Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Microbiome Medics

Microbiome Medics artwork

The Only Good Germ is a Dead Germ? A Surgeon's Radical Rethink with Prof John Alverdy

Aug 13, 20251 hr 8 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode, Dr Siobhan McCormack is in conversation with Professor John Alverdy from the University of Chicago, a Professor of Surgery and a pioneer in microbiome research. They explore the crucial link between gut health and surgical outcomes, particularly in addressing post-operative infections and complications. The conversation highlights the significance of the gut microbiome in healing, revealing that many infections may stem from the patient's own flora. The episode also tackles the implications of widespread antibiotic use and the need for prudent stewardship to protect beneficial gut microbes. This podcast is brought to you in collaboration with the British Society of Lifestyle Medicine. Disclaimer: The content in this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your doctor or qualified healthcare provider. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have heard on this podcast.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Intro and Outro: Hello and welcome to the Microbiome Medics Podcast. I'm Dr. Siobhan McCormack. Intro and Outro: And I'm Dr. Sheena Fraser, and we're your co-hosts. We are both GPs and lifestyle Intro and Outro: medics with a shared passion for microbiome science. Intro and Outro: We'll be translating the evidence and packaging it into actionable, Intro and Outro: bite-sized chunks so that you could harness the power of the microbiome to improve Intro and Outro: your own health and that of your patients. Siobhan McCormack: Hello and welcome. I'm Dr. Siobhan McCormack and today's microbiome medics topic,

Siobhan McCormack: which is the role of the gut microbiome in surgery, has kind of blown my mind Siobhan McCormack: mainly due to the work of today's guest. Siobhan McCormack: So microbiome science draws on many disciplines, microbiology, Siobhan McCormack: gastroenterology, genomics, ecology, evolutionary medicine, metabolomics, Siobhan McCormack: machine learning, the list goes on and on, but I have to say I've never really Siobhan McCormack: considered surgery to be a central part of this team. Siobhan McCormack: That changes today because of this professor from the University of Chicago. Siobhan McCormack: He's a colorectal surgeon, a gut microbiome research pioneer,

Siobhan McCormack: the world-renowned expert in post-operative infections, and a radical thinker Siobhan McCormack: whose research findings on the role of gut bacteria in post-operative infections Siobhan McCormack: I think have practical applications far beyond the Operating Theatre. Siobhan McCormack: Professor John Alverde, welcome. John Alverdy: Thank you so much, Siobhan, Dr. McCormick, for the invitation to join. John Alverdy: And it is an honor and a pleasure to be here. John Alverdy: And we will just freely associate.

Siobhan McCormack: Absolutely. Well, I wonder if I can start by asking you to introduce yourself to the listeners. John Alverdy: Sure. So I am a general surgeon, a general gastrointestinal surgery. John Alverdy: My clinical practice was focused on the foregut, the esophagus, John Alverdy: the stomach, the gallbladder, the pancreatic obiliary tree. John Alverdy: And I became interested in, John Alverdy: with colorectal surgery because it has a high failure of healing when two pieces

John Alverdy: of bowel are brought together. John Alverdy: And it's particularly problematic when a leak occurs in the colon anastomosis, John Alverdy: which has the highest density of bacteria. And, you know, it's a life-threatening problem. John Alverdy: People don't like to talk about it. People don't like to admit that they've John Alverdy: had leaks, but no surgeon is immune. John Alverdy: You know, there's no surgeon that I know of in the best hospitals in the United John Alverdy: States and in the United Kingdom that has not suffered this complication.

John Alverdy: And when it happens, it's devastating to both the patient and the surgeon because John Alverdy: it's rare, but it is life altering, because the surgeon, we call them the second victim, John Alverdy: feels that something he or she did had something to do with this thing not healing, John Alverdy: because so many times it does heal. John Alverdy: And it's been dogmatically explained away by surgeons as a technical error,

John Alverdy: which we think we've dispelled that. John Alverdy: It's not due to a technical error. How is it that you got 90% of them correct John Alverdy: and only 10% of them leaked? How did that happen? John Alverdy: Well, you know, it's biology. It's complex. John Alverdy: It has to do with the tension and ischemia and this and that. John Alverdy: And they explain it away without any hard evidence. Siobhan McCormack: Most people, including your non-surgical colleagues, have a pretty two-dimensional Siobhan McCormack: view of colorectal surgeons. Siobhan McCormack: You know, you go to work, you open someone up, you wield your scalpel,

Siobhan McCormack: you do some magic stuff, you close up, you drive home, you come in the next Siobhan McCormack: day and do the same again. Siobhan McCormack: What does being a surgeon mean to you? John Alverdy: Being a surgeon means that you have to see the patient, understand their pathology. John Alverdy: Prepare the patient and the family for what you're about to do. John Alverdy: Then you have to get there early in the morning, John Alverdy: talk to the family, talk to the patient, make sure everything is properly checked

John Alverdy: off, that they've stopped any anticoagulation, that their medications have been stopped, John Alverdy: that they were nothing to eat or drink after midnight, John Alverdy: that their bowel, for example, if you're doing colorectal surgery, John Alverdy: that their bowel has been properly prepared for the surgery. John Alverdy: And then you do your surgery, which can take four or five hours, John Alverdy: but then you worry after that because you know you're depending on the patient's John Alverdy: nature, their biology to heal what you've done.

John Alverdy: And there's some uncertainty there, Yet you have to be at the ready to meet John Alverdy: any challenge that you're faced with, whether it be an infection, John Alverdy: bleeding, any kind of postoperative problem. John Alverdy: And, you know, I think non-surgeons think of this, or maybe the lay public, as a manual task. John Alverdy: It's just a person performing a manual task when there's so many judgments that John Alverdy: take place, so much of an intellectual discipline that takes place before you.

John Alverdy: Do the actual surgery. So this is an old aphorism in surgery. They say, you know, John Alverdy: great surgeons know when to operate. John Alverdy: Even better surgeons know how to operate. But the best surgeons know when not to operate. Siobhan McCormack: Wow. Yeah. John Alverdy: And so that aphorism is sort of like, you know, how do you make a judgment that you should not operate? John Alverdy: So I don't know if you've ever read the book, Cutting for Stone,

John Alverdy: you know, he wrote in there, I violated, when he operated on a patient that John Alverdy: died on the table, he said, I violated the first commandment of surgery, John Alverdy: never operate on the day of the patient's death. John Alverdy: I thought that was brilliant. Siobhan McCormack: Yeah, I mean, you do, I do, I've listened to a few of your talks, Siobhan McCormack: you do seem to draw from literature and from, you know, the past, Siobhan McCormack: And there was one quote, which I think you recommended your students read, a paper by Crummel,

Siobhan McCormack: which was 2006 or something. Siobhan McCormack: Surgery is not an operation, but an intellectual discipline. John Alverdy: That's correct. Siobhan McCormack: And I've just never thought of it like that. Siobhan McCormack: If we can, we don't often get to go to the theatre. Siobhan McCormack: I haven't done it for years. You know, I qualified in 1989. And I remember the Siobhan McCormack: theatre is quite a frightening place. I always seem to get the scrubbing up Siobhan McCormack: wrong and it seemed very kind of intriguing and mysterious. Siobhan McCormack: So can we invite the listeners into your operating room at the University of Chicago?

Siobhan McCormack: Can you show us around? What are you wearing? What does the room look like? Siobhan McCormack: And can you introduce us to some of the team? John Alverdy: Sure. So, you know, the first thing you do is you're wearing surgical attire John Alverdy: so that you're dressed properly. John Alverdy: And you first have to go to a bin and pick up ostensibly sterile clothes that you put on. Siobhan McCormack: Are they still greens? John Alverdy: They're greens, they're greens, we call them greens, yeah. And then you,

John Alverdy: walk into the operating room and make sure that the patient's positioned properly John Alverdy: for the operation that you're going to do. John Alverdy: Then you introduce yourself to the nurse. And there's two nurses, John Alverdy: the circulating nurse and the nurse that's going to be the scrub tech who's John Alverdy: going to hand off the instruments. John Alverdy: There's the anesthesiologist and his or her team of people to put the patient John Alverdy: to sleep and make sure that they're secure and that they will give blood when needed, et cetera. John Alverdy: And they have a very important job. And so you had this whole team.

John Alverdy: And then you have, at least at the university, you have, you know, John Alverdy: students, residents, and fellows who are there to train and learn from you. John Alverdy: And, you know, I always find it fascinating that at least in British English, you call it theater. John Alverdy: We call it an operating room because it actually is a theater. John Alverdy: There is a performance going on. And there is an audience watching this performance. John Alverdy: And, you know, the performance is supposed to, you know, have the right crescendo, John Alverdy: decrescendo, and it's all supposed to be beautiful and timely and,

John Alverdy: you know, orchestrated, choreographed properly. John Alverdy: And so I think theater is a better word than room. It's not a room. It is a theater. Siobhan McCormack: Yeah. I remember being quite frightened just scrubbing up. And I don't know if Siobhan McCormack: you can just go through from memory for me Siobhan McCormack: it was you know I was kind of terrified of one was looking at Siobhan McCormack: me to make sure I was doing it properly when you went as a medical student to Siobhan McCormack: watch an operation and it seemed quite a Siobhan McCormack: laborious process that could go on for five or ten minutes you Siobhan McCormack: were you know had to be really careful you have these special trough-like basins

Siobhan McCormack: and you moved the taps with your elbows so that you didn't touch anything with Siobhan McCormack: your hands and you you got a brush and you were brushing we had to brush for Siobhan McCormack: like five minutes we had these slightly frightening nurses looking over us And Siobhan McCormack: if so much as moved or touched the wall slightly, Siobhan McCormack: they were then like, no, stop, start again. Siobhan McCormack: You have to take everything off and, you know, start again. Is it still like that? John Alverdy: Yes. And, you know... John Alverdy: One of the myths or dogmas that we're trying to dispel is that all infections

John Alverdy: from surgery come from some type of external contamination event. John Alverdy: So you bumped into something, something fell out of your nose or your hair or whatever it is. John Alverdy: And so to maintain sterility in the operating room is very important. John Alverdy: You scrub for a long time, you have the right clothes on, you know, John Alverdy: you cover your head. And people keep trying to study this. John Alverdy: And thankfully, and a lot of this work was done in the United Kingdom where, John Alverdy: you know, we've gone from the 1920s to today to go from where we had a 30% infection

John Alverdy: rate after surgery down to somewhere about 5% or 10%. It's low. John Alverdy: And that's because of the sterility and the antibiotics and all the other precautions that we take. Siobhan McCormack: So that has worked to an extent, but then we're going to talk about where it's Siobhan McCormack: not working or where actually there are problems. Siobhan McCormack: So I know that you consider the patient the most important person in the room. Siobhan McCormack: So I don't know if you or I can conjure up a typical case that I think you might

Siobhan McCormack: see or whether you wanted to sort of paint a picture of a patient or? John Alverdy: Sure. So a typical patient would be, you know, a patient who, John Alverdy: would undergo, let's say, a colon removal, you know, removing their colon because John Alverdy: they either have inflammation or a cancer. John Alverdy: And you would make a, I'm going to stay in the field of maximally invasive surgery,

John Alverdy: not minimally invasive. John Alverdy: So, you'd make a big incision down the middle of their abdomen, John Alverdy: and you'd open them and sterilely prep everything. John Alverdy: So, you'd make the incision after you've prepped and draped them and, John Alverdy: you know, made sure that you maintained sterility, gloved and all that stuff. John Alverdy: And then you'd make an incision and you put in a wound protector to protect the edges of the wound. John Alverdy: And then you would do the operation, which is to remove part of their colon John Alverdy: and then take the piece that you've removed, the two ends, and connect them together.

Siobhan McCormack: And that's what you call anastomosis. John Alverdy: That's what we call anastomosis, right? And, you know, back to your other point, John Alverdy: I just want to throw in one anecdote, which I found very interesting. John Alverdy: I went to medical school in Mexico and watched babies being delivered by a midwife. John Alverdy: All came out normal. Then I came to the United States where I spent a year at John Alverdy: Loyola University's medical school.

John Alverdy: I remember walking into this operating room and bumping, to your point, John Alverdy: bumping into the IV pole, the intravenous pole that was holding the IV fluids. John Alverdy: And I bumped to it, and the professor yelled at me. He said, John Alverdy: who's this medical student? What the hell is he doing in here? John Alverdy: Go back and scrub again, to your point about the nurses watching over you. John Alverdy: And I'm back there scrubbing, and I re-draped and everything. John Alverdy: And I thought to myself, and it was a delivery. John Alverdy: I don't know why I was in this particular case. But I said to myself,

John Alverdy: does this person know that like 90% of the babies delivered on this earth are not delivered this way? John Alverdy: It's not in a sterile operating room. John Alverdy: It's like out in the open in their home by a midwife who's, you know, John Alverdy: being as clean as they can. John Alverdy: But, you know, and all the babies look normal to me that I was watching being delivered to Mexico. John Alverdy: And I had come to the United States and, you know, we're in this operating theater John Alverdy: and, you know, everything's sterile and don't touch anything. John Alverdy: Thing in your life, wait a minute, John Alverdy: this is kind of at odds with what goes on in the rest of the world.

Siobhan McCormack: And I suppose it's all based on the germ theory of disease trumps everything still. Siobhan McCormack: And this idea that all microbes, particularly bacteria, are all highly pathogenic Siobhan McCormack: and dangerous and must be avoided at all costs. Siobhan McCormack: And I suppose this whole, you know, microbiome science has completely revolutionized Siobhan McCormack: the way we think about microbes, that a small percentage, Siobhan McCormack: I don't know if you know the percentage I'm guessing I don't Siobhan McCormack: know I read somewhere six to ten percent of all the Siobhan McCormack: bacteria on earth are potentially pathogenic to

Siobhan McCormack: man but most of them are either disinterested or free Siobhan McCormack: riders but then we've got this group that are incredibly beneficial Siobhan McCormack: and so it's this idea of this kind Siobhan McCormack: of you know ecosystem within where we're always Siobhan McCormack: focusing on the few bad guys or and Siobhan McCormack: we'll talk about that because there's no such thing and we'll talk about Siobhan McCormack: sort of virulence and virulence factors later on but um Siobhan McCormack: yeah so it is kind of really interesting uh Siobhan McCormack: but it's also interesting how difficult it Siobhan McCormack: is to change shift perspectives uh

Siobhan McCormack: even in the face of you know very good evidence but um so this this you know Siobhan McCormack: let's say this 43 year old uh gentleman that we're operating on maybe the father Siobhan McCormack: of two kids um he's you know incredibly anxious he's been diagnosed with colorectal Siobhan McCormack: cancer at a young age, which maybe we'll discuss again later. Siobhan McCormack: Maybe he's had some chemotherapy, radiotherapy. Siobhan McCormack: Maybe he's not in good health generally, if he's anything like the normal population. Siobhan McCormack: A poor diet, lots of ultra-processed food. He may have other pre-diabetes.

Siobhan McCormack: He may be on a couple of medications. Siobhan McCormack: His family are waiting outside anxiously. It's all depending on you. Siobhan McCormack: How does that feel for the surgeon? John Alverdy: Yeah. So, you know, we work in teams. John Alverdy: You know, most of the time that patient will be, John Alverdy: at least over the course of my life, I've seen that responsibility was originally John Alverdy: all on the surgeon to know what medications to stop,

John Alverdy: which ones to start to prepare the patient beforehand. John Alverdy: And now all of our patients go to pre-op anesthesia clinic, where an anesthesiologist John Alverdy: spends time with the patient, goes through their medications, John Alverdy: and then tells them which ones to stop, which ones to take, John Alverdy: and reinforces what the surgeon's preferences are for that particular operation. John Alverdy: But to your point, no patient goes to the operating theater that has no disease.

John Alverdy: These are sick people. And I think that's what you're trying to paint the picture. John Alverdy: This patient's coming to the operating room because they have a disease. John Alverdy: That disease might be cancer. John Alverdy: And not all, but most cancer patients have underlying comorbidities, John Alverdy: to your point, diabetes, hypertension, obesity, etc. John Alverdy: And, you know, we're all trying to be as healthy as we can be, John Alverdy: but some people aren't as healthy as a doctor thinks they should be.

John Alverdy: And therefore, they're now about to undergo an operation. John Alverdy: And, you know, many times we'll see a patient and we will send them to their John Alverdy: general medical doctor for what we call medical clearance. John Alverdy: And I'm about to do a four-hour operation. Is this the best shape you can get John Alverdy: them in for their diabetes? John Alverdy: Is this the best shape you can get them in for their hypertension? John Alverdy: Is this the best shape you can get them in for their weight problem? John Alverdy: And can, you know, how urgent is the surgery has to be balanced against how

John Alverdy: much time, you know, you have. John Alverdy: And these days, I think, you know, we like to think of, for elective surgery, time is your friend. John Alverdy: You know, most people that are old, they have an orthopedic problem. John Alverdy: It's not urgent. John Alverdy: They've had the pain for months, if not years, and they're about to undergo John Alverdy: a big operation. And, you know, time is your friend. John Alverdy: You could wait a week or two or a month, and we'll get into that later,

John Alverdy: which we call dietary prehabilitation. John Alverdy: You know, what is the impact of dietary prehabilitation on outcome from surgery? John Alverdy: That's going to be a big issue over the next 10, 20 years is can you get somebody John Alverdy: in better shape and improve outcome? Because, John Alverdy: Um, as I mentioned before, we've gone from 30% infection rate down to 10%, which is good. John Alverdy: Thank, thank you to all the antibiotics and the sterility and attention to detail.

John Alverdy: But how do we move the needle from 10% down to zero? John Alverdy: You're like more of the same. Just do more of what you're doing, John Alverdy: more sterility, more antibiotics. John Alverdy: And the answer is no, because antibiotics are indiscriminate in their killing. John Alverdy: They kill the good guys and the bad guys. John Alverdy: And you're like, well, sterility, more sterility. No, you're killing both the John Alverdy: good bacteria and the bad bacteria. John Alverdy: Well, okay, how about selective use? Nothing selective.

John Alverdy: And it's a one-size-fits-all to everybody. John Alverdy: I call it, in the United States, we use a drug called cephalosporins. John Alverdy: And I call it, it's the cephalo du jour. whatever it is that day. John Alverdy: Whatever drug you're using that day, you just use it for everybody. John Alverdy: Oh, you're doing colon surgery? Well, everybody gets this cephalo du jour. John Alverdy: Oh, you're doing stomach surgery? Well, everybody gets this cephalo du jour. John Alverdy: And remember, at least in the United States, there's 100,000 elective operations done every day.

John Alverdy: And every one of those patients gets an antibiotic. John Alverdy: So you start to think 100,000 every day times 365 days. John Alverdy: And so we live in a world of human progress where we have antibiotics, John Alverdy: but we are probably overusing them. John Alverdy: And yet we don't know how to stop. Siobhan McCormack: So if we go back to our patient, let's call him Harry, you know, Siobhan McCormack: we're scrubbing up, you're showing me how to do it beautifully, Siobhan McCormack: everyone is using aseptic techniques. Siobhan McCormack: What has he had before, just before and during the operation to reduce his chances of infection?

John Alverdy: You brought this point up before, and it's been shown to be very important that, John Alverdy: the anxiety the night before, you know, we always say, get a good night's sleep John Alverdy: and don't eat or drink anything after midnight. Right. John Alverdy: Well, imagine you're about to get cut open. You know it's going to hurt. John Alverdy: You're going to have pain. You don't know what the doctor is going to find, John Alverdy: the surgeon is going to find. John Alverdy: And you're hoping they just find what was seen on the imaging studies, John Alverdy: that the tumor is localized.

John Alverdy: And you have all that. And, you know, I ask my patients, how'd you sleep last John Alverdy: night? Most of them say, I didn't sleep at all. What are you talking about? John Alverdy: I had to be here at 6 o'clock in the morning. John Alverdy: How could I sleep? I woke up at 4 o'clock to drive an hour and a half to get to the hospital. John Alverdy: And so there's that element that plays a role. John Alverdy: And if you're doing a bowel prep, which means they drink that stuff, John Alverdy: we call it go lightly. It's polyethylene glycol. John Alverdy: They're up all night pooping. you know John Alverdy: it just doesn't stop you know that we say start drinking at you know 12 or 2

John Alverdy: o'clock in the afternoon and then they're still pooping way into midnight 1 John Alverdy: o'clock in the morning they might feel an urge and go and so nobody gets any John Alverdy: sleep and then they can't eat and they're hungry and they can't eat the you John Alverdy: know they can't have breakfast, John Alverdy: if they're having surgery between 6 and 9 o'clock in the morning and so. John Alverdy: This is a very stressed individual whose microbiome has been altered by the John Alverdy: bowel prep, by the use of antibiotics, by the prep and draping.

John Alverdy: We decontaminate the skin. John Alverdy: You're like, what do you decontaminate the skin of? John Alverdy: Everything. What do you use? John Alverdy: Iodine, chlorhexidine, alcohol, whatever we can get our hands on that will just John Alverdy: kill everything. Do you want to kill everything? John Alverdy: Well, I want to kill the good guys and the bad guys, and I don't know who's John Alverdy: good or bad, so I kill everything. It's kind of like war. John Alverdy: You know, unfortunately, there's going to be collateral damage. Siobhan McCormack: So if we go to, I mean, the aim is to reduce surgical site infections and anastomotic

Siobhan McCormack: leaks in a colorectal operation like this. Siobhan McCormack: What would be the rates of surgical site infection and anastomotic leaks? Siobhan McCormack: Because there's quite a wide variation. John Alverdy: Yes. So I always say that if a famous hospital, John Alverdy: either in the United States or in the United kingdom could stand up and go, John Alverdy: we have the lowest infection rate of any operation involving the colorectal, John Alverdy: they would do it in a minute. John Alverdy: It'd be the best marketing campaign ever. And nobody can do it.

John Alverdy: And because if you have surgery, if you have colorectal surgery in the UK or John Alverdy: in the United States, the first thing the surgeon will do is give you an informed John Alverdy: consent. We'll say, okay. John Alverdy: You know, the chances of you having an anastomotic leak are low, but they're not zero. John Alverdy: And they're somewhere in the literature between 5% and 10%. John Alverdy: And you're like, well, can't you pick the surgeon that, you know,

John Alverdy: has the lowest, you know, anastomotic leak rate? John Alverdy: No, because no surgeon is immune. John Alverdy: And most surgeons don't want to count their anastomosis leaks. John Alverdy: They want to forget them. Siobhan McCormack: Why do surgeons dread anastomotic leaks and they don't dread surgical site infections in the same way? John Alverdy: Yeah, because a surgical site infection usually is superficial. John Alverdy: And over 90% of the time, it can be treated without doing surgery.

John Alverdy: You can open the wound up a little bit. John Alverdy: You can clean it up, put a wick in there, give some antibiotics, and you're done. John Alverdy: We call all surgical site infections about 10%. John Alverdy: Most of them are superficial. A few are what are called deep organ space infections, John Alverdy: where around the area that you operated on, the cavity, the lung, John Alverdy: the pleural cavity, or the abdominal cavity, there is an abscess. John Alverdy: And it's usually next to the area that you operated on.

John Alverdy: And that's called an organ space infection, deep, you know, next to an organ. John Alverdy: And that usually has to do with something not healing properly. John Alverdy: Because just think of all the operations you do. You say, well, don't spill anything. John Alverdy: Just be careful. And you're like, oh, so the infections only occur when the John Alverdy: surgeon wasn't careful. No, not true. John Alverdy: So, you mean they occur even when they're careful? Yes. So, can a surgeon predict

John Alverdy: which patient is going to develop a leak or an infection? They can't. And it's been studied. John Alverdy: There's a study from the Netherlands where they said to the surgeon, John Alverdy: you know your patient, they're 85 years old, we'll call them hairy, John Alverdy: you know what you've done, it took you four hours, you did a bowel prep, you did everything. John Alverdy: You tell me on a probability scale of 0% to 100% what you think the chances of a leak are. John Alverdy: And they correlated it. They documented it.

John Alverdy: And the surgeon, oh, this patient's 85, diabetic. This case took four hours. John Alverdy: I spilled all this crap. This one's going to leak. Didn't leak. John Alverdy: They were wrong more than they were right. John Alverdy: And so the ability to predict, you know, is always with hindsight bias baked into it. John Alverdy: In other words, the surgeon, when they have a leak, they'll be like, John Alverdy: I knew that patient was going to leak. John Alverdy: I knew they were going to leak. They're 85 years old. It took forever. John Alverdy: I knew this was going to happen. John Alverdy: And they forgot all the times they operated on an 85-year-old in the same circumstances

John Alverdy: that did not leak or did not develop an infection. We call that confirmation bias. John Alverdy: You confirm your own bias by looking at things in hindsight. John Alverdy: And we all do it. You know, we can't. John Alverdy: We're human beings. We make judgment errors. Siobhan McCormack: Well, I mean, reading around the subject, this will be known to you, Siobhan McCormack: but I found it astounding, and I think the listeners will as well. Siobhan McCormack: The most sort of post-colorectal surgery, surgical site infections, Siobhan McCormack: originate from the patient's own gut?

John Alverdy: Well, I would say we don't know today which are due to external contamination John Alverdy: and which are due to internal or the patient's own flora contamination. John Alverdy: We don't know because, you know, I'll give you an example. John Alverdy: If your patient develops clostridium difficile infection and it happens to be John Alverdy: on the nurse's fingers or on the sink,

John Alverdy: an infectious disease specialist will say, well, John Alverdy: your patient got multiple antibiotics and the nurse gave it to the patient. John Alverdy: I'm like, how do you know the patient didn't give it to the nurse? John Alverdy: And they're like, well, it's logical. John Alverdy: Was on the nurse's fingernails, it was on the sink. So I'm like, John Alverdy: maybe the patient put it on the sink. John Alverdy: Maybe the patient put it on the, no, no, no, it's, it's, we know. How do you know?

John Alverdy: Did you have a baseline DNA fingerprint of that bacterial strain in that patient John Alverdy: before this happened and after? And they're like, no. John Alverdy: So you didn't vectorially detect this. John Alverdy: You know, you didn't go from person A to person B and have the baseline DNA fingerprint first. John Alverdy: You're like, well, that would be hugely labor intensive. Yes, John Alverdy: but that's the challenge for the next 20 to 30 to 50 years is somebody will do that.

Siobhan McCormack: And you reminded me of crime scene investigations and evidence and will it hold Siobhan McCormack: up in court, which is kind of really interesting. Siobhan McCormack: Let's move on to this subject, which I find amazing. Siobhan McCormack: Why is a colorectal surgeon also doing research into microbiome science? Siobhan McCormack: So when did that happen in your career trajectory? Siobhan McCormack: And was it even microbiome science then, or was it just microbiology? John Alverdy: Yeah, I don't want to mislead the viewers here that I'm a colorectal surgeon.

John Alverdy: I'm a gastrointestinal surgeon. I've done colorectal surgery. John Alverdy: In the United States, there is a special board and a special fellowship for colorectal surgery. John Alverdy: But I've done plenty of colorectal surgery over the course of my career. John Alverdy: Um, but, um, what happened was I was studying the gut microbiome and bacterial virulence in general. John Alverdy: And this woman who was a surgery resident wanted to come into my lab and she

John Alverdy: wanted to go into colorectal surgery, do a fellowship after her general surgery training. John Alverdy: And, um, she said, I want to work in your laboratory, but I want to be a colorectal surgeon, John Alverdy: and I want to study anastomotic leak, could we come up with a hypothesis that John Alverdy: would allow me to study this? John Alverdy: And I said, of course, we'll frame anastomotic leak as an infection, John Alverdy: not as a technical error.

John Alverdy: And we'll prove it. And she did the first study. John Alverdy: Andrea Olivas, She did an amazing study where she took large rats, John Alverdy: did preoperative radiation on them to create sort of a field effect of radiation, John Alverdy: then did the anastomosis. John Alverdy: And then contaminated that anastomosis with a bacterium that we knew had the John Alverdy: capacity to make this collagenase enzyme that eats through the tissue.

John Alverdy: And she proved the hypothesis. John Alverdy: She proved it was not an error in surgical technique, that it was due to the microbe, John Alverdy: expressing this gene that made this gene product, this protein, John Alverdy: collagenase, which bound to the tissues, John Alverdy: ate through the tissues, and caused the leak. John Alverdy: Sort of unambiguously, uncontestably, she proved it. Siobhan McCormack: So just going back to help the listeners, because this is really important. Siobhan McCormack: So when you're cutting through, you need wound healing afterwards.

Siobhan McCormack: And the laying down of collagen is a hugely important part of that. Siobhan McCormack: And also your immune system to recover from wounds and to heal properly. Siobhan McCormack: So you're saying that there are certain bacteria that are found in the gut that produce an enzyme, Siobhan McCormack: called collagenase which actually cuts through Siobhan McCormack: enzymically the collagen that's being laid down Siobhan McCormack: so it's almost undoing all your work if you Siobhan McCormack: like and these collagenases are found

Siobhan McCormack: in in pathogenic bacteria which Siobhan McCormack: are part of the the normal commensal Siobhan McCormack: in the gut when in surgery Siobhan McCormack: if you're sort of giving people lots of antibiotics you alter the balance so Siobhan McCormack: these guys are kind of more uh there's more growth uh they're more um formidable Siobhan McCormack: they're the ones uh have this enzyme so obviously you don't want them around Siobhan McCormack: in large amounts when you're trying to heal because they're We're doing the opposite.

John Alverdy: That's correct. I mean, I think you got the story exactly correct. John Alverdy: And remember that, you know, I call them flesh eating bacteria because I think John Alverdy: the lay public understands that. John Alverdy: Oh, I don't want to get one of those flesh eaters that will eat my face off John Alverdy: or take my arm off. I, you know, I got to avoid that if I cut myself. John Alverdy: You know, just imagine this, and you might know this, Shiv. John Alverdy: You know, if you cut yourself in the garden, John Alverdy: and you go to the emergency room and say, I cut myself and it's really deep,

John Alverdy: they're going to irrigate it and give you antibiotics. No question. John Alverdy: And you might say, how many people that cut themselves actually go and get the John Alverdy: antibiotics versus those that go to the doctor, to the hospital, John Alverdy: and get the antibiotics? What is that balance? John Alverdy: And to what extent are those antibiotics necessary? John Alverdy: And you don't know the answer because you'd have to get all the people that John Alverdy: cut themselves in their garden deeply, and you'd have to find them that did

John Alverdy: not go to the doctor and did not get antibiotics versus those that did and look at the infection rates. John Alverdy: And, you know, I just look in my neighborhood and I think of all the gardeners John Alverdy: I see around here and I'm like, I am sure people have cut themselves deeply John Alverdy: many times and have not gone to the doctor and not received antibiotics and healed perfectly fine. John Alverdy: So what constitutes who's at risk and who isn't? John Alverdy: But in medical practice, I call this guilty knowledge.

John Alverdy: You're the doctor, you're in the emergency room, you have guilty knowledge. John Alverdy: Here's a person who came in, they got a big cut, you're like, John Alverdy: okay, let's irrigate it and give you antibiotics and a tetanus shot. John Alverdy: Why? Because I know you came to me, and that's at risk. John Alverdy: And so I need to do something for you, not nothing. Siobhan McCormack: Okay, let's break that down a bit. So, okay, there's the medico-legal aspect. Siobhan McCormack: So you kind of, you never get sued for doing something. Siobhan McCormack: Even, you know, you will get sued for not doing something. So you kind of think,

Siobhan McCormack: if in doubt, do something. Siobhan McCormack: So there's that pressure. There's also the pressure of social norms. Siobhan McCormack: So we're still in that kind of germ theory of disease. Antibiotics are amazing. Siobhan McCormack: And, you know, my doctor didn't take me seriously. So there always is that kind of worry. Siobhan McCormack: And I suppose for a while in the 80s and Siobhan McCormack: 90s it was look it's not going to do any harm but all Siobhan McCormack: that has changed now because and i Siobhan McCormack: think it's going to be interesting when the first case of Siobhan McCormack: you know that actually you do

Siobhan McCormack: did you inform your patient that it could alter their microbiome they Siobhan McCormack: have you know had their they can prove that they've had sort Siobhan McCormack: of pre-antibiotic post-antibiotic stool samples and they Siobhan McCormack: you wreck their microbiome that's going to be a very Siobhan McCormack: interesting thing so i want to sort of go Siobhan McCormack: back a few steps we talked about your the operating room Siobhan McCormack: uh we talked about your team and how important Siobhan McCormack: they are and how most important person in the room is Siobhan McCormack: the the patient but there is another team i Siobhan McCormack: want to talk about now um who is incredibly important and that's the the team

Siobhan McCormack: of microbes in your gut um this incredible uh sort of facility that we have Siobhan McCormack: who can help us heal after you've done your job and you've closed up, Siobhan McCormack: you need this team to be the best quality possible. Siobhan McCormack: And I just want to talk through that a bit, because I don't know if people understand Siobhan McCormack: how important it is when your immune systems is needed and when you're healing from wounds.

Siobhan McCormack: I mean, what do we know about that in terms of wound healing? John Alverdy: Dr. Yeah, that's a great question. We've just published a paper in Nature Microbiology John Alverdy: that asked that very question. John Alverdy: If you infect a mouse... John Alverdy: That is genetically, all these mice, we infected 20 or 30 of them, John Alverdy: they're all the same genetic background. John Alverdy: Do they fight the infection better with their microbiome or worse with their microbiome?

John Alverdy: So we gave them antibiotics, infected them, and many died. John Alverdy: And the ones that we kept their microbiome intact survived better. John Alverdy: And the ones that we decontaminated and then gave a fecal transplant to did John Alverdy: as well as the ones with an intact microbiome. John Alverdy: So we then discovered that a metabolite in the gut that is produced by the normal microbiota,

John Alverdy: these indoles, they're called, they're from eating tryptophan, which your microbiome. John Alverdy: Metabolizes to indoles. John Alverdy: Those bind to the aryl hydrocarbon receptor on macrophages and turn on these John Alverdy: macrophages to be a little bit more immune activating. John Alverdy: And so all of a sudden, you now see the molecular pathways by which having an John Alverdy: attacked microbiome can activate your immune system to make you not only fight

John Alverdy: infection better, but heal better. John Alverdy: So now, to your point, you're better off with a normal microbiome than a not a normal microbiome. John Alverdy: However, you're coming to the operating theater with a disease. John Alverdy: And you're coming to the operating theater maybe having received chemotherapy John Alverdy: and radiation. And you're coming to the operating theater and you're going to get antibiotics. John Alverdy: And you're going to get everything decontaminated and you're going to get everything sterilized.

John Alverdy: And so all of a sudden, the team that you talk about is being indiscriminately destroyed. John Alverdy: Because going back to the 1920s, we thought, you know, the only good germ is a dead germ. John Alverdy: You know it's i stole that John Alverdy: line probably from some general in the John Alverdy: army or something like that you know uh John Alverdy: you know or at least in america we used to say the only the only

John Alverdy: good indian is a dead indian you know because they John Alverdy: were the they were the foe and you know we were colonizing this country and John Alverdy: so but that was wrong and and this is probably this idea has been good up to John Alverdy: this point but you've made this point before Shiv it's probably not, John Alverdy: the path we're going to take in the future we're going to try to be more. John Alverdy: Selective. And that's why there are, in many battles between friend and foe, there are,

John Alverdy: methods to be more selective in getting at the pathogenic, the bad actors, John Alverdy: if you will. And we don't know how to do that yet. John Alverdy: And so I like to think of the microbiome as just, to your point, John Alverdy: a team that we need to understand. John Alverdy: And how wonderful would it be if we could take that patient, John Alverdy: Harry, that you talked about, this 43-year-old, and we could understand who John Alverdy: is friend and who is foe in there before we operate. John Alverdy: You're like, well, that would take a lot of time and money, right?

John Alverdy: Yeah. Do we do that now? No. John Alverdy: Should we do that? Maybe. John Alverdy: And what are the two most important things that affect the microbiome? Diet, antibiotics. John Alverdy: Are we concerned about those? No. Antibiotics for everybody? John Alverdy: I don't care what diet you're on. You've got a cancer. I've got to get at that thing. John Alverdy: Wait a minute. Let's take a step back here and think about how we might modulate those two things,

John Alverdy: those two major advances that got us from the early 1900s to today and maybe John Alverdy: be a little more selective. John Alverdy: And, you know, scientists hate when you anthropomorphize an argument. John Alverdy: You turn an argument into, you know, something that involves a human interaction. John Alverdy: But, you know, war is no different. Everyone would like the innocent civilians John Alverdy: not to be killed and only the bad actors to be killed. John Alverdy: And it's very hard. How do you preserve the lives of the innocents and just

John Alverdy: get the bad guys to be eliminated. That's no easy task. John Alverdy: And it's the same with the microbiome. Siobhan McCormack: Okay, well, I'm going to add another sociopolitical element to it, Siobhan McCormack: because there's this idea that there are good guys and bad guys in your gut. Siobhan McCormack: And as you know, you've got these microbes, mostly bacteria, in a well-balanced gut. Siobhan McCormack: You may have potential pathogens who just are harmless. Siobhan McCormack: Then we talk about what turns a disinterested bacteria into a potential pathogen

Siobhan McCormack: that can do you harm when other times in your life, it's just sat there doing Siobhan McCormack: nothing and not causing any problems. Siobhan McCormack: And even more interestingly, has benefits in certain conditions. Siobhan McCormack: And then we get to this kind of really complex idea. There's lots of contextual nuances here. Siobhan McCormack: And yet, I kind of always draw on the idea that we're used to watching really Siobhan McCormack: complex detective movies or really complex box sets on Netflix, Siobhan McCormack: which really do show the complexities of any social group. Siobhan McCormack: And I suppose these are Earth's earliest inhabitants, these bacteria,

Siobhan McCormack: Earth's earliest social groups. Siobhan McCormack: And they do reflect a lot of our behaviour. Siobhan McCormack: We've got cooperation in form of cross-feeding, you've got growth, Siobhan McCormack: you've got virulence, you've got competition for resources, the competitive Siobhan McCormack: marketplace, if you like. Siobhan McCormack: You've got rules, it's dynamic, they're responsive, they're Siobhan McCormack: interactive they they create beautiful architectural Siobhan McCormack: structures called biofilms you know the Siobhan McCormack: the analogies go on and i just Siobhan McCormack: i suppose when i'm talking about this to patients Siobhan McCormack: i do use a lot of these potentially annoying to scientists analogies because

Siobhan McCormack: you have to explain in in in ways that people understand um and you know if Siobhan McCormack: you start talking about receptors and the molecular mechanisms then they kind Siobhan McCormack: of fade off and it doesn't seem relevant. Siobhan McCormack: I suppose we use this language to try and make it relevant to them but it makes Siobhan McCormack: it relevant to me as well because it helps me Siobhan McCormack: kind of understand it's a good way to to get a grip of the science so if you're Siobhan McCormack: talking about harry's you know the city in his gut microbiome that has these

Siobhan McCormack: living you know bacteria and we want him to have the best workforce he can to Siobhan McCormack: help him recover from the operation. Siobhan McCormack: Surely if he's been eating a terrible diet for years and he's where he is now Siobhan McCormack: is it not just too late for him to make dietary changes a week or two weeks Siobhan McCormack: or three weeks before the operation. Siobhan McCormack: Because I think people would find it incredibly empowering, but most doctors, Siobhan McCormack: most surgeons would say, ah, you know what? Siobhan McCormack: It's not going to make any difference now. He is where he is. Don't make him feel bad.

Siobhan McCormack: Don't make him feel it's his fault, which it clearly isn't and wouldn't want Siobhan McCormack: to do that. How potent is changing the diet pre-operatively? John Alverdy: Yeah, that's a great point. and actually this guy, Harry Flint, John Alverdy: he's originally from Scotland and he came to visit from the University of Chicago and he's retired now. John Alverdy: And I showed him some data that we had in mice where we put mice on a Western John Alverdy: diet and they did very badly.

John Alverdy: They had a high complication rate after surgery. Siobhan McCormack: So you gave them a sort of junk food diet, you did colorectal surgery equivalent Siobhan McCormack: on them And then afterwards, you found what they had a high rate of surgical Siobhan McCormack: site infections and leak. John Alverdy: Yes. Siobhan McCormack: Compared with mice who were on a plant-based diet or what would it be, chow? John Alverdy: Yeah. So mice eat what's called mouse chow and rats eat what is called rat chow. John Alverdy: And here's what rat chow and mouse chow is. John Alverdy: High fiber, no meat, low fat fat.

John Alverdy: All the goodies in it. And you're like, who eats like that? Nobody. I know. John Alverdy: I don't know anybody, myself included. Last night I ate pizza. John Alverdy: I mean, that was not high fiber, low fat. In fact, it had some sausage on it. John Alverdy: So, but Harry Flint told me this. John Alverdy: He said, you can change that mouse's microbiome in two days. John Alverdy: Back to normal. I'm like, but the mouse was eating this junk food diet,

John Alverdy: to your point, for almost two months. John Alverdy: And he goes, two days. And he was right. We wrote that. We published that paper John Alverdy: in British Journal of Surgery. John Alverdy: And he was absolutely right. We did all the microbiome analysis. John Alverdy: And it takes almost no time to shift your microbiome back to a normal state, John Alverdy: a near normal state with food. John Alverdy: Almost no time. And that's the point you're trying to make, Shiv, John Alverdy: which is, well, if somebody's been eating bad for 40 years, you're not going

John Alverdy: to fix that in two days. Yes, you are. John Alverdy: In terms of microbiome composition and microbiome function, now, John Alverdy: maybe you're not going to reshape their diabetes and reshape their hypertension John Alverdy: and reshape all the other systems that have been done. John Alverdy: But you certainly are going to change the metabolomic, the metabolites that John Alverdy: that gut microbiome produces that activate the immune system, John Alverdy: that boost it, to use your point. John Alverdy: And you certainly are going to shape its composition, its team composition.

Siobhan McCormack: Yeah. I mean, the David paper where they sort of do a radical change in diet in a human study. Siobhan McCormack: And I think it was in three or even in 24 hours for some of them. Siobhan McCormack: But they talk about three to five days. if you radically change your diet you Siobhan McCormack: radically change the composition and I know that people will argue well you Siobhan McCormack: know you have to test out whether that alters the function but I suppose I'm Siobhan McCormack: also thinking Sheena Fraser, my microbiome. Siobhan McCormack: Co-host and partner in this endeavor. Siobhan McCormack: I mean, we always kind of think everyone talks about, well, you know,

Siobhan McCormack: you don't know that, but we've got to kind of put it in balance with the overall picture. Siobhan McCormack: I mean, we're talking fruit, veg and legumes here. Siobhan McCormack: We're not talking about chemotherapy with, you know, incredible side effects. Siobhan McCormack: And in fact, the only side effects would be, you know, positive ones. Siobhan McCormack: Okay, maybe it won't help with this operation, but it may, if they alter their Siobhan McCormack: diet like this long term, it will alter their metabolic or improve their metabolic Siobhan McCormack: health, their cancer risk, their cardiovascular risk and so on. Siobhan McCormack: So no one, I don't know, I'm a bit confused about how we look at the evidence

Siobhan McCormack: because as a general practitioner, I have completely ignored research. Siobhan McCormack: I just wait for guidelines to come out. Siobhan McCormack: The National Institute of Clinical Excellence, is it in the guidelines? No, I'm not interested. Siobhan McCormack: Until I'm now back at uni doing a master's in nutritional medicine. Siobhan McCormack: And my mind is like, you know, exploding with the complexity of it all and what Siobhan McCormack: you guys are trying to do. Siobhan McCormack: And so I'm changing my opinion now. Siobhan McCormack: We have to look at when we're talking about, you know, do no harm, Siobhan McCormack: but we have to also talk about what's the best available evidence for the patient in front of us.

Siobhan McCormack: And if we're sort of putting on blinkers and refusing to look at the totality Siobhan McCormack: of the evidence, unless it's in guidelines, which can take, I don't know, Siobhan McCormack: they say 17 years for something to move from the lab to guidelines, Siobhan McCormack: then that's not going to help the patient in front of me now. Siobhan McCormack: So how do we change that? Siobhan McCormack: I mean, you're someone who's looking at the evidence from all angles, Siobhan McCormack: but I'm guessing that clinicians that you know and surgeons that you know are Siobhan McCormack: not able to spend the time looking deeply into the evidence in in vivo studies

Siobhan McCormack: on animals and in vitro studies and collate it all together. Dr. John Alverdy: These are all excellent points. And, you know, again, you're faced with the patient. John Alverdy: Remember that, and you know this as a practitioner, you know, John Alverdy: patients will do anything you tell them to reduce their risk of a bad outcome. If you said to them. John Alverdy: You know, you can actually reduce your risk of getting a postoperative infection John Alverdy: if you go on this diet and maintain it afterwards.

John Alverdy: In fact, one of my colleagues, Ben Shogan, who spent two years in my lab, John Alverdy: he actually wrote the paper in Science Translational Medicine on the collagenase gene. John Alverdy: He is a colorectal. He trained at the Mayo Clinic to be a colorectal surgeon. John Alverdy: He has his own laboratory at the University of Chicago, very close to my laboratory. John Alverdy: And he has really exciting evidence that your cancer recurs. John Alverdy: So you do a colorectal cancer and it's curative, and you're like,

John Alverdy: I nailed it. The margins are clean. John Alverdy: The CAT scan looks good. your chances of recurrence five years later are dependent John Alverdy: on whether you harbor one of these bugs in your GI tract. And you're like, John Alverdy: well, we gave antibiotics. John Alverdy: We killed that thing. It's antibiotic resistant. John Alverdy: The one that makes the collagenase in those patients that develop a recurrence John Alverdy: are the ones that are antibiotic resistant, both by genetic means.

John Alverdy: So we do PCR are to see that they carry that gene. John Alverdy: And we do culture, you know, where you put it, you know, have antibiotic discs. John Alverdy: And you can see that the antibiotic you used during surgery didn't kill the John Alverdy: germ you wanted, you hoped it would. John Alverdy: And that germ persists in a small group of patients, and they go on to develop a recurrence. John Alverdy: Well, if you told a patient, you, Shiv, said, well, I know you've had the surgery, John Alverdy: and things went well, and your pathology report looks great,

John Alverdy: and the surgeon's all excited and you didn't leak but you know you're still John Alverdy: at risk for a recurrence in five years, John Alverdy: and you can reduce your recurrence if you'd lose some weight and maybe shift your diet, John Alverdy: and maybe let nature push this bad bug out of you by building up your microbiome having more, John Alverdy: I call the good guys in the microbiome, they have home field advantage You can John Alverdy: build up your normal microbiome with diet and avoidance of antibiotics and push this bad actor out.

John Alverdy: You know, I know we haven't talked about virulence yet, but remember that people John Alverdy: talk about humans having the killer instinct. John Alverdy: These are the circumstances that we probably put some bacteria under. John Alverdy: These are the environmental cues that we expose certain bacteria that behave nicely in the sandpit. John Alverdy: And we put them in an environment in which they're forced. John Alverdy: So just think about this for a minute. anxiety, no food after midnight,

John Alverdy: a boatload of antibiotics. Now, how about some opioids? John Alverdy: How about some morphine, a little after surgery? And by the way, John Alverdy: don't eat or drink till you poop. John Alverdy: Okay, so we're going to starve you. And they're like, hey, my only way out is to kill this host. John Alverdy: And if I kill this host, maybe a bird will eat its carcass and I can jump to John Alverdy: a new host. I don't know. I'm making this stuff up. John Alverdy: But, you know, that's kind of how you might conceptualize this and say, John Alverdy: look, you know, we don't know all, we don't have all the answers.

John Alverdy: I know you like an agonist, a receptor, and a drug that blocks it. John Alverdy: And here, take this PPI or take this thing and this will work. John Alverdy: We like that idea. It's nice and clean. John Alverdy: And, you know, you give it to patients, you do a clinical trial and it works for whatever it is. John Alverdy: But we're now dealing with a social group, a team. John Alverdy: And I like to think of the microbiome as just another gene pool. John Alverdy: It's just another set of molecules and genes that we have to account for, which we didn't before.

Siobhan McCormack: Okay. So I like to think of it as a team that you have to look after. Siobhan McCormack: So if you have this workforce within you you have to pay fair wages you have Siobhan McCormack: to feed them you have to and if you do you will get so much back and if you Siobhan McCormack: don't and all those beneficial microbes kind of die out then you're left with Siobhan McCormack: potential pathogens so it's a kind of no-brainer for me that, Siobhan McCormack: you know what do they eat they might plant fiber to make these short-chain fatty Siobhan McCormack: acids that are so important in post-operative recovery and in a myriad of ways

Siobhan McCormack: which we don't have time to go into. But. Siobhan McCormack: It's just sort of changing. I don't know what hospital food is like at your Siobhan McCormack: hospitals, maybe the same as the NHS. Siobhan McCormack: You're looking, and look from the expression on your face, it's not, Siobhan McCormack: you're not kind of talking, you know, beautiful plant, whole food, plant-based diets. Siobhan McCormack: But this is incredibly important when you think of how much money and expense Siobhan McCormack: into research that many of your colleagues are looking into tiny areas,

Siobhan McCormack: tiny receptors that may have a very small effect on reducing surgical outside infections. Siobhan McCormack: And then you've got this, the low-lying fruit, you know, basically what you eat. Siobhan McCormack: And there was one quote, I was trying to find it this morning in one of your Siobhan McCormack: papers that kind of really resonated with me, because you said, Siobhan McCormack: out of all the ways we can modulate the gut microbiomes, you're talking biotics, Siobhan McCormack: antibiotics, probiotics, prebiotics, symbiotics, Siobhan McCormack: postbiotics, and even FMT, although there's some interesting research being done in that area.

Siobhan McCormack: You said the one, something I'll paraphrase, the most potent, Siobhan McCormack: affordable, available, acceptable, you know, an equal way to alter your gut microbiome is diet. Siobhan McCormack: And I just thought, wow, you've got a gut microbiome researcher of many decades Siobhan McCormack: and a surgeon and that seems crazy and that no one's really grabbing that. Siobhan McCormack: I mean, And Sheena and I just want to get going with that now. John Alverdy: Yeah, I think it's great. You know, I got to tell you that James Kinross,

John Alverdy: he's a brilliant, brilliant guy and studies the microbiome. John Alverdy: And he invited me to give a talk in London. John Alverdy: And then this guy got up, who was a PhD researcher, and he took these rats and John Alverdy: he did these horrible things, gave him nitrogen, mustard. John Alverdy: I can't remember what he did. He did some horrible thing. And the rats all developed John Alverdy: cancer, or many of them developed cancer. John Alverdy: And then he put walnuts in the cage and then did all these horrible things and John Alverdy: none of them developed cancer.

John Alverdy: And I'm thinking, this is what people want. This is why the probiotic industry is so hot now. John Alverdy: I want to eat pizza, hamburgers, and french fries, but I want to take a probiotic John Alverdy: pill the day before surgery and it to cure me. John Alverdy: And surgeons, unfortunately, are the same way. John Alverdy: CAT scan, tumor, me, trained, I can take it out. John Alverdy: And you're like, wait a minute, hold on, cowboy, cowgirl.

John Alverdy: That's not exactly correct. Maybe there's things as an internist we can do that John Alverdy: can change the course and outcome. John Alverdy: And they're like, nah, what are you going to do? Give this person walnuts for John Alverdy: three days? It ain't going to make a difference. John Alverdy: And it might. And that's why you're right. John Alverdy: The public doesn't like this idea of it's complex and team. We have to understand John Alverdy: it better. But the future is coming. John Alverdy: It's here, maybe, where we can assess the microbiome in that cancer patient.

John Alverdy: And you're hairy of 43 years old and say, you got a couple of bad actors in John Alverdy: there. you don't want there during surgery. John Alverdy: And let's delay things for a couple of weeks and put you on this diet. John Alverdy: And then let's re-interrogate your microbiome and see if we can eliminate them John Alverdy: and make it and put it in better shape. John Alverdy: Can't change your hemoglobin A1c. John Alverdy: You know, I can't change your blood pressure yet. John Alverdy: But in the next five years, this is a wake-up call. John Alverdy: You're having major surgery and you've got to stay on this diet. John Alverdy: You've got to lose weight. You've got to get those things back in shape.

John Alverdy: Otherwise, all the surgery that was done is not going to do you any good. John Alverdy: And that's exciting because it's something you can modulate. John Alverdy: And it's the simplest thing in the world. But like anything else in medicine, John Alverdy: at least, you know, in the United States, for example, John Alverdy: imagine if it's proven that dietary prehabilitation can shift your microbiome John Alverdy: and benefit you in terms of infection rate and in terms of cancer recurrence.

John Alverdy: Imagine if it were to for a moment. John Alverdy: Who would have to pay for that two weeks of dietary rehabilitation? John Alverdy: The insurance companies. John Alverdy: They don't want to pay right now. Maybe the National Health Service doesn't John Alverdy: want to pay also because you're going to delay surgery for two weeks. John Alverdy: It's going to cost X amount of money. John Alverdy: It's going to increase costs. But, you know, I like to think of truth as being John Alverdy: invincible in its own way. John Alverdy: If it's true, it needs to be done. John Alverdy: And, you know, you say, oh, I used to wait for the guidelines and stuff,

John Alverdy: but now you're like looking going, you know, there's a lot of science behind John Alverdy: this and it all makes kind of sense. Siobhan McCormack: If all the arrows are pointing in the same direction, and I suppose the best Siobhan McCormack: available evidence for any listeners out there who are, you know, Siobhan McCormack: contemplating or having surgery of any sort, really, then getting, Siobhan McCormack: you've got nothing to lose by getting your gut microbiome in good shape. Siobhan McCormack: You know, it's really empowering. It's really exciting. Siobhan McCormack: What's the worst that can happen? There is really no particular downside.

Siobhan McCormack: Getting those whole food, plant-based foods in and cutting out the things that Siobhan McCormack: we know are detrimental to the biome. Siobhan McCormack: That's the emulsifiers, the additives. Siobhan McCormack: So all those ultra-processed foods. Siobhan McCormack: So it's not just what you do have, it's what you emit as well. Siobhan McCormack: You know, let's get most people in good shape using what is available. Siobhan McCormack: I kind of think it's exciting. John Alverdy: It is exciting, but it's also very challenging, in my opinion, John Alverdy: for the primary care physician, the general internist, to be able to change

John Alverdy: behavior because, you know, in your own practice, you know, getting people to John Alverdy: quit smoking and to lose weight and to change their diets, not so easy. John Alverdy: And it's very tempting to think you can modify these things and yet they're John Alverdy: not so easily modifiable. John Alverdy: You know, there's a, you know, I wrote a paper about U-curves, John Alverdy: Laffer curves and U-curves and, you know, and there's a lot of interest in,

John Alverdy: you know, how human progress has gotten us to this point where we're here. John Alverdy: But if we keep going, human progress, Let's have more plastic in the ocean, more garbage. John Alverdy: Let's use antibiotics more. If some is good, more is better. John Alverdy: Let's get more processed food. Let's get more McDonald's on every street corner around the world. John Alverdy: Let's all get fatter because, you know, let's all drink more. John Alverdy: All of a sudden, you're like, wait a minute. John Alverdy: We've made all this progress, and now the curve's going back up where we're

John Alverdy: seeing we came down a little bit and now we're going back the wrong way because... John Alverdy: We haven't paid attention to nature-inspired design. John Alverdy: To what extent can we destroy the ecology of the GI tract with our current methods? John Alverdy: And when will it bite us back? Siobhan McCormack: The striking parallels aren't there between Earth's ecosystem and the issues Siobhan McCormack: we have with reduced biodiversity and global warming and our own planetary,

Siobhan McCormack: if you like, ecosystem, which is mainly the gut microbiome, where we also talk Siobhan McCormack: about reduced biodiversity. Siobhan McCormack: And well climate change could be chronic low-grade inflammation I guess and gut barrier, Siobhan McCormack: permeability issues so yeah yes there's Siobhan McCormack: plenty of parallels there and it's all you know Siobhan McCormack: a lot of it is is based on the the Siobhan McCormack: food supply and agriculture and soil and Siobhan McCormack: how we look after the earth we've kind Siobhan McCormack: of been taught on this sort of pharmacy model which is

Siobhan McCormack: the body gets disease and we have to take medicines Siobhan McCormack: and uh yeah it's kind Siobhan McCormack: of i suppose it's been a revelation to me my journey over the Siobhan McCormack: last 10 years looking at you know the lifestyle medicine um research papers Siobhan McCormack: and publications in the last couple of decades and the molecular biology of Siobhan McCormack: what happens when you sleep or don't sleep what happens when you eat certain Siobhan McCormack: things and polyphenols and physical activity and it's incredible what's been Siobhan McCormack: found and yet because there isn't a, Siobhan McCormack: pharmacological, you know, therapeutic agent which you can sell,

Siobhan McCormack: it's just not really spoken about so much. John Alverdy: No, I think you're right. Let's work on things, to your point, John Alverdy: Shiv, that can maybe shift the microbiome, modulate it in a way that you never John Alverdy: get the disease at the beginning. John Alverdy: How important would that be? You know, people survive cancer better. John Alverdy: We've actually turned it from an acute problem where you get it and you died John Alverdy: to more of a chronic illness. John Alverdy: But there is...

John Alverdy: No interest, either by industry or at least in the scientific community, in prevention. John Alverdy: There's not, well, let's say, there's not only say no interest. John Alverdy: There's less interest in prevention strategies and how they might be owned by the individual. John Alverdy: You know, you have to have ownership of your own health, to your point. John Alverdy: And preventing disease. And maybe that's where they go. And that's why,

John Alverdy: again, television in the United States, John Alverdy: I'm watching all these probiotic commercials, and they help support. John Alverdy: They've got to be careful with their claims so they don't get sued. John Alverdy: Helps support your microbiome. They can't make a claim that changes your microbiome. John Alverdy: They can't make a claim that it prevents cancer. John Alverdy: But it helps support. Please take this. John Alverdy: And we know that, again, your own microbiome has home field advantage. You shaped it this way. John Alverdy: Putting one probiotic down is not going to do anything.

John Alverdy: It's not going to, you know, I want to take a probiotic and eat hamburgers and John Alverdy: french fries all day long. No, that won't work. John Alverdy: Stop the hamburgers and french fries. Move to more of a Mediterranean-type plant-based diet. John Alverdy: And there's a way to study your microbiome that's using emerging technology. John Alverdy: One person you might consider talking to is Eugene Chang. John Alverdy: He's a gastroenterologist, and he is a world-famous figure in the microbiome space.

John Alverdy: He's a close collaborator of mine, and he's developed a 20-panel point-of-care diagnostic. John Alverdy: To understand what metabolites are being secreted in response to the foods that John Alverdy: you eat or your general health. John Alverdy: Remember, right now, we do not know how to tell anybody, a doctor or anybody John Alverdy: else, if your microbiome is abnormal or normal. John Alverdy: But I like to think of moving away from a disease state toward a healthy recovery state.

John Alverdy: I don't like to think of disease healthy because it's too complicated. John Alverdy: I like to think of moving. John Alverdy: If I could have a measurement and that I could give to you, Shiv, John Alverdy: and you'd say, I'm going to put your stool on this panel, 20 metabolite panel. John Alverdy: I'm going to say, you're changing your diet. You've lost 10 pounds. Wonderful. John Alverdy: You're moving away from the disease state toward a more healthy state, John Alverdy: not at a healthy state, but you're moving in the right direction,

John Alverdy: you would like that test. John Alverdy: But you don't want a test where like, well, your tryptophan is up and you're John Alverdy: short-chain fatty. It's like, you know, it's like, it's too much information. John Alverdy: You know, and it's too binary. John Alverdy: Disease, health. That's not how the world works. It's sort of like, John Alverdy: You're in an unhealthy place. I know you've probably been through this with John Alverdy: many of your own patients, but you're in an unhealthy place, John Alverdy: and I need to slowly move you to a more healthy.

John Alverdy: Place in your journey of your own body. Siobhan McCormack: It is a journey, and it's a dynamic thing, isn't it? Siobhan McCormack: This idea of health being a destination is kind of ridiculous because, Siobhan McCormack: you know, as you know, we eat the pizza. Siobhan McCormack: We're not so healthy afterwards. Then we maybe have a nice salad and then we're in a healthier state. Siobhan McCormack: So it's this kind of dynamic, ever-moving journey until the end. Siobhan McCormack: But actually, yeah, I think people just talk about health as one thing. Siobhan McCormack: Professor John Alverde, you are, you know, it's been incredible talking to you. Siobhan McCormack: I love your work. I've been deep diving into your papers for six months.

Siobhan McCormack: My family think I'm a boring, obsessed nerd, but I don't care. I kind of love it. Siobhan McCormack: And yeah, thanks so much for your work. Thank Thank you for spending the time speaking to me. John Alverdy: It was a pleasure. Siobhan McCormack: Yeah. And thank you for letting us come into the operating theater with you. Siobhan McCormack: And now that you've closed up and Harry is back on the ward and safe in the nurse's care. John Alverdy: Then I think Harry needs to be in your hands now. Siobhan McCormack: Oh, right. John Alverdy: And he needs to be under your care for the next five to 10 years so you can John Alverdy: keep Harry healthy to age.

Siobhan McCormack: Well, I tell you, Sheena and I would love that because we do talk a lot with Siobhan McCormack: patients about this kind of thing. Siobhan McCormack: And we would like, you know, we'd be talking about exercise and sleep. Siobhan McCormack: We'd be talking about whole food, plant-based diet, talking about getting rid Siobhan McCormack: of all the emulsifiers and additives. And I tell you, the patients love it. Siobhan McCormack: They love it. They love the, you know, the ecosystem idea. They get that. Siobhan McCormack: And they do it in a much easier way than sort of telling them that they're bad Siobhan McCormack: and they should stop eating burgers. Siobhan McCormack: Kind of, you know, feed your ecosystem. And that kind of works. Siobhan McCormack: Excellent. All right. Well, safe journey.

John Alverdy: Nice to see you. Thank you. Siobhan McCormack: We'll speak again sometime. You take care. Sounds good. Bye now. John Alverdy: Okay, bye-bye. Intro and Outro: Thank you so much for listening to this episode of Microbiomedics Podcast. Intro and Outro: We really hope you enjoy the content and we welcome your feedback. Intro and Outro: We'd love to hear any suggestions you might have for microbiome topics that you'd like us to cover. Intro and Outro: And we also appreciate listeners' questions and we'll endeavor to answer them in the next podcast.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Our Testing Journey: Dr Alena Pribyl on analysis of the human gut microbiome at Microba Life Sciences

    Oct 16, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Have you ever wondered what microbiome testing looks like? In this episode, co-hosts Dr Siobhan McCormack and Dr Sheena Fraser chat to guest Dr Alena Pribyl from Microba Life Sciences, after sending off their poo...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Defining Gut Health: Moving Beyond the Buzzwords with Prof. Maria Marco

    Jul 15, 202653 minAudio

    While "gut health" is a ubiquitous buzzword in the wellness industry, it has historically lacked a clear scientific definition. In this episode, host Dr. Siobhan McCormack sits down with world-renowned expert Professor...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Eat to Sleep: The Power of Chrononutrition and Circadian Rhythms

    Jun 17, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    While we often think of sleep and diet as separate pillars of health, our internal biological clocks and gut microbiome intricately connect them both. In this episode, co-hosts Dr. Siobhan McCormack and Dr. Sheena...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Beyond the Gut: The Surprising Science of Respiratory Microbes with Dr. Michael Cox

    May 13, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    While the gut microbiome often steals the spotlight, the microorganisms residing in our respiratory tract play a vital role in our health and immunity. In this episode, Dr. Sheena Fraser sits down with microbial...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Biological Liquid Gold: Why Breast Milk Isn't Actually for the Baby (It's for the Microbes) with Prof. Chris Stewart

    Apr 15, 20261 hr 40 minAudio

    Join Dr. Siobhan McCormack as she welcomes one of the top early-life microbiome scientists in the field, Professor Chris Stewart. Discover the origins of your gut microbiome, the biological superpowers of breast milk,...

    Credit the people on this episode