Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mamamia Out Loud

Mamamia Out Loud artwork

So, That’s Where The Pubes Went & The Eldest Daughter Trap

Nov 13, 202642 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Taylor and Travis. Beyoncé and Jay-Z. Katherine Ryan has noticed a pattern and it all comes down to who was born first. Holly Wainwright unpacks the theory that eldest daughters keep ending up with youngest sons and Jessie Stephens has a confession about the charming men she used to date. Plus, a woman named Kim House charges $85 an hour to run other people’s homes like corporations. Jessie asks whether what we all actually need is a household manager. Also, Kim Kardashian’s SKIMS released a $276 advent calendar. It runs for 12 days and includes bobby pins twice. Em Vernem has many thoughts and none of them are positive. We’re so excited to be selected for Apple Podcasts Creators We Love, which recognises people who are trailblazers and leaders in podcasting. We’re featured alongside some other amazing Australian podcasters. You can check it out on Apple Podcasts or at apple.co/creatorsweloveau. Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription for Black Friday with code BLACK30. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends November 30. Women 30+, we want to hear from you! Take our quick 3-minute survey for your chance to win a $1,000 gift card. Recommendations Em recommends Aveeno Intense Relief Hand Cream Jessie recommends A Thousand Splendid Suns by Khaled Hosseini Holly recommends Black Doves on Netflix Keen for more? Check out the Mamamia Out Loud newsletter. What To Listen To Next: Listen to our latest episode: The Most Famous Psychology Study of All Time... Was It Fake? Listen: David Walliams Is The 'Very Famous Man' & Why We're All Mess-Washing Listen: “How Do I Do It All? I Don’t.” Listen: What Russell Brand Did & The Great American Vibe Shift Listen: The TV Show That Was Fun Until It Wasn’t & The New Bookshelf Rule Listen: Everything Jessie Stephens Did Before Getting To Work Listen: Craig Silvey Pleaded Guilty. Then Published A 9000-Word ‘Apology’. Listen: Kristen, Dax & Nobody Wants This Connect your subscription to Apple Podcasts Discover more Mamamia Podcasts here including the very latest episode of Parenting Out Loud, the parenting podcast for people who don't listen to... parenting podcasts. SUBSCRIBE here: Support independent women's media You can now watch our show in full length video on the Apple Podcast app - make sure your phone is up to date and we can't wait for you to see Mamamia Out Loud on Apple What to read: Eldest Daughter Syndrome: The curse of being born first. 'Eldest daughters, you're about to enter the era of "peak death".' 'Kimberly, you're about to piss me off.' Why everyone's talking about the SKIMS advent calendar. THE END BITS: Check out our merch at MamamiaOutLoud.com GET IN TOUCH: Feedback? We’re listening. Send us an email at outloud@mamamia.com.au Share your story, feedback, or dilemma! Send us a voice message. Join our Facebook group Mamamia Outlouders to talk about the show. Follow us on Instagram @mamamiaoutloud and on Tiktok @mamamiaoutloud CREDITS: Hosts: Holly Wainwright, Jessie Stephens & Emily Vernem Acting Group Executive Producer: Georgie Page Executive Producer: Keeshia Pettit Senior Producer: Tessa Kotowicz Video Producer: Matt Perry Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1I just said, oh shit, it's Friday the 13th. I know, and you seemed genuinely freaked out by it. Well, I've been watching a lot of horror movies.

Speaker 2Okay, so let's just pretend that isn't happening. Welcome, welcome, welcome to Mamma Mia Out Loud, what women are actually talking about on Friday the 13th of November. I'm Holly Wainwright.

Speaker 1I'm Jessie Stephens. And I'm Em Burnham. And here is what is made our agenda for today. I hope it all goes well. What could go wrong?

Speaker 3I feel like it always storms on a Friday the 13th on an afternoon.

Speaker 1It gets very cloudy. I've got Girls Weekend away. It's got to all go well. It's got to all go well. It has to come out.

Speaker 2No time for storms. Okay, here's what's made our agenda for today. As I was saying, firstborn daughters are really having a cultural moment. Question for the group. Why do so many of them end up with lastborn sons?

Speaker 1We discuss.

Speaker 4Plus our weekly recos. We have a moisturiser, we have a TV show and we have a book.

Speaker 3And is what you really need a household manager? We discuss the rise of an executive head of the home.

Speaker 4But first, Emily Vernham, Kim Kardashian's business, Skims.

Speaker 1You might have heard of it. I have heard of it. I have some Skims. I bought a Skims bra, no regrets. Really? Oh, it's so good.

Speaker 2I've got a Skims bodysuit and it was like paying a lot of money for to know what it would feel like to have a boa constrictor wrapped around.

Speaker 1You at all times.

Speaker 2So I paid a lot of money to have my internal organs compressed and squished in a pleasing black velcro.

Speaker 1Not velcro. What do you call it?

Speaker 2Like that stretchy, elastic-y material.

Speaker 1So I do have some skims.

Speaker 2Kim?

Speaker 1What are you doing to me? We support Kim's business endeavors.

Speaker 4Well, Skims is getting absolutely rinsed on TikTok because they've come out with a product advent calendar.

Speaker 1So you know how back in the day, advent calendars, chocolate only.

Speaker 3Yes.

Speaker 1You get a chocolate a day for 25 days. Now we get presents.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2I'm raising this only once because the Outlouders have heard me whinge about this before, but when I was a child, not even a chocolate, just a picture behind the door.

Speaker 1Anyway, please move on. What? That is just a star. Or a bell. You're like, wow, yay. Or a donkey.

Speaker 3Do you think your parents were taking out the chocolate and then just closing the door and then making you open it again?

Speaker 2It was in the olden days, Em, when everybody didn't get a prize. Yes, just call me Alan Jones. Here we go. Go on.

Speaker 4Skims has put out a calendar, an advent calendar, with little surprises of their products in each door.

Speaker 1Can I guess the surprises, please?

Speaker 3Yes.

Speaker 1Okay. Day one, undies.

Speaker 3No.

Speaker 1Day two, bra.

Speaker 3No.

Speaker 1Day three, Holly's corset. My bodysuit that holds me in. You would hope so.

Speaker 3Oh, day four, that weird head thing. Remember they had the chin strap?

Speaker 1Oh, yes. Day five. The panties, the pants with the pubic hair on it. I want this. Or the nipple bra. The nipple bra.

Speaker 3Yes.

Speaker 1Wrong, wrong, wrong. Oh.

Speaker 4So I do have to say also, it's not 25 days, it's 12 days of skims.

Speaker 1That's stingy.

Speaker 2You don't need to just reinvent an advent calendar. Strictly speaking, it's 24. The nipple bra, you could dangle some Christmas ornaments on.

Speaker 1Oh, that's nice.

Speaker 4That would be festive. The advent calendar is right now out of stock. You can't even open the page anymore. I've tried so many redirect links. It's not working. I need to tell you what's included in these 12 days. So spoilers for anyone who has the calendar and you paid, you would have paid $ 276 AUD for this calendar.

Speaker 1Oh, no, no, no, no. So if you haven't, if you're doing the days, don't listen because I'm about to spoil what you're about to get. I don't know any of the out loud. Okay.

Speaker 4Day one, bare key chain. Does anyone even have keys anymore? No, it's like a little bear on a keychain. Day two, three-pack hair elastics. Hair elastics? I can just get them from the chemist.

Speaker 1You just need to tie your hair up. Day three, three-pack satin scrunchies, also for your hair. But I already have my hair ties. And I know what you're thinking. I know what you're thinking. There's something missing.

Speaker 4Day four, three-pack bobby pins. So now you've got the whole collection. You've got the whole collection.

Speaker 3Wait, wait, wait.

Speaker 1Sorry, bobby pins?

Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 1Skims aren't a hair situation. Skims are about holding in your jiggly bits.

Speaker 4But you need the hair to also go with it, right? Day five, a Skims stress-relieving toy because you're just so stressed about all the hair stuff.

Speaker 1Is that a vibrator? No, unfortunately. It's like one of those squishy toys that Mia uses. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Day six, two-pack... Hair clips.

Speaker 2Back to the hair clips.

Speaker 4Day seven, two-pack bra elastic headbands.

Speaker 1What? So it's bra straps repurposed as headbands.

Speaker 3Oh, my God.

Speaker 1And you get two of them. I thought I was getting a bra.

Speaker 4So in case, like, you're not wearing a bra but you want the essence of a bra, you can put it on your head.

Speaker 1Okay, day eight. Essence of bra. The essence of bra. Day eight, three-pack bobby pins. We've got more bobby pins. Oh, my God.

Speaker 3There's just pins I really didn't expect to get more bobby pins than I do. And you know what?

Speaker 1Sometimes when I have three bobby pins, I'm like, I wish I had six. So then you get, you do think I get that, but on day eight, day eight. So you have to wait for it. You know what? You've probably lost your first three.

Speaker 3They've gone down the drain and you're like, all right, I need more.

Speaker 1Day nine. This is quite interesting.

Speaker 4A comb key chain. So it's a key chain, but it's also a comb.

Speaker 1It's not a bad idea.

Speaker 2Somebody said, not a bad idea. Somebody told me and I thought that's the best idea I've ever heard. For perimenopausal women, car keys with tweezers on them. Because you know how you're driving and you see the chin hairs. It's the only time and there's no tweezers. So, Kim, you can have that idea for free. Yeah, except this is a comb.

Speaker 1Yeah, I know. Well, that's to comb your chin hair. It's actually really helpful. Evergreen was on to that.

Speaker 4Okay, day 10, logo keychain. So it has a Skims logo on it.

Speaker 1I've already got a keychain. You've got two already. Day 11, I know what you're thinking. Don't worry. Three-pack satin scrunchies. I'm not expecting more scrunchies.

Speaker 4We can't have six bobby pins and not like six scrunchies as well.

Speaker 2This is the most annoying advent calendar of all time.

Speaker 3Okay, when my daughter turned one, my mum was like, what would she want? And she ended up getting a snap lock bag and filling it with trinkets because all Luna liked was to just go through.

Speaker 1Things and have a little bag full of shit, right? And is that because she would see you go through your bag?

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1And she's like, I want that too. And she just loved things.

Speaker 2This.

Speaker 1is a bag for Luna.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Like if she had some bobby pins and loves a key ring. Yeah. Like it's just, it's a one-year-old Snaplock bag. A $ 276 one-year-old Snaplock bag. Oh, my God. Last day, day 12. Something big, something big.

Speaker 4Faux fur compact mirror key chain.

Speaker 1Okay. A furry mirror. It's like one key with eight keychains. A furry mirror for the last day. For the last day of Advent. That can't be. All right, I'm doing the maths. I'm doing the maths. That is... $ 11. 50. Yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1But it is Skims.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1It is Skims. That's true.

Speaker 2You know how everything in Skims is a tasteful neutral?

Speaker 1Yeah. Is it that?

Speaker 2Is everything like, you know, brown, beige, coffee, latte?

Speaker 4Well, I can't get the Glenelg coffee latte.

Speaker 1Theory about the furry mirror.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1It's the pubes.

Speaker 3It's the pubes.

Speaker 1It's the leftover pubes. It's the leftover pubes because.

Speaker 3They're actually being really environmental because they're like, we've got too many bras. Yes.

Speaker 1Chuck them in the thing. Nobody bought the hairy knickers. We'll put them on eight. Yeah.

Speaker 4So it is like there's a lot of videos on TikTok about people like absolutely rinsing this calendar. And some people have pointed out that it is called an accessory advent calendar, hence all the keychains.

Speaker 1Okay. You're not an accessory business though. That's so true. She's trying something new. Okay. This is not good. That is not an advent calendar I'm buying. Well, it's sold out so you can't.

Speaker 2I couldn't. I did one year when my daughter had just entered teen world buy an inappropriately expensive beauty advent calendar for her. but it was a stupid thing to do because what did she do the minute she got it?

Speaker 1Opened it all. Opened every single box. Kids these days, Holly. Kids these days. Delayed gratification. Well, you're like, back in my day, I got a picture of a star. And I jumped up and down.

Speaker 2I got disproportionately mad about it because I was like, the joy is in the surprise.

Speaker 1And she's like, the joy is in all this free shit. I think you wanted that advent calendar.

Speaker 3Is what we actually all want, just a household manager. I want to tell you about a woman named Kim House. That's her real name. Her last name is House. She charges $ 85 an hour and she runs households like corporations. We're talking. She walks in in the morning. She fixes your coffee machine. She fertilises your trees. She grills your chicken. She's sending off your returns.

Speaker 1And so on.

Speaker 3Wow. There's a story about House in the Washington Post and apparently it's the job that she does has seen rising demand over the last few years, especially it's always been something that kind of elite aristocrats do and upper class. But now it's kind of filtering down to the middle class. The middle class need this position filled in their homes. Some household managers are tasked with a daily reset. So they walk in in the morning, they clean that food-encrusted baby chair, high chair. They see all the things you need.

Speaker 3They do like a stock take of your fridge and they're like, right, this is the grocery shopping we need to do. They make the beds, they organize. And so when you walk in in the afternoon, you walk into a home where it looks like no one lives there. The role is marketed as basically another wife. And my favourite comment on the article was this one that read, we had one of those people when I was a kid, we called her mum. To that person I asked, did your mum work 40 hours a week?

Speaker 1That's so true.

Speaker 3I have offered my husband this role. We're still in negotiations regarding pay.

Speaker 1But Holly, is this a dream? Yeah, it's definitely a dream.

Speaker 2The only thing I issue I had with this story is the headline was the women. Was it the women who will make your house look like nobody lives in it? Well, look, the implication was woman. Let's be real.

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 2And I'm like, who wants to live in a house that looks like nobody lives in it? I'd like to live in a house that didn't look like. a whole litter of happy puppies had been left alone in there for.

Speaker 1A week or two. That would be nice.

Speaker 2But the idea of pristine, I'm not really down with, but she totally had me at the daily reset. Oh, like say it softer in a sexy voice, like a daily reset.

Speaker 1It's just like heaven.

Speaker 3I watched this TikTok a few months ago and it was a woman being like, um, look at what this role is at night. And it was someone coming into her house and making cookies and resetting their school uniforms, ironing the school uniforms and unpacking the dishwasher and doing the laundry.

Speaker 1And I was like, this is amazing.

Speaker 3And I showed Luca and I was like, how amazing is this? And he said, have you watched this till the end? And I watched till the end and it was like, I'm the mom. I'm just the mom who's doing this shift.

Speaker 1For free. And I was like, oh, I got done. Of course.

Speaker 2I was in, one of the things I was into this, because obviously this is about, you know, have you got the money to pay somebody like that? And that it's, you know, In this economy, who does? But the thing that was interesting to me is the idea of reading this article of the kind of.

Speaker 1People who are really good at it.

Speaker 2Because they said, this kind of job is for the highly methodical and operations-minded. Now that is the opposite description to my brain. I am not methodical. I am not operations-minded. I get very overwhelmed by, you know, all the things that need doing all the time. And so some of the women interviewed in this who did, they'd made this their role, said it brings them so much pleasure to restore order.

Speaker 3I loved that this was positioned as a skill set because it absolutely is.

Speaker 1It is a skill set.

Speaker 3Homemaker is something that we have completely undermined over history. My gran was an amazing homemaker. Like she had a particular set of skills that I completely respect about like how you make sure you've got enough food and interior design, like all of those things.

Speaker 1And I just.

Speaker 3There are some people who are brilliant at it and there are some people who need to outsource it in terms of money.

Speaker 1I mean, that's a big question. Em, do you need a household manager? 100%. I need a household manager. What do you need them to do?

Speaker 4And I don't even need that many things managed. But this is like my dream list if I had a household manager. I need them to let me know exactly what groceries I need to buy. Remind me to do my car rego.

Speaker 1Is that not just your dad? Yeah, it is my dad. He is my house manager.

Speaker 4I have like random things in my house. When I got floorboards put in. They gave me like the excess floorboards and I was like, I might need these one day. And now they're just hanging out behind my fridge and I don't know what to do with them.

Speaker 2What are you going to need them for? That's what the household manager would tell her. Yeah, she would know.

Speaker 4She would know. I need to repaint my stair railings. I need to throw out all my expired makeup products, fix my wardrobe hinges. Sometimes my whole wardrobe just comes out and I have.

Speaker 1To like carry it back on.

Speaker 3Everyone has that door in their house. And book my dentist appointments and my gyno appointments. Okay, I want a household manager. to get my marina inserted. I know I need to get a marina but I don't have time.

Speaker 1Yes. Go and do my skin check. Go do it. I don't know.

Speaker 3Apparently you're good at executive function.

Speaker 1Make it happen. I don't want to be involved.

Speaker 4I like that also Kim said that they don't do like the dirty work, like they don't clean toilets, which is good because then you can stay humbled.

Speaker 1You're like at least I'm cleaning my toilet.

Speaker 3It's true.

Speaker 1I clean my own toilet.

Speaker 2Apart from obviously I am famously a hate folding washing and I seem to spend so much time all my weekend doing it but empty out my fridge please because in my house every single night someone goes this will be good for leftovers puts it in the puts whatever it is in the fridge in a container that doesn't have a lid just has some alfoil at the top because we've lost the lid which is another thing the household manager would be good at knowing where that was and my fridge is just full of stuff from like may you know and it's gross and no one ever

Speaker 2eats leftovers So I'm just endlessly going in, lifting up the alfoil, big sniff, like, oh, no. Household manager would just have that shit labelled.

Speaker 3Yeah. To take this to a more serious place, I have a friend whose mother has been diagnosed with dementia. And what they've found is that there's the caring, there's the emotional element of it, but there is also a life that now needs administration.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's true.

Speaker 1Everything from, like.

Speaker 3bank to repairs at home to wardrobe to house to build like it's it's so overwhelming and I was thinking and I know that obviously you can get help with all those little individual jobs but I was like there is with dementia now being the biggest killer in the country and you know increasingly something that impacts people there is this role of like come in and organise a life of just how, because some people are really bad at it. You might not have anyone in the family

Speaker 3who has that skill set.

Speaker 2Because to your point earlier, when we were talking about the kind of mind who's good at this and you were saying how homemaking has been devalued, for a long time it was just assumed that women were good at this. Can confirm not good at it. Yeah, you had no choice. Like homemaker is your ascribed role. You will be good at knowing when to throw out the leftovers and that this thing needs doing and when that, you know, whatever it is. And as we've been allowed to have more choices in our life, a lot of us are like, ah, not my strong suit. But for the people who are, like that would be amazing because it's true there is

Speaker 2so much admin involved in ageing Like looking after elderly parents, there is so much admin in that. Looking after caring of all kinds. And some of that is really important that it's done by, well, not really important, but some... Some of that is very much preferable to be done by somebody close to you who loves you, but really anybody can sort.

Speaker 1Out, you know. A repair of the roof. Yeah, or your rates bill or whatever it might be. Or not anybody, but somebody who you can trust.

Speaker 3Yeah. I had a, I was a bridesmaid and the three of us had to organise our hens and one of the other bridesmaids was the most skilled organiser, executive. She was a CEO of the bridesmaids. Mm-hmm. In a way that blew my mind and I went, oh, that's like a skill set.

Speaker 1I was like, whatever.

Speaker 3If I ran a business, like I am hiring you to do all of this. Just some people who are good at getting shit done.

Speaker 1100%. And I think that's why, like the idea.

Speaker 3Of having a CEO who just– comes into your household, comes into your life and just fixes it all up.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Dream.

Speaker 4What do you think, because both of you have like children and you have like houses, I'm just in my studio apartment going, oh my God, this one room is really stressing me out with these floorboards. What do you, like, how would you benefit from that? Because what I've heard from my mum is that she was very similar to me where she didn't like doing any of this stuff. And then she's like, and then I had kids and then I just had to do it. Like you don't have a choice.

Speaker 1You have to do it.

Speaker 2And I always talk about that, about cooking and baking and stuff. Like there's an element of that you just have to do. Like everyone needs feeding every day. Somebody's got to do it.

Speaker 1Here we go. No question. So outsourcing food. Yeah.

Speaker 2If that's not your joy, it might be your joy. Like for me, it's just the chaos of domesticity. When I get home, because often I'm away early in the week, when I get home, Brent's done an amazing job, but the fact that the house is– As I say, the fridge is full of bad leftovers. Things just haven't really happened. We've got no tins of tomatoes or whatever it is. Like when you're in a stress frame of mind that all bubbles up and just makes you go, and.

Speaker 1Everything's out of control and I'm a terrible person and, oh, my God, we're all going to die soon and whatever.

Speaker 3Just because I gave birth doesn't mean that I know how to book doctor's appointments for three children like that and know when the vaccinations are. And the other skill set I don't have is like this child keeps getting bigger and needs new clothes.

Speaker 1I don't want to buy clothes for myself. I don't know what size shoe.

Speaker 3Like I then have to, I don't get a lot of pleasure in that. That I outsource to Mia.

Speaker 1And that's why everyone needs Mia to go, may I buy Luna a new wardrobe? Yes, you may. I will allow you that as the grandmother. She wouldn't be the one to clear out the fridge, though. Not really. Oh, no, no, no. We couldn't expect that of her. No. Outlouders, do eldest daughters always end up with youngest sons?

Speaker 3Every eldest daughter was the first lamb to the slaughter So we all dressed up as wolves and we loved fire.

Speaker 1Are you a firstborn daughter?

Speaker 3Yes. Okay, this question is discriminatory against twins.

Speaker 2It is.

Speaker 1But which one of you is first? Claire. That's right. So no, you're not. Am I the eldest daughter or am I the youngest daughter? I don't know. You're the youngest daughter. You're the youngest daughter. By 20 minutes.

Speaker 2By 20 minutes. Oh, I've got questions about this coming right up. You are the eldest daughter.

Speaker 1I'm the eldest daughter by six years. You're very untrustworthy.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Right. Everything at the moment, and this has been the case for a few years now. is about eldest daughter syndrome. There's a lot of personal essays written about me. Loads.

Speaker 1And songs. Yeah.

Speaker 2I think we don't have to all sit and listen to them, but maybe we'll throw some in. Taylor Swift has written a song about being an eldest daughter. There's a very famous one from Disney's Encanto about being an eldest daughter.

Speaker 1It's a thing.

Speaker 2There are TikToks about it. They're iconic in 2026. Thank you. Yeah, you're iconic. I think my identity is complex because I'm an eldest daughter, but there's only two of us. And I'm the younger one, so I'm also the baby. So it's like those two things cancel each other out a bit.

Speaker 1There's an added eldest daughter, eldest altogether. There's an added element of which is what you are.

Speaker 2So it's a syndrome that was coined on Twitter in 2020. And like all good syndromes, it's not acknowledged.

Speaker 1By doctors at all.

Speaker 2There's no scientific evidence of it, but the vibes.

Speaker 1We know it to be true in our hearts.

Speaker 2So here are some of the traits of an oldest daughter. an intense feeling of responsibility, being an overachiever, type A and very driven, worrying a lot and probably having anxiety, people pleasing, trouble setting and holding boundaries. Maybe I am an eldest daughter. Resentment towards sibling and family, guilt, difficulty in adult relationships. I think those are like the negative bits. Classic eldest daughters, Taylor Swift, Oprah Winfrey, Sheryl Sandberg and Beyonce.

Speaker 1Basically bosses. There we go. Bosses, eldest daughters.

Speaker 2Anyway, Katherine Ryan, the comedian, has a theory. She's written a book about.

Speaker 1Being eldest daughters. That's a very smart thing to do.

Speaker 2It's called Firstborn Daughter, and it's all about that. And she has a theory that eldest daughters always marry youngest sons. Now, that's about straight eldest daughters, obviously. I would love to hear from Outlouders who date women if there's like a youngest daughter thing that this works with as well. The idea is, is the reason that that happens, that oldest daughters marry youngest sons, In the 1950s, psychologists got into this because they were really into birth order. They said, we use the coping styles that we developed with our

Speaker 2siblings as like models for our future relationships. So the pairing works best when the partner's sibling positions fit together. The classic match is the older sister of brothers and the youngest brother of sisters each creates the dynamic that they grow up in.

Speaker 1Interesting. Well, did you know? So Taylor Swift, classic eldest daughter. Yep. Taylor and Travis. Travis, youngest son. Absolutely. Beyonce, Jay-Z, youngest son.

Speaker 3Yes.

Speaker 1It does work. Amal Clooney, eldest daughter. George Clooney, youngest son. Interesting.

Speaker 2The vibes-based thing about this is that firstborns are cast as responsible and achievement-driven. Youngest children are always cast as carefree and adventurous. So the eldest daughter supposedly gets lightness and fun from the youngest son and the youngest son gets stability and care from the eldest daughter. But we know what actually happens here, don't we?

Speaker 1Is they get a household manager.

Speaker 2The eldest daughter just ends up taking care of everybody. Is this ringing true to anybody?

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 3It.

Speaker 4Doesn't really ring true to me. Some elements of it does. In my family dynamic, sometimes people get shocked that I'm older than my sister because she's very much the responsible, quote unquote, sensible one. You've got youngest energy.

Speaker 1Yeah, I've got like younger sibling energy. I'm like, I'm the youngest son.

Speaker 4I'm like chaotic and stressful, but I do feel responsible for her. Like I do sometimes feel like, oh my God, I feel like I'm talking to her like my mum talks to us. And I feel like she's like the thing I protect and she can just do what she wants. She doesn't need to give that back to me.

Speaker 3So a dominant theory in relationships and attachment is that we go towards not necessarily what's good for us, but what is familiar. And we repeat And so if you had a certain relation, you know, there's the old school theory that you'll repeat whatever as a straight woman, whatever relationship you had with your father. If he was absent, you're going to find someone who's emotionally absent. Or if you had a father who was very doting, that's what you're going to expect and vice versa. And I think that this is very true, that eldest daughters... might look

Speaker 3for something that is familiar, which is that people who rely on them or need to be cared for. But the more I read about this dynamic, the more I'm like, I'm not seeing what's in it for the eldest daughter. Like I see what's in it for the youngest son, which is someone who looks after them, does all their shit, provides structure and organization and whatever.

Speaker 1Like bringing a bit of fun just doesn't seem like a fair trade.

Speaker 2Okay. In defense of this, So Brent is the youngest of four. So I am, on paper, I'm the eldest daughter with a youngest son. As I said, my identity is complicated with eldest daughter.

Speaker 1I guess it's true.

Speaker 2I think it's complicated because I'm not the prime parental caretaker because I live here. But it probably, my mum would probably say it was true in that when I was home this year and I was trying to help them out with various.

Speaker 1Things, she's always like, you're so bossy, you're so bossy, you're so bossy.

Speaker 2So I think I do step into that role when I'm allowed to. But I want to stick up for the youngest sons because, sure, it could just mean that you end up being the person who does all of the caretaking. But there is something wonderful about being around somebody who brings you lightness. Like if you're somebody who stresses a lot, who feels a lot of responsibility, who worries about things, there is something that is quite profoundly important about having someone in your life who is like,

Speaker 2it's all right.

Speaker 3Remember we spoke years ago about the– was it the gardener and the something?

Speaker 1Do you remember this? Yeah, what was that? There was this concept which was flower or gardener.

Speaker 3And I wonder if the youngest is almost the flower and gets to be– the fun, rebellious, silly, charismatic, all of those things. And then the eldest daughter is very much the gardener who's the caring. And I suppose I just wonder about the youngest is used to being cared for and having their needs met. And there's a certain power in that, that I just go, I can see how the attraction happens, but I can also see how

Speaker 3when you're in your 50s, 60s, 70s is not very fun anymore.

Speaker 1I agree with that.

Speaker 2But also, Katherine Ryan in particular, she says the eldest daughters are, so the stereotype is that you're high achieving and you're capable and you can look after a lot of people, right? And that brings you stresses and strains. But also, if you match up with somebody who's the same, the power dynamic is hard. Because actually a lot of eldest daughters, and again, we know this is all pop psychology and Taylor Swift songs and whatever, but they also get a lot of self-esteem from being the one who's

Speaker 2in control and being the one who makes the choices and makes the calls and says where we're going and how it's going to work. And if you're with someone else who likes to do all that all the time, that can also be hard. So that could be another reason why. why eldest daughter, youngest son could be positive because youngest son is probably more, or youngest daughter or whatever, is probably more comfy with like, sure, whatever you say.

Speaker 1You know what I mean? And you do need those two attitudes.

Speaker 3The other one that's apparently quite compatible, according to my pop psychology research, are two middle children.

Speaker 1Oh, interesting. Because they're very used to compromise.

Speaker 3Yeah. And, like, kind of going with, I mean, I don't know who'd book the holiday, but they gravitate towards each other as kind of the sandwich child. But twins, I feel like you could write.

Speaker 1A book just on twins. You definitely could.

Speaker 3Because they're just made differently. Like, I don't think that because Claire was born 20 minutes earlier.

Speaker 1Okay, question for you.

Speaker 2Revisiting the 20 minutes thing.

Speaker 3If.

Speaker 2your parents need help with something, which one of you two would they call?

Speaker 1They'd call us both. How can they call you both?

Speaker 2That's so weird.

Speaker 3Well, I don't know.

Speaker 1Is it because you're always together? They'd probably call me and.

Speaker 3Then I wouldn't answer and then they'd call Claire or something. She definitely wouldn't call my brothers. That would be a ludicrous thing to do. But we would probably then get in our group chat and be like, yeah, mum's being annoying. Can you help me? And then we'd kind of bitch enough so that we'd be like, it's your turn. which is why everyone needs, like I think that having siblings is great because you can bitch about your parents privately. But I don't know if that, Claire's probably got a slight more eldest daughter energy in that.

Speaker 1She's a bit more responsible. Is she a little bit more organised? God, no. I don't think we both compete for who's the least organised. As soon as I said that, I suddenly thought, no. Have you seen her?

Speaker 2That energy everybody listen to lady um okay all right well i don't know i want to know from the out loud as if they think this theory has legs if it has legs and if it has like as it and if you've had experience of it and whether it's a good thing or a bad thing and whether it's nonsense.

Speaker 3Yell out some names of men and you tell me whether you think they're the youngest.

Speaker 1Son oh yeah please do adam sandler.

Speaker 3Youngest youngest robin williams mrs doubtfire yes mrs doubtfire not to be confused with robbie williams who.

Speaker 2Is possibly also a youngest son i would guess.

Speaker 3I would guess that there's no way that is an eldest son no way hugh grant uh oldest youngest holly's got it these are all youngest men hugh.

Speaker 2Jackman youngest funny people funny people and show-offs see brent my Brent, is a show-off.

Speaker 1He's such an entertainer.

Speaker 2He is a show-off. And he's, as I say, youngest of four. He's got two brothers and a sister. And he was always, because I think, you know, the classic thing of attention seeking, right? You're the end of the chain. You've got to get your attention from the busy family. And he is such a show off. Prince Harry is such a younger son.

Speaker 3100%.

Speaker 1Such younger son energy.

Speaker 4After the break, our very best recommendations of this week. It is Friday and we want to help set up your weekend with our very best recommendations.

Speaker 1Who wants to go first, Holly?

Speaker 3Me.

Speaker 1I've got quite a basic one this week.

Speaker 2You know, Ashley, I just realised that I did quite a basic one a couple of weeks ago when I recommended The Diplomat.

Speaker 1I'm onto it now.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2I'm recommending another return Netflix series. Better than The Diplomat even.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1Black Doves.

Speaker 3So good. I didn't even know this was coming back. Did you both watch season one of Black Doves?

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1I did. Keira Knightley loved it.

Speaker 2Yes. So if you did, it was a massive smash hit a few years ago, maybe three years ago.

Speaker 1Yeah, I assumed it was a one-off.

Speaker 2Yeah, and basically Keira Knightley plays a spy who is married. You don't know that at the beginning, of course, of season one. She's married, the perfect politician's wife. British, it's set obviously in London. Her husband is a Tory MP. She's got the beautiful children and the beautiful house, but you quite quickly realise she has this whole other life, right? Classic spy story. And season two, her husband's actually the prime minister now. What makes this show so amazing, though,

Speaker 2is the dynamic, in my opinion, between Keira and Ben Whishaw, who is the guy who plays Sam. So Keira is Helen and Ben Whishaw is Sam. He is her co-assassin, like the guy who taught her about spying. And he's very troubled and very adorable. And if you can't remember who Ben Whishaw is, all parents need to know he's the voice.

Speaker 1Of Paddington Bear.

Speaker 2We were watching this show, Bread Night, and it's really violent. It can be quite violent, this show, and it's dark. Like, poor Sam is going through a lot. And Matilda was walking through the room, you know, doing her nighttime whatever. And she was just like, that's Paddington Bear. Just as he blew somebody's head off.

Speaker 1And she was like, my goodness. But it is great. The season two is just as good. It is fast.

Speaker 2There are some new characters who bring loads of color and energy. But that central relationship, the friendship of Helen and Sam, I think is the heart of the show.

Speaker 1It's really interesting. And I reckon it's Keira Knightley's best performance ever. I agree.

Speaker 2She has got better and better. And she is so good in this. So I'm very happy it's back. Are all the episodes there?

Speaker 1I think they are.

Speaker 3Yes, they are.

Speaker 1I think you can binge because I have already watched four.

Speaker 3Fabulous.

Speaker 1And that was in two nights. It's good. That's next after The Diplomat for me.

Speaker 3Netflix.

Speaker 4Sorry, it's on Netflix. Netflix, all episodes. I want to recommend a product. So I was staying at my parents' house. It was like a last-minute sleepover and I didn't have anything on me and I went into their bathroom. And for the first time ever, my skin's got really dry. Like I think they say youthful people have really oily skin and now I'm clearly not youthful people. So now my skin's gone really dry.

Speaker 1I'm having a moment about that.

Speaker 4I'm having a big moment about it. Like it's quite obvious. Like people are looking at me going.

Speaker 1Do you think they are though?

Speaker 4I think they are because I've been asked a lot like what moisturizer do you use? And then it's kind of in the sense of like I know you're not using one. You probably should.

Speaker 1And I'm like, okay.

Speaker 4But I was in my parents' room in their bathroom, and my dad had this product. It's the Aveeno Skin Relief Repairing Balm. And I'm putting my dad on blast here because it says on the bottle, for dry, cracked, and sensitive skin.

Speaker 1And I used it, and it literally.

Speaker 4Lasted me a whole day and a half. Like, I looked like I had glowy.

Speaker 2On your face.

Speaker 1You used it on your face.

Speaker 4I used it on my neck and my arms and my hands. But you can use it on your face as well. So it's like an all-purpose balm. And it's not greasy.

Speaker 1I've used it too. I've used it on my hands mostly. It's nice. Because I get really dry.

Speaker 2Hands and like dry skin on my fingers and it is really good.

Speaker 1It is really good. When you go to your parents' house, do you feel like what's theirs is yours? Like did you just take that home? 100%. I just go through rooms and just take shit.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1It is the best. Yeah. I like to take like containers, like stuff in their lounge room, candles. It's so good.

Speaker 4I saw you can get it for around $ 15. I did take my dad's, so I.

Speaker 1Didn't buy it. But you can get it for around $ 15. Your poor dad, he's there going like. I need something for my dry, cracked skin. I swear I bought it.

Speaker 2It was here.

Speaker 1It was right there.

Speaker 4I do have to say, though, that Aveeno is a Mamma Mia client. So you might have heard ads on our network, but this is not a sponsored recommendation.

Speaker 3Okay, but your dad probably bought it because of the ads. I think my dad listened to the podcast and then bought it from the ads. So roundabout, your dad was influenced by the ads. But I am going through a dermatitis era.

Speaker 1Oh, yeah.

Speaker 3And I am looking for products. There are very specific products you can use on skin that's flaring up and that's one of them.

Speaker 1Yeah, because it's just like oats or something.

Speaker 3Yeah, and like acetophil and a QV. Like they're the ones that I have to keep.

Speaker 1The classics. Yeah, they're just your reliable ones.

Speaker 2I never could go back to my ring. I don't know if you excitedly remember when I got my favourite big blue ring gave me eczema.

Speaker 4Every time we're in the studio, I always look at your hand to see if you're wearing the ring and you never are.

Speaker 2Well, because I went back to it for a bit and it just came straight back again.

Speaker 1So I'm very sad about that.

Speaker 2Maybe the Aveeno might be the same.

Speaker 1Yes, it's a good idea. Jessie, what do you have?

Speaker 3I have a book because for the last month I've been reading this really thick, really long book called Theo of Golden, which is great.

Speaker 2Everybody's been talking about that.

Speaker 1Are we recommending that? We are not recommending that today.

Speaker 2Would you recommend that?

Speaker 3I would recommend that book to someone who reads a lot. It is not something that if you want to tear through something and read it quick and... It's long and it's slow.

Speaker 2It was a publishing sensation because it was a self-published book by a guy in America. And then I think the story goes that his daughter or his granddaughter was like, we can market this for you, Dad. And it's gone viral. Like now time's bestseller. Isn't it sort of spiritual and it's about living a good life?

Speaker 3It's stunning in that it's about an old man who goes to this town.

Speaker 1You don't know why he's turned up there. He's in a cafe.

Speaker 3He sees that there are portraits all over the walls and he decides to embark on this project where he finds the person who the image is of and gifts it to them. And it's about finding out about those stories but also why is this man here and why is he so interested in portraits? It's like it's about life and little good deeds.

Speaker 1That's really cool.

Speaker 4But that's not even what we're recommending. And his children marketed it. Who says Gen Z doesn't work these days?

Speaker 2I know.

Speaker 3After I read that, I thought, okay, I want something that I'm going to like tear through that's really sort of reliable. And I kept seeing in all the best books of all time lists. A Thousand Splendid Suns by Khaled Hosseini. And I remember 20 years ago reading The Kite Runner. Can't tell you what happened, but I remember it being one of my favourites ever. So I went, okay, I'm going to sit down and read that book.

Speaker 1A page, I'm in.

Speaker 3And it is about two, it's set in Kabul in Afghanistan and it follows two women over decades.

Speaker 1And I kind of.

Speaker 3Knew about the Soviets and then there was a monarchy at one stage and then the Taliban rule and My favourite way to learn about history is through fiction where I just learn how, it doesn't feel like I'm learning, but these two women's lives, how impacted they are by the warring, you know, governments and everything and how it impacts their literal lives.

Speaker 1It is so good.

Speaker 3It's an obvious thing to say, but I just keep thinking reading this that the the most random thing and the greatest stroke of luck is where in the world you're born and when in the world you are born in that society.

Speaker 1And it's so.

Speaker 3humanizing and insightful but basically these two women and what rights they have how one year they could walk down the street and go to the cinema and whatever and then the Taliban send out this decree basically and what it does to to their lives it's fascinating it's so powerful and I haven't had a book in a while where I walk around my day and I'm thinking about it and I'm like what's gonna happen to that character like it's just my running monologue.

Speaker 2Can I ask you a question You're reading these on Kindle? Yes, I'm reading that on Kindle. Because I was like, you know how you said I saw it on lots of lists of the best books of all time? It's an interesting thing that like if you are, and Outloud is often going in the group and saying, I need a book too. And they'll be like, get me out of a reading slump or get me through a hard time or that's easy, that's whatever. And I think that those kind of lists, even though as a writer, I'm a bit like me about them because I'm like.

Speaker 1Who gets on those lists?

Speaker 2But it's a really good place to, like, stretch your reading capacity. Yeah, and I also– And then if you do– if you are reading digitally, it's very easy to then test it rather than necessarily– I mean, I'm always going to advocate buying books.

Speaker 1Do not get me wrong. But you can read a few chapters and go, is this for me?

Speaker 2But you can go, do I like this? And then decide how you're going to read it.

Speaker 3And I realise that what I've been doing is reading every hyped book of the year. Yes.

Speaker 1And that's great, but it's a particular type of concept.

Speaker 3100%.

Speaker 1And this is 20 years old.

Speaker 3Yep.

Speaker 1It's one of the best books for a reason. It's a moment in time. It's history. And it's like there are so many books that have been written that we just forget. Yeah.

Speaker 3So to refine this one, there's so many out louders that are going, oh, my God, I read this 20 years ago.

Speaker 1Read it again. It's just so, so good. I'm learning so much. I love it. A Thousand Splendid Suns. Thank you, Jessie Stephens. What an excellent recommendation.

Speaker 2That is all we have time for on Mamma Mia Out Loud.

Speaker 1This week, friends. Take your dry skin. Pack your bags. off you go. I'm off on my girls weekend. So lucky.

Speaker 2I know.

Speaker 1And we will see you all on Monday.

Speaker 2Massive thank you to our Out Loud team, as always, for getting us through the week.

Speaker 1This weekend is our issue with the mercury in the retrograde. It's about to end. Things are about to get very good, ladies. Holly booked her weekend away around it. I did. Last year on my weekend away I got my first tattoo. She's going to come back with a face tattoo.

Speaker 2Because it was raining. So if it is raining this weekend, maybe just a.

Speaker 1Couple of little things, little stars maybe. Holly, you know what you should get?

Speaker 3You know how the other week we were talking about Ethan Klein and how he has a tattoo of his wife?

Speaker 1Yes. You should get Brent's face on your thigh. Elderly boyfriend. Elderly boyfriend. Brent's face would look like a really bad picture. I need it on an appropriately wrinkly bit of skin.

Speaker 3Yes.

Speaker 1Yes, exactly.

Speaker 3And you can pull his face in different directions so that you can make him smile, frown.

Speaker 1That's so funny.

Speaker 2Okay, don't get love, but not have any margaritas.

Speaker 1I'll totally be doing that. We'll see you on.

Speaker 2Monday, everybody.

Speaker 3Bye.

Speaker 1Bye.

Speaker 2See you. Too many recos are never enough recos. And for those of you who love this bit of Friday's show, I have the best news. We are making a whole show that's just about recos. Out Loud Recos is dropping this Sunday, first episode. Mia's hosting it. This first episode has me, Keisha, M. Vernon, and a special guest, sharing our favorite recos. It's going to drop every month. There

Speaker 2is an Instagram account and there is going to be a special newsletter coming to all Substack subscribers. So if you need another reason to subscribe to the Mamma Mia Out Loud Substack, here it is. It's going to list all the recos, including the ones from the show. And it starts this week and it couldn't be more exciting. Outloud Reckos is dropping in your normal Outloud feed. So it will just, if you follow us, and of course you do, if you follow us, it will pop up in your feed on Sunday.

Speaker 3Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Revenge Podcast Gossip & The New Morning Routine

    Nov 20, 202644 minAudio

    Diana's cheating ex went on a podcast (sort of) with Elton John. Yesterday on subs we spoke about forgiving cheaters if enough time has passed and it appears that Elton listened and has decided to let bygones be...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. FREE SUBS TASTER: If You Find The Love Of Your Life, Is It Okay To Cheat?

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    Outlouders, enjoy this free taster of Amelia Lester, Emily Vernem & Keeshia Pettit on our subscriber-only episode. You can listen to the full conversation here: If You Find The Love Of Your Life, Is It Okay To Cheat? So...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Bond Girl Maths & ‘Don’t Call From The Car’

    Nov 18, 202650 minAudio

    If your colleague started sniffling or had a mystery headache today, prepare for them to call in sick tomorrow. ‘GTA flu’ is going around, and the gamers need some time to themselves. An AFLW game that took place over...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Prenups, 'Midnups' & Cheating Billionaires

    Nov 16, 202632 minAudio

    Imagine getting an all-staff memo from your boss admitting he was unfaithful to his wife of 41 years. That’s what staff at Nvidia received from CEO Jensen Huang, and the story has since turned into an international...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Introducing: Out Loud Reccos, An Entire Episode Of Things We Love

    Nov 14, 202636 minAudio

    Welcome to the first ever episode of Out loud Reccos - the show where Mia Freedman and the Out loud hosts tell you exactly what they've bought, watched, read and tried, and whether it was worth it. In this episode: how...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode