Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

make joy normal: Catholics in the new springtime

make joy normal:  Catholics in the new springtime artwork

moving from theory to practice, part two on BEHAVIOUR with Dr. Deborah MacNamara

Mar 6, 202650 minAudio

send us a text via Fan Mail! How do we make dealing with our kids behaviour easier? Dr. Deborah and I discuss key principles for strengthening connection and compliance in our children. 1:21 - Resilience is the fruit of good development 4:32 - Tears, sadness and facing futility 7:15 - Make it safe to feel 11:46 - How our brain is shaped 15:22 - Show up, care and decide 20:06 - It's a relational problem 24:43 - Avoid coercion // Come alongside the resistance 27:33 - Kids who struggle with transitions 29:54 - Who's in charge? When a child tries to take the lead 40:57 - Emotions, instinct and deep capacity to care 42:25 - Working ahead of a problem Dr. Deborah MacNamara (Website) As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Nourished: Connection, Food and Caring for Our Kids (And Everyone Else We Love) by Dr. Deborah MacNamara Rest, Play, Grow: Making Sense of Preschoolers (Or Anyone Who Acts Like One) by Dr. Deborah MacNamara Hold On to Your Kids: Why Parents Need to Matter More Than Peers by Dr. Gordon Neufeld, Dr. Gabor Mate carrot and stick: letting go (blog post) With Audible Standard you can now select one audiobook a month for only $8.99/month and enjoy a free 30-day trial. More on that here. Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make Joy Normal Podcast!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Hi, I'm Bonnie and welcome to this podcast. Join my guests and hosts and myself here. What are the coolest normalizing joy? Don't hesitate to reach out via thumbnail or email with questions or comments. If the podcast has touched you, leave a review and share with a friend. I'm so grateful for all your parents showing up with the desire to make joy normal in your family.

SPEAKER_02Good afternoon to all my listeners, and I want to welcome back our guest, Deborah McNamara. We did an episode specifically on relationship, but of course we're dealing with a lot of overlap. And so we have a couple of more episodes on behavior and on discipline, and hopefully, sort of finding some catalyst where we can move from the theory to the practice. And I was commenting earlier that you I think you do that really well. I think that's something that you hold really well to help us understand what's going on theoretically, but also what we need to do in practice and the guiding principles being really a primary item that we need to address because I think what we are looking for rules.

SPEAKER_02And that brings us to behaviors. So I'm assuming that most of the time people are coming to you because they're having a behavioral problem, right?

SPEAKER_00Or a learning problem, an emotional problem. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Some problem. Okay. So they're they're having a problem. Where for you does resilience, both of the parent and of the child, where does resilience fall into the big umbrella of behavior?

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. Well, resilience is really the fruit or the outcome when adversity and challenges, frustration, resistance, whatever the emotion that has been stirred up, when that has been brought to its developmental conclusion. We're more resist, we're more resilient, not getting our way when bad things happen, when we can't, you know, when we um don't like the agenda of someone else, you know, when something is just not working out, there's a lack, there's a loss.

SPEAKER_00Resilience is meant to be our human outcome. That we're, you know, I think it was Hemingway said, you know, to be stronger in your weakest places. And so we have this capacity as human beings to adapt and to become more confident and more equipped in the face of those lacks and losses. But that takes that's a huge developmental journey for a three-year-old. It's a cookie they don't get, or you know, if you're homeschooling, it could be math or English or whatever it is, the challenge, you know, this is too hard.

SPEAKER_00I want to give up. Uh, and you know, it could be your kid taking their driver's test and this is too hard, and I'm so scared. And, you know, you can see that trajectory, you know, to university, to the test they take there. And, you know, you want them to be increasingly equipped to take on harder and harder things. And so resilience is the fruit of good development, where a child has had to face things that might be difficult and has gone through the emotional journey of recovery, of release, of looking into the lack and loss and realizing I can survive this.

SPEAKER_00But here's the challenge is it's not a cognitive process, it's an emotional process. And that's where we get stuck in the place of the heart.

SPEAKER_02And I think, I think as a parent, it's it's important for parents to recognize that was a big leap in just because the first time I thought about it for me is recognizing that me saying no to the child about the cookie is as devastating to them as maybe me not getting the job that I wanted or not being able to afford the holiday I want to go on. Like the the it's it's sort of irrelevant. Like in their child world, the no, the hitting the wall, the absolutely not, that's not gonna happen, is just as devastating to them as our big no's in our our life.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. You know, would you say that's accurate?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think there was a wonderful quote. I can't remember if it was Mark Twain. Someone said we shouldn't compare the losses of a small child to the losses of a king, because for both they are equal, they are equivalent.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. And so so can we learn resilience? Because we've I think we live in a fragile culture, right? I think we've got increasingly fragile over the last three or four decades. I don't know. I mean, I don't know what we're doing.

SPEAKER_00I think fragility is certainly used with a lot of our children today, the idea that they can't handle not getting what they want. They fall apart when there's things get difficult, you know, they run away instead of running into something and having courage to tackle hard things. And I mean, you know, that's just I just go with how, you know, the the presenting concern is your child, do you need more resilience in your child? And this isn't something you learn, it's a it's an emotional process, it's a developmental process. So the question then is is how do we become increasingly equipped to handle when things don't go our way or bad things happen?

SPEAKER_00And it is about the journey towards tears and sadness and facing futility. One of the hardest things in life is to face futility, what cannot, will not change. You think about grief and loss and a death of someone or whatever the issue is upon us, like we are facing the ultimate. You can't bring them back, something has changed, you don't have control. And so it can move you to aggression, it can move you to frustration and attacking foul energy. It often does. It can move you to alarm that, oh my goodness, what else is gonna go wrong?

SPEAKER_00And you're extra careful and my health and whatever else is going on. It can move you into all sorts of pursuit to hold on, to cling, to clutch, to don't go and not want to be separate from everyone. It when you are facing separation, lack and loss, and some futility, it revs your whole emotional system to try to fix that problem. And sometimes it does. Sometimes frustration needs to be there. Sometimes it needs to push us to change what isn't working. Not every time should we accept stuff.

SPEAKER_00Sometimes the resiliency is to hang on, even though there it's painful, but you're like, this book this matters to me, and I'm gonna continue to find my tears about something that isn't working, like you know, something small, like writing a book. Uh, you know, there were a lot of tears, is all I'm saying. And I'm like, why do I want to do this? Well, because I believe this, I need to get this message out. It's burning a hole in me. Okay, so I'll stick with it. And so I was resilient. I decided to show up every day and write, even though there were some days where I throw at everything I wrote, where there were some days where I wrote, I didn't write much at all.

SPEAKER_00And there were some days I'm like, this is brilliant. It's so easy. It was a mixed bag. The resiliency was showing up every day and facing the challenge and the futilities and the frustration, but still caring enough to push forward. A child doesn't even get to that capacity for caring and frustration until five to seven. So, I mean, before that, like go easy on them. Resiliency is like it's really about finding tears about the cookie you can't have or the vitamin that's the wrong color, that your parent cut your toast into four instead of two.

SPEAKER_00And then, you know, that's just the way it is, honey. I'm sorry. Yes, you like a world where toast is in twos and today it's in fours. Yeah, you can be upset about it. Your body, you know, eat, don't eat. You'll figure it out, sweetie. Um, you know, or you make them new toast if that's what you want to do. It's fully up to you. But at some point, you know, it's allowing the child to feel the sadness and to feel the futility. You can't make them feel, you can only make it safe enough to feel. So don't get in the way of that safety. Make it okay that they can have their emotions, but you can still say what you need to say.

SPEAKER_00Like this is this is gonna be a no. So make it safe to feel. That is, if you want one sentence, that's the underpinning of resilience. I love that. Make it safe to feel, and you only feel safe in relationship. Like safety isn't something you pursue. Safety is the result of a caring relationship. And that in that relationship, then you feel safe enough. When you can say, I'm frustrated, I hate math, you know what, or I hate you for making me do math. Um, like, you know, not that you want your children to say that to you, but you can you can uh you can come back around.

SPEAKER_00I remember that incident with my daughter. I'm never doing math. I hate grade four math, you know, and blah, blah, blah. My teacher's stupid, they're making me do this. I'm like, look, here's the deal. Math's not going away. You can do it now, you can do it later, you can do it in a year from now. You can do your grade four math in grade five, you can do it in grade six, seven, or eight. But until grade four math is done, it's not done. I've done my math. I'll help you figure out your math, but you can figure out what year you want to do your math.

SPEAKER_01She I was mocking her a bit, but she did get the message that this is futile, that you know, there was a lot of hollering and screaming and running around, and yeah, it's hard.

SPEAKER_00And I know you're frustrated and wasn't making sense. Anyway, she eventually came back about half an hour, looked at it and said, Oh, that's how you do it. Because the brain releases, like when it can get to futility, it releases that pressure to do it a certain way. Everything's driving down one particular lane until the brain realizes that's not viable, there's no other capacity for another answer. So you got to hit the wall, as it were. And all you can do is a parent. Like, I can't talk her into like grade four. Well, don't you know?

SPEAKER_00And this can happen, and then I'll do this, and this is the consequences, and then there's no dessert and there's no screen time. Like, no, it's just like it's hard. You'll feel we're gonna figure it out. It's not going away, it needs to be done. Well, I can't do it tonight. We're gonna figure that out. Like, I'm not, I don't need, I don't have the answers to any of that. All I know is that she needs the answer that this isn't going away, this is part of your life, and we're gonna find a way through. And so there's a lot, there was a bit of hollering and yelling and screaming, whatever, let it come out. I really don't care. Better out than in.

SPEAKER_00Um, you know, the dogs know enough to go and hide when someone's yelling. That's all good.

SPEAKER_01They're they're taken care of.

SPEAKER_00Her older sister just doesn't care. And I'm the one just dealing with it. It's just fine, you know. So, anyway, within half an hour, an hour she was back at it. And, you know, the greatest irony, which she wouldn't even remember this incident. But you know, when university came around, she's like, Yeah, I think I might major in math.

SPEAKER_01And I'm just like, I'm like, Yes, thank you very much. I mean, you don't say I told you told so, but I'm just like, oh my gosh, like, yeah.

SPEAKER_00So resiliency, yes, yes, she got back to it, but oh, we're so impatient with those emotions that need to come out. Sometimes you don't hit the wall and you don't get to futility quick, and you have a sensitive kid, it might not take a half an hour, it might take 24 hours if it's something really big. And so, no, this isn't gonna work. No, this isn't gonna change. And if your child's tears get stuck, that's the thing. It's like we assume that everyone's got tears and can feel their sadness. That's not true.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, some kids lose that capacity to feel their sadness. You get emotional defenses and they can't get to it, and then you've got really chronic frustration and aggression. And there's no resiliency then. You can't talk them into that, you can't walk them towards that emotional vulnerability. You've got to warm up that emotional system, get those defenses away, and then we can start the process of resiliency uh again by walking into tears. So it's a beautiful thing to be so adaptive as a human being. Like when you realize we've got this capacity to whatever's coming down the line that we can adapt to that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Like that's incredible. When when we are looking at sort of resilience or capacity with a small child, really are we, in a sense, we have to start with our expectations, just understanding that that just isn't part of their brain right now. That's something that they're going to develop, but it's not going to Would you say to some degree that sort of temperament where a kid that's, you know, you say no about something, they freak out about it, or they just go, Oh, okay. Would you say to some degree that's sort of a temperamental thing? And the resiliency comes just over time.

SPEAKER_00Well, it certainly comes over time, and there are different temperaments in the sense of the nervous system reactivity. But how much you care about something usually is correlated to a lack in loss. Like if someone says, you know, like you don't really like chocolate, and they say, Well, I'm taking away chocolate, and you're just like, Well, I don't really don't care. It's not a big upset or, you know, the chocolate got lost. Who cares? Or teddy bear that you didn't even like. I mean, you're not going to get upset about it. So it's all about whether or not you care about something, if it's going to feel uncomfortable for you.

SPEAKER_00The the brain, what we know through the neuron with neuroscience is that the brain is shaped by exposure to things that that you cannot change, that that will not go your way, that are truly futile. Your brain is shaped by lack and loss, not actually by what is working. What is working is what's left when everything that doesn't work is pruned out. Right. Okay. So you prune out what isn't working, the brain says, ah, that doesn't work. Oh, that won't work.

SPEAKER_00That's why kids, when you say no to a cookie, they come at you with one response. And they're like, they get a no, and then they'll go, okay, well, what about this? And you're like, no.

SPEAKER_01And they say, well, Daddy said this, and then you're like, no. And their brain's like trying to find a doorway through. And you're like, clip, cut that neural, clip, cut that little neural pathway, clip, cut that neural pathway. And you'll actually see when all the little pathways have been clipped, and their brain just goes, but I really like that.

SPEAKER_00And you're like, Yeah, you'll have one later. And then you can just see the energy shifts, and there's no more pursuit. It's like it's like this position of rest or acceptance and adaptation has occurred. You are from a neural point of view, from a cellular point of view, you are not the same anymore. When your brain has realized that's futile.

SPEAKER_02It's funny. I had my oldest grandson. I just had this exact conversation with him. He was leaving the house and he was saying, Oh, oh, maybe can I take a, you know, can I have something to take home with me? Can I have something to take home with me? I'm finally actually no. Actually, we can't do that. Actually, no. And finally went, and I thought, okay. And then he put on his coat and gave me a hug and laughed.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. Neural apparatus intact, resiliency intact.

SPEAKER_00I can get, I can't, I don't always get what I want, but I get what I need. The Rolling Stones had, you know, that beautiful. I you don't always get what you want, but you get what you need. And that's the you just do that over and over and over and over again. Hit repeat, hit repeat. And the brain becomes shaped by that. This is not viable. This is a no. This is where my guardrails are up, and the brain can feel them, and then it just finds the path that's still working through there.

SPEAKER_02So I was hoping I could explore a few sort of common struggles that kids might have a small reaction to and they might have a big reaction to. And what guiding principles can we access? Can we practice to help us to know what to do in these situations? I remember one time years ago, a friend of mine saying, But what do I do when my child is jumping on the bed? And I said, That's up to you. I don't, I don't have there's no rule for that, right?

SPEAKER_02You have to decide if it's important enough that it's a yes or a no, right? And then how you're going to respond to that. But it was a funny thing, like, but we want rules. We want rules because rules are gonna make it easier. Rules don't make it easier, right? Um, because we're dealing with individuals, right?

SPEAKER_00And they make us feel safe, like we're doing it the right way. We just want, you know what? Here's the thing to be a parent is to have constantly thrown in your face all the things that you don't know.

SPEAKER_01As an adult, you think I've got here and I really would like to know. Why can't I know? I'm a grown-up.

SPEAKER_00To sit in ambiguity, to sit in uncertainty, to sit there, especially with someone you love, is so alarming and unsettling. And I think as a parent, you know, that's why the second and the third benefit from a more confident parent, usually, is because it's just like I can remember my parents talking about me, the firstborn. Like they were like, and yet they knew what to do with everyone else. And I'm like, well, that's why I'm a little more neurotic because you were figuring it out on me, right? You know, yeah, somewhat joking.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, I'm the guinea pig. And that's okay. Firstborns, you know, have a lot of traits as a result of that, uh, potentially. So um, yeah, you are having to sit on uncertainty. You don't know what's going on. And sometimes you have to learn by trial and error. You would say the same thing to your child. Sometimes you have to try some things you're learning by trial and error. Go give it another chance, go give it another go. As long as you're trying to be caring, you're trying to take the lead, you're looking out for their safety and their well-being, then you know, I mean, just don't be negligent.

SPEAKER_00Just get in there, but not overpowering and sit with some of the uncertainty. You could probably answer what to do with a child jumping on a bed a hundred ways, and that might not be right for that mother and child or father and child.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00How would we know how to answer that question? I wouldn't presume to have the arrogance to say I know what is needed in that situation. But be the caring leader, show up and decide what you want to do that day. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Step one, decide if you care if they jump on your bed. Like, do I actually care? You know, I mean, it's it's not wrong or right. Yeah. So so I'm gonna, I'm just gonna kind of pull out a couple of the things that came out of this email. So this is a big, often a battleground. And I mean, I would say anybody, if you're dealing with a battleground, read nourish, because I think very much what I'm trying to do in in my homeschool podcast is we talk about homeschooling all the time, but most of all it's about behavior, right?

SPEAKER_02Like, how do I get the child to do X? Right. Well, that's not the point. How can we be in this relationship? How can we be in this circumstance? Because if your child's having a fit, they're not gonna learn math, right? So so let's let's not talk about or let's not talk about math right now. We just don't need to go there. But I would say nourish is is such a great resource for applying the principles. And and let's be really, really clear. Nourish is not about what to eat.

SPEAKER_00No, you might think it's a book about food. There will be no direction on what snack to provide or when or how to, or you know, that you should cook all the time and eat together all the time. It's not that kind of book. It's about how caretaking, like our biggest place that we show up to take care of someone, is typically around food. We repeat that action over and over and over again every day, two to three times. Depends if you give snacks or whatever. And so that becomes a template for caretaking. How do you show up? Do you show up with coercion? Is there connection?

SPEAKER_00Is there uh good intentions? Is the environment warmth or is it fraught with um battles? And are you pushing and shoving or are you using relationship? And because as soon as you are in relationship with your child and you're taking the lead, the instincts and that sort of archetypal template to follow you kick in. They want to be like you, they want to copy, they want to imitate, they want to be good for you, they want to, you know, share the same values as you, they want to be like you, they talk like you, walk like you, eat like you. And so so much of what happens is that we are in the context of relationship, that's where caretaking happens, that's where learning happens, that's where eating happens, that's where sleep happens, that's where values uh acquisition happen, language happens, everything happens in the context of this relationship, which lowers, it creates a sense of safety.

SPEAKER_00So the brain can then pay attention and wire up according to the environment that they're in. So our job is to create a relationship, to create safety, and then to lead our children. But what happens is we're constantly met with behavioral and emotional challenges in our children that put us offside from one another. They aren't, you know, their emotions get the better of them and whatever, they're impulsive and or they're just upset that because math is really hard. And so now we've got uh like what if we said we don't have a behavioral problem, a learning problem, what if we have a relational problem?

SPEAKER_00Right. Then you're like, how am I going to lead? How am I gonna get through this? Holding on to the relationship, what do I do here to lead? And that's where your head starts to spin, right? Do I press pause? Do I come around? Do I let them, you know, express some frustration? Do I do all of that? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And when we're whenever we're day day in and day out, multiple times per day, we're we're sort of faced with these situations, one of them I'm gonna use is getting out the door. Yeah, right. So not because this is what we should do to get out the door in a safe and reasonable way, but that how how the many ways, um, you know, maybe we can discuss a few ways we might approach that as a parent so that we can get out the door, or so that we we have an understanding of what what it might take to get out the door, right?

SPEAKER_02And getting out the door is gonna get easier the more you do this. I mean, that's something that I absolutely, right?

SPEAKER_01We really hope. the goal. That's the goal.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that that, you know, children just become more you know, I I hate to use the word compliant because it sounds like, you know, they adapt. What's that? Yeah, they adapt. They adapt compliance or non-compliance. We tend to think in pretty, you know, black and white terms. You know, why are they compliant? Why are they not compliant? But they become compliant, I think, because the relationship is uh is intact and you're doing your job well, right? You're leading well. It doesn't mean they're always going to be compliant, but you get more compliance. 80%.

SPEAKER_00We're working to the 80%. Well and we do and we do want compliance. I mean of course speed limits on the road. We want compliance and it gets enforced. Like you're you're not just one person. You're part of a you know there's definitely challenges to leadership getting out the door. So what are some ways to think about this? Well if you have a small child in particular and under the age of five to seven we really always have to collect them. Whatever they're absorbed in and their attention is in, they live in that moment. So to get them out the door is usually overrated unless it's got some, you know, it really is exciting for them to get out the door.

SPEAKER_02Even if it is sometimes it's still a problem. They want to go to their friend's house but they're kicking and streaming. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So collecting before you direct, you know, it's everybody talks about collecting or connecting before you move along. But you know, when you're in a hurry or you've got a strong agenda, what happens is you just think I've done this a hundred times already, they should know. But especially if kids are, if there is neurodiversity and sensitivity or there is a lot of emotional activity, getting to the child's side and collecting before you direct or lead outside the home is generally not a bad strategy. So you know pay attention. Get into their face in a friendly way, you know, focus on what they're focusing on.

SPEAKER_00Try to see if you've got, you know, if they're ignoring you and they're not listening, you know they can hear you, but they're ignoring you. Then you know this is not, we're not going in the right direction here. So you've got to slow down figure out how am I going to collect them before I get out that the door. So collecting is is doing all things in in relationships. So that's number one. Number two is always a fallback for the immature or hard to lead is structure routine. And everybody I'm sure will know this, but structure and routine that we happens at a particular time and place that you know we have a class we have you know you've got your little board it's Monday, Tuesday, Friday, whatever it is and they know what's coming.

SPEAKER_00It's a structure and routine. And so it's not you they should adapt to that. They should um you know know that's coming and just sort of move through it without feeling as much coercion you know to go. And that's if they're following you. That's if they're depending upon you and they take your lead. You collect your structure routine and you go. The other thing that's really challenging is the more that you expect resistance from kids to transition, uh oftentimes we put a little bit more coercion into our responses.

SPEAKER_00So come on we got to go hurry up we're going to be late I've told you a hundred times. So what happens is especially kids when they feel pushed everybody but the more immature you are when you feel pushed someone's got a strong agenda coming at you you know there's futility sometimes you just have to you know uh abide by that but you have to have repeated confrontations that this is futile we are going to move we are going to you know stand in a straight line to go into the school if that's you know the case if that's where you're at that we are you know going to have to put on all this you know equipment to go outside in the forest to play you know so there should be some acceptance that some things are futile but sometimes kids haven't had their tears about it yet.

SPEAKER_00This is just the way it is we'll get outside when the snowsuit gets on or whatever it is. But sometimes the more commanding and demanding you are we do ourselves in hurry up. I've told you a hundred times and so their counter will their resistance and their opposition comes up like this and you can just feel that they're starting to slow down. That's chapter nine in Rest Play Grow counter will I know listen I wrote it from the perspective of as being a parent and also a developmentalist. So we have an instinct to resist when feeling coerced try not to provoke that structure and routine helps prevent against that collecting them helps prevent against that helps them want to get out the door and you know part of a strategy is to be less explicit to be more implicit.

SPEAKER_00So I wonder if you know they fix the slide uh you know because last time we were there that we wanted to go down the slide and that wasn't working. I'm really wondering you know or or it's really snowing outside wow we're gonna have to bring some hot chocolate. I'm gonna go get that and I'll meet you at the door like it's not hurry up get your shoes on we're heading out we're gonna be late the more that you push and you shove and parents will oftentimes say yeah you know what like I notice yeah when I'm in a hurry that nothing goes well. When I feel when I have like all the time in the world everything goes well I never let my kids know when if I was in a hurry or not it was like the kiss of death you know if the kiss of death it's like sharks they can just you know they can just tell and it's just yeah and they just start to slow down a little bit.

SPEAKER_00And then I would say if you do get into another place of resistance then just acknowledge it. Yeah you feel really hurried today and you didn't want to be hurried and you want to play with that we'll get back to that I can help you set it up here over here and I can see you know maybe you can you can do some of that but just come alongside the resistance.

SPEAKER_02Yeah you don't want to go I get it do I have to go yeah um but you know let the tears come yeah the not hurrying thing is a is a really interesting thing sometimes we're in a hurry sometimes we have an urgent situation you know and and so hurry happens but if we can avoid hurry right if we can factor that into our structure and routine we are so far ahead of the game if we plan well if we plan well right and so it's just one of those things that you know you're it's inevitable there's gonna be some things you can't but on the day to day if you can if you can factor in so you don't feel like okay I got to get out the door you know whatever that is like I'm all about buffers because I just I don't want to feel wound up.

SPEAKER_02I want a big buffer between all my things that I'm doing. And so I've always been like that and and but having kids was like oh okay the buffers need to be pretty big. I don't know if this is a helpful thing but if it helped in my situation my youngest daughter just did not transition well. She was a pretty easygoing kid but not for transitions, right? She's just very focused and into things. And at some point maybe she was eight or nine or something and and I said you know every time we try and go out of the door no matter how much notice I give you like you have 45 minutes, you have you know 30 minutes I'm giving it you know whatever.

SPEAKER_02But I think that was read as sort of threatening even though it wasn't but it was sort of had a you know for her that's how it felt. And so until finally I turned the conversation around and I said you know I don't want to feel frustrated going out the door I won't feel frustrated at you. I don't want to feel like I'm hounding you maybe that's how it's coming across but you tell me how long you need. And so we'd have this conversation every time we were going to, you know, okay well we're going to the lake later how long do you need right? And she would say some autonomy. She was quite specific right but it worked it would just change everything because then I would say okay we're at the 25 and then she was responsible for doing the things she needed to do.

SPEAKER_02Right. And I wasn't feeling frustrated anymore.

SPEAKER_00Yeah exactly some autonomy and some responsibility when when it's appropriate she's eight or nine I did the same thing with my kids. So when are you planning to do your homework like and the work that needs to be done uh what's your plan for the schedule in the morning you know what needs to be done. I don't need to be chasing you around getting dressed brushing your teeth you know I said you're old enough to figure that out you tell me what your schedule is and I'm here to provide but see you are still leading because it's not if you're going to get it done it's you have some autonomy to figure out how you're going to get it done.

SPEAKER_00So your will as a parent is there, but everybody, especially as a child gets a little older, they want to have some autonomy in how they do that. What I would say as a caveat is if you are constantly frustrated to get out the door, your child isn't able to, you're not able to easily collect them. You can feel there's a constant no when you want to move them in a particular direction the resistance and opposition the resistance and the opposition is really intense and you can anticipate that every request will be met by a no then I don't want you to think these strategies are going to work.

SPEAKER_00We've got to go back and say okay what's happened here that I can't lead my child we've got to work at that who's in charge chapter five what about the relationship why isn't the child why is the child trying to lead me or is resistant to my leadership and how do I take the lead again? Because one of the things that happens is when the child takes the lead in the relationship or they become peer oriented or they're attaching say it's um a split family in some ways like there's two homes the child can be holding on to a parent in the other home and be very resistant for the other one.

SPEAKER_00The child could be very peer oriented and following the cues of their peers and so adults come in, they feel like what are you telling me what to do? You're not my people or the child can feel like they're in charge of the relationship and then they're resistant to the parent telling them what to do. Resistance and opposition when it's chronic stuck and pervasive tells us something about the relationship. It could be you know the latest preoccupation with the PDA label or whatever is a you know a chronic level of resistance and opposition which is real counter will right as I would go down that line stuck counter will but there might be some neurodiversity here that makes it you know bristle yeah and so we have to make sense if a child isn't listening and following a lot of what parents get is okay have you tried this this this and this which are great strategies however which are relationally based.

SPEAKER_00However we also then have to take a step back and say does the child actually follow? Do they actually comply? Do they actually see you as their answer or has something happened here where that dance between you leading and then following is there's something in the way here that we've got to repair, fix, understand and find a way through and that's the problem is that so much of just behavior gets isolated. How do I fix this behavior? You forget about development you forget about emotions that you don't understand relationship.

SPEAKER_00Like so behavior becomes isolated it becomes seen as dysfunctional. You got to understand it what's stirring it up is it a four and a half year old with no impulse control and likes to live in the moment or is it a 14 year old who's peer oriented or trying to be in charge of you that's a different strategy. And so parents get frustrated like though that worked for a while or didn't I don't understand you know I don't know what I'm doing. If your child's stuck take a step back get some help get someone to support you that understands human development you're not alone this is happening everywhere.

SPEAKER_00It's not your home trust me it's it's everywhere I've never seen in my entire career for the last 30 years are children so stirred up so out of alignment with their parents and not because they don't have amazing parents or teachers. Something's really not working. And so that would be the message I'd send to everybody like please don't think this is all just what's happening. It's happening everywhere.

SPEAKER_02It's like it's in the water what do you think the biggest factors leading to that are too much separation.

SPEAKER_00It's too much separation and you could tease apart what separation looks like on many different levels um you know just threats to self it could be just from a geopolitical environmental like when kids pick up that or they feel adults being alarmed that creates separation. Then you had a pandemic where we didn't know what we were doing. You have an earthquake I see that in places that I've worked uh New Zealand and Christchurch big earthquakes you know and then you have fires and you have shootings and you have all this kind of stuff. Like how do we convey to our children that we're building a world that they can safe and count you know count on us when everything seems to you know turn it upside down in our environment and we have so much information they're now aware and they're seeing stuff.

SPEAKER_00So that environmental stuff is huge. And then you've got a culture that doesn't protect adults as the answer in terms of you know parents can be sidelined in all sorts of different ways you know and and not seen as the answer here. And so that's a whole other question. And then we've got a very peer-oriented culture where our children have for now in the fourth generation as you know Gordon and Gabber written hold on to your kids are now more attached to each other than ever before. So your child might be really attached to you you put them in a school environment or you can be a homeschooler and put them in homeschooling groups you're still going to find some of this here.

SPEAKER_02Yeah it's not a pensay for sure.

SPEAKER_00No but I mean you can reduce a lot of that with homeschooling which it can be one of the wonderful benefits to it and that it's hierarchically based if you have all your kids with you and you've got the age ranges up and down. But you still find it I still find it in the homeschooling groups that we've got peer orientation and cliques that are happening as well. And so your children get wounded so much separation so much wounding our children are losing their caring feelings and our parents are struggling and as well they should in today's climate you know a lack of support lack of you know extended family the financial pressures work pressures feelings of unsafety in their own communities lack of support like where do we go I think every generation of parents has said it's pretty bad but like and we give screens let's not forget that little doozy like I really think I really think this generation of parents you know I think Gordon even said to me once in some conversation yeah it'd be really tough to be a parent right now I'm like and you you know yeah yeah you get that perspective so it's tough but is it insurmountable?

SPEAKER_00No it's not I raise my own two children in this environment and you just can't take your eyes off the ball. My relationship with my kids is going to be central to shielding them to the resiliency they develop to leading them if I don't have that we're gonna have a really tough time today.

SPEAKER_02Well yeah and it's not just you know when when uh hold on to your kids came out for lack of a better term the sexiness of your peers right you know like that that was those relationships were very attractive very very um uh seductive that and now we have screens right as well I mean partly I think that's just uh you know actually attaching to what's going on on that screen because it's you know thrilling that the screen the information that's coming in right and and I mean I think is I didn't read a newspaper for decades right I didn't read a newspaper and listen to the news because I thought I don't need that I need to be here and that will take me out of this right and not that there are some things maybe we need to know but I don't think we need to know everything we need we know right it's information overload and the brain doesn't know how to titrate it because it's alarm-based and so the brain is going to be attracted to the alarm to the alarm to the alarm and once you get that emotion rolling and you know you're it's quite provocative to our emotional systems.

