Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Making Vinyl @ Masterdisk

Making Vinyl @ Masterdisk artwork

How Much Music fits on a Record?

Oct 9, 201938 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail Everyone knows that you can only fit 20 mins of music on a record side? OH... really? Not according to Scott Hull - Chief cutting engineer at Masterdisk. With help from KJ of the Oddysy- Scott debunks the common myths and explains WHY - some projects need to be edited to fit on to vinyl and some do not. How much music fits ont he side of a record >? " It depends.,,," Making a record of your own? Your music deserves the best. Learn more about Masterdisk here. Support The Oddysy here. Music heard: Lettuce - FLY - Listen to Lettuce on Spotify Lettuce on FB: https://www.facebook.com/LettuceFunk/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello again and welcome to Making Vinyl at MasterDisc. I'm here today with KJ, the Odyssey. Hello, hello. Amen. And uh we're gonna have a great conversation today because this is the question that I'm asked the most, and it's uh actually one of the hardest questions to answer. How much time really fits on the side of a record?

SPEAKER_00I'm betting there's a short answer and a long answer.

SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, and what most people read online is the short answer that you your music shouldn't go over twenty minutes, and so they take that at face value. And uh the long answer is you you really need to have a conversation with whoever's cutting your record to find out what they think they're comfortable with putting on a record.

SPEAKER_00It sounds to me like the short answer is it depends.

SPEAKER_01Well, it all depends. It depends it it depends on on many different factors, and we'll we'll try to go over them uh in in detail. But I'm I'm really kind of giving away the bunch line here at uh at the beginning, because if you know who's cutting your record and you're in communication with them, um they'll help you make this decision. If you've chosen someone to cut your record, you need to trust that they're going to have your best interest in mind, at least at least hope that they have your best interest in mind.

SPEAKER_01Uh what what typically happens, people call me and ask me, you know, can I put 28 minutes on the side of a record? And they hear the, you know, my first answer is like, well, yeah, sort of, and then they don't listen to the whole rest of all of the other drawbacks or the pitfalls of of what's going to happen. Um they're just so motivated to get all that music on the side of a record, and and there's good reason. Back in the day, we started with singles, and when we moved from 7 inch 45s to albums when the LP came along, we um, you know, we put about four or five songs on the side of a record, and it was somewhere between 18 and 22 minutes, and that was pretty much the end of it.

SPEAKER_01You didn't put more than five songs on a record, and if you wanted your record to be really hot and to be sort of play like a group of singles, you only put four songs on a side so that the level would be nice and hot. But now, coming back to vinyl the way we're doing it today, uh, we've all had 15 years of or more of experience with uh compact disc, and there we've been writing for the 60-minute format or 65-minute format, even the 70-minute format. And when you go to try to divide that up into a record, you get 28, 29, 30 minute sides.

SPEAKER_01And I'll just I'll state the the only sort of given is if you're approaching um anything over 25, 26, 27 minutes, you're gonna have to have some real compromises to get it onto the side of a record. Like what, for instance? Well, it's usually best just to think about it in terms of level, because that's the simplest thing. A side that's 18 minutes long, that's to say that that's our standard, and that we could cut um at a level of um uh uh at our reference level.

SPEAKER_01We'll just call that at zero uh at zero level, at nominal level. If we increase that up to twenty minutes, we've got to drop the the recording level about two dB, maybe a little more than two dB. If we increase that up to 24 minutes, we're down now four, maybe five dB from the original. And if we're at say thirty minutes, it's easily 15 dB down from the original source. Now, anybody who's you know been around audio knows that 15 dB is a heck of a lot of of level.

SPEAKER_01Um in most cases, um 15 dB is a difference between being able to hear if it's if something's on and whether it's not on. If you're listening on headphones and someone turns the source down 15 dB from from nominal, you might not be able to hear the the audio in your headphones over the you know the background noise.

SPEAKER_00Right. So um aside from the uh from from the reduction in volume, is there also a reduction in sound quality?

SPEAKER_01There are several different ways to come up with a compromise. There's several different ways to look at this. Uh essentially the problem is how much space the groove uses up. And the louder the program material is as it's recorded, the louder that is, the wider the grooves are, the more space the grooves used up on the record. So if you drop the level, you make the groove smaller, means you can fit more of them on a side. A different way of making the groove smaller is by reducing the base that's uh in your recording. So if I had to reduce the level 2 dB, I might have been able to keep the level um at the same level that it was, but reduce the base by a bunch.

SPEAKER_01Uh I'll digress for a second here and describe a scenario. If uh people haven't been making records of themselves, they would won't understand uh what I'm talking about. But there are basically two different ways to get your record cut or record processed. You can send off WAV files to a pressing plant, and somebody in that plant has a a cutting lathe, and they will cut the master lacquer or the master copper disc in that plant, and then they press the records and you get records back in the mail. It's uh what could be easier? It's just uh send off your files and back come a set of records.

SPEAKER_01The problem is almost all of the sound quality issues that come up when making a record are not optimized in that situation. They're not optimized for a variety of reasons, most of which is that the cutting person at the factory is not really in direct communication with the producer and isn't particularly motivated to um spend the extra time and effort to um make sure they get an optimal level on the record and make sure that they get as much of the base uh on the record as they possibly can. So one of the first things that average cutters would do would be to um reduce the low frequencies, reduce the high frequencies because they might distort, and then lower the level because we want to make sure it fits so that we don't have to cut it, you know, more than once or twice.

SPEAKER_01But that's completely the opposite approach that I use and and um my colleagues that are making really fine records out there take a um a very different approach. My prime directive is to get as much of the music uh from the master tape onto the record as as humanly possible. And that takes several attempts, multiple passes to make sure you get the level just right. And even at times making decisions to reduce one s one section of one song a little bit, or to reduce a bass area, you know, maybe even discuss it with the mastering engineer.

SPEAKER_01Um, can we reduce the bass, but only on this song where there's this massive kick drum? Because if we reduce the bass there, we'll be able to keep the average level of the whole side up. Or what happens a little more often is uh someone brings me up a longish side that has you know really good sound quality, and I look at at it on the lathe and realize I'm gonna have to really reduce the level quite a bit. Sometimes I'm able to convince the producer to switch their plans to a double album instead of a single album.

SPEAKER_01So now we have four sides to divide that music up to, and that really helps us get a higher quality product. But only if you go to the extra effort then of making sure that you've got an optimum level, you know, on the disc. Right.

SPEAKER_00So I'd like to point out here that uh, you know, here again, this is another it's another reason to have a relationship with your mastering engineer and make sure that you're having a creative discussion back and forth about the pros and cons of of either putting more music on or putting more less music on, um, you know, in in order to raise the overall quality level of the recording.

SPEAKER_01At the beginning of our discussion, I I almost said, well, if you ha have a discussion with your cutting engineer, then he'll help you solve these, he or she will help you solve these problems. Um and but you know, then what we I I realized what we really needed to do was talk about the problem with a little more detail so people would know what it is that they're would be giving up, what they'd have to compromise. Um it's a really difficult conversation to have. Um it ties into marketing. You know, if you say you were a small label that had um a few different artists and releases and you wanted your record to sound good, but you also had a a limited budget, um, you might also be looking creatively at the the content and realizing that there was that you wanted all of those songs to be on there.

SPEAKER_01You didn't want the the buyer to pick up the record and realize it was missing two songs that were on the CD and feel like they had gotten shortchanged. But I I want to tell all the record buyers out there that don't know this already, um if a song or two were taken off of the project to put it on vinyl, it was for one reason, and that was to make the vinyl sound better.

SPEAKER_00Which is which is a very good reason. Uh and you know, you can always, I mean, certainly in this age of music, you can always find the other the other songs on Spotify or something like that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and they're even um oftentimes included if there's a download card or if there's an opportunity. Uh a lot of people releasing vinyl put a download card or some sort of mechanism so that the the buyer of the vinyl is is legally uh able to take a digital copy of them with them for portability. Um and occasionally throw in bonus tracks and and that as well. But it's a simple problem, but it gets a little bit more complicated when we when we stop when we're not talking about just pop music.

SPEAKER_01Um let's talk about um let's talk about a light jazz trio record, um, piano bass and drums, for instance, um might have two songs on a side that are really like full quote unquote sort of band tunes, where there's a uh a solid groove and everybody's playing hard. But there might be two or three other songs that are down tempo, it might be on brushes, he might just be playing a ride symbol, barely hitting the kick drum. Um all of these factors weigh into a decision about how loud to cut the record.

SPEAKER_01Um the levels have all been set, presumably by a a mastering engineer, and hopefully the mastering engineer understood what it means to master for vinyl. Um there'll definitely be another topic that we'll discuss. But um assuming that they do, the the softer songs, the songs with a wider dynamic range that have essentially softer softs, will help conserve space on the record. So if you you could actually re-sequence the record so that you distribute your louder songs across the two sides, you might be able to improve the record level.

SPEAKER_01Um and and let me say one more thing. Um, why are we so concerned about the uh record being recorded hot? Um it's not it has nothing to do with the volume wars of a digital realm uh of uh you know everyone trying to make their uh song sound louder on Spotify than everybody else's record. This is very, very important. Um a record has a finite surface noise. Um even if there was no audio being recorded on it, you would hear shh shh shh you would hear a little bit of c groove noise, regardless of any of of how um the music was recorded.

SPEAKER_01You it's most obviously evident, you know, in between the songs, at the spirals between the songs. Now, if you record low-end level, the music is not that much louder than the noise, and when the listener turns up the volume of their playback to hear the a lot more noise. Yeah, that makes sense. It's called signal-to-noise ratio in a tech in a technical environment. Uh, engineers understand this that you want to record uh really as loud as you can without running into the limitations of the media, which might cause distortion or might cause skipping.

SPEAKER_01So there's caveats, we can't make it too loud. If you had an eight-minute side, like a disco 12-inch, I can't make it like 12 dB louder. I can only make it as loud as the groove you know can can survive. I can only make it as loud as the needle can play it back. But on a on a mixed media sort of record that doesn't have all loud songs, we might be able to conserve uh space and conserve time and uh keep our record level kind of hot. And then there's one final thing, uh a hot recorded record or record that's cut at a reasonably high level um really seems to sound better.

SPEAKER_01There is something about um for anybody out there that's that's recorded to tape, you could you'll get the analogy. Um when you record to to analog tape um at like lower levels, it sounds nice. It sounds what you expect. But when you record at higher levels, it's it there's a little bit of tape compression and there's a little bit of saturation that's going on, and a little bit of tone change that's very usually very pleasing, especially for rock, especially vocals and especially guitars. It's got a cohesiveness, it just sounds more alive.

SPEAKER_01Vinyl seems to do the same thing. If we and we noticed it just yesterday, we cut something um that we got all the way through the the the process and it and had cut the master for the A-side. And was I was having a discussion uh with my co uh co-engineer uh in the cutting room, and there was a little bit of space left on the record. We we ended it, you know, like 84%. We didn't quite make it all the way out to the end of the record. And we hemmed and hawed about it a little bit and thought about it as like, you know, the record's really gonna be better if it's a DB louder.

SPEAKER_01And we both knew that. We decided to convince ourselves that, yeah, it's worth throwing that part away and putting it back on, spending another half an hour and cutting the part the right way. And my uh junior engineer um responded after after um listening to the playback of the of the louder cut, um, I say it really jumps out of the speakers more. It doesn't sound like just a DB. It sounds like, you know, uh like it was better mastered.

SPEAKER_00Right, right. Because a DB an another D B could give you a whole other slice of the spectrum of sound in in the end, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. There's there's this feeling in my to my ears that it feels like it's jumping out of the speakers. And if the volume of the cut is too low, it just doesn't seem to jump out of the speakers. And I'm sure our vinyl listening friends have records that just don't that just feel sluggish. It doesn't seem like the sound is coming out, jumping out of the speakers. Um, and that's usually the often the case of either not quite the best mastering or a an average cut, um, one that doesn't that where where all of those factors haven't been taken into consideration.

SPEAKER_00Right. So you said before that um you mentioned earlier that that there are multiple aspects to the decision that has to be made um concerning the the how much music you're gonna put on a side. Not only is there the technical aspect, but there's the emotional aspect from the artist and perhaps the producer um who is in so so in so in love with the song that they don't want to cut it. And also perhaps the record label you would give an example before where they were just trying to stuff as much on there as humanly possible, greatly to the detriment of the listener.

SPEAKER_00Um so my question is, you know, are there times where you really have to sort of you know get in deep and go to the mat with somebody uh in order to get them to you know to see the other aspects of of uh of this decision?

SPEAKER_01Well, the same question kind of comes up when we're talking about the level wars in digital. I mean, it's our uh our clients are the ones making the records. We're we're the mechanism with which, you know, we're we're the we're the hands that help execute that for them. And it usually comes down to making sure that you're not being the chicken little and always crying, you know, that the sky is falling. Um in some instances, losing a DB, losing a DB and a half on a record that was well mastered is not the end of the world.

SPEAKER_01And uh you just have to explain to the client what the options are and uh uh what they might be giving up by making a choice one way or another. Um I I wouldn't say I'm often overruled, but if if I fought too vehemently for this, um uh they would simply find somebody else that would cut it the way they they want them to. But and at the same time, um I've got my you know personal reputation and my my pride in my work, and um I wanted to see it executed well, um, and that's um why these people have chosen me.

SPEAKER_01So sometimes I have to remind them uh of of the importance of some of these issues. Um I've gone as far as to um to cut the side um two different ways. Um I had one project where they just really didn't want to go to a four-sided record. They marketing and management had decided it was going to be a single record, and um they insisted that it was gonna be okay. And I I really I differed with them. I I thought that uh this was a uh high profile um metal band uh doing a reissue of uh of of the record.

SPEAKER_01Uh I'm talking about a white snake record that everybody knew uh the way the digital sounded from the original record. And uh in my opinion, it was going to be um inferior. It was going to uh be noticeable. I I really dread the day when uh and uh when when a vinyl collector goes, like, geez, my my MP3 sounds better than this vinyl. And you've heard me say this here before. It's just it's it's something that's always on my mind. Um I I feel like we're we're going we're we're we're doing everybody a disservice if we kind of let that happen.

SPEAKER_01Um but the the label was insistent, um, and I made a set of uh reference discs for them to listen to, and I sent a another side cut a second time with the levels that I could put on if they had made it a double record instead of a single record. So they only ordered one set of refs, but I sent them three sides, an A side and B side the way they wanted it, which ridiculously low level, and it sounded pretty, pretty weak. And then the same A side instead of uh seven songs on the A side, you know, with four songs or so on the on the A side split up as if it had been on a double record.

SPEAKER_01And the difference was mind-blowing. And so when faced with that reality of of okay, this is what we're really giving up, um, they they opted for the four sides. And um it was um it's a shame it took quite so long to convince them of that, but I understand there's a lot more to it than just the you know, just the engineering and just the technical aspects of it. Um they're pulling money, you know, uh uh they've got a budget and they're trying to make a package, a box set happen, and they looking at how much they're gonna be able to sell it for and how many they're gonna make, and they've got a budget for the production.

SPEAKER_01And making a change like that dramatically affects the uh the numbers. So I'm I'm with them. I um and sometimes it takes uh um a little extra effort to um to make sure that they hear what I'm trying to tell them.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm I'm glad to hear that that they went with it in the end. I was pretty sure at the end of that story you were gonna say, well, they just said, screw it. You know, we're just gonna do the crappy sounding version.

SPEAKER_01Well, I I've had those stories too, but they didn't but it didn't uh it didn't end, I don't it didn't end as well. Um well well, but just to say it a different way, it ended the way the client it ended with the compromise that the client wanted. Um and so then I go into damage control mode. Um the client says, no, absolutely, we want you know 26 minutes on this side, um, you know, and we think you can do it. And uh so then I spend even more time looking at the audio and figuring out where I can make compromises.

SPEAKER_01It's uh um, I don't know, it may be something like uh taking on water in a ship and you've got to decide what to what to throw overboard to survive. It's like, you know, well uh we're trying to buy level back uh by maybe reducing some bass or maybe cutting some gaps between songs. Maybe we can get 15-20 seconds back over the course of the side by making the songs closer together. Maybe we can um roll off some of the bass and mono some of the bass, even though that's never my preference uh to uh to do it that way.

SPEAKER_01Um it might help us save their release so that they can, you know, so that it doesn't completely suck, that it just it just sucks a little.

