Frances Cook joins the TVNZ Breakfast team to explain the loyalty tax costing New Zealanders hundreds of dollars a year on power, insurance and banking, and the simple habit that can win it back without even switching providers. Follow me everywhere! Facebook / Frances Cook - Journalist Instagram / Frances | Money | Investing (@francescooknz) • Instagram profile TikTok / Frances Cook on TikTok Join the Money Memo newsletter for a free weekly money tip in your inbox each week https://www.francescook.co.nz/subscribe Become a confident sharemarket investor by signing up to the Market Memo newsletter https://www.francescook.co.nz/invest
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey, team. Being a good customer is surprisingly expensive. Loyalty, unfortunately, is not rewarded. New customers get the deals, loyal ones get the price creep. And it happens with your power company, your insurer, your bank. Stay longer and you'll probably pay more. Leave or even just threaten to, and suddenly there's a better offer on the table. It's a loyalty tax and most of us are paying it without realizing.
So I had a chat to the TVNZ breakfast team about how we can put a stop to it in our own lives and also totted up some of the ways it's costing you. It's a lot, they were nice enough to say. I could also share that chat here with you, so enjoy. We all want to be loyal customers, but is our loyalty getting us anywhere? Some would say no, with many companies creeping in a loyalty tax. So what does this mean and how could it be affecting you?
To tell us more is independent financial journalist Frances Cook. Good morning, Frances. What is a loyalty tax? Basically, you've stuck around, you haven't done anything, you've maybe been there for years and everyone else is getting a better place than you are. Where are we getting hit by these, what sort of services? Basically everywhere. But if you're thinking about any of your core bills, anything that sort of sticks around refreshes regularly, that that is where you are most likely to get a loyalty tax. So your power bill is shocking for it. Bank fees, insurance, and it's often these areas of life where we
are really struggling with the costs of it. So it really, really adds up. Power, absolute classic one. And power prices have gone up 12% just last year, 20% over the last two years. So we're really struggling with them. And then the classic thing is if you just go and have a little look@powerswitch.org nz super easy way to compare. The average person there saves $450 just by price comparing. That's considerable. Right. We've also got Billy Co nz. You can upload your power bill.
They'll give you a personalized comparison. The average person there apparently saves $700 a year. It's massive. So there was consumer research out this morning too, showing that more than a million households are likely paying too much for power. So what do they say? Half of the nation's households have stayed loyal to their power provider for at least five years. We just tend not to move. New Zealanders are quite famous for being what they call really sticky customers. So we just tend to, we pick someone we like, we stick around for it. And you would think Right.
It's what we know. Right. And it's always been the way. Yeah. And we've got a lot going on in our lives. You know, it's a lot to sit there and price compare in your evening. You'd rather just, you know, zone out in front of the tv. That's fine, I get it. Me too. But it could be costing you thousands of dollars, your insurance as well. Right. So that's another one where they just the exact same coverage. But if you shop around Consumer Inside also looked at that before and it could be a $1,600 difference over the course of a year. I mean these are really big costs.
What about the upside for loyalty? Is there ever or is that, you know, is there often ever any upside to it for a loyalty card? I've got the card. I must be getting some sort of benefit. No, no, none. It's really annoying. Right. So it tends to be that even when they run these really great deals, that's to attract new customers, some companies, but it is the MIN will let their existing customers know, hey, we've got this new deal and you could switch to it. Mostly they just leave you be. So be attracting all these new people for hundreds of dollars of
difference and just leaving their existing customers. If you have had one of your core costs not changed for anything over two years, you almost certainly could be doing better on it and getting a cheaper price. Your bank as well, there's a lot of these old very fee heavy accounts around and that's adding up every single day. Even things like using your Internet. Right. I mean I've had this before where after a few years you look at it and go, man, you know, this is obviously, you know that it's going up because they're sending you the email saying it's
gone up a little bit, but actually the services change. Right. So even things like broadband, you might be going to fibre and not realize that all these upgrades have taken place and you could essentially be paying the same or less for better services. Right? Yeah, yeah, exactly. And it's anything that comes out of your bank every single month and you've just signed up, check that. And I know it's a pain to go through and do these, but I think pick one per week and just say I'm just going to pick this one, do a quick price compare and often you'll find out your exact same provider has a cheaper deal, you don't even have to move.
Yeah, because that's the thing, isn't it? It's the admin of moving companies and the thought of being on hold with a call for ages, talking to someone in a call centre somewhere else, that's probably the thing that's putting people off, isn't it? Exactly. And you know, you mentioned loyalty cards earlier. I mean, that is a really classic one. They want keep you in the same place, they want to encourage that inertia, they want to keep you shopping with them. And that's why, you know, loyalty cards often mean that you can get the exact same thing even after the loyalty discount has been applied, the exact same thing for cheaper elsewhere.
But if you take advantage of the fact that they want to keep you there, you can often say, hey, I found this good deal. Will you match it? And nine times out of ten they will. So it's really worth doing. And I will say with banks, a lot of people are worried about those fees and things that they add up, but they say, oh, I don't want to move all my direct debits. It's a real pain. Get more prestigious. Yes, that too. But you know, open banking means that they can move all that stuff for you. All of your direct debits will come across with you automatically,
even if you change banks. So always good advice. Francis Cook, thank you so much for joining us. As always, this podcast can only give you general information about how things work in most situations. It's not individual financial advice. If you're after that, a financial advisor is always the best bet.
Nvidia was the biggest company in the world. Now it is at the centre of a scandal and its share price has cratered. I join the TVNZ Breakfast team to explain what is happening, why your KiwiSaver is likely feeling it,...
What if you could pay off your mortgage years earlier with just a smidge of extra effort in the right place? Katie Wesney, Head Strategic Coach at EnableMe, joins Frances Cook on Making Cents to share the moves that...
Eight weeks before her wedding, lawyer Holly Egerton’s life fell apart. What followed was a brutal four-year legal battle over the house she helped build and nearly $100,000 in legal fees. Holly joins Frances Cook on...
I join RNZ Nights to talk through what is actually happening with AI valuations, what a correction or crash could mean for the average KiwiSaver balance, and why the sleepy New Zealand sharemarket might be better...
The luxury flex is changing: it is no longer about watches and handbags - it is about trips, access, and shared experiences. Even with cost-of-living headlines, Kiwis are breaking ticket sites, booking international...