Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Scott describes the process of making a 7-inch record in detail. He talks with KJ of The Oddysy, who has some questions as The Oddysy ventures into the world of vinyl for the first time. Making a record of your own? Your music deserves the best. Learn more about Masterdisk here. Support The Oddysy here, and listen to "Bang Bang" here.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome to Making Vinyl at MasterDisc. I'm Scott Hall, the owner and chief engineer of MasterDisc in New York. What you just heard was Bang Bang by the Odyssey. And here with me today is KJ from the Odyssey to talk about the band's first venture into the world of vinyl.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the thing we're talking about at the moment is uh we we want to start out with uh uh uh seven inch. Um we want to do our our first single um we just dropped called Bang Bang uh with uh Chuck D from Public Enemy. On the other side, we want to put our second single, which is called Rage of Love. And so um, you know, we're talking about doing this as sort of a promotional, you know, kind of raising money for the band uh uh kind of thing. We're gonna do a full, you know, full 12-inch record later, but you know, we want to start out with this. So I'm a little in the dark, to be honest with you, about uh about how the whole process works.
SPEAKER_01So the first question I have is we need to do, you know, obviously this is an Indie Act. We're on a we're on a budget like most Indyacts. Um, so we want to save money where we can, but we don't want to cut out too much of the quality. Um so my first question to you is we'd like to do a short run and we want to do it in multiple colors. Is that kind of thing even possible?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, some of the plants will let you do that. Um we've got to be careful that we don't let the that we press enough copies. I mean, a short run so that you can kind of test the waters with uh with vinyl, you know, kind of makes a lot of sense. But unlike with CDs, vinyl, there's so many upfront costs, one-time charges. Um the mastering, the cutting, the plating, the setups, the artwork setups, the the proofs for the artwork, um the printing uh minimum quantities and things.
SPEAKER_00So if you get some plants will allow you to print as few as a hundred copies, but the cost per copy is so high that unless you're selling these things with a huge markup, um it's gonna be a you're gonna lose money. And the sort of the worst thing that can happen is you can end up selling out your record, not making any money, and and not having any other any more records. Right. So um I know nobody wants to have boxes of records sitting around, but um they do move pretty well.
SPEAKER_00I mean, if you're if you're playing performances and if you're out in the public, they you know they they really do move pretty well, especially hand signed, especially customized uh versions of them. So my first recommendation is usually to, you know, not go at the very minimum quantity, but to keep a close eye on what the per cost charge is. Well, is there, in your opinion, is there a sweet spot? Well, for seven inch, it's two or three hundred is is really should be where you start. You can just look at the cost per disc. It changes with it, it's different with every plant, but uh a s short sort of rule of thumb is it's gonna cost you almost as much to make 200 as it costs you to make 100.
SPEAKER_00So the cost per disc is gonna be nearly half. Um if you can find any justification for you know adding another hundred to your total, um, then each copy is going to be less expensive and you're going to be a little more free with letting you know certain people, important people in the business, that you want to have this record, you're gonna be a little you're gonna have more ability to give them away or to make them as promotions or to buy promo copies, send to radio stations, managers, that kind of thing. Yeah, I mean the whole thing about vinyl is that it's this cool format, and you want to get it in as many people's hands as possible.
SPEAKER_00I'm not trying to just talk people into spending more money. It's just you gotta spend it smart.
SPEAKER_01Well, but yeah, but smart is the key. I mean, it you know, if it's gonna be ten dollars to into make a hundred and twelve dollars to make two hundred, you're you're insane to make a hundred, right? I mean it you find the extra two bucks, right?
SPEAKER_00It it really is. It really is the case. You you could literally find um um a sponsor um or another band that wants to go together with you to make a record and you guys could split the cost. So if you wanted to do a single but you knew somebody else that wanted to do a single, um, a band that you tour with, or that that works really, really well if you guys are going to be in the same shop and and you've got kind of the same audience.
SPEAKER_01That's actually a really good idea. I mean, you know, splitting the cost between the two projects and having something. I mean, like you said, if you go on tours with somebody, you you know, you sell it at a at the merch table and everybody makes out.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And well, you can do whatever you want with the with the profits, but you can you can use that justification to order twice as many copies. So now each copy you profit from uh everybody profits from better. I mean, it's just simple it's just simple business logic. It's it's just not the first thing musicians tend to think about.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Well, so okay, so the other part of my question is um, you know, I mean I and I'm a vinyl fanatic like you, and um, and one of my favorite things is when I, you know, I open up the uh the jacket and slide out something that's you know orange or purple or marbled or something. Um is it possible for me to do that on a short run with a seven-inch desk?
SPEAKER_00It it depends on the plant. Some will accommodate, uh, some won't. On the automated presses, it takes quite a long time for one color to be removed from the press to clean out the first color and for the new color to make its way into the mold. And that's downtime as far as the press operator is concerned. And so they charge a premium for that or a second, they charge an additional setup charge for that. It's it's not impossible, but it's it just adds to the cost. Um, hand pressed records are kind of in the vogue in certain pressing plants, and in those cases, every one of them is a manual as a manual step, and they it's it's really cool to watch.
SPEAKER_00They literally take a handful of colored pellets and put them on the press and you know, scatter them, you know, in a particular way. And so each record, each individual pressing is a one-off, you know, sort of a piece of art, uh, as it were. Um and um wait, so somebody interacts with every single copy that that goes to the street. Yeah, that's that's the cool part of it. It they they are handmade records. Um there are two kinds of presses out there. There's the the the one meant to automate you know large scale productions, and another that's um small footprint that uses more manual labor.
SPEAKER_00And those are the kind that you can actually do. You have more opportunity to you know really customize the process. You know, it adds to the cost, but then those those records are are are truly unique. It's it's almost you've got a few different options. I mean, you could literally press up a few of another color and make them sort of like the golden ticket kind of records, or you can set aside the premium ones and offer those, you know, autographed or or customized in some way and offer those um to your fans as a as a premium item or as an endorsement uh you know kind of item or to thank your fans.
SPEAKER_01Right, absolutely. I mean it turns into a a sort of a marketing exercise, you know, giving this thing a little bit more value than it might have inherently if you were just gonna pick up a single at the store.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, and and and then I think you talked about doing part of your run in a in standard look, standard feel, and and part of your order in a uh in a custom uh view. And I I think that that works. It's it's gonna kind of balance the the costs um, you know, uh about it. The good news is by and large, these days, anything but the translucent colors, pretty much all of the opaque colors are gonna sound really close to as good as as black vinyl. Wait, wait, wait. There's a difference in sound for color?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Oh yeah. Oh, it hit me. Well, I I can't really speak too well of the science of it, but the chemical nature of translucent um PVC is that it interacts differently with the molds, and it, you know, it has more inherent surface noise than black vinyl. Really? Historically, black vinyl had some um lead in it as well and some other heavy metals that made it slippery or and made it sound quieter.
SPEAKER_00We've you know, all of the modern formulations have removed all or most of all of those toxins, but the the colors just simply are made from a different chemical composition. In a blind test, you can often tell the difference between a black disc and a colored disc, but it it's very subtle, professional, in a quiet studio, you can kind of tell the difference. Most people can kind of tell the difference between a black vinyl and a translucent, but the difference is still there, you know, you've really got to weigh it against the hip factor. I um it's not it's not the end of the end of the world.
SPEAKER_00It's it's just a little bit noisier. Um and you have to take it into consideration. There's a there's a really good reason why uh 180 gram, you know, heavyweight audiophile discs are done on black vinyl, because that that's the best that we have available.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. No, it makes sense when you explain it. I think it's kind of you know, it's hysterical to me that, you know, this thing that I love, you know, this thrill that I get when I take out a purple record from the thing, and I'm actually kind of you know screwing myself on sound quality a little bit. And for that matter, didn't you show me ages ago, didn't you do Donald Fagan's uh new record sunken condos? And can't you see through that thing like perfectly?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they did that in a clear picture disc format, and uh it's sort of baffling to me. For some reason, clear with no color can sound amazing. But translucent colors in in general um have a lot of things.
SPEAKER_01Oh wait, so he didn't screw himself because I mean Donald's like notorious, notorious for like it sounds gorgeous.
SPEAKER_00I mean the thing is it it blew my mind. I was concerned about it when he when when they told me it was gonna be a picture disc because uh historically picture disks sound terrible. Uh basically they you know they put a a a piece of art, you know, a piece of artwork, a paper, underneath the inside the press, and then they put the clear PVC on down on top of it and press the grooves into the clear. But in this case, um it wasn't really a picture disc. Um they left the piece of paper out and you can actually see through the record. I mean it's it's like grooves on one side, and you look through the grooves, and you can see the backs of the grooves from the other side.
SPEAKER_00It's it's it's kind of trippy. When it's spinning, it's definitely pretty trippy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I need to get myself a copy.
SPEAKER_00But it sounds it actually really sounds good. I mean, good audiophile good. I don't know of too many plants doing that, so um you really have to look for that particular style, um, that particular um uh type. And and I know they spent extra money to make that sound good and look good.
SPEAKER_01I'm sure, and it was probably worth it. So, but let's talk about let's go back to the non-moneyed people like me. Um so um, you know, obviously we're on a budget here, you know, the band's just you know getting its C legs kind of thing. So uh in your opinion, uh, you know, there's there's gotta be there's gotta be a um well, I won't say there's gotta be. Is there a way to save a little money on this process, you know, your first time out without sacrificing quality, without sacrificing the, you know, I mean the the the whole point of this thing is to sound good, but also that you know money is finite.
SPEAKER_01Where in this process can you shave off a little bit of cash?
SPEAKER_00There are three really kind of important steps. The cut, the original disc master that's cut um for your record is vital. That i it's not hard to imagine if you're gonna make five hundred of something, that the initial mold that you make for that those five hundred things has to be pretty damn good because there's no way that the product's gonna be any better than that that mold that you make. Right. And that mold, uh metal mold in this case, that is what uh the vinyl records are made from, that is a a piece of metal created from the master lacquer that's that's cut.
SPEAKER_00That's what we do in it at MasterDisc, is we we cut the master disc. That's actually how we got our name many, many years ago. The master disc is cut at Master Disc. It's an expensive part of the process because we've got you know top-notch machinery, we've got experience, we've got demand. You know, it's there's only so many ways that you can, you know, discount uh that service, but it's really, really crucial. I have to say that um most of my it new independent clients for cutting come from clients that have tried to do it inexpensive really inexpensively before and were so disappointed with the way their record turned out.
SPEAKER_00Um some of them just abandoned the project altogether, and others just you know said to themselves, we're not doing it that way next time.
SPEAKER_01We're gonna So they basically just threw the money away on a on a cheaper process and had to spend more money having you do it better.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it happens too often. Um it's it's the kind of thing that the brokers never tell you about this because they want you to that's want you to feel that it's gonna be a simple process. You send the send your files after mastering off to somebody, and they magically come back as records.
SPEAKER_02Here we go again, check it out. We're gonna win, like it's all in. What's the miracle? Did you make the miracle? How other people stay followed for now. What you wanna do? What it can save you. You still want to listen to the list of paradigm. That's why they got me in the stomach, but it's the wax at 2520. Never had a gun.
SPEAKER_00This isn't how the process used to be done. The process, you know, um in the 70s and 80s was closely managed. The producer, you know, communicated with the the cutting engineer and uh made sure that that cut record was exactly the way they wanted it to sound because they knew the rest of the process has some potential for flaws, um, you know, ticks and pops and noises and manufacturing problems and things like that. And the only way to to to hope to get a great sounding product is to start with a great sounding master.
SPEAKER_00So it's not one of the ways that you want to save money, in my opinion. You um and that goes hand in hand with the advice that you're gonna get and the the the care and handling, you know, the the uh fiduciary uh responsibility to use a big word uh that you're gonna get from an independent cutter um is huge. And I can't explain this enough until someone's actually gone through the process and had it fail for them. Then they can relate to just how how alone they felt out in the wilderness listening to the record trying and thinking, wow, this really doesn't sound great.
SPEAKER_00But the people from the planet are telling me, well, they all this is how they all sound, and it's both this is as good as it's gonna get, and they're they're forced to just sort of believe it and move forward until they bump into somebody who's had a different experience and they can and they can share their uh share their experiences. So I contend it happens to be my job, um, but I contend that you save money by hiring somebody to do that first part of the process right as somebody who can then also guide you through the process to help you save time and money on all the other steps.
SPEAKER_01Well, sure. If you only have to do the whole thing once, it's gonna be cheaper than trying it once paying for it, failing, and then paying somebody else to do it. I mean, it makes perfect sense.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there aren't a whole lot of other places where we will we'll take that chance. I mean, we w we all know better than to buy the the$3.99 sushi. We just we just know that that's not gonna be good.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, been there.
SPEAKER_00And we paid the price for trying, you know, two days later you're still paying for it.
SPEAKER_01Right, exactly.
SPEAKER_00But with but you know, with stuff that's less tangible, um it's it's harder for people to understand what that quality difference means. Because few very, very few people will go through the process, you know, in in parallel and then compare the results. In other words, you know, your record's you know, being cut here and being done professionally and it's gonna be uh optimized through the process. If you had not taken that advice and made that same record um through you know the a standard discount factory environment um and compared the end results, you would have no question that the money was well spent.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I literally have to justify that extra expenditure to all of my clients every day, or they just don't ever come back.
SPEAKER_01Gotcha.
SPEAKER_00But I didn't answer your question, of course. I talked on and on about ways to do that.
SPEAKER_01Answer my damn question. Let me point you in a direction. Talk to me about test pressings. It's a small run, it's a seven-inch. I mean, do I need them? Do I not need them?
SPEAKER_00You know, I I don't ever want to tell people to not get a test pressing, but on a really short run, it's it's kind of like warranty replacement insurance on something that's only$80 to begin with. It's like the cost of the insurance is gonna add up to more than you know the cost of the item. It just seems foolish to spend uh money when it's such a small run. That said, if you're up against the deadline and you you know that those records are gonna come out of the plant and go right into important people's hands, you know, reviewers and fans and such, you you really need to know what that is.
SPEAKER_00But test pressings on a seven-inch single uh platform are probably the only place where I could really say you're not taking an enormous risk. But let me preface that carefully by saying you gotta know it's been cut right and cut well. Um can I there's some misconception within the uh within the biz about the difference between a test reference disc that's cut by the master engineer and a test pressing. Um and I'll spend a second just describing the two. When I receive the files and cut them into a a lacquer, um I can make a reference disc and I do that for test and analysis and for quality control before I make the final master.
SPEAKER_00And so those lacquer disks are are um cut and played back from top to bottom and visually inspected to make sure that they're in good that they're perfect. Um and then um when I do finally send the master lacquer to the plant, the plant makes a test pressing and sends it back to the to the customer, hopefully also to me for evaluation. That test pressing it does not replace the function of the reference, and the reference doesn't replace the function of the test pressing. They really have two different purposes.
SPEAKER_00And on an album project, I highly, I highly recommend it. Actually, not getting a test pressing is is pretty foolish on an album project because the the cost of of of remaking them after they've already been packaged and uh and shipped is is is just too much to bear. You really have to know that that record is in good shape. Most plants will actually um test pressings aren't really optional. But in a seven-inch, I I I think uh you're not taking a big risk in this case. I've also let me uh uh clarify, in this case, we're also working with a plant that I've hand chosen uh that I have good faith in.
SPEAKER_00And I know that this plant is going to check your pressings in-house and alert us if they find something that's gonna be a problem. So we don't have to go through the expense of them packaging up the test pressings and shipping them to you. Um, but I'm I'm I'm I also um if you don't have that kind of relationship with your cutter or with your with your plant, then you probably should have test pressings.
SPEAKER_01Right, right. That makes sense. Um okay, let's um let's talk about weight. Um so all my favorite records, um, you know, the the best ones in my collection, colored or black, they're all they're all nice and heavy. They feel good in my hand, you know, 180 gram, I guess, or possibly more if there's such a thing. I'm wondering, you know, is there do people do that on a seven inch like I'm doing, or is there any point to it?
SPEAKER_00I don't I have seen ho um heavyweight seven inches. I don't personally think that there's a substantial increase in quality. As recent as twenty years ago or so, thirty years ago, when seven inches were were popular. Um a lightweight seven inch was a cheaper alternative, and they uh they were almost always warped and they didn't stand up very well in your collection. But what they're doing today, the standard weight of both a seven inch or of a twelve inch is heavy enough to be a substantial and good uh feeling uh record.
SPEAKER_00To be honest, I'm not exactly sure of the gram number. It's it actually a hundred and eighty gram disc is because it literally weighs 180 grams when it's when it comes off the press, and that's how it they um they adjust the press to um allow more material in and it's it's heavier.
SPEAKER_01But that's 180 grams that's a 12-inch disc.
SPEAKER_00Yes, uh a seven inch would be a smaller number, but it's it's uh the relative thickness is still um appropriate. I I kind of see people that have pressed a seven inch or pressed a single before and had problems with warping, you know, the next time they do a seven-inch or a single, they'll they'll increase the weight to see if they can get something that doesn't warp. I think the warping um issue has more to do with the quality control at the plant than it really has to do with the weight. In in private conversations with the plants, most of them are enthusiastic about making 180 gram um final LPs, but they um they all agree, and I think agree publicly that the 140 or 150 gram standard absolutely sounds great and is adequate and uh and gets the job done.
SPEAKER_00But I will say that I believe the consumer feels that the hundred and eighty gram record feels more substantial and they're more excited about the collectibility of it. And uh and I gotta say, I agree. And then there's This interesting thing that happens. If you decide to spend the extra money on a 180 gram vinyl record, you pick your master engineer carefully, you do the extended QC, you get reference discs, you get test pressings, you you you even maybe fire your pressing plant and send and have new leckers cut if they can't produce a good product for you.
SPEAKER_00You're making, after all, you're making a hundred and eighty gram beautiful hi-fi you know statement, a piece of art. Um and so it's my opinion that what makes 180 gram vinyl records different is because they're produced with more care and more quality control.
SPEAKER_01No, no, it makes perfect sense. You're actually talking about the psychology of the of the artist and the you know their their intent, you know, their their attention to detail and their you know their desire to put something out that's you know above average.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. It has less to do with the weight of the disc and more to do with this the the intention of the release. But let's go back to the other extreme. There's plenty of uh records produced these days that are more or less made for for collectibility, for can for consumption of of the artwork and to have and hold something f physical that means something to you. And I've heard the discussions um uh from some labels and artists that they just don't feel that it's justified spending a lot of time worrying about the sound quality of their project.
SPEAKER_00They're in their particular instance, they're they're making an art statement, a collectible. Um so there are instances when it might make sense to cut corners and uh and not go through the the to the um to the extremes. But the people that come to me, by and large, almost really to a man, are um are already concerned with quality. They've chosen uh MasterDisc for uh for a reputation to actually to master the record, master their song to begin with.
SPEAKER_00I already know they're very interested in how the record's gonna sound. They want a fan to love it, they want a reviewer to love it and to comment on it, they want people to like it on social media. They're so uh how it looks and how it sounds is is is vital. Is almost what's the point of doing it unless they do it well.
SPEAKER_01Right. Absolutely, absolutely makes perfect sense. All right. Um here's my last question. We're gonna end it off by talking about my hole. Uh excuse me. Not that hole. So um I have a choice, uh, as my research has shown, between a big hole in my seven-inch or a small hole. Oh, that's right. What's your opinion? That hole. By what criteria am I supposed to make that decision?
SPEAKER_00Well, uh boy, ask five people, you'll get six different opinions. Okay. Um what's yours? Um, a large hole 45, a large hole disc tells everyone that this is a 45 RPM disc, in my opinion. Um, a small hole 45 asks the question, is this a 33 or is it a 45 disc? But DJs will give you a different opinion on that because I'm sure they hate losing those little adapters that go inside the 45 so that they can put them on their on their player.
SPEAKER_00There's also a substantial consideration that I think the wow of you know, the off-centerness of a record um is kind of made worse with the large hole because you're now dealing with a uh you know an adapter and some of them fit tight and some of them don't.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I see. Okay, yeah, yeah. That makes sense.
SPEAKER_00So a small hole, a small hole, um, you know, 45 can be thrown down on a DJ table without him having to even think about it. But you know, yeah, obviously it should be labeled uh well so that it it doesn't start at the at the wrong speed. Uh by the way, your side A sounds freaking awesome at 33 instead of 45. We uh we found that out by accident when I went to test to a test cut. It's very very white. I love it. It definitely should be the beginnings of a remix for that too.
SPEAKER_01Seriously. Well, seeing as how the um the adapter that came with my record player, I I think my cat pushed it under the the the couch or something, so I think maybe the small hole is the way to go.
SPEAKER_00Um I think um, you know, your band uh you know your ensemble includes a DJ, so um, you know, he's he should weigh in on that too. Um I guess I should ask him. Yeah, Juice probably has an input. And I I'm I'm almost certain his answer is small, small hole because probably. Otherwise, you know, you pick Sebket up and he goes, damn it, another big hole. Where the hell's my adapter?
SPEAKER_01Well, that's all the questions I have. Any parting shots of advice for me before I journey into the land of seven-inch vinyl?
SPEAKER_00No, it's uh it's it's uh uh the water's great. Come on in. You know, it's uh it's uh it's it's fun to see people interact, you know, with music in a way that's really constructive and really creative. Um to take uh you know their music and have it be substantial again, have it be something that they're excited to give somebody. I mean, sending somebody a file, you know, just it doesn't have anywhere near as the uh the sex appeal, uh the you know, the the groove appeal of of of a seven-inch of a piece of kidding.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and um it's it doesn't seem to be going away. It doesn't seem to be uh tapering off at all. Um, you know, the major retailers have all got on board, they all have replaced their CD racks with vinyl racks. You know, it's not the heyday of the of the 70s and 80s where we sold millions of records, but it's it's interesting now because you know, uh an indie artist, you know, with um the beginnings of a of a strong social media you know following can produce a few hundred records and get the word out and get people excited about the record.
SPEAKER_00So it's um right it's um democratized now. It's it's it's like anybody can really do it and it's not that expensive. But if you want to do it well, if you want if you if you want to do it for the purpose of sounding good and sounding like a record, definitely find out who's cutting your record and what their background is and talk to them because that will get you your best sounding record.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. All right.
SPEAKER_00Cool, man. A lot of fun. Cool. So thanks for listening, folks. If you've got any vinyl questions you'd like to answer, please send them over to MasterDisc. This is making vinyl at MasterDisc.
SPEAKER_00Hello, and welcome to Making Vinyl at Master Desktop. I'm Scott Hall, owner, and my headphones are fell off my head. I don't want to wear them.
Send us Fan Mail A song can be a product, or it can be a place you go to tell the truth. We head off campus into Hudson Valley songwriter Michele Gedney’s home studio and talk about the moments that changed her creative...
Send us Fan Mail Masterdisk's Scott Hull talks with Vetren Disk Cutting and mastering engineer Kevin Gray. Keven is well know for decades of work in mastering some of vinyl-s best sounding LPs and re-issues. This...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Scott talks with Dave O'donnell. A well known producer, mixer, engineer who is known for his work with James Taylor, Keith Richards, John Mayer, Eric Clapton, Sheryl Crow, and many...
Send us Fan Mail Scott talks to Witek Wolny about his song "Fran" and the production of the song as well as the making of the music video. Links to Witek and the song "Fran":...
Send us Fan Mail Groove Oddities - Show Notes Making Vinyl @ Masterdisk Podcast Host: Scott Hull, Chief Engineer at Masterdisk Episode Overview In this fascinating episode, Scott Hull explores the weird and wonderful...