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_00So there there it's not real it's not just about volume and EQ. I mean you mentioned a couple other things, for instance, the space between the songs. There are multiple dimensions at work here, and you can um as the mastering engineer you pick and choose your the the least destructive methods to uh eke out a a couple um another minute or two from from a side, yeah?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's really the case. Um on a record that's built around the you know a gargantuan drum sound and a big bass and wide guitar sound, um you know, i i it's gonna really hurt the production value of the song to reduce the bass. But on a you know, uh maybe a traditional jazz record, um, you know, rolling off at 40 hertz or eight to sixty hertz, you know, might not be all that destructive. And And um it would be a lot less noticeable than having the level down so low.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's but I uh really have to emphasize that doesn't mean you should make these changes to your mixes before sending in your music. So don't r rearrange what I said it to to mean, well, if you've got more than twenty minutes on a side, you gotta reduce the bass. Um please let your cutting engineer make that decision for you. Because only then do you really know if it's necessary. I can't even tell until I put the music up on the lathe and watch and s uh and run through a dummy pass, um, just a test cut pass on the side of the record.

SPEAKER_01That's the only way I can really tell if it's gonna fit or not.

SPEAKER_00So when when we're talking about when we're talking about re-EQing something, uh you you you've mentioned the base a couple times. Is it um is it how often is it a function of mastering EQ and how often do you go all the way back to the to the mix?

SPEAKER_01Um it's usually just a function of altering the mastered version with a little more EQ. Okay. Um and um my preference is to do that with analog EQ whenever I can. Um all of the music goes through my disc cutting console, and in the disc cutting console, there's some very gentle equalizers and and um filters that I can use. Um you know, there's digital controls and plugins and EQs and filters and and and such. Um and then there's the you know the analogue versions of them.

SPEAKER_01Some some work better in some circumstances, some work better than the others. But um if the music comes to me heavily compressed, um like like it was mastered for digital, but not really remastered, custom remastered for vinyl, um again I'm making reference to we'll discuss that at a later time, um, what the difference between mastering for digital and mastering for vinyl really is and and what mastering engineers should be thinking about and what artists should be thinking about when they're working with a mastering engineer making a purpose, you know, custom made for vinyl.

SPEAKER_01But if the m if the audio that I was sent to cut uh was mastered for digital and it was heavily compressed and limited so that to make it loud in a sort of contemporary loudness wars kind of way, that makes it even harder to cut. Um, because it shoves all of the quiet spot all of the well, when you limit something, you're you're preventing it from getting louder. You're limiting the level at a particular ceiling. And as a result, all of the quieter stuff is made louder.

SPEAKER_01As I said earlier, if the if there's quiet spots on your record, the grooves can nestle closer together and we can actually save space on the record. But now if you've made all of your soft spots louder, the entire record is louder. Every groove on that record now is fatter than it would have been without the limiting. And I'll say it uh as matter of fact as I possibly can. For every DB that you raise the level with a peak limiter, I have to lower the level that same dB or more when cutting.

SPEAKER_01So it's a completely not um effective mechanism. Well, it's even more than a wash, okay? But uh, but this is a little hard to explain without visuals. But let's visualize a heavily compressed waveform with flat tops on it, right? And um now I have to lower that level two or three or four dB to get it to fit onto a side of a record. And now what you have is a flat top still with you know all the louds, all the soft smushed up against the bottom, but all the louds limited as well.

SPEAKER_01If we backed up one step and didn't do that limiting to begin with and delivered me a master that didn't have four dB of peak limiting on it, but had um occasional peaks that hit zero and had dynamics that allowed for the softer stuff to happen, I wouldn't have had to lower that, you know, maybe at all. Right. So that not only would it appear to be to have an average level that's a little bit louder than the limited one, the peaks would be a lot louder. And analog cutting has no had generally has no problem with peak levels.

SPEAKER_01There is no absolute ceiling. Um, you and and you you actually can kind of get an an improvement on the sound if you allow the dynamics to to work into the cutting system.

SPEAKER_00You're right. It's it not only is it not a wash, it's it's sort of like adding insult to injury at that point.

