Tonight on Marcus Lush Nights with Tim Roxborogh callers indulged in a bit of election chat before discussion of whether the Melbourne Cup is a dying event and the craziest coincidences. LISTEN ABOVE
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1You're listening to the Marcus Lush Nights podcast from Newstalk ZB.
Speaker 2It's Newstalk ZB. Welcome along, Tim Roxburgh again for Marcus. Remember, Marcus has been on holiday for the last couple of weeks. Well, this is the third of three weeks, so he is having a nice sort of pre-Christmas break, and he will be back on Monday next week. My name is Tim Roxburgh, and great to have your company. By the way, Quincy Jones, two years ago today, since one of the greatest producers of all time, a guy who did everything you could possibly really do in music and really almost every genre you can think of, and had an insane number of
Speaker 2Grammy nominations. He had almost 80 Grammy nominations. It's just bonkers what he did. Most famous were working with Michael Jackson, but who didn't he work with? People like Aretha Franklin and Paul Simon. He just cropped up everywhere. The Brothers Johnson, George Benson. One of the greats, two years ago today at the age of 91. And in his last few years, Quincy Jones just started to do the most hilarious interviews. And he could not care less about who he upset. And he would just essentially throw everyone under the bus,
Speaker 2including people who had been good friends. But he was so charming. I think he just got away with it. All right, 0800 80 1080, you can give me a bell. Text on 9292 and facebook.com forward slash Tim Roxburgh. Remember, no, you in Roxburgh. We do have another poll out today, but we've got three out in this last week. And so you may be at the point where there's just kind of total fatigue with this election. But I weirdly am kind of going, actually, it's... So close. And I
Speaker 2think I thought that by this point that it might be getting a fraction less close, but the polls are just showing, no, this is total knife edge, total knife edge. So the latest one today, you've got both National and Labour up a tiny bit. They are essentially neck and neck on roundabout 30. The Greens are 16.4. ACT is on 10, which is down two. And New Zealand First is also down two on 8.4. Opportunity, once again, are
Speaker 2above the threshold. They're on 6.2. As we know, it's Party Murray not campaigning for the party vote. So they are on 0.4. So it again comes back to opportunity. So I think if you wound the clock back a week, 10 days or so ago, then there was that feeling that actually things are starting to soften for opportunity. And so maybe Luxon's tactic of saying, no, no, no, I couldn't be any clearer. We're not going with them. We're not even going to talk to them. Maybe that was
Speaker 2going to work because the easiest, most obvious, most mathematically good chance of the Labour Party forming the next government is with the Opportunity Party. But if they say got like 4.9%, then maybe that was ingenious from Luxon. But the last two polls have showed Opportunity aren't teetering on on or about that 5%, that they're holding comfortably, 6.2% in this one, a poll a few days ago, which was closer to seven. So that brings me back to
Speaker 2that question of whether or not you really believe that Luxon would just not speak to them. And if you're listening last week, I said, I just can't for the life of me think that you'd take someone like, say, Bishop, who whether you personally agree with his policies or not is is clearly an effective politician uh an intelligent guy um whether he would be in a situation where national could form the government if they spoke to opportunity but luxon has said they won't speak to opportunity so therefore
Speaker 2they forfeit the election i just can't see that happening so so either luxon has the most almighty amount of egg on his face after election day if if on these numbers it's um You know, the opportunity party is kingmaker. So he has the egg on his face. And all these times, you know, we're up to more than two dozen times where he said he's not going to talk to them, that he does, in fact, talk to them. I mean, wouldn't that be so embarrassing? Or it's the other scenario that he gets rolled after election day to
Speaker 2pave the way for other people within the national party who want to keep their jobs, i.e. Chris Bishop, to have a chat with Opportunity. I find all of this actually where I know some of us might be reaching kind of peak fatigue. And this is where you come in and don't worry, we won't be doing politics all night as I start every show at the moment with, don't worry, we won't be doing it all night. But I just wonder where some of us might be reaching peak fatigue. I feel like, ah, it's actually so, so close.
Speaker 2I'm finding it more interesting, I think, than at any other time. And it is really the fact that Opportunity are not dipping, with these numbers, they're not dipping below five. So if you want to have a chat about the latest poll before we move on to some other things, then you can on 0800 80 1080. And it really is that point there about the Opportunity Party being kingmaker. What actually happens if this poll and the previous one, because they're fairly similar, if these two most recent polls
Speaker 2are accurate, Do you really think that National wouldn't have a chat to Opportunity, that they would rather be in opposition than speak with Opportunity? That's kind of the most odd thing to me about this whole election. Luxon might believe what he's saying, but I don't think anybody else does. And therefore, does it mean that actually Luxon would get rolled in order for National to speak to Opportunity? 0800 80 1080. You can text 9292. There's also something really interesting looking at how many people have changed their mind
Speaker 2in this election campaign, which I don't mind in some respects. I think it's kind of healthy for democracy for there to be a certain percentage of the population who can be swayed. So apparently 29% of people said that the campaign had changed their vote. So if you're in that almost 30% of people that you were going to go one way, but something happened during this election campaign that made you go the other, then it'd be interesting to
Speaker 2know what that is. I think some of us might be surprised by how high that number is. You know, we can often think that everyone's or that the bulk of people are just really entrenched and will go with their side no matter what. But 29% of people changed their vote during the campaign. Oh, 880, 1080 on that one as well. All right, we'll go to the phones right after this. Just about quarter past eight, it's Newstalk ZB. Newstalk ZB, Ben, to kick us off, how are you doing?
Speaker 3How are you doing, mate?
Speaker 4Look, we're looking at tonight's poll, and based on opportunities at 6%, and we have had polls in the past where Winston's been at 6%, but he hasn't quite made the 5% on the day. So I think that it's a... It's a yes and a no. You know, they might get there and they might not. But if opportunity don't get there, based on tonight's poll and the redistribution of the boat, Te Pahi Māori would lose two of its overhang seats. The Greens and Labour would pick up another
Speaker 4one each. National would pick up one and so would ACT and. New Zealand first, and then based on National at 30%, expected to win close to 40 electorate seats.
Speaker 2That would give.
Speaker 4Them an overhang of three to four. So you've got a right government. But if opportunity win, then National would have to get, you know, would have to win around about 28, 29% of the vote while winning 40 electorate seats with the overhang in order to win. So this could go either way at the moment. Hey, it's that down to the wire.
Speaker 2So one of the things I'm wondering tonight is whether people have election fatigue or whether it's the opposite, whether we often get told, oh, this election is a lot tighter than people think. You know, elections where there's actually been a massive thrashing, which we used to think was impossible in MMP, but elections where there's actually been a very comfortable winner, or at least the larger of the two parties has been large by a long way, you'll hear political commentators say, oh, no, no, I actually think
Speaker 2this is going to be close. And then it isn't. Now, this one, It's just so clear, unless election day gives us a big surprise, which are good. But it feels like it's so clear that it is going to be so close. It's conceivable that you will have the two biggest parties with give or take 30%.
Speaker 5Yeah, look, I'm over it.
Speaker 4I voted on the first possible day I could just because I was over it. But what I'm worried about is that this goes straight down to the wire that we don't actually have a result for three weeks until the final vote's done three weeks past the election before we actually have a clear winner. And that's what I'm worried about. And this drags on for another three weeks.
Speaker 2Yes, that would be a bummer. Once it's done, you do want it to be done as opposed to Just carrying on through summer. All right, Ben, thank you for the call. So whether or not you're feeling election fatigue or whether the fact that these polls are showing just how close it is is making you more engaged, what do you reckon? Let's go to Neil. Hi there, Neil.
Speaker 6Hi.
Speaker 7So Ben spoke for me.
Speaker 8There.
Speaker 7I've got election fatigue. I've been following this on ZB since day one. And it's unbelievable how, even when you feel really, really tired, You just don't let yourself let go of the story because the way it unfolds, it seems in such a rattle and harmony, if you like, way down to the wire. And I always seem to think in the back of my head, oh, and King makes a cherry-cherry game. Even if it's not opportunity, Ben Kingmaker, Winston,
Speaker 7that suddenly pulled the plug. We don't know. There's time for him still to do it.
Speaker 2I really, of all the things that Winston said of late, I do believe him that he wouldn't go with Labour this time around.
Speaker 9I'm not sure.
Speaker 7I'm not sure. And those Ben's got it right. It's sad that we're going to be had dishevelled at us one way or another. even after Election Day, and I just can't believe I'll keep my entry levels up. I get excited talking to you, for instance, just now, so they'll keep you going for an hour. There can probably be a discussion about the poll from a more intellectual point of view by someone like Grant or Sue. And then,
Speaker 7so I'm going to be up all night again, and this has been my life.
Speaker 2What I like, Neil, is that you've referred to regular callers... as if they're political commentators, which, for the purposes of this show, they are.
Speaker 10They are.
Speaker 2And, I mean, who's to say whether they're also in the queue to come on the show soon? We just don't know, slash we do know, but you don't know. I do, but do you?
Speaker 7I'm pretty sure Sylvie calling before the morning.
Speaker 2Could well be. We just don't know. All right, Neil, thank you so much. Enjoy your night. Sue, how are you doing?
Speaker 8Oh, all the better for your asking. Well, I haven't got fatigue, but I will comment on the polls. I've been doing polling myself around the Auckland area, but I wanted to... It.
Speaker 2Needs a name. The Sioux Poll?
Speaker 10The what?
Speaker 2The Sioux Poll. You know, if you're polling and then all the other polls have got names like the One News Varian Poll and the Reid Research Poll, we need the Sioux Poll.
Speaker 8I do it, yes, straw poll. But I know people all around the region, you see. But I wanted to clarify one issue that's been in the news, because it's important. In Tamaki, at a meeting, the childish nitpicker in the ACT Party, the candidate, he tried to bring to the forefront a few points Al Mahesh said, made, and this
Speaker 8is about the Labour small businesses and all that, the policy, saying it was interesting, and what happened, yeah, and isn't it, I'm just trying to think the words I haven't got in front of me, the article, I think he said, isn't it nice or something that you know, about, he thought it was quite positive, you see, put a positive
Speaker 8slant on it.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 8And I thought to myself, about time, you know, instead of tearing others to pieces, he was actually, you know, very positive, you see. And what made me laugh, say they support freedom of speech, and What an outdated pick. I can't even say the word, can I?
Speaker 2Look, you've been doing a lot of polling, Sue, and it's been tiring. I think I can sort of sum things up, and then let's hear whether I've summed up correctly for you, Sue. Which is, to bring people up to speed, and we touched on this briefly last night, but National's Tamaki candidate, who's Mahesh Muralidhar, so he got... We imagine a little bit of trouble with his own party because he praised some of Labour's small business policies, saying that they were good. And that's unusual behaviour at
Speaker 2the best of times, certainly in an election. However, here's the thing that I think we should calm down with this sort of thing, or rather political parties can calm down a little bit if someone admits that there's something that the other side is doing that they don't mind. that Hipkins said that when it comes to David Seymour's handling of, say, Pharmac in the last couple of years, that he doesn't have an issue with it. And I
Speaker 2like that there are some politicians who maybe in the previous case are naive enough, in Hipkins' case, who are treating people as intelligent enough, to know that, of course, he fundamentally disagrees with David Seymour on a truckload of issues. But if Seymour has handled the Pharmac situation well in the last couple of years, that he doesn't have to pretend that he thinks he's done a bad job just for the sake of the soundbite.
Speaker 8That's what I'm saying. And Mahesh pointed out the right. Do not have a heart. And I thought, blow it, it's about time someone come out and said it. And since Tuesday, I've had so many people in Tāmaki that are going to vote Mahesh. Heaps of them, Tim. And around Auckland, this is the funny part about it, and I think what it is, because people have told me this too, is the fact that there's been one really bad.
Speaker 8Negative campaign from one side and the other one is laid back and relaxed and smiling and getting on with everybody. A lot of them are going back to Labour. But in Tamaki, I'm saying, I am positive about this, two votes for blue in Tamaki because we've got to, in our area, we've got to get representation for the constituents because it's blinkin' important but I was quite surprised Labour
Speaker 8polled so much lower because In Tāmaki or in overall? No, all around Auckland. This is West Auckland, South Auckland.
Speaker 2And is this in the Sioux Poll or in other polls?
Speaker 8No, this is people I've been speaking to and I think And a lot of them have said they're just sick of the running down of negativity. And Neil was probably feeling a bit the same.
Speaker 2Do you know what I find really maybe surprising about what's happened today when you talk about negativity is that I thought that all the attention, the negative attention that National got for the kind of the childish campaign campaign personally directed Chloe Swarbrick on their social media, where in the space of six days they did 37 posts about her, which, you know, whether you like Chloe Swarbrick or not, it's quite embarrassing. It's quite weird behavior. And as we talked
Speaker 2about last night, Heather de Plessis-Allen wrote a whole column saying, oh, my gosh, if you actually go to the National Party Instagram page, it's just so strange, this obsession with Chloe Swarbrick over anything else. most of the posts are about Chloe. So I thought that it kind of backfired for National. In fact, I still think it has. But it hasn't stopped them with Chloe Swarbrick posts today. So just today alone, let's see how many mentioned Chloe. There's one, two, three, four.
Speaker 2Four more Instagram posts today about Chloe Swarbrick on the National page. It's just a bit strange.
Speaker 12All right.
Speaker 2Thank you, Sue. And good on you with your Sue poll. Oh, 880, 1080. And says Evenington. So my votes for opportunity weren't wasted or wasted. I don't know why I said wasted, but we'll carry on. Luxon is all talk if by some strange twist of fate, if he needs the opportunity party to get in, of course he will talk to them. This to me is really the most fascinating part of the campaign. aside from the policies, which we will have
Speaker 2differing opinions on what the best way forward for the country is. But it's the whole thing with Luxon ruling them out. So again, so it's election night. National could form the government if they go with opportunity. So does Luxon fall on a sword and say, you know all those times I said that there was no way? Well, I was just joking. Or does he make up a reason and say, well, no, things have changed now because they've ruled out doing that pesky tax that I didn't want to do. So is it that one? Or is it that he's informed by his colleagues, you're gone unless
Speaker 2you do this? Or is he informed by his colleagues, you are gone, irrespective, and we will negotiate with them and you need to resign now? It's... remembering that they can negotiate with them and opportunity don't necessarily say yes so so they could they could boot him and then opportunity might still say no oh 880 1080 now whether any of that is enough to make you feel more engaged or it's just all too much 0800 80 1080
Speaker 2we'll carry on with that in just a moment figure out why I said wasted instead of wasters because I've been doing citizenship ceremonies all day today and I really enjoy doing this it's a great honour it's the people who've got so many different stories so many different sacrifices they've made and they've chosen New Zealand as a country they want to live and these people do more for the economy than people born in New Zealand that's a statistical reality so Welcome the Stranger. And anyway, so I'm
Speaker 2doing citizenship ceremonies all day and I've got to read out all these names, a lot of South African names. And so a South African W is a V. So when you're doing that all day off not much sleep and then you see a W word, you go V. And next thing you know, you're saying wasted on nationwide radio. It's fantastic. Dallas, how are you doing tonight?
Speaker 13Good.
Speaker 14I hope I don't waste your time tonight.
Speaker 2I don't think you will waste my time. I mean, I had like a few Vickuses and Wagners. Yeah, anyway. So when you move to New Zealand, if you're Neil Wagner, you become Neil Wagner. If you become a famous cricketer. Anyway, moving on.
Speaker 14Yeah, first thing is, what does it say about our trust of Luxon that no one believes him when he says he won't pick up the phone to Opportunity? What does that say about his integrity?
Speaker 2Well, I think the other thing which has been so disappointing is just the avoiding of interviews. You know, I just think that there's some disconnect as far as his understanding of the requirements of the job. You know, it's not just that he avoids Jack Tame. He doesn't do interviews with Mickey Forbes, as Moana Maniapoto pointed out. So he doesn't do interviews with Jack, with Tovar O'Brien, with Julian Wilcox, Scotty Morrison, Mihi Forbes, or herself. He avoids
Speaker 2so much. And his whole thing is to say the plan is working, but he doesn't feel confident in himself to sit down for a tough interview to explain why and how the plan is working. It's not really good enough.
Speaker 9Yeah, it's weird, yeah.
Speaker 14Hey, the other thing is that from tonight's poll, and we must always remember with polls there's, there's at least 2% margin of error. So that means, say greens are 16, that could mean they're on 18 or it could mean 14. So you've always got to remember there's a margin of error of these polls. And a swing, a 4% swing, you know, a 2% swing either side can make a huge difference. And that could explain the difference between, like the Reid Research poll had Nats on 25% Well, that
Speaker 14could have been because they caught that swing a bad day for the Nats, and it actually is 27. You see what I mean?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 14So we've got to keep that in mind. But bearing that in mind.
Speaker 2… And just before you carry on with the bearing in mind, so this poll had a margin of error of plus or minus 3.1%. So that heightens that even more.
Speaker 9Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 8Exactly.
Speaker 14But bearing that in mind, it would seem to indicate that the split vote strategy is not working because we had ACT and New Zealand First back again on around 10%.
Speaker 2Yes, back as in down. You're right. And do you know what? I'm not surprised. I see Don Brash's full-page ads and I think, man, it would be good if you had something worthwhile to spend your money on, like helping people less fortunate. Here's your wordy, wordy ad with your stupid AI picture, and you could be helping people. And in his befuddled way, he will be thinking, I am helping people. This is what's right for the country. No one can be bothered reading your full-page ad, Don.
Speaker 2They just can't be bothered. People have got busy lives. What do you think you're doing? It's just messy.
Speaker 14And Kiwis hate to be told what to do with anything, let alone vote. This is the only time in three years, the only time we have a say, and the rest of the time it's the politicians. They have a say and they argue amongst themselves. But this is a golden time of two weeks where we can actually have a say and be more powerful in a way than the politicians. The other really striking thing, as you said, was, opportunities looks like now are going to be over five percent
Speaker 14um it looks like it anyway and that that is huge because then does that make them the kingmaker after all and uh you know and then i my opinion is i'm more likely to favor the left just judging by kule wong's reaction to winston peters for instance and his reaction to her and uh you're like, I can't really see them going into coalition with the right, can you?
Speaker 2I know that Q. Le Wong really wants to keep that option open, but that option is ruled out by Luxon. And like I said before, maybe that was accidentally ingenious if Opportunity were going to poll the maximum they could without getting in, like 4.9%.
Speaker 15But.
Speaker 2That doesn't look like it's going to happen. So that creates the scenario that I was talking about where, you know, he's potentially going to get knifed shortly after the election in order to allow negotiating to happen, negotiating that may or may not sway things in nationals' favour. That to me, I keep coming back to that as, you know, well, Most of us of a certain age have watched a lot of elections over the years, but I can't quite recall a scenario where the leader could potentially get kicked
Speaker 2out by his colleagues for refusing to negotiate with a party who could keep them in power and keep him prime minister. It's bizarre. Thank you, Dallas. So 880, 1080, 23 to nine. 21 to nine. Hi there, Grant.
Speaker 10Tim, in round figures, there's a 3% margin of error for calculating the poll. What I want to know is, what is the margin of error for calculating the margin of error? Because this is a 2% margin of error in calculating the 3% margin of error. It may only be a 1% margin of error.
Speaker 2Oh, well, that's hurting my head. But look, I'm going to Google it. What's the margin of error for calculating? I mean, presumably the margin of error for calculating the margin of error is the same as the margin of error.
Speaker 10Or is it?
Speaker 2What do you think? What's the answer to this going to be?
Speaker 10Well, I have no clue. It's just a sort of left-field thing I thought I'd throw in at the start of the conversation.
Speaker 2Yes, well, I do have an answer for you, and it's as I suspected. So the margin of error itself does not have a margin of error because the definition of a margin of error is that it is the margin of error. So whatever the margin of error is, is the margin of error itself doesn't have a margin of error because that's kind of covered by the name being the margin of error but the official explanation is that the margin of error doesn't have a margin of error in the same way that a survey result does because it's a mathematical calculation rather than a random sample
Speaker 2uh something something something something something anyway there we go so that's that then okay we'll put that to one side i think so.
Speaker 10Now, the one thing I'm sure about is the electorate vote. I voted Labour in the electorate vote in 2020 and Labour Party vote in 2020. 23 Labour electorate vote again but National Party vote and this election is going to be a Labour electorate vote but I still have not decided between two parties on the right who's going to
Speaker 10get my party vote and opportunities sort of faded away a bit because Well, yeah, I mean, I don't really know what they stand for, and this week you go with anyone, sort of, so even though, you know, you've got... We could go with National, as long as Winston's not Foreign Minister. Or rather, we could go with the right-wing coalition,
Speaker 10and I presume Winston would want to be Foreign Minister again if he... Yes, I thought some years ago when New.
Speaker 2Zealand First weren't... in, when they were well below 5%, that he would just sail off into the sunset and that those of us who had been highly critical of him over the years still had enough instances of witnessing his charm to wish him well think of him fondly as well as being critical of the various episodes of race baiting and climate change denialism and anti-science stuff that
Speaker 2cropped up during the pandemic. But no, I just don't think he'll ever go away. He will always be with us. When it comes to opportunity, so they have a financial backer who is their wealthiest donor. Now, I was listening to Heather today. Now, apparently... Alan Wilderland made some comments suggesting that he would prefer that the party go with Labour. I need to clarify the exact quotes so that I'm not misquoting him, so I will do that shortly. But
Speaker 2that's what Heather was saying. Yeah. Now, you contrast that with Gareth Morgan, who founded the Opportunity Party, saying, oh, you don't want to get too cosy with Labour, you've got to get the tradies, and the tradies don't vote Labour, and I'm concerned that Opportunity is not getting the tradies. So he's essentially said the opposite. And I think that, to me, sums up one of the issues for Opportunity, is that you can have the biggest financial backer and the guy who created the party who have different ideas of what this party is. Now, that is not an
Speaker 2insurmountable problem when you're not in government, but it does get pretty messy if you do cross the threshold.
Speaker 10Yeah, I mean, probably my ideal thing with opportunity would be that they scrape in just above the 5% or 5%, whatever, we'll call it 5%, but are not part of government. so that their MPs, whoever, I don't know, 5% would be probably about 7 MPs, actually have three years of parliamentary experience, including the leader, and then we can reassess
Speaker 10at the next election whether we want to vote for them.
Speaker 2Well, perhaps.
Speaker 16Perhaps.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think what it's come down to now is that on these numbers, I think that they're likely to get in. And so whether they can kind of keep that together, it's very, very difficult for minor parties, particularly when they haven't been in power very often, to try to keep it together, particularly when you've got people further down that list who suddenly will have the spotlight shone on them in ways that hasn't happened before. Thank you, Grant. Better take a break. Quarter to nine, it's Newstalk ZB. 12 to 9. So very quickly, Gareth Morgan created the
Speaker 2Opportunity Party. He recently said that the party risks, quote, slipping to the left and becoming irrelevant if it fails to win over centre-right tradies. So that's the creator of the party. And I don't know whether that's quite in cahoots with the largest financial backer of the party, Alan Wilderland, who has said that working with the left, such as Labour Party, could potentially be easier than working with the right. He did emphasize that a centrist, evidence-based approach opened to
Speaker 2negotiating with either side to play a kingmaker role was really where he was at. So in fairness to him, that's the full thing. But it sounds like a preference from the financial backer to go to the left. And it sounds like a preference from the creator, not the creator of the universe, but the creator of the party, at least, to appeal more to right-wing tradies. I don't think they're on the same page. Oh, 880, 1080. Bruce, how are you doing?
Speaker 5Hello, Mike.
Speaker 3How are you?
Speaker 2I'm good. What's going on for you?
Speaker 6I would probably qualify as a tradie. I think I'm a mechanical engineer, but I'm retired now.
Speaker 3I'm very old.
Speaker 2You sound youthful, Bruce.
Speaker 6Thank you very much. I've heard people tell me I look younger than I am. I'm 77, so I've been around a while.
Speaker 2Okay. Before we get into the polls, how young can you get away with, do you think?
Speaker 17Sorry, say that again?
Speaker 2How young do you think you can get away with in terms of how you look? Do people think, I reckon Bruce is about 65?
Speaker 6No, the guy I used to know, we were having a talk about it, and he said, well, how old are you? And I said, how old do you think? And he said, oh, about 58.
Speaker 2Really?
Speaker 18Yeah, really, yeah.
Speaker 2You're passing for 20 years younger.
Speaker 5Yeah, that was a bit of a laugh.
Speaker 2Bruce.
Speaker 9That was a year or two ago.
Speaker 2That's a self-esteem boost. That's awesome. Carry on.
Speaker 19Yeah, I do get that.
Speaker 6However, why I rang is because there's three issues currently that really, really concern me, which.
Speaker 14I'd like to talk about.
Speaker 20The first one is conservation lands. I've heard that the right wing is planning, or I think it's ACT, was planning on selling off our conservation land.
Speaker 2Well, it was certainly something that was botched by the coalition government. And Tama Portaka, I think, showed that he didn't have a full grasp on his portfolio and was really surprised at the backlash against him.
Speaker 6That would be a terrible, terrible thing to do to New Zealanders to sell off conservation land. You can't do that. You really can't. It's just not on.
Speaker 2And look, the defence was that this would be unremarkable bits of conservation land including like gravel car parks. The problem was that the actual wording in the document did not make that clear. So if you're trying to you know, allay people's fears that actually, you know, our precious remaining native forests are up for grabs and don't have the same protections that they used to. And then you say, just don't worry about it. That's not what we're talking about. But then you actually look at the wording of the document and you're like, well, the document doesn't allay my concerns,
Speaker 2so maybe you need to change the document. So ultimately that's why that one got parked.
Speaker 6One of the other two things is. Deep sea trawling, seabed trawling, that's incredibly destructive to the seabed, which is important to keeping New Zealand green, I think.
Speaker 9You've got to protect the seabed.
Speaker 6You can't destroy it.
Speaker 2I think it is highly embarrassing. Highly embarrassing as well as being, you know, one of those things, I don't want to overuse saying things like morally bankrupt, but that There's a vision. Maybe we have different visions, not you and I, but maybe everyone in New Zealand has slightly different visions of what it means to be a New Zealander. But one of the ideas that I thought that most of us agreed on was this idea that we really prioritize the environment. And to think that we could have people in positions of power who prioritize short-term financial gain
Speaker 2in terms of deep sea bottom trawling versus massive long-term environmental degradations. feels un-New Zealand to me.
Speaker 9Exactly.
Speaker 6That's how I feel about it as well. This is not what New Zealand is about. You can't go around destroying stuff like that. And the third thing is offshore oil wells, oil drilling. I've heard that being talked about as well, and that would be another one that would be terribly destructive.
Speaker 2Well, I think what it is with that one is that it's an easy thing to say that, well, because we stopped this, it's been damaging to the economy, and that overlooks the fact that there's not a lot of new oil reserves being discovered in New Zealand anyway. Thank you, Bruce. Got to run to another break. Seven minutes to nine, Newstalk ZB. Five to nine. Cathy, hi there.
Speaker 13Yeah, hi, Tim. I just came inside when you were talking about how many people you had made citizens. And I just wanted to say that was such a lovely way you said it.
Speaker 2Well, that's very nice. Look, I didn't personally make them citizens, but I read their names out.
Speaker 13No, but it was the way you said how hardworking they are. Because I come across a lot of people every day and I'm blown away when they teach me how to pronounce their names. But I especially like what you said about how much they contribute to our country.
Speaker 2I think it's really important, you know, when we have some politicians who try to stir up anti-migrant feelings, you know, and that to me is really the lowest of the low. And I can't stand it when people who claim to be Christians would do the opposite of welcoming the stranger, which is more of a commandment than the Ten Commandments. Not to get all religious on you there, Kathy, but performative Christianity just rocks me up. Because if you're someone
Speaker 2who likes to tell people loudly that you're a and you're not particularly interested in welcoming the stranger. That's something that was absolutely directly explicitly pointed out by the guy who the whole religion's meant to be about. Anyway, that brief deviation, welcome the stranger, whether you're spiritual or not. And guess what? People who decide to move to New Zealand contribute more financially to the economy than people born
Speaker 2in New Zealand, statistically, on average. So if you're ever thinking, oh, this person stole my job. No, this person who decided to move here and leave behind family and friends and sacrifice everything for a better life for their kids, they are creating work for your family and friends, as well as potentially sometimes doing the jobs that New Zealand-born people don't want to do. But statistically, on average, people who move to New Zealand contribute more to the economy. And I think that's good to remind those of us who have those kind of xenophobic flames fanned from time to time.
Speaker 2Thank you, Cathy. We've got the 9 o'clock news coming up next. If you'd like to be on, it's 0800 80 1080. It's Newstalks AB. Tim Rocks, Bryn for Marcus. Once again, this week, he's back next week. And the song that was number one this day in the States back in 1990. Do you know what's hilarious when you look back on this? Is that Vanilla Ice. No one would suggest he might want to join Mensa. But he actually denied that it was really a ripoff of Queen's Under Pressure. This bass line is a direct lift from
Speaker 2Under Pressure. But he would say with a straight face in interviews, no, no, no, no, I added one little extra bass note. So it's not a ripoff. It is. And he had to pay millions. And eventually it was responsible for Under Pressure finding a new audience because Under Pressure was never a big hit in the States. Now, it doesn't matter where you are in the world, that is one of the most popular Queen songs. Anyway, Vanilla Ice, number one with Ice Ice Baby, this day back in 1990. Alison, how's your Tuesday been? Welcome along.
Speaker 8Good, thanks.
Speaker 11I just got to say, I can't understand the obsession with the National Party with Chloe. And if Nicola Woodard says one more time... We don't want her as the finance minister. She won't be because, of course, he's going to have Barbara Edmonds, so she's not ever going to be the finance minister.
Speaker 18Chloe is.
Speaker 11She can't be.
Speaker 2Yes, so one... I was talking about this with Olivia, who produces the show, and saying maybe for Chloe Swarbrick, saying that she potentially could be interested in finance is one, because it's true. Secondly, it could be because she's... very intelligent, knows that the National Party wouldn't be able to resist all the attacks that they would then make after she said this, which would then ultimately backfire on National because it would make them look silly. Or thirdly, it's more of a negotiating tactic in the same way that when
Speaker 2you're doing a pay negotiation, you ask them the biggest amount that you'd like, and you settle for something a little bit less. So You know, might be some truth in that.
Speaker 11They do it the same with Greta Thunberg. For some reason, people just don't, they like to attack these sort of people. I just want to say, Winston Peterson didn't do himself any favours when he wouldn't pat the dog on the news, would he? He said, no, I don't pat dogs. I knew he didn't like greyhounds, but I didn't realise it was all dogs.
Speaker 2Oh, I didn't see that. So he wouldn't pat the doggy?
Speaker 11No, we refused to do that. And one item on the news I must mention, I must mention one item on the news that got lost in the news is the people in the red zone in Christchurch now being turfed out of there. And I think that's wrong to turf these people out just before, they've got to get out there before February. If I had a bigger, I've got a property in Christchurch, if I had a bigger area in my property, I would happily take, but I can't, I haven't got enough room for 30, there's 30 people there. But I think it's terrible that they're, pushing those people out of the red zone in Christchurch.
Speaker 2Yes, and that's more serious than the dog situation. But, yeah, you know, there are some things that I do, some things, and then, to be honest, these days, more minor things, that I agree with Winston Peterson on, because the serious stuff, the anti-immigration stuff, the shameful and the anti-science stuff, and the environmental stuff, I just can't stand, and the importing of American. Kind of um political strategies and who's the biggest patriot and all that i just don't like but i do
Speaker 2agree with him when he hit out at politicians flipping burgers you know like no one needs to see the prime minister cosplay as a minimum wage worker a fast food restaurant what.
Speaker 11Is that supposed to tell us that was dumb yeah dumb.
Speaker 2But what about the dog patting allison.
Speaker 11Well, I don't know. I thought he owned a dog himself. That's the thing. I thought he had a dog.
Speaker 2I think he does have a dog. Can someone quickly text?
Speaker 11Didn't somebody throw something and break a window once and the dog was inside and it was on the news that his dog could have been injured or something and the grass could have hit the dog or something? Wasn't that a story at one stage? Now I'm making this up. Now I'm just making the story up.
Speaker 2You're spitballing. No, no. So Winston, he was complaining. It's the same thing as the photo opportunity of a politician pretending that they work at McDonald's. that he'd complained about both Hipkins and Luxon patting dogs. So I think if he'd complained about them doing the photo ops, and I'm sympathetic to that complaint because it is, well.
Speaker 11Just a little controversy with the greyhound. You see why I bring more dogs into it there. We sort of just got over the greyhound, stopping that. Now we've got the story now, haven't we, coming up now on top of that.
Speaker 21Yeah.
Speaker 22Okay.
Speaker 2All right, Alison. Good stuff.
Speaker 12Thank you.
Speaker 2Nice to have you on, 0800 8010 80. Raewyn, hi there.
Speaker 11Hi.
Speaker 21Tim, you know what really brassed me off? The whole world is actually screwed because this hate of different people, of different nationalities, it just splits the planet apart. And I happen to be standing with a group of people talking about this in the main street And this lady was doing her nut about immigrants. And she said, they don't belong here. She said, they all should be shot
Speaker 21and carry on like this. So I got really wild. I don't normally turn into a vicious vampire. And I turned around and I said to her, excuse me. I said, if I took one person from every country in the world and stood them in a line... and got a knife and cut their arm. I said, what colour would they bleed? And she looked at me and the whole crowd went silent. And I said, they'd all bleed red blood.
Speaker 21I said, it doesn't matter what nationality we are or where we came from, we are all related way back from the time of man and woman's beginning.
Speaker 7Exactly.
Speaker 21And that's... what they don't understand. I don't know why I do, but why can't they? What's the matter with people? They're just so vindictive and bitter and twisted. You know, I think they go outside and practice knife throwing to stab people in the back all the time. It drives me insane.
Speaker 2It's motivated by fear. And it's one of the oldest tricks in the political playbook of populist parties to know that you can get a certain percentage of the population interested in you if you stoke their fears. And fears about other people, people who look different to us or worship differently to us or arrived more recently than we did. And you see it used around the world. And it's always wrong. And it's always shameful. And I wish the
Speaker 2people who fell for it were aware that they're being played, as well as the fact that it's wrong and it's needlessly cruel. And even if your argument is economic, that you're wrong on that one too. Because as I said, you can look at study after study that shows that people who move to this country, who were not born here, contribute enormously to the economy and affect statistically more than people who were born here.
Speaker 21Well, this is it. I mean, the thing is, I've always treated everybody as equal. I don't care if they're blue or purple spots and pink noses. As long as they're polite and respectful to me, they get the same back. And I've never had any trouble making friends with people that have come into the country and that. And I just don't understand the people. And I'll tell you this.
Speaker 21I really shouldn't because I'm going to get into trouble over this.
Speaker 2Oh dear, yeah.
Speaker 8Woo!
Speaker 21Well, I have a sort of, God, they're going to say I'm nuts, but I'm sick of this. I have a sort of premonition now and then in dreams.
Speaker 2Oh yeah.
Speaker 21And unfortunately they come true and.
Speaker 23I've got witnesses to this.
Speaker 21There's a day of reckoning coming. I hope I'm not here to see it because what I was shown terrifies the hell out of me. And it's not so much that. It's the kids that are coming through now that are going to have to live in this mess that all the politicians and greedy people have made.
Speaker 2Well, I hope that you have a more positive premonition of to balance out that one that gives people some hope. But certainly I would like in my lifetime for the richest person in the world to not be the most selfish. And I would like in my lifetime for the richest person in the world to not think that empathy is a weakness. And not just that richest person, but I would hope that their buddies, who are merely worth hundreds
Speaker 2of billions rather than a trillion, would also understand that empathy is indeed a strength. And a lack of empathy is associated with being a sociopath. So that's one of my hopes for the planet. Because then, if you do have the wealthiest among us being empathetic, they are motivated to go, Actually, how could I uplift people? You know what I might do? I might try and end poverty. Now, just on that briefly, because it's sprung into my mind,
Speaker 2I was talking last week about how children are obsessed with watching YouTube to the point that they're kind of turning away from Netflix and they just want to watch YouTube. So we had a good conversation about what are some positive shows that kids can watch on YouTube that are not just kind of mindless. Now, there's a guy, and the jury is out for me. I'm actually going to throw this out there as a topic, seeing as it's come up organically. There's a YouTuber who is worth apparently
Speaker 2about $ 5 billion, or that his parent company is worth $ 5 billion. Now, is that New Zealand or US? Let's have a double check. Let's do it in NZ dollars. Okay, so MrBeast, oh, it's US dollars. Okay, so he's worth 2.6 billion US, which is about 4.6 billion New Zealand dollars. And he is a YouTuber. He makes videos that kids like. Now,
Speaker 2a lot of these I find pretty mindless. A lot of them are kind of game show, challenge-y type things. But kids under the age of 10 just lap this stuff up. And it's always like an arbitrary challenge and you've got to beat the clock and will you do it and there's money up for grabs. And he's a pretty young guy. He looks younger than me. I wonder how old he is. I'd say he's probably in his 30s. Oh, he was born in 1998. So he's 28 years old and he's worth 2.6 billion US dollars because he makes
Speaker 2videos that people all over the world or kids all over the world like. Now, there's a point I'm getting to with this. is that amidst all the stuff that I was like, oh, this is more kind of mindless, YouTube, arbitrary, race against the clock kind of game show stuff, that there he was in South America, and I'm not sure which country it was, but he was paying for houses for people who had lost everything in these floods. And I thought, okay, well, if my daughter is becoming very
Speaker 2interested in this Mr. Beast guy, then at least she's learning about compassion and helping people less fortunate and what it's like for children who grow up in a situation where you lose everything and how you come back from there. Um, then there was a video where Mr. Beast had like this challenge where he wanted to buy a prosthetic limbs for like a thousand people or even 2000 people. And, and so he was, he was, there was like this counter each time he paid for a new limb, but I got an uneasy feeling watching it. And so I,
Speaker 2I'm just going to throw it out there if you do know anything about this Mr. Beast guy. And if you don't, that's fine. Then hopefully the yarn is at least kind of food for thought. Because it's not like conventional TV where you've got producers who might be steering you in a direction. This guy's made his fortune by kind of doing what he wants. But that lack of oversight really does show through. So in this one where he's kind of playing God by paying for these prosthetic limbs... which in the States, this was in the States, this one,
Speaker 2those cost a fortune. And so a lot of people who hadn't walked for months, sometimes even years. For the ones he felt the most sorry for, he gave them briefcases full of thousands of dollars of cash. And he would look at the camera when he'd do this in a way that made me just kind of go, this is all about you. And I didn't love it. And on the one hand, It's nice that some of his videos aren't just these race against time, fast cut kind
Speaker 2of meaningless challenges and that he's showing compassion. But I feel like he's showing compassion in a way which is entirely self-serving. You know, it's where he has the power. He's the billionaire. I'll make you walk again. And if I feel extra sorry for you, I'll give you $ 10, 000 cash too. And when I do it, I'll look at the camera so you know that this is actually all about me. and not about those people. I just kind of got what in modern lingo is referred to as the ick. So if you know anything about this Mr.
Speaker 2Beast guy and whether you've got any thoughts on that, I welcome you to chime in on that one too. We will take a quick break. It is Newstalk ZB at 9.21.
Speaker 119.23.
Speaker 2Kristen, hi. Good evening, Tim. Good evening, Kristen.
Speaker 18Oh, good evening.
Speaker 24My goodness gracious me. I love your show.
Speaker 2Oh, that's very kind of you. Yes.
Speaker 24No, it's not very kind of me. It's honest of me. And I am first generation Polish New Zealander.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 24And my family came here. Well, my dad and my mum were accepted into New Zealand in 1950. Long time ago now. And we worked really hard and very proud of being in New Zealand. And now I've got my
Speaker 24three children.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 24And another little wee baby, second child. coming into this world, and we all were.
Speaker 2So this is your grandchild?
Speaker 15Yes.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 24Two little, well, my wee first grandchild, she is coming five, and then this wee bubba on her way.
Speaker 2And so you're already a, well, how old were you when you became a grandparent, if you don't mind me asking?
Speaker 24Oh, my goodness me. 70.
Speaker 2Oh, right. Okay, yeah. See, because my wife and I were slightly late starters when it came to beginning a family. And we think of some people we know who were grandparents when they were in their early 40s. And we're in our mid-40s. We're not going to be grandparents any time soon.
Speaker 24Well, my daughter couldn't have children because of cancer, and then my son, my musical son, who didn't, and my autumn leaf, and his beautiful partner. Yep, here we are with beautiful, well, beautiful willow, and next we've got a seabury.
Speaker 24coming this February.
Speaker 2Oh, right. I thought you were saying the child's name was February, which it could be, but not necessarily.
Speaker 24No, wee baby is going to be named I don't know what, but we are so excited. And so New Zealand is a good country. It is a good country. People are kind and good.
Speaker 2Yes, most people. Certainly not those who turn up at Diwali celebrations to protest. I wouldn't say those are good people. They might be people who could be good, but they've been misled.
Speaker 24Yeah, we embrace all cultures. Do we not or should we not?
Speaker 2Well, we should because there's the earlier call. It was Ray Wynn saying that if you're cut, you're going to bleed. And we all bleed the same. And funnily enough, even though there are differences, that it's more interesting. And, you know, we're all the product of our childhood. I said this to someone who sent me a very, very long email once saying, you know, I can't stand how you support multiculturalism. And I was just going to ignore it. And then
Speaker 2for some odd reason, I thought, I'm going to respond to this person. And life is short and I've got to look after my kids and pay the mortgage and be a good husband. So I don't normally go, you know what, I'm going to take the time to write a long response to this long email from someone who's very racist. But I was just like, okay, so you're wondering where I come from. Well, where I grew up was a place where you saw a church next to a temple next to a mosque. And by the way, the types of churches were quite many and varied. And
Speaker 2by the way, the types of temples were many and varied. And by the way, those mosques, well, the architecture I loved. Um, and I wasn't scared of the sort of praying that was going on on the inside because that, that was just what I grew up with. And, uh, and so, you know, when you see that, and then that, that for me was living in KL for all those years as a kid, that's just what you're used to. Uh, and, and maybe if you grew up and your parents told you, gosh, this economy is so hard, you know, you know, who's
Speaker 2to blame. And then that stuff kind of gets passed on. And then if you hear politicians on TV telling people to go back to where they came from, then, and if life is really tough for you and you want someone to blame, then maybe that kind of takes hold, but it's never right.
Speaker 23All right.
Speaker 2Thank you very much for being on the program. We've got a lot of text messages, so we'll get to some of those after the headlines. Stuart Willie is with us first. If you would like to be on the program, 0800 80 1080. Look, I've just thrown it out there as maybe a little thing, but I I've got other stuff, so don't worry. But this YouTuber, MrBeast, he's huge. He's worth billions. If your kids or grandkids have watched him and you've got any thoughts on whether he's good or whether he's not good, because I honestly had a very
Speaker 2bad feeling watching this guy seemingly do good, but make it all about himself when he was building houses for people who'd lost everything and when he was paying for prosthetic limbs. It was very messianic and very focused on him with these weird, almost David Brent-like glances to the camera. You see what I just did? I just gave another guy the chance to walk. See what I just did? That guy who needed a limb, well, he was also short of cash, and I just gave him a whole
Speaker 2briefcase full of it. Aren't I amazing? And the kids lap this stuff up on YouTube. Anyway, here's something else I'm going to throw out there, and then we will get to all the text about earlier topics, including the latest political poll. Now, the Melbourne Cup. Melbourne Cup happened today, and I'm wondering whether your perception is whether this is holding in terms of its popularity or whether it's declining. So have a think. You won't have to think very hard because it was today. Whether your office was into it,
Speaker 2whether the sweepstake was happening, whether this whole line that we've heard our whole lives, the race that stops two nations, whether that's really still true. You know, I don't say it in a gleeful way. You know, we were talking about the banning of greyhounds last night because someone brought it up, and then that kind of morphed into someone saying, well, you know, horse racing is not so flash. Anyway, I'm not energized to ban horse racing, so I don't get the wrong end of that argument as much as I hope the horses are okay. And I've been to the
Speaker 2Melbourne Cup once, and that was fun. because I was with a bunch of friends, but our collective knowledge of those horses was through the floor. But it was a fun day out. But I've looked at some stats, and it would suggest that the love affair with the Melbourne Cup is actually declining fairly rapidly. So I'm interested to know what was going on in your office and compare what it was like in the past. I mean, the office sweepstake, that's always fun. I mean, no one knows
Speaker 2who the horses are, really. except for people who are highly engaged. But the bulk of people don't really know. But it's kind of a good team bonding thing. So I've got no issues with the office sweepstake. But given I work nights, I wasn't involved. So I was invited, by the way, but I wasn't involved. So I don't know. The office sweepstake, how big a deal that was, and whether or not you kind of sense that there is a declining interest in the Melbourne Cup, 0800 80 1080. You can text 9292. We are back right after this,
Speaker 227 to 10. 25 minutes to 10.
Speaker 24Ron, hi.
Speaker 22Hello, how are you?
Speaker 2I'm good. What about you?
Speaker 22I'm good, thanks. Just a quick small story about the Melbourne Cup. And it's not really about the race itself. It's about the cup, the gold cup.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 22Okay, so back in 2015, I was a security officer in the Victorian Racing Club. brought the cup over to New Zealand and put it on tour. So they took it around different places to show people the Melbourne Cup and the New Zealand Breeding Breeders Association had a big meal with it.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 22But the interesting thing was we went up to the top of Mount Victoria and wanted to have a photograph. And then the people from... the Victoria Racing Club left me with the cup for about an hour. They said, oh, you can look after it. And I traveled around looking after the cup. And when we met up at this cafe, they were asking some places that we could take the cup because we had some spare time between our next venue.
Speaker 22And I said to them, well, why don't we take it into our ATAB and just pick a random one, walk in there and go, hey, we've got the cup in this bag, would you like some photographs? And without a word of a line, they said to me, Ron, we cannot take the Melbourne Cup into a heathen gambling den.
Speaker 2Probably not wise.
Speaker 22Well, I thought it was a great idea, but no, you're not allowed to take the Melbourne Cup into a TAV.
Speaker 2Well, how exciting was this escapade for you, Ron?
Speaker 22Well, it was quite cool because it was a solid gold cup. I was worth over 200 Australian dollars. That's 200,000.
Speaker 2That makes more sense.
Speaker 7Yeah, sorry.
Speaker 22And they give away one every year. So every year it's a brand new cup.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 22And one of the most famous cups was one of the owners got a little bit drunk one night and went down and put some champagne into the modern cup and gave it to the horse. And the horse took a big bite on the cup and left his teeth marks on it. In the world of modern cups, that's the most famous one to get now.
Speaker 2And did the horse have some of the champagne?
Speaker 16Yes, of course.
Speaker 2So do horses get tipsy?
Speaker 22I don't know. I don't know.
Speaker 2I mean, they're a large animal, so I would imagine it would take a bit, but also they don't generally drink alcohol, so then their tolerance would be less. Here's something I've never Googled. Do horses get tipsy? Let's have a look. No, horses do not get tipsy or drunk easily, if at all, from normal amounts of alcohol. Apparently, they have a supercharged liver, and they have... So actually, I mean,
Speaker 2I don't want to encourage anyone to overindulge, but apparently the horse's liver is such that they could actually have a few shandies quite regularly and they'd be fine because they produce large amounts of the enzyme called alcohol dehydrogenase, which is very good at processing alcohol.
Speaker 22Well, it wasn't the horse that was drunk, of course. It was the owner. He's the one that got pussed and went down to the barn and gave some to the horse.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 2And some owners do give horses dark beer like Guinness because apparently the horses like the taste of the barley and the hops. And given that the horse is so big, they're not really getting tipsy at all.
Speaker 22Well, I heard that the mighty Raj in India had war elephants and they used to feed them up on cider before they went out into the battlefields.
Speaker 2Well, I guess it's a bit like soldiers in the World Wars being on amphetamines.
Speaker 22Well, that's a whole different story, isn't.
Speaker 11It?
Speaker 22It is.
Speaker 2From drunk elephants. Well, it would take a... You think about Andre the Giant. Now, Andre, have you heard the stories about how much Andre the Giant would imbibe?
Speaker 22I'm sorry, if he was?
Speaker 2You know how much Andre the Giant would drink? Do you know Andre the Giant?
Speaker 22Oh, yes, yeah, sure, yeah.
Speaker 2Okay, so Andre the Giant. I've got to look it up because it's scarcely believable just how much he could drink. And, you know, as the name suggests, he was a giant. But here we go. So, yeah, he once drank 117 beers in a single setting.
Speaker 20Oh, no.
Speaker 2Yeah. There was another time. Well, where it was alleged that he'd had 119 beers in a six-hour period at a Pennsylvania pub. That's a lot of urinating as well. Goodness me.
Speaker 22And he would, before wrestling, I mean, I know him from The Prince.
Speaker 10Bride.
Speaker 2That's where I know Andre the Giant. But apparently before his wrestling bouts, he would have six bottles of wine and he wouldn't appear intoxicated because he was a giant and was very used to this extremely hard-living lifestyle. Yeah, so when he was filming The Princess Bride in London, he racked up a $ 40, 000 hotel bar tab, and that was mostly on himself. It wasn't through overwhelming generosity for anybody else. But anyway, that's a tangent, isn't it? Yes,
Speaker 2Andre the Giant. I haven't watched The Princess Bride for a little while, and that is just one of the best movies in history. It's just such a beautiful film. It's ridiculous and action-packed and sweet and funny. and fantastical and it will never fail to to make me laugh um i love the princess bride i would put that in my top 10 favorite movies ever and yes andre the giant was in that now he weighed 520 pounds when he was doing this sort of tomfoolery what's 520
Speaker 2pounds in in kgs it's just one of those shows where i'm googling on air again quite uh audibly 235 kilos all right uh Now, the Melbourne Cup. The Melbourne Cup. What's your perception of whether it's declining in popularity? Tell me what was going on in your office today and your own kind of personal levels of interest with it. Because here's what we know from across the ditch. The Guardian has run an article saying that a record number
Speaker 2of Australians are turning their backs on the Melbourne Cup. More than two-thirds surveyed saying they have low or zero interest in it. So just 9% of Australians said they had high interest in the race. Now, in the space of one year, the level of interest has halved. So that would suggest it's not a slow decline for the Melbourne Cup, that it's actually fairly speedy. So 2025, okay,
Speaker 2so once again, so this all makes sense. I don't want you to drown in figures. So the latest research this year In Australia, 9% said they had a high level of interest in the Melbourne Cup. It was 16% last year. So the drop from 16 to 9 in the space of a year. Now, you might argue, and maybe you will on 08801080, that lots of things are struggling to get the level of attention that they used to. We've just got so many options for entertainment. Back in
Speaker 2the day where there are two TV channels... and from a New Zealand point of view, it's rugby, racing, and beer. You know, it's very, very different from now where lots of people will have seven different streaming providers at home. So, of course, it's declining, but I think we understand there's a little more at play, too. 0800 80 1080, it's quarter to 10, Newstalk ZB. 14 to 10. Trevor, hi.
Speaker 10Yes, hello.
Speaker 3Good, I didn't think you'd ever get to me.
Speaker 2Oh, goodness.
Speaker 3Andre, Joanne. Now, getting back to the... The Melbourne Cup. Yeah, I reckon it's been, you know, declining for some years. And I'll tell you why I think. I've been following it for years. I'm 82 now. And I've actually won a few suites, which are really quite good. And they're exciting. They're in the pub. In fact, where I used to work once in Australia, we used to put so much money in a week.
Speaker 12So.
Speaker 3At the end by the time the cup come around there was quite a bit of money in the kitty and it was quite a big price for first second third and last and whatever But what's happened over the years it used to be like some New Zealand horses coming over to Australia and they used to know the horses all the Australian horses and there'd be Four or five or something horses from overseas, but now they get no you don't know the names of the horses you've got to look them up see where they come from what they've done and I was looking at it today before I had a better bet. I ended up backing the winner, but I had a few bets and.
Speaker 10Lost in the day.
Speaker 3But, you know, it was like, who the hell, where's this one from? You know, you don't know the jockeys, there's different jockeys. And it was actually sort of like, it was good to see the New Zealand horses over, especially when they won. There was one New Zealand Melbourne Cup to this. We had the first three from New Zealand, and they were New Zealand-owned bred and... Trained. And New Zealand jockeys used to go over. So it just lost a lot of interest, I reckon.
Speaker 2Well, we had a couple of horses, so we had Chocolates rather than Chocolates, which was.
Speaker 3It was named after a horse called Shocker or something.
Speaker 10Oh, okay.
Speaker 3One the Melbourne Gap used to go. And the other was this dam which was actually zilch or something. And they changed the letters around to make it Lips.
Speaker 2Ah, I see. So chocolates came sixth.
Speaker 3Yeah, it did, actually. A lot of sorts go into naming horses because they name it after part of the sire and part of the dam.
Speaker 2Ah, okay.
Speaker 3Yeah, a lot of it, yeah.
Speaker 16Yes.
Speaker 2I always think siring is, well, maybe it's a slightly juvenile mind that I have every now and then, but I was reading about, was it, Which horse had been sired by another horse who was well-known in the race? Was it Chocolates or was it Asterix?
Speaker 3I don't know.
Speaker 2But being sired, you know, because it's such a sexual term, isn't it? Because that's what it's all about, isn't it? Yeah.
Speaker 3And you can figure out where the horse is going to be. They say, oh, it's a good sire. You know the sires of some horses and they put out good horses or they... They saw our horses of heavy track things, you know, trying to work out who the winner is. You just do that bit of study.
Speaker 5You know?
Speaker 2Yeah. Because Mark Greatbatch, the cricketer, he had a horse. Well, he had Asterix. That was the other New Zealand bred one. Oh, he co-owns that one.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 2But did you hear this story, Trevor? So Asterix was scratched just hours before the race. He had to be withdrawn because a stable hand... had mistakenly applied an anti-inflammatory ointment to the legs and that wasn't allowed. Can you imagine being that stable hand? Like your one job is getting the horse ready for the Melbourne Cup and you put on the wrong ointment.
Speaker 3I knew it was some veterinary thing that made him be scratched, but I didn't know what it was. That's news to me. I didn't have that in my selections anyway.
Speaker 2Do you feel sorry for that factory hand?
Speaker 10Yeah, sure do.
Speaker 3The horse that went, you know, the one that went out, I hate it when that happens, when a horse goes out to about 20 lengths, and you wonder whether it's going to bloody hold on again. He actually held on for fifth.
Speaker 2Right, okay.
Speaker 3And, of course, there's a lot of state money goes to the owners, and they would have been quite happy, because the money they would have got back for fifth would have been quite big.
Speaker 2Yes. Look, I appreciate your knowledge on it, Trevor, and seeing as you felt like you'd had to wait quite a while, is there one last point you want to make about the Melbourne Cup?
Speaker 3Oh, it's a great race. I've been following it for years. Well, I've been following the races for years here. I live in Christchurch, and it's just a bit of excitement. We've worked in a lot of different places. We always had a sweepstake going on there, and then the The race, they'd stop working and put the race on or on TV. We had little radios in those days, and then there was TV. But you knew all the horses.
Speaker 7Yes.
Speaker 3Even the Australian ones and the New Zealand ones, of course.
Speaker 10And then these things would come out.
Speaker 3You know, we've had horses come over from Japan and all sorts coming out.
Speaker 22I thought, what is this thing?
Speaker 3I didn't even know the bloody horse, let alone the trainer or jockey. And it's just.
Speaker 2Well, I'll give you my little... My little Melbourne Cup fun fact, Trevor, is that the most famous horse of them all, Farlap, that we've been saying Farlap's name wrong all this time because it's my understanding, yes, it's my understanding because it's true, that Farlap is a Thai word for lightning, as in, like, fast. But we know how you pronounce Phuket, and it's just as well that we
Speaker 2pronounce Phuket Phuket. you know, without making the P-H sound an F. Anyway, so Puket is spelt P-H-U, and it's not Foo, is it? It's Poo, which means that Farlap, which is spelt P-H-A-R, the most famous horse that ever was, we should be calling it Parlap. It's Parlap. It's not Farlap. All these years, Farlap, who died in 1932... was foaled
Speaker 2in 1926. I'm sorry, it's par lap. That's disappointing, isn't it? Seven to ten. Five to ten. Tim Roxburgh here. Jill, hi.
Speaker 9Yeah, hi.
Speaker 23How are you?
Speaker 2I'm good. We've only got a couple of minutes, Jill, so over to you.
Speaker 7Okay, quickly.
Speaker 23There was a horse, I think, ran. One three times in a row. Her name was, I'm not sure, was it Junos? It was a kind of French name. Can you remember that?
Speaker 2I would like to say yes. because very soon I can make it appear that, yes, I do know. So we'll just wait a second. There we go. Yeah, well, I do know, of course. I think we all do know the answer to that, which is Maccabi Diva, the only horse to win three Melbourne Cups.
Speaker 25Yes.
Speaker 23How extraordinary was that? But also, there was a horse called Empire Rose.
Speaker 14Ah, yes.
Speaker 15Which was a New Zealand horse.
Speaker 23And she won it. And she was the biggest horse. And I think she was the first mare that won it in about 72 years or something.
Speaker 2Oh, yes. She was described as a gigantic chestnut.
Speaker 10Yes.
Speaker 2A gigantic chestnut.
Speaker 23And she is a Kiwi.
Speaker 2Did she only just fit into the barrier stalls?
Speaker 15Oh, well, there you go, but she's still around.
Speaker 2Wow. She was a big girl, wasn't she?
Speaker 15Oh, absolutely.
Speaker 2A gigantic chestnut.
Speaker 15That's all I wanted to say.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 23Because although I'm not a horse person, a gambler on horses, but I remember certain things.
Speaker 2Yeah. Well, how do you feel about Farlap, that we've been mispronouncing the name, that it should be Parlap?
Speaker 10No, no, no, no.
Speaker 23It'll always be Farlap to me.
Speaker 15Yeah.
Speaker 2Well, I guess because everyone called it Farlap, but yeah, you know, you think of Phuket and it's.
Speaker 23No, no, no, no. Farlap, I'm sorry. That's how it's always been to us.
Speaker 2Yeah, it would be very hard to get used to par lap when you've had a lifetime of far lap. Par lap would be quite difficult. Thank you, Jill. Nice to have you on. We've got the 10 o'clock news in two minutes. Okay, 0800 80 1080. Now, there's one aspect of the Melbourne Cup that I think is worth mentioning in a non-mean way. And if you are just joining us, I think we can carry on by asking the question, what's your perception about the Melbourne Cup and
Speaker 2its declining popularity? Like, what have you seen in your workforce? I mean, place. You know, was the office sweepstakes still the big deal that it used to be? But a Guardian poll revealed that over two thirds of Australians have low or zero income. interest in the Melbourne Cup. Only 9% had high interest, and that's virtually half what it was just last year. So the decline is rapid. Now, you still get tens of thousands of people at Flemington. So
Speaker 2that drop-off, while it's substantial, it's still a lot of people. So they got nearly 123,000 people 20-odd years ago. They're down to about 90,000 now. The TV ratings over the last decade have fallen from about 3 million to under 2 million. And I think, like with many things, there are multiple factors at play. And yes, increased concern about the health and safety and the animal welfare is undoubtedly
Speaker 2part of it, as well as the fact that we've got more entertainment options. But I think even if we imagined that the animal welfare is totally fine, Like 100%. And I'm not likening it to greyhound racing. But let's say that any of the concerns that people do have, let's say that was just not a thing. I think it would still be declining for the very fact that in this day and age when you do have so many entertainment options, and I'm including sport and entertainment, that you've got sporting teams where you care about the team,
Speaker 2where you've been following the team all season. You care about the players. And as much as there is a small... percentage of the population who feel that way about different racehorses, most of the population has no idea. So the office sweepstake is more, I think, a habit of team bonding, which is not to be dismissed. Team bonding is important. So gathering around to watch something where you've pulled a name out of a hat and you get to have
Speaker 2a laugh with your colleagues and win a small prize or whatever you've decided to do in the office, that's a bit of fun. But as far as comparing that to whatever your favorite sport is or favorite sports are with all the dramas, the season-long dramas, and the highs and lows of that team and the history of that team and the history of those players. I mean, everyone knows my obsession with cricket. Shane Curry still has that Kane Williamson book sitting on his desk. I might ask him tomorrow if I can borrow it. Anyway, you know
Speaker 2when you borrow a book, you have the book too. He's someone I've followed for How many years? I don't know, 15, I can't even remember how many years. With horse racing, it's just not that. So when we didn't have so many options for our eyes and our dollars and our time, then it made sense. But I think irrespective of the animal welfare aspect, I think interest in the Melbourne Cup was always going to wane. And I'm not saying that gleefully.
Speaker 2If this is your favorite thing, and particularly if you're involved in the horse racing industry, you'll probably be very cross with me. But you don't want me to be anything other than honest, do you? So forgive me for that.
Speaker 250-800-80-10-80.
Speaker 2Okay, Melbourne Cup. And Farlap. Now, Tim, in Thai, Farlap, spelled F-A-H-L-A-E-P with this text, means lightning flash, pronounced with an F as used in English. Perhaps of interest to you, Phuket is derived from the Malay word Bukit O and is pronounced similarly to Malay in spoken Thai, says Rod. Now the plot thickens. So Phalap, from what I've read,
Speaker 2Phalap is a Thai word, but spelt P-H-A-R in Thai. And, you know, this is the... the english spelling of it but nevertheless spelt like that and so if phuket is spelt ph then it stood to reason that it should be parlap rather than farlap but if phuket is actually similar to the word bukit which means hill you know if you know kl bukit nanis bukit bintang though those
Speaker 2are all you know hills um even though i can't really recall the hill at bukit bintang anyway oh that's that's that's as i say that's plot thickening rod good stuff Phantom Photo Phase are all pronounced as F, same as Farlap. Yes, you're right that it is pronounced as F, but though Phantom Photo and Phase are not Thai words is the difference there. For a race that stops two nations, says DB Cooper, it didn't make the first item on the 6 o'clock news. You had to wait for the
Speaker 2sports section. Yes, you're quite right, DB Cooper. And the amount of drunkenness at the Melbourne Cup is nuts. Okay, so the one year I went to the Melbourne Cup, which I think was 2011 or 12, I had never seen so many rich people absolutely slaughtered drunk. When I say rich people, I mean people dressed up like it's a wedding. And not just drunk, but as in men
Speaker 2and women who looked like they had high-paying finance jobs, were falling over drunk, uniformly falling over drunk. I've never seen that level of drunkenness in my life. All right. Thank you for texting through on that one. And then we've got a few about Andre the Giant. Murray says, I knew a 140-kilo guy who once drank 56 handles at the Hastings Angus Inn and then drove home. What? Oh,
Speaker 2my goodness. That's so irresponsible and so dangerous. He drove home to flaxmere in the Mark II Zephyr. Yikes. Okay, 9292. Oh, 880, 1080. And if you do want to talk the Melbourne Cup and the declining popularity or the perception of declining popularity, then what have you seen? But as I say, there's this one other aspect just before we get to this break that I want to mention about the Melbourne Cup today. And I don't want to be mean about it. However,
Speaker 2so the other New Zealand breed entry other than Chocolates, who's co-owned by Mark Graybatch, love Mark Graybatch, was scratched just hours before the race. And this was after a stable hand had mistakenly applied reading here, a routine anti-inflammatory liniment to his legs on race morning without prior approval. I feel very sorry for that stable hand. And it kind of makes me think of the times in your life where you kind of had one job and and
Speaker 2and you stuffed it up i just it's it's just so unfair really that this sort of thing can happen in life and um and i wonder if you you would own up to that whether you learned a lesson from it you know the the time that you stuffed up the one thing that you had to do but did you actually learn from it um I hope that person's okay. All right, we'll be back after this. Just about 20 past 10, Newstalk ZB. 10.22, Cherry, hi.
Speaker 10Hi. Hi.
Speaker 12You were saying that you felt sorry for the stable hand. Well, I feel sorry for the connections, the owners, because you don't just wake up sort of three weeks before the Melbourne Cup and decide that, you'd like to enter your horse. The entries open months before the cup and you end up paying a very sizable amount of money as entry fees.
Speaker 12You know, it's sort of staggered. They cut the field down about three or four times. I don't know the exact figures. I was involved about 30 years ago, and you end up paying, I should have Googled it before I spoke to you.
Speaker 2No, no, that's okay. I'll have a look.
Speaker 12Yes, a considerable amount of money by the time your horse has made the final field. So I'd feel sorry for those people. They will have lost.
Speaker 24$ 40, 000.
Speaker 12Or $ 50, 000 in nomination fees. So I just thought I'd put that aside.
Speaker 2No, absolutely. Do you know that's part of why I feel sorry for the person? And I don't think that's particularly ironic, but what you're saying reaffirms it. It's when you do in life the stuff up, even if it's really inexcusable, where it's not that other people can say to you, don't worry, it's fine. It's where you really know that actually... It's not fine.
Speaker 5It's not fine.
Speaker 14No.
Speaker 12I would be surprised if he still has a job.
Speaker 2So, yeah, the final declaration fee, which is the total of the initial nomination, the first acceptance, second and third acceptance, and then the final declaration fee, is $ 45, 000 on the Saturday before the race. And then that's refunded if the horse is balloted out of the final 24-runner field.
Speaker 11Yes.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 12So, you know, to begin with, they probably get about 100 nominations and then they are weeded out and there are certain prestigious races that if you win, then you get automatic entry into the Melbourne Cup. I don't know. I assume you still have to pay the money. But yes, with a normal race, There's the nominations and you pay
Speaker 12a fee and then there's the acceptances and that determines the final field so that the horses, if they're handicapped, if it's a handicap race, then they are ranked with the highest handicap as horse number one in descending order and the top 20 or 24 or 15 or however big the course is, they are accepted and you've got
Speaker 12to pay another fee and accept that you're in the race.
Speaker 2I just wonder what, when people are listening right now, when they hear that there was a stable hand who accidentally bunged some cream on the horse, I mean, I know you really rub more than bung when it comes to cream, but they put the cream on the horse and then, oh, no, no. We're not allowed to put that cream on the horse. The horse is disqualified. This thing that we've spent all this time building towards, oh no, I've ruined it with the cream. But what are some of the most absent-minded stuff-ups, blunders in history? And it
Speaker 2might just be your history. I've looked at a little list. There was a German spy who left his briefcase on a train in 1915, so during World War I. It was the spy Heinrich Albert. And he accidentally left a briefcase with some sensitive intelligence plans for sabotage on a New York elevated train. And that was apparently a turning point because the U.S. Secret Service tracked him. They got the papers. They leaked them to the press. And American public opinion turned against Germany. So thank goodness for Heinrich
Speaker 2Albert being a hapless spy. If you can think of other examples, and yes, I'm not trying to pick on this person. Let's not find out their name. And I mean that seriously, who accidentally, well, accidentally on purpose put the cream on the horse, which meant it couldn't race in the Melbourne Cup. But if that's like a springboard to other absent-minded blunders, then go for gold, 0880, 1080. Craig, do you have one you want to add to the mix?
Speaker 17I've got a couple of small ones.
Speaker 10Okay.
Speaker 17I worked for a sound company in Hamilton for many years and we did a concert that was about 120 k's away from Hamilton and I forgot to pack the multi-core lead that goes between the front of house rack and amp racks.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 17I was doing something else and then a friend of mine rang up and wanted to know whether I wanted to go around for a friend's birthday on the weekend and got sidetracked so that was that one and the other one had a friend of mine who works for a company in Hamilton that looks after the wind turbines on the hill at Ragland.
Speaker 2Oh yeah.
Speaker 17And we were replacing one of the little amontometer things I think the one's That's the wind speed or whatever. So down the bottom there, putting all the safety gear on, he said, right, here's what we need to do then. He was just showing me how to do it and got away to the top of the tower. And then we realized that, well, I realized that I'd left the sensor still sitting on the tailgate of the yurt down the bottom.
Speaker 4Oh, no.
Speaker 17So it's a long walk, long way to get down again. So it's a couple of stuff. But you're talking about the words that are a little bit weird. I always found psychologist was a bit of a word where it starts.
Speaker 9With a P.
Speaker 17I found those sort of words a little bit strange sometimes, especially when you learn a spell as a kid.
Speaker 2Well, yes, I guess words where there are silent letters can be a bit confusing. And also the words like red. You know, you read a book, but you read a book, and the color is red. And trying to get a child to get their head around all the different versions of red and read is a little confusing.
Speaker 17Yeah, I've got a friend of mine, I look after his daughter sometimes when they go out for date nights. And when she was learning a few years ago, she had trouble with the which and the which and the there and the there.
Speaker 8Oh, yeah.
Speaker 17Trying to explain them there. And she, yeah, had a quite habit of writing different things or whatever. And she'd put the wrong which in the sentence, which made it quite hilarious for the teacher. But, yeah, it's just like, it's so many different words that are quite similar in that. And it makes the English language just quite hard and all that sort of stuff. It just steps up a little, especially on English. I imagine it would be quite hard for people who English is not their first language coming to New Zealand trying to learn that. It would be very difficult sometimes trying to work out your way around all these different words that sound the same and mean totally different things.
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 2And, you know, I think when we hear in other languages, I'll give you an example. In Thailand, once again with Thailand, because we were talking about Phuket and Phalap, that's how that came about. One of my best mates went to a place called Ayutthaya which is not that far from Bangkok. And if you know Ayutthaya, it's a little bit like Angkor Wat, not as spectacular, but a beautiful place with these old temples. And it's a common tourist day trip
Speaker 2from Bangkok. So my mate's staying in Bangkok, goes to Ayutthaya for the day, comes back to the hotel, and the lovely staff at the hotel said, oh, what did you get up to today? And he said, and they had English, they had good English. And he said, oh, I went to Ayutthaya. And they just total blank face. They're like, Ayutthaya? Oh, what's that? And they'd never heard of Ayutthaya. And my mate was like, how have you never heard of it? It's extremely famous. And indeed, your hotel offers day trips there. Totally had never heard of it.
Speaker 2And then eventually, it turned out they had heard of it. They went, oh, you mean Ayutthaya.
Speaker 6And.
Speaker 2So he could say Ayutthaya, they had no idea. It wasn't that it sort of rang a bell and they couldn't connect the dots. They had no idea what he was talking about. Ayutthaya, nope, never heard of it. And then it was when he described, boy, you know, these ancient temples and everything. It's pretty amazing. Oh, Ayutthaya. And that subtle difference was blank face to, yes, I know exactly what you're talking about. It's up the road and we go there or we offer the trips there daily. It reminds me, I always forget to mention it, that there's a house in West Auckland that has, no exaggeration,
Speaker 2about 25 fridges outside, presumably to sell, unless the owner just loves fridges. And then I think, are fridges so sturdy that you can leave them outside? Because people are buying, they must be buying fridges off this person. Would you be happy to buy a fridge that had been sitting out in the rain But unless they are just a fridge collector, this property, there are no exaggeration about 25
Speaker 2fridges sitting in the front yard. It's a curious situation. Oh, 880, 1080. Peter, g'day.
Speaker 5I must call you up on that, what you said before. You said, Don Vess wrote something in the paper and no one wants to read it. And because of that, you said... It's just rubbish. I mean, the whole thing is that if you're a Labour voter, you'd say that, wouldn't you?
Speaker 2Peter, before you get your knickers in a twist, you might want to establish what the facts of the yarn were first because you may not have quite established those facts there, Peter. Are you interested in what the yarn was about or not really?
Speaker 5Yeah, I'd read it and judge what it said. I wouldn't dismiss it straight away and say it's rubbish. I would say we have to know what's happening around the world and what's happening in New Zealand.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2So Don Brash's full-page ads are not about what's happening around the world.
Speaker 5No, no. I only say what's happening in New Zealand. Last time the Labour Party was in New Zealand, There's just that backup the company.
Speaker 2Okay. As frequently said, it's easy to throw out those words. The fact that they're not true, I hope will interest you one day. But now, as far as what I was saying, because you're a little bit confused, and that's okay. As far as what I was saying about Don Brash, I do find it curious that you would use having sort of half heard something as an opportunity to get annoyed. rather than going, well, you know, I maybe didn't catch all that story, but no, I still want to get annoyed. Anyway, what I was talking about is that Don Brash is
Speaker 2taking out full-page ads. Now, full-page ads in our biggest paper cost a lot of money. So he's taking out full-page ads to encourage right-wing voters to split their vote. He's trying to encourage people who want national to be the foundation of the next government to not vote national. And I was saying that Dear old Don Brash is under the impression that people in their busy lives have time to read a full page ad with small text
Speaker 2from someone obsessed with politics about why the party that they want to form the government should not be the party that they vote for. And in my opinion, because this is a job where I'm paid to give opinions, I think that he's being a little bit too clever by half and also showing some low emotional intelligence, which is that People just aren't going to read that ad. And the proof of that to me, Peter, is that you are clearly a right-wing voter who also can't be bothered reading the ad.
Speaker 7Oh, no, no, no, no.
Speaker 2Have you read the ad? Have you read the ad? Have you read the ad?
Speaker 5No, I haven't read the ad. I haven't read the ad.
Speaker 2Okay, well, that could be a nationwide paper, and I wouldn't be surprised if he's taken out that ad in other publications. But nevertheless... If you saw that ad in front of you, would you be hanging on every word telling you as, if you are a national voter, to not vote national?
Speaker 5No, I'd have to look at it first.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think you would.
Speaker 9Yeah, no.
Speaker 5I'm going to go for David Seymour. Seymour is the name of the bank on.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 3Seymour. All right, Peter.
Speaker 2Thank you for the call. Now, this text to Tony says, I found it strange when I went to California for the first time years ago and couldn't pronounce. Oh, I should have looked up how to pronounce these things before I started reading the text. Oh, yes.
Speaker 23Yes.
Speaker 2Okay. So let's start this one again. Tony says, I found it strange when I went to California for the first time years ago and couldn't pronounce Van Nuys. and Yosemite. When I pronounced Van Guise, they had no idea what I was talking about. It sounds like Van Nuys. Yes, it's one of those ones that you hear it said, you know, it's Van Nuys. But then when you see it's written and it's written like, you know, Van Guise, G-U-Y-S. Now, as far as Yosemite is concerned, even well-known Americans will
Speaker 2have no idea that it said Yosemite, but one of the most beautiful places on earth. uh hamish on the melbourne cup just as we head to the break is the decline of popularity slash interest of the melbourne cup directly linked to the decline in alcohol consumption i don't know uh we know that young people are drinking less than previous generations but and and you know my firsthand example of going to the melbourne cup and never having seen so much drunkenness in my life by people dressed like they were going to a wedding I mean, that
Speaker 2is some years ago now. That was 15 years ago. So I'm not sure. I think it's a whole bunch of reasons why the Melbourne Cup is not what it used to be as far as its place in society. Oh, 880, 1080. All right, we'll be back after this. 23 to 11. 20 minutes to 11. Asking about the decline in popularity of the Melbourne Cup. Noleen makes a really good point. Many workplaces have rules about gambling on site, and this
Speaker 2has dampened the vibe around office sweepstakes. Where I work, the TAB is blocked on office Wi-Fi, as is Lotto. That's interesting. I hadn't even thought about that, whether your office Wi-Fi would block something like the TAB. I don't think that that could happen in this workplace because so much sports reporting is sort of intertwined with sports betting or at least an understanding of what the odds are
Speaker 2and that's something i've talked about so many times over the years that that try not to be judgmental it's just an observation but i i feel like such an outlier as a male interested in sports that i don't bet on sports because it feels like if you're a male under the age of 50 especially a male under the age of 40 that that You simply do not watch sport without placing a bet on it, which I don't love. Darren, talking about the Melbourne Cup, says, My
Speaker 2cousin Marie Linden was the first female to ride in the Melbourne Cup in 1987 on Argonaut Style. Finished well back, but a proud moment for New Zealand. And Fraser says, Surely every person over 30 and now under 10, thanks to recent movies, knows Yosemite Sam and therefore how to pronounce Yosemite. Well, you'd hope so. But I've even heard American politicians call it Yosemite. And whether that's people just getting nervous, I don't know. It's fairly embarrassing. Now, I
Speaker 2mentioned about Mr.
Speaker 16Beast.
Speaker 2This is just sort of a tidy up of text messages we haven't gone to earlier on, and I appreciate you sending them through.
Speaker 17Now, Mr.
Speaker 2Beast is a YouTuber. He's 28 years old. He's young. YouTuber who is worth $ 2. 5 billion. based on his empire, which is a few different things, but his popularity is founded on YouTube videos. Cash is always up for grabs, and there are arbitrary challenges, and like so many painful YouTubers out of the States, it's very loud and very fast, and kids, very young children, get very addicted to it.
Speaker 2So I'm concerned about that as a parent. But I mentioned earlier on that my daughter, who's sometimes watching these things and I'm saying, no, come on. She loves playing outside. She loves drawing. So she's not necessarily watching too much TV. It's just that when she wants to watch TV, she wants to go to YouTube. And then lo and behold, Mr. Beast is doing charity work and building homes for people in, I can't remember which South American country, who'd lost everything in a flood. And then he's buying and paying for
Speaker 2prosthetic limbs for literally hundreds of people who've lost limbs. And watching this, I initially thought, oh, well, okay, this isn't so bad. This is good. And then realized it was all about him in such a really unpleasant, self-centered way that this wasn't giving in a selfless way. This was giving in a way which is I have the power and aren't I amazing? and I will provide for you.
Speaker 15I will.
Speaker 2You know, it was a very, I have a very sort of almost creepy look into his soul when he would look at the camera as another person off the assembly line is dispatched. I'm going, yep, you've got your limb now. Aren't I amazing? Okay, right. Who's the next person to meet me, God, as I provide another limb? Now, If you haven't seen him, you might think, oh, this is some sort of tall poppy syndrome at play. Honestly not. I want my children to see about being selfless and
Speaker 2giving to those less fortunate, but he's not the guy to do it. Anyway, we did have a text from Bradley about Mr. Beast and said, he reminds me of Jerry Maguire, help me help you. On politics, Patrick says, Luxon is purely focused on pushing national. He thinks this plan will work. and he won't need opportunity party. I honestly think his voters are worried with another poll showing that opportunity really are looking like being the kingmaker, but Luxon won't negotiate with them. So then what happens to Luxon on election night? And this text says, did Luxon
Speaker 2refuse to be interviewed by Jack Tame? Yes. He hasn't been on for something like two years. Seriously, if so, that says a lot. Correct me if I'm wrong. You're not wrong. Nice guy, apparently, no doubt. However, New Zealand requires a tough, innovative, smart leader who can be interviewed by anyone. This is the thing. So Luxon thinks that by not doing interviews with Jack Tame and Moana Maniapoto, Scotty Morrison, various others, Tova O'Brien. He thinks that by not doing that, he's saving himself because he's not being
Speaker 2exposed for his lack of knowledge. So he's saving himself. Maybe, maybe to some extent, but he's also not stress testing himself. So, you know, the whole red pill, blue pill thing, that even colleagues of yours who are on your side should be picking apart your good arguments so that you can not just defend them, but that you can sell them, you know, so that you are aware of what those tough questions are so that you can say, I hear what you're saying, but this is why this is important
Speaker 2and this is why it works. So he hasn't stress tested himself. And that's why he's still, despite avoiding those interviewers, he still gets found out for a lack of knowledge. And then there's the other aspect that we're a relatively small country. And this is an important function of our democracy, that our money goes towards making shows like Q & A. So you avoid doing it. You're doing a disservice to our democracy. And there are plenty of politicians who I
Speaker 2don't agree with who at least will front up. I mean, say what you will and I will about David Seymour. He's not scared to do an interview with someone who's going to challenge him. All right, thank you for texting through on all of those ones. And Kristen says that she voted this afternoon while having to go into town here in Invercargill. Kia kaha. Good on you, Kristen. 29% of people have changed their vote since the election campaign began. And Tony says, I changed my vote from the National Party as soon as Cameron Brewer didn't support the safeguard action to assist the New Zealand aluminium manufacturers against imported products.
Speaker 2You wouldn't believe Cameron Brewer is Minister for Small Business and Manufacturing, thousands of jobs at stake. And Leah, one more before the break, Leah says, it's clear why Luxon turns down interviews. If he's on stage saying what he wants with no one questioning him, he's in control. Interviews aren't the same. He's not in control, which he can't cope with. And this text says Luxon lost my party vote when Hipkins in the debate said he would ban bottom trawling and Luxon sort of agreed, voted act. New Zealand first other vote today. They won't stop it. Crazy talk.
Speaker 2Six billion revenue and 14,000 jobs. Yes, but they're not jobs forever, are they, if we destroy the ocean floor? Thank you for texting in. 13 to 11, Newstalk ZB. Newstalk ZB at 11 minutes to 11. Now, I want to throw out a new topic, and this is something that Olivia, who produces the show, and I were talking about, which is coincidences. And there is a launch pad that's not entirely random to talking about coincidences, so I'll remind
Speaker 2myself exactly what that is. But I want to talk about the craziest coincidences in your life, as well as the ones in history that you've remembered and you're like, gosh, that's insane. Okay, so here we go. It was this day in history that the Barry Lyndon novel was finished. So that was back in 1844. And then 120 years later on this day, Lyndon B. Johnson defeated Barry Goldwater for the presidency. So you've got the Barry Lyndon novel finished,
Speaker 2and then you've also got Lyndon B. Johnson defeating Barry. So Lyndon versus Barry. So it's a bit of a coincidence there. Sometimes we don't need the greatest launchpad to have a great conversation. So let's talk about coincidences. And indeed, there are others in American politics which are kind of strange. So Lincoln and Kennedy. So two assassinated presidents, a century apart. Lincoln was elected in 1860, Kennedy in 1960. Both were
Speaker 2succeeded by a Johnson. Both were shot in the head on a Friday, which is no good. And both were shot by men with three names totaling 15 letters. I don't know whether the last part blows my mind so much, but okay. Still, the Hoover Dam deaths. Now, some of these, well, maybe these are all American, so let's get some New Zealand ones. But George Tierney died during Hoover Dam's early survey in 1922. 14 years later, on the same day, his son Patrick passed away while working on the project.
Speaker 2Neither event was linked, reading here, but the dates and bloodline make it unforgettable. Okay, so what's a coincidence that you... think was just crazy, whether it happened in your life or it's one that you know about. Mark Twain reading here once joked that he'd go out with Halley's Comet. He was born in 1835, the same year that the comet passed Earth. 1910, he died of a heart attack the day after its closest approach, which is a bit
Speaker 2of a coincidence, you'd have to say. So what's yours that you want to share? Oh, 880, 1080, because you must. I think most of us have an idea of the coincidence in our life or the one that we're aware of, even if it wasn't to do with us. So here's one which has stuck with me of late, which is that the Pepsi commercial where Michael Jackson got severely burned on the back of his neck was the exact midpoint of his life. So as in the exact midpoint of
Speaker 2his life. So the Pepsi accident was January the 24th, 1984, which he was aged 25 years, four months, and 29 days. So he died 25 years, four months, and 29 days after the Pepsi incident. Now, is it just a case that you could explain that away by saying that someone as famous as Michael Jackson, who in the 80s was doing so much that maybe any given day in the 80s looks like a significant moment in his life. So
Speaker 2maybe you can kind of take the wind out of the sail somewhat with that. But still, that was a defining moment in his life. And it was the exact midpoint of his life. Oh, 880, 1080. Let's talk coincidences. Why not? Because why not? It's seven minutes to 11. Newstalk ZB. 5 to 11. Sean, do you have two minutes you can share your coincidence story?
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 9Sorry, it's a little bit long.
Speaker 2Tell you what, do you want to hold until after the news and then I won't rush you through it? Can you hold?
Speaker 9Yeah, I hope it's worth it.
Speaker 2Well, hey, look, tell you what, even if it's not, I'll say that it was.
Speaker 9Okay, thanks.
Speaker 2So we'll get your coincidence story after the news. You stay where you are. And I will share a very brief one of mine. So I mentioned Michael Jackson. I wasn't there when it happened, so it's not one of mine, but this is one that I heard fairly recently, which I think, gosh, that's kind of a crazy coincidence, which is really the nature of coincidences. So yes, indeed, it is true. Michael Jackson with the Pepsi commercial, which happened January 27th, 1984, was the exact midway point of his life. Now,
Speaker 2how it impacted him, he was in hospital for some time. He had the victory tour with his brothers booked, and this was seen to be a moment, kind of a line in the sand, which changed him physically and perhaps, you know, it wasn't the first time he had plastic surgery, but it perhaps kind of spared up him becoming more interested in how he could change his body, even though this burns to his head and to his neck. Anyway, yeah, so he was born August 29, 1958. the Pepsi commercial
Speaker 2shoot was January 27th, 1984. And when the time between those dates is calculated precisely, it equals exactly 25 years, four months and 29 days. So that is the halfway point of his life. I think of a time I went to Hong Kong 2010 and I got lost in Kowloon and ended up in this bizarre but delicious Indian restaurant, like six stories up in a very tall building. And when I went back to Hong Kong six years later, I got lost in Kowloon again. And I was starving.
Speaker 2And I didn't know where I was. And I ended up lost. And then in this building where somehow I got directed to a random Indian restaurant six stories up. And it was the same Indian restaurant. Your favorite coincidence, 0800 80 1080, 11 o'clock news next. Newstalk ZB. Tim Roxburgh filling in for Marcus at the moment. He will be back next week. Quincy Jones, as I mentioned earlier on the show, passed away two years ago today. And sometimes talking about entertainers, we can be prone to hyperbole.
Speaker 2But when you're talking about Quincy as being one of the greatest producers ever, that is an understatement. So he was 91 years old, and one of the bands he produced, the Brothers Johnson, loved the song. This was number one in New Zealand back in 1980. Written by Rod Templeton, who wrote a lot of the big Michael Jackson hits like Thriller and Rock With You, but also wrote songs like this for the Brothers Johns. Produced by Quincy. All right, 0800-80-1080, if you'd like to be on and talking coincidences, Sean, here we go. Let's hear it. what's the coincidence that
Speaker 2you wanted to uh share with the entire nation.
Speaker 9Okay so it's a it's a chain of events sometimes things happen or don't happen you never know what really went on why it did or didn't happen I put this together a few years later, but this is back in the 80s, 1986 in fact. It's a bit of a war story. I was up in the Persian Gulf then working for the oil companies and we were working up in the northern end where a lot of exocets were used against shipping and we knew that we were going to be in that area. Anyway, one morning we
Speaker 9were just coming into Kharg and about three or four hours steaming from it and We were hit by an Exocet missile. It went through the deck and went through the main working deck. Why it went there, and it didn't get me, because it got killed or injured about 18 out of 25 in our crew on.
Speaker 2Deck that time.
Speaker 9But the Exocets go by a radar reflector and by heat, and normally they'll go into the largest piece of the superstructure where the smokestacks are, and they'll go off. They set fire to the Antelope and the Falklands, and that was pretty bad for a lot of people. We were sort of hit the same, but it did not hit the superstructure. It didn't hit the funnels where I was sitting having breakfast. My watch stopped at quarter past 11,
Speaker 9and I had to be on shift at 11.30, and I thought I got time for a cup of tea. So I stayed in the stacks having a cup of tea, which is where it would have gone. Another guy on deck opened up the side doors to a big container and he started a really big hot water generator and the whole side of that thing was polished stainless steel for about three or four square meters. So this Exocet went through the working area on the deck and went down into the deck and it didn't go through the superstructure.
Speaker 9So that was the first thing, the watch stopped That morning, it never stopped before. It was a gift on my 21st from my parents. The first time it stopped, it meant I didn't go down on deck.
Speaker 2So that saved you.
Speaker 9That's where I would have been.
Speaker 2My goodness.
Speaker 9The guy that opened the doors, he had to open the doors and start the hot water machine for the missile to go somewhere else. So literally, it was just a piece of binary code, a zero or a one. It went there and not the other place. But here's the funny thing. The guy that opened the doors... is one of nine children, and he was the last one in his family not to be convicted of murder. And then he came back to New Zealand, and a few years later, he was convicted of murder. So it was
Speaker 9just like.
Speaker 2So all the others had been convicted of murder, or were convicted of murder?
Speaker 9All of his brothers and sisters, all eight of them, had been convicted of murder, and he was the only one, and he was working with us. And he went back to New Zealand, and eventually he got convicted of murder too. So just a strange thing.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 9All these things had to happen. Yeah.
Speaker 2That's crazy because, yeah, you have those outright coincidences, and then you have the kind of the twist of fate or the sliding doors moment. But that one with the watch is, I don't know, how do you, How does an event like that change you? As in, do you reconcile that this is just a twist of fate, that these things happen, or does it make you think in a more kind of spiritually-minded way? How does that impact you?
Speaker 9Well, I've had a very long life with a lot of near-misses because of the nature of what I did for a job. And I was talking to a couple of other guys. They'd been in Afghanistan and other places. And we all kind of sat down and agreed that you can be good and you can be careful, but if you haven't got luck, you're not going to make it. There are so many odd things that happen, and it's just, and I've seen it, it's just a roll of the dice.
Speaker 9It's like surviving all those events. They're not a qualification. It just seems to happen.
Speaker 2And were there people... who kind of got the sense that they were always going to be lucky, or did people generally think that their luck was going to run out at some point?
Speaker 9You're always scared. You know that it could happen. So you're not like, oh, I'm bulletproof. No one thinks they're that. And they're always trying to get those percentages and chances and make them work for them. But you're doing the best you can. But I've come to the... Later in life, I've just come to look at it. So, well, just don't die stupid, but you definitely do need luck because I know guys who are.
Speaker 3Very, very good.
Speaker 9And when the ball drops and it drops in your lap, that's it. It could have happened to a lot of other people and it happened to them. And there's no rhyme or reason. It's just very, very odd that that's what it comes down to. And most of the time, You don't know whose shoulder the Grim Reaper is sitting on. You really don't. You could think, well, that guy, he's going to make it. He'll be fine and there'll be
Speaker 9no issues. But yeah, the Grim Reaper does call and you just don't know where they are from day to day. It makes you appreciate life a lot.
Speaker 19Yeah.
Speaker 9At the same time, it's luck. There's good judgment, of course, but there's also a huge element of luck.
Speaker 2You know, I don't want to do a sort of a callous transition from a story about life or death. But there's a sporting example. Here's the callous transition. There's a sporting example which a lot of people are talking about in the world, in the cricket world right now, because it's about luck and how Marnus Labuschagne, the Australian batter, had A crazy, and as in a statistically outlying, almost absurd amount of good luck in the first few years
Speaker 2of his international career, where he got dropped, as in catches dropped, far more than the normal kind of, if you're looking at a graph or you're looking at a bell curve or whatever, the. What's the term from, I guess, the standard deviation? Anyway, when you're looking at what could be expected for the number of times that you might have a catch dropped when you're batting, and so you get a reprieve and you get to keep on going, he was way outside
Speaker 2of any statistical norms, really, of any batter in history. And he rode that luck for about three or four years, and he was on track to be one of the greatest players of all time. And he had an average of, at one point of, 63. He was looking like he could go down statistically as second to Bradman. The only problem was that it was based on him getting these hundreds where he would survive dropped catches far more so than essentially any player in history. And after a few
Speaker 2years of riding this insane run of obviously there's skill there, skill enough to be able to score hundreds, But there's luck because he keeps having these drop catches that it evened out. And now I'm sure he's played his last test because he can't buy a run. And so his career average is going to end at 42 because he's averaged about 20 for the last few years. So the average of 60 combined with the average of 20 means
Speaker 2he'll end with an average of 40. And it's just so strange as far as thinking about how numbers work and how good luck and bad luck can happen to the same person.
Speaker 9Yeah, well, it's odds, isn't it? I mean, it's not a callous transition either because that's where you can see something happening. You can measure it. I mean, his batting average, his dropped catches average. You can compare it. You can see it. And you go, there is something odd going on because he's People do say the harder you work, the luckier you are, and that's very true. But there's also, when there's lots of random events flying around your ears, there could be bullets or cricket balls. It wouldn't matter.
Speaker 9It's just the wrong place, wrong time, and it happened to you. And it's wild because, you know, I think Einstein said, I can't believe God plays dice with the universe. But, you know, perhaps he does. You don't know.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 9And it's just averages. But then you get into distribution and where things sit. And the whole universe is not an even distribution. Nothing's ever uniform anywhere, ever. And you've got to have those outliers. You've got to have the odds.
Speaker 2I enjoy this, Sean. I'll give you the stats because I've just looked them up. So... When he was averaging 60, and people thought, far out, is he the second best batsman ever after Bradman, even though that was clearly premature, he was about 42% of the time, about 42% of the catching chances that he offered were dropped. I played cricket for 27 years. What I would have given to have had 42%, percent of the times i hit a ball to a fielder that they'd drop and that went
Speaker 2on for about three or four years now the the standard global test average for drop catches against the batter is about 20 percent and he had several years of it being 42 percent but it couldn't last and in the last couple of years the drops off when he's batting is down around 17%. Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 9I mean, I guess that happens in a lot of other things. We just don't know what's going on, and you just wonder how did that ever get there. There's stories of people that just do things and everything falls in their way.
Speaker 17Sure, sure.
Speaker 9That's excellent. But yeah.
Speaker 10Yeah.
Speaker 9I might have to go now.
Speaker 2Hey, Sean, you weren't sure whether you were going to deliver and you delivered. So well done. Nice to have you on. Really appreciate that. And, you know, as far as the more serious aspect of that, where people lost their lives and that watch that was a gift that had never stopped and the day it stopped, it saved your life. It's amazing. All right. If you've got a strange coincidence, whether it's something that happened to you or it's just one that, that, you know from history that you'd like to share. Why not? Oh, 880, 1080. Text 9292.
Speaker 2Like this one. Sometime in the 90s, I drove around a roundabout, this texter says, with two other identical red MKV Cortina station wagons. You know, I mean, so it doesn't have to be earth shattering. It could just be that time you're at the roundabout with a couple of the same other cars.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Oh, 880, 1080. Good stuff. All right, we'll be back after this. 11.19, Newstalk ZB. 11.21, John, hi.
Speaker 9Oh, hi.
Speaker 16Yeah, a bit hard to follow Sean's story, to be honest.
Speaker 2No, that's okay. Look, you could have a story like the roundabouts with the cars. I don't mind. What have you got?
Speaker 16I did used to own a Mark 1 Cortina, and I've driven many roundabouts. Anyway, my story, it relates to a property in London and it's back in 86, same year as Sean. And my now wife had the lease on this property and there was a lot of coincidence around it for me anyway. And so my story started, I was backpacking through Southeast Asia from New Zealand to London and met a friend of a friend coming out
Speaker 16of Raffles in Singapore. told me, oh, you know, my friend who I was going to stay in this place in London, he's having trouble with the landlord. They might be getting evicted and, you know, it might not be there when you get to London. And this is the place that my wife had her lease on. And some months later, we arrived there and I did take the tube there. They weren't on the phone, of course, and nobody answered the door. So I went back to the.
Speaker 16Victoria coach station and court was catching the bus to my grandmother in Manchester. And I went to the pub across the road and in walked the person I was going to be meeting at the flat in London who happened to be there on a course and he's having a beer after work. So I connected with him. And so I went to Manchester, came back and stayed in London. And some months later, my wife had been to America, back to, uh, New Zealand, decided to come back to
Speaker 16England and she was flying on a plane and sitting next to this lady she'd never met and said, oh, I've got one address in London. Pulled out the address and it was the house we were staying in and had a photograph of me saying, and this person's moved in and I married her.
Speaker 22Wow.
Speaker 9Yeah.
Speaker 2Do you know, I often think about the coincidences which I'm sure exist where you've got people in the background of a photo who then, and they don't know each other. And then their paths cross years later, you know, like I, I have kind of vague memories of hearing stories like this, but I don't, I can't think of one in particular, but, but a little bit like, like, you know, you with your, your travels, when you were backpacking, you think of all those photos, let's say you're on, you're on a Khao
Speaker 2San road in Bangkok and there's, you know, if you counted all the people in the background of that photo, you, there might be, you know, a hundred, um, who knows anyway. And then to think, wonder all the times where you've intersected without knowing it, those people in the rest of your life, you know? And then, and then if you ever then befriended one of those people, and then one day they were looking at that photo from 1997 of you on Cal Sun Road, they're like, hang on, it's me in the background. You're like, like those, those kinds of,
Speaker 2surely exist. And I find that kind of weird. All the times that we intersect with people and we just don't know or almost intersect with them.
Speaker 16And, you know, like, you know, backpacking, you are intersecting with people all the time because the rule of thumb back in the day was we were following the Bible, which was Southeast Asia on a shoestring.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 16But the rule of thumb was speak to travellers who are coming the other way.
Speaker 2Yeah, you're right.
Speaker 16And interrogate them about where to stay, where to eat, da-da-da-da. And so you're always intersecting and always, you know, taking their names, taking their numbers, photographs.
Speaker 2Yeah. Because when you're doing that sort of trail and you're back in the day where you're all reading the same guidebook, that you're exactly right, that you would be heading into... Cambodia, and then after Cambodia you'd be going to Vietnam, and then after Vietnam you'd go south to north and then you'd cross over into Laos, and then from Laos you'd cross over into northern Thailand, and then you'd go back down to Bangkok and then through Malaysia. Or, as you say, vice versa, and so sometimes you'd keep
Speaker 2bumping into the same people. But I often think about when you've met people who have become friends when traveling, or even if you're doing a group tour– And you ended up getting along really well with those people. To think all the events in your life that led you to starting that adventure on that day at the same time that those people and all the events that happened in their life that led them to start that adventure on the same day with you. The chance meeting that we have with anyone that we meet that we end
Speaker 2up having a connection with is kind of cosmic, you know? I think that I think of those things.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 16You know, I've, I've done a couple of group tours later in life and, you know, met different people from different walks of life. And then you'd, I have actually bumped into them later and you have that moment where you're looking at them going, God, I know you. And you're trying to work out where it's from and how you know them.
Speaker 2Yeah. And then you get that thing where certainly when people spoke on the phone more often, um, So you were getting more phone calls, but you would get the call from the person that you were just thinking about. And whether that's just literally the definition of a coincidence, or is it just because you are someone who has a connection with them, so it's not anything kind of. cosmic to say that use that word again it's just that you have a connection with this person so you
Speaker 2it's not crazy to think that you might be thinking of them at the same time that they're thinking of you this is i guess kind of the more fun aspect of it which is that there's some something pulling you towards them and something uh that is likewise the same thing is happening to them thank you for ringing through Nice to have you on, 1128. This text says, Hi Tim, I was 16 in Bern, Switzerland, just walking through the arc with the famous clock, or the arch with the famous clock. Coming towards me was my doppelganger,
Speaker 2identical in every way. We both smiled at each other. Another incident. What? That's crazy. Another incident that happened, my family and I were shopping in Sheffield, UK. I was 18, and George Harrison walked past us. I turned around and waved to him. He waved back and smiled.
Speaker 9Wow.
Speaker 2You've reminded me. So the only time in my life that I saw a doppelganger, I would have been around about 20 years old, and my friend was having a big party, heaps of people there from our school days, and someone put a homemade video on the TV of a bonfire with lots of people dancing around a bonfire. And I remember going, oh, it's a video of me,
Speaker 2but that's weird because I don't really dance in front of people. And it was absolutely me. But I didn't know who had filmed the video, but it was like a homemade video. And it fully looked like me. And someone said, oh, Tim, it's a video of you dancing. And we're like, no, but who? Oh, no, it's not you. It's the only time in my life where I've seen someone who I didn't just think looked like me, or rather what is more common. It was not just that other people said they looked like me, that I looked at them and went, oh that's me but it wasn't me uh a fairly strange oh yeah a fairly strange
Speaker 2coincidence this texas says i had a passport issued the same day as 9 11 my next one issued on the day bin laden was killed that's that's a strange coincidence um all right nine two nine two and oh eight hundred eighty ten eighty look we're full boarded so let's get to some more calls after the break half past eleven it's news talks airbnb 28 to 12. Susie, hi. Hello. Kia ora, Tim.
Speaker 18Kia ora. I lived at an address that was 111. I left the location September the 11th, 2001, which was when the Twin Towers got bombed. Then in 2011, at 11 minutes to one, the earthquake struck in 2011. 11
Speaker 18minutes to one. Quite often, when I go to bed, I'll go to bed early because I'm tired, I'll wake up, I'll look at the time, and it's 11 minutes past 11.
Speaker 2I know people mock people for exactly what you're talking about um but i will just tell you what has been my honest experience um and and look there's this sort of thing it can be talked about where it's confirmation bias so it's a little bit like um people will often say if you get a real run of unusual calls on talkback shall we say slightly off the wall people will go oh it must be a full
Speaker 2moon And then what happens is that you look outside and if it's not a full moon, you forget about it. But if you look outside and it is a full moon, you go, oh yeah, see, full moon does make people go a bit weird. And it's confirmation bias. You forget about the times that you don't notice it. However, Susie, I have had times in my life where the same thing is happening to me. I'm seeing the number 111. Now, some people think that this is, you know, these like angel numbers or that it really means something. Other people just mock anyone who starts thinking about it. My experience
Speaker 2was that I had no inclination. I'm not remotely interested in horoscopes. I place no stock in magic numbers or anything. I just have had times in my life where I was seeing 111 so much. So I wasn't seeing 1111, but I was seeing 111 all the time. I'd stop at traffic lights somewhere I'd never been and I'd look out the window and the house was 111. Now, it was the confirmation bias that When I stop at traffic lights in a suburb that I'm not normally in and I see the number 89, do I just forget about it maybe? But I would see it all the time.
Speaker 2And then I'd go through periods where I wouldn't see it. And, you know, is this just what life is? All I'm saying is that I've experienced the same thing too.
Speaker 22Thank you.
Speaker 2And thank you. Oh, 880, 1080. My husband and I had a habit in London of traveling by underground, says Kate, to a station we'd never been every Sunday and having lunch in the first pub we saw when we got off. That's so cool, just in and of itself. You sound like cool people, Kate. One Sunday, we walked into a pub, ordered and sat down. My husband said, that guy at the bar looks a lot like the guy that rented our house in Auckland. Guess what?
Speaker 15It was.
Speaker 2Afterwards, we went back to the underground, stood waiting for a train, which stopped. The doors opened. And there was our friend Russell from Birkdale. He said hi, we said hi, and the door shut again. He died two weeks later in a car crash. Oh, my gosh. Oh, my gosh. I got chills reading that. Thank you, Katie, and I'm so sorry. Wow. 9292. Jeff on 0800 80 1080. Welcome along. Hello, Tim. I've got a couple for you.
Speaker 25I had a 64 PB Vauxhall. And in 1985, I was in the Rustley Hotel car park, and there's another car there identical to mine, my yellowy 64PV Vauxhall. I looked at the number plate, and it's the one exactly right next door. And I found out later that they were both post office fleet cars. 21 years later, they're
Speaker 25both sitting in the same car park again. I thought that was rather unusual. And the other one is my sister married a Robin Hughes, which became my brother-in-law. My wife's only true brother is Robin Hughes. So I've messed up with two Robin Hughes, his brother-in-laws. We talked about Big Robin and Little Robin. Big Robin was six foot
Speaker 25two and three quarter and Little Robin was six foot two and a quarter.
Speaker 2That was rough on the little one. Yes, you've reminded me, Jeff. So when my wife and I first started going out, we'd known each other in high school but had lost touch. in our early 20s and then reconnected in our early 30s. And next year it'll be 10 years of marriage, two kids, good times, great times. And when we started going out, I had an apartment downtown and I rented a car park next to my apartment. And so it was in a car parking building. And my wife had been parking,
Speaker 2I forgot about this one, so you mentioned this. My wife had been parking her car in the same car park building, and she had a rented space that her office was paying for. And her office car park was directly next to my car. Now, that's a coincidence. So before we were going out, and the other part of that coincidence is that we were both driving V-dubs. So before we started going out, unbeknownst to us, because our paths didn't cross at the exact same time, here's my V-dub, and next to it is another V-dub. And I was like, okay, well,
Speaker 2the V-Dub's a fairly common car. That's fine. And it wasn't the exact same model or anything. But then, yeah, when we started going out, oh, you park in that building. Okay. Oh, whereabouts? Right next to my V-Dub. That was a nice coincidence. So we were like our cars were dating as well as we were. 0800 8010 80. Michael, hi there.
Speaker 9Yeah, hi, Tim.
Speaker 2Hey, it was in 1996, and.
Speaker 19I was in Africa on my motorbike, and I'd spent about a week or 10 days at this mining mission town in the middle of the Belgian Congo. And there was a number of expat Belgians working for the mines, and the mining company flew their motorbikes out from Belgium so they could use them while they were stationed there. And I got to know some of these guys quite well, and one of them in particular, he said, oh, I would love to do something like what you're doing. And
Speaker 19I said, well, just Frank. I said, just go and do it. Anyway, we didn't keep in touch. And it was over two years later, I was in South America in Chile. And unbeknownst to me, he was in there in Chile as well. And he didn't know I was there. And I went into this town to get some supplies. And it was a long gravel road leading into the town. And then sort of in the middle of the town up ahead, I saw this massive person with his arms
Speaker 19like the YMCA dance, you know, in the air. And I thought, oh, I wonder if.
Speaker 12That guy's okay.
Speaker 19I just better be a bit careful here. And so anyway, I went cruising. As I got a bit closer, I thought, oh, that guy looks like he's got motorcycle gear on. And as I got closer, I realized it was Frank from... the middle of Africa. And he said that he didn't know I was there. I didn't know he was there. But he said he heard the sound of my bike from way off. And he said, there's only one bike.
Speaker 24That makes that sound.
Speaker 19That'll be Michael.
Speaker 7Really?
Speaker 19And so he goes on, runs out into the middle of the street, does a big scarecrow dance to attract my attention. And yeah, sure enough, that was over two years later and neither of us knew In.
Speaker 2A different part of the world?
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 2That is crazy. And so did you guys maintain a friendship since then, or did you just kind of leave it at that?
Speaker 19No, we actually traveled together down towards Ushuaia. But some of the advice I gave them, as I said, have steel gyro cans for fuel and carry spare tires.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 19And he didn't have any of those. He didn't have spare tyres, and he had plastic jerry cans, and he only got about another 500 k's closer, and his tyres were destroyed, and his jerry cans had holes in them, and he had to end up shipping his bike back to Europe because he had no tyres, no fuel.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 19So we haven't kept in touch, but... But, yeah, that was good to see that guy that scared her doing that YMCA dance thing out in the street. And I was thinking, gee, these are a bit crazy.
Speaker 16Oh, I love that.
Speaker 2I love that, like, how a cat recognizes the sounds of the different cars that would. drive down a driveway, if you share a driveway, or if you live on a busy road and a cat knows your car, the same way that your mate, he was like, no, it's Michael's bike. I know it's two years later and we're on a different continent, but that's Michael's bike, and lo and behold, it was you. There's a saying that most people would have heard, I'm sure, which is that people come into your life for a reason, a season, or a lifetime. Apparently, that's attributed to the writer Brian A.
Speaker 2Drew Chalker, and I kind of subscribe to that. Also, I think that it gives you comfort when you have friendships end, you know, and you Sometimes, as we know, friendships end just because you drift apart. There was no falling out as such. Other times, there's a falling out. And the loss of platonic friends is, I think, one of the great underplayed, underwritten about sadnesses that people will
Speaker 2face in their lives. We talk a lot about the loss of romantic love, but the loss of your friends, your platonic friends, is, is a huge thing. Um, and, and, and particularly for guys, because guys are not good as good at maintaining friendships. Um, once they get dangerously close to middle age, uh, and not as good as women are anyway, but, but the, the notion of a reason, a season, um, or a lifetime just can give you a bit of peace that, that even if that, that
Speaker 2friendships come and gone for whatever reason that, um, well, maybe there was a reason, uh, and a season or a lifetime. 0800 80 1080. Back right after this, 16 to 12, Newstalk ZB.
Speaker 1For more from Marcus Lush Nights, listen live to Newstalk ZB from 8pm weekdays or follow the podcast on iHeartRadio.
On Marcus Lush Nights with Tim Roxborogh callers discussed more on sandpaper gate and the Guinness World Record they have witnessed or participated in. LISTEN ABOVE
Tim Roxborogh returned to fill in on Marcus Lush nights where listeners called in to discuss weirdos in public, creeps on the TV, GTA IV, and sandpaper gate. LISTEN ABOVE
On this edition of Marcus Lush Nights listeners called in to discuss the Melbourne Cup horse tossed in the tip after dying at the vet, and mispronouncing place names. And, in the last half hour of the show callers broke...
Marcus talks the scurge that is AI parking cameras (and the new windscreen barnacle parking deterrent), plus milkshakes and stolen trophies. LISTEN ABOVE