Blake and Peter reflect on the winning road trip and go position by position to discuss what they’ll be watching for down the stretch. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit themetropolitan.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Mets Fix Podcast. I'm Blake Zaff, joined by Peter Kaufman. At a time, you know, as a Mets fan, you know, what do you even say at this point, Peter? I mean, they were terrible for most of the season. Then we were treated to a week or so where they won six out of seven games. And you start to think, I can get excited about this team again. They were on a tough road trip. And they really were fun to watch. And I'm not going to get all bent out of shape about losing two or three to Atlanta in Atlanta.
SPEAKER_01But it did soften the good vibes a little bit, let's say. But putting that aside, it's a pretty good road trip. How are you feeling about these Mets since the last time we spoke when they were just on the beginning of starting? It's funny. I think we were excited because they'd won two in a row or maybe three. And that felt exciting. But you got to like what you've seen over the last seven to 10 games.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, they went for a stretch where they went six and one after the trade deadline. And I had most of the texts I was getting from my old Mets friends were things like, they're going to win 25 in a row. They're going to get to win. And then a game of the playoffs and then lose the last day of the season. That's pretty much where it netted out that we were like, let's just go and let's enjoy the next few weeks because that's how it's going to end. And then the Braves just really outclassed them this week.
SPEAKER_00And you just saw a team that is on hyperdrive to run away with the division. A lot of talent there. Pieces are clicking. And, you know, it brought the Mets back down to earth. But having said that, it's been a lot more fun to watch this team. And I like watching the team. Where there's some reason to invest in some of these players. And I think we'll get to that. And I think we should go through. I think one way to do it is to kind of go through piece by piece and say,
SPEAKER_00like, what are we watching? Because I think that's for me as a fan, I don't think they're going to come back. But I feel more confident in 2027 than I did a few weeks ago. So what are we looking at right now?
SPEAKER_01All right, so let's do that. And just to recap again, since the trade deadline, 6-3 on a road trip against some pretty good teams. So you really can't complain too much. I mean, that's good. All right, so I think you're right. I think it would be fun this episode. There aren't too many new storylines, and we're not kind of diluting ourselves into the idea that the Mets are on the verge of contention. So I thought it might be a time to step back and let's take a look at different positions and how we think they're playing out right now and what we'd like to see in terms of 2027. I'm just going to start at catcher.
SPEAKER_01I think it's a really interesting one that doesn't get a lot of discussion. Very kind of subtly this year, a couple of things have happened, a couple of developments, a couple of shifts. One of those is that Francisco Alvarez has, I don't want to say he's been displaced or supplanted as a catcher, but You know, he got hurt yet again. They decided this is a bat that's valuable and we want to protect him and his health and we're going to have him catch less. So he's been catching less. Toren's catching more.
SPEAKER_01Toren's has continued to be elite defensively, put up pretty terrible offensive numbers and yet somehow seem to give you a professional bat when you need it. You know, it's like he's one of those players who I regard as having an idea of what to do when he's at the plate and then you look at his numbers and they're terrible. So The Mets kind of made that shift. And the other thing I want to say is that Francisco Alvarez is still quite young, putting together a sneakily decent offensive season. And, you know, we always had the highest of hopes for him. I think at one point he might have literally been the number one prospect in
SPEAKER_01the country, according to, or not the country, in the league, according to, you know, the prospect watchers. And maybe that's unfair, but being 24 years old and putting up the kind of offensive numbers he has gives you some hope. So, Peter, my question to you is, What do you see for the future of that position? How are you feeling about that position? Do you want to see a platoon? Do you feel confident just giving the reins to Torrens and just agreeing you're not going to get a lot of offensive production, but it's elite defensive production? Do you want to see Alvarez kind of be,
SPEAKER_01stop, forget these games and just let Alvarez be your starting catcher? What are you seeing and what do you like as we look into 2027?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think Alvarez keeps getting lumped into the baby busts, which I don't think is fair. Brett Beatty, I think at this point, we need to end it. We'll get to that. Mark Vientos, we need to get to that. Ronnie Mauricio, again, I will ride this. He has not been given a chance, so I don't consider Mauricio a bust yet, because he hasn't, frankly, because we don't know. But Alvarez has not been, and I think he has been in some ways held, it's almost held away.
SPEAKER_00He put up 25 home runs as a 21-year-old catcher. And it was this, holy hell, wow, we have Gary Carter is coming to save us. And hasn't kind of lived up to that. Now, a catcher is never going to have that many starts in a season, but the power is still there. He has 13 home runs this year. His OPS is at 772, which is above his career of 743, and
SPEAKER_00There is still it's still there. And, you know, I had written this piece a few weeks ago for the newsletter where I sort of looked at some of the some of the young players. And when do you give up on young players? And there's kind of this magic between five hundred and a thousand at bat seems to be what front office is really like laser in. And Alvarez is at thirteen hundred at bats. Beatty, Vientos, far past that. We can sort of stick a fork in them. But the one player I left out of that, which is really relevant to Alvarez, is Travis Darnot.
SPEAKER_00Travis Darnot had a lot of hype. He's going to be a solid defender, but a real offensive first, but a good defender coming up as a young prospect. He was the heart of that trade for R.A. Dickey. It was to get Travis Darnot, our catcher of the future. Syndergaard was a throw into that deal. Darnell never really put it together, had a few weird injuries that extended it, and he was 29. That wasn't like a 500 at-bats and we gave up on him at age 25. He was 29 when he left the Mets and then had his career in his 30s.
SPEAKER_00Peter, are you saying Francisco Alvarez, let him be the starter and let him take the reins and let's see what happens? So I would say for the catching position, and I spent so much time because I do think this is a cornerstone of the team, I like the split they have now. I am a defensive first. Philosophically, I like defensive first for catchers. I love Torrens getting two-thirds, 60% of the starts. Alvarez has a bat. I don't want to lose that. I like the combo as it is now.
SPEAKER_00I like having some pop. Give Alvarez some DH opportunities as he can. I really love Torrens, and I like the combo that we have now. I would keep this combo.
SPEAKER_01So when you say Torrens gets two-thirds of the game as a catcher, Alvarez is starting DH when that happens, in your mind?
SPEAKER_00Or time off. Keep him fresh. It depends what we have in the DH. And yes, I don't want to give up either one. If one is playing better, we can shift. If Alvarez develops defensively, we have both. I'm saying there's no reason to change. I can go into 2027 with the two of them splitting time at catcher. That's a strong catching problem.
SPEAKER_01I think Alvarez has to get, if he's healthy, you got to give him 400 at-bats. I think you just got to get that bat in the lineup and you got to figure out a way to make it happen. Let's go to first base. I'm not inviting you to talk about Pete Alonso. We all know that that was not good. Mistake. Let's just move on. But given what we have now, Polanco is supposed to be the first baseman, has not played it. Vientos had some time there. He's really seemed to kind of tail off. Jared Young seems to be getting the look right now. It's an interesting situation. It's a guy who doesn't have a ton of major league experience,
SPEAKER_01but I believe he's 31 years old, obviously played overseas, has shown some ability to flash some leather there. And you think if he gets more time and really practices in the offseason, he'd get even better. And he's putting together one of the better offensive seasons on the team, which is not saying much. But if you look at it from like an OPS perspective, doing a lot better than Bo Bichette. So is it enough for you to feel like, well, we've got this cheap in-house alternative moving forward? The free agents options are not amazing for first base moving forward.
SPEAKER_01So the team is in a little bit of a bind. You have some sort of like B-level prospects. You know, they got Cole Mathis in that trade. For David Peterson, they got Billy Amick back in the Minter trade, I believe. So they have some prospects. I mean, I just assume that Clifford has fallen off of Clifford. He is hitting under 200 in the minors, and I don't know if we should even be saying that name in a serious way anymore when it comes to first base. What have you been seeing at that position? What would you like to see next year?
SPEAKER_00The position's a black hole. I like Jared Young. Seems like a nice guy. Shows a promise. That's a black hole. That is terrible. Polanco is not going to be able to play 140, 150 games in the field. Just give that up right now. And if it were me in charge, I would have a serious sit down over the offseason with Juan Soto and see if he'll be like Bryce Harper and shift to first base. That could solidify you at first base. And for the foreseeable future and give some more openings to some of the prospects
SPEAKER_00that we have developing that could play in the outfield, I just think that's a black hole for this team. And I don't see any positives on the horizon unless Soto would entertain a shift to first base.
SPEAKER_01That's a very interesting idea. In that world, are you imagining the Mets re-signed Luis Robert Jr. and that's your third outfielder?
SPEAKER_00Not necessarily. We'll see. But I don't see anyone... You're not... You're not comparing that to what you're sort of replacing. Whoever you put in left field is replacing what you have at first base. So it just has to be better than Jared Young or Mark Vientos. And that's an improvement because you're putting Juan Soto at first base. First base for the next several years. And maybe, you know, maybe you tell Juan Soto, you get to talk to everybody. Guy gets a base hit and you get to chat with him.
SPEAKER_00I mean, what more does he, the guy loves to hit and he loves to talk to people and you can play first base and you'd be the premier hitter in the league and chat with everyone that comes to first base.
SPEAKER_01And you think if they tell him that you can chat with people and they give him that permission, that might be the...
SPEAKER_00He might chat so much with opposing players that I could see opposing players not wanting to get a hit because they don't want to stay on first base and have to talk to Juan Soto for so long.
SPEAKER_01What if Francisco Lador gets traded and he's an opposing player? There you go. And he gets the first and Soto's there. All right, let's move on to second base. You know, look, it's funny. No one really thinks or talks about Jeff McNeil anymore. We could do a whole separate podcast on what the hell happened to Jeff McNeil. It's really something. I mean, I don't even know how to explain it. Some guys, I guess, just start their decline earlier than others. But this is a problem area for the Mets. Marcus Semien is not a realistic long-term option, even though he is under contract through the 2028 season.
SPEAKER_01So I don't think the Mets should or will feel any obligation to play him just because they're paying him. But you do have to have other options. AJ Ewing is a potential option there. He has played second before. They have some new prospects they got. Stefora could end up being a second baseman. Maybe even Jefferson Rojas. I'm not going to pretend to have intimate familiarity with his versatility there. That does feel to me to be a situation where you're opening... Yeah, absolutely. I think Semien holds it. He's on opening day, second baseman, and you hope.
SPEAKER_00That he either finds a little bit of life, but more realistically, probably more realistic that one of these two studs, if it's Rojas or Sephora, gets Sephora, I mispronounced that name, but one of them steps up and wins the second base job at some point in 2027, not early, probably second half of 2027.
SPEAKER_01All right, let's talk about one that is likely to get a lot of discussion, but I actually think is very simple. And that's shortstop. I don't think they can move the Francisco Lindor contract. So then you're in a position where it's like, are we going to trade this guy and pay teams to take him? And as we learned with Luke Weaver, they're willing to pay teams to take players who have value and are good. I wouldn't recommend it. I don't know. I mean, it's a similar thing. I mean, by the way, we haven't talked about Ronnie Mauricio other than kind of you mentioning him briefly at the beginning.
SPEAKER_01Does he fit in? I'll ask the question this way. Does Ronnie Mauricio fit in your mind in terms of second, short, third, anything like that for
SPEAKER_00next year? I would be able to answer that if they gave the guy the next six weeks to start and put him in second base. And then we would know if he could hit major league pitching, then we could go into next season and say, oh, you know, we don't have to. If Bo Bichette opts out, we have Mauricio and his cannon arm at third or put him at second base. We don't know. I would love to find out without finding out. There's no reason to move on from Lindor. The guy has been a 30-30 guy every single year. He's a Hall of Fame shortstop.
SPEAKER_00He's now played more games as a Met than he did as a Guardian or an Indian. He will go into the Hall of Fame as a Met, and he's had great moments. He's had clutch moments. He's a phenomenal shortstop still. I can see him transitioning. Maybe one of these studs that we just traded for, maybe they can. And Lindor shifts over to second base in a couple seasons. But 2027 for the foreseeable future, Francisco Lindor is the shortstop.
SPEAKER_00And any talk about getting rid of him, we are not going to get value for him. And he is still so good. He's 32 years old. He's got a couple more seasons. It may not look so good in year 9 and 10, but it looks good for the next couple years. We should not move him. We should not pay another team. Now, I will say, look, if they can get value back,
SPEAKER_01you know, some teams like actually really prizes him or they have a contract that's similar and it meets a need that the Mets have. I'm open to it. I'm open to anything. This team needs to be open to anything, but I just don't see it is what I'm saying. A name who we should mention, though, if we're talking about middle infielders, Peter, who I don't think we've ever mentioned on this show before. Is Mitch Voigt. I think this is a riser. I think this is a guy to really be excited about. He didn't start off fast or super hot. But after they drafted him, this is, you know, a recent first round pick by the Mets last year.
SPEAKER_01Take a look at what he's doing in the minors lately. It has been ridiculous. He's been sizzling. And if he can keep that up, maybe he's your second base option. It's really exciting to think that we just named Rojas, Stafora, Voigt. These are all blue-chip prospects. And hopefully, you just have to hope that one of them can take the reins at second base next year. Because I think Lindor stays at short, and that brings us to the next position, which is third base, where I assume that Bo Bichette... He's not going to be able to opt out and get more money than what he's guaranteed from the Mets after this season. Though you never know.
SPEAKER_01You never know. I assume though he stays and I assume we keep him at third base where I have to say his defense has not been a problem.
SPEAKER_00His defense has been solid. I'm not itching to move off of Bichette. I do think he's going to hit better next year. He's already hit better. Take out the first two months of this year. He's hit very well. Reading the tea leaves of what he says, I don't know. Maybe he's full of it. I don't know. He seems like he wants to come back. He seems to have a lot of pride in his game. He takes it very seriously. So there's a practical matter, which is he really He wants that big payday. And, you know, P.S., $42 million is in chump change.
SPEAKER_00And so he can come back. He can show that he's still a hitter and he's still going to be young enough to get that big deal. So I anticipate he will opt in, come back and play one more year and welcome him back and give another year for Void or Rojas or somebody sort of to develop and potentially replace him when he walks for a big deal to the Cubs or some other team.
SPEAKER_01All right, that gets us to the outfield. Obviously, you know, Ewing and Benj, pencil them in, or not pencil them, put them in permanent marker. Yeah, ink, permanent marker, Sharpie, big fat Sharpie with gold lettering. I feel really excited about Benj. I mean, we haven't spent a lot of time just sort of talking about him in detail, but I don't know. You could really see a world where this is a guy who can hit 20-plus home runs, steal 30-plus bases, 350 OBP. I mean, he's almost there now. I mean, the numbers he's putting up as a rookie, You can't really take away that first month.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't work that way. But if you just want to see like after he adjusted to the major leagues, really good player. And the fielding is there too. Ewing, the question for me is, does he end up at second base? I think not. I think given, we just talked about all those middle infield prospects. So I think you got Ewing and Benj there as your cornerstones. Then the question is going to be, is Soto there or not? If Soto's there, great. If he's at first base, that changes the equation, but it shouldn't be too hard to find another outfielder, whether it's a trade or free agency.
SPEAKER_01There are plenty of outfielders. One thing I will say is, In the politics world, Peter, there is a man named Dave Wasserman who is an expert in watching congressional races. And when there's a primary night or an election night, he'll see the returns. And before all the votes come in, because he has these complicated projection models, he is pretty confident in saying who he thinks has won. So maybe only 70% of the votes are in, but his catchphrase is, I've seen enough.
SPEAKER_01I've seen enough. So and so is the winner in this district. I'm going to tell you right now, with Luis Robert, I've seen enough. My verdict is I don't need to keep him. $20 million for one year is not like a crazy long-term commitment, but the guy gets hurt. He's one of those tantalizingly frustrating guys who has so much talent, but there's just no consistency. He can hit the ball 500 feet. Honestly, the fielding has not really blown me away. I heard what a great gold glove fielder he was. The arm does not feel elite to me.
SPEAKER_01I'd say if we can find other options, we should do it. But that said, he's on the team now. So play him, get him some time now so we can see, especially while Soto's hurt, so we can evaluate. But for me, I'm
SPEAKER_00ready to move on. You would think for $20 million, you could get someone to either play And if you're getting superior defense from A.J. Ewing, I've seen enough. A.J. Ewing in center for the next 5 to 8 to 10 to 12 to 15 years. Please, Carson Benjen Wright, let's lock it in.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I'm totally with you. I think we've seen enough of Luis Robert. Let's talk about pitching. We've got the bullpen. Let's just make that quick because bullpens are very dynamic. They got rid of everyone except for Devin Williams. I assume Devin Williams is probably your closer next year, but maybe they could sign a closer and then make him your setup guy. In terms of all these names that are out there that they're trying now, so far, so good. I'm not sold on all these guys, but Nate Lavender,
SPEAKER_01that feels like an arm we've been waiting for for a while, looking good. Jeffrey Yan, to me, the verdict is still out. I'm excited for Reid Garrett to come back. I hope that Daniel Nunez turns things around. I'm just going to not get into too much. There's too much depth on this because it's not the kind of thing you plan for in a long-term way. There are always guys available, whether it's people with big names, like Luke Weaver kind of was, or it's people, and AJ Minter was, or it's people that we never heard of who you can turn into good relievers. We've seen that movie before. So for me, not going to get too hung up on that. I think that that's something where we take the rest of this season to kind
SPEAKER_01of audition these guys who are shuffling through, and some of them will stick and some of them won't.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that's exactly right. And so I think you can't spend too much time planning it. We'll figure it out. We've seen enough. I've seen enough positivity that there'll be optionable, talented pitchers next year. We have our closer. Hopefully there's some improvement there and a high leverage and who knows if Senga may be our guy for next year. We'll see. I like 98 miles an hour and a ghost fork. Let's do it. And then that brings us to the starting rotation.
SPEAKER_00Nolan McClain, I think we jumped the gun after eight career starts to kind of put him in as the ace or the 1B this season, but he's finishing strong and he's doing well. I think you have Nolan McClain. I think you've seen enough with Christian Scott, that those guys are, I think, on a competitive team, potentially a two and three. Minaya has shown life. That's got to make you feel good for one more season. It's $25 million. So you have three starters who I think... I love Zach Thornton.
SPEAKER_00I really love Zach Thornton. I really like watching him pitch. I am partial to guys who can't throw gas and make it work. I like it. Now, whether he starts in Syracuse just for the first few weeks of the season and comes up when somebody inevitably gets hurt, I don't know, but I really like him. And then it brings you to having to sign,
SPEAKER_00bite the bullet and sign a big chip free agent for this staff because I don't think you can go in next season and do what we did this year and just hope
SPEAKER_01So when you say sign a big chip starter, you mean either Clay Holmes, David Peterson, or Freddy Peralta, right?
SPEAKER_00David Peterson? No, I would definitely bring Clay Holmes back as a number two. That makes it better. And I don't know, you really want an ace. I don't think once Tariq Skubal has gotten a taste of LA, the Dodgers have as much You can forget that. That ship has sailed. He's in Los Angeles. What do they say in Hangover 2? Bangkok has him now. The guys go to Dodgers. Dodger Blue has him now. He's done. He's going to pitch in the World Series this year.
SPEAKER_00I think it's a done deal. So who is the next thing? I certainly wouldn't give Freddy Peralta big money. Let's just be clear.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, look, I think that the team is sort of, when it comes to pitching, in the same spot it was last year. And it's unfortunate because this is a franchise that was always known for starting pitching. That was what always got us through the years, even in the lean times and in the great years. And the complexion and the personality, the identity of the franchise has changed now to one where we don't have a ton of pitching. But we're starting to see, look, the three you mentioned, McLean, Thornton and Christian Scott, that is a nucleus of homegrown pitching that you can get excited about.
SPEAKER_01And so what you need to do is go out and sign at least two really solid, big, big time guys. I'm thrilled to see what Minaya is doing now, but I don't count on it for next year. It would be a bonus. They need to get at least two big timers next year. But I think it could be done. It's not five. They don't have to get five or six. They just need two, I think, to round it out. And then you could feel like you have some semblance of confidence. And it's funny, Peter, before you were saying That if Soto's in the outfield,
SPEAKER_01you know, the Mets can take the Louis Robert $20 million and pay someone $20 million, maybe even on a one-year deal to hit the ball and play first base. And I was chuckling to myself because... They tried that. The man's name is Jorge Polanco, making, I think, exactly $20 million and has one year left on that deal next year. So we'll see if that works out. Anyway, it was fun kind of going through all this with you. Obviously, in the offseason and later in the season, we're going to go in way more depth on all of this, maybe even just devoting an episode to one or two of these at a time.
SPEAKER_01But for now, I thought this was a good cursory overview because what it makes you feel in conclusion is, yeah, this feels like a lost season, but... All is not lost. There is a future here. There is a little bit of, I don't know, a nucleus sounds too good maybe, too solid, but there's a hint of a nucleus here to build around. And there are some reinforcements coming, I think, on the farm. And so that's a good feeling. I don't think contention is reasonable to hope or expect.
SPEAKER_01I think the games are worth watching because we can see who's auditioning for roles and glimmers of what's to come next year. So with that, Peter, thank you for your time. Thank you everyone out there for listening. We will continue to watch in the way we just said. Let's see what we've got. Let's see what these relievers have. Let's see if we might have some young bats come up and get excited for next year. We'll be watching. Thank you for listening and let's go Mets.
Blake and Peter offer their thoughts on keeping Andy Green on as manager, invite another guest on to discuss Brett Baty’s resurgence, and more! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other...
Blake and JB discuss the week that was with Pete Alonso returning to Citi Field for the first time in a strange uniform. They are also joined by National League Town (a Mets podcast) host Jeff Hysen to breakdown the fan...
Blake and Peter discuss the increasingly watchable Mets as they are joined by Michael Nitzky, who offers his take on who the manager should be for 2027. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with...
Blake, Peter and JB offer their thoughts on the team heading into September, before Hollywood writer Elizabeth Cosin joins to give her take on David Stearns. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this...
Blake, JB and Peter are joined by JB's dad Steve Bellone, the frequent commenter and sometimes critic of his son's Mets analysis. They break down the current squad, JB's childhood fandom and the Amazins' outlook for...