SPEAKER_01It's may it's the worst of both possible worlds. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um here's a question I have. Uh we're talking about a uh a large continuum of artists. You mentioned Whitesnake before. Um I don't know about anybody listening right now, but my first white snake experience happened on vinyl versus um newer, modern, perhaps more independent artists. My question to you is is there a sort of um uh a dichotomy between how uh between these two artists in terms of how much they understand the limitations of vinyl uh and the work that you the the the time that you need to spend explaining the basics to them?

SPEAKER_01By and large, most of the people familiar with making vinyl from 20 years ago are no longer in in the biz. There's there's some exceptions. I was a young mastering intern and assistant back in the day, and so I learned about disc cutting and watched a hell of a lot of records being cut um while I was learning about mastering, um, then transitioned to CD and back. But the but the point I was making is that um even the the traditional artists um have been so out of touch with making records for many years, they need to be educated just as much, if not more, than the contemporary artists who are approaching vinyl for the first time.

SPEAKER_01Um I think um it really comes down to how much of a fan of this of the media they are themselves. You know, if the artist has a vinyl collection, has a turntable that's well set up, listens to vinyl on a fairly regular basis, they're gonna be an ideal, you know, producer client of mine, because they're gonna understand what they already understand what they like and don't like about vinyl. Um I've had remarkably, quite remarkably, several, you know, classic artists.

SPEAKER_01Um uh I'll I'll save that dropping names in this particular instance because I don't want to embarrass anybody, but several, you know, major classic artists from the 70s and 80s, um, when they get to the point where they go, you know, we we got our rights to our music back and we want to do a new release or a box set, yeah, and let's make some vinyl. Uh they don't even have a turntable. They don't even have any means of listening to the references or listening to the test pressings. Now I can still help them. I can, you know, I can be their surrogate set of ears and and quality control department for them.

SPEAKER_01Um and I think that's one of the best ways you should, well, one of the things you should think about how to use your mastering engineer, your cutting engineer, um, is to to help you um understand and and and manage your quality control of your project. But, you know, you contrast that with a uh a modern artist who, you know, five or six years ago kind of understood that vinyl was pretty cool and is already into their second or third turntable and has a an avid collection. They're listening to vinyl almost every day. Um the you know, that person um it really doesn't matter whether they were um a reissue or or modern project.

SPEAKER_01The the the big issue uh the the big problem with reissue projects is they're they generally want to fit more material on the on the vinyl than um um than is really practical. Um they usually have a catalog and and such um that they're trying to squeeze everything onto vinyl where possible. Um there's some exceptions. There's people making box sets where they give everything ample time uh and ample space. Um uh guess some of these things sound you know can sound amazing.

SPEAKER_01Um but uh yeah, it uh it has more to do with uh whether they're a fan, um and even uh should I say an avid fan of the format.

SPEAKER_00Has um has anything about um disc cutting technique or technology been developed over the past um couple decades that would change the answer to the question how much can I fit on a side?

SPEAKER_01Well, when DMM was first developed, um it was about well I guess the early nineties. What is DMM? Direct metal mastering. Um that's where instead of cutting into a lacquer surface, the all the cutting head um operation, all the cutting operation has been changed and modified and beefed up so that you can actually cut into a soft copper disc. Um that copper disc can then be plated and stampers made from it. And there's some efficiencies in that process. Um but what was the the main two motivations for for developing that technology in the nineties were that um CDs were out and available and people were um getting used to very quiet sounding um CDs and were complaining that their records were too noisy.

SPEAKER_01So um DMM was supposed to be able to make that quieter. And also at the same time they had longer records. So people were putting more than 60 minutes on a CD, and there was a complaint that we couldn't put 30 minutes on a side, you know, on a record. So both of those factors drove the manufacturers to develop this direct metal um mastering concept, and it achieved some of that, but it gave up some of the warmth and some of the genuine tone of a vinyl pressing um as a result.

SPEAKER_01Um it's it was it's not a total win-win uh situation. For certain types of music, um there may be an advantage, but almost always um the record levels have to be reduced because part partly because the the um the format itself can't put as high a level on the disc. So even though it's a quieter pressing, you've also reduced the uh the record level somewhat, so there's not a big um benefit from that. Um other than that technology, um uh there's some advancements on the horizon that I'm involved in and that we'll talk about at a later time.

SPEAKER_01Um, but um they are not you know ready for release or ready for publication just at this time, but there are some new ways of making records um uh record masters that um may move the mark, may move the line uh to some extent. But remarkably, um there's been almost no changes in technology since um my 1982 record lathe was made. Um it's it's it they did a damn good job of of putting all the technology together to make a good sounding record.

SPEAKER_01Um the rest um remains uh uh the skill and the persistence of the operator to make sure it turns out great.

SPEAKER_00Which is part of the art form really of of creating a record, you know, aside from the art form of creating the music, it's really um, you know, this is a this is a uh a creative endeavor. And as we've discussed um uh a few times, it's a cooperation between the artist and the producer and the mastering engineer. So there you have um any any other any other thoughts on uh on this question? Anything else you tell people regularly when they ask?

SPEAKER_01Well, I'll just I'll I'll just sum up. It's it's really important that you find out who's cutting your record and um wherever possible, and it's it it is usually very possible to speak with the person cutting your record. Um if you've chosen a broker or a manufacturing facility that doesn't let you actually talk to the cutting engineer, um uh understand that you're probably not getting uh um everything that you can out of your record. Um so to date, everyone that that has come to me after having a subpar experience um um with a factory cut record, um, we've solved the problem by just giving a damn and putting the extra effort into doing it right.

SPEAKER_01In some cases it's as simple as not um not screwing it up. Uh as you know, but in some cases the the factory cutting will try to compensate for too many things when uh they don't really need to. Um so anyway, so know who's cutting your record, ask to speak with the person who's cutting your record and communicate your your your needs, your wishes uh to them. Um we're not that rare, but you know, you have to seek out the the people who are doing this and putting their name on the disc and putting their stamp um and their uh initials in the dead wax.

SPEAKER_01Um and I I usually tell people um when they're looking for records, looking to buy records, if the person um who made that record um had pride in the way that record was made, on the back he's going to credit the person who cut it and the person who played it and the person who pressed it. And if you see that on the back of a record, it's a darn good sign that it's a really good sign that someone cared about the way that record sounds, and it's probably going to be a better sounding record. Um I'm working on trying to convince people to put that production detail somewhere on the back of their record, um, not just so that I can properly be credited, but so that the consumer can then appreciate the work that we do.

SPEAKER_00Sure, absolutely, and with good reason. And there you have it, folks. If you're wondering how much time fits on the side of a record, the answer is it depends. Um so if you have other questions uh uh or for Scott and the team, hit them up on uh social media, you know, Twitter and Instagram and Facebook, and uh reach out and talk to your mastering engineer because they know a lot and they're here to help, especially Scott.

SPEAKER_01Well, thanks, man. It was a great conversation. Hope we uh enlightened some people on uh if if nothing else, got them to ask some more questions uh so they could understand the process. Um this has been Making Vinyl at Master Disc. I'm Scott Hall and uh with my guest KJ from the Odyssey. We'll see you next time. Bye-bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Making Music At Masterdisk (that matters) - Michele Gedney

    Sep 1, 202638 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail A song can be a product, or it can be a place you go to tell the truth. We head off campus into Hudson Valley songwriter Michele Gedney’s home studio and talk about the moments that changed her creative...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Making Vinyl Scott Hull with Kevin Gray

    Jul 6, 202641 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Masterdisk's Scott Hull talks with Vetren Disk Cutting and mastering engineer Kevin Gray. Keven is well know for decades of work in mastering some of vinyl-s best sounding LPs and re-issues. This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Interview With Dave O'donnell. Grammy winning Producer, Mixer, and Engineer.

    Jul 28, 20251 hr 21 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Scott talks with Dave O'donnell. A well known producer, mixer, engineer who is known for his work with James Taylor, Keith Richards, John Mayer, Eric Clapton, Sheryl Crow, and many...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Interview With Witek Wolny

    Jan 9, 202536 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Scott talks to Witek Wolny about his song "Fran" and the production of the song as well as the making of the music video. Links to Witek and the song "Fran":...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Groove Oddities

    Dec 25, 202428 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Groove Oddities - Show Notes Making Vinyl @ Masterdisk Podcast Host: Scott Hull, Chief Engineer at Masterdisk Episode Overview In this fascinating episode, Scott Hull explores the weird and wonderful...

    Credit the people on this episode