Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Making Cents

Making Cents artwork

How to Plan Your Retirement as If NZ Super Won't Be There

Jun 10, 202615 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Retirement planning is stressful enough without governments constantly threatening to move the goalposts. Means testing, wealth taxes, a rising retirement age; how much of it is real, and how much can you actually count on NZ Super? Katie Wesney, National Coaching Lead at EnableMe, joins us in the hot seat to cut through the noise. We get into whether the pension is a plan or just a foundation, what the actual numbers look like week to week in retirement, how KiwiSaver, property, and investments fit together, and why worrying about a wealth tax might be the most expensive mistake you make. Plus: the one mindset shift that separates people who reach financial freedom from people who are still waiting for a politician to sort it out. If retirement feels far away, close, or just confusing, this one's for you. In this episode: How much can you actually rely on NZ Super? What does retirement actually cost week to week? How KiwiSaver, property, and investments work together Should you worry about means testing or a wealth tax? How to build a retirement plan that doesn't depend on government settings staying the same If you have a letter you’d like us to answer, please send it through to ask@francescook.co.nz and you might feature on our next episode! Follow me everywhere! Facebook / https://www.facebook.com/FrancesCookNZ Instagram / https://www.instagram.com/francescooknz TikTok / https://www.tiktok.com/@francescooknz Join the Money Memo newsletter for a free weekly money tip in your inbox each week https://www.francescook.co.nz/subscribe Become a confident sharemarket investor by signing up to the Market Memo newsletter https://www.francescook.co.nz/invest #MakingCents #FrancesCook #MakingCentsPodcast #InvestingPodcast #MoneyPodcast #FinancialFreedom Production and video editing by Lana Byrne Audio engineering by Tash Chittock Filmed by Fanaticals

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Retirement is one of those conversations that gives people the ick. First it feels far away, then suddenly it's terrifyingly close. And the whole time you're trying to figure out what to do about it, the ground keeps shifting under your feet. Every election that rolls around, there are new questions. NZ super might get means tested, the age of retirement might go up, and if a wealth tax arrives, is there an argument that the savings you've been building could actually count against you? Honestly, how much can you actually count on the pension?

Well, welcome to Ask the Experts where each week people from inside the money world help us make sense of what's happening right now. In the hot seat, Katie Wesney, national coaching lead at EnableMe, who helps clients every day with exactly this. We're gonna pick your brains. Making Sense has partnered up with EnableMe to get you the strategies for reaching financial freedom faster. Head to their website to learn more. Visit Enable Me. Today, I want to help as many people as possible reach financial

freedom by taking control of their money. You can help me in that mission two really easy ways. First hit subscribe wherever you like to listen. YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts or any other podcast player. Then send this episode to a friend so we can all level up together. Then the show grows and I can keep giving you the money info that makes a difference for your life. Okay, back to it. In the hot seat, Katie Wesney, national coaching lead at Enable Me. Congrats on your promotion.

We love it. So I've got a great letter for you here. Hi, Francis. How real is the risk that future governments means test super or introduce a wealth tax? I'm trying to figure out how much to rely on super in my retirement planning. But if the rules could change, I'm not sure if it's safe to count on it. And besides, if saving more just makes you a target, what's the actual incentive? Few things wrapped up in this one. So let's start with. They want to know how much to rely on Super. What do you think? You must talk to people about this all the time. Yeah, we do.

And I think the younger you are, the harder it is to rely on it as it is at the moment. And I think you treat it the older you are as a foundation, not a plan. Single people living alone get paid 555 after tax per week from Super. And if you're a couple, I think it's about 854 a week at the moment. That often doesn't cover everything as well.

So we have to acknowledge that. I think The Massey University study found that that a single no frills metro budget is about 705 per week. That's already $150 over the pension. And if you want a little bit more wiggle room in terms of the odd holiday, fixing a car that breaks down, maybe helping out family, that rises to about $250 per week.

And when you're talking about couples, it's about 1,780 per week and the pension's 854. That's a huge shortfall. There is already a hole. So I think we need to acknowledge that. So we come back to what can we control and understanding the numbers and what you need to do going forward in terms of a plan. Well, exactly. I feel like that's a really tough part of this conversation, right? Where there is a reality of there are big levers that governments

can pull and there are big changes that they may or may not make. They talk about them a lot. Some of them happen, some of them don't. And then there is the, the point of, well, we're the ones who are going to have to live it. We're the ones who carry the risk of then going through life with or without these things and controlling those things for ourself. I mean, how do you balance those things when you are helping clients and talking to them about their money? Look at both sides of the equation. Because I think there is a real need to have that better collective

conversation in New Zealand in terms of what's sustainable. Cause the mass blows your mind in terms of an aging population. And what we're doing now likely is unsustainable as population changes. And you're never gonna have a plan based on government settings staying the same for 30 years as a collective. We need to be having a big debate, honestly, and asking questions like what happens to the vulnerable people that we might leave behind if we do get this wrong, what kind of society, what

we want to be, what is fair. So I think we need to be asking those questions and answering them honestly. But at an individual level, when I'm sat in front of a client, we talk about what they can influence and their plan, which is what they do every day. Yeah, absolutely. And so there is that balance, right, of you might have something like the pension that could help. Then you have things like Kiwisaver, which you can save into on your own, and then you have things like your own outside savings

and investments. How do you see those sorts of various factors? And if I've missed one Hit me with it. But how do you see those various factors interplaying with each other and what sort of emphasis you would put on each one? It's always a little bit of everything. You don't just do one thing. And I think it starts with ensuring that you have money left over every week. So that's quite simple. Well tricky in this environment actually to be honest, in terms of cost of living. But you have to ensure that you're working and that your income

is more than your outgoing. So that that's the place you start. Cause that feeds everything thereafter. I think understanding that accommodation question in terms of whether it's right for you to buy a house or not. Cause that is a big cost in retirement. In terms of if you are carrying a mortgage or rent, you think $555 for super at the moment. And having to rent. You can quite quickly see how the math ain't math. And I think we try and secure often that accommodation piece first

to be saving for a house. Have a good debt reduction strategy around that house. And then we're thinking about what other levers do we pull. Kiwisaver really solid foundation. Particularly when you are employed. You know, 3.5% now rising to 4 next year. I hope you're matching that in terms of if you are employed. So otherwise you're leaving money on the table. It's like giving up a pay rise. And in this environment a lot of people are getting pay rises much lower than that. So it's really worth having.

Absolutely. If at all, if at all. So best be pulling the levers that are available to you. And then you're also looking well if there are surplus funds over and above that in terms of that really solid foundation. What else should I be doing? Should I be investing in funds or potentially another property? What is right for me and my situation and my goals and. And how long I have to retirement. That really plays into strategy. Because the closer you are to retirement, the less strategies available to you. You've got a shorter trajectory.

So again, less likely to take on bigger risk. Yeah. And you have less time to do the heavy lifting for you. So you're gonna need more money. Yeah. And I think it's such a fallacy when people come and some people come and they're so proud to be mortgage free and it's amazing. But they've concentrated on just doing that and they're 60 and you can't eat your house. And there's an opportunity cost of just doing one thing in terms of not getting gains elsewhere. So I think to answer your questions, it's a little bit of everything,

but it's kind of where do you lean? But you've got to have that solid foundation that's universal in terms of cash flow, debt management and making sure you're pulling the levers available to you, like the KiwiSaver piece, et cetera. Not so fun fact. When you take on a 30 year mortgage, you'll probably pay more than double what you originally borrowed because of the cost of interest. That's probably not the Kiwi dream you bought into the team at EnableMeet. Specialise in taking charge of your money and growing your wealth,

including how to get rid of your mortgage faster. Book a consultation with an EnableMe financial advisor today by visiting Enable Me. It's interesting, as you say all that and I so agree, you've got to have some money coming in. This is why I always say your house might be an asset, it's not necessarily an investment unless you treat it a little differently. But if it's just the standard paid off house, not necessarily an investment, and you need investments that bring cash in, as this letter writer says, though they're worried about if something

like a wealth tax comes in, that they get penalized for working hard and trying to get themselves ahead. What do you think of that argument? It frustrates me. The settings will change. They will. I think we're naive to think that they won't. But even if means testing comes in, there will be thresholds. And I think if you have saved and grown wealth and you don't need a government contribution to live in retirement, in my mind, you

won, you won. That is the prize that you don't need that. And I think the fear of setting changes or people taking money off you, well, that's just an excuse to do nothing. And then you absolutely seal your fate in terms of what comes next and you are putting your fate in politicians agreeing the settings in time. Autonomy is important.

Control what you do and ensure you have a plan and you are growing your wealth to enable you not having to rely on the government in future. That is the prize. I could not agree more. I really could not agree more. And I think the way you've framed it there is so important. It's a little bit like when people talk to me about, oh, if I earn more, I'll pay more tax. And I, I get it. It's often people will look at the pay slip and be like, I lost how much to tax? And you can say, oh, you drive on Roads.

Oh, you get health care, yada yada. Yeah, when you're looking at the, the pay slip, that's not what we're thinking, it's not how it feels. But at the same time, like say you're paying 30% tax on something, you've still got the other 60%. You, you're still ahead of where you were. Are we going to cut off our nose despite our face? You're still ahead. You are, you are. And make the most of it because you only control what you control and what you bring in. And it's that classic. I see so many self employed people come to me and they're like,

oh, I'm not cutting back on that tax deductible. The tax deductible does not mean it's free. You are still needlessly spending money, you're just getting that tax benefit back, you've still lost the money. So again, classic, isn't it? Just in terms of how we justify things in our head, we all have a collective responsibility to use the resources that we have within us to contribute to us, our families, but also for the greater good.

And again, tax can be annoying, I appreciate that, but it facilitates a whole other layer in society. So again, control the controllables. You can't control the tax settings, you can't control what super looks like. It's almost like plan for it not to be there. And again, anything else is cream. I look at it and I think, you know, yeah, things could change. Things will change. Yes, actually, good point. Yeah, they will. But at the same time it's just like they could change in all sorts of directions and you might be penalized on this, you might be not

penalized on that. At the end of the day, all you can do is protect your fiefdom as best you can. And waiting for someone else to do it is to me the riskiest move of them all. Yeah, you're essentially banking a loss. You are essentially that. And you're putting your fate in someone else's hands and that does not feel like what anyone should be doing. Yeah, and I mean as much as, you know, all the love in the world to politicians, they do a tough job. At the same time, I don't trust any of them. Do you ever watch any of the debates around? I mean just recently we saw Winston Peters saying he wants to

change Kiwisaver. And God forbid that I be agreeing with Winston Peters in a public forum. Who would have thought, right? Stopped clocks, et cetera. Yeah, I know it's blowing my mind here, but I'm just so relieved to hear a politician for once adding to KiwiSaver, because we have seen it systematically stripped back over years and years and years. So to even have someone saying, hey, maybe we should be adding to it, I'm like, I'll take it. Do you watch any of these sort of debates around changing the age

or means testing or changing Kiwisaver? And I assume you would wait until things come into force, but do you watch any of these? Does any of it change the advice you give to your clients? None of it. Interesting. None of it. None of it. We're never relying on government settings, as I said, to stay the same for the next 30 years to execute on a plan. And I'm actually grateful that people are talking about it. We need to be talking about it more. The super question, it has to be sustainable and fixing it sooner

rather than later just means that we have that good kind of tailwind in terms of affecting change, so people aren't upended with quick change, which might be necessary in the future. I think it's easy to be complacent and when the headlines are screaming that super is changing, I think people sit up and they pay attention and I want them to pay attention because that's when you can take action and think about what you can control.

So I am grateful. But you've got to use that attention in terms of affecting change and doing something in terms of your own strategy and plan. Understand your number. What do you need in retirement? Are you on track or not? That is a really good place to start. You're speaking my language as ever. Thank you so much. Katie Wesley from Enable Me Now. If you have a question about anything, everything to do with money. We love getting Katie in here. So any excuse, send them through the email as askranciscook

co nz. We'll get under the skin of your questions for you. Until next time, have a great day. This podcast can only give you general information about how things work in most situations. Situations. It's not individual financial advice. If you're after that. A financial advisor is always the best bet.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. An Affair Just Caused A National Security Crisis And Hurt Your KiwiSaver At The Same Time

    Nov 19, 20266 minAudio

    Nvidia was the biggest company in the world. Now it is at the centre of a scandal and its share price has cratered. I join the TVNZ Breakfast team to explain what is happening, why your KiwiSaver is likely feeling it,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A 30-Year Mortgage Costs $626K in Interest. Here's How to Cut It

    Nov 18, 202620 minAudio

    What if you could pay off your mortgage years earlier with just a smidge of extra effort in the right place? Katie Wesney, Head Strategic Coach at EnableMe, joins Frances Cook on Making Cents to share the moves that...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. A Lawyer’s $100k Breakup & the Money Rules Every Couple Should Know

    Nov 15, 202645 minAudio

    Eight weeks before her wedding, lawyer Holly Egerton’s life fell apart. What followed was a brutal four-year legal battle over the house she helped build and nearly $100,000 in legal fees. Holly joins Frances Cook on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why NZ Could Benefit From an AI Crash

    Nov 12, 202616 minAudio

    I join RNZ Nights to talk through what is actually happening with AI valuations, what a correction or crash could mean for the average KiwiSaver balance, and why the sleepy New Zealand sharemarket might be better...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Experience Economy is Booming, I Went To Singapore Grand Prix To Find Out Why

    Nov 11, 202620 minAudio

    The luxury flex is changing: it is no longer about watches and handbags - it is about trips, access, and shared experiences. Even with cost-of-living headlines, Kiwis are breaking ticket sites, booking international...

    Credit the people on this episode