Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Lutheran Confessions

Lutheran Confessions artwork

Live with DJ Deutch

Sep 18, 202656 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00We're live with DJ Deutch, who is a friend and also somebody who's running for city attorney in the city of Fayetteville, Arkansas. And this is a little bit outside of the orbit of what some of my substacks have been for people who are coming on because we're not going to be like probably not overtly religious or Lutheran, but... DJ's really an interesting person,

SPEAKER_00and I'm excited about his run for office, and so we're going to talk about what he's doing. So I thought it'd be fun to just start with you introducing yourself.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, for sure. So my name's DJ Deutsch. I'm originally from Australia. I've been out of Australia for about, should be about 14 years now. My background's a little... Bobbing and weaving, but it's all guided by something that Clint and I share, a commitment to social justice and what that looks like in all the various forms. I started my career working on specifically refugee and asylum seeker policy back in Australia.

SPEAKER_01Australia really was leading the way in how to be cruel to refugees quite a while ago. So I worked on that with a couple of organizations. After that, I came to the US. I had a brief stint in New Orleans where I worked with kids that had been released from juvenile detention in a school setting, providing extra support.

SPEAKER_00And that was a real kind of wake up call.

SPEAKER_01Well, you know, it was a real kind of hard introduction to race relations in the US and how poverty is so heavily tied with that in urban areas. That was a real kind of like jolt to the system. I got a master's in public administration at Columbia University. And then I spent my middle year at Columbia. I spent it in Palestine. I studied Arabic at Birzeit University, which is just outside of Ramallah. And that was, you know, I'd always been kind of committed to the region and committed to this idea that in

SPEAKER_01the West, we're often doing harm in places that we will never see. And we're doing profound harm. Because I was seeing the other side of that with refugees. So that kind of changed and pushed me on this trajectory where I worked with UNRWA, the UN Relief and Work Agency, which is the Agency for Palestine Refugees. I worked with a local organization in Palestine that represented prisoners in the Israeli military courts. And then I spent some time in Syrian refugee camps on the border between Syria and Lebanon.

SPEAKER_01And that all led me back here where I went to law school and I've been working as a public defender ever since I graduated. So that's kind of my long weaving strand.

SPEAKER_00So the logic to move from working in Palestine is to move to Fayetteville, Arkansas?

SPEAKER_01You know, I came back just because I had to be confronted with the hard truth that What good are you doing by simply bearing witness? And the idea that these kind of human rights discourses, they really require, I can't remember who the quote came from, but there's a quote that, you know, begging on someone's rights, and maybe it was Frederick Douglass, begging on someone's rights implies that your oppressor has a conscience or

SPEAKER_01that your oppressor is paying attention to this rights discourse. So it was really a question of like, How can I be doing good in a real tangible way and not a way that just gives you a pat on the back? So that's kind of what led me to be here where we are rooted, where one of my children was born, where I feel like every day I'm serving the community.

SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah, so you came to the University of Arkansas what year?

SPEAKER_01No, so I went to SMU. I went to SMU for law school.

SPEAKER_00Oh, you went to SMU. Okay.

SPEAKER_01And I only did that, I did that in 2020, so fairly recently.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01It was really my pivot.

SPEAKER_00And then you came here and you've been a public defender since you got here? Yeah, since 2023. All right. So really quick for viewers, just in case they don't know, what's a public defender do?

SPEAKER_01So a public defender is someone who specifically in the realm of criminal law represents people who can't afford to hire an attorney. So who are a certain portion of the poverty guidelines. And I will take their case from the initial charging from the prosecutor all the way through the trial phase to a verdict. And the thing that a lot of people don't necessarily think about is that it's close to 90% of all criminal cases involve people in poverty.

SPEAKER_01So we receive an overwhelming majority of those cases.

SPEAKER_00Gets to know very intimately a certain economic class within the community in which they serve. 100%. Yeah. And that is a county position?

SPEAKER_01It's a state office, and there are county positions and there are state positions. And the time that I've been there, I've been both a state and a county.

SPEAKER_00Okay. So if you pay... Your county assessor dues, some of that may go to funding this or possibly your state taxes. Is that like some kind of granting system that the state does, like based on need within certain communities or how do they do that?

SPEAKER_01No, so it's a budgeting process out of Little Rock that goes to the Public Defenders Commission and the Public Defender Commission sort of divvies it up based on population and case size.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01So there are... There are public defenders spread across the state. It's just in the smaller counties, sometimes they are part-time public defenders in Pulaski, Benton County, Crawford County, Washington County, etc. You've got a full-blown office due to the case numbers.

SPEAKER_00Right. And there's multiple public defenders in Washington County.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Okay. So you've been doing that. This is how you practice law. And then... This is the part that's always interesting within elections and government. You have these overlapping layers. So there's multiple cities in the county. Somebody who works for the county represents anybody in the county. But now you're running for a position where you'd be practicing law as the city attorney and you'd be representing what?

SPEAKER_00So what's that?

SPEAKER_01The city attorney, you know, The city attorney at its core is like having an in-house counsel specifically for the mayor, the city council and the sort of city departments under the direction of the mayor. So what that involves is providing legal counsel on their operations and their actions. It means drafting or reviewing any legal document that the city is engaging or entering into. So contracts, agreements,

SPEAKER_01drafting ordinances and ensuring that ordinances comply with state laws, federal laws, pre-existing ordinances, leading and handling any litigation that the city is involved in. There's also directing and overseeing the policy of the city prosecutor. And there's a kind of enforcement mechanism as well, making decisions and enforcing the existing ordinances. You know, the tree ordinance is something that gets talked about a lot and determining

SPEAKER_01the sort of priorities around that. That's the kind of core functions of the city attorney.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Yeah. So like when I have had... When my awareness of the fact that there is a city attorney comes up, it's typically because I'll be at a city council meeting or I'll talk to somebody like the mayor and they'll say, well, we wanted to do that, but the city attorney said. So that's one part, right? These leaders are consulting about whether or not they can pursue certain courses of action and your job would be to let them know what the law says around,

SPEAKER_00say, state or federal level laws. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, it's funny that you bring that up because that's really what got me here. People came to me in the community who were trying to take action on sort of housing issues. And they said, look, the city attorney, they felt, firstly, they felt that they weren't being assisted with the drafting of ordinances that they wanted to pass, that they had to do all the work for that. And then secondly, they felt that the city attorney's office was just saying no, no, no, and not necessarily helping them with the Well, how do we get there? You know, with the existing legal framework, how do we navigate that?

SPEAKER_00Right. Yes. And I've seen that over time that, well, and I think this is just a kind of a cultural thing. In the broader culture, when people think about legal stuff, and if a lawyer says, well, you probably shouldn't do that because you might, you know, break the law or get sued or whatever, that's kind of a killer, right? Like that's a, okay, then we're not even going to go there. Um, but you're saying the city attorney could also like say,

SPEAKER_00okay, let's take what you want to do. Let's look at the law and let's figure out how you could still do what you're wanting to do without breaking any of the laws or whatever.

SPEAKER_01And you know, that's a core principle. That's a core principle. This whole thing, this whole campaign that we're running here is that there's the traditional bucket of things that the city attorney does providing that legal advice, directing the litigation, et cetera. And then there's the secondary thing that is a path that has not been treaded by the city attorney's office, but is 100% within its legal right to do so. And I feel as an elected position, it's duty is to say, okay, well, the city council is saying, but we're trying to get a policy that achieves XYZ goals or XYZ goals. How do we get there in the context of preemption by the state?

SPEAKER_01Did you like that little XYZ, XYZ thing?

SPEAKER_00I was waiting for something to come out.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Can you say aluminum now for me?

SPEAKER_01You mean aluminum? Yeah, I can say aluminum. But that's a crucial aspect of things that the city attorney's office has almost been reluctant to do, even though it's within its purview. And I think my big opinion on the way that state power is handled, and I know this is getting real meta on this very quickly, but the state has certain powers to do certain things, and those are divvied up into certain roles. If you do not put a clear value position on that exercise of power,

SPEAKER_01then it is exercised for the default kind of set of principles or set of power, which is money, which is big money at this moment.

SPEAKER_00Right. Because they can hire a lot of lawyers, for one. And researchers who can figure out pathways for them that are things that you as just a regular citizen may never ever

SPEAKER_01They can draft an ordinance. They can come ready with it. They can give it to a city council member who's sympathetic to them. And that city council member can bring it in, bring it to the city's attorney's office and say, is this legally sound? City attorney's office gives it a rubber stamp. That's it. Ordinary citizens don't have that power. Although they could. They could. There's no reason that they can't. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01The citizens' ordinance desk, which is citizens will be able to come to the city attorney's office and we will do our best to draft an ordinance that addresses their need or work with them to sort of craft something that can kind of move in that direction and then give it to the city council. Of course, it's up to the city council whether they pass that or not. But to have that step where someone's saying, hey, this is how we put it into the law for you, I think is an essential aspect of a functioning democracy.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so going back to that, because I'm kind of operating on the premise that just pure stating what things are is valuable in this conversation. So the city attorney is elected to this role. You named stuff earlier that stuff I don't necessarily think about most of the time as a regular citizen. Like on the daily, the other thing the city attorney is probably doing is reviewing a bunch of things that city staff, mayor, And then how often is the city attorney representing the city because there's

SPEAKER_00an actual lawsuit? Like is that also a thing? Like if I filed a lawsuit against the city of Fayetteville on something, is that you're the person that would be representing the city then?

SPEAKER_01Yes. And, you know, currently there are a few going at this very moment. There's the one in relation to that student housing that was slated to go on Dixon Street. I think the Airbnb case is still, you know, the city's Airbnb quota and licensing. I think that's still going on as well.

SPEAKER_00So these are all lawsuits related to development, essentially?

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00Okay. But would it also represent lawsuits that are more, like, say... I don't know, like somebody falls in a big hole and dies and you file a lawsuit against the city for criminal negligence. Is that also represented by the city attorney or is that something else?

SPEAKER_01So there's the Municipal League that can handle some compensation claims, but the division of labor can go either way. So that could be something that the city attorney has to deal with or it could be something covered by the Municipal League.

SPEAKER_00So really the city attorney, more than anything else, is around the development stuff and around ordinances.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And the big part of it is also reviewing documents. A lot of it is reviewing contracts and agreements that the city enters into. But litigation is a big piece. Let's take the Collier Drugstore sign ordinance. That was a city attorney and a city attorney's office litigation. So most litigation, the sheer bulk of litigation that comes against the city, the city attorney's office handles as the chief litigant.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Okay, so now we know what you do. So my other kind of fundamental question is why is this an elected office?

SPEAKER_01Do we know that? You know, that's a great question. It was determined by ordinance to be an elected position. Most cities don't have it as an elected position, but Fayetteville made that decision way back when. I couldn't tell you what their thinking on that was. My position on why things are elected positions is that you want two things out of your person that you may not get. You want someone who is qualified and capable to do the job, but then you want someone that actually is beholden in some way to the people

SPEAKER_01and represents people. Okay, so like in a lot of cities, the city attorney is selected and hired by? The city itself. The mayor? Yeah. Okay.

SPEAKER_00Like basically every New York movie. Yeah, pretty much. Okay, so that's not the system we have. We have a system where we all get to elect the city attorney. And so then this finally, I think, brings us to what I've heard you have as a kind of a platform for the role is pretty different than what your opponent's campaigning on. Yeah. To really summarize what I've heard

SPEAKER_00Blake Pennington say is he's essentially running on kind of this two legs of experience. So he's been the aide to Kit Williams or whatever.

SPEAKER_01He's the deputy city attorney. He's the chief deputy city attorney.

SPEAKER_00Right. So experience and then he's going to keep Representing the city in the way, kind of in the habits and the practices that you've seen, essentially. That's really his whole platform.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I was at an event with him last night and it was interesting because we were very much presenting contrasting views of that. But that was his kind of platform is that I've been there and that he's going to be the trusted arbiter that he's been.

SPEAKER_00Those are his words. Yeah, I'm going to keep doing this like I've been doing it, basically.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so then that opens the space for you to talk a little bit about, I've heard you say your kind of your key platform pieces, but I'd love for you to have, to share those.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so... We are aiming to exercise the power of the city attorney's office in a way that is specifically aimed at making the law work for people and ensuring that people's voices are heard and that they have access to the similar streams or the similar facilities that big business has access to all the time through their lobbyists and their lawyers. We're running on three key platforms. One is Representing the people in court when it is necessary and when it is optimal

SPEAKER_01to do so and not shying away from those fights. The second is direct democracy. So I already spoke about the citizens' ordinance desk, but it's a real commitment to the idea that not only are we beholden to some sort of entity of the city,

SPEAKER_00we are beholden to

SPEAKER_01the people.

SPEAKER_00We should be working for the people.

SPEAKER_01And third is transparency and accountability. It's that... We will enter in, you know, my office will not approve non-disclosure agreements. The city council can handle that as they wish. The mayor can handle that as they wish. But we don't find them to be A, in the interest of the public, or B, necessarily to be the best legal option to pursue whatever development goals the city is trying to pursue.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so let's take these kind of in turn questions. If people, and I'm not going to assume that everybody who's going to watch this has read everything that I've written on my blog, but if people do read my blog, they can go back and they can find, I did do a whole thing about the Swarm Arrow controversy that we have going on in our municipality slash county. And that's where these NDAs took place.

