Thank you to everyone who tuned into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01So we're live with Kurt Fredrickson, which we've just been catching up because he and I saw each other on the regular over about a four or five year period when I was doing my doctorate ministry at Fuller and then a few other times, but not as much in recent years. But Kurt is the associate dean of a doctoral ministry program. Programming at Fuller Theological Seminary and also Associate Professor of Pastoral Theology.
SPEAKER_01And we were just catching up. He lives in Lafayette, Colorado. So does a lot of his work distributed for Fuller, which is in Pasadena. And you were just saying that you like this gig because all of your family's in the Colorado area.
SPEAKER_02We're all in the Boulder area. So we've got kids and spouses and grandkids all around us. So that's pretty wonderful. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then I finished my doctor ministry at Fuller in 2000. I always forget, but I think it was 2013. And was my only adventure outside of Lutheran Academics. Yeah. Because I went to Luther College and I went to Luther Seminary. Good for you. So then when I was considering a doctor of ministry, I was like,
SPEAKER_02well, maybe I should try something else.
SPEAKER_01So Fuller was my adventure outside of that. So Kurt's written this book right here, Compelled, Nurturing Local Missional Communities of Pastoral Theology. And I realized when he published it, I would have to get it because I was like, I thought to myself, well, I bet you that I will get to review a lot of some of the kinds of framings around pastoral theology that was a part of the Doctor of Ministry program that I had been a part of.
SPEAKER_01And that turned out to be very true. And so I wanted to spend some time talking with you about some of that. Yeah. So let's start with, I got this, I kind of made a list of questions because I have a lot of stuff that I think about around this. But you, maybe a question that we can start with that I think is really good and I think that the book focuses on.
SPEAKER_01So what do you think a pastor is actually for? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02How long have you been doing this? You're still trying to figure out what are you doing and why are you here?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. That's so good. Yeah. You know, for me, the role, the task of a pastor is to nurture a local congregation in terms of worship and discipleship and care and mission. And that continues to change in our world. That church culture is now gone. And now we live in an era that I describe as diaspora.
SPEAKER_02It's not even just exile. Exile has a sense that you're going to come back home eventually. Diaspora is you're living in a whole new world. And so how do we... Lead a people, a people of God, you know, in worship, in care, in discipleship, in mission, in this new and crazy world. And too many of us, I mean, I was a pastor for 24 years before I got to Fuller,
SPEAKER_02Evangelical Covenant Church, you know, Lutheran Church.
SPEAKER_01A little different, you know, and the church now— Although they're related, right?
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, yeah, we're related. I mean, it comes from the state church in Sweden, and so there's a lot of good liturgical stuff that gets built into a lot of covenant churches still, infant baptism and dedication and confirmation and all that good stuff, you know, that is in our rooted heritage, you know, back in Scandinavia. So I grew up in the church, and the church that I grew up in and the church that I think I served
SPEAKER_02until 20 years ago, it's so different than the world that we live in now. And I think that causes a lot of anxiety for pastors who are seeking to serve well, but in this new, crazy, different world, this diasporic world.
SPEAKER_01So to step back for a second, the way I think about that is like when I was in, well, definitely towards the end of seminary for me and into my first call, this would be like in the aughts. Yeah. This was when some of these conversations in church leadership were happening around things like emergent church, missional church. Theology, like things around innovation and adaptive leadership.
SPEAKER_01And I think in that moment, there were these pushes for pastors to lean into those kind of approaches. And what you're saying is now we've kind of gone through that period and you think we're even in an entirely different phase. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, I think the stuff that you just experienced or that you just described, you know, was an attempt by different groups to say that the world is changing and so how are we going to be churched? Church is really important. I mean, I'm just, I'm a church guy, you know, and Tom writes, he's got this new phrase that's popped up in a couple different books that the local church is to be a small working model of
SPEAKER_01the kingdom of God.
SPEAKER_02You know, so how do we do that in a local setting that is going to be very different from the way it was 20, 30, 40, 50 years ago? And too many of us, when we are trained for pastoral ministry, we're trained for a world that just doesn't exist anymore. And so all those forms, Emerging Church, Missional Church Conversation, that was all an attempt to see how do we do church You know, somebody,
SPEAKER_02Methodist guy, wrote about the fact that the day of the church culture's over, the day of the mission field has come. The day of the professional clergy pastor is gone, the day of the missionary pastor has come. And that's because we've moved out of this Christendom church era into something new. That doesn't take away from the fact that pastoring, shepherding a people is still very important and moving them towards discipleship,
SPEAKER_02becoming more like Christ daily.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So do you think that those things, which interestingly, they don't, a lot of that terminology is now a little passe.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Nobody talks about emergent church anymore. Yeah. Even though there are forms of almost all of these things, it's just like the language.
SPEAKER_02There's this fresh expressions, all this, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Missional church or whatever. Do you think those were reactions to transitions and now we're in this entirely new space or do you still think we're in the transitions?
SPEAKER_02Or like, where are we? Yeah, yeah. I think those expressions... It came to fruition because people were sensing that the way we used to do church or talk about church just wasn't working anymore. I don't like saying it that way, but at least there wasn't that missional sense anymore. In a Christendom era, everybody went to church or at least lied about it. You know, we all went to church even if they didn't. You know, now we're in this whole different era.
SPEAKER_02We're so much more secular than we were 50 years ago. How do we get the good news of Jesus Christ out into the world? I think that the way we used to understand church was kind of come and see, build a building. And if you're part of the denomination, you're going to land up in that church. That's just not the world we live in anymore. And I think much more we are living in a world where gospel people need to take
SPEAKER_02the word out to people and meet them where they are in the world. The big question, I think, for so many congregations is, are we going to be a congregation that is settled or sent? If we're settled, we're just happy in our nice little world, you know, and we take care of each other and we worship and it all is fine. If we are a sent people, then a local congregation is always looking for the ways in which it can worship,
SPEAKER_02disciple, care for each other, and also extend out into the world. And I think that can happen in every congregation. It's going to be different for every church based on the context and its location, but there can always be that missional sent mood. Which I think is a giant paradigm shift from the way we used to do church.
SPEAKER_01Just the mentality of that you would think of yourself as a community as being sent in some way.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Is a shift.
SPEAKER_02I think that's because we didn't used to have to think that way as much. I mean, we had missionaries who were the sent ones, but we were in our congregation and that was fine. We took care of ourselves. And the next congregation over, different domination, next street, they were doing their thing too. And that was also good. And it blessed the community to some degree. But I think we have to be much more intentional about how we actually serve for the neighbor's good
SPEAKER_00in the world
SPEAKER_02now.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so... I'm thinking, for example, that you have now, you know, you still have... You get to see a bigger cross-section of clergy... Yeah, then I do because you have all these pastors coming through the doctor of ministry program. What's changed? What like what are they coming with that maybe is different than?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, I think personally, pastors come into our program often with a sense of just being very burnt out. They are just pushing hard and they're not getting the results. If I use that language, that they wish. Or either they or the people in the congregation are looking at the big megachurches around and saying, hey, pastor, how come you're not like that marvelous communicator? Or how come our church isn't like that?
SPEAKER_02And part of what What we're trying to do in our program is help people, ministry leaders, remember their call, remember why they got into this crazy vocation in the first place, help them fall in love with Jesus again. Church can sometimes beat our own relationship, walk with Jesus out of us, but then also begin to think about new ways. So how can we be the church that the Lord wants us to be?
SPEAKER_02I describe it as people of God, body of Christ, temple of the Spirit. How do we actually live that out in new ways in a world that is now different? And I think underneath the pain that pastors are experiencing is out of Ezekiel 37, can these bones live? In this local congregation that I'm serving,
SPEAKER_02and even in my own life, Can there be new life that comes to me and comes to the people I serve? Paul in 2 Corinthians confesses about the conflicts on the outside and fears within. And that's no different for us today, for those of us who are serving in ministry today. There are conflicts all around us. Some of them our fault, sometimes not.
SPEAKER_02And then just a lot of fears on the inside. So how do we, as a program, help ministry leaders reframe or rethink how they might do ministry in a new and changing age, in diaspora, in a lot of ways?
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01When in the book you start out by kind of reviewing some of your pastoral ministry contexts before you got to Fuller. Yeah. And you talked about kind of being part of that growing church movement for quite a bit of time until you weren't.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. No, when I started serving our church, I was associate pastor, then I became senior pastor at our church. We were on a growth curve. A lot of that growth curve was people coming from other congregations and coming to ours. And the way that our community worked is kind of like restaurants. Brand new restaurants open up, can't get a table, next new restaurant opens up, then there's plenty of seats.
SPEAKER_02That was happening in our community, that there was always a new and cool church. And We were that new and cool church for a while, even though we were old, but been around for a while, but new pastor, you know, new vision. And I got the sense within me, it was kind of this conversion experience. I didn't have any of the missional theology language, but I just had the sense that we were not being true to who we're supposed to be as
SPEAKER_02a congregation. And the silly way that I describe it now is rapture theology. You know, it's pre-tribulational, you know, the trumpets blare, all the Christians gone. I don't think that's the way it's all going to happen. But I was just thinking, what if the trumpets blared and all of a sudden everybody from semi-covenant church, my congregation was gone, at least most of them, because I know some wouldn't make it. But if most of us were gone,
SPEAKER_02Not naming our names. No names. Yeah, no, no, no. You know who you are. If we were gone, would our community know that we were gone? And would they be happy or sad? And I got the realization, and then us as pastoral staff and leadership team started to think that they wouldn't know we were gone because we were just this happy little cloister congregation doing good stuff
SPEAKER_02for us, but not engaged in the community in a way that we wanted to. And so we made a shift as a congregation to be... Embodying that sense of being sent rather than settled. And we lost people from our congregation because in the midst of that sentness mentality, we were really seeking to be disciples of Jesus in a greater way,
SPEAKER_02to really have that cruciform nature about us and trying not to be so performative as too many congregations are, you know, just have... The fancy Sunday. There's a guy who pastors a church in my community now. He wrote a book and he talked about a megachurch that is located in our community. And he describes that megachurch as a Coldplay concert with a TED Talk added on.
SPEAKER_02And that happens a lot. And I don't. I know discipleship happens there. But I think that in other settings, it can be so much more intentional and it can be disturbing for people and uncomfortable. And people move on if they're not ready for some of that push towards discipleship.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It is something I think about a lot. This comparison, a lot of the statistics out now are that the majority of churches are small churches. There's lots of them, like around average of 70 in worship or whatever. But now the majority of Christians in the U.S. go to these churches Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I kind of wonder, like, so are the students that are coming to Fuller also from those megachurches? And are they having that same kind of burnout experience that the smaller churches are having? Or is there a real distinction?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, no, no. I think that that sense of burnout and fatigue and frustration is actually across the board. Mm-hmm. Whatever size church and all sizes of church could be really great places. We have to be intentional about what we're supposed to be all about. And that is being these missional communities that worship and care and discipleship and reach out to other people.
SPEAKER_02Small church pastors, they're certainly fatigued and frustrated. And it becomes more difficult to keep some of those churches going just economically. Big congregations, megachurches, some of my friends who are in those settings talk about how you have to just keep feeding the monster. You know, and every week, you know, it's just got to be another home run.
SPEAKER_02And you're worried about finances there, too, because you got the big program and you got the staff. So how do we keep that moving? You know, and whether it's COVID or economic downturn, how do we keep this show happening?
SPEAKER_01And it's just hard.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. See, and that's why I use the metaphor throughout the book of the church is more like a garden than a machine, or at least it should be. You know, no matter what size church we are part of, often it feels like that machine where you just have to keep it going. What are you going to do to keep the lights on and to keep people coming? But if we look at the church as a garden, It's a whole different mentality.
SPEAKER_02In a garden, I'm in Colorado now, you know, we have like five months of growing things, you know, and then fall hits and everything dies and goes to sixth season, you know, and that's okay in Colorado. And it's okay to have these different seasons in a church. And if it's dictated by what's going on in our community, both the neighborhood and the local congregation,
SPEAKER_02then it's okay to be more like a garden and to figure out, find ways to create a new mood, a missional mood, that actually nurtures the garden rather than trying to feed the monster week after week. And that feeding happens in small churches as well as the mega churches, I think. It's a different mentality that I want to kind of stress. And it moves beyond kind of strategic planning model where we're at A,
SPEAKER_02we need to get to B, so how do we get to B? To more of the question of who is the Lord calling us to be in our local congregation? Who is the Lord calling us to be at this time in this place? And how do we nurture practices so that we have better eyes and ears to hear what's going on with our congregation and in the neighborhood so that we might actually be that small working lot of the kingdom of God right
SPEAKER_02in our little place. Mm-hmm. But it's hard. That shift in mentality has significant implications. When we became more intentional about discipleship in our church in California, people left and went other places, which also meant that people power left, finances left. And so there were implications both for programming,
SPEAKER_02And finances, budget. It's tough. It's easier to keep doing it the same old way we've always done it. But to move into a new way of being church, to see ministry leaders as missionary pastors who are equipping a congregation to be missional, and to see our community as a mission field... There's a reorientation that happens.
SPEAKER_02And so many people that I run into in our programs at Fuller catch that vision, but then it becomes more difficult to actually live that out because all those implications that happen back home. I mean, we've had people who've been let go from the congregation because they've been through the DMIN program.
SPEAKER_01It changed their personal perspective so much that it couldn't work with the local culture. Yeah, I could see that, although that also probably plays to how a personality is too, because they always joke about how... If you go away and you read this book and then you come back and you tell everybody that they all have to do everything according to this new book that you brought, that's not necessarily the right way to...
SPEAKER_02No, no. And then that goes back to the nurturing sense. If you do get this sparked idea that you bring back to your congregation, you can't just dump that on a congregation. It's something that then gets... Yeasted into the congregation over time. Someone said, you know, in pastoral ministry in the church, we all want the avalanche, but most likely we're going to get the glacier.
SPEAKER_02It just takes a long time. And that's okay, because ultimately, we are a people of God together, right? I did kind of that brash stuff. I came back with the fancy idea and tried to impose it on my congregation. And it didn't go well. And I heard a lot of people in the process of ramrodding the new great idea that I was bringing back. My ministry shifted to where it was more of a sense of us doing this together.
SPEAKER_02And... And then we saw good fruit and I didn't hurt people along the way.
SPEAKER_01That's something I've learned from a long pastorate that I didn't know I would discover until I discovered it. You know, I've been here like 15 years and I'm still an ideation person. I'm still, you know, the person who I've been. But I'm part of the community. And so when I, if, and when I would do that at the beginning of arriving, and especially if I was in a position of power, that would feel not great to people,
SPEAKER_01you know, at the beginning, because you're just like rolling in and with all these new things. But if you're part of the community and you know each other and trust each other, then it becomes more along the lines of like, oh yeah, that's Clint throwing a couple of ideas up on the wall to see if they're going to stick. You know, that's how we do things. Yes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And he's going to do it again, but we love him and he loves us. It's going to be okay. See, and that comes out of a sense of being part of a community for a long time and being trusted by And being loved by them and them also sensing that you love them and you care about this community. It's not you just kind of trying to throw out the new crazy idea.
SPEAKER_02Even though you want to move the congregation in new different ways. But you don't do it. You don't go into somebody's house and start rearranging the furniture. You move into a home if the congregation has been there for some time. And you sit there and you live there. And you listen and you observe and you think and pray what might be different here.
SPEAKER_02But it's a we thing. It's not a, I'm going to do it. You're so lucky to have me. The great savior of the congregation now. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I think what a lot of clergy miss too, I have to remind myself of this all of the time, is at least those of us that are full-time, we have just way more time to think through and process these things related to the church And it's our career or whatever in ways that it's not for almost anybody else in the church. And so it feels bigger to us.
SPEAKER_01It's like existentially bigger to us. And so you have to moderate that with, Where other people are within the congregation, where it's not necessarily even their core community. It's just one of their communities or whatever.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and so many people in our congregations are not thinking, how are we going to drive the gospel of Jesus out into our neighborhood in new ways? It's, I want to have a place where I get to worship with my friends and my family. I want to grow in my relationship with Christ. I do. And if I'm pressed on it, yeah, I'd like to be salt and light in my community. But I'm not a program.
SPEAKER_02Don't cram a program down my throat. How do we be this people of God over time? And I think that as we help people develop new eyes and a new heart and new ears, things do change. For the better. Ministry leaders can be intentional about that. And something gets caught along the way. And a few years down the road, a congregation can look and feel very different.
SPEAKER_02And it wasn't because Clint came in with the newfangled idea, the binder from the conference, because it's being nurtured. It's the garden thing. It's being nurtured over time with the local people.
SPEAKER_01No, I like that image a lot. It's a valuable one from the book. And it really is true that although you couldn't magically make a garden look better or worse, gardens do look better or worse when you walk into them. And that has a lot to do with the approach of the gardener. You know, like really the whole thing.
SPEAKER_02You fertilize and you water and you prune and you take care of the bugs. And over time, something good can happen.
SPEAKER_01Right. So here's an interesting kind of test question for you. I was thinking about this. So I came away, to back up to Fuller, I really did go through Fuller during a period of time when some of this church multiplication... And missional church language, although missional is older. That was even coming up around the time I was finishing up Luther Seminary, but it was still a big kind of thing.
SPEAKER_01So I've been doing this for a long time now in Fayetteville, Arkansas. So I'm a left. Leftist pastor in a red state. And what that means in practice is that we have a lot of people who are connected to our church who have come out of other kinds of spaces in the kind of religious space that ours is. We just did a survey the other day actually of the congregation and well over 20% of
SPEAKER_01the congregation has had Um, but are still wanting to connect with Christian community here. So that's one piece. Yeah. And then another piece of, of our community that's kind of radically unique, I guess, is that we have established some things that are, um, actually community service, but basically entirely, um,
SPEAKER_01Not religious. It's intentionally not religious because it's the only way we can create the kind of safe space for those communities. So our shelter, we have people living in the church and we're not going to foist religion on our residents. And we also have this camp that we do. It's called Queer Camp. It's an LGBTQ teen youth camp. And there again, the last thing you want to do with a bunch of... Queer youth is like pop Christianity on them at the end of the week because that's
SPEAKER_01the way so much evangelical culture works is you try to get people in. So on this missional language, which I do hear you use, but I know you think of it in a different way. What I'm wondering is like,
SPEAKER_00is that, so
SPEAKER_01is that, what is that in terms of missions? Like, how do you think about that in terms of the language of mission?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Um, I like your approach. I like what you're doing. Uh, Missional has become kind of this catch word, and depending on who says it, it means different things. For some people, it's the old church growth model, or it's like an old evangelistic Sunday school model. You don't call it that anymore, but they call that missional. I think that for me, missional should mean something.
SPEAKER_02That we are an embodied presence of Jesus, but sometimes, I'm just thinking this out loud, we're kind of secret agents. You know, Paul talks about the aroma of Christ in 2 Corinthians. And my hunch is, for those ministries that you just described, there's an aroma of Christ. It's not overt. You don't use that type of language. But you are a community of faith that is seeking to do good towards other people.
SPEAKER_02And your motivation ultimately for doing that, I think, is good gospel. But you're not cramming things down anybody's throat. I think that church so often, it is just going after the nominal Christian and trying to get them back into a congregation. And there are so many people who are either completely turned off by church
SPEAKER_02for very good reason or just wondering and are... Don't want to dip into kind of the craziness of church. And so, you know, you're salt and light. You're an aroma of Christ in a very gentle way. So my evangelism verse is 1 Peter 3.15. So set apart Christ Jesus as Lord and always be ready to give an answer for the hope
SPEAKER_02that you have within you and do that with gentleness and respect. That is such a different way of approaching sharing good news with other people from the old first spiritual laws, you know, grab somebody by the throat and, you know, you're going to make a decision today. And if you don't make the decision today, well, we know what your destiny is. I mean, that's just horrible stuff that I learned how to do.
SPEAKER_02Where if we're just seeking to be a follower of Jesus, Live out a different sort of life. And sometimes you'll actually have the opportunity to share, why do you do this? Why are you like this? And you do that gently, gently with respect. Yeah. Well, in the best sense of the word.
SPEAKER_01I mean, yeah.
SPEAKER_02That also happens other times like that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. No, I actually had two interactions just last night. We do this event on Wednesday nights called Open Doors, and it's just a hangout time for teens. Well, it's a hangout time for anybody, but the group who shows up are all these teens. And one youth came in and actually showed me a tract they'd been handed that afternoon by somebody in the Walmart parking lot. It's like a rapture tract. It had all those rules that you're talking about, about how to be saved and whatever.
SPEAKER_01And they were like, I never had this before. Now I have a tract. They were, you know, amused by it.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_01And then another student asked to interview me for a class. And wanted to ask, so these are all kids who are not religious, mostly. Or if they are religious, it's maybe different communities. You know, it's not exclusive to just our church. And they wanted to interview me about pastoring. So we talked, you know, for 20 or 30 minutes for this paper that they're writing. And they asked exactly those questions, like what you're talking about. And for me, the...
SPEAKER_01Space that I feel really good about, like I feel like I have integrity in that space, is they all know that I did not set up open doors or a queer camp so that eventually they would ask me questions like that. Like, is that instrumentalization?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But they can.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. You are a safe space and you're open and they can... Talk about that stuff with you if they want to. Because somehow you have created a mood that is open and safe. And even though you don't use the words, it's Christ-like. I mean, there's Jesus at the best, but you don't have a plaque on the wall that says, we're trying to be Jesus at his best.
SPEAKER_02You're just being you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, and also, I guess the other way that the missional thing works is that the missional, the people who coined the term missional, like, was it Gruder? Yeah. Anyway, it was about joining the missio dei. It was about joining the mission of God, which is a little, quite a bit different than Going and reaching people for the gospel or something. Yeah. Something different to that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. I mean, the bottom line sense of that is God is a missionary God.
SPEAKER_01He cares about the world. And God continues to extend towards us with love and grace.
SPEAKER_02So how do we enter into that in very tangible ways in our neighborhood? It's just not... Beating people over the head with the Bible. And the whole trauma piece, which I think has always been around. It's more prevalent now maybe because pastors are more knuckleheads or because it's just we're able to talk about it more freely and recognize that that's
SPEAKER_02a bad thing. That when pastors act in ways that are inappropriate, that's just wrong. And we can talk about that now, I think, more than we did a generation ago. People just accepted that kind of stuff.
SPEAKER_01Well, when I say religious trauma, I mean, yes, maybe some people were directly experienced abuse, but more what people are reporting is a culture of abuse. Because they came out as queer and they were in churches that are non-affirming and there was a whole bunch of manipulative stuff. Well, I was going to say, the other is they were trained in these ways of thinking that now they realize were actually very controlling.
SPEAKER_01And because they learned that, Leaving it is almost like leaving a cult. It was inscribed in your body almost because it was so great. Because it's all tethered to salvation. It's like you have to believe these things or you're going to go to hell.
SPEAKER_02It's a pretty manipulative formulation. Yeah, so there's the condemnation of you're not accepted, you're not loved as you are. Yeah, and then... It's brainwashing. You don't know that it's brainwashing until you start being around other people who think differently and look at Scripture in a different way. It's kind of like, hey, wait a second. Where'd you come from? You know? And there's a lot of good people who just think differently on these issues,
SPEAKER_02and they're not going to hell just because they think like that. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay, so going back to your book, one thing I loved about it was I'm always going to appreciate kind of like a pastoral memoir because it helps me think about my own ministry. And I could tell that this is at least in part definitely you kind of writing toward the end of your career. I think you're maybe even retiring this year. Is that right?
SPEAKER_02End of December.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay. Uh-huh. So did you have any kind of like a special insights as you were writing it of like stuff that especially came up that was poignant to you where you're like, wow, that's wild to remember that or think about that or. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So this book really comes out of both my teaching at the master's level at Fuller and my teaching in the D-Men. And it's kind of. The best of my thinking, I think, I hope. I teach this pastoral ministry course. It's every Thursday evening this quarter. And I tell a lot of church stories. And those church stories in different forms have landed up in this book.
SPEAKER_02And some of them are just wonderful stories about great stuff. And other times, it's just really... Tough stories. And about midway through the quarter, someone in the class will always ask me, Kurt, did you make these stories up or are these things real? I go, no. Everything I talk about and hear about church life, sadly, crazily, is real. What I'm trying to do for my own life and then for people in ministry is
SPEAKER_02to help them recognize this thing called church. It is a mystery and it is messy. And that's just the way it is. There is no ideal church. There's no ideal pastors, ministry leaders. It's people come together seeking to follow Christ, sometimes well and sometimes in horrible ways. But it's very, very messy. And so I... As I'm writing this book, and I've actually written this probably over the course of five years
SPEAKER_02and finally got around to actually putting it into a form that could be published. A lot of those stories just came back to my mind. Wonderful stories of people in my congregation and heartache with those people as well, as well as just getting beat up. By church people along the way. And it's been hard.
SPEAKER_02I shouldn't have this, but I do. I have a file that's entitled Worship Wars and Hate Mail. And then there was a period where we were transitioning our congregation from a more traditional style of worship to something more contemporary. And we just got beat up. I got beat up. And when I go back and look through that file, it just hits me in the gut again.
SPEAKER_02You live the stuff in your body. But in the long run, I was called to be a pastor. And my work at Fuller, I call myself an accidental academic. I just fell into this job at Fuller and doing it because I wanted another platform to encourage pastors and help churches.
SPEAKER_02And I had gotten to do that at Fuller. But I wrote this book because I wanted to kind of share some of the best and the worst for me in terms of pastoral ministry as an encouragement, saying, you know, It's okay. Can these bones live? Yeah, they can. And you can have new seasons of ministry in your congregation and even more so in your own life.
SPEAKER_01I appreciate your love of the local congregation because I share it, for one. I was talking with I was actually talking with one of our parishioners the other day and they're very active and they're very supportive of this church. And then they also said, and I've never really understood like what church is for.
SPEAKER_02Oh, so you asked that question like 30 minutes ago because you're still looking for an answer, right?
SPEAKER_01And well, what was funny was they said they had watched... As a family, they were listening to one of these great courses that you can listen to. And it's one on... It's a big... Scan of the rise of civilizations over the millennia and what is human civilization or whatever. And what made sense to them in listening to it was that humans have moved towards,
SPEAKER_01and maybe in a more general sense, evolution moves towards complexity. And this made sense to them like, oh, that is, you know, humans aren't meant to be alone anymore. And as they come together as individuals, there's this greater and greater complexity. And that helped them make a little bit more sense out of church. Although I will tell you that I also sometimes don't believe people
SPEAKER_01when they tell me what they think, if their actions are different than what they actually think. And the way they act is they do believe in church.
SPEAKER_02Because they're part of it, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01But what I thought was interesting about that was, that's really what I think about what's so cool about church. And what has fascinated me since I could remember about church is it's literally this voluntary, you're not conscripted into it like the military. You're not in it because you have a paycheck. If you're a regular member, you literally are just in it. And you're forming these things and in its best forms it does things in the world
SPEAKER_01that almost no other form of organizations of humans can do.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. So I was listening to a podcast earlier this week, and these podcasters were talking about people who just go up into the mountains, you know, and worship, you know, and that's church and that's God to them. Someone asked that image, talked about that image to Eugene Peterson, you know, pastor, you know, forever. And...
SPEAKER_01The Patriots have doctored ministry students, right?
SPEAKER_02There you go, exactly. They asked Eugene, so is that church? And his response was asking two questions. First of all, does that experience connect you to the faith of the Apostles? You know, is it rooted or is it just, you know, looking at a tree? And secondly, and maybe even more important, is that community that you're a part of welcoming to people who are not like you?
SPEAKER_02And that's church. You know, church is, should be, This long table of a lot of different people who are able to come together and we identify with each other as sisters and brothers in Christ. As different as we might be with difference of opinions and a whole bunch of crazy stuff going on in our lives. But, you know, are we seeking follow Jesus, faithy apostles? And do we have arms wide open towards other people?
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02There's not very many places in the world that are like that. Church, at its best, is like that. We are sisters and brothers in Christ, doors wide open to you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. That's a pretty good answer. I always struggle with that, too, because if you want to do that, that's great. I was talking with somebody who was headed up to seminary last year. They're going to Yale. Oof. I was encouraging them to consider, they're doing an MDiv, but they weren't sure they wanted to be a pastor.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. There's more of those.
SPEAKER_01I never understood why people want to get a master's divinity if they don't want to be a pastor of a congregation because I'm just like, isn't that the degree to me? But they were like, but I really, could a garden be my church, like their literal garden?
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01And I was like, I think that gardening can be very spiritual. Gardening is an awesome activity. And you should be a pastor. You know, there's something about working with people in community that is what I think God has called the together in the world. And it is complex. It's really hard. Yeah. So I'm not saying like go into it lightly.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, but it's beautiful. So I was a lead pastor of my congregation for 18 years. I was in the church, my church for 24 years. And because I was there for a long time, I got to walk with people. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02A wife died and a husband was left and another family, a husband died and wife was left. And we watched these two widowers fall in love with each other. And the congregation knew that they were going to get together before they knew. And then the wedding took place. And because I had buried the spouses and I did the wedding, we were able to talk about...
SPEAKER_02Their past relationship, their past marriage, and how two new families are coming together. And that just takes place because you're around for a long time. And there's a lot of sadness. I mean, both people died of cancer, and it was tough deaths, you know, and lots of sadness and grieving and loss. But then there's a celebration of these two people. They're coming together. We see it, wonder when they're going to see it. And it was fun.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. That's true. Wongevity, that's something I didn't know I would end up with in a call. I think I thought that I was going to kind of move through a series of calls. Yeah. And now being into it, you do... Move through a series of calls even within your own congregation, I think. Things change so much over five or ten year periods
SPEAKER_01that it's like your congregations or whatever.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, people change. And then even the sense of how the congregation is supposed to exist among itself and in the community continues to change. No church is static. No. But if you're pastoring over a long time... You get to see those changes and accept them, hopefully accept them and move forward.
SPEAKER_01There are some churches that are pretty static, though. I went back. I used to be a pastor in rural Wisconsin before I moved here. And I went back last summer to that congregation to visit when we were on vacation. And I had not been there for 14 years. And I still knew 95% of the people in the pews and they were still sitting in their same spots.
SPEAKER_02There you go. Bless them. Yeah. It's kind of like a soap opera. You can leave a soap opera for like three or four years and come back and get the storyline just easily, right?
SPEAKER_01I think there are some big differences. This is, you know, we can't cover this in this conversation, but it is a thing I know is that Some of the sociological contexts are just so different, like urban, the change in urban context is so different from the change in rural. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02And so, you know, if a pastor steps into those situations, and those are often difficult situations, kind of seminary into the last year who becomes a pastor, you know, but, and then is gone. But how do you move a static, Congregation into some new sense of life, which is going to look different from an urban suburban setting. But it's the challenge because I still think every congregation can have that mood
SPEAKER_02of sentness and
SPEAKER_01not be subtle and static. That church is a really interesting example of that because I watch them on social media these days. I was the pastor at East Kashkanaan Lutheran Church. It's like one of the first Norwegian Lutheran churches in the U.S. And they do it by, I can tell, is they've just leaned into being in their neighborhood, as it were. They just do a lot of things that contribute to the culture of that rural place.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And they do it really well. It's beautiful. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, like, socials are still a thing. And they steward a lot of history there. There's, like, a little mini museum that they've developed. Nice. Because it's a place people go on
SPEAKER_02historical tours.
SPEAKER_01Because it's, like, you know, if you want to follow your family... Genealogy, people will stop through there because that's where the Norwegians came through or, you know, that kind of thing. Do they leave gospel tracks out? I'm kidding. They have a copy of the Constitution that the founding pastor wrote of the Norwegian Lutheran Church in America because he also formed the denomination.
SPEAKER_02I guess that's like
SPEAKER_01one of a track.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, that's like four spiritual laws right there.
SPEAKER_01That's right. So you're retiring in December. Wow. What are you going to do? Do you have an idea of a shape after December of what you're going to do?
SPEAKER_02Well, it's going to be interesting. We don't know all that it entails. I mean, we got kids and grandkids around here. And so they're going to take up our lives. We're getting a puppy in January, which is going to take up a lot of time.
SPEAKER_01That's a whole like documentary right there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. I'm going to stay on as demon chaplain at Fuller. So and it's going to be an unofficial volunteer role. And my job will simply be to be available to DMIN students, you know, because pastors don't have a whole lot of safe places to talk, to vent. And so I will just be that. I'll have no academic involvement with them.
SPEAKER_02I will just be a listening ear if they want to talk.
SPEAKER_01That's cool.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it'll be fun. We had this back when I started at Fuller in 2003. Walt Gerber was the pastor at Menlo Park Presbyterian Church, a trustee at Fuller, who retired from the church, retired from the trustee board at Fuller. And Rich Mal, the president at that point, called me up one day and said, Walt Gerber needs a job. Give him a job. And so we made Walt demon chaplain back then, volunteer role then.
SPEAKER_02And Walt came into our first demon class and he said, my name is Walt Gerber. I've been a pastor for a long time. There's nothing you can say to me that will shock me. I'm like Las Vegas. What comes to Walt stays with Walt. And if you want to sit down and chat with me, I'm here all week. And we put out a schedule of times he was available. Every slot was full because pastors just need that place to talk.
SPEAKER_02You can't talk to your superintendent or your bishop sometimes because that involves placements and jobs in the future. People in your congregation you think are safe, and sometimes those are the ones who will sabotage you. And so where do you find those safe spaces where you can just talk? And sometimes it's a pastor in the next community over or it's the guy who just runs the DMIN program who's available.
SPEAKER_02And I'll do some teaching. I've got nine students who are part of our Middle Eastern DMIN cohort. We met mostly in Cairo, but students from Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Syria. Scotland and Orange County, California. And so we're there at the dissertation phase. So I'm working with them and that's going to be for the next couple of years because some of them are trying to finish the DMIN while they're also involved
SPEAKER_02the war zone, which is just humbling to me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, wow.
SPEAKER_02And I'm chaplain police department here in Lafayette and so a volunteer also. So I'll stay busy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you're not, doesn't sound like you're, you're not retiring. You're shifting to some new callings.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's good. I like it.
SPEAKER_00We'll see. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, congratulations on that. Thank you, Clint. I received a lot from you forming me in my early years of ministry. I'm chasing you now into all of this midlife reflection. You're turning out pretty good. Keep on going. Well, you do start. I mean, the one thing I'm realizing I'm, you know, mid 50s now is you do start to look back a little bit more.
SPEAKER_01You know, when I was in my 20s, I was not spending a lot of time thinking back to my earlier life. Partially it's because you have so much life to look back on. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So Terry Walling, who used to teach in our DMIN program, he says that I am moving fully now into the convergence phase, which is, you know, where you have thoughts, wisdom, maybe, that you can pass on to other people. There's this Jesuit, not Jesuit, Sorry, another order.
SPEAKER_02Ronald Rollheiser teaches a school in San Antonio who's written three different books on kind of spirituality of aging. And so I'm reading the book called Insane for the Light, which is for old people. And it's just, you know, how do you do this stuff? Stage of life, well, because you're not in preparation stage anymore. You're not in the achieving, doing it stage, which you're still in. It's in this final stage where you're seeking to make a contribution for people behind you.
SPEAKER_02And he uses the language, which I can't embrace yet. How do you prepare for a good death? But it's, how do you... Gift other people, you know, in a gracious way and with wisdom. So I'm trying to learn that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't know that you're that close to that yet. No, we hope not. We never know, but I mean. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Thank you. No, I took Terry Walling's class when I was in my DMIN program. And it was a wonderful class that I was not prepared for. It was like I was too young. I mean, it's still fine because I brought that equipment along and it still has framed how I think about some of these things, but when you're thinking about like And you're 30, you know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. No, no, no, no. No, see, and you know, yeah. So my deal at my church was I was taught confirmation, which was for 8th and 9th graders, you know. And I loved doing it because I had my connection with that age. But it was dreadful. They hated. They were awful. They're just, you know, a bunch of punk, you know, 8th and 9th graders, you know. When they become seniors in high school or they're freshmen in college, they'd come back home to the church and said,
SPEAKER_02Pastor, I think you said some really good things. I should have listened better back then. Yeah, yeah, you should have. Give me the Bible back. You didn't deserve it.
SPEAKER_01That's funny. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Story of my life.
SPEAKER_01Funny. Well, hey, well, thanks for taking the time. It's really nice to connect. Wishing you well in that. I'm assuming there's going to be some kind of celebration. Are you going to get a cake?
SPEAKER_02Actually, so I was in California the first part of this week, and we had celebration. And there was cake. And, you know, I've been at Fuller 23 years. When I hit my 20th year, I got a rocking chair. So I got my rocking chair right over there in the corner. And it's got my name burned into the back of it and still Fuller's logo. Wow. So it's kind of a cool thing.
SPEAKER_01Oh my gosh. Okay. So I'm going to be 25 years of ministry starting next year. I need to tell my church that they... Yeah. I don't know.
SPEAKER_02Is this going to mess up everything? There's the rocking chair.
SPEAKER_01Oh, wow. Okay. Yes. And there you are in the grandpa phase with the pillow too. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_01Love it.
SPEAKER_02That's my life right there.
SPEAKER_01Well, thanks so much again for taking the time. It was really great to connect.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. Blessings.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Yeah, you too.
SPEAKER_00All right. Have a great rest of the day.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe
Where exactly are people supposed to go when we make it illegal to be homeless but give them nowhere else to live? I had a really informative conversation today with Quinn Emmett, Executive Director of the Northwest...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit clintschnekloth.substack.com/subscribe