with him and the impact he left on you? Well , I was so honored to have met and known Doctor Guthrie because when I came to San Diego , I was looking for a family as a psychology major.
And when I met Doctor Guthrie , I go , oh , wow , how did he know that? I used to wear a white lab coat and have a white rat and do experimental psychology. And when I read his book , it underscored all of those things that I knew in my heart. And he put them all together and talked about how. The Traditional Western psychology would use statistics to justify berating African-Americans.
So I was very appreciative of Bob's work and found his mentorship completely inspiring. And as you mentioned , you remember your undergraduate training , the the white lab coat , the white rat pigeon. Um , and and you the only black person in your cohort. Um , at the time when you read Guthrie's book , what did it help you recognize about the assumptions built into the training that you were receiving?
Well , one of the things that happens when you are a student , often you don't question your professors. And I think after a while , perhaps when you get to graduate school , you start to think more critically about the research and question your professors and do additional research. And that's what Doctor Guthrie's book did for me. He it really made me think , which is what we should be doing. He used the word in his book bamboozled.
He said , so often we get bamboozled by things that we don't understand. Statistics being one of them. A lot of people don't understand how statistical data can be manipulated and used and misused toward whoever is doing the work toward their ends. And Bob's book made me really think critically about it , and I think it did that for a lot of students who started doing their own research.
It sounds like it totally changed the questions you asked as a psychologist. Yes. Um , I took a college course at Famu with Doctor Dana Dennard called The Psychology of Racism and prejudice , and it really informed how I understand these issues , and it still shapes the questions that I ask , even. Um , Ricardo , when your father examined racism in psychology , how did he connect researchers assumptions to the power of institutions , you know , schools , universities or government agencies?
Well , like most students at that time , he went into the field with a deep dive thinking all this information that I'm sharing from the black experience , the kin clerks and the mami clerks , etc. , that will be part of what we learn. And then he found out that actually it was discounted and that he was teaching a different type of psychology , or learning a different type of psychology than what was being taught. The institutions were teaching deviance , difference and deception. And he was saying his scholars in the Black College Network and elsewhere were saying similarity , equality , things that are um , shared among humanity.
So he was very distressed to say that. Am I being part of this mechanism that's teaching people to hate themselves? No I'm not. I'm teaching something different. And so for him , psychology and the institutions that emerged created a object lesson of what not to do. We can improve on what they did. And I really think he he was working throughout his life to try to improve on the science of psychology , if you will. And I think this book , however , says , well , maybe there's something on the genetic profile of science that is inherently racist.
It's a hard thing to swallow and say , well , that diagnosis might actually be more correct than saying science is just subjective and we just need to be better scientists. Mhm. And well , I want to get into what that actually looked like for people. What are some of the harmful practices that the book pushed back against Professor Sundial? Well , one of the things that was brought out was the whole idea of intelligence testing that you could test and measure the intelligence of people , which we know is fraught with problems.
And you can't really measure intelligence per se , but when you're trying to put down a whole people and it's easy to use data and create instruments that seem very scientific but are inherently flawed. And Doctor Guthrie's book explored that completely. In fact , he talked about one early test that involved memory where black students actually scored higher than white students.
And he said , interestingly enough , those kinds of tests were put back and buried. They weren't put forward because they did not support the idea that blacks were inferior. Mhm. And here in California. The Larry P case um , you know , challenged the use of IQ tests to place black children in certain special education classes for example. Talk about I mean , what did that case reveal about how schools were judging black children's abilities?
Well , I'm glad you brought that up , because even though that case was started back in the early 70s , by the time Doctor Guthrie's book was published , actually , the information in the book informed the judge in that case and helped make that ruling , uh , substantiated so that no longer can people use , um , standardized intelligence test on black children in California to place them in special ed or used to be called , um.
well , it's just , um. Um , what was the old word for , you know , not being smart enough , but you don't call it that anymore. But. Exactly. Don't call. It that. Don't call it that. For people who are in special ed , you can't use standardized intelligence tests. And I believe California is still the only state in the country where you can't use standardized intelligence tests to place black children in developmentally , um , um , special ed classes.
Hmm. Another thing the book explores is the relationship between psychology and eugenics. How did the two intersect? Well , eugenics was put forth as a way to say that there's one race that's better than the other. Placing races in certain categories. Uh , the early Western psychologists. European psychologists believe that Africans , black people , brown people were subpar , primitive , and they use a variety of different measures measuring the head circumference and all kinds of things to try to fit something into their idea of superiority.
And of course , Doctor Guthrie's book brought out how flawed those studies were and how flawed the theories were. But many of those people were the forerunners in the American Psychological Association , the early presidents of the American Psychological Association. And when black psychologists tried to bring this out to them , they refused to see and to accept that a lot of their theories were inherently racist.
They didn't come to that realization until 2021. Right. Well in in 1968 at the APA convention in San Francisco , black psychologists got together and they had certain demands. And the APA refused to meet those demands. And so 200 black psychologists walked out of the APA convention. And that's the birth of the Association of Black Psychologists.
Mhm. I mean , and speak more on that , Professor Guthrie , because the book , even the Rat was White was it was groundbreaking , but it also wasn't without its detractors. So what was the reception like to the book when it first came out? So it was um , it was warmly received by the , the black psychologists who said , okay , now we've got the data , we have the history , we have the biography and the geography of what the landscape looks like. We're not wrong. And surely they will embrace this. Well , I think the vituperative nature of the response says a lot.
They were not willing to accept the the data and the history that Doctor Guthrie put together my father. They in fact , they went on , on , on the attack mode saying , well , that might have been true in the 1930s and 1940s , but clearly we're no longer doing Nazi experiments , etc.. And Doctor Guthrie , my father and others had to say , well , wait a minute , we still have the IQ tests. We still have genetic profiling , we still have sterilization. We still have all the things that happen that we use psychological or mental , um , apparatus , if you will , to try to say you are less than.
And so my book , as difficult as it is , is to say there's a cancer here , let's deal with it. And I'm not going to tell you how to deal with it. That was the way he was pretty much a traditionalist , in the sense that my role as a scientist is to show what the problems are. Your role as a social policy person or a social worker , etc. is to find the correct policy. And I can make some suggestions , but I've already hit the the goal posts right. And and I've made scores , so let's move on from there. Well , the the Association of Black Psychologists has really advanced African centered approaches to psychology and healing.
Talk about the , you know , what understanding of a person and their relationship to family and community guides that work. Well. There's a long history of saying that the black experience is underreported and under understood. And the idea that our superpower really are our families and our extended networks , and the way we use traditional ways of knowing in untraditional ways. And the example I use always is the Jubilee Singers at Fisk University taking coded language from the black experience , work songs , blues , etc. and saying one thing that's heard by black folks and another that's heard by the dominant society and in many ways , the black families , the African traditions that have been carried forward.
That's the secret sauce. That's the part that we use to try to keep ourselves together in the midst of the storm. And so many of the psychologists now who say , well , actually , we don't have to reinvent it. Let's go back and find what was there. The Sankofa experience. Go back and bring it forward. There's something there that we have to use. And then those folks , like my father would say , well , I'm an American. I'm not necessarily ready to be an African philosopher , but I can see where you're going with this in our music and our culture and our language and the way we use our bodies and our lives , and indeed does have this African influence that we should name and embrace.
Well. Professor Sundiata , what work needs to be done to continue developing the field and make sure this past that Robert Guthrie documented is not forgotten. What a great question. I think that we need to continue in terms of his legacy to mentor our students , encourage and inspire them. The future belongs to them. The Association of Black Psychologists has created a wonderful healing strategy called Emotional Emancipation Circles.
And these are healing circles that are happening now around the country to get together and have African-Americans of all ages confront the myths and lies of racism and white superiority and encourage the students to share these experiences. We've never really had a national Movement to heal from the , um , the horror horrors of enslavement for over three centuries.
So these healing circles are giving black families a chance to heal. I've been speaking with Ricardo Guthrie , professor of social justice at Fisk University , and Judy Sandia , licensed clinical psychologist , professor emeritus at Mesa College , and president of the local ABC chapter. They'll both be at the San Diego Central Library tonight to talk more about. Even the rat was white. The event starts at 6:30 p.m.. We'll link to more details on our website , KPBS.
Professor Guthrie , professor San Diego , thank you so very much for this conversation. Oh , thank you Jade. It's wonderful. Thank you so much for having us.
It is a busy week in arts and culture in San Diego. For a special edition of Midday Movies, KPBS Cinema Junkie Beth Accomando taps a James Bond aficionado to talk about Monday's announcement that actor Robert Pattinson...
San Diego's coast has been experiencing high surf in recent weeks, along with wetter weather. That has led to coastal flooding in some areas. El Niño's impacts are expected to be particularly damaging to San Diego's...
On Tuesday, the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) announced that the United States lost its measles elimination status. That means the disease has been circulating nationwide for more than one year. The...
An 8-year-old Haitian child taken into federal custody by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement in San Diego reunited with his family Monday. The Haitian Bridge Alliance, a local immigrants' rights advocacy group and...
On Monday, the San Diego City Council unanimously voted to end the use of automated license plate reader (ALPR) cameras in the city. The decision comes after several council members changed their stances on the...