Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Making Cents

Making Cents artwork

Is The Worst Over For NZ? Simplicity’s Sam Stubbs on Housing, NZ Super & More

Nov 1, 202643 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The money world feels like it’s falling apart, but underneath the doom and gloom, is New Zealand’s economy actually on the brink of its best 30 years? Between high petrol prices, food bills, and a housing downturn, everyday life feels tough. Yet for the first time in modern history, house prices have dropped 30% in Auckland without dragging the wider economy into a deep recession. We are moving from a country that borrows to an economy that saves and invests - and that changes the game. Sam Stubbs, founder of Simplicity, joins Frances Cook on Making Cents to challenge the story we've been telling ourselves about our money. Sam shares why New Zealand is at a major turning point, how KiwiSaver is quietly transforming our wealth, and the simple shifts we need to make to stop copying a poverty mindset. In this episode: Why Auckland house prices dropped 30% without crashing the economy Borrowing vs investing: why saving our way to prosperity beats debt The Australia comparison: how a $1 trillion KiwiSaver pool could wipe out our infrastructure deficit Why KiwiSaver must become compulsory with rising contributions The side-pocketing rule: unlocking billions of KiwiSaver funds for local startups and high-growth businesses Why the best investment you can ever make during tough times is in yourself Whether you are feeling squeezed by the cost of living or wondering where the New Zealand economy is really heading, this episode breaks down what you need to know to take control of your financial future on your own terms.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

The money world feels like it's falling apart, but underneath the doom and gloom, there are signs our real economy is doing well. In fact, some people who watch the money world for a living say that this is a painful growth period, one that could actually make life better overall once we get out the other side of it. So is there light at the end of the tunnel or is that just another train heading our way? Sam Stubbs runs KiwiSaver provider Simplicity, and he says the story we're telling ourselves about the economy

is out of date. I think the next 30 years will be the best in our history, so I'm more optimistic than I've ever been. Housing is well down and typically that's been terrible news for New Zealand. But Sam says it's not the be all and end all that it once was. For all this bad news, we are still growing as an economy and we just had our principal savings asset. Our houses all go down in value. So what's changing below the surface and can it actually help those of us who are finding daily life a struggle right now?

You've got a product in Kiwisaver now that people trust. You know, we haven't had a trusted financial product in this country since the Chequebook. Welcome to Making Sense. It's the podcast people who want financial freedom without giving up their coffee. I'm Frances Cook, a financial journalist and fellow financial freedom seeker who makes money simple for you today. The vibes are bad, but the economy maybe isn't. I want to help as many people as possible build a better life for themselves by understanding and taking control

of their money. You can be part of how that happens. First, make sure you're subscribed wherever you like to listen, whether it's YouTube, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. And then send your favorite episode to a mate. Then we can all level up with money together. The show grows and I can keep bringing you the money info so that actually moves the dial. Welcome, Sam. So nice to have you on. Been yonked since it has been a. Long time. I always love getting your thoughts because you're a bit of a contrarian, but not a contrarian for the sake of it. You

just have your own thoughts, which I really respect. It does all feel a bit grim right now and I've had a lot of people in my DMs saying the cost of living is really killing. The jobs are hard, the housing market's hard and can all feel a bit grim on the surface particularly. Do you think it is truly that grim For New Zealand right now. Yeah. Look, I don't think you can take away from people's personal experiences. Right. Most people are doing it tough out there and you know, a lot of that's got to do with the sort of K shaped recovery we've had post Covid. Like the rich are feeling really good right now, but there are very few of them. Right. The vast

majority of people are feeling it pretty tough. So you can't take away from the fact that it's tough. However, I do think we are at an inflection point in New Zealand's history now. We're about to go from being a capital starved to a capital rich economy. Kind of like where Australia was in about 1990. And when you get that money being saved, it's primarily a kiwisaver thing when that gets invested into the economy. If we follow Australia's example, and I see no reason why we won't, you're just going to get a lot more consistent growth. Australia's had one recession

for about three months and 27 years and the price of iron ore and coal has gone up and down like a yo yo over that time. But because they've been saving money and investing it through the economy, it's just created a much more stable period of economic growth. And that stability really matters if you take away people's hope. Life becomes pretty shitty without hope. Right. Economic yo yos strip people of optimism and hope. Right. So while I don't, don't deny that it feels tough out there right now, it is actually slowly getting better. Let me give you another example.

What if I'd said to you 10 years ago, Auckland property market's gonna be down 30% but the economy's still gonna be growing? Yeah. That would've gone against everything that we think. And it wouldn't in 10 years ago it wouldn't have happened. I mean we would've been in recession for sure. But actually, slowly but surely, Kiwis are saving money and that's getting invested in the real economy. Slow grind of commerce, but it does create jobs and it does create wealth and it has in Australia and has in every country that has started saving its way to prosperity. So I'm more optimistic than I've ever been, but I'm in a very privileged

position. I see the money coming in every day and I get to help make the investments. And all we are doing is investing every single day. I think the next 30 years will be the best in our history. But you can't deny with petrol prices where they are food prices where they are. Every single bill seem to be going up. There's pretty tough out there. The economy is a complex beast. But I do know that capital, investment money, that's the lifeblood of an economy. You can't borrow your way to prosperity forever. You have to invest your way to true prosperity. We have been borrowing

for decades now. We're starting to invest the $50 million we just announced today. Actually, the additional $50 million, the multiplier effect on that in the economy is huge because that's real cash going in there. And that means businesses can grow, expand, employ, and then in due course make money and pay taxes and keep the hospitals open, right? Yeah, yeah, well, because there's that very famous line about New Zealand's economy being basically a housing market with bits tacked on. So you would say that's no longer the case anymore.

How do you think that's shifted? Yeah, look, I think it's changing, eh? But it's demonstrably changing now. The last time we had a 30% drop in houses prices in Auckland, the economy was literally in recession and quite a deep recession, and it was terrible unemployment, that was in the early 90s. So it's slowly changing. And you are seeing that by the ability of us to get through a housing market downturn. More people have, more money saved elsewhere. People have changed their mentality now that the only way to make money is to buy investment properties. Gear up as much as you can. So you are seeing

this painful readjustment from an economy and a people who are totally wedded to housing as the principal creative wealth, which had been the case, by the way, for the last 50 years. I totally get why people thought that that was a good idea, but now they're starting to question that. And you're seeing some demographic changes too. Are you seeing young people saying, ah, I don't want to buy a house, I want to be able to move around. I'd rather rent and save money. You've got a product in Kiwisaver now that people trust. You know, we haven't had a trusted financial product in

this country since the checkbook. So they're putting money in. None has gone bust. So these things take a while. I call it a rising tide. You know, if you look at it, you don't notice it minute by minute, but then you look around a couple of hours and, oh, tide's gone up. And I think you'll find that that's what's gonna happen here, because that's exactly what's happened in Australia. And really we are very similar economies, way more similar than you think in terms of our mix of commodities, added value, you know, obviously, rule of law, democracies, same cultural heritage. So I think that if we basic. Some of your

listeners are going to hate me saying this, but if we basically copy Australia, we're actually going to do okay. And I think we're starting to copy Australia in this regard and I think we're going to start to see the benefits of it come through. So how much can we copy Australia? Because obviously we don't have their mining. We are a natural resources country just like them. I mean, everyone talks about iron ore and coal and they think that that's the source of eternal wealth, but of course it's not. It's not how you get the money, it's what you do with it that matters. Right? Venezuela's got the biggest oil reserves in the world and it's bankrupt. Republic of Congo has about the same mineral profile as Australia. It's

bankrupt. So as long as we sensibly export and remember, we get a lot more from our exports than we pay in our inputs generally. So if we get that money and if we invest that sensibly, then we should be on a pathway to prosperity. There should be not a lot of difference between Australia and New Zealand. And I can tell you some distinct competitive advantages we have in New Zealand versus Australia. I mean, Australia is a huge country. It is expensive to move everything around. It is expensive to live there as well. They've got to cool their houses. They have a lot more complex geopolitical situation than we do.

They have a much more fraught relationship with a whole bunch of countries on their border. So Australia's not better than New Zealand in everything what thinking? What you're going to see, Francis, is just a lot of announcements coming out that are just a little better than forecast. That's the sign. And you started to see this. I laugh every time I hear it when they say, oh, GDP was slightly above forecast. And that's because everybody in New Zealand's thinking backwards. We're so good at dumping on ourselves. We think, oh, we're no productivity. Australia always does it better. Every country does it better. So we always have this

forecast which exists in this sort of like, well, you know, we're battlers and we're good number eight wire people and we're bloody good at winning Oscars and winning sports matches, but we're not really good at business or enterprise or. It's rubbish. We're really good at it. And so we've got to stop forecasting our future with a pessimistic lens and start forecasting it with the optimistic lens because go and have a look at where we sit in the world. We're actually pretty good. We're a pretty smart nation. We just need to get ourselves out of this sort of, you know, little

Kiwi battler insecure mindset that we have and start realizing that the country that can make the Lord of the Rings split the atom, climb Everest, win every sports tournament it's really serious about over time, is actually capable of achieving in a whole lot of other areas as well. I love that. I feel like I'm in a desert and you've just offered me a glass of water. Yeah,. Yeah. Surrounded by negative headlines and you're like, no, everything's gonna be great. I'm like, yes, please, more. And it ain't gonna be a smooth. You have bumps. Of course,

if you want to grasp onto reasons to feel despondent about life, there's plenty to grasp there. Right? But I don't actually think it's the reality of what our economy, and therefore how we feel is about to happen. And I can start to see it happening. So, you see, I'm just in this incredibly privileged position because I get to invest in these companies. I get to see them grow. We get to see what happens when we put serious capital into these companies. And. And I can see this rising tide of Kiwisaver savings. You know, I'll give you a number. The Infrastructure

Commission says our infrastructure deficit in this country is about 250 billion. At the moment, we have 140 billion in KiwiSaver. It's going to be a trillion dollars. About 40 billion is invested in New Zealand right now. But if we kept the same amount invested in New Zealand, it means 30% of a trillion dollars, $300 billion. So we have 30, 40 billion already invested. That means we've got another $260 billion that we could invest in New Zealand just to keep the proportion of international and domestic investments the same. So it's not like we're taking a major bet on New Zealand.

We're just keeping it the same as it is now. That is our infrastructure deficit. That is every school, every hospital, every road, every port, every airport, every wire, every pipe that we need paid for by ourselves with our own savings. So that is what's possible when you get into a potentially capital rich mindset. And we've. The last time New Zealanders thought they were rich was about 1950, coming out of the Korean War, when wool was reaching

record prices and we were supposedly the second richest country in the world, we felt rich. We've never felt rich. We had this poverty mindset. We talk about our number eight wine mentality. Kiwis love doing more with less and we romanticize poverty in that sense. That's not gonna happen in the future. There's gonna be more money around. So the next generation of leaders and entrepreneurs and so on, and politicians, by the way, need to be in a mindset of an abundance mentality, not a starvation mentality. Because otherwise

if we don't, for example, we don't invest this money in New Zealand, it's gonna go overseas. We'll get the investment returns, but no jobs. And in fact, we will make more money by investing it domestically than overseas. You make better risk adjusted returns in your own market usually than you do by investing it offshore because you have control of it. You understand the politics, you're investing for the longer term. Economists call that the GDP multiplier. So you make more money from a dollar invested domestically than you do from a dollar from an offshore investor in an economy.

You create more jobs, more wealth, more taxes. You know that's gonna happen. It already is happening. But it's just hard to see right now because we just swamped with wars and inflation,. Tariffs and tariffs. And debt and all this funky shit going on all around the world. And here there's sort of a despondency, I think, about leadership as well. You know, I just don't think the country is coalescing around somebody or some idea or something that makes them feel better.

Well, you said that the next 30 years could be some of our best ever, which love that, want to see that happen. What sort of investments are there and ripe for the picking and what would we need to do to make sure that does happen? If you look at New Zealand, let's start out small, right? With venture capital, small startups. New Zealand is an incredibly good place for a startup. There is low regulation. It's one of the easiest countries in the world to set up a company, like literally hang your shingle out and say, I want to do business. It has relatively easy access to capital. Now if you're, if you've

got an idea and can't raise capital, it probably says more about the idea than the capital market. So there's a lot of money coming in. You know, we, we put in a lot. You have an entrepreneurial mindset. There are a lot of real smart Kiwi entrepreneurs As I said, all of those things that people have done. Actually, I'll tell you a funny story and that really summarized it. I was in Hong Kong once, I went to see the Two Towers, which is the second Lord of the Rings movie, and there's an Aussie woman standing behind us in the queue and she said, oh, these New Zealanders, they're getting all this publicity about the bloody Lord of the Rings. It's not like they split the atom or anything.

Yeah, we did. Yeah, we did. So, you know, so there's great entrepreneurialism here. What we've lacked is I guess what I call the follow on capital. Like so, for example, a company like Rocket Lab has too few New Zealand shareholders and companies that are growing really quickly, like halter and so on, they need a lot of capital quickly. New Zealand hasn't been able to supply that. We've been good for the little amount of money up front. We haven't been so good for the really big checks through that cycle. That's starting to change now as well too. If we're going to have an economy with a trillion dollars of kiwisaver savings and a good load of that will be available

for the next Rocket Lab that wants billions of dollars, not millions of dollars. And also if you think about technology, this is how I think about technology generally it actually advantages those people who are farthest away because if you can do everything at the speed of light, then it doesn't matter whether you're in New Zealand or Germany. But that used to matter, now it doesn't. So it levels up the playing field, which is why someone like a wetter workshops can export a movie every night to California, have it worked on while we're sleeping, export it back here and then we work on it during the day. You can get incredible productivity

gains by virtue of what's available. It's just common technology internationally. But we should relatively be better off. And I've just seen this like, you know, simplicity's been running for 10 years now. The environment for startups in New Zealand is so much more dynamic than it was 10 years ago. We've got an English middle class mindset about business. We think that big businesses and listed businesses and traditional businesses and traditional career paths and go and become a lawyer or go and become an accountant.

Right, Very English middle class way of thinking about success. But actually quietly, what we've been doing is actually becoming a much more entrepreneurial and diverse economy witnessed by the fact that we still, and I know I hang on this, but I think this is really significant. We are still growing as an economy for all this bad news. We're still growing and we just had our principal savings asset, our houses all go down in value. That really says something about how much more robust and diverse our economy is now than the way it was even 10 years ago. And that's only going

to get better. It's interesting what you're talking about with the investing in New Zealand and the opportunities for investing here and using Kiwisaver to do so. A few weeks back I had Bernard Hickey on and one of the things that he believes quite strongly is that we should use Kiwisaver and say it can only be invested in New Zealand and that that would really boost up a lot of the opportunities here. What do you think about something like that? Or is that too hard and fast of a rule? Yeah, it is too hard and fast. I mean, I see where Bernard's coming

from and I have a lot of respect for the way he thinks about these things. But that would create a sort of a Dutch disease, like if you're forcing allocation. One of the great miracles of capitalism is you've got to let people succeed and fail and you have to allow countries to succeed and fail as well. You have to create. You will only be a nimble fighter of an economy if you have to fight for the resources, if you've got to work at it. But if you're basically, if you're instead of getting into the boxing ring and working out on this, you just sit

there and someone feeds you a meal every day because there's all this Kiwisaver money arriving, you're going to become bloated and fat and overvalued. So no, I don't agree with that. But I do agree with him that there needs to be some policy initiatives about encouraging investment in New Zealand because it's a competitive world out there. There's no point being. Roger Douglas, holier than thou. Free markets always work in every circumstance. If some country's putting a tariff on you or if someone's allowing accelerated

depreciation for capital investment or something. Countries play this game of fighting each other for competitive advantage and we should be playing that game too. We sort of are, but I think we can just get a little bit more, sort of a little bit more chutzpah in this, eh? Like, this is one of the things about the Aussies that I actually admire. Like, you know, they're arrogant, noisy and all that sort of thing, but man, they get in there and they fight Right. They've got so that sort of American entrepreneurial grit. And I think we just need a little bit of more of that. We

need a few policy settings to change, and I won't bore you with the details, but there's a handful of those things that could change, which would make the investment environment a lot. Hit me with a couple, though, because I did see something. I think it was an article where you were saying, if we changed KiwiSaver to allow more startup investing with the use of pockets. Yeah. Side pocketing. Side pockets,. Yeah. So one of the miracles of KiwiSaver is that if you, Francis, want to move from your current provider to simplicity, which of course is a sensible thing to do, that provider has to provide

all of that, your money, in cash within 10 days. Right. So if that provider was invested in an illiquid asset, say venture capital, private equity or whatever, they can't sell that within 10. They can't sell the company within 10 days and provide you with the cash. So they have to provide it from other sources of cash. Right. So if you have suddenly an inability to provide all of that money within 10 days, you have to suspend the KiwiSaver scheme. You have to say, hold on, nobody can take their money out because it would be unfair to give Frances all her cash and leave everybody

else with all of these extra illiquid assets. That immediately kills the KiwiSaver brand, because it doesn't matter who that was. Oh, my KiwiSaver. I can't get my KiwiSaver out and everyone's going to panic. Right? We don't want to do that. Right. So there's this concept called side pocketing, which is actually, it already exists for non KiwiSaver funds in New Zealand. Basically, what it says is, I'll tell you what, for instance, we've got these investments. You want all your money, we'll give you 98% of it now, but we'll keep that little 2% beside, and we'll fix that problem

over time and then we'll send it to you when we've solved it. So that means that KiwiSaver keeps on running. You don't get any suspensions, you don't get any panic. It's just a normal workout of what you call a distressed asset workout. If you're a manager like me, that means I know that the scheme is not gonna have to be suspended or wound up because there's one mistake or one asset goes wrong. That means I'm gonna be encouraged to make more Investments, a few more investments in those sorts of assets. And I'm talking about it might be venture capital, it might be private

equity, it could be build to rent housing, which we do all those things. That means that more money will get allocated into the part of the New Zealand economy which is actually the strongest, which is the small businesses, smaller liquid businesses. That's the heart and soul of our economy. Because at the moment, if you want to invest in New Zealand and you've got billions of dollars to invest, what do you invest in? Go to the same 20 companies in the stock market, you buy the same local government bonds and then you start scratching around saying oh this is actually a little bit harder now you can choose to make those investments

than we have and it's fine, the liquidity should be just fine. But if we really want to get a lot more money into New Zealand and a lot more money into high growth companies that don't want to be listed on the stock exchange, then we will have to allow for this thing called side pocketing. It's very common overseas, it's just new to New Zealand, we haven't experienced this before and, and we've just got to get the regulators and the legislators across the line on it and I'm highly confident that we'll get there. It's perfectly normal. It's just one of those little things and it just changes the mentality. Now I had this conversation with

Christopher Luxon and this is sort of an interesting thing about how I think we need to think about investing in New Zealand. I said to him, and by the way, this is a joke, right? But I said to him, I said prime Minister, I says, I have got 12 billionaire mates who each from my time working overseas and they each want to invest $10 billion in New Zealand. So it's about $120 billion. That's about a third of our GDP. I said look, if I got them all on a plane, would you meet them, show them round, give them

the red cover? He said oh absolutely, absolutely. And I said well I said I've got another piece of news for you. He says they're already here. He said the top 12 KiwiSaver managers will have a trillion dollars between them. And I bet that no politician knows the name of more than two of them. He says so the 12 richest people in New Zealand are already here and they're just going to get richer and richer and richer. So we have to encourage that money to be invested here because we've always had this, the foreigner's the person with the money we've always sucked up to offshore

capital because that was the only money available. If we wanted to build a paper mill or build some dams or whatever, we had to either borrow the money from offshore or we had to go and find an offshore investor. That doesn't have to be the case anymore. We are now masters of our own destiny. But we do have to create that connectivity because if we have this huge pool of money and it is huge, like, you know, to show you what can happen, Australia started doing this in 1990. Here we are in 2026. Australia has

five times our population, 30 times our savings. Wow. I think it's the second or third biggest savings pool in the world now. Retirement savings pool in the world. It's only 30 million people in Australia, right? So that's what's going to happen with New Zealand. If we get kiwisaver, right compulsion. We're going to have this huge pool of money. But we have to create that connectivity between the stuff that we want, the infrastructure we want, the businesses we want to start and that pool of money. Because the easiest thing for any fund manager to do is just push

a button and send it overseas, buy more Nvidia shares. It's so easy, right? So you have to create a competitive environment where people want to invest in it. But. And that does require politicians, regulators, fund managers, business. We have got to get together and get our heads around this opportunity because for generations no one's ever had this opportunity, no one's ever had to think this way, right? So we have to change our way of thinking

and start being a lot more optimistic and saying, hey, we want this. We've actually got the money here. How do we make that a sensible idea for all involved? Quick interruption. To say, if you're enjoying this episode, you'll love the Market Memo, my weekly newsletter where I teach you how to actually invest. No jargon, no spreadsheets, just real talk about share shares and how to make your money work for you. It's the thing I wish I'd had when I was starting out. You can sign up for free at Franciscook Co NZ Invest. That's

Franciscook Co NZ Invest. But don't worry, I'll put the link in the show notes and the description of this podcast. All right, back to it. It's been really actually fascinating watching the election and Keely Sabre was one of the very first election promises this time around, which I thought was a fantastic, fascinating sign at the Times. And of course, coming up on 20 years of having Kiwisaver, there's been a lot of discussion of, you know, does it need a reset and a little bit of a overhaul? What have you seen in terms of the discussion that we're having around

Kiwisaver and the rules and the potential changes? Are we talking about the right things with it or are some things being missed? Kiwisaver's really good. Like, it's actually the basic plumbing of Kiwisaver is quite miraculous, actually. It's very efficient, very easy and so on. So it's been well designed from the start. I think the problem with Kiwisaver now, and this is just my personal opinion, but I think it really risks starting to discriminate against the poor. Let's have a real conversation about the future

of New Zealand, the conversation that politicians won't have. Everyone acknowledges that national superannuation is a problem. Here's the degree of the problem. I think we spend $23 billion a year on it now. It's rising by $1 billion every year. That's a billion dollars. So that's a hospital and that's every year. So this year it's 1 billion, next year it's 2, the next year it's 3. So it's just sucking the life out of any ability of any government to redirect money towards anything else they want to spend money on. Right. So we have to deal with National

Super. We have to be honest with ourselves in saying that a kid born today is simply not going to have the national super payments that our parents have had and that we might still have. Just. Some people will be terrified hearing you say that. Absolutely. Absolutely. And that's why no one will electorally go and say, we've got to raise the retirement age, we've got to make it means sets or whatever you need to do. The only way you can have that conversation with the public, and particularly an aging public, because everyone sees they're getting closer

to national security and they want it right. The only way you can have that conversation is say, we will make you so wealthy that you won't need it, or you'll only need a little bit of it. And that comes from Kiwisaver. But let me give a message to the wealthy people out there who say, well, I'm going to have this money anyway. I can tell you, if you don't make Kiwisaver compulsory, the poor people, when you retire will be 100% dependent on the state and your taxes will be paying for that. You want everybody to be wealthy so that actually you don't have to be subsidizing

them. And also, does anyone want homeless people sleeping on the streets of New Zealand? Does anyone want abject poverty? Does anyone want the indignity of being old and poor? I think a society just fails itself when it allows that to happen. So we have to have this honest conversation with ourselves that we simply cannot afford to fund people's retirements the way we have. We have got to save our way to prosperity. So Kiwisavers must be compulsory. We also have to have rising contributions because you know what? We're all living longer. The demands that

we will have on the state and on our own savings will only grow the longer we live. Right? But basically we've got a really good system. If you look at the projections for KiwiSaver savings, they have consistently been beaten. We are saving more money than treasury has ever predicted we would save. And I think that that will carry on going. And it was really interesting, Francis, at this election, hey, Nashville had done a u turn on KiwiSaver. They used to dismantle it. I have never seen an example of national

government expanding Kiwisaver until now. As far as I read, they are more in favor of Kiwisaver than the party that invented it. Right. So labor are not fulfilling Michael Cullen's dream here. They are taking a very. Don't want to upset anybody. Middle of the road, don't do anything. Adventurous policy, which is of course completely contrary to what Michael Cullen did when he set it up. Right. And suddenly national have become now, this is the party of economic rationality. Save your way, Keep

the books in order. They suddenly worked out. Oh, hey, presto. Kiwisaver is really good. I'll give you what I think is the real reason for that, and I'm going to take some credit. We did a survey on KiwiSaver. The net promoter score is how much do people love your brand? Right. So a really, really positive net promoter score would be plus 50%. 50% of people would recommend you to somebody else. A really bad net promoter score might be minus five. You know, where the banks typically score. But if you have a look at. We put Cubisaver into a sort of a de facto

net promoter score survey. At the time, the most popular brand in the country was Whitaker's chocolate, plus 68. And of course, we all love Whittakers, don't we? I mean, I'd back that. You can tell from my tummy. Whittaker's Hokey Pokey, right? So can't resist it. I'm nut girl myself. Plus 68. You know where KiwiSaver. We just did. What's KiwiSaver? Not any brand of KiwiSaver, it's what KiwiSaver. Do you know what it rated? No, tell me. Plus 90. KiwiSaver is the most popular brand in the country. Now

that was an informal survey but Kiwisaver is easily the most popular brand in the country. And think about it, it actually kind of makes sense. Three million people have got one, none of them have ever gone bust. The balances have generally gone up and up more than people have been surprised because they've been regularly saving. People have bought their first home with it. It's been there in times of hardship. People have not had a bad experience generally with Kiwisaver. So when we told the politicians and I made a special point of telling all of them, if you've got a brand that high, brand weakness, if you attach your name

to it and you get in behind KiwiSaver, that is going to be a vote winner. And I actually think that I'm not going to take all credit, of course, politicians, many different inputs and so on, but I cannot believe that politicians who are very savvy about public perceptions of things would not have registered that as being a pretty interesting data point to say we want to be pro Kiwisaver. And of course it's exactly the same in Australia. Look at National Super. It's exactly the same in the United States. Look how people talk about their 401ks. These things are becoming a big store of wealth. In

fact in Australia now it's very rapidly becoming the primary source of wealth, like worth more than their house. If you are in favor of that then you are in favor of prosperity. So I think now there's no political party I know that says kiwisave is rubbish, we should dismantle it, which they used to. And I think they're all talking about expanding it in some way, shape or form that is really good news for New Zealand if that happens because it's where our health crisis, right? How do you afford a really

amazing free health system? You have to spend the money, right? In order to spend the money you need the tax revenue. In order to get the tax revenue you have to have economic growth and economic vitality. In order to get that, you have to have investment in the economy and the businesses to grow the tax revenue. And in order to invest you have to have saved the money. There has to be A big pool of savings. So if you have a look at. And there's a pretty close cor. In fact, there's a very close correlation to this all over the Western world, all through history,

those countries and sometimes civilizations that have saved their way to prosperity, not borrowed, but saved their way to prosperity, end up being far wealthier. And so if we want to pay, we want more nurses, we need more taxes, which means we need more growth, which means we need more investment, which means we need more savings. It all starts out with savings. So back in the old days when we could export all the butter and wool we needed,

that provided all the money to afford this. And we had. When we set up National super, we had eight working people for every retired person. Now it's four. By 2070 it'll be two. We can't afford it, so we're going to have to have this huge pool of savings. And Kiwisaver's the way the train's already left the station now it's got a great brand name, people like it, so let's double down and make it even bigger and better.

I also wonder a little bit because I certainly noticed a shift in how New Zealanders as individuals like to invest. As Kiwisaver came along, it sort of, and this is a little bit anecdotal, but it certainly had an effect where people learned by doing where people were putting money into the share market and big numbers for often the first time, and they sort of saw how it went up and down, they saw how it worked. They got more familiar with the share market through Kiwisaver and therefore more comfortable with it.

And then we had things like the big Covid investing boom. I think that was partly because people were already sort of warm to the idea, they were more familiar with it. It didn't feel as terrifying and weird. And there's also that impact on the business community where you think about business more as the big part of our future, the big investment, rather than, just, as you were saying, housing being what we were so wedded to for such a long time. I feel like Kiwisaver has had a really big impact on mentality and what we think

of as possible and just sort of opening doors that then maybe we walk through with other parts of our money, but it's still opening those doors. I feel if we were to use Kiwisaver and you've outlined what you think will be good for individuals and I think they're really interesting ideas, if we were also to use it to try to Promote our business sector or look after it more? Look after the startup world. What's a big change you would like to see to have it supporting our economy better?

Look, I'd like to be compulsory with rising contributions so fund managers can make very long term, very large investments with the confidence that the money's coming in the door. So that works for both the individuals and the overall then? Yeah. And to put a floor under poverty, I want everybody to have money in their account. You know, look, here's an example. The government currently spends, or will spend next year, $256 million on KiwiSaver subsidies. I call that a middle class tax credit. You could give every kid in the country 10 bucks a week into their

KiwiSaver account if it's compulsory, and then they'll have somewhere between 15 and $20,000 by the time they're 18. Every child may not matter for a rich kid. Certainly matters massively if you're living in south or West Auckland where I come from. Because with that of course comes empowerment. Money is power. I think also we need to up our level of maturity. I think that you've got to give sharesys a huge amount of kudos there for democratizing investing. The second phase of that now is people will realize that

the difference between investing and gambling, most people shares these accounts are gambling because they have no competitive advantage. They're trading on emotions and trends and all that sort of thing. But they'll work out that they can lose money as well as make money. And then they'll discover the virtues of diversification and dollar cost averaging and all that good stuff. But they deserve a huge amount of credit for getting people to think about that equally. Also Kiwisaver, which is a brilliantly designed scheme, I mean it was Michael Cullen's gift to this nation is already creating trust in something other than houses. And

the important thing about that is all this money invested in houses doesn't actually create that many jobs. It's not that productive. We are such an unproductive country, partly because we have so much damn money in our house. Right. If you invested it in a real economy, in real businesses, you create more jobs, more productivity and so on. So I think that you just some very simple settings because I think we're actually moving very strongly in the right direction here. And I don't think we have to change a lot dramatically. I do think there's a real thing about financial literacy and

everyone talks about financial literacy and drop it off, but it's unbelievable how many people make Dumb, simple decisions with money just because they don't know. Gonna stick the banking industry in the dock here on this one. How does an industry which makes $10 billion a year in pre tax profit not actually spend tens of millions, if not hundreds of millions of dollars a year on educating everybody about money, kids and all that sort of stuff? And there are too many people who make money by wanting you to be ignorant and apathetic. I really do want to start to see billboards by

banks and financial service providers that are talking numbers and facts and ways to save money. Rather than buy this product from us and happy families jumping into swimming pools, they're creating this subliminal message there. Money is difficult and hard. Give it to us and we'll look after it. Well, yeah, sort of. The attempts to educate people I think should just be better funded because as an investment, like if I just thought holistically in the economy, what's the best investment you could possibly make? Honest to goodness, I know I'm in the industry, but I'm running a nonprofit owned by a charity. The honest, the

best investment is just to get everybody just a little bit smarter with money. That would actually be the best long term investment you could possibly make. Because knowledge is power. You look at the funding of. I'm going to start to sound a little political here, but we've just spent $256 million on weapons for our helicopters that we will never fire or highly unlikely to. One tenth of that would fund the sorted websites, your podcasts, educational programs in schools, all this sort of thing. A little bit of money makes a massive impact there.

Okay, well if you were talking to someone who's listening to this and it's probably feeling a little tough for them at the moment on whatever sort of level they're at. I think most people on a lot of different incomes are feeling it's a bit tough and they're hearing what you're saying of it's about to get good and they're really hoping that you're right. What would you say to them in terms of hopefully how fast it might turn up and anything they can do to make the most of it. So it's not about to get good straight away, it's just going to improve. We're on this improving trend now. So it's going

to get a little better most of the time over a long period of time. That doesn't necessarily mean you're going to get bailed out or this angel will appear and provide you with all the money you need. Oh, what? No, I know, it's tough, eh? I have never seen a successful pessimist, Right? So if you want to get yourself in a pessimistic mindset, then you will certainly be creating the path for your own demise. Optimists win all the time, as tough as it is. So there's a mindset

about that. The second thing is I've never seen an investment in yourself being a bad investment. It can be anything. Going to the gym, investing in socializing with other people, clubs, societies, all that sort of thing. All of these things are investments in yourself. And ultimately, if you think about, and I tell this to my kids, I say, look, it doesn't matter what you do, just do it well. Because the people who do something well do well in life always. So some people say, oh, I've got to be a lawyer because hairdressers don't make any money. The best hairdressers

do really well because they love what they do and they do it really well and they enjoy doing it. So find something you enjoy, invest in it heavily, do it well, and actually life will look after you. In this AI world we're going to this world of uncertainty, it's not actually that different, to be honest with you. This is just this generation's concern. My previous generation's concern was we had different ones, but we're going to die in nuclear war. The Internet was all going to put us out of work. This is AI's version two of the Internet. The spreadsheet was going to put every accountant out of work. Did it? No. There are more

accountants employed now than there ever have been. So don't rest on these naysayer conclusions. Doom and gloom, that's the easy message, the easy thing to say. So be optimistic, invest in yourself and trust that it will work out. Because 99 times out of 100 it does. Most people out there are actually doing pretty well, eh? It feels tough, but if you have a look, I mean, I've just been on holiday in Iraq. It's interesting watching a failed state like Iraq,

you come back and you realize, oh, there's so much that's good about New Zealand. They were wonderful people. I had a wonderful time, but boy, am I thankful to be living here. So what we're about to get into and what you should feel really optimistic about is that if money can make things happen and investable capital can make things happen, that's about to get. Well, it already is getting a little better. Now. You can see this with all of these high growth startups as blossoming in New Zealand. Now, that

is going to get consistently better for a long period of time. So that will mean more jobs, better paid jobs. But I can't predict to you right now what they'll look like. Who knows what will happen? But having a lot more money floating around in the economy is generally a way better place to be than having not very much. And New Zealand has had not very much for a long time and now we're about to have a whole lot more arriving a little bit at

a time. Sam, you've given me so much food for thought. You always do. I love this. It's. Brilliant. We could go for about three hours. Yeah,. Well, I'm in a very privileged position. I have the best job in the world to be able to do this. But I feel very impassioned about getting rid of some of this despondency out there and getting Kiwis into a more optimistic mindset. A hundred percent. Well, I'm certainly feeling more optimistic now. So you've at least done it for one person. You're. A natural optimist. This is why you're. In the boot. You set. Up your own business and you got a very positive.

Attitude. Like an idiot. Exactly. Oh, no, no, no, no. You made exactly the right decision. I love it. Hey, Sam Stubbs from Simplicity, such a delight talking to you as always. Thank. You. So much. Cheers. Thanks very much. Now, if this episode was helpful to you, send it to a friend. We can all level up with money and maybe get a bit of optimism in our lives too. Until next time, have a great day. This podcast can only give you general information about how things work in most situations. It's not individual financial advice. If you're

after that, a financial advisor is always the best bet.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. An Affair Just Caused A National Security Crisis And Hurt Your KiwiSaver At The Same Time

    Nov 19, 20266 minAudio

    Nvidia was the biggest company in the world. Now it is at the centre of a scandal and its share price has cratered. I join the TVNZ Breakfast team to explain what is happening, why your KiwiSaver is likely feeling it,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A 30-Year Mortgage Costs $626K in Interest. Here's How to Cut It

    Nov 18, 202620 minAudio

    What if you could pay off your mortgage years earlier with just a smidge of extra effort in the right place? Katie Wesney, Head Strategic Coach at EnableMe, joins Frances Cook on Making Cents to share the moves that...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. A Lawyer’s $100k Breakup & the Money Rules Every Couple Should Know

    Nov 15, 202645 minAudio

    Eight weeks before her wedding, lawyer Holly Egerton’s life fell apart. What followed was a brutal four-year legal battle over the house she helped build and nearly $100,000 in legal fees. Holly joins Frances Cook on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why NZ Could Benefit From an AI Crash

    Nov 12, 202616 minAudio

    I join RNZ Nights to talk through what is actually happening with AI valuations, what a correction or crash could mean for the average KiwiSaver balance, and why the sleepy New Zealand sharemarket might be better...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Experience Economy is Booming, I Went To Singapore Grand Prix To Find Out Why

    Nov 11, 202620 minAudio

    The luxury flex is changing: it is no longer about watches and handbags - it is about trips, access, and shared experiences. Even with cost-of-living headlines, Kiwis are breaking ticket sites, booking international...

    Credit the people on this episode