After running an hour-long session on editing poetry at the end of January, I had such lovely feedback that I decided to make a few little clips on some of those ideas that I could share with you here. This is the third of three clips on the subject of editing poem titles. The first clip I posted covers the idea that a poem’s title can add a richness, greater depth or other kinds of possibilities to your poems - you can find it on my 4th of February Substack post here. The second clip looks at how a poem title can set the stage for a poem, so that a reader can be fully immersed in the language of the poem from its very first line - you can find that clip on my 7th of Feb Substack post here. This third clip looks at what happens when we lift a phrase from our poem and use it as its title, how that can serve as a kind of arrow that points to the place in the poem where the phrase appears. I use Maggie Smith’s wonderful poem Good Bones as an example. Drop me a comment below to let me know what you’d like to hear about next! Get full access to Marjorie’s Table at marjorielotfi.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hi, everyone. This is the third of your three installments on how to edit the title of your poem. And I wanted to point to one other thing that titles do. And this is the kind of title I use a lot. And I know lots of poets do, which is to pick out a phrase from the poem that matters, that means something to you that you think is maybe the crux of the poem or something that you want to point to and use it as a title.
SPEAKER_00And what I said in our editing course last week, and I'll say again, is that when we repeat phrases in a poem, for me anyway, They ring a kind of bell in my brain as a reader. I've heard that before. Oh, this must be important. It's been repeated. I definitely slow when I see a phrase twice. And there's something about that that's still true when the phrase is the title, except that it's probably my brain saying, this is important, pay attention.
SPEAKER_00So when we do that, and I do it a lot in my poems, I want you to think about it as a kind of arrow to the part of the poem where that phrase comes. And make sure that it's part of your poem you want to be pointing to. You want your reader to think, this is important, I must pay attention. And sometimes that can be way down at the bottom of the poem. Sometimes it can be at the beginning of the poem because you want the reader to take note of of that phrase or that idea throughout the rest of the poem.
SPEAKER_00But again, don't just pick your favorite phrase. Think about where it falls in the poem. And think about how long your reader's gonna need to wait to get to it before they have that aha moment, this is a really important wait. And I'm gonna show you a poem that does that very well. It's a poem you probably know, and if you don't, go find it because it's a beautiful poem. It went kind of viral by a poet, an American poet called Maggie Smith, and it's called Good Bones.
It's pretty long, so I won't read it for you, but it's on the Poetry Foundation website.
SPEAKER_00And it's about selling the world to your children. And I'll read the first couple of lines so you have a sense of it. Life is short, though I keep this from my children. Life is short, and I've shortened mine in a thousand delicious, ill-advised ways. A thousand deliciously ill-advised ways I'll keep from my children. The world is at least 50% terrible, and that's a conservative estimate,
SPEAKER_00though I keep this from my children. And this keeps going on, but keeping it from the children also rings like a bell all the way through this poem. which is an interesting question. But we have many lines to get through before we see the phrase good bones again. It comes all the way down at the bottom of the poem. So, so far reading this poem, we're thinking about good bones and keeping things from our children, which is interesting. And that's an interesting connection.
SPEAKER_00And yet at the end, we see the phrase good bones come back. And that's the moment the reader's brain is going ding, ding. I know this. This is an important moment. And I'll read you where it comes. Any decent realtor walking you through a real shithole chirps on about good bones. This place could be beautiful, right? You could make this place beautiful. So it comes in the penultimate line and we know it's important,
but we've been waiting for that phrase in some way all the way through the poem or trying to figure out how it connects to the ways that we keep information from our children. that's a really interesting question i won't go into it now but it's it's a great example of how it points to a point in the poem that's a kind of aha moment or a moment where something bigger is revealed in this case the metaphor of the realtor walking you through a house that the structure is there it's our job to make it
beautiful so that's what you should be thinking about when you're picking out a
SPEAKER_00phrase from your poem to use it as a title It's an easy, quick way to make a title for your poem, but I think we always need to think about the effect of the reader when we do that and make sure it's in the right place in the poem and that it's also something we want to be underlining or highlighting or ringing a bell for.
The light was so beautiful in Galloway the day we recorded this conversation that I sent Naomi out to the sea, and we did this conversation in the evening. Apologies for the quality of video, but the sound is perfect!...
After running an hour-long session on editing poetry last week, I had such lovely feedback that I decided to make a few little clips on some of those ideas that I could share with you here. The first thing we tackled in...
After running an hour-long session on editing poetry last week, I had such lovely feedback that I decided to make a few little clips on some of those ideas that I could share with you here. The first thing we tackled in...