Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

make joy normal: Catholics in the new springtime

make joy normal:  Catholics in the new springtime artwork

my take on it: lying

Oct 14, 202512 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

send us a text via Fan Mail! When kids lie - what are parents to do?! here's the instagram post on lying I mention. Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make Joy Normal Podcast!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hey, good afternoon. I have a part two from a question that was submitted, sort of a multiple part question from a listener, that was submitted. And I wanted to kind of break them down because there was a couple of questions uh in there. So the second question uh was about lying, right? So the listener says, you know, my husband and I are confused about where this behavior comes from. They're they're obviously by the tone of the email, they're really sensitive parents and um are very aware of uh kind of keeping the relationship intact and all that.

SPEAKER_00So so um, you know, we we do not give up punishments, but we hold boundaries when necessary in as loving a way as possible. Um and uh to this to this, they feel like to some degree this is this particular child's behavior is uh is kind of part of his temperament. So this child was also uh struggling with um with sort of being vulnerable or being uh you know, telling them he was fine when he wasn't fine.

SPEAKER_00Um so the last episode, uh my take on it was just sort of, you know, how that how that might uh how we might respond to that particular um uh attitude or that sort of sense of bravado, you know, that that uh prevents kids from being able to just say, you know, I'm I hurt myself or I'm you know sad or whatever. So this particular part is about lying. So so one of the things that I I'm just gonna say this out there, and this is nothing, this is not a pride moment, okay?

SPEAKER_00I didn't have a lot of problems with lying uh or sneakiness. It just wasn't, it wasn't something that um our family was affected by very badly. And please believe me, we had lots of other issues, but please believe me. I don't think it was anything that, like, because I was some sort of supermomor or anything, because I wasn't. Um, and I just lying was never really a big part of the program. Um, you know, so so my old experiences was limited. Happened, you know, once in a while, but it it was really limited.

SPEAKER_00Um just the temperament of my children, I think. Uh, but I, you know, lots of known lost parents over the years that have had to uh struggle, struggle with this. It's common, it's really common. Um and so one of the things that I know for sure is to punish a child for lying uh is absolutely not going to do anything, right? Um and and so we should not punish a child for lying. We absolutely need to talk about it. We need to make it part of the conversation. Like all things that seem like they need to be punished, uh, it's something that needs to be talked about, right?

SPEAKER_00And we need to talk about it uh in a general way that this is this is not not something that we do and this is why, but we also need to talk about it in a specific way if it's actually happening. You know, this is uh this is the consequences of uh not being truthful in this particular circumstance, right? This is how it affected other people, this is how it affected uh, you know, your your uh um relationship with your siblings, maybe or or whatever. So we need to talk about it, but if we're reactive or if we're just punishing them, it's not really going to teach them anything, right?

SPEAKER_00It's not going to help them to stop lying. Uh so a couple of things. First of all, I'm a big advocate of uh, as you know, about talking about things outside the circumstances. So as a family, you know, if you're talking about virtue in general, which you know most thoughtful families are, you're talking about virtue, you're talking about uh, you know, how it is we want to live in the world and and function well, and you know, it's also about our relationship with God primarily, but but our relationship with others, which is you know how our relationship with God plays out.

SPEAKER_00So we we need to be talking about that, the reasons why we need to be honest, right? Uh in in that sort of global general way. Maybe it's something that we include if it's a problem in your family, maybe, or even if it's not, included in your prayer life. You know, Lord help us to be uh forthright, help us to be honest uh and not ever feel like we need to withhold, uh, withhold something because we'll get in trouble. Whatever, maybe that's part of your prayer life. Um, but also to to deal with things uh outside the circumstances.

SPEAKER_00So if you have a child who's lying, to um to deal with that outside of the circumstances of the lying, like not to not to try to catch them up in the lie, because that's puts a kid's defenses up and puts them uh in a in a situation where uh we're we're um we're accusing them of something and they feel they have to defend themselves. So even if in some circumstances they it might not come to a lie, uh if we approve like uh, you know, you didn't do such and such, right?

SPEAKER_00That that child is going to uh to go go on the defensive, right? But if we can deal with it outside of the circumstances, you notice a lie, you know, maybe, maybe it's opportune depending on the age of the child, temperament, various other circumstances. Maybe you say, uh, okay, um they say they did something and they didn't actually do it. It's like I actually noticed that that was not done. So what time did you do that? Um, or or uh can you tell me about when you did that? Because I need to know, I need a little bit more information because it doesn't look done, right?

SPEAKER_00Uh or maybe they hit their sibling and they lie about it. Well, you know, I'm I'm having a hard time understanding why they are uh your little sibling is is uh reacting to you hitting them. Um, you know, what are the what were the circumstances? What did that look like? You know, tell me about that. Um you know, maybe it was an accident. There could be circumstances that that uh, you know, but if we kind of stay curious about why uh why they are saying something that doesn't sound true, you know.

SPEAKER_00But often we make the best traction when we deal with something outside the circumstances. So for example, at bedtime, you know, um, you know, something happened today that I'm concerned about, right? I asked you if you had uh had fed the dog, and uh the dog was obviously really hungry and you said you did. So I'm just wondering uh, you know, what happened there. I'm just wondering if you'd maybe like to talk about that. You know, I'm not gonna get mad at you, uh, but I would like to to kind of get to the bottom of this.

SPEAKER_00I don't know really know what happened. Um, you know, so kind of staying curious and being curious with them as opposed to threatening them, but bringing it up outside of the circumstances, right? Now maybe they're still going to deny uh that they were lying or deny that they didn't do the thing that they said they did or or whatever, but uh but if they if we kind of give them an opportunity that feels safe, so it's an opportunity to connect. So maybe they say to you, um, yeah, I actually didn't feed the dog and you know, I just was busy playing Playmobil and I just didn't uh feel like it.

SPEAKER_00So when you asked me, I said yes, I had, but that wasn't actually true. So, you know, really a great opportunity for connection, like give them a big hug. You know, thank you so much for being honest with me. You know, I know that's hard, especially when you've already said something that wasn't true, to then admit that it wasn't true. That's really hard, and especially at your age. So thank you so much for that. I really, really appreciate it. And I just want our relationship to be honest. I want you to be able to tell me something. Even if you said to me, if you were in the middle of a game and said, Mom, can I do it in 20 minutes so I can finish up this game?

SPEAKER_00I might even say, you know what, I can see you're having a lot of fun, maybe I'll do that for you. Or I might say, Yeah, you can do that in 20 minutes. So so we can talk about things and it's gonna be okay. Right? So dealing with it outside of the circumstances when the when your suspicion isn't high, when your maybe emotions are riding high, and also when the child is feeling uh guilty, defense, you know, uh defensive, that we wanna we wanna avoid, sort of let that um dissipate a bit before we actually kind of climb in there and say, okay, what was going on here?

SPEAKER_00Um so it's a conversation, right? All all virtue, all discipline is so much more effective as a conversation. Uh, you know, this is why we don't do this. This is the impact that your behavior would have. So you talk about it in circumstances like if you did this and also when you did this, right? Uh so that's just, you know, part of our walking with them as as parents, right? Um, I also think that it's really important to focus on the action and not the person, right?

SPEAKER_00Um, so that the person did something that was uh not appropriate behavior. But, you know, we want to be careful not to say, um, you know, nobody likes a liar or uh or I never thought you'd be a liar. Now, you know, we don't want to label them as um as a person who does a thing. Because, you know, reality is kids live up to our expectations of them, right? So let's not do that. It's like, you know, lying's not okay, and you know, this lie happened, and let's deal with that.

SPEAKER_00Uh, but but, you know, don't make it about them as a person, make it about this particular behavior, not okay, right? And even if there's somebody who misbehaves a lot, right, if we start referring to them as, you know, as misbehaving, uh, you know, that that it's the person misbehaving as opposed to their behavior's not okay, you know, that's that's kind of a problem in other areas than than lying, right? Um couple of other things that crossed my mind is that we can also phrase questions in such a way that uh that kids are less kind of in a sense less caught or less likely to lie.

SPEAKER_00So for example, if we say, uh, you know, did you clean your room? Uh did you tidy the living room? Um we could say something like, so they might, if they're busy with something, might say, Oh, yeah, I did that already, or if they're want to get out the door or something. You know, that it could potentially increase the uh possibility of a child lying. But if we say something like, I noticed the living room wasn't done that, when's that going to happen? Right? Uh, or I notice that you haven't fed the dog yet. So what's the plan for that?

SPEAKER_00Right? So that we're not actually, we're just telling them what we've seen, and uh and then it's less likely they're sort of gonna have that defensive kind of lying reaction. Um so uh yeah, so those are just some of my thoughts on on lying and um how we might respond to it in the same way. Also, we might respond to other sort of unsavory type behaviors that our kids do, and you know, because they're kids. But also, there was a great just a few days ago, was actually the same day I got this email, uh, Deborah McNamara posted on her Instagram, posted a um kind of a little Instagram reel on uh on lying that's really good.

SPEAKER_00And so she's kind of talking about different stuff that I'm talking about here, more about the idea of lying being a um being a kind of a developmental milestone in a way. Uh, and not that we're celebrating lying, we still have to deal with lying, but that we that we need to see that there's actually something positive and maturing in a brain that can lie, right? And that, and then you know, sort of what do we do about it then. So I'll put the link to that in uh in the show notes to this episode.

SPEAKER_00So God bless you, have a great day.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. culture of life - raising the next gen

    Nov 20, 20269 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. culture of life - men and women, ya, different

    Nov 13, 202610 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. culture of life - the Church leads

    Nov 6, 202614 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. culture of life - early inklings

    Oct 31, 202614 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Conversion - thoughts on Mickey's funeral

    Oct 17, 202610 minAudio

    send us a text via Fan Mail! Contact On Instagram at @make.joy.normal By email at makejoynormal@gmail.com Search podcast episodes by topic www.bonnielandry.ca Shop my recommended resources Thanks for listening to Make...

    Credit the people on this episode