SPEAKER_00But to Kind of spell that out. Basically, like, the way our city was involved in that was they signed NDAs with Swarm Arrow agreeing not to disclose information about the process that led up to Swarm Arrow coming here, essentially, right? Is that the... Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So, can you say, like, why a city attorney would or wouldn't

SPEAKER_01So in this particular case for the Swarm Aero stuff, we've actually got the counterfactual, right? Because the original site that was being eyed by Swarm Aero was Rogers, which makes a lot of sense because it seems that between the Northwest Arkansas Council and Steve Womack's kind of involvement in that whole Swarm Aero thing, Rogers seems. And what happened was that Rogers and their city attorney refused to sign the non-disclosure agreement that Fayetteville later signed. So we really

SPEAKER_00know that there was a city who did exactly what you're saying they should have done here.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Rogers did exactly what they should have done when they looked at this agreement and they thought it was outlandish. And, you know, a lot of it was kind of hypothetical until we had the agreements in front of us, which only happened in June, I think, when the agreements got released as part of the FOIA lawsuit. There are a few key reasons to not sign that particular agreement. Firstly, it made the agreement itself confidential information.

SPEAKER_01So what that meant was that completely cut against state FOIA law. The agreement must always be released if requested to be released. The second thing that really cut against it in the agreement was that at the request of Swarm Aero, the city had to return all confidential information to Swarm Aero. Meaning the agreement itself, right? There was a clause in the agreement that said you have to hand over this agreement if we ask for it and essentially not keep a copy, right? The third problem with it was that there was a clause in there that said if

SPEAKER_01the city is legally required to disclose any of this information, they must take proper legal remedy to fight against that disclosure. So if the city was being forced to complain about any of that stuff, they would have to, per the agreement, fight it in court. And then the third or the fourth kind of part of it is that it subject the municipality to California law. It had a choice of law clause, meaning that if the city were to be sued under that agreement, that it could be processed in a California law court,

SPEAKER_01which there are legal issues with and there are practical issues with for a municipality, a sovereign under the state of Arkansas to put itself under California law. So for those key reasons, It should not have been entered into if you were giving sound legal advice.

SPEAKER_00And we know for sure that Bolt, that Kit and Blake and other people were directly involved in that process.

SPEAKER_01What we know for sure is that Blake reviewed the agreement. Put a video on his Instagram about it. I saw a document from that FOIA case. There was an affidavit signed by him saying that he did review a non-disclosure agreement from Swarm Arrow. But before that, all we knew was we got the whole FOIA stash of emails. And there were the emails going back and forth about the non-disclosure agreement itself. There was no email there sending the non-disclosure agreement to Blake.

SPEAKER_01No email saying, hey, I've reviewed it, it looks fine. But there was an email that said, Blake has given us the go-ahead on the non-disclosure agreement. I think it says, Blake says we're good to go.

SPEAKER_00Right, okay, so... Sorry, go ahead. No, you go ahead. Well, okay, so my reaction to that...

SPEAKER_01I have multiple...

SPEAKER_00The California one is just funny to me on some levels because, I don't know, everybody always has a weird relationship to California, right? It's one of those states, kind of like Texas, where it's like an exception that everybody wants to be on another level and doesn't want to admit it or I don't know what. But anyway, California is weird. It makes a lot of sense to me that it would be alarming that we would put ourselves under the jurisdiction of laws of another state,

SPEAKER_00and probably that's a violation of Arkansas state law. But the part that makes me just really worried as a voter is if Blake signed off on that and was willing to sign off on things that hide information from regular citizens of the city, What's to keep them from repeating that process in the future? I just don't even know what would. And if they do a better job of hiding it next time.

SPEAKER_01One thing we have to be concerned about, and this is kind of off the trail of things that I've spoken about, but is issue three that's coming up for a vote this year. It's an amendment to the Arkansas Constitution to develop these economic development zones. And these economic development zones will have to be instituted by the legislature, but then their formation is instituted by either the municipality or the county. And in these zones, there are a few things that are problematic about it.

SPEAKER_01The board that is established itself will collect all the additional property tax as property taxes grow. So your taxes will be shifted and go to the board. The board can then divvy out that money to economic development projects. But the big problem in terms of information is that FOIA laws are going to be turned on their head in those zones and in the stuff that the board is actually engaged in. It will be the corporation involved with the information who will decide if it can be disclosed.

SPEAKER_01So we've got something coming down the pipeline that will really kind of potentially gut Arkansas's quite strong FOIA laws. And it will be, say Fayetteville establishes one of these, it will be the city attorney's office that is drafting the constitution for that economic development board.

SPEAKER_00Right. So we're kind of standing at the precipice of

SPEAKER_01FOIA law becoming completely beholden to corporate capture.

SPEAKER_00Well, right. And the thing about that is, and this is why I think more voters should care about this. When I was planning this conversation with you today, there was one part of me that was thinking to myself, like, well, are we just going to harp on the NDAs? Because that's just one thing. And then there's another part of me that's like, Coming to a city near you, you know, like 72-foot fighter drones with bombs, which most people don't want in their communities,

SPEAKER_00don't want built in their communities, don't want flying over their communities, etc. And so this topic of NDAs, mixed with what you just mentioned, means you want to elect the person who's going to ensure as much as they can that you're going to know what's coming to your neighborhood next time. Next year. Or in four years or whatever.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, and we've got to place this in the context of the overall growth of war industry in the state. Right. That it is, you know, Arkansas is a prime producer for munitions and now growing more and more high-tech munitions.

SPEAKER_00It's our biggest export now.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And that is the reality, right? And I think We can harp on the swarm era and the NDAs, but I think it captures a bigger issue that we're confronting, right? It is a prime example of, well, I was just following what was legal, leading to a form of corporate capture of our institutions of governance and leading to outcomes that the people of Fayetteville or the people of any city do not support and do not want.

SPEAKER_01More than anything, what people have told me is that they feel, and not only just in Fayetteville, but Fayetteville specifically, they feel that the institutions of government do not listen to them, that their voices don't matter at all. And in the Fayetteville context, they believe that they can get up and give comments. I know you were at that Swarm Arrow hearing where many people spoke, and more people spoke against it than for it easily. But there were people that got up and said, well, you know, it'd be a real shame if Fayetteville didn't give the thumbs up on this

SPEAKER_01because maybe investment, maybe this, maybe that. And it just became clear that if you are a normal working person here and you can't get an NDA and you can't shove it in someone's face and you can't dangle investment, that the institutions of government do not work for you. And that's what a lot of people are feeling. And it's what the Swarm Arrow issue captures so much. Or so clearly is that we are bending over backwards for these kinds of interests

SPEAKER_01against the will of the people. And the city attorney's office is that kind of, you know, I don't think it's too far fetched to say, especially looking at Rogers, right? Swarm said, okay, we're not going to build here. They're not going to sign the NDA. So if Mr. Pennington had said, There's a problem with this NDA. We're not going to sign it. Then there's a chance that that wouldn't have come to be that the drone factory building 72-foot AI-powered military drones to replace

SPEAKER_01the Reaper drone wouldn't be here in Fayetteville.

SPEAKER_00Right. He was like the major hinge. He could have been the deciding or a significant deciding factor in what we currently have coming in. Yeah. And I don't think, so I know for sure because he has a group that's, you know, campaigning for him, they're going to want to, like, diminish how big that actually is. But I don't want to diminish how big that actually is. It's like huge. It's a massive decision that he kind of made for all of us, essentially.

SPEAKER_00And with no real citizen input. Yeah. Okay, so I heard you say at the picnic I was at with you last week when you were listing these things and you talked about the citizens, what are you calling that? Citizens' Ordnance Desk. Desk, thank you. The one that you named as a big example is habitability.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so there have been a lot of housing advocates. Arkansas is one of the states that doesn't have a standard of habitability for rental homes.

SPEAKER_00Right. Which to put that in context for people from the pastor side of the equation means I have visited homes of people that I've helped who are living on dirt floors in their apartments because there's no floor and that's legal or they don't have a front door because that's legal or, and you can keep going on, but like the level of what's okay for a landlord to do and not rectify is insane.

SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep. Pine Bluff passed an ordinance. This is one of those examples that Mr. Pennington likes to point to a lot of state preemption. The state of Arkansas loves to say, well, cities, we don't care how progressive you are, you can't deal with XYZ, another XYZ. And housing is a big one because they're like, well, this is a private contract between you and the landlord. The municipality can't become involved. But Pine Bluff attempted to With an ordinance

SPEAKER_01that I believe ultimately will be struck down because it still uses the avenue of a standard of habitability as a kind of legal constraint. I believe that there's a clear avenue using the city's safety power. So code power, right? This got to be up to this code. This got to be up to that code. That for rental properties, establishing property. We already need to register if you're renting usually in the city, but establishing a registry with a fixed code of safety,

SPEAKER_01using that avenue because the safety power is under the policing power for the municipality. If we are willing to go out on a limb on that and maybe have to have a fight with the state. If we're fighting for people to not have dirt floors or to have front doors, then I'm completely fine to have that fight. But that is an avenue through which I know members on the city council, because we've spoken on it, want to try and get a standard of habitability. And that's a prime example of how we chart the course to get there, right?

SPEAKER_01We can't just say, well, you know, we've preempted that. There's nothing we can do.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've heard that. I've lived here for 15 years. And what I've heard over and over again from city leadership has always been like, well, our hands are tied. The state laws are blank. As opposed to what are the avenues we could pursue, including pressure points and strategies that could get us to a different place. Yeah. I'm imagining that like a big thing, which of course this would take a lot of movement and a lot of spaces, but I'm assuming that the city of Pine Bluff and the city of Fayetteville and city

SPEAKER_00of whatever could file some kind of lawsuit.

SPEAKER_01Hmm.

SPEAKER_00Right? To pursue something if they thought that there was this shared thing where the state was going against what they needed to enforce at the municipal level?

SPEAKER_01Because the state is the power that sits on top of the municipalities and the municipality derived their power in large part, that becomes somewhat difficult in terms of that particular question. But if for whatever reason... You know, you can have a judge define what is the realm of the state and what is the realm of the municipality. But suing the state in that regard becomes difficult, especially since the law is quite clear on standard of habitability. But the avenue for code,

SPEAKER_01the avenue for safety code is wide open for the municipality to sort of explore.

SPEAKER_00Okay, I just want to point out to everybody who's watching this, especially the people who thought that DJ was this radical who's running against this other guy who's just going to hold the status quo. The DJ did just exercise his legal capacity and point out how it would actually work and what can't work when I proposed my weird thing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, I'm not just some weird pinko, even though I am.

SPEAKER_00I'm the non-lawyer, so I can just be like, well, why can't we do this? And then I have to...

SPEAKER_01And look, I love it. Love it. You know, part of the thing is being a litigator is, you know, someone who gets up in court and has to sort of argue wild things is you think about how can we do it, right?

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, exactly. And that's one function of it, I think, that needs to be exercised, especially in a state like ours. I remember Greg Letting said a couple years ago that he asked, The Arkansas legislature, while they were in session one time, to raise their hands if they were a landlord. And like 90 or 95% of the room raised their hands.

SPEAKER_00So the elected officials of our state, they're representing only one class, which is the landlords. And so of course we have the laws that we have.

SPEAKER_01You know, it's like, I think we exist in an interesting moment whereby the narrative that's been dominant since the 1970s, 1980s about the aspirational class and that you can be the Elon Musks, you can be the Jeff Bezos, you can be the whatever. For my generation, and I see it most clearly with the generation below me, Those things are not holding true for anyone. They're like, well, maybe I can be a YouTuber who makes money off being a YouTuber, right?

SPEAKER_01That's the kind of their avenue of the American dream. And they're really seeing class interests re-emerge and understanding, even if they're not using the language of class, they are understanding that there are classes and there's a rule and there are rulers. And I think we exist in that moment where the post-2016 Bernie Sanders and Trump reorienting of the political landscape

SPEAKER_01to see class interests much more clearly than we had in the prior 20, 30 years.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so let's play this out just a little bit then. So what the city is used Is a city attorney who is primarily focused on receiving direction from questions, queries, whatever, from the mayor, the city council, etc. How does this work if the city attorney becomes more available to the residents the municipality?

SPEAKER_01Well, you know, hopefully it puts more kind of governance power in the actual people and hopefully it means that they don't feel awash and that democracy for them is just when you get to come vote or you give a comment that no one listens to. I'm hoping that if we think of it as like a power center, that some of that power that is only concentrated in the hands of people with wealth can actually trickle out To the normal everyday people who don't feel like they have any avenue to dictate policy in their city.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so that's interesting. So like, for example, you said earlier that a big corporation could put together an entire ordinance that they could basically walk on to the city council because they would have figured it out, legally drafted it. They would go... They still have to solicit a city council person to actually walk it on, right? Yeah. They can't just bring it. It has to come from a city council member. Yes. So in this instance,

SPEAKER_00the city... Tell me if I'm wrong about this or if I'm describing it the right way. It's just like an end user. So I could go to the city attorney. I've got this thing I really want to work on together with other residents of the city. I would be able to review that with you and get to... Where I actually am bringing one of the city council members a reasonably drafted ordinance. Yep. That they could walk on.

SPEAKER_01That's the goal. The goal is to be able to have you come in or groups come in and to instead of having to solicit directly a city council person who then has to solicit us to then write and to then work, you can just come straight to us and we'll help you draft that up into a reasonable form. Actually work with you on how to get that legally sound. And then it would be up to the city council, but to give people that actual avenue.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's clear to me. I hadn't thought about how it worked before, but that's not partisan on your part at all because they still have to convince a city council person to bring it. And that would be up to the city council person

SPEAKER_01or people or group or whatever. And the maximalist position for this office involves a lot of Here are issues that people have expressed concern on and here is how we would work with the city council to potentially address them. At the end of the day, as city attorney, I'm not going to be acting on my own whim outside of the power that the city attorney's office has. But I will be the person who sits at that sort of funnel point, at that choke point on things that I don't believe are serving the legal interest of

SPEAKER_01the people. And Trying to use the power of the city attorney's office in a way that is serving the public, not just this idea that, well, I just provide a rubber stamp on yes or no, or that would clash with this, but rather take the power that is directed to the city attorney's office through its founding ordinances and actually saying, well, we're going to make sure this is available to all the people.

SPEAKER_00Well, and the other thing I could see that that would really shift, one thing I'm observing is that There is a, for lack of a better way of saying it, if you're watching this and you're not from Fayetteville, I'll put it a little bit more in context. So Fayetteville is about 100,000 people. It's one of the largest cities in the state of Arkansas, which is not a very big population state. So the culture of Fayetteville is very much like,

SPEAKER_00yeah, we have some Metro accoutrements, but not all of them. And I also always joke that we're like the biggest small town that I've ever lived in. Everybody knows each other. I can't go to the grocery store without having four conversations, etc. That's the culture. Within that culture, there is kind of like an ensconced establishment Fayetteville group. And that group of people definitely feels like

SPEAKER_00the current city attorney represents them because they have access to the current members of the city council, at least some of them. They know the avenues and channels for pursuing their interests. They all go to the same bars, you know, et cetera, or whatever. Your proposal, what it also does is it spreads access in a much broader way. Yeah. Than just that establishment group. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know, the thing that was most shocking in Fayetteville for me was that on the micro level in the city, everything is operating as it is on the macro level in the sense that there are people that have direct access. There are people that no matter who, you know, the makeup of, well, not no matter, but Even given the changing seats on the city council, there are people that have institutional access to them, institutional access to the legal,

SPEAKER_01the lawyers, the legal institutions and the mayor's office and all of these kind of things, right? There are people who just by merit of their name and by merit of being sort of sixth, seventh generation civilians are pulling the levers of power. They are the people that owned the land before you were here and Now are fabulously wealthy off their sort of estates.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a real thing that exists. Yeah. Right. And what's really wild is they think they're liberal.

SPEAKER_01Just because you wear Teva sandals and you have a bum bag and drive a Subaru. This is very Fayetteville specific, but I feel like people can understand this everywhere. Does not make you someone who stands up for working people or the oppressed. Right. Just because you love pride does not mean that you are really standing up for the oppressed.

SPEAKER_00Right. But there's really no reason it needs to get overly personal because what you're talking about is structural shifts.

SPEAKER_01I am wholeheartedly.

SPEAKER_00The office is going to function in this way, and that's a structural shift that gives broader access. That's what I hear. That is the goal. The goal is

SPEAKER_01to ensure that the avenues of power or the avenues of decision-making, which when retrenched and walked through again and again become avenues of power, but those avenues of decision-making are open to everyday people.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I try to stay aware of this. It becomes hard in the culture I just described because even though I'm not a, I cannot say, no, I'm born and raised, which is what some people say when you ask them if they're from Fayetteville. I can't say that. And there's not multiple generations. I'm definitely an import from Iowa. But I've been here for 15 years, so I have social connections.

SPEAKER_00I'm one of those people that can, you know, move certain things. And when you're in that position, it becomes, it's fun. It's kind of like, oh, okay, I might be able to move this piece on the board because of... So then that's even more reason why you have to give thought to who's thinking about how to ensure that the thousands and thousands of residents of Fayetteville

SPEAKER_00that I don't personally know... Have the same kind of reasonable power as voters and citizens as everybody else. Yep. That's a whole design thing.

SPEAKER_01You know, and I got friends here who, and their parents and their parents' parents, you know, are multi-generational Fayette Billions are the kind of people who have been here forever. And they just don't happen to have a stake in Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01Does he have to be to be the city attorney? Mm-hmm. That's good.

SPEAKER_01The response has been, this is something that is necessary and that's very comforting. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Any final words or things that we haven't even covered at all that you have on your mind?

SPEAKER_01You know, I guess one thing that I'm thinking about a lot these days is a lot of people have been coming up and sort of Saying that they believe in me, right? That they believe in what we're doing and they are committed and that they trust that. And as time was born on, this went from just a race with policy goals and goals of democratization

SPEAKER_00to something that people really believe in.

SPEAKER_01And no matter how this ends up, that matters. That matters that people feel seen, people feel heard, and that They can believe in something again, especially in this kind of political climate where apathy and rage seem to reign. And I hope going forward, no matter the outcome, that we can have more discourse and more candidates in Fayetteville that are saying,

SPEAKER_01well, this is what we're going to do and we're doing it for you. We're not doing it for any other reason. And that's what I really hope that this is trailblazing, right? That's what I hope we're actually doing here.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've been thinking about your campaign as it's interesting on a couple of different levels. Like on one level, I would love for you to be our city attorney. And then I also think of your campaign as a lever, to pronounce it in the Australian way.

SPEAKER_01Lever.

SPEAKER_00Thank you.

SPEAKER_01For like...

SPEAKER_00Well, I've got multiple campaign signs in my yard. I like the people that are there. Most of them are much less that for where I'm coming from as a social Democrat or I don't know what I... Democratic

SPEAKER_01Socialist, maybe?

SPEAKER_00Democratic Socialist, right? Socialist. That's actually hard to know what to say exactly because we don't have a full-on party that I can be like, that's my party. I feel like you're that lever of kind of naming that and it draws attention to how habituated conservatism is even in what we think of as moderate space.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Because if we just keep doing what the city attorney has been doing the entire time that I've lived here, and presumably longer than that, and that's longer than 15 years, that's not actually progressive. That's just

SPEAKER_01neoliberalism or

SPEAKER_00something.

SPEAKER_01And as more As more capital flows into Fayetteville, which it is, as more big companies look and see, well, we can develop this, we can develop that, the money seeps through everything. And unless you are willing to push back against it, we're already waking up day by day and seeing the capture. And unless you're willing to do something to push against it, that's the natural slope. That's the slide it will take.

SPEAKER_01And I don't want my children... To live with, you know, not only the weapons manufacturers, but to live in a city that they've taken while we were asleep at the wheel thinking everything was staying the same. And saying that we could keep it the same by just doing the same. Because the circumstances around us have changed.

SPEAKER_00Oh yeah, massively. And that's going to accelerate.

SPEAKER_01So buckle up. And that's what we're trying to push back on.

SPEAKER_00No, that's exactly right. Which is why I kind of think you have the most creative campaign that's available to me to vote in this election cycle, for which I'm thankful.

SPEAKER_01You know, it's become so much bigger than I thought it was going to be. And it's become, you know, a bit of a lightning rod. And I welcome that as a lever, right? As a lever for... As an actual lever... To ensure that not only governance, but development and all these things work for the people. And that's the labor we're trying to lean on with this.

SPEAKER_00And I kind of think I have to end our conversation by just saying Zed, because it's the coolest word. And really, honestly, we should stop saying Z, because Zed is cooler.

SPEAKER_01You know, with my three-year-old, we have a big debate between me, my wife and I about the alphabet. So, you know, the ZZ, it's a real live controversy.

SPEAKER_00I could see within the song. Okay, so V doesn't rhyme with Z. No, it doesn't.

SPEAKER_01We've got some book. We've got some book where aunt is a big like core word that's meant to rhyme with something else. And because they say aunt and not aunt, it doesn't rhyme. Like none of the book works because of that.

SPEAKER_00So wait, so how do British people sing that song then?

SPEAKER_01W-X-Y. No, we do. We say Z in the song.

SPEAKER_00Oh, in the song you say Z. I'm pretty sure

SPEAKER_01we do, which is funny.

SPEAKER_00Okay. All right. I'm always going to be a fan of talking about these things because dialects are fun.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Cool. Well, thanks for taking the time. Of course, man. Yeah, it's really great. And I hope you guys have a really good weekend.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we're staying busy, but you know.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, all right. Okay, see you.

SPEAKER_01All right. See you, Clint.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Live with Victoria Barnett, General Editor of Bonhoeffer's Works in English

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Election Day jitters

    Nov 3, 202613 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Live with Eric C. Smith author of By What Power: The Book of Acts, Autocracy, and Resistance

    Oct 29, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Criminalizing Homelessness Is Not a Housing Policy: The Cicero Institute's Agenda for Arkansas

    Oct 21, 202657 minAudio

    Where exactly are people supposed to go when we make it illegal to be homeless but give them nowhere else to live? I had a really informative conversation today with Quinn Emmett, Executive Director of the Northwest...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Report on first day of pilgrimage for homelessness

    Oct 15, 20266 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode