Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

make joy normal: Catholics in the new springtime

make joy normal:  Catholics in the new springtime artwork

the first two reasons to rethink carrots and sticks

Jan 12, 20269 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

send us a text via Fan Mail! 1. you have to be pretty creative, and you're probably already tired 2. it requires a lot of energy to determine what rewards/consequences work with whom, and you're probably already tired Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make Joy Normal Podcast!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00So I want to just talk a little bit about uh the idea of why uh attachment or relationship-oriented uh parenting is actually easier. Uh on the outset it might look harder because of the time commitment that it takes, because of the sort of one-on-one that is required, but why it might be easier than than what we would do otherwise. Okay. So culturally we're kind of in this place where uh we've seen generations of of really sort of hard-nosed parenting where everything is done, uh everything is cooperation is always gained by punishment.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Uh, if you don't do this, X will happen. Uh sort of the school of of um of hard knocks, authoritarian parenting. And uh on the other s extreme of that, parents who essentially, you know, just let their kids do whatever they want because it's too hard, uh, uh or they want to avoid the conflict of kind of getting into it with their kids. So they uh, you know, things like um don't provide really any discipline at all for their children.

SPEAKER_00So culturally, we know that those two things uh are are problematic, right? And so I would say, I don't know, you know, when this all started in the 70s or 80s, probably, but as we moved away from those extremes, that what we moved into thinking it was sort of a middle way was this idea of consequences uh or carrot and stick. Rewards and consequences are carrot and stick, which I talk a lot about. So culturally, that's what we've been doing for a couple of generations now, and I think that uh carrot and stick is probably, in my opinion, the most complex way we can gain cooperation from from our children.

SPEAKER_00And I'd like to go over over the next couple of days, just in a uh short framework, what why that is like why are why is carrot and stick um more time consuming, more difficult, more uh challenging than attachment parenting, and then kind of get into attachment and uh why it's easier, because I think ultimately it is. So, so carrots and stick, first of all, it can be uh successful, right? Um, we can secure the desired behavior we want, but I think that it has a lot of drawbacks.

SPEAKER_00Um, and sort of let's take a look at a couple of those today. So, one is that the biggest one, in my opinion, is that parents, because children grow and change rapidly, you know, every six months we're in a new phase, that we must constantly be finding new ways, new carrots, new sticks to address behaviors because the child is getting more savvy. It's taking, we have to up the ante in order to meet them where they're at.

SPEAKER_00Uh, and that we are uh they're also their their behaviors are changing. So not only their expectations of okay, what am I willing to jump through a hoop for, what punishment, what reward, because they're kind of the same thing. Uh, what am I willing to jump through a hoop for, or what am I willing to do in order to um to obtain the the goal that I'm after is going to change with the child as they get older, but also their behaviors are going to change.

SPEAKER_00So you're going to have to constantly be coming up with some new way of addressing a new problem. You also have to be really aware of that some reward or consequence that works in the privacy of your own home may not work effectively in public. And so, uh, whatever situation we find ourselves in, the child, the reward or consequence may not be effective, and we constantly have to be thinking up new ways to come up with rewards or consequences that effectively deal with the behavior that we're trying to mitigate.

SPEAKER_00Um here's just another example of that is that if your children are with their friends, they may respond more effectively or less effectively, depending on their relationship with that friend. The peer influence around them may make them more or less responsive according to how how that other child is going to view them or how that other child is going to respond. Here's an example of what I might mean by that is that, say, for example, um, you say, if you guys um you know come inside now, uh, I'll give you each a cookie, right?

SPEAKER_00You're trying to get them in the house, out of the sun or out of the rain, or whatever you're trying to do. And the normally that might not work with your child, but this particular day, because they have a friend there, the friend might say, Oh, I love cookies, let's go inside now. And they might, your child might say, Oh, okay, and follow along with that. Um, or alternately, you might say to your child, uh, come on inside, you can have a cookie, and that normally works for them. And the friend that they're with says, I don't care about cookies, I want to stay out here. And your child might say, No, I don't want a cookie, and decide to stay outside.

SPEAKER_00So we're constantly having to kind of chase down what works and what doesn't work on any given day or in any given situation or in any given new phase. So that's complicated. I think that's probably really making it a lot more complicated than it needs to be. So the second part of that, I'll talk about more tomorrow, but the second part of that is it requires a lot of energy to be on the cutting edge of what works in what situations with what child at what age.

SPEAKER_00Okay. So it's not going to be the same for every child either. And so if we have three children, we might have to be bouncing what works with any particular child at any given time in any given situation with rewards and consequences. And so we are really have a lot of balls in the air once we're talking about multiple children as well. Uh, and the other part of that is because different things work with different kids, there's a real fairness problem here, right?

SPEAKER_00Um, and in fact, it might even weigh out that you're you're, in a sense, um giving a consequence to a child who doesn't require one, uh, because maybe that child doesn't require the motivation, and yet, in fairness, you might have a child saying, Well, why don't they have to do X under these circumstances? Why don't they have to um uh get a punishment or get time out if they don't clean up the room? Well, maybe that's not an ongoing problem with a child cleaning up the room.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, but if you have to establish a fair uh consequence, if you don't clean up your room, you don't get to go out for ice cream, uh, that might not be fair because that child doesn't actually require uh a consequence for not cleaning for cleaning up the room is something they're just more cooperative about. And now we're forming them to actually require a consequence for something they were willing to do. Um, or uh a child has an issue with um getting something done, you know, you want them to put their shoes away, or everyone to put their shoes on.

SPEAKER_00If you don't put your shoes on, you're going to get X. Uh so how do we deal with the sort of the lack of fairness that may exist in different circumstances and with different temperaments? So those are just two of the things that I think are worth looking at in terms of why carrot and stick uh is something that we should be taking a look at. Parents have to constantly be finding new ways to address the demands that naturally come as a child gets older or is in different circumstances, and it requires an epic amount of energy to be on the cutting edge with what works.

SPEAKER_00So I'll leave you with those two things for today and um go through a couple more tomorrow. So God bless. Have a great day.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. culture of life - raising the next gen

    Nov 20, 20269 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. culture of life - men and women, ya, different

    Nov 13, 202610 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. culture of life - the Church leads

    Nov 6, 202614 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. culture of life - early inklings

    Oct 31, 202614 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Conversion - thoughts on Mickey's funeral

    Oct 17, 202610 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode