Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Marcus Lush Nights

Marcus Lush Nights artwork

Didn't have a hope in hell (9 November 2026)

Nov 9, 20262 hr 26 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In a surprise to no one tonight's topic of choice upon Marcus' return was a debrief of Saturday's election. Listerners called in to chat the grand coalition, the MPs who missed out, compulsary voting, and who will be the next speaker? LISTEN ABOVE

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You're listening to the Marcus Lush Nights podcast from Newstalk ZB. Greetings and good evening. Feel free to call. The number is 0800 80 1080. With this rental midnight tonight, looking forward to your calls and nice to be back. Although I feel I've missed the fireworks and I feel I've missed the Melbourne Cup and all those early November standard topics. But anyway, we will see how we go. Yeah, nice to be back. Get in touch if you want to. Just call, don't text at this stage. 0800 80 1080

Speaker 1if you want to talk. Fair bit bouncing around, no doubt, in people's minds tonight. It was weird for me, actually. I had a fairly busy Saturday. I'm talking about election day, obviously. I had a fairly busy Saturday. Sport and sport and sport and yadda yadda yadda. And was out from early till about half past five. And for the first time, I think ever, I had that feeling that people must have that I can't be bothered voting feeling, which I've

Speaker 1never experienced before. And I don't know what that was about. And I don't know if that was the malaise of the condition or the fact that there'd been so many permutations in the late days it became complicated or anything else. And I guess I just was wondering if you yourself were in that position, or you yourself were someone that normally votes and didn't vote, and if you could put your finger on what the reason for that was. Because I can't actually work it out. I just felt, I

Speaker 1don't know if it's because it's gone on for so long or because there was so much, to be fair, I've been away from work for a couple of weeks, but just felt that general electoral malaise. But toddled off and went to the Bluff School and did the whole thing, and a very pleasant experience it was too. Went without my enrollment card. I mean, whoever remembers that, I wouldn't even know if I've got one that exists or where that arrived. But anyway, that was a fairly good process. So yeah, if you were someone that normally votes and didn't vote, I think it's the second lowest turnout in history.

Speaker 1And that's 75, I think it was 75%. And I presume that is of people that are enrolled. Remember, a lot of people aren't enrolled. And the other thing that I've been mindful of, and I don't fully know the reasons, is that the election coverage in the MMP early voting way is kind of bizarre. Because when you watch the TV coverage, and I switched around, I think ended up on TV3 for obvious reasons. what happened for me was

Speaker 1that as soon as, and I don't know which votes they count first, but you're watching four or five numbers that hardly vary through the four hours. So I'm not quite sure what that's about, but could have made for sort of slightly undramatic watching. I was on the website updating it the whole time, seeing, you know, and that was only several seconds before the TV website, but yeah, it was up point, and it wasn't even going up in any sort of direction. So I've got no idea what that was about. But anyway, you might have some

Speaker 1clarity around that. So feel free to get in touch. The number is, as I say, is 0800 80 1080 and 9292 to text. So if you didn't vote, why did you not? And then, of course, we've got all those other general topics after election that include such things as, was there a sausage outside your polling booth like they do in Australia, democracy sausage? By the way, those aren't free in Australia. You pay for those. Were there fundraisings here? Did you have a party before the election? Did you

Speaker 1gather with kindred spirits and how did that work for you? And then the great old talkback favourite, and I see one of the billionaires has come through and talked about that, and that is the Grand Coalition. So any of those things, some of the things that you want to talk about tonight, if you do get in touch, Marcus till 12, the number is 0800 80 1080 and 929. And by the way, it's going to be. Three weeks before all the special votes are counted, I think there's 400,000, and they will take a while. So anyway,

Speaker 1get in touch. You want to talk 12 past 8, 0800 80 1080. Andre, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 3Good evening, Marcus. How are you? I voted in the election last week, and I had an easy vote card.

Speaker 1When did that arrive in the Post?

Speaker 3It came in the post and I cut it out of it.

Speaker 1Did you cut it or was it like on a big sheet of paper and you cut out that little bit?

Speaker 3Yeah, I just cut out the little bit, took it in and voted for National and the Greens.

Speaker 1That's an unusual combination, isn't it?

Speaker 3Yeah, I thought about Mr. Luxton. I thought, he's the best looking guy in politics. And I thought about voting Greens and I.

Speaker 1Thought about being a loser. Did you vote National for your electoral seat, or did you vote the Greens for your electoral seat?

Speaker 3The Greens' electoral seat in.

Speaker 1In what area, Andre?

Speaker 3South Auckland, Otahu.

Speaker 4Perfect.

Speaker 1Is that the name of the electorate?

Speaker 3Ah, I've forgotten the name of the electorate. There's quite a few different names for it. But I thought if I voted my electoral vote for the Greens, it would give Christopher Luxon a better chance of coming in.

Speaker 1But you don't remember the name of your electorate?

Speaker 3I know it's out of Hoover area.

Speaker 1I wonder what it's called.

Speaker 3South Auckland.

Speaker 4Brilliant.

Speaker 1Good on you, Andre. Thanks for that. Well, I'm none the wiser, but it's a good start. 14 past 8, 0800 80 1080 and 9292 to text if you want to be a part of it. I'll keep you updated with the news throughout the course of the night too, so feel free to come through. And if you want to partake, 0800 ATE, just hold your texts for now, and I'll see if I can get those G'd up eventually, people, sheeple, and the website. But yeah, get in touch. You ought to be a part of it. As I say, 0800 ATE, 1080 and 92. So did anyone actually not vote? And

Speaker 1I can't work out why. I think Andre was, I think Andre was, I think Andre was stirring, was he? They'll be analysing that for years to come, what in fact Andre was saying. But yeah, anyway, if you want to be a part of it, 0800 80 1080 and 9292 to text. We are talking about if you didn't vote, why didn't you vote? And also talk of the Grand Coalition, which, and I have never, I always thought the Grand Coalition is a kind of a pompous name. I thought that's what they did during war times. But apparently in the

Speaker 1article today, there's a number of times where it's been talked about where they have had Grand Coalitions. And that's when National and Labour seem so similar. They combine and then ACT and New Zealand First and Te Pati Māori and the Greens and Opportunity Party, they're left to die on the vine. And I guess what happens for them is that if there's a grand coalition, their particular party kind of disappears. We've got a massive chunk. That's what people would want. But then, of course, National and Labour

Speaker 1would become one party.

Speaker 4So.

Speaker 1I don't know how well that would go. 15 past 8, if you want to be involved, 0800 80 1080 and 9292 to text. If you want to come through, 16 past 8. Hold your horses. 18 past 8, feel free to come through if you want to talk on air. The number is 0800 80 1080 and 9292 to text. It's just the kind of critical mop-up. Gosh, there's been a lot written, hasn't there? Jeepers, creepers. I can't work out. I can't work out what votes they count first. And those numbers just kind of hover around. I think watching Labour and National, they didn't sort of vary between 28

Speaker 1and 30. I don't think she ever got up to 30, but just, it's like watching paint dry, literally. DB Marcus, good evening and welcome.

Speaker 6Thanks.

Speaker 1Thank you.

Speaker 7To do with counting, what they count first, they can start counting early votes almost immediately the polls open. Yes. They are segregated out in that way, and that's why they can get some results very quickly after the polls close. So that's that one.

Speaker 1So I'm feeling that the votes they must be counting straight away must be a very good representation of the population at large because they almost from the very get-go at 2%, that almost seemed to be the exact number that we ended with at midnight.

Speaker 7It really proved to be very close to the exit.

Speaker 1Very close.

Speaker 7And I was surprised when you said that it was a low turnout because the early voting is the most it had ever.

Speaker 1Yes, and that's why they thought it could be the weather.

Speaker 8Ah.

Speaker 1Because I don't know where you were. It wasn't bad where I was, but I think Auckland had thunder. And I guess that's something if you sort of feel malaise about voting and then it's a wet day and then you think, oh goodness gracious me, really, my party's probably not going to get it anyway. I can imagine that.

Speaker 7I voted early, so it wouldn't have affected me.

Speaker 1But you can't vote early because you missed all the Michael Laws stuff and Qualey and, you know, there's always a twist in the last day or two.

Speaker 7I absolutely agree with you and it would have changed my vote had I not stuffed up my vote anyway.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 1Oh, you stuffed it up?

Speaker 7In a minor way, I thought I was in Southland.

Speaker 3Oh, I see.

Speaker 7And I had my candidate in mind who I decided I'd vote for because he had impressed me. But when I went to vote, I'm in the cargo. And of course, no, he's not there. And so I had to make a command decision on the spot. And so I am one of those people that you don't believe exists. I'm a floating voter.

Speaker 1No, I believe you exist. I float myself from time to time.

Speaker 7I have voted blue, red, green, whatever your own future's colour was, and tartan, which is McGillicuddy's theory.

Speaker 1Oh, yes, of course. We miss them. Did you think the pen was too thick for the small circle?

Speaker 7No, and I've heard so many people say they were worried that it could be mistaken for a different part of it.

Speaker 1It's thick. It's obvious. Well, I thought the pen was very poor. I looked back and thought, hang about. Yeah, anyway.

Speaker 7And they picked that because there has been complaints in the past, because I used to be a poll clerk, that the pen was blue in colour.

Speaker 8Therefore a natural thing.

Speaker 7Oh, yes, they've chosen orange.

Speaker 1Yeah, okay.

Speaker 7So they went orange so that they could have that complaint. There's always someone looking for an angle. Anyway, yeah, it would have stuffed up my vote because I was going to go for the New Zealand first candidate in Southland. But Michael Laws would have done that in for me. That was just stupid.

Speaker 1Oh, well, you should wait. Always say wait to the end. I said to my partner, I said, how is it you spell act again in a very loud voice? But anyway, I think she got the joke. Nice to hear from you, TV. 23 past eight, 0800 80 1080 and 9292 to text. Zane, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 4Yeah, g'day, mate.

Speaker 8Look, I voted way early.

Speaker 4I think the second day, which was the day after. The long weekend, what's it called, Labor Day? I should remember that. It was a good bit of light entertainment before the real stuff at 10 o'clock started with Tonga versus the Kiwis in the league. Basically, I didn't really bother too much with the TV. I just went online to the Electoral Commission website Just did the old squiggly thing. You update the page every minute or two. And I

Speaker 4was just kept entertained by, in my electric, Michael Wood and Carlos Chong and Roscoe going back and forth. You know, one would be.

Speaker 1200 a year at one stage. That was exciting. You'd feel you'd want to vote there because it was so close. That's a ripper.

Speaker 4Yeah. It was a ripper, actually. It was a bit of a ripper as far as keeping my mind occupied before the footy.

Speaker 1Did you see those Fijian women last night?

Speaker 8No, I didn't.

Speaker 1Oh, they were good. And I don't know how many are in the NRLA or whatever they are, but boy, oh boy, that was a courageous performance. Anyway, back to what you were going to say.

Speaker 3You know, that's cool.

Speaker 4Because I think, you know, a bit of a sceptic early on, I think I'm now starting to come around to women's rugby and women's league.

Speaker 8I think it's.

Speaker 4Got a bit about it. as long as I don't get too injured. But look, a grand coalition, no, not for me. I think Labour and National are just too ideologically different. I mean, they're at the two different ends of the spectrum, aren't they? And really, after what happened today with the Prime Minister doing a complete 180 backflip about Kilo Wong and Opportunity Party. That's just like nothing

Speaker 4I've ever seen before. This is my opinion, and I know lie is a strong word, but to me, he lied to the nation, barefaced, time after time, day after day, press conference after press conference. And as soon as the election finishes and he knows after the specials, a one or two-seat shift away from him. He is going to need an opportunity. All of a sudden, oh, yes, we'll have a relationship with him.

Speaker 1I'll pick up the phone and talk to him. It's not going to help his credibility, because that's a really important thing, is if you are going to prepare to work with the party.

Speaker 4Look, I know people blame the media, and I'm not saying I'm blaming the media at all, because I think the media in New Zealand generally do a great job, but I think they really do need to be harder on him. and they have been in the last 24 hours about this opportunity thing. I think they need to say, I know it's a big word, that word starting with L, but they need to say.

Speaker 1Look, Mr. I think you're just quoting what someone said on the radio. I forget who it was. Someone, I think, on this morning's radio said that word, and I think it might have been someone from the Greens. But anyway.

Speaker 4That was about something else. But no, I just, I couldn't bear to support a government with a prime minister as far as a grand coalition goes. Look, what National do if they decide to roll Luxon anyway and get Stamford or Mark Mitchell in there? Because they will have way more credibility if they do go on opportunity because they never actually said that they wouldn't. I think I can live with that even though it's not my side of the political aisle. But I couldn't stomach a Labour

Speaker 4National coalition with, in my opinion, a barefaced liar in charge of the country that's It's just not my.

Speaker 11Cup of tea.

Speaker 1Zane, thanks so much for that. Get in touch if you want at 8.27. Someone said, Marcus, you're calling the media going about Luxon saying 19 times he wouldn't work with Topper, missing a big point. It's unbelievably naive. There's a massive difference between what he wanted, planned to do, what he said, and what the electorate tells him they want him to do. Well, no, I think that Luxon needs to know the reality of what the votes are going to come and are likely to be, and they're asked about that. we've got the polls, they're quite accurate. People have asked him if this is the situation, would

Speaker 1he go with opportunity? And I know in this seat a number of times I've Googled it because I suspected that there was going to be a nod in that direction, but yeah. And I thought I'd missed an interviewer actually going about that and said that he would. But no, it's clear that he said he wouldn't. But anyway, there's plenty to talk about and I'm happy with that. Get in touch if you want to. I have got texts, people, so I will go back and get all those out to you too. So thanks for all the texts coming through. Ian, nice to hear from you. This is the third text through God Change the Subject, which I imagine should be God!

Speaker 1Not God Change the Subject. It is probably the one day in the year you should talk politics. Sorry, it's probably the one day in the triennium you should talk politics. Sue, it's Marcus. Good evening.

Speaker 12Hi, Marcus.

Speaker 13I agree with what you just said. But talked about a lot is the Grand Coalition. And it's probably one of the most practical ideas, I think, under the present circumstances. With Nicola going, the next best would have to be Barbara Edmonds. She's got solid experience and was a tax lawyer for, I think, 10 years. And I think that

Speaker 13could actually work, you know, I really do.

Speaker 1I just wonder if you'd be signing the death warrant for your party, because what would people vote? If you go a grand coalition this time, in three years' time, you've got National and Labour back on the ballot, well, people would think they're the same thing, wouldn't they? I just don't know how you split apart after a grand coalition. I have to look how they've done it in Denmark and all those other countries where they've had it.

Speaker 13Well, it's like you were saying earlier. about the wartime grand coalition. Well, that worked well, didn't it? And I think our country, like a lot of others in Europe, is at a crossroads with the situation we have at the moment. And what we need and we're short of is stability. That is one missing factor that's really important, Marcus.

Speaker 1Is it what, sorry?

Speaker 10Stability.

Speaker 14Yeah.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 13You know, with the issues arising lately, a lot of countries, including ours in Europe, are very unstable, and we don't know what's around the corner, and we have to have stability. And that's the way I kind of look at things.

Speaker 1Nice to talk to you. Thanks so much for that. Marcus, the guy who... said he'd voted Green for his electorate National Party vote to help Luxon. Can anyone explain to me how that would help the right bloc? I don't think he got the memo. I think he was tricky, but too tricky. Dan, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 12Hello, Marcus.

Speaker 8How are you, mate?

Speaker 1Good, thank you, Dan.

Speaker 8Welcome back. Hey, I'm really, really frustrated because I took Luxon for his word that he wasn't going to have anything to do with opportunity, and I'm not a Luxon fan at all. In fact, I actively voted for opportunity to... try and give Labour an extra coalition partner so that he could hopefully get the left across the line. And to hear today that he's just going to go against everything he said in the campaign and that my vote might help him, it just makes me sick. He's got

Speaker 8no credibility, man. I miss... Oh, I'm so frustrated with it all. I mean, what would happen if Winston turns around tomorrow and goes, oh, I ruled Labour out, but I might go with Labour.

Speaker 1Well, he still could. He'd have every reason to do that now. And if they gave him the prime ministership, if I was him, I'd do that.

Speaker 8Yeah, 50-50. Do it like he did with the vice with Seymour. Do it with Hipkins. Go 50-50.

Speaker 1And I'm also.

Speaker 5Sorry, mate.

Speaker 1Yeah, no dramas. I saw them talk to Kweli at the Eden Park and she was quite keen to talk to him straight away. And look, they're a different crowd. None of them have been in Parliament before, I think the seven from Opportunity. But I can't work out why you'd talk to the party with the most seats rather than the party with the most votes. With the highest votes, exactly. To me, that has more credibility because literally you're saying more people voted for this party.

Speaker 8She's basically backing up Mowbray in that with their strategic voting rather than going for the people, the most votes.

Speaker 1The thing, and we'll put Mowbray aside, but some of my reading today was a guy in newsroom, Jonathan Milne was writing about The reason that National won so many of the electorate seats, he puts down to incumbency. If you are one of the local MPs for Epsom, oh, that's not right because that's Seymour, for Invercargill or for Southland or whatever, you're turning up to every school, prize-giving, you're at every– field day, you're everywhere, so people get

Speaker 1to know you and you're familiar so you get returned. Yeah, that's right, so it's called incumbent, you know, it's not the overhang, it's people, because the last time National had so many seats, people were just saying, oh, he seemed like a good bloke, he gave them a daughter of the science prize at school, he seems like a straight shooter, have a crack, give him a shot, and that's it.

Speaker 8But I took him on his word that 19 times I heard today in the afternoon show that during the campaign that he emphatically ruled them out. So I figured that opportunity was a vote for the left. For him to turn around today and offer, he's going to need her because he can't just have a government With a one seat, because what happens if something happens.

Speaker 1During the time someone... I don't think Peters and Seymour would go into a coalition with Opportunity because, I mean, those guys are old school. They're not going to like some smart young party. No, exactly. You've seen some of New Zealand's first attitudes towards women. I mean, particularly if she gets a portfolio... they'll be kicking off.

Speaker 8I know, and it's just the way he's done a backflip on it, and then it's made, like, I just hope, like, Winston, he should be ringing Hipkins tomorrow and going, hey, man, how about this Prime Minister thing?

Speaker 1Oh, it'd be great. Because we could fight, I mean, it's like Prince Charles, if you tried it.

Speaker 15For 50 years.

Speaker 8If it's good for Luxor, it could be good for Winnie too, can't it?

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 1And I think people would enjoy that. And finally, you know, it's one and done. He's gone. Three more years and there'll be 85 or 86.

Speaker 8He's going anyway. Anyway, mate, good talking to you.

Speaker 1Nice to talk to you too, Dan. Text through. Marcus, we voted and spent the last three days at Lake Mavora, no coverage. Nicola Willis out. What a real genuine shame. That was the bit that I thought was weird, was Lux had talked about how all these people are his great friends. But if he'd sorted his act and stepped aside earlier, those people would have been back in. They'd got 5% more with a new leader. That would be my take. I don't know if he'll last the whole term. I don't know. But everyone seems, all the commentators seem to, mind you, the commentators are just the same as talkback callers, aren't they? Anyway, 24 away from 9. Looking forward to

Speaker 1your calls. Be in touch if you want to. Heddle 12. Someone said, Marcus, please give us a break for the elections. It's been morning, noon, and night. Well, it will be. It will be for the next three weeks. And then it'll all kick on again, I would think, because elections, you know, people are into them. I thought 74% was pretty good, but I don't know what percentage of people are enrolled. Stephen, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 2How are you going?

Speaker 5Good, Stephen.

Speaker 2I'll just refer, actually, the last guy that was speaking, he said the words, the reason why he voted for opportunity was to get rid of Luxembourg. I don't understand that theory of voting because surely you don't vote for a party just to get rid of someone. You vote based on the policies and the the outcome that they're going to produce for the country.

Speaker 1Oh, I think under MMP, people vote for all sorts of reasons. They want a particular combination of parties to get together. And when we've got that 5% threshold, if it means that party that's just hovering around 5% will be there, that might be a more effective use of your vote.

Speaker 16I understand.

Speaker 2So that's why opportunity, but they're a centre-right party.

Speaker 1Well, that's not clear.

Speaker 17Well, it was.

Speaker 2It was described by Gareth Morgan, who's the founder this morning. He said we're a centre-right party.

Speaker 1Yeah, but I think it's changed lots and some. That's according to my interpretation. But yeah, fair enough if you want to, but that's not how I see it. He actually, actually, he actually categorically... But Gareth's gone now. It's a different party.

Speaker 2Yes, but he categorically said this morning that the policies that he created are still in place. And they've all sent all the right policies except for the land tax, which he doesn't agree with.

Speaker 1And emissions and bottom trawling.

Speaker 2Bottom trawling, that's, I mean, my father was a commercial fisherman, so if you want to get into bottom trawling, I can talk to.

Speaker 17You about that.

Speaker 1Oh, no, I don't want to get into it, but I think these are new policies that have happened. And I think it's probably, I mean, most people go on about Gareth all being about cats.

Speaker 2Yeah, the other thing is about, like, when you, they talk about the swing voters and their number of seats, like he was talking that because National got 42 seats and because of it, well, if the shoe was on the other foot, I bet you he wouldn't be complaining.

Speaker 1Are we talking about Gareth Morgan still?

Speaker 2No, your last caller, he was talking about because National had 42 seats and they shouldn't have had 42 seats because New Zealand.

Speaker 1Had, Labour had more votes than National. I think he was talking about what Luxon had said. That's all he was talking about was, but anyway. Tanya, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 8Hi, Marcus.

Speaker 18Hey, I just want to share with you my journey on voting. So I vote in the, what you call the Māori electorate. And so when I, I think I rang you up about it, and I said that there was only three candidates and they were both, Labour winged parties and I wasn't represented in national and that sort of stuff. What's come out of that is I've made a complaint to the electorate commission to say that the voting,

Speaker 18as the voting law goes, is that any voter needs to be able to vote for any party that has the opportunity to vote for all parties.

Speaker 19And so what I've suggested.

Speaker 1Hang on, Tony, what was your situation?

Speaker 18I went to vote.

Speaker 1Are you blind?

Speaker 18I was in Wellington. I voted in Wellington. It was in the electorate for the Māori votes. There's only Te Whare Māori, Greens and Labour for the electorates.

Speaker 3Sure.

Speaker 20Yeah.

Speaker 18Do you want to research that before you want to carry on and talk to me about it, or.

Speaker 3So what.

Speaker 1Are you on the Māori roll? Is that where you are?

Speaker 18Yeah, so basically what I've done is I've complained to the electorate commission to say that all parties, if they are going to run for Parliament, must have two Māori seats, one to pass the motion and one to second it. And that would be passed as law. I've got hold of the Māori courts. So in the rest of the way, Māori... to party Māori in them didn't get in, but Māori

Speaker 18has to be represented, be able to be represented in all parties. So yeah, that's what I've done. So that's what you think.

Speaker 13How about that?

Speaker 18Pretty good, eh?

Speaker 1What electorate are you in?

Speaker 10Wellington.

Speaker 18Tauranga National Wellington.

Speaker 15Okay.

Speaker 1I don't really understand any of it, Tania, but as long as the people you spoke to understood you. And I mean, yeah, that seems like a fine kind of thing that's happening there. But yeah, good on you. I mean, that's it. Everyone's got good ideas about elections and all, Food for thought. We've all come up with ideas about what's to make it smoother or more interesting or more peppy. Be in touch if you want to. HETL 12 0800 80 1080 and 9292 to text. Keep you updated with news. Marcus,

Speaker 1people voted for National, but then Winston jumped to Labour in 2017. 46% National, 35.8% Labour. Why is everyone crying this time? No one's crying this time at all. I think in 2017, Winston hadn't ruled anyone out. People were upset that he'd gone with a smaller party. People were furious. So what I think people are upset about, if I'm reading the mood of the nation, they're upset that Luxon said he wouldn't work with Opportunity. There was that weird thing on the TV coverage where they had Mark Mitchell

Speaker 1trying to sort of be the bugler and say, oh, well, actually, we've changed our mind. It would be pragmatic. But the time to say it'd be pragmatic is before the election, not once the results come through, because otherwise it looks like you're shifty, shifty, shifty, shifty. Someone said Opportunity GM is ex-national minister.

Speaker 20Isn't it?

Speaker 1Interesting what people say, eh? And I don't know, it's like you can't say something whispers anymore. You know what the word I'm looking for. If you're thinking about Ian Lee's Galloway, he was a cabinet minister in the Labour government. So He's the GM of top. That's my understanding. So, yeah, I mean, just don't text through lies or check them. Well, you text through what you want, but that'd be my take.

Speaker 3Oh.

Speaker 13Oh.

Speaker 1I'm liking the texts too, the private texts. Keep those going. Hetal 12, 14 to 9. Hetal 12, good evening, 12 away from 9.

Speaker 21Second lowest.

Speaker 1Voted turnout ever 74%, which still sounds pretty good to me. If you didn't vote, why didn't you? And I don't care, I'm not going to be judgmental about your reasons, but if you're enrolled, why wouldn't you vote? I'm just trying to think, because I felt malaise before I went to do my tick, and I did think the pen was wrong, and the layout was bad, and the circle was too small. A minor quibble, really, when people fight for democracy, what about some of those countries where they put your pen and ink and dye your finger? Stuart's Marcus, good evening. So what we are talking about, and if anyone had an election party, and what about a grand coalition? And

Speaker 1were there sausage sizzles outside near the booth? Stuart's Marcus, good evening and welcome.

Speaker 11Yes.

Speaker 6Yeah, I.

Speaker 11Rang up on, I don't know, it must have been Saturday morning, and I wasn't allowed to say after I'd been down to my voting booth in West Melton Community Centre. I'm on the mayoral electoral roll, and... I knew who I was going to vote for. One was Nicola Grigg, which is national, and the other one was that. Well, all the party votes were on the left-hand side, which

Speaker 11is good. And then on the electoral roll, all you had was Labour, the Greens, the Party Maori, independent first or something, and legalised cannabis, and there might have been one more. Well, I didn't want any of those, so I went up to the woman at the booth and I said to her about it, and she said, oh, well, that's what happens when you go on the Maori electoral roll.

Speaker 11And I said, yeah, but where's my, you know, woman that I want to vote for in Selwyn? She said, well, they're not on there. And I said, well, that's a bit rough. And then one of my mates happened to turn up into the booth as well. And I happened to owe him some money. And I said, good day, mate.

Speaker 15How's it going?

Speaker 11And he said, yeah, good. I said, who are you voting for? And he looked at me strangely because he's still sitting at the booth getting his paperwork done. And he looked strangely at me. And I said, yeah, I'll give you 50 if you vote for ACT. And then I got a bit of attention. And then I said, not enough, 150. I owed him 450, you see. And I kept increasing it. And I said, look, make it 400. And he's going, what? And I said, 450 and that's it.

Speaker 11And he said, the keys are in your car on the floor.

Speaker 1Very good. Thanks, Stu. Keep it going, guys. Nine to nine. Hetel 12, seven away from nine. Good evening. Feel free to get in touch if you want to. Lisa, it's Marcus.

Speaker 22Hello.

Speaker 23Hi, Marcus.

Speaker 15Yeah, I think a.

Speaker 23Lot of the reason that Luxon might have did what he did in ruling out the top party was because it seems to me the old party older established parties just couldn't get their head around the fact that there might be someone new in town sort of thing. And they just assumed that they wouldn't make the 5% and that it was safe to say that. And then, um,

Speaker 23when things started changing, he didn't want to go back on, on what he had already said, you know, they don't like to, to turn around on what they've, they've already committed to. Um, And, you know, after the vote, after Saturday night, when most of the votes were counted, Sunday morning, they're all sort of saying, oh, we might have to work with these minor parties. Like, it was a revelation to them, oh, we actually have to do this.

Speaker 7You know what I mean?

Speaker 23They're so entrenched in, oh, it's Labour or National, Labour or National, we don't have to worry about these minor people. And that's the way it's been since I left school in 1987. Nothing changes. Labour, National, Tweedledum, Tweedledee, doesn't matter. They all do the same thing. And that's why a lot of the time I haven't voted. And I'm now, you can imagine, I'm around your age. I'm 58 now. But a lot of the time I haven't voted because

Speaker 23it makes no difference. They all do the same thing.

Speaker 1Yeah, okay. But, I mean, we get different policies. We get things that no one's done before, don't we? I mean, you say they're all going to do the same thing, but I mean.

Speaker 24They talk.

Speaker 23About different policies, but they don't do it, is my take. They say, oh, we believe in this and we believe in that. But in the main, they tend to do virtually the same thing. They bring in lots of immigrants to help prop up the businesses, to give cheap wages to the businesses. They've been doing that since 1987. They've propped up the housing prices for a long time. They've suddenly realised that's maybe not such a brilliant idea.

Speaker 1You'd vote New Zealand first then, wouldn't you?

Speaker 23I did, actually, yes.

Speaker 1Yeah, well, I mean, yeah, so you've got to be honest. Jeepers. We're honest to admit, but you can't say you're not going to vote for anyone. Anyway, hey, we're just ambling towards the news. People, if you want to come through and talk, I'll catch you after the news. there's two lines, they're free. Get in touch. The number is 0800 80 TADIA 9292 to text if you want to be a part of it. Anything else you want to say, it'd be nice to hear from you. So yeah, get in touch, you want to talk on air. Here till 12. If you didn't vote, why didn't you vote? How do you

Speaker 1feel about not voting too? Is it a good feeling? I guess it probably is. That's my take on it. Because, well, I suppose it is true, you can't really complain from here on in. But it's the second highest... What's weird is quite a few people voted during that COVID election. Remember that? In fact, I don't really remember it. But yes, get in touch if you want to talk. Mark is still 12. And more lines will be becoming available. But you've done very well. So 0800 ATTATI and 9292 to text if you want to be a part of it.

Speaker 1And I'll check around for any other news internationally that we've got happening also too. But yeah, if you want to be a part of the show, it's good for me. I've been away for a couple of weeks. It's quite good to talk politics. Quite enjoying it. Catch you in a bit. Good evening and welcome here till 12 o'clock tonight. I hope it's good in your neck.

Speaker 2Of the wood.

Speaker 1Are we rudderless? Are we rudderless? Well, there will be an interregnum, I guess. Romance along at midnight. We're not rudderless. Romance coming at 12. But we are talking about the mop-up from the election.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1What I was amazed by is from the very beginning, when 2% of the votes were counted... The percentages didn't really change in four hours. It kind of wasn't much fun to watch. I mean, some of the commentators in the column, some of the commentators, I thought, ended up watching TV3. It was pretty good. And they watched the rugby, obviously. And that was pretty good too. That was Tonga. Nothing's quite as good as the Samoan-Tongan match, so that was unbelievable. They should take that match to Vegas instead of, Vegas

Speaker 1round instead of the four random teams. I think that would be much more impressive. Because, man, have they got passion. Ben Marcus, welcome. Good evening.

Speaker 25G'day, Marcus. Look, I see Polymarket's got 85% chance. Hipkin's gone by the 1st of December. And, yeah, look, I got into the.

Speaker 1What else has Polymarket got?

Speaker 25It hasn't got a lot else. It's got on forming the government. I think it's a 90% chance that the government's back.

Speaker 1Has it got a chance of Luxembourg being rolled?

Speaker 25No, it hasn't got a chance of Luxembourg being rolled.

Speaker 1How do you get that to be on Polymarket? Can anyone with any money just put that up?

Speaker 25Oh, you can view it, but you can't bet straight from your debit card, you know, not from here in New Zealand because, you know, it's illegal to place bets on Polymarket.

Speaker 1It's easy to get around that, wasn't it?

Speaker 25Yeah, you just run a VPN and stablecoin in that. Yeah, it's completely easy. But, look, just on the split voting, so I got really into the split voting. I split voted sort of pretty much the outcome is what I expected.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 25I would like them to change the law, though, so it can't happen again.

Speaker 1How would you change it, Ben?

Speaker 8I'm not sure.

Speaker 25But I just don't think it goes with the spirit of democracy kind of thing. I know the Maori Party have done it for a number of elections.

Speaker 1I think this was the first election the Maori Party were talking about that. Because the Party hasn't been around that long.

Speaker 25No, well, they've done the overhang previously, but yeah, I think it's the.

Speaker 8First time they've actually pushed it.

Speaker 1How old are you then?

Speaker 25I'm 37.

Speaker 1Did you ever vote in first past the post?

Speaker 25No, no, no. So the first time I voted was like the 2005 one, actually.

Speaker 1Because if you vote in first past the post, right, unless you were in a really close election, no, unless you're an electorate which was really close, there was no point voting. So say you're in Remuera where I was and Alan Hyde and whatever, you know, the Tories are on 80%. So if you voted for anyone else, there's no point because the guy was always going to be there. So I think people have forgotten how futile and meaningless voting in First Past the Post was. It was terrible.

Speaker 25Yeah, but my concern with this now is we've seen how it works. We've seen how it happens. and we can completely stack the deck for next time. National consistently wins more electorates, eh?

Speaker 1Well, they talk about incumbency, and that's because they... And I think as those number of seats go down, you know, because, I mean, I imagine that National gets turfed out next time. They're not a three-term government. They're barely a two-term one, right? So then there'll be the clean sweep, probably the electorates of Labour, and then... Incumbency comes in, so it means if you are the local MP, people are more likely to return you because they've got to know you and they like you. So I reckon it could exactly work better.

Speaker 1It could work and it could be screwed the other way as well.

Speaker 25Yeah, look, it could go Labour, it could go National. You know, I just reckon there's going to be a lot more fighting for local electorate seats now that people have, you know, seen how this works and what can be done. And then I'm worried that we're going to blow out to 150, 160 MPs. You know, that's what I'm worried about.

Speaker 1I can't work out why Labour doesn't put more effort into getting good electorate candidates for some of their local MPs. Because I tell you what, some of them have been pretty patchy. It seems, I mean, certainly in South, in Invercargill, not so much this time, but normally they brought someone in from somewhere else. I mean, they must be able to find someone in Invercargill who can run. It's been really.

Speaker 25I've seen that Invercargill lady won by like 10,000 votes.

Speaker 1Yeah, which is amazing when you have any experience with the Invercargill Hospital. They've got a guy with a catheter in for 1,000 days or something. They've got no urologists. in an underfunded healthcare system. So anyway, don't get me started.

Speaker 25Just quickly, Marcus, on the votes that are left, the specials, I see that last time there was about 700 of them and now there's only about 400. I've seen Chris Lynch put up that Labour needed to win 125% or something of what they got last time on special votes in order to just draw a level with National as a hung parliament. So if you've got 200,000 less votes and you need 125%, it's not looking good. Yeah, I

Speaker 25don't know the robustness of that, but yeah.

Speaker 1I think they think two seats will go the other way. Will they, one or two? I think that's what they think. And, of course, one or two means a difference of four, doesn't it? Could have two go for one.

Speaker 25Yeah, but the way the overhang works, because nationals have got no party vote, if their party vote drops, then they get another overhang seat. So you've got an even.

Speaker 26Bigger parliament and it counteracts the other seat. So you're no better off than what you were. So it's pretty much game over for Labour at this point.

Speaker 1Nice talk, Ben. Thanks so much for that. Yeah, 700 days. The guy with a catheter because of a lack of urology or urologist. So that's the healthcare system. Fears Southland's urology service could collapse as surgery is cancelled.

Speaker 5So, yes.

Speaker 1Faye, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 15Marcus, welcome back. Welcome back from your holiday. Did you make it through Taranaki this time?

Speaker 1Faye, it wasn't a holiday.

Speaker 4Okay.

Speaker 15Oh, sorry.

Speaker 25Sorry.

Speaker 15I beg your pardon.

Speaker 1That's all right. But, yeah, so, yeah, that's the situation.

Speaker 15Okay.

Speaker 1But, yeah, so.

Speaker 15I'm confused. I'm confused. Do you remember two or three years ago there was a little lady that stole dresses and underwear and things, and she got caught out and she needed a fine? She was on one of the panels on Saturday night.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 15Did you notice that?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 15Oh, I don't think they had anything to do. She shouldn't have been, I don't think.

Speaker 1I thought most of the criticism was about Paul Henry, who was a candidate, who was a panellist. That's what I'd heard.

Speaker 15Yeah, but when she was on, I thought, how? You got the bums rushed from the Parliament and you're sitting on the panel.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 15Very strange this time.

Speaker 1No comment on that, Faye, but thank you. Jay, it's Marcus. Good evening.

Speaker 20Hey, Marcus, how's it going?

Speaker 1Good, thanks, Jay.

Speaker 20Hey, just sort of... Like, leading up to the actual election itself, is this, for being how close it is, is this a reflection on national, over the three years? Had it been this close, had they done a good enough job in the three years they were in government, why was it this close?

Speaker 1Oh, from my understanding, Jay, if you're in, if you get elected to government in New you always get two terms. It's only once, I think it was Bill Rowling's government, that just went one term. So for this to be so close after just one term, because normally you get in and it's all new and people love you and you get returned with an increased majority. So everyone said that this does not reflect well on Luxon's leadership or

Speaker 1on Simeon Brown as campaign manager. That was all that is. It's very bad to almost be a one-term government in this country.

Speaker 20Yeah, yeah, no, definitely. And I think the way their campaign, how they ran it, it just didn't reflect on National itself.

Speaker 1Well, there were no ideas. All their ads were about attacking the Green Leader. I think their online ads were a weird obsession with Chloe Swarbrick.

Speaker 20Yeah, and the whole Noni Texas. Like if they had gone a different approach, I.

Speaker 1Think everyone would have looked at them in a different way. If they'd been positive and shown leadership and said, okay, this is what we're going to do. They need to have some ideas. It was just a tap from the very beginning.

Speaker 20And that's what I think as a general, as New Zealand, we don't really see that as a good way because we're still, as a country, we like to make it a fair fight. We don't like to attack each other. I think that's what we've been. And I think when National came out attacking the Greens and attacking all the other parties saying, oh, because all they had to say in their campaign slogan was no new taxes. Yeah, okay, you've got no new taxes.

Speaker 7But what else do you guys have?

Speaker 20You know, as a party. And that sort of, that's reflected on this result. That's the way I look at it. And I think.

Speaker 1Jay, you might better explain this to me, right? Why did they not put their Nicola Willis and Gerry Brownlee and Chris Bishop and Paul Goldsmith, why didn't they put them. Why didn't they put them in a winnable seat to do something? I can't work out how they managed to just throw those people out. They were their best and they've gone. And I guess that's... I guess that's the problem when you win more seats than you've got places on the list. But still, it feels weird to me that they couldn't strategize to get their high performers back in.

Speaker 20I think this comes down to a leadership. I think this comes down to Chris Lux in itself. Because I don't think John Key as a national leader back in the days would have done that. And I think this is reflecting on Luxon himself. He sort of, there's that mindset like, okay, they're gone, I can get some new guys in. You know, and it's probably just, I don't know, probably a reflection of him being, you know, a CEO

Speaker 20of a company, you know, employers. employees are replaceable but.

Speaker 1Yeah that's right and you've also got to think okay well if someone's gone you think okay well that's over and then you start the focus on the new you're quite right that is the business model isn't it people get tuned over quite quickly yes.

Speaker 20And i think it's quite sad because i'm from lower hut and to see chris bishop gone not not so much gone as the electorate but he's out of government and that's like oh that's pretty sad because he's been in government for five years And just to be replaced like that, it's pretty sad. And it's pretty sad on Luxon not even mentioning him in his speech as well.

Speaker 1Well, I think he was going to roll Luxon, and that's why. It's punishment.

Speaker 20Yeah, it is punishment, but then what about Goldsmith and Willis? Yeah. geez it's pretty yeah it's pretty brutal isn't it like myself i wouldn't i wouldn't be a politician and yeah it is it is brutal out there like you're for your friends one day and then you know you don't even get mentioned the next day so.

Speaker 1Did you see any did you see anything of bishop in lower hut.

Speaker 20I did. Like, I think you can sort of see it in the parties with the generation of these days, like Labour and the Greens are real active in their social media presence. And I think National have just started to jump onto it. And it's quite sad. I think in the last week, Chris Bishop was just So he was just putting a lot of videos and a lot of posts on Facebook saying, oh, you know, I've been leader,

Speaker 20I've been in government for 12 years. It was almost a cry for like, vote for me, please. You know, and it was quite sad because it was like every second day he was putting out a post saying, vote for me, I've done this, I've done that.

Speaker 1So you think he panicked too late or something, do you? Is that what happened? Because I was seeing that sort of stuff and I can't quite work out what it was because maybe he was busy with other stuff. But Ginny Anderson, she is quite, I mean, she's a likeable sort of a person.

Speaker 20Yeah, but you've got to remember that Hutt Self is a red domain.

Speaker 1Yep, okay.

Speaker 20And, you know, Trevor Mallard held it, and, you know, and Ginny held it, and then all of a sudden, Chris Bishop won it. So there was always going to be that sort of, that boundary between, and because Chris Bishop is a Hutt boy as well, so that was sort of what tore apart as well, but it was quite sad, and And just the whole Chris Luxon not even mentioning him, that was real sad because, you know, he gave 12 years to the government. But he was also, he did a lot over the three years with the

Speaker 20whole transport and the whole RMA reform.

Speaker 1All the pundits always said he was the best performing of the National Party ministers.

Speaker 2Oh, he was.

Speaker 20And for myself, like I work in the building industry, I'm a project manager. So for him working on the RMA reform, that sort of helps me in my field because that opens up a lot more work and a lot more just work for developers as well. And we're in the business of building houses and it's, It's all about quantity because we're trying to build houses and just with a lot of red flags, I think Chris Bishop has done a lot to sort of take those away

Speaker 20and then sort of allow us to do what we can do and what we're good at.

Speaker 1And the weird thing is Ginny Anderson, I presume, would have gotten on the list anyway because she was 12 on the list. So that's why it can't work out. But I see that in Wellington, they reckon... National support was at 20% because of all the redundancies and layoffs and things like that. So they– that was the– Wellington was the place where they really fell out of love with National. So, you know, because I can't work out why in Lower Hutt they didn't vote for Bishop and just get Anderson on the list.

Speaker 20Well, that's– and even, like, I worked in a commercial construction company in Wellington and it was– about a year ago and it's just so dead, so quiet up there and lunchtime you couldn't walk through Glampton Quay but now it's just so dead and so quiet and it's real sad because a lot of public servants have gone and that's what brings businesses to Wellington. You've got the foot traffic, you've got people that are going away to buy lunches

Speaker 20and spend money on a weekly basis but To not have that, that's probably why it's reflected with only 20%.

Speaker 1Jay, thanks so much for coming through. I appreciate your call. It's 23 past nine. Back in a bit. Here until 12, feel free to give us a call. It's 26 past nine. Colin, it's Marcus. Good evening.

Speaker 22Yeah, g'day, Marcus.

Speaker 17How are you?

Speaker 1Yeah, really good, thank you.

Speaker 7Great.

Speaker 5Hey, just a couple of things from that previous caller I was just listening. And my understanding was the option was there for the listing piece of Mistout to go into. That weren't there. But you'd look at Nicola Willis's case. She's Wellington-based, four kids, husband working in Wellington. For them to move, you know, six months in advance before an election to another area they hadn't represented was just not a goer for some of them. And they honestly thought that they would still get in, but it's just the

Speaker 5electric vote went so high.

Speaker 1So what do you do? If you're the National Party Committee, then do you... move around some of your candidates and put weaker candidates in some of the electorates so more list people will get in? Is that what you do? Because they must have known this was going to happen.

Speaker 5Well, I don't think they did, because I think that they always thought that they'd get a few, you know what I mean?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 5And that just went one way, and you could argue perhaps the vote spitting went against them a bit as well, you know? And the second thing about the idea that Luxon didn't really lift Bishop off in the speech, He'd talked to Bishop beforehand and it was agreed he wouldn't be put on the speech because... He still thought he could win. Yeah, he hadn't conceded at that point.

Speaker 1But this was midnight, eh?

Speaker 5That was canvas. That was out on the media over the last two days. So it's not Luxon not putting people in the right places and it's not Luxon... Has he acknowledged him since? I haven't listened to everything.

Speaker 1No, I haven't either.

Speaker 5I don't think he's made a speech as such. But then, of course, Bishop's only come out at 10 to 6 tonight and said that he was conceding. So, yeah.

Speaker 1Just trying to think about MPs that have been great and have come back in, you know, in Cabinet. I guess Michael Wood is one guy that was there and then he's left and he's back in. I don't know whether Bishop, I mean, Bishop, would he be back? Because he seemed to be someone that was chomping at the bit to get there and has moved quite quickly. He's probably done his dash, has he? Do you think he'd come back in?

Speaker 5I don't know. I mean, I suppose it really depends what he does over the next year. three years and it's really interesting because he made some serious comments on either Jupiter City Island tonight about the fact that you know he's been a poor dad and a poor father and if he finds a position he enjoys and it gives a better family life I don't think you will see him back.

Speaker 1Work life balance because I tell you one thing everyone bags about politicians but they do seem to work they do seem to work they do seem to work long hours a lot of reading.

Speaker 5All right Oh, yeah. I mean, and that's the thing he said. He said it would be great to be able to go away with the family over the holidays without a satchel of notes in the corner of the house, you know.

Speaker 1Well, maybe he might realise that being a parent and a partner is not what's going to happen. It's quite nice to have an escape route.

Speaker 5Well, I don't know what the Opportunity Party MPs will do because they'll have nothing to do.

Speaker 1No constituents. That drives me crazy. That drives me crazy.

Speaker 5Absolutely, and I should be paid half the price.

Speaker 1Oh, absolutely, because none of that sitting in your office with people on medical waiting lists with health problems. I'm hearing you. I'm going to run for headlines, Colin, but nice to talk. Thank you. I'd like to congratulate all the callers for being so level-headed, which is lovely. Sometimes after the election it can be a little bit fraught. But, yeah, that's right, the old Kule Wong. Every time I hear that, I think that Neil Diamond song, and I can't work out what, anyway. Yes, of course, none of them will

Speaker 1have constituents. And I think there's seven MPs, I think, for the Opportunity Party. It used to be called Top, but there you go. Be in touch if you want to talk here till 12. Very exciting, Invercargill was at the supermarket, and there was a woman in the supermarket with a pineapple. And you never see a woman with just one pineapple. And she was, anyway. Long story short, I'm not quite sure where the segue was, the World Aerobics Champions. The World Aerobic Championships are in Virkago. So

Speaker 1we have world aerobicists at the supermarket shopping in their kind of national tracksuits. Quite exciting, I thought. I didn't know it was still a thing, aerobics. Remember Brent Fairweather? Remember that all those years ago? That guy that was, it must have been the 80s. He was like a New Zealand aerobics phenom. I don't know what's happened to him. Pete, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome. You there, Pete?

Speaker 27Yeah, how you going there, Marcus?

Speaker 1Pete, good, thank you.

Speaker 27You there?

Speaker 8Yep.

Speaker 11Yep.

Speaker 27Yeah, I hope you had a bit of a break.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, yeah, I did. Yeah, good.

Speaker 4Yep.

Speaker 27Yeah, just going back to the politics, I reckon Chris Pritchard was overrated. He blew out all of his budgets when it came to the roading and all that, all these plans. He went, oh, we haven't got that money, we can't do that. So I'm looking at his background now. He hasn't done much. He ran a tobacco company for a while, but.

Speaker 1I think it was a lobbyist for a tobacco company. I think it was a lobbyist. I think that's what happened with him. I think it was sort of a smart debate at university, then worked for a tobacco company, then ended up in politics. So you're probably right.

Speaker 27Yeah, so he hasn't done really much running a company or doing... He's one of these typical politicians that get in there, he jumps on his little white horse and goes for it and He did a lot of, and also all those developments up here. He forgot about Auckland. He was footy to go up there and build those three units on one piece of section on that. He just basically... is trying to tear Auckland apart.

Speaker 1It probably needs to be torn apart.

Speaker 27You've got to build up.

Speaker 1You can't just keep building out and out and out. I thought he was seen as someone who was a moderate. He wasn't kind of a fundamentalist. He was a moderate within the national party you know he wasn't like a um he wasn't sort of a christian he wasn't one of the sort of the christian right oh no.

Speaker 27He wasn't but then quite often too all those developments there you think before now they've got to move all that stuff all the you know what all up north or whatever to get rid of what you know what you got to get rid of and if all this fast tracking stuff and i reckon even a bit too far with that if you build it uh i think my uh David Seymour's got on that. Before you build a subdivision, you've got to make sure you've got your pipes, your pumping stations in place before the developers can move in and start building houses or whatever. So basically, he

Speaker 27didn't think about that one. So basically, he was a bit out of control in some ways.

Speaker 1Should we be kicking him while he's down?

Speaker 17Oh, that's life, isn't it?

Speaker 27Politics, that's the way it is. You win stuff, you lose stuff.

Speaker 1Fair enough.

Speaker 27You know, you've got to be the big boy. You've got to wear the big boy's pants on. You can't handle it. Well, if you do things wrong, sometimes you pay the price. Maybe people just thought, well, you know, the things that he did, like how I think, maybe thought, no, he's a bit of a loose unit.

Speaker 9Yeah, okay.

Speaker 27If I did a job like that and I found out I wasn't doing it right, I'd expect to get my knuckles sort of whacked a little bit as well, but he just kept on doing it. I reckon he's got a bit out of control, personally.

Speaker 1Anything else from you, Pete?

Speaker 27Oh, no, I sort of voted and did the thing you have to do as a person, you know. But I'm still not happy with Winston Peters, how he hasn't handled that Michael Laws issue.

Speaker 1I was away from all of that. And tell me about Michael Laws. No one seems to think that was good what he did. Is that right?

Speaker 28Not at all.

Speaker 1That shows we're pretty good. Because he's had a lifetime of saying extreme things. I've worked with him. He's fairly full on. He's one of those people that loves to wind people up and get a reaction and say inappropriate things.

Speaker 27But he's not even in Parliament yet. Basically, he's got foot and mouth disease. His mouth got him into trouble. And how would he handle that? You listen to all the shows that when he's with.

Speaker 16Ryan, all that.

Speaker 27And when he just put his little lawyer's hat on, thought he was going to get away with it. When he had the opportunity to deal with it right then and then, he's not going to be a member of our party. End of story. Matter gone. And also, New Zealand First lost a lot of votes. I listened to Kerry's talkback shows last week. And a lot of people were going to vote for New Zealand first. They went to ACT or whatever, another party.

Speaker 1Okay, so it certainly lost votes. Okay. Because I thought, because from my, and I wasn't really involved with the news in the last three weeks, but from what my understanding was, is that a lot of people thought it was just a media set up and it was just a, yeah, it was a stitch up on laws. But actually what you're saying, and you've got your finger on the pulse, you thought actually people were upset that it lost New Zealand first votes.

Speaker 27Oh, definitely. When he had the control of the steering wheel that day, he should have just made it quite clear. Michael Laws is now gone. He's got nothing to do with our party. When he got to work, he would have got the respect of New Zealand first. So he lost that respect because he handled it the way, oh, I'm going to deal with it when I get back. We can't do it because the lists are all out. He made excuses to try to keep them in there. As far as I'm concerned... Chris Lutskin won't even deal with him. So he's a bad apple from the day when he moves into Parliament anyway. So why would you want to deal.

Speaker 1With the guy? They didn't lose your vote from New Zealand First though, did they, Pete?

Speaker 27Well, I had no choice. Because I thought about it, I spoke to it. I was almost going to put my paper in the Act box, but Act. So you swallowed your dislike of him and voted for New Zealand First anyway? Nice to talk, Pete.

Speaker 1722 to 10.

Speaker 2720 away from 10.

Speaker 12Alison, it's Marcus.

Speaker 20Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 14Welcome back. I'll try and be level-headed. I'm just going to say the attack ads on Chloe worked against them completely there. That was a bad, bad what they did there. I possibly wasn't going to vote at all, and because of those ads and everything, I voted for the Greens party. Last time, I voted for New Zealand First, but when, nothing to do with the law, that didn't come into it, but when Winston Peters sacked Whatever he did with Phil Goff, I decided back then I wasn't going to vote for the New Zealand First because of that, so I'd already made my mind up.

Speaker 1That was out of Trump. And boy, he's... Boy, Trump's been giving as much in orders in the States, hasn't he? Goodness me.

Speaker 29Wow.

Speaker 14What he said for Goff was actually correct. Nobody else would back him up there.

Speaker 13Yeah.

Speaker 14It was correct, but nobody had the... He was the only person that stood up and said that, you know, and I agree with what he said, but nobody else, there was a week there.

Speaker 20Yeah, so.

Speaker 14And I do think that David Seymour would be good as the finance minister, but I also think they should get a new minister of health. I think Simeon Brown's too weak.

Speaker 1Well, the health system's in crisis. It's terrible.

Speaker 14So that's one they should change there, but I do think that David Seymour would be a very good finance, because he does all the pharmac and does all the medication. He's in charge of that, and it would be good to have him controlling the finances.

Speaker 1Are you glad you voted Ellison? Oh, yes, I am.

Speaker 14I went down at 5 o'clock. I thought, what's the best time? They said, what's the best time? And I thought to myself, everyone will be watching the chase on TV. I'll go down there.

Speaker 1You see.

Speaker 14And there's no queues.

Speaker 24There's nobody down there.

Speaker 14So I picked the right time.

Speaker 1Yeah, good on you, Alison. Nice to talk to you. Thank you for that.

Speaker 4Wow.

Speaker 1It's an interesting vote. Joyce liked that a lot. Tanya, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 13Yeah, hi, Kia ora.

Speaker 24Hi.

Speaker 28Just talking about Christopher Luxon and his 19 times... I have ruled out the Opportunity Party. Unequivocally, I've ruled out the Opportunity Party. So we're in a bit of a cadundrum now, aren't we? Because, obviously, he's backtracked. Well, he isn't backtracked, he's... He's like now entertaining the thought that he.

Speaker 1Is that a mistruth or a change of mind? What's the difference between a lie and a change in your mind?

Speaker 28It's an interesting question, isn't it?

Speaker 24I will not work with them.

Speaker 13And then what was it?

Speaker 28David Seymour and Winston Peters were like, don't even talk to me about that. They're not going to get over the line. And now all of a sudden they want to talk to them.

Speaker 1I mean, the whole key for them was to keep Opportunity Party below 5%. Well, I don't know, yeah, to below 5% and have those votes wasted. So, I mean, what he said was effective, but it was untrue.

Speaker 28Yeah, but the point being that a lot of voters heard Christopher Luxon say, I will not work with them. So some voters on that premise went out and voted and got Opportunity Party over the line.

Speaker 1But surely if you're going to be someone that's fallen out of love with Luxon, you would have fallen out of love with them already. I mean, this is... You'd have to be pretty thick-skinned and loyal to him to support him right up to this stage, wouldn't you?

Speaker 13Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 28Well, I don't support him, but I do think if he didn't have any integrity before, he definitely hasn't got any now because you can't trust his word.

Speaker 1I like the way you put that. I wonder who he had integrity with.

Speaker 13I don't even know if he ever had any integrity.

Speaker 28Maybe for, I don't know, maybe for his social media employees. How many of them were there?

Speaker 24Seven?

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah. Tell you something. Did you see any of the Chloe ads when National was having a go at Chloe?

Speaker 27Maybe.

Speaker 30Maybe. Maybe.

Speaker 28I think I heard more about the Michael Laws and the attacks, which wasn't very nice.

Speaker 1Yeah, people, that seems to have gone really badly. Because it's interesting talking to Pete and to talking to Alison, who I've always thought were both quite conservative people. And Alison went and voted Green on the back of that. Wow, goodness me, good on her.

Speaker 28And isn't it interesting, re-universities and the Greens?

Speaker 1What's that?

Speaker 28University students.

Speaker 13Oh, yeah.

Speaker 1I don't want to get banged up. It's too confusing with too much policy, but I'm hearing you. Tania, thank you. 15 to 10. Hedl 12. Yeah, those that didn't vote, why didn't you? I'm enjoying the discussion. People are talking about a grand coalition. But I'll tell you something, I reckon people have landed at a really, everyone's happy. Well, not everyone's happy, but people, actually, what is the mood? It's not everyone's happy, but everyone's reached a place of, of opinion and comfort with where they're at, I guess.

Speaker 1I mean, National hasn't won. They've all said National's campaign was terrible, and you should get a second term easily, but they're back in power, so it's interesting. Anyway, here till 12, if you want to partake. By the way, Russell Brand will be sentenced today. Well, his sentencing begins... in the courts in london this morning but obviously there will be victim impact statements and that could take a long time um so yeah be in touch you want to talk 14 to.

Speaker 3010 oh 10 away from 10 o'clock so just those things that i've got to tell you about that um that um russell brand sentencing although i don't i mean that's i mean that's gonna be fairly grim isn't it but um There'll be the endless tabloid stories about his life in prison, which I always find fairly uncomfortable reading, but I guess that's, people want vengeance, they want incarceration, but they want punishment as well. So that's, I guess

Speaker 30that is what that is.

Speaker 1Now all the videos are surfacing of his interviews in various places. Some screened, some didn't screen. I seem to remember when he was being interviewed at TVNZ, he was fairly I'm trying to think of the word. I'm using my word carefully. He was fairly, yeah, he was fairly on the line of what was decent. But yeah, there we go. Curious to know all those very strong comments on Michael Laws. And I see that Tane Randall and Albert Nauru have both commented and said they thought that

Speaker 1NZ First should have done better. And apparently for New Zealand First, you don't comment about the polls unless you're Winston Peters. So maybe they'll get told off as well as Michael Law's getting told off. Six away from 10. If you were trying to get through, there's some lines of Elkie. And email me also, romanzalong at 12. If you didn't vote, I'd be curious to know why you didn't vote. That's kind of interesting for me. Also, I know that in Australia it's huge to have a democracy sausage. Is that a thing? When you go and have a vote and then you get a hot dog or a sausage.

Speaker 1I don't know if we had those here. By the way, the democracy sausage, which is a tradition, they are not free. It was the word of the year in 2016, democracy sausage. And there are apps you can actually look and see where the democracy sausages are going to be. I don't know if we do that in New Zealand. I mean, all the last probably seven elections, I've voted at the Bluff School, which is a lovely school, but there's not a lot of, it's not a sausage sizzle place. By

Speaker 1the way, too, I can see that the price of sausages have gone up. At Bunnings, the sausage sizzle has gone from $ 2. 50 to $ 3, which I still think is pretty good value. I don't know what the price of a sausage would be these days. November 14 prices go up. The price of drinks would remain unchanged. So a sausage and drink combo would continue to cost about $ 5. I don't know if I ever thought that actually it was a thing. I thought the sausage sizzles... Now, I'm thinking

Speaker 1probably more so of the ones outside the warehouse. I always thought they were run by individuals, not by the hardware store themselves. Anyway, always good. Mind you, I've worked long enough in radio, and often in radio, I have to go into a sausage sizzle, and there'll be some sausages at the back of the freezer in a scody old chili bin. I wouldn't go near a sausage at a public sausage sizzle. Anyway, be in touch if you want to talk or if you want to be involved. Now, it's always interesting when people say, I sent the below

Speaker 1text earlier. They're not below on my screen. Oh, by the way, the sausages and bunnings are $ 2 in West Auckland still. Someone says, Marcus, could New Zealand first flip to support Labour if they offer Winston to be Prime Minister? Well, yes, I've posited that. That wouldn't be a bad idea. Winston, I'm sure, would jump at the chance. But would the Labour core voters want it? Would they want to be in a party with Michael Laws? I think Michael Laws

Speaker 1has probably made New Zealand First fairly toxic. I don't think anyone, I don't think any of the MPs, I mean, the women from the Opportunity Party don't even want to be in the same room as him. But yeah, get in touch if you want to talk. 0800 80 1080 and 9292 to text. Anything else you want to talk about too? Oh, by the way, I've got the World Cup coming up on Sunday. The Aussie women versus the Kiwi women, then the Aussie men versus the Kiwi men. That's going to be a good Sunday night. That's two great matches. Great matches. Boy, oh boy, that Tongan Samoan match.

Speaker 8Wow.

Speaker 1Have the flags come down yet? It was a shame to see Samoa. I didn't like what happened at the stadium on the match last night because it seemed as though the Samoans who were there in the majority were singing. And in the stadium, they started playing The Voice and Horses, Aussie anthems to drown them out. I thought that was mean-spirited. Marcus, I usually miss out on the sausage sizzle because the bread is usually pre-buttered. I don't like butter or margarine. It is always pre-buttered. Be in touch if you want to talk on air with you till 12. The number

Speaker 10800 8080 is a text. It's 9292. Looking forward to what you've got to say with you through until 12 o'clock tonight. Someone's talking about compulsory voting. Is that what we want? Surely not. By the way, greetings. Good evening. I had everything worked out and planned tonight. But of course, there's really bad weather. So I suspect there might be flooding. So if you've got an update on the weather, it's important we cover that. Someone's texted, and thanks for the reminder, some hearty surface flooding around Hamilton. Still running. Take care and drive safe. So if you have got a weather remote...

Speaker 1A weather report, let me know what that is, if there's flooding or anything, update like that. So there could be problems with traffic. Marcus, I think the old snag is still good value. Think about buying a pie from the dairy. Still delicious, but surely equal in value. When I go to buy a sausage and bread, it has a different effect that being I'm helping a cause or charity. I don't think anyone begrudges the cost of a sausage ever.

Speaker 20$ 2.

Speaker 153 going to charity, you don't make much money. How much is a sausage a dollar, is it? The cheapest law change is fairly simple. Make voting legally compulsory and with heavy fines for failing to do so. Easiest way to get a fairly AMAP elected government. I don't have a problem with compulsory. I think Australia has compulsory voting. I don't think we need it. But 74% getting down there, isn't it? I think in America it's less than 50%. Anyway, anyway, anyway. Marcus, in the new year, I'll be stocking up on popcorn

Speaker 1in preparation for live TV debates from in the house. Think it will be great entertainment, Lindy. Marcus, I wouldn't expect anything less from Michael Laws, but it's not like he killed someone. I still gave two ticks to New Zealand's first special vote. So obviously they like what he says. What else are people saying via the texts? Anyway, get in touch. Here till 12, you do want to talk. And the Grand Coalition, already that's been mentioned. People are

Speaker 1explaining the overhang too. I think we're familiar with how the overhang works and we're familiar with incumbency in national seats. If you've got the seats, you're more likely to hold on to them because people are familiar with the person that's your local MP. People love meeting their local MP at school prize givings and they're like, oh yeah, they seem good, they can speak. I've seen them in the flesh, we'll give them another go. Also talk about the World Aerobics Championships in Invercargill. I didn't even know that aerobics was still a competitive sport. Pauline, it's Marcus. Good evening.

Speaker 24Hello, Marcus. This business of thinking of making voting compulsory could backfire because if you've got people who, for one reason or another, don't want to vote and it becomes compulsory, they will deliberately vote in a weird way that actually backfires for the government or.

Speaker 1But people are so random, would they not vote in the wrong way and in such a way to cancel each other out?

Speaker 10No.

Speaker 24I think the very idea of making it compulsory annoys me because at the moment I have a choice and I choose to vote. But if it was a compulsion, if I had no choice and I had to go and vote, I don't want anything else put onto me in that way. I vote because I.

Speaker 1Are you Australian?

Speaker 14No.

Speaker 1Because in Australia, voting is compulsory. Can you soil your form? Not soil it. Do an informal vote? Can you just write, like, do pictures and stuff, I wonder?

Speaker 24I don't know. I don't know. It's just I think they need to leave it as it is because if people aren't voting and you make them vote or otherwise they get fined, they're going to muck the paper up or they're going to make a silly decision. By the way... I quite like the idea of Winnie being Prime Minister. He's got a jolly good suit and he speaks well.

Speaker 1I'm sure he'd love the job.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 24You have a word with him, Marcus.

Speaker 1He's not someone that I run on. I have run on him from time to time. It's been a long time ago. Why do Australians have compulsory voting? What went wrong for them?

Speaker 24I don't know, but it might be interesting to hear from someone in Australia who's listening.

Speaker 1I'll find out. Marcus, the reason I didn't vote was because all my adult life I have voted for our racing minister, Winston Peters. Then he banned my family's livelihood of greyhound racing, which tore us apart I lost my partner my home has tipped our lives on its head who can you trust never again that's from someone who was into the dogs yeah he didn't do that didn't he I think it's going to be an extremely dynamic three years I'm not sure if it will go the term whoever it is I'm not quite sure if Luxon

Speaker 1will go the term maybe they will though Maybe they'll realise they have one of those meetings and say, look, have we got to do this together? But I can't imagine the coalition discussions will be straightforward because New Zealand First and ACT have now got more power. And last time they got Deputy Prime Minister Winston and Seymour. What would they want this time? And then if you've got the Opportunity Party and Kweli Wong in there, then what will they want? Although they are, of course, greenhorns. All the Opportunity Party people, it's all of their first time

Speaker 1in Parliament. So they have zero experience and they've got zero constituents to look after. They don't represent electorate. So I imagine they will be on committees and they seem like live wires. They seem to be into research universities and stuff. I guess some of them within two or three years or the next term will be with portfolios, I would think. And the cream rises in Parliament, does it? Is it a meritocracy? I don't know. How's the flooding where you were at? And what about aerobics?

Speaker 20Um.

Speaker 1Marcus, regarding Michael Law's comments, seriously, all this fuss over one tongue-in-cheek comment. Women make derogatory comments about men all the time.

Speaker 2Wow.

Speaker 1Did any women make any derogatory comments about men in the run-up to this election? Why is it suddenly such a big deal when a man makes a cheeky comment? Look at some of the things Paul Henry said over the years. Michael's comments certainly didn't change my vote. People need to lighten up. Welcome back. If we make voting compulsory, there should be a box on the ballot to tick. Don't, like any of you, do better. Marcus, I'm 53, never voted, only because no one has inspired me to, and whoever gets in, just backtrack on most of what they promise anyway.

Speaker 1I support compulsory voting as long as there is an option to vote for none of the above or similar. It's a pretty sad state of affairs that some 870,000 people who are enrolled to vote couldn't be bothered.

Speaker 8Are you one of those?

Speaker 1Why did you bother not to vote? Why did you not bother to vote? Do, do, do, do, do. Anyway, get in touch. Marcus, my 15-year-old is meant to do a Rangitoto overnight tramp on Wednesday. Just heard your weather alert. Never been myself thoughts. Where will they camp? Are they going to Rangitoto or are they going to Motutapu? Because I can't work out where you'd camp on Rangi. Unless you're going to, yeah, that would be what I'd be curious to know. Oh, what a fantastic island. Anyway. Enough

Speaker 1from me. What have you got to say? People, if you want to join the discussions tonight, there might be something else you want to talk about. $ 3 for a sausage sizzle, you all right about that? Did anyone have an election party? Because there's so boring elections to watch these days. Because when 2% of the votes were counted, this is the thing of early votes. They start counting those first, and there's such a fair representation that I was out mowing the lawn, and the kids called me in. And, um, I said, oh, you can swear tonight because it was

Speaker 1a fairly lively discussion in the House. They called me in to watch it. But from the very get-go, the percentage votes didn't change. I think Labour started on about 28.3% and didn't vary much. Went up about a percent over four hours.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1And I've been to some of those election parties. They're terrible, eh? Because no one turns up until it looks like they're winning. I had a funny experience in 2002 in Gore. We'd been at the Hokanui Fashion Awards. I had to do some emceeing there. And the after party was the same place. I think it must have been one of the licensing trust hotels in Gore. The after match function was at the same place as the National Party headquarters when they got their lowest ever result. Boy, that was a glum lot. That was when they got 22% with people tapping away

Speaker 1at computers looking at the results coming in. Anyhow, be in touch if you want to enjoy your discussion. Marcus, I'm now 30 years old. This was my second time voting. As I've matured and grown up, I would never again not vote for a couple of primary reasons. Firstly, I've come to enjoy political conversations with friends and family, though I feel it's only morally correct to comment on other decisions once I've taken the societal responsibility myself. Secondly, I have a young son that means the world to me. Therefore, partaking in political discussion and decisions is a way I

Speaker 1see taking responsibility as a parent for his future. Do, do, do. Get in touch. If 25% don't vote and then are forced to, that potentially another four parties hitting the 5% threshold. Imagine that by crikey. 5.7% of the vote shouldn't be demanding rolls, otherwise it's the tail wagging the dog. Isn't the word proportional the P in MMP? Well, it's about using your leverage. What was Winston on seven times? 7% and he got Deputy Prime Minister? That's what happens if

Speaker 1you're desperate. Anyway, get in touch. Headle 12, 20 past 10. 10.22, romance along after 12 o'clock tonight. I'm concerned about the flooding. If you've got comments on that, let me know. By the way, in Australia, the compulsory voting came in in the 1920s and the voting numbers went from 60% to 91% in the space of one election. I imagine we'd still get the same result if voting was compulsory. I don't quite know what it's going to achieve. But yeah, there

Speaker 1we go. By the way, you might have heard that in the news, the Rugby World Cup's going to be in North America for the first time. Like a magic round kind of a thing. They have Samoa playing Tonga. Boy, oh boy, they'll be into that. Patricia, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 12Good evening, Marcus. Nice to have you back.

Speaker 1Thanks, Patricia.

Speaker 12That's all right.

Speaker 15I missed you.

Speaker 12What was I going to say? I nearly didn't vote. I don't drive anymore. I've just turned 85. So I decided I'd just walk down. They said the polling booth was down by Oranga. I had a pretty fair idea where that was, but I got down there. Not a sign of anything. I left home at 8 o'clock and I walked for two hours trying to find where I could vote. There was just no signs out. There was

Speaker 12a coffee bar right on the corner. They were selling coffee. I went in there and I just said to the lady, could you tell me where the polling booth is she said oh I don't know no idea I said oh well I've just about given up because I walked for two hours and I thought right if I can't find it in 15 minutes then I'll just go home and forget about it so I almost didn't vote then I walked along and there's a big park and I saw red signs with black on and I thought that must

Speaker 12be it so I walked right across there No, it wasn't that at all. So I said to the gentleman who was standing there, could you tell me where do I go to vote? He said, oh, it's way down the corner there. But he said, they don't open until about 20 past nine. I said, oh, my gosh. So I thought, oh, okay. I did want to vote. So I walked and walked and walked. Then I saw the lady coming out with a few signs to put up.

Speaker 12And I said, why aren't you opening? why are you opening so late? She said, oh, it's just what we've been told to do.

Speaker 15I said, oh, right.

Speaker 1Does it sound very professional?

Speaker 10No.

Speaker 12She said, oh, you're the first one to come. I said, but look, the time is now 20 past nine. She said, well, normally we won't open till 9.30. I said, but then you're missing a lot of the people that were going to work. They could skip in and vote and get it done. Why are you opening so late? Oh, well, she said, we have to do what we're told. I said, oh, well. So I went back with her, did my voting, and then I had to sit for half an hour. And in the end, instead of trying to walk home again,

Speaker 12I jumped, waited for a bus, and went on a bus and got me up the corner.

Speaker 15So that was good.

Speaker 1That was quite the adventure. What time did you get home?

Speaker 12Probably about 2.30. And I left home at 8 in the morning. And I walked, and I could walk and walk. I could hardly walk by the time I... found the place. It was really not good. But I did my voting and I thought, okay, good luck, whoever gets in. And I just voted for who I always vote for, Winston.

Speaker 1Good on you.

Speaker 12So I did that again and he got both my votes.

Speaker 1So that was that. You got the bus home on your Winston card too, on your pensioners card, eh?

Speaker 15That's right, I did, yes.

Speaker 1That's cheeky. That's cheeky, Patricia. Love you. Thank you so much for that. Heddle 12, my name is Marcus.

Speaker 4Welcome.

Speaker 1Um, yeah. Funnily enough, I shouldn't say this, but I got to send a picture of my father going to vote and, um, He's got a skateboard in his hand, which I thought was pretty interesting since he's on the cusp of being 97, but looks slightly stage managed, but good on him. Well, that was good. Anyway, yeah, I normally dress up for voting, but we're rushed, our family. Such a busy day, and busy day on the farm. We've had the shearer on the farm today. We've got the sheep, Sean. That was exciting. Boy, that was good.

Speaker 1Sean the sheep coached the kids' football team tonight. which is all right. Vanessa's out of action, so that was fun. Well, I don't think she'd be much of a coach. Probably shouldn't say that. But the thing with coaching kids' teams, like, here we go. It's five a side, and there's a goalkeeper, and you've got seven. So you've got five a side, and there's seven players. How do you fairly substitute people off so everyone's got the same amount of time? If they're 10-year-olds playing soccer or football, does each person have

Speaker 1the same time? Because some people are useless in the goal. I don't know how you run the goal. Do you get some person to be in the goal all game and switch it around week by week? These are the questions I've been pondering tonight and today. Dave, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 31Yeah, good evening, Marcus. Hope you had a good break.

Speaker 9Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 31Got a bit of work done, did you around the house?

Speaker 1Well, look, it was a funny sort of break because actually my partner was in hospital in Christchurch.

Speaker 5But she wasn't sick.

Speaker 1And it wasn't plastic surgery. So it was a slightly confusing situation, but she needed support. And we had a great, I mean, yeah, so that was the situation there anyway. So, yeah, so I can't be dishonest, but that's kind of what it was about. So I don't want to make out I have been on holiday, but yeah, that's the situation.

Speaker 31No, fair enough.

Speaker 5No, I understand. Still quite stressed off. Yeah.

Speaker 1Oh, yeah, certainly required some stuff to do.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 31Especially looking after the kids. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, I'd just like to defend the integrity of Chris Luxon. I'm not a national supporter. I voted Act. But, yeah, I mean, he did rule out working with the Opportunity Party.

Speaker 1Dave, just hang on there. I'm going to come back to you because it was unfair of me to take you just before the headlines. I will come back to you. So just on the results, I will come back to you on that too. So, yeah, you can defend your integrity. Hold your horse. I'll be back with you in 30 seconds. Yeah, Dave, so defend Chris Luxon's integrity?

Speaker 17Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 31I mean, yes, he did say he wouldn't work with Opportunity, and I mean, on the results to date, he doesn't need to.

Speaker 1Exactly.

Speaker 31Yeah, so, you know, everybody's bleating along tonight. I'm not quite sure why.

Speaker 5But, you know, Barry Soper said earlier on here at the Duke of Seas show that, you know, they've reached out to her, the National Party's reaching out to her through the back channels.

Speaker 31And I would imagine there will be a conversation. But, I mean, what it will be, who knows? But, I mean, I would imagine that he will, at their stop, would encourage her to sit on the crossbenchers. That would be the logical thing. They've got no political experience. Though, you know, and she's got quite an interesting CV because her mum was a senior advisor to Judith Collins. So, of course, she'd have brought up in a National Party head. household,

Speaker 31one would think.

Speaker 1Are you still there?

Speaker 32Yeah, I am familiar with her background, although I don't know, yeah, her mother was, yeah, yeah, I don't necessarily know that the true nature of the Opportunity Party has really revealed itself, because.

Speaker 1From where I sit, there were so many people from the left and the right, it was in their interest to diminish the credibility of that party, and they went both ways. People went on and on about the fact that Ian Lees-Galloway, who was a former minister in the Labour government, was the general manager of the party, and then they tried to diminish it by talking about her mother's connection with Judith Collins. Then they tried to diminish

Speaker 1the party by saying that they have a board structure and two people need to veto any decisions. So I think we really need to wait and see what the party's about, don't we? Because everyone's kind of tried to disparage them below 5%, it seems. Everyone takes the oxygen out of them because I think people would have found it easier if they weren't there.

Speaker 31Yeah, it's true. But even Barry Soper didn't think they'd make it.

Speaker 1And look, I don't want to criticise Barry's, but yeah.

Speaker 10Yep.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 31So, and I mean, you know, New Zealand politics has always been.

Speaker 16A bit like this.

Speaker 1By Barry saying that, does that Barry say he didn't want them to make 5% or was that his thought that they weren't going to? I mean, that's the thing, isn't it?

Speaker 17Yeah.

Speaker 1Everyone's got their own stuff going on.

Speaker 14Yep.

Speaker 1But what is interesting, Dave, is I think there's seven end up going there. None of them have got experience as politicians. Some of them have worked in the back rooms. And none of them have got constituents that they're answerable to. So what do they spend their whole time doing?

Speaker 12Yeah.

Speaker 31Yeah, I mean, probably the bigger picture is the fact that they've reach the 5%, say something about the state of New Zealand politics. You know, there's a hugely disenfranchised voting population out there that both parties, Labour and National, need to take heed of and look at what they're standing for.

Speaker 1So if you're Kweli Wong, right, and you've come from nowhere and you've brought the party up to 5%, I mean, she seems to perform very well in the media spotlight, which is not easy. If you want to guarantee. The continuation of the party being in Parliament, do you join the coalition or do you go into opposition? Because some are saying if you go into the coalition, it would be the death of the party. Because I think

Speaker 1Phil Goff was saying the majority of the supporters and ideas are left wing and it would be the people would never forgive you.

Speaker 31Yes, well, I mean, the Maori Party were never forgiven for joining the John Key government. That's right.

Speaker 16And yet, I mean, that was a.

Speaker 31Very astute move on his behalf and also on behalf of Turiana.

Speaker 1It made John Key, really.

Speaker 31Yes, but I mean to say, Turiana and Peter Sharples, I mean to say they got a lot done. And, you know, their own people sharpened them because, you know, they worked tirelessly for their people and... And, you know, I just think, you know, they were statesmen in their own right. And a lot of people on the right-hand side admired them both for what they did, you know, compared to the present-day Patty Murray.

Speaker 22Thing.

Speaker 31Can I just move on to another... Oh, you're.

Speaker 1Getting your confidence up. You're getting into some pretty interesting territory.

Speaker 20Well, not really.

Speaker 1Okay, do you think David Seymour should be Minister of Finance?

Speaker 11Oh, absolutely.

Speaker 1Okay, there we go.

Speaker 31Yeah, he's a pragmatic man.

Speaker 1What's your other thing?

Speaker 31Oh, yes. How long did Sir Dove Myer Robinson stay in politics for?

Speaker 1Would he be from about 1965 to 1980? Would it be that long?

Speaker 31Oh, Yeah, sorry, it would have been easy, but I was trying to remember his age. I think he got tops out about 81 from memory. But you're bang on the money, yeah.

Speaker 1Is that how long he was in for? I always just see him walking, walking without his shirt on up and down Portland Road. He was a.

Speaker 5Oh, okay.

Speaker 1Yeah, he was an interesting sort of a character.

Speaker 17Right.

Speaker 19Anyway.

Speaker 31He was well into his 80s, wasn't he?

Speaker 1I'll look it up, Dave, but nice to talk. Thank you, 24 to 11, feel free. I'll find out how long he was in there for. But what is– yeah, anyway, let's have a break. 20 away from 11. Cathy, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 22Yeah, hi, Marcus. I heard you talking about soccer, and I wasn't quite sure. Were you indecisive about putting the kids in as goalkeepers?

Speaker 1What's the best way if you've got 10-year-olds playing soccer– Do you choose one to be in the goal the whole time, half the game, or do you give everyone a turn?

Speaker 22I know when my youngest was little, right up until he was about maybe... Oh, I totally got to Rex. The kids, to be fair, because a lot of them didn't really want to be goalkeepers.

Speaker 1No one wants to be. It's too brutal.

Speaker 22Yeah, and so to be fair, every kid had to have a turn.

Speaker 1Yeah, that's how I run it.

Speaker 22Yeah, because my son, he was really, really good. He ended up in Hong Kong and Canada once. representing New Zealand as the goalkeeper when he was 15. He loved it.

Speaker 1So he just from day one thought that's what he wants to do?

Speaker 22Yeah, he was on the soccer field, the first one, when he was seven years old. Excuse me. And he was so passionate. But when it got really competitive, he sort of got quite burnt out because way back in those days, The kids weren't really taught how to look after themselves after injuries.

Speaker 10Yeah, sure.

Speaker 22And, yeah, it got a bit too competitive for him. And the son, he lost interest in it, but he was absolutely awesome at it.

Speaker 1I bet the coaches loved him. someone that really wanted to be a goalkeeper because every team wants that, don't they? Because most people hate it.

Speaker 22Yeah, they don't like it, especially if the ball's up the other end of the whole game. But it's also, yeah, when it's a real close game, close score and like you might miss a goal boy you're not very popular.

Speaker 1And what i've noticed to people if you do put them in the goal and you tell them and they stay they if they're new to it they sit right they stand right on the goal line so they've got no time to anticipate where the ball's going so it just goes flying past.

Speaker 22Them no but yeah i love soccer.

Speaker 1Got to do more coaching. Cathy, thank you so much for that 19 to 11 here till 12. Very, very heavy rain. I haven't looked at any of the websites, the news. I've forgotten how to do this job. It wouldn't be that easy, that hard. How many All Blacks have been in Parliament? Here's a quiz for you. We had Graham Thorne. How many All Blacks have been MPs? Was Chris Laidlaw an MP? I think he was. Well, no, was he a broadcaster? Was his wife an MP? How many All Blacks have been Members of Parliament? Because we've

Speaker 1got Tain Randall now, although I never won a World Cup, or did he? I'm going to ask ChatGPT this, or you can text me through. Seven. Oh, there was Ben Couch and Chris Ladell. Two Wiley, All Black of 1980, Māori All Black and MP. Graham Thorne, I think he was the MP for Ōnihanga. Chris Laidlaw, Tony Steele, the Honourable Ben Couch, Jack Ormond slash Tiaki Ormana, and Billy Glenn.

Speaker 1And of course, I think Winston says he was a Māori All Black. I think so. I think Sir Peter Tapsell was a Māori All Black, and as was Paul Quinn, the mighty Quinn. Come on without. Come on within. You ain't seen nothing. 17 to 11 if you want to partake. Pretty nice to hear from you. Marcus, the call from the elderly woman who could not find her local polling booth was very disturbing and underscores a major failure in this year's election organisation. In contrast to the previous years, the package we got for elections in it contained no

Speaker 1advice about booth locations at all and told voters to look up locations on the internet instead. Bureaucrats must realise that even in this day and age, there are still many people out there with no access to the internet. How dare people not vote? The arguments are facile. I say go live in North Korea, Russia, the Democratic Republic of China. Many have no idea what I was talking about. Marcus, this opportunity party is playing games with New Zealand people. She said she will talk to the largest party but will go with left. She will tell the public that

Speaker 1deal not done with national. Yeah, it's interesting. She said she's talked to the party that had the most seats, not the most votes. And the words made sense when she said them. But in retrospect, it makes no sense to me at all because the fairest way would go with the party that got the most votes. But, oh, well. She could also go and say, here are my five bottom lines. I said, no. Oh, well, I'm going to go talk to the other side. But some seats need to swing first. Marcus, good evening. I was disgusted with

Speaker 1this overhang situation. With the state of the country, we cannot afford to pay more people in Parliament. There is enough get paid by us taxpayers now who do nothing. Although, I'll tell you something, the number of MPs at the ground level is 120, and in MMP when it started in 1995, the population of New Zealand was a lot less. So probably if you'd increased, it would have been about that. What's the population now? Population of New Zealand in 1995, 3,673,000, and now it's 5.3%. So it's increased by 50%, hasn't it?

Speaker 1So by that token, there probably should be 180 MPs by now. So yeah, that's just me. 14 to 9, 14 to 10, 14 to 11, 14 to 10, 14 to 11. If you want to talk on air, that's the plan. Get in touch. And I'll tell you something, too. We go on about the overhang, but man, oh man, first past the post was a dog of a system, was a disaster. Unless you were in a marginal seat, you had no sway. 10 to 11, Ross, it's Marcus.

Speaker 4Welcome.

Speaker 1Good evening.

Speaker 6Yeah, good evening, Marcus. Look, I'm a little bit confused as to the mechanics of the Opportunity Party and From what we've been told, I hope I've got her name right, Quay Lung is really the spokeswoman for the party because in the caucus of the party there's a group of people that fronted it, promoted it, thundered it. and I think it's about five people, and two of them have to agree on every policy. So say she's in Parliament

Speaker 6and they're debating a subject, everything has to be referred to those two people for comment and for a vote.

Speaker 1That's not my understanding.

Speaker 24No?

Speaker 6What's your understanding?

Speaker 1Well, that wouldn't be practical, would it?

Speaker 6No, but that's how it operates because they've got a power of veto over everything that they, that group of people, don't agree with.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 6So in a debate in Parliament, they virtually... And we should know who they are because that group of people really control New Zealand for the foreseeable future because if the top party or opportunity party has the kingmaker... and they're dependent on those votes, they could vote a government in and out on their whim if they find something that they don't like.

Speaker 1I think they would require sign-off of the board on any governing arrangements. So it's more, I think, about the coalition negotiations.

Speaker 6Well, but surely.

Speaker 1I don't think it's about what happens inside Parliament. But wouldn't the. The bodies of the political parties themselves also, you know, the president of the National Party, would he not be involved in coalition discussions?

Speaker 6But wouldn't we have to know who the people are that have yay or nay say over policy? Shouldn't we, as a people of New Zealand, know who these people are behind it that have this power? And should they have a power to say nay, yay or nay over things in Parliament? Because they're not the elected people. I mean, Kweli Young, she's just a front person for these people.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, OK.

Speaker 6Shouldn't there be some sort of... not exposure, but some sort of explanation of what is going to happen.

Speaker 1Are you saying that we don't know the names of those people?

Speaker 6Well, no, shouldn't there be some sort of explanation of what is going on? Because she is only a front person. She's been selected by them on a Facebook interview or whatever it was, or a Sikh interview, and she's very articulate, and I've got nothing against her. I think the policies are quite reasonable.

Speaker 8I kind of thought.

Speaker 1I mean, the fact that she was interviewed on a Facebook page or whatever you're saying, wouldn't you take from that that so many other parties should be doing that that way because they got someone that's an extremely good performer and operator and she's sort of... she's sort of shown up all the other politicians who are so dreadful with explaining policy.

Speaker 6Well, not necessarily, because she just spoke the preference that they had for the answers. If she had spoken something else, she wouldn't have got selected. But she thinks along their lines, and who am I to say they're right or wrong, and who is anyone to say they're right or wrong? But She thinks like the five people on the selection panel that selected her. I mean, I think their policies are quite reasonable, so I'm not against the policies. I don't have an issue with them. What I'm against is that do these people, and I don't want to be

Speaker 6rude and call them faceless, but are these people, shouldn't they sort of present themselves to the people of New Zealand and explain things? the power they have and the reasons for the power. Because if they fall out with the people of New Zealand and they get Scotty, well, we could be held up to ransom to a degree.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 6I mean, I think for the power that's been given to them, there should be some explanation.

Speaker 1I thought there's been such an obsession with the Opportunity Party as everyone has tried to portray them has been too far right or too far left or too close with Judith Collins or too close with Enly's Galloway or it's the board that controls them. I think a lot of it has been a lot of scaremongering because people, whether it be ACT or New Zealand First or the Greens or Labour, well, not so much with Labour, but these parties have wanted to keep Opportunity Party under 5%. That's why I thought there's been so much hysteria around

Speaker 1their board. That's my take on it.

Speaker 6Look, I don't have an issue with their politics. I think their politics are quite reasonable. I think some of them should have been done a long time ago. But it's just the mechanics of the possibilities that I'm just worried about. I mean, how do we know that these people, are they an AI or are they human?

Speaker 30Okay.

Speaker 1I don't think they're AI. Good evening, New Zealand and welcome. I hope it's good where you are, people. And we're talking a bit about thoughts on the political situation, reasons you didn't vote. No one said they had a party to celebrate the election. So it used to be a big thing, but as I say, it's not an exciting thing to watch anymore. Because you know from the very get-go what the percentages are going. In the old days, you have a pendulum, you have different seats coming through.

Speaker 1It was exciting right to the end. Anyway, that's fine. It is the more democratic way, MMP. I'd much prefer it than first past the post, but I'm up for these discussions. I also wonder, I'll save that thought. Yeah, Rose, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 10Hi, Rose.

Speaker 19Hi, Marcus. I'm not a great person on, I haven't got a great knowledge on politics, but I was looking at a site on Google, as one does, and it was the 2026 general elections preliminary results. And I see that National received 142 seats and they have no list seats. And then Labour won 21 seats, yet they get 15

Speaker 19list members. And then you've got, as you go further down, you have the Green Party. They won two seats and they get 14 list members. How do they get all these list members?

Speaker 1Okay. So you've got your party vote.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1And if you get, say you get 50% of the party votes, say like, I think when Jacinda in 2020 with the COVID, when she got returned, she got 50, over 50%, but let's say it got 50%. If you get 50% of the party vote, then that means you get 60 seats in parliament, which is half because 120 parliament, 120 seat parliament. So you get half of them. So what they do, is they first get all the Labour seats. So maybe Labour has won 15 seats. But they've got

Speaker 160 people in Parliament, so you get the 15 seats from the electorates, and then that's 60 minus 15 is 45. So then you get the first 45 people on the list.

Speaker 19It just seems that here we have 131 members, and only 71 of them actually have elected seats. and 60 of them have flipping list MPs.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 19And I mean, really, it just doesn't seem right.

Speaker 1Would you rather they all had electorates?

Speaker 19Yeah, I think if they don't win an electorate, they shouldn't be there.

Speaker 1But the trouble with the old system, that was first past the post.

Speaker 21Yeah.

Speaker 1And the trouble with first past the post, if you lived in somewhere like Southland, which has always been It's full of farmers. It's the most national seat there is. And they've always won by about 15,000. So if you've lived all your life in South and in the old system and you wanted to vote for Labour or Greens, there was no point voting because it was meaningless where you were because Bill English would always get in.

Speaker 19Yeah, he didn't have a hope in hell.

Speaker 1He didn't have a hope in hell. So this is a fairer way, but then you've got the overhang, so it makes it a bit trickier. And the reason National won so many electorate seats this year, I reckon, is because they had a huge swing to them last year. They did really well. They talked about the blue sweep. So they won everything. Not everything, but they won so many electorates. And if you win an electorate, then your local MP, he's at the school prize giving, he's at the local fair, and people get to know him or her.

Speaker 1So they're much more likely to return them. So because National had so many electorate MPs last time, then, of course, most of them are going to get returned because people, once you've seen someone that scored a prize, you go, oh, well, she speaks all right, she dresses well, I'll vote for her again. She said hi to me, and that's what happens.

Speaker 19Yeah, it just seems funny. National did have, I think, four list MPs last term.

Speaker 1Yes, that's right. But this time their vote has dropped a lot. In fact, they got less votes than Labour.

Speaker 19Yeah, but they still gained more seats because they got more party votes. Is that what it is?

Speaker 1They haven't gained more seats.

Speaker 19Well, they gained the majority of the seats.

Speaker 1Yeah, and they've got the over. Yeah, so it is a flawed system.

Speaker 19Yeah, because, I mean, I just think they have seven... MPs there without any well there's a several there that have got no.

Speaker 1No one in the Opportunity Party's got, and for a long time that was the Greens but now the Greens have won seats as well so that makes them yeah for a long time yeah so Opportunity Party there's seven of them they've got no electorates they've got no one to hold them they've got no one that can front up and go to electorate office to.

Speaker 19Talk to them That's right And the other one that really surprised me is New Zealand First. They haven't got an electorate either.

Speaker 31No.

Speaker 19They've got 12 members in there.

Speaker 1I wonder if Michael Laws will continue to do his radio show. Oh, God. Well, that's the thing. I mean, he probably will.

Speaker 7I'm sure he will.

Speaker 19But whether he stays as an MP.

Speaker 1I was surprised coming back to work tonight. I was surprised. There's people that I talked to on this show who I think are fairly conservative, almost except one person. People were horrified by his comments.

Speaker 19I mean, he's always been chauvinistic anyway, hasn't he? Well, you can't say that, but I can.

Speaker 1Well, he's always had a preoccupation with, yeah, no, let's not go there.

Speaker 3Why?

Speaker 1No. There's almost a schoolboy teenage nature to some of the comments he makes.

Speaker 6Yes.

Speaker 19Absolutely.

Speaker 1And I guess that's the fairest way to say it, which most people think, well, you know, that sort of stuff, we sort of grow out of that, even if we are like that in the beginning, yeah.

Speaker 19Yeah, and he's never grown up, and he never will. Wash my mouth out with soapy water.

Speaker 1Oh, well, they always say they're going to clean, they're going to stop people at the trough, but they've been in the trough their whole lives. You know, that's the thing, isn't it? It's always the one. Gosh, we're a hypocritical lot, aren't we? You know, politician, then local councillor, then the whole time in the trough, but they're going to clear out the trough. I'll tell you what, they turned on Trump, though, didn't they? Boy, oh boy, oh boy.

Speaker 32Absolutely.

Speaker 1And what's interesting about all those Democrats, they're all very young people. They'll be around for a long, long time.

Speaker 19And that is why I can't understand how Trump ever got in when he did. I think it's more money.

Speaker 1Sure it is. Rose, lovely to talk. Thank you so much for that 15 past 11. Feel free to come through. My name is Marcus. Good evening. 0800 80 1080 and 9292 to text back in a bit. My name is Marcus. Good evening. If there's something else you want to mention, feel free to come in. It'd be nice to hear from you. Matt, it's Marcus. Good evening and welcome.

Speaker 9Hey, Marcus.

Speaker 17Just a little prediction. I reckon that we're going to see Bishop for New Zealand first.

Speaker 1Great idea.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 17Why not?

Speaker 1Because he's got a bit of that working man hero about him. He's a bit like Shane Jones, straight shooter, rough as guts, likes to smoke.

Speaker 17Yeah, and he was endorsed by Winnie as well. So I reckon... It's not a bad idea myself.

Speaker 1Can they kick Laws out and bring him in?

Speaker 17Only when they have to. They'll probably keep him hanging in. Well, who knows if they need the spot, they'll kick him out.

Speaker 1Can you re-change your list? I think it's your list from the election. I don't know about that. I presume it's your list that you took to the polls. So if Laws goes, it's the next person. You can't just walk a jump, Bishop, in there, can you?

Speaker 17Well, it probably won't take Laws long to say something else.

Speaker 1I mean, he's not going to get a ministerial post, so I don't think Laws would want to go. I reckon Laws would be furious with the blowback he's got. I reckon he won't. I don't reckon he'd be interested. He wanted to be Minister of Broadcasting or Minister of Civil Service or something.

Speaker 17Yeah, it'll be interesting. Watch this space, you know, cut and paste.

Speaker 1But, Matt, you reckon three more years until he's in for New Zealand First?

Speaker 17No, I reckon within three years, but three years at the moment. Who knows? Who knows? Maybe the next election, but it depends what he wants to do next. But I reckon he'll be keen to go in and go against his old boss.

Speaker 1Nice prediction. Thank you, Matt. Malcolm, it's Marcus.

Speaker 4Welcome.

Speaker 5G'day, Mark.

Speaker 16It's Malcolm here.

Speaker 1Hi, Malcolm. Sounding good?

Speaker 9You know, you're still talking about the election and the fallout, but I take a weird bit of a different take on it all. And that is, I honestly believe, I mean, I voted mentally national all my life. Not always. I was a great Helen Clark follower, by the way. But simply put, the limpest election preparation ever done by a

Speaker 9recent government. And I believe, with all the shenanigans going on, that regardless of what happens in three weeks, we will be back with another election campaign. in March to April next year.

Speaker 1Malcolm, it wouldn't surprise me at all.

Speaker 30No.

Speaker 8It's a gut feeling.

Speaker 9Look, I'm 69 years old, so I've been around a wee while. I came to New Zealand in 72, and I'm telling you now, the fallouts from this last election will go right through to early next year.

Speaker 1And Malcolm, I think it's quite common in overseas countries with MMP that, you know, they go because and they seem as it goes down the track MMP that it gets more and more fragmented. How many parties have we got in Parliament now? Are there nine? It's a party moldy. We've got Opportunity. We've got the Greens. We've got Labour. We've got National.

Speaker 9It's a disaster waiting to happen. And I mean that sincerely because I won't go into individualities on this, but I used to work with a lady here behind me The Maori Party. Lovely lady. And you will never hear her name. I know who it is. She worked for me for a year. Even Barry Silver didn't even know who she was. There's a subterfuge in politics in this

Speaker 9country I have never seen before. It's not me being anti the Maori Party. Well, maybe I am.

Speaker 1At least you can recognise that, Malcolm. 22 past 11. Get in touch. Mark is still 12. I'll wait. 180, 1080. I thought it was going to become incomprehensible by the end of it. Anyway, how are you all going, people? Welcome. Headle 12. Yes, that's right. The Russell Brand sentencing. The British papers are having a field day of that. Much, much coverage of many photographers photographing the police vans as they've arrived from the prison. And many, many photos of

Speaker 1his wife arriving at court. or very performative. No, that's not quite the right word for it, but the sentencing is today. Starts at 10.30 Britain time, but that will be victim reports. I think this is for one of the charges he has been found guilty of. Anyone got any comments on the Rugby League World Cup too? I just want to mention that because that certainly had me entranced, particularly the Samoan Tonga match. And I'm pleased the Rugby League World Cup is going to the United States because

Speaker 1I think if there's a Tonga Samoa match to see the, now I'm going to have to Google this because I don't know the name, but to see their versions of the haka, the siva. Have I got that right? Unbelievable. Is it siva tau? But that was unbelievable. And then the Samoans did it again last night and came right up to the Australian team and it was, yeah.

Speaker 20Ha!

Speaker 1The Aussie commentators are always a bit bamboozled by that. They go, right. Anyway, it's a shame that they didn't play as well as they'd done. I don't want to say that in a demeaning way, but, yeah, I think it was a– I think it might have been at Suncorp, but I reckon the people who managed the stadium played Aussie anthems right throughout the game to kind of dissipate the crowd, to stop them getting a full head of steam. There should have been no music. It should have been listening to the chants come out. But there's the other thing, right,

Speaker 1about the election, since we are reflecting on that. How do you even get to know your candidates these days? Because the meetings no one turns up to. So how are people finding it? Because it seems as though people are just watching stuff on Google and YouTube, which is all rubbish, or AI ads. So yeah, I wonder if you're a candidate, how you get out and about in your community. I guess it takes a long, long time. That's what Labour's got to work up. They need better candidates that can really build relationships. I know certainly down south, and not this time, but recently, it's always someone flown

Speaker 1in from a different area. I thought, jeepers, I'm sure they could find one good person. But yes, have you got comments about that or the coverage or anyone wants to go back to first past the post? I certainly don't. This is just, yeah. And look, I don't necessarily know that the tactical voting for the overhang made any difference. I think it's mostly just... It's mainly just incumbents and people being loyal to their existing sitting MP. But they, I'm sure, will find that data before too long. They'll have all that evidence. Because I think all your voting forms are anonymized, so the researchers can have the data

Speaker 1without your names on it and look at trends and voting. They'll be very interesting, all that stuff. Lines free romance from 12. It is 26 past 11. Really wet weather. You've seen the warnings too. Those warnings are continued most of the cases well until tomorrow. So yep, just be warned. The weather is not good. Not good about the Nvidia guy having the affair with a Chinese spy. It's unbelievable. You follow that story? Now Trump says he was kidding about Dana White press secretary offer. Of course he would

Speaker 1say that. That's a standard thing. And 2026 is to be the hottest year on record. Not only is it the hottest year on record, it's the coldest year there'll ever be, the way it kind of works. 27 past 11. Yeah, Dave, Marcus, welcome.

Speaker 4Good evening.

Speaker 21Well, welcome to you back.

Speaker 8Thanks, Dave.

Speaker 12Yeah.

Speaker 25Do I ask.

Speaker 21How was your three weeks and where'd you go and what'd you do and how'd you get on?

Speaker 1No.

Speaker 25You don't have to answer that.

Speaker 1My partner was in hospital in Christchurch. So we're staying at the Ranui Apartments, which is a newer part of the town. She wasn't unwell, and it wasn't plastic surgery, so that's probably what I need to say about that. So it was, yeah, it was a thing, and then it's not a thing, and... She is recuperating. So, yeah, extremely good. Spent a lot of time in Christchurch Hospital, extremely happy with that and thought it was fantastic. So,

Speaker 1you know, once you get in the serious part of it, it seems to work really, really well.

Speaker 3Yes.

Speaker 21And reading between the lines, I would like to say that I'm pleased to hear that.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 21That you needn't expand, but I sort of get the gist. Now, yes, I enjoyed the Australia-Samoa match very much. Australia have come to the fore, as I sort of predicted and expected. They're not to be underestimated, and next weekend I shall be.

Speaker 25Glued and.

Speaker 21Looking forward to it with glee. I think we're going to stand a good chance, but it could go either way. I'm slightly hedging towards Australia.

Speaker 1I don't like Bostock, only because he was so good with those intercepts. He seems to be a guy to never rate, but he's been extraordinary.

Speaker 11Rhys always seems to pull it out when he needs to.

Speaker 20Well, he does.

Speaker 1And that backflip.

Speaker 5Yeah, it's fantastic.

Speaker 8But we nuggety, he can't be underestimated.

Speaker 11He's always there or thereabouts.

Speaker 21Now, I would like to say good result. I know you don't agree with me, but however, I did vote Act, and I think at the end of the day for stability, et cetera, and direction of the country, yeah, I'll leave it at that. But anyhow.

Speaker 1Hey, Dave, because people say... I kind of couldn't be bothered for a while. Did you think for a while you're not going to be bothered voting, or were you always going to do it?

Speaker 20No.

Speaker 31Oh, heck no.

Speaker 21I voted the Friday last.

Speaker 8Oh, no, I got in.

Speaker 21The only thing was I voted over in. Pioneer which is over in Spraydon Way and I found out that I am a special vote that gets kind of last and it takes some through few weeks to count up and I didn't realise because I voted outside my electorate that it was what it was but I just took opportunity when I was over there you understand so you know yeah one thing I would like to point out is with the increased 5% Overhang, I hate

Speaker 21that term or that phraseology. Bigger seats, more seats. But how many companies can employ five new employees or afford five new salaries? I know it might be fairly penny-nicking, penny-nicking. penny you know penny pinching but well how many companies can say righto we're going to take on five new employees I don't know I just put it out there I know it might be but anyhow bottom line being

Speaker 21good to hear you back and I'll hang you on again you just turned in with a cup of tea and welcome back mate I'll be doing.

Speaker 1The same soon Dave thanks so much for that 27 away from 12 here till midnight 0800 80 1080 and got us a lot of exciting stories from Christchurch, actually. Walked to Littleton across the hill. That's a good walk. Went to the Rickerton markets. I've always heard a lot about the Rickerton markets, but boy, yeah, maybe they've had their day, have they? There's a big thing in it today. Wilson, it's Marcus.

Speaker 4Welcome.

Speaker 1Good evening.

Speaker 15Good evening, Marcus.

Speaker 1Evening, Wilson.

Speaker 11Yeah, definitely.

Speaker 10It's been an interesting election with the amount of electorate seats that National won.

Speaker 15I'm quite curious to who they're going to pick.

Speaker 10As their new speaker, given there's no list MPs to really pick from for them.

Speaker 1It's a really good point.

Speaker 10Because I think last time I checked, it's been a while since an electorate MP has been the speaker. It's quite uncommon, isn't it?

Speaker 1Well, was Brownie still the MP for Ireland? Was he list only? He was list only, was he?

Speaker 10No, he was list only. I think the last one was technically Adrian Ruafi, but he kind of popped in midterm for Labour. So I actually don't think there's been one this century that started off as an electorate MP.

Speaker 1Who would be their longest serving MPs? Would it be Todd McClay or someone?

Speaker 10I was thinking, I think it might be Louise Upson or Mark Mitchell.

Speaker 15I think those are the two.

Speaker 10That might be though. I'm curious if that, um, I don't know, maybe.

Speaker 1Is it a job people want, or is it just sort of when you kind of given up and think, okay, then we're going to.

Speaker 32I don't know.

Speaker 10I was curious if Winston Peters was going to have a go at asking for it.

Speaker 2It'd be interesting.

Speaker 1And it's not, it's not, you could also go and get someone from the other side. You could go and get someone like, um, Damien O'Connor, he's been there forever, hasn't he? He's been there 32 years.

Speaker 10That's true. But I doubt the right would let that happen, eh? Have someone from the other side become Speaker.

Speaker 1Well, I think it's been done before. But yeah, okay. It's a good thought. I haven't heard any discussion about that either.

Speaker 10Have you?

Speaker 30I don't know.

Speaker 10Not too sure. I'm also curious who will be deputy leader for the Nats. I don't even know when.

Speaker 1when they might be electing that. I think it could well be Mark Mitchell to keep everyone in order, couldn't it? Yeah, I wonder if that's going to be what it is.

Speaker 10I thought they'd try and go for someone more, you know, to balance out.

Speaker 1Would you go for Erica to keep her in the tent?

Speaker 12Yeah, I think Erica, eh?

Speaker 10Because she's definitely more that liberal side that the party needs to replace for Nicola Willis. And I feel like if you've got two guys... In the top two jobs, it's going to not appeal to.

Speaker 1A little bit pale stale, doesn't it?

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1Pale male stale.

Speaker 33Yeah.

Speaker 12That'll be interesting, though.

Speaker 1But, I mean, Erica... Because now that Chris Bishop has gone and Chris Pink has gone, Erica Stanford's really all they've got is to take over from Luxembourg, which I'm sure will happen, unless it's Mark Mitchell. So, I mean, I don't know when that happens. I guess it depends on how well the negotiations go.

Speaker 15I assume it could.

Speaker 10Might as well happen in the final year of the government, you know, just like how John Key did it potentially.

Speaker 20Yes.

Speaker 10That Luxon doesn't get forced out.

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 10But, yeah, I don't see.

Speaker 1Luxon lasting another election. Although I don't think Key was going to get forced out. I think he was just bored.

Speaker 10I think, wasn't he? Oh, yeah, just enough. At least, like, you get the choice of saying that you were leaving.

Speaker 25But, yeah.

Speaker 31No doubt.

Speaker 1Maybe in one of those meetings they've discussed succession.

Speaker 20Yeah, definitely.

Speaker 10But I'm curious if they will start negotiations anytime soon, or are we really waiting until the 27th of November to get the ball rolling?

Speaker 1Are you a poll watcher, Wilson?

Speaker 10Yeah, I would say I do keep in line with the polls that I think.

Speaker 1The polls are pretty, apart from Roy Morgan, the polls are pretty spot on.

Speaker 25Yeah, I think so.

Speaker 10I do think now with the way that New Zealanders are voting with the electorate seats. They kind of become a bit irrelevant because.

Speaker 20You can't poll those.

Speaker 10So it does look tight, but when you consider the overhang, it's actually not as tight as it seems.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 1And I just think probably, I just think in other years, the overhang's not going to be the thing it was this time. I think it's just a, I think it might, it's a bit of a historical aberration, the overhang, just because there was such a blue sweep last time And National won all those seats they'd never won before. And once you're there, people love to vote for the incumbent.

Speaker 21Yeah.

Speaker 10I'm curious to see what seats will flip from the final count. I'm hoping that maybe Mount Roskill might flip, but we'll see.

Speaker 1It's Mount Roskill and it's... Wairarapa, definitely.

Speaker 31Yeah.

Speaker 1Could be there.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And that's a rural seat too. That'd be weird for the rural one to go Labour.

Speaker 14Yeah.

Speaker 1Well, then it's kind of every man is in the old, yeah.

Speaker 3I know, yeah.

Speaker 10But definitely, I think, yeah, 27th of November will be another day for election coverage.

Speaker 11It'll be.

Speaker 1Oh, I'm sure there'll be. Yeah, it's quite right. And then the real horse trade will begin. I don't think we'll have a new government by Christmas. I think it'll take a long, long time. I think probably... You'd say, Wilson, that Luxon probably most of his troubles in his first term were because of the negotiations and because he'd given too much power to Winston and Seymour, wouldn't you say?

Speaker 10Yeah, but now I'd say that he's going to have a lot less power.

Speaker 1A lot less. He has got a lot less. He's below 30%.

Speaker 10Yeah, I'd assume we'd see a 50% national in the rest for the coalition partners, I think, for ministers.

Speaker 19I don't think he'll be.

Speaker 10I'd be really shocked if he got over 50% of national ministers in his cabinet.

Speaker 1Yep, that would make sense, although they've got 30% of the vote and New Zealand First and ACT are on about 23%, 24%, are they?

Speaker 10I think so, but if you think about it, they've got 42 seats currently and then New Zealand First and ACT combined are 25 seats or 24 seats, so. I reckon that they probably would get, yeah.

Speaker 1We will find out. Wilson, nice to talk. Thank you for that. 20 away from 12 o'clock here till midnight. 18 to 12, anything goes. Free weather around the... Well, South Island's been pretty good, actually. That's why I was excited we got the sharing done today. Boy, oh boy, that was exciting. Yeah, gee. And the coaching of the football team. It's been a full-on day. Then back to work, back as the hobby broadcaster. If you want to talk just quickly about... and, and, and, yeah, I, sometimes the whole political discussion I talk about can get a little

Speaker 1bit fraught with people, can be a bit snide or passive aggressive or sort of, just a little bit mean spirited, but actually, every caller tonight has been, um, very reasonable with what they've said, very well thought out and very considerate of what they've said and I think probably we've talked about the election, we've got a new government, a different government and people are talking about the process, whether it's the right process or not. Are we happy with it? Um, It's been very, very interesting. And my two takeouts from what people have said, having been away for a couple of weeks, is that people weren't happy with what Michael

Speaker 1Law said. And people also upset about Christopher Luxon saying that he had not worked with Opportunity Party, now ruling that in. By the way, I'm sick of calling them the Opportunity Party. That's too many words. And we can't call them top because that's their own name. Or can we call them that? I think we can call them that. Anyhow, and I don't know what they should do, actually, if they're going to continue to be a force in government, or sorry, a force, yeah, in Parliament. not continue if they're going to be, because they are the first party that's ever got into Parliament an MMP under their own

Speaker 1kind of stuff. Other people have branched off from other parties and then gone solo and got in, but these are brand new. And they're young too, which is probably a good thing. Youth is always good. I think we've seen that in the American elections. All the Democrats, they're all very young, 20s and 30s. So, yep, that's what we are discussing. If you want to talk about that, it'd be nice to hear from you. Um, 0800 80 1080. If you want to text, it's 9292. Hetel 12. A texter said that they think the next speaker will be

Speaker 1Barbara Kruger. She's been there a long time, I think. A lot of the others I haven't heard of. So, yeah. Now, if there's something of political nature you want to mention before 12, does anyone wish we were back with first past the post? I think the system is miles better. I mean, it's got some challenges, but that's a good thing. I don't mind challenges. As a country, I think we're quite good with challenges. Always find a way around it. And what seems to be a great crisis one day will quite quickly dissipate. Maybe in three years' time, we're not talking about the overhang. Something else will have come along.

Speaker 1Interestingly enough, when we're talking about Opportunity Party being the first party to get in Parliament, I thought, what about ACT? Of course, ACT was started by the former Labour people who had been in Parliament, Roger Douglas and Richard Preble. And then Richard Preble, he won Wellington Central, which I'd forgotten about.

Speaker 5So, yes.

Speaker 1I forget what year that was. Anyway, be in touch if you want to talk. My name is Marcus.

Speaker 5Welcome.

Speaker 1Phil, good evening.

Speaker 33Hi, Marcus.

Speaker 29Don't you think it's funny, the system now, how everyone who voted for National would have voted for Nicola Wallace and the other fella and one or two others that were the face of the National Party and all those people voted for them and yet they're not there.

Speaker 1So what went wrong? wrong with that? So say you're Nicola Willis, right? And in Wellington they hate the Nats because they fired everyone. They love the Greens. So what do you do? You say, Nicola, take your family and go and move to Southland because they knew you needed an electorate to get in, eh?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 29It seems bizarre to me that everyone loved them and wanted to vote for them.

Speaker 25All those ones that did, I didn't.

Speaker 29But there you go.

Speaker 1But Chris Bishop, the thing about Chris Bishop, he was up against Jenny Anderson. She would have gotten on the list. You'd vote for him for Lower Hutt, then you'd get two for one.

Speaker 7It's bizarre.

Speaker 25I don't really get it.

Speaker 1I think in Lower Hutt, I think in Wellington, they really hate the National Party They're on 20%. And they wanted to punish them. And so they got rid of Willis. Well, they got rid of Willis because he had no electorate, but they got rid of Bishop and gone.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 29They were the face of the National Party.

Speaker 1You're looking at the list now. It's full of lightweights.

Speaker 29You don't know half of them, do you?

Speaker 2No.

Speaker 1Well, you've got people like, you've got that guy from Southland. What's his name? I mean, Jeepers Creepers. Anyway, I mean, sometimes people rise to the occasion, you make a minister and they've got good advisors and something happens.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 1You heard of Miles Anderson and Waitaki?

Speaker 29Vaguely.

Speaker 1Carl Bates, Lloyd Budd, Blair Cameron. Yeah, okay.

Speaker 25Yeah, it's a.

Speaker 29It's a funny system, but I think it's a good system because I remember back in the first past the post days, they just used to tell all their lies and then get in there and not do what.

Speaker 2They were going to do.

Speaker 9Exactly.

Speaker 33That's why everyone... And if you're in a seat that was like, you may as well not vote because the national candidate would get in by about 15,000 votes.

Speaker 1It would never change.

Speaker 8Yeah, that's right.

Speaker 29Yeah, so it was, I don't mind the system, but this one, this time, it sort of seemed to backfire on everyone.

Speaker 1Yeah, and look, we still don't know what's going to happen. I mean, I think probably there could be some changes that happen. There could be another election. There could be, the Opportunity Party could be, but, you know, let's wait and see.

Speaker 8Really, another election? Is that possible?

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1If they can't form a government, we go back.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 1But then that would be because the Opportunity Party wouldn't back them up And they probably then would get punished at the polls for wasting everyone's time. That's the supposition.

Speaker 29Right. Because Chippy would surely want to get it. He'd throw them a.

Speaker 25Line, wouldn't he?

Speaker 1Oh, you'd think so. If a couple of seats went the other way, I'm sure they would think, well, rather than not be on. And I think people think the Opportunity Party are more likely to go with Labour because a lot of their five bottom lines are about the environment and bottom fishing and breaking up the monopolies of the supermarket. Because now Nicola Willis has gone, that's off the table. So it does seem to be more along the lines of the left policies. That's my take.

Speaker 21Yeah, interesting.

Speaker 29Good on you.

Speaker 1Nice to talk, Phil. Thank you. Five to 12 if you want to be accompanied before the end. Romain is along next.

Speaker 31Oh, good.

Speaker 1Yeah, and by the way, too, someone's texted me about the refereeing. I thought the referee last night in that match against Samoa I thought he had a real colonial patronizing attitude towards the Samoans. I thought he was overly officious. He treated them like children, punished them. I mean, to punish Luai just for kicking the ball, I thought he did an incredibly bad job of it. He's normally a good ref, but yeah, I just think that bias kicked in.

Speaker 1But the Samoans were outpassed. Well, not outpassed. I think they probably, it must have been a huge occasion for them.

Speaker 8Anyway.

Speaker 1Hello, Brent. It's Marcus. Good evening.

Speaker 16G'day, Marcus. Sorry about my voice.

Speaker 1No worries. It sounds good.

Speaker 16All day I've been listening to the radio and you've been talking about the coalition partners, about this and that. I heard one person ask the question of all the people who have done interviews with us, the National Party, how much of a farm are they prepared to give away so that the Prime Minister can stay as Prime Minister? And that's the big question. How much are these other parties going to demand out of him? How far is he going to go? before he says, no, that's too much.

Speaker 1Well, he hasn't got many options, has he?

Speaker 10Well.

Speaker 1Are you saying he goes back to.

Speaker 16He can go back to the electorate and point out and say, these people have been too greedy, and I wouldn't do them any good the next time around.

Speaker 1So you have an election in three months' time.

Speaker 16Yep, but make it clear to everyone the reason why, because these people were too greedy. I mean, it's quite honestly, I know it's not going to happen in Parliament, it's certainly not going to happen in a lot of New Zealand.

Speaker 1Because you think he gave.

Speaker 5We haven't come across that yet, eh?

Speaker 1You think he gave Acton, New Zealand First too much last time?

Speaker 16Well, I tell you what, Winston Peters killed the TAB. He's killed the racing. He did away with 10,000 jobs from Greyhound. He wasted a heap of money on the ferries. Never mentioned any of that before the election. They were just loved up to him.

Speaker 1You do what you like in the first year, because three years' time, everyone forgets about it.

Speaker 16Well, that's the problem, eh? You know, Melbourne Cup, that was last week, and I know a lot of people I've been associating with for years and years and years never had a bet because they closed the TAB in Batoni. They're going to close the next ones around the Hutt Valley pretty soon. Pretty soon there'll be no TABs and people won't be able to bet on on the phones, on their accounts, because the whole TAB agency is only interested in under-30s. That's what their whole advertising campaign is all about. It was covered in the racing form by the now-retired editor. He covered all this.

Speaker 17Winston Peters ignored it, and it's happening now.

Speaker 1It's all sport betting, too, which is actually a fairly, yeah. I think sport betting is a fairly dangerous form.

Speaker 10Of betting, too.

Speaker 16That's his eye trigger, Winston Peters, you know. I mean, I wouldn't trust him. I haven't trusted him for years and years and years. All the different... back and forth over time as he's been in and out of Parliament.

Speaker 1This would be his last time, wouldn't it?

Speaker 16It would have to be. But tell me, what has Shane Jones ever won? Shane Jones gets them behind him, he goes in on his coattails. What's Shane Jones ever been elected for?

Speaker 1He's so self-satisfied.

Speaker 16Hey, I mean, you get two for one, but neither of them make a whole.

Speaker 1Nice to talk, Brent. Thank you. That is it. for me for tonight. And, oh, Marcus, proud Wellingtonian here. It's quite amusing listening to these boomer callers and their lack of understanding about voting or who they voted for is quite ridiculous. These people are the problem. But not to worry, us millennials and Gen Z voters are here to save the day. Let's wait for special votes. Things could get really fun.

Speaker 17Erin.

Speaker 1Thank you, Erin. I don't disagree. Someone's betting that Barbara Kruger will be the next speaker. Oh, hi, Marcus. Rugby World Cup. We can't have the Aussie refs or bung this weekend until the game's not riddled with controversy again like the Samoa Aussie game. At least five calls went against them. At least another five 50-50 calls. Ridiculous has changed the whole momentum of the game and gave them no chance. Bloody ridiculous. Having home refs never happens in rugby union. Watch the Sean Johnson video clip post game. If the ref stays out of it, Kiwis will run comfortably. One of my 2026 predictions with you. Anyway, thank you

Speaker 1for that. That's it for me. Roman is along next. Nice to be back, and I'll talk to you again tomorrow from 8 p.m. Have a good one. For more from Marcus Lush Nights, listen live to News Talk ZB from 8 p.m.

Speaker 9Weekdays or follow the podcast on iHeartRadio.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What would a human do? (20 November 2026)

    Nov 20, 20262 hr 13 minAudio

    On this free-for-all Friday Tim Roxborogh discussed being appreciated at work and sports fads with callers. LISTEN ABOVE

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. World Record for the (blank) talkback show ever (19 November 2026)

    Nov 19, 20262 hrAudio

    On Marcus Lush Nights with Tim Roxborogh callers discussed more on sandpaper gate and the Guinness World Record they have witnessed or participated in. LISTEN ABOVE

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. High heels and handbags in the sauna (18 November 2026)

    Nov 18, 20262 hr 20 minAudio

    Tim Roxborogh returned to fill in on Marcus Lush nights where listeners called in to discuss weirdos in public, creeps on the TV, GTA IV, and sandpaper gate. LISTEN ABOVE

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Is it illegal to eat a door? (17 November 2026)

    Nov 17, 20262 hr 19 minAudio

    On this edition of Marcus Lush Nights listeners called in to discuss the Melbourne Cup horse tossed in the tip after dying at the vet, and mispronouncing place names. And, in the last half hour of the show callers broke...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. They have very poor road sense (16 November 2026)

    Nov 16, 20262 hr 20 minAudio

    Marcus talks the scurge that is AI parking cameras (and the new windscreen barnacle parking deterrent), plus milkshakes and stolen trophies. LISTEN ABOVE

    Credit the people on this episode