What if the story worth telling isn’t buried in the most dramatic chapter of your life? What if it’s waiting inside a familiar restaurant, a family tradition, or a place you’ve returned to for years? In this episode of Making Memoir Magic, I share the story of Al Dente, a restaurant in Boston’s North End that my husband, Rick, and I first discovered in 1994. What began as an unplanned dinner became part of our family history - a place we later shared with our children, friends, and colleagues. Using this ordinary but meaningful memory, I explore how memoir writers can uncover the deeper stories hiding inside everyday experiences. In this episode, you’ll learn: Why specific details make personal stories more relatable How familiar places can unlock meaningful memories How to use “then and now” scenes to show the passage of time The difference between what happened and what a story is really about Why readers often connect most deeply with ordinary moments How scene and reflection work together in memoir Try this writing exercise: Choose a place that appeared during more than one season of your life. First, write about your earliest memory of that place. Who was with you? What did you notice? What could you see, hear, smell, taste, or touch? Then describe the place during your most recent visit. What changed? What remained the same? What do you understand now that you couldn’t have understood then? Finally, complete this sentence: This isn’t really a story about __________. It’s a story about __________. The first answer identifies the visible subject. The second may reveal the deeper story - and possibly a theme that belongs in your memoir. Ready to begin the memoir only you can write? My signature course, Make Memoir Magic, will help you move from wondering where to start to identifying your core story, creating an outline, beginning your first chapter, and developing a sustainable writing practice. Learn more about Make Memoir Magic: https://kerrykriseman.myflodesk.com/mmm3 Visit my website for memoir resources, workshops, and ways to work with me: https://kerrykriseman.com If this episode helped you recognize a story hiding in your own life, please follow Making Memoir Magic, share the episode with an aspiring memoirist, and leave a review. Thank you for listening to this episode of Making Memoir Magic. To learn more about my course, Make Memoir Magic, click here. Join my free Facebook Group, Memoir Magic for Aspiring Authors, where we honor your story, provide tips, create community, and help you write the story you were meant to tell. Join here!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Making Memoir Magic, the podcast where we unlock the power of your story and guide you through the magical process of turning life experiences into memoirs that inspire and impact. I'm your host, Carrie Chrysman, a memoir mentor and storytelling champion. And I'm here to help you find the courage to embrace your unique story and share it with the world. Whether you're just starting out or refining your final draft, this is the place to be for practical tips, inspiration, and the encouragement you need to write the memoir Only You Can Tell.
SPEAKER_00Ready to make some magic? Let's dive in. Hello and welcome to the Making Memoir Magic Podcast, the podcast that helps aspiring authors write, publish, and promote the stories only they can tell. I'm Carrie Kreisman, author of the memoir Accidental First Lady, and a memoir mentor who believes you don't need to be famous, extraordinary, or completely healed to write a story that matters. Today, we're talking about why ordinary stories often resonate so deeply and how a restaurant, a familiar room, a family meal, or a long-standing tradition can become meaningful material for your memoir.
SPEAKER_00Last week, my husband Rick and I returned to one of our favorite restaurants in Boston's North End. The restaurant is called Al Dante, and we first discovered it in 1994. We had spent the day wandering around Boston, seeing Rudyard Kipling's famous ducks in the common Boston Commons and visiting museums and taking the tea all over the city, and we wound up shortly before dinner, just as it was getting dusk, in the north end.
SPEAKER_00And I have some Italian heritage. My father was Italian and definitely wanted to visit the North End. So we spent about an hour wandering up and down Salem and Hanover streets. We were trying to figure out where to have dinner. We didn't have any recommendation. No one had suggested a place to eat. We just kind of winged it. But what we did do was we followed our noses to where to where the garlic led us. We're like, okay, if this is the strongest garlic smell, we're gonna find where this is coming from, and this is where we're going to eat.
SPEAKER_00So it wasn't easy to figure out where the best places were in 1994. There was no cell phones, or we could Google something like best restaurants in the North End, or you know, something like that. So we just, you know, figured we would try this restaurant, Al Dante. And as we approached the door, the host was a little gruff but friendly. It was okay. Um, he didn't scare us off. He looked at his clipboard and he found the last table for two. So already, before we even walked in the door, we're like, we're meant to be here.
SPEAKER_00And we loved the dinner. Now my husband orders chicken parmesan at almost every Italian restaurant we go to. He likes to see how they prepare it a certain way, which one is better, which one becomes his favorite, how good the red sauce is. And um Al Dante is certainly one of the top choices of all time for his chicken parm. Um so we have returned many times over the years. We've been fortunate to uh be able to visit Boston.
SPEAKER_00And um, over the years we brought our children when they were toddlers. Um, so I remember maneuvering a stroller into a crowded, busy restaurant, um, then when they were middle schoolers, and then as young adults, we brought friends, we recommended the restaurant, we brought colleagues and other political families during that time of our life when our travels took us to Boston. So what began as one unplanned meal became part of our family tradition. And when we returned last week, the restaurant was quiet.
SPEAKER_00It was a Wednesday evening, but it was still quiet, and we were a little nervous. So for part of the evening, we had the whole place to ourselves. Um, I have to be honest, I Googled um on my phone and looked at recent reviews, and they were still getting five-star reviews. So we're like, we have this whole place to ourselves. They were getting ready for the busy San Gennaro festival for the weekend, and they said they had just been busy on Tuesday night. So for whatever reason, Wednesday night was quiet, and but it was all good. And the host is still the same guy.
SPEAKER_00Um, he wasn't there 32 years ago, but he's been there for 17 years. He used to work at the restaurant, and um eight years after he left, they hired him back to be the host. So he now keeps track of diners on his phone, although his clipboard remains close by with all the outlines of every table. So the decor inside has not changed much. The sauce, and I know this because I cook with these kind of tomatoes, is still made with San Marzano tomatoes. And the same chef has been in the kitchen for its entire 32-year history.
SPEAKER_0033 years, I take that back, 33 years. So as we left carrying our box of heavy leftovers, we were told that, or we told the host that Al Dante has been one of our favorite North End restaurants. And I later shared the experience in an Instagram reel. And the caption of that reel told the story of that first dinner, the years of family visits, and what it felt like to return. That post received more likes and engagement than any other of my recent posts that teach memoir writing.
SPEAKER_00So, um, and why do you think that is? Of course, it's a story, and everyone loves a story. Um, and so I don't think that people responded because they're planning to go to El Dante. I think people recognize something from their own lives in that story, and that's what I'm gonna talk about. Um, that was a long introduction, but you can tell that I love Boston. I love our memories at this restaurant, and I see how that relates to memoir, and I want to share that in this week's podcast.
SPEAKER_00The reaction to the real and the comments that I got is happened because I believe that people recognized something from their own lives in the story. They may have remembered their family's favorite restaurant, a beach cottage that they visited every summer, their grandmother's kitchen, a neighborhood they once knew by heart, a holiday meal that always included the same food and the same people sitting in the same chairs. My story gave them access to their stories, and that is one of the gifts of memoir.
SPEAKER_00Your story begins with you, but it should not end with you. A well-told personal story creates room for a reader to remember, question, recognize, or reconsider something about their own life. The reader may never have lived through your exact circumstances, but the underlying emotions of love, loss, embarrassment, longing, fear, belonging, reinvention are shared human experiences.
SPEAKER_00The more specific that you become about your experience when you're writing, the more likely a reader is to recognize an emotional truth from theirs. So that may sound backwards because sometimes writers try to make a story more relatable by making it more general. They remove names, places, objects, and sensory details because they think those things only apply to them. So instead of writing something, this is just an example. Instead of writing the sentence, my grandmother stood at the stove stirring tomato sauce in a dented silver pot.
SPEAKER_00They would write, cooking with my grandmother taught me about family. Both true sentences possibly, but which one is more interesting? The second sentence gives us the lesson, but not the life that went into it behind it and who the people are. We don't see the stove. We don't smell the sauce, we don't know what the grandmother's hands looked like or whether she measured every ingredient carefully or poured spices into her palm without looking. The general statement tells the reader what the memory means.
SPEAKER_00The specific scene allows the reader to discover that meaning. So let's look at several ways an ordinary memory can become meaningful in memoir.
SPEAKER_00First, begin with a place. Places are powerful containers of memory. When you think about your childhood, you may immediately see a room, a kitchen, a school hallway, a backyard, a church, a neighborhood street. You may remember when where the furniture was arranged, which floorboard creaked, or what you could see through a particular window. A place gives your memory physical boundaries. It helps you move from the large and intimidating task of writing your life's story to the more manageable task of writing what happened in one location.
SPEAKER_00So ask yourself, what place can return me to an earlier version of myself? Don't immediately choose the place where the most dramatic event of your life occurred. Pay attention to the ordinary places too. Where did your family eat on Friday nights? Where did you go after school? What relative's house or which relative's house did you visit regularly? Where did you feel most like yourself? Where did you feel like you had to become someone else? Choose one place and list everything you remember about it.
SPEAKER_00What could you smell? What sound belonged there? What objects were always present? Where did people sit? What happened so regularly that no one thought it needed to be explained? Those details can help you reconstruct the world in which the story occurred. So, second, look for change across time. One reason the Aldante story resonated was that the restaurant allowed me to place several versions of our family side by side.
SPEAKER_00There was a young married couple discovering the restaurant. There were the parents arriving with toddlers, there were the middle school years, and there were our visits with our young adult children. The setting remained relatively stable while our family changed. The contrast gives the story the emotional weight. Try choosing one meaningful place and writing about it during two different time periods. Write the first time you remember being there. Then write the last time you were there.
SPEAKER_00Who was present the first time? Who was present the last time? Who had changed? What was no longer there or who was no longer there? What did you understand during the later visit that you could not have understood during the first one? Placing these two scenes next to each other creates movement without requiring you to explain everything that happened in between. The reader can see the passage of time. Third, determine what the story is really about.
SPEAKER_00When I teach aspiring memoirs, I often ask them to distinguish between what happened and what the story means. What happened is important, but we need action, setting, and context. Memoir also includes reflection. It tasks the writer with looking back and considering why a particular experience has remained significant. The Aldante story is not ultimately about eating pasta or my husband's favorite chicken parmesan. The restaurant is the visible subject.
SPEAKER_00Underneath it is a story about tradition, family, and the places that bear witness to our lives. So when you finish drafting a memory, try completing this sentence. This isn't really a story about blank. It is a story about blank. This isn't really a story about learning to drive. See the difference? Here's another example. This isn't really a story about a ruined Thanksgiving dinner.
SPEAKER_00It is a story about the year our family stopped pretending everything was fine. This isn't a story about cleaning out a closet. It is a story about deciding which pieces of my former life I was ready to release. The first blink identifies the event. The second identifies the emotional or thematic meaning. So you may not know the second answer when you begin writing, and that is perfectly fine. Often we write in order to discover it. So fourth, give the reader a scene before giving them a lesson.
SPEAKER_00As memoir writers, we have the benefit of hindsight. We know how an event affected us. We know what happened later. We know which relationships lasted and which promises did not. That knowledge can tempt us to explain too much too soon. We tell readers that a moment was important before we allow them to experience it. Try resisting that impulse. Let us walk into the restaurant with you. Let us hear the host say there is one table left. Let us watch your toddler drop a meatball or your teenager roll her eyes when you insist on another family photo.
SPEAKER_00Then, once we have experienced some of the moment, you can step back and help us understand why it remains with you. Scene gives us immediacy, reflection gives us meaning, memoir needs both. Fifth, trust the ordinary. Many aspiring memoirists believe their experiences are not dramatic enough to hold a reader's attention. They compare their lives to stories of war, survival, celebrity, addiction, scandal, or extraordinary achievement and conclude that no one will care about what happened to them.
SPEAKER_00But readers don't connect only through spectacle, they connect through recognition. A reader may be moved by the story of a mother packing her child's lunch on the final day of high school because that small action contains years of parenting, repetition, and impending change. A reader may remember a father through the way he folded the newspaper every morning. A marriage can be revealed through a disagreement in the grocery store. Grief can appear in the moment someone reaches for the phone before remembering the person they want to call is gone.
SPEAKER_00Your job is not to make an ordinary moment sound artificially dramatic. Your job is to look closely enough to understand the meaning that moment contains. So here's a writing exercise to try this week. Choose a place that has appeared in more than one season of your life. Write the heading then at the top of the page. Describe your earliest memory of that place. Include who was with you, what you noticed, and at least two sensory details. Then write the heading now.
SPEAKER_00Describe the place during your most recent visit, or if the place no longer exists, describe what you know about it now. What changed? What remained? What does the distance between those two moments reveal? Finally, complete the sentence. This isn't really a story about place, it is a story about, and don't force yourself to produce a perfect answer. Write several possibilities. It may be a story about belonging, relationships, or the person you're trying to become. So finally, answer that question through your writing and answer with what makes you curious.
SPEAKER_00So you do not have to know the entire structure of your memoir before you begin writing. Begin with one place, one meal, one room, one tradition. Then ask, why did that memory stay with me? So if you're ready to move beyond wondering whether your story matters and begin shaping it into a memoir, I've included information in today's show notes about how you can learn and work with me. So until next time, keep writing bravely. Your story matters, and you are the only one who can tell it.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for joining me on this episode of Making Memoir Magic. I hope today's conversation inspired you to take the next step toward telling your unique story through memoir. Remember, your story matters and someone out there is waiting to read it. If you enjoyed today's episode, don't forget to subscribe and leave a review. It helps others find the show. You can also connect with me on my website at caryCreisman.com, on Instagram at Carrie.
SPEAKER_00And each Wednesday, I host a memoir magic writing where you get to join other writers to accomplish the often arduous task of getting words on the page. Until next time, keep writing, keep sharing, and keep making memoir magic.
Have you been dreaming about writing a book but questioning whether you're a good enough writer? Perhaps a teacher, professor or someone from your past made you doubt your abilities. Or maybe you've simply never...
Five Small Ways to Nurture Your Memoir During a Busy Season The holidays are approaching, calendars are filling up, and finding time to write your memoir might feel nearly impossible. But staying connected to your story...
Does a memoir have to begin with childhood and move chronologically through every major event? Not at all. After returning from the Florida Writers Association’s WritersCon, Kerry reflects on questions participants...
You have plenty of memories - but how do you find the story that connects them? After three trips in three weeks, an unexpected cold, and an editing project that brought back memories of Copenhagen, I found myself with...
Your memoir may include a larger-than-life parent, a spouse facing illness, or someone whose choices changed your life. But if readers know more about that person’s inner world than yours, an important question arises:...