SPEAKER_00It's meant to grab it. It's one of the base emotions that is the highest order which is meant to grab our attention is the threat to self and the people we love. And so that's the challenge. So titrating it and having a relationship with it and you know never forgetting that you must be the the leader of your kids and and in a caring and firm way um that both of these things can exist and that you've got to be much more sensitized now to places where your children could be um that compete with your attachment with your kids but yet not paranoid about it.

SPEAKER_00And so it's this delicate dance kids will have friends. As long as those friends don't compete with adults for guidance then good. Fill your boots like those are great friends. You know we do have to think about building villages and you know collecting and when we go to the dentist or the doctor I am taking the lead on the introductions I am no I'll come in here. My child's five they don't know who you are you're telling them to open their mouth this is not gonna well no I'm not hovering or you know I actually just I know what's gonna work here for my kid. And so you know you've got to take the lead.

SPEAKER_02And you know yeah and parents sometimes feel intimidated like a doctor dance you know I think it'd be easier if you were out of the room right and like my kids need to I know it's easier unless you're not going to leave them and I've I've had to say that to a dentist like no I'll be sitting here this is my kid. Right? What are they gonna say to you? Okay well we're not gonna work on them well big deal I'll go to different dentists right but we can't be we can't be intimidated because I think there's a lot I mean I think all parenting books are written and all parenting podcasts and everything that's out there, they're all written with the idea to to help you right I hope so but in in the end I think much of that information intimidates.

SPEAKER_00Well and it and it pushes the the thing is is that information never made you a better parent. If it pushes you into your head and out of your instincts and your emotions and your yeah your insight I mean it's not we're just not a head we're heart and we're insight and intuition and so again we've we've inherited a model of human behavior and understanding that's very cognitively driven and we have machines that are very cognitively information based focus and it's like we're forgetting that what is truly human the most animating features of us is our capacity for imagination for play and for relationship and for caring deeply I remember I had my philosophy class I won't even say how many decades ago it was my first university philosophy class.

SPEAKER_01Someone said you should take philosophy it'll make you smarter and then I got into philosophy I'm like it might make my grade point lower actually it was a tough class but it was a brilliant class.

SPEAKER_00And I remember a philosophy instructor saying and remember this is decades ago what's the difference between a computer and a human being like if uh the chess game the the computer now for chess can now learn are we really that different you know it's now got the capacity to learn even though we haven't taught it like isn't like aren't we now can machines become conscious and like now we're like and I remember hit him arguing with everybody and my point to him was and I was proud of it at the time although I think he found a way around it but it was left as an unknown was but will they have emotion right will they have emotion when this is hardwired into us I knew even at 19 or 20 whatever I was that human emotion was what defined us.

SPEAKER_00And he said well we don't know we're gonna have to see if that comes and so what I would say is that all of the information that out there isn't going to save us as parents it's got to be connected to your emotions your instinct your insight and your deep capacity to care. I have seen caring parents figure out new and novel ways to take care of their kids and pay attention to when it didn't work and that they had to change it. So again and again don't let information blind you to your child.

SPEAKER_02Yeah if you think something's off then go get some help then talk to somebody it's okay that you don't know get some help to say you you when you reach out for help a good therapist or you know or a good counselor is also going to say you know I think I think there's a big issue here and we this is what we need but they might also say you know I think that you're you're doing a lot of good things right and and you know maybe we need to address this a little bit more or whatever right so so we don't have to be afraid that you know we need to overhaul everything we're doing and we look to them to guide and say what what might need doing right and I think that that's that's a great thing.

SPEAKER_02It was it was the first place we went when we were you know who I felt like we were in hot water because I just thought you know there's people out there who understand more about the brain than I do and I don't understand what's happening. I don't understand what's happening and it's scary, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah it is scary.

SPEAKER_02So on the sort of sort of wrap up kind of discussion on behavior, I wanted to ask if you would just spend a couple of minutes kind of talking about ways that we can kind of in a sense front load connection because I think that's one of the guiding principles that we absolutely have at our disposal to make dealing with behaviors easier in the long run, right? What can we do to connect with our child before there's a problem?

SPEAKER_00Yeah yeah exactly. And we will talk about discipline I know in the in the next episode like I think the best stance we can take is if we can work in the antecedents before there's a problem then yes I think that's it's always better on all of us, including you know us as parents. So what would that require? Well that would require probably noticing when things didn't go well number one and then working ahead of that the next time every time we go to the park every time we get out of the house every time this person or friend is around okay you only you know you can what is it um fool me once shame on shame on you fool me twice shame on me something like that yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah okay so that saying right so you how many times you go to the park and there's problems leaving or whatever right I remember that you know we'd go over to a friend's house and uh the kids had learned from the other kids oh we're gonna run away from the parents they never did that to me until some of these other kids and they were more peer oriented and so they weren't listening to the parents and oh my gosh it was so frustrating.

SPEAKER_00So then my kids thought oh isn't this fun this is what kids do. They play a game on their plant parents it never occurred to them not to listen in calm when it wasn't when it was time late. So they did that once I'm like, okay. So kept my patients, went and found them and said, we are going now. This is not working. This is not how we leave. We're going to talk about it later. Just, I was mad. And so get them home, put them to bed. Like it's no point having that conversation. So you're biding your time to have a conversation, but you got to collect them first. So I collected them up and said, listen, doesn't work when we go to friends' houses and you don't come when I call.

SPEAKER_00Like, you know, I'll come let you know when we're going, but like it doesn't work. When we go somewhere, we need to leave. When we're gonna leave, like I don't play that game. That isn't fun for me. That's that's not okay. So do you think you can handle that? Can I count on you that when we go do that again, I'll remind you. Can you can I count on you? And that's the magic words right there. Can I count on you? Because what you're doing is you're giving them an orientation to what you want. You're collecting them and using the power of your relationship to say, let's steer in this direction.

SPEAKER_00If they want to follow you, then you've already built that little framework of we're heading in this direction. This is the right thing to do. And if they're attached to you, they're going to adopt it much more readily. If they're not attached to you, and in fact, if they think they're the boss of you, they're going to do exactly the opposite. If they're attached to their peers, they're going to do the opposite and work to rule. So it working ahead of a problem requires a relationship. Something is usually not working, unless you're really clever and you can anticipate it.

SPEAKER_00Okay, this is what I need you to do, which sometimes I did get there. Like, you know, we're going to out for this outing. I need you to hold my hands. Uh, we only have a short time period or whatever it is. Can I count on you? Okay, okay. Now, what if they say no and say, well, that doesn't work. Okay. So I'm gonna let you think about it. We'll get back to it, you know, or what would be the hard part here for you that you might need my help with? Um, and they might say, well, you know, if they got into a big debate and argument about what's not fair, whatever, I'm like, well, I'll just let you leave and sit with it because it just doesn't work. It's a futility, right?

SPEAKER_00Or I might say, I hadn't thought about that. You're right, we can adjust this, but like, here's still the deal. So working ahead of the problem, getting the child on side, using your relationship is very powerful. And that's not just discipline, that actually is inculcating them with your values, with making them fit for society. This is the right thing to do. And it's not just a little bit, it's like it's for when they're young adults as well. Like I would do that with my nieces and nephews. If they're out of line at uh, and they're not often, but if they were out of line, one was swearing at Christmas time.

SPEAKER_00I'm like, like, what's up? Like, this is a Christmas family gathering. Like, we don't need those words here. If you need to go outside and do them, oh got in my face a little bit. I'm like, this isn't gonna change. Yeah, right. So there was a bit of a kerfuffle between us. And then I just said, we can talk about this later if you like, or we can go outside. Uh-uh, whatever. Anyway, came back around to me an hour later and said, Yeah, I'm really sorry. I guess I should not swear here. I'm like, Yeah, I know I knew you'd figure it out. But you're preserving your relationship and you're leading, you're just dropping the seed in, you're putting the futility there, you're not failing to be the adult to stand up and say, This is my job to say, hey, this is how, but doing it in a way that preserves that will to connect to you.

SPEAKER_00Uh you don't have to use a stick. You don't have to use a stick. If you use connection, you've got the greatest chance and not use the connection against them, which is you can't come here again if you do that. That's okay. Uh I'll continue this conversation with you. We'll continue to sort it out right now. I'm gonna go make the gravy. Um, you know, and you know, feed you uh, you know, here's your food, sweetie. I'm not gonna hold that against you, but we both know there's a conversation coming.

SPEAKER_00And so sometimes you have to bridge the things that are between you and hold on to the relationship. So we can work in the antecedents. We can have structure and routine, we can have make it really clear our expectations. Some kids, when they're alarmed, they want to know every little single thing that happens. And we're you don't have to give them every little single thing that happens. You can say, I give you to your, you know, your outing if they're going to a particular class or something, and that person will tell you what to do. The class is from eight to four, if it's, you know, or eight to three or whatever.

SPEAKER_00If you're gonna leave earlier, they know how to get a hold of me. If there's something they need me for, they'll get a hold of me. Well, what will I do? I don't know, but your teacher's gonna tell you. And I chose this for you, and I trust that, you know, and you can report back later, you know, what worked or didn't. That's fine. But this is what we're proceeding to do. So you work ahead of it, you know, you uh, but all of it depends on a child following you. Do they follow? Do they trust? Do they look up to you? And if you have a teenager, they need to have some autonomy, right? You need to have you have to do, you know, something for your phys ed credit.

SPEAKER_00What are you gonna pick from these things that we have available? What do you want to do? I can make any of these work. It's up to you. You have some autonomy here. This is your school, this is your, you know, your credit in this area. What are you gonna do for that?

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And so sometimes they do get autonomy, but not until they're at that age where, you know, autonomy is appropriate.

SPEAKER_02Exactly, yeah. Okay, well, I'd love for us to sort of dive into discipline for our next uh episode. So, uh, but this gives, I feel like this gives us the the last two episodes, gives us a really good uh platform to now talk about discipline. Now talk about talk about discipline. So thank you so much.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. culture of life - raising the next gen

    Nov 20, 20269 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. culture of life - men and women, ya, different

    Nov 13, 202610 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. culture of life - the Church leads

    Nov 6, 202614 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. culture of life - early inklings

    Oct 31, 202614 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Conversion - thoughts on Mickey's funeral

    Oct 17, 202610 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode