Our guest on this week's episode is Claire Li, vice president of Credit Strategy at Moody's Ratings. Critical minerals and rare earth minerals are needed in most electronics and tech devices, yet the United States does not produce many of these components domestically. China is the leading producer and its rare earth dominance threatens U.S. supply chains. How does the U.S. assure the mineral supplies that are needed to produce consumer products and critical defense systems? Our guest explains the vulnerabilities and offers possible solutions. Cargo theft is more sophisticated, and more frequent, than ever - and as a result, business leaders are getting more and more concerned about the security of goods moving through supply chains. This is according to a recent report from technology company SmartSense by Digi. The company surveyed 150 U.S.-based loss and organized retail crime (ORC) prevention leaders. 81% of those respondents said cargo theft has become more organized in recent years, and 79% said their organization is more concerned about cargo theft today than ever before. Fires in warehouses are not common, they do happen. Not only is there loss of products housed in the warehouse, but there can also be environmental damage from a fire, again, depending on the products and equipment systems housed there. But this brings up the question of who pays for the damage? Some new laws in California seek to determine who pays, but not everyone in the industry agrees. Articles and resources mentioned in this episode: Moody’s Ratings Report: Cargo theft intensifies Trade group criticizes California law regulating cold chain warehouses Visit DC Velocity Visit Supply Chain Xchange Send feedback about this podcast to podcast@agilebme.com This podcast episode is sponsored by: ID Label
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Critical minerals and why they are in demand. Cargo thefts intensify. And who pays when warehouses catch fire? Pull up a chair and join us as the editors of DC Velocity discuss these stories, as well as news and supply chain trends, on this week's Logistics Matters podcast. Hi, I'm Dave Maloney. I'm the group editorial director at DC Velocity. Welcome. Logistics Matters is sponsored by ID Label. As the year winds down, now's the time to get ahead of warehouse projects planned for late 2026 or early 2027.
SPEAKER_01From durable rack and pallet labels to cold storage solutions, floor striping, signage, and professional installation. IDLabel helps make sure that your facility is ready when it's time to go live. Visit IDLabelInc.com to request your free sample pack today. When ID Label does the barcodes, you can do more. As usual, our DC Velocity senior editors Ben Ames and Victoria Kickham will be along to provide their insights into the top stories of this week.
SPEAKER_01But to begin today, critical minerals and rare earth minerals are needed in most electronics and tech devices. Yet the United States does not produce many of these components domestically. China is the leading producer, and its rare earth dominance threatens U.S. supply chains. So how does the U.S. assure the mineral supplies that are needed to produce consumer products and critical defense systems? To find out more, I spoke to Claire Lee. She's the vice president of Credit Strategy at Moody's Ratings.
SPEAKER_01Here's our conversation. Welcome, Claire. It's good to have you with us today on Logistics Matters.
SPEAKER_03Great. Thanks for having me, Dave.
SPEAKER_01Our pleasure. For those who are not familiar with Moody's ratings, can you share a bit about your organization and its role in supply chains?
SPEAKER_03Sure. So we are a global provider of credit ratings, research, and risk analysis. So we assess the ability of companies and government and other debt issuers to meet their financial obligations, really helping market participants better understand and manage the credit risk. So we do not operate supply chains ourselves. So our role is really to analyze how supply chain vulnerabilities translate into credit risk.
SPEAKER_03In this case of rare earth, we look at whether a disruption could interrupt production, make risk costs, increase working capital needs, or ultimately put pressure on companies' liquidity and financial flexibility. So we recently spent a lot of time researching rare earth and critical minerals across sectors, looking at which industries are most exposed and what the supply chain dependencies could mean from a credit perspective.
SPEAKER_01Great. Thank you for that background. And of course, we are talking today about critical minerals, both for products and for defense purposes. I guess to start with, can you just describe what are critical minerals and why are they so crucial to these industries?
SPEAKER_03Sure. So critical minerals are metals or non-metals that are important to the economy, modern technology or national security, but whose supply could be vulnerable, right? The designation is not permanent or universal. Different countries maintain different lists, and those lists can change as technologies and strategic priorities of nation evolve. So they are also behind a lot of technology and infrastructure we depend on.
SPEAKER_03So semiconductor batteries, medical equipment, uh radars, aircraft, and power grids. And demand is getting an extra push from growth in AI, data centers, renewable energy, and defense spending. So what makes them critical is not just that what they're used for, but how hard they can be to get. Production and processing are often concentrated in just a few countries.
SPEAKER_03So even if a manufacturer only needs a small amount, uh a shortage can still hold up the entire finished product if there isn't an easy substitute.
SPEAKER_01And you mentioned some very critical areas in which those uh critical minerals are used. So we also hear about rare earth minerals. So what are the differences between rare earth minerals and critical minerals?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so the easiest way to think about it is um that critical minerals are the big family, and rare earth are one branch of that family. So the US considered around 60 minerals critical, and that list includes things like lithium, nickel, cobalt, uh, copper, and also rare earth elements. And so for rare earths, they are a specific group of 17 elements.
SPEAKER_03Um Dave, I could try to impress everyone by rattling off the names like um desposium or tervium, but I probably lose half of the listeners in the process. So what makes them so useful is that they have a very specific magnetic, catalytic, and conductive properties. And that is why you see them in everything from electronics, uh lasers to electric motors, wind turbines, and uh defense equipment.
SPEAKER_03So despite the name, most rare earths are not actually that rare, right? The harder part is finding deposits uh that make economic sense to develop and then separating the individual elements. So they usually occur together. So refining them is technically complicated, expensive, and can create some uh environmental challenges.
SPEAKER_01That makes sense. Of course, geopolitical conflicts around the world have affected the supply of these critical resources. How is that affecting what availability can be found this year because of all those geopolitical conflicts?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so I think about that in two ways. So, first, the geopolitical tensions are adding to the demand, right? When countries spend more on defense, advanced technology, AI, data centers, and energy infrastructure, they also need more of these equipment that they need that really depends on critical minerals. And second is the trade dispute, right? Trade dispute have turned um concentrated supply chains into a real point of leverage.
SPEAKER_03China introduced rare earth export controls in April 2025, expended them in October last year, and then suspended those uh controls until November this year. So that pause helps in the near term, but it does not really solve the underlying problem because the processing and magnetic supply chain are still highly concentrated. So from a credit perspective, the first thing you would probably see is production delays.
SPEAKER_03So if the disruption dragged on, the companies could then face higher sourcing costs, big redesign expenses, uh, bigger inventory needs, big margin pressures, and eventually financial pressure. So companies that already have enough inventories or qualified um alternative suppliers would be in a much better position than those relying on just in time or just single source supply. So geopolitics did not create the concentration, but it has made that concentration much more visible and much more strategically important.
SPEAKER_01That makes sense. You had mentioned China, and China currently supplies most of the world's critical minerals. Why can't the United States just simply mine more of what they need? Is that a matter of availability and cost? And I guess the second part of that question is are we vulnerable as a US uh supply chain in having China supply so much of these critical resources to us?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, um that's a that's a very good question. So, but Dave, I tweak that premises a little bit. So China does not mine the majority of um every critical mineral. It really depends on the mineral, right? For example, coal, bought, nickel, copper, and lithium productions is it's spread across several major producing countries. So where China is especially dominant is further down the supply chain in processing and refining. So that matters a lot for rare earth.
SPEAKER_03So in 2024, China accounted for around 60% of rare earth mining, but 90% of global rare earths refining capacity. And by comparison, the US had about like 10% of mining and only 1% of that refining capacity. So I think the short answer to your question, the first question is that it is not really a mining problem, right? The bigger challenge is everything that has to happen after mining.
SPEAKER_03So the ore has to be separated, purified, and turned into oxide metals and alloys, and eventually magnets or other components. So that takes technical know-how, specialized facilities, um, environmental permits, approvals, skilled labor, and also enough demand to make the investment worthwhile. And you mentioned cost, uh price is also a big part of it, too. So rare earth prices can be very volatile.
SPEAKER_03We have seen periods when higher prices encouraged new projects, um, only forced some of those projects to become uneconomic when prices later fell. So that kind of boom on the bust cycles make investors very cautious, especially when the facilities can take years to build. Your second part of the question is what vulnerabilities are there in having China, right? Supplies so much of these resources. I think that the clearest vulnerability is a single country choke point.
SPEAKER_03So even rare earth mined outside of China may still pass through China for processing. So a supply chain that looks geographically diversified at the mining stage may still remain concentrated further downstream. Um, so yeah, and um this creates several risks like export licensing can delay shipments, restrictions can limit availability, and um companies may face sudden increases in sourcing costs.
SPEAKER_01So, what should North American industries do to actually be able to diversify their sources of critical rare earth minerals looking at other countries, maybe countries that won't provide that same choke point.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Um, but I'd say there isn't one silver bullet here. So if North American industries wants to reduce their dependence, they really have to work across the whole value chain. Okay, the first step is a broader sourcing. Companies can look to suppliers in places like Australia and processing capacities in countries such as Malaysia, Japan, and Estonia. That helps, although China still plays a very large role in the system.
SPEAKER_03Um, but sourcing is not is only part of it, right? The bigger need is to build more processing, refining and um magnet making capacity in North America and among like allied countries. Otherwise, you can mine the material but still like depend on someone else to turn it into something manufacturers can actually use. So yeah, um I think over time substitution redesign and recycling will matter more too.
SPEAKER_03So some companies are already trying to use fewer uh heavy wearers to localize macan supply or increase recycle content. Um so that can reduce vulnerability, but it takes time because again, new materials and suppliers use usually have uh to be tested and qualified.
SPEAKER_01Sounds like an opportunity for science, business, and government to all work together to find some other kinds of solutions.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah, like policy can help also, like through stock buys, loans, grants, or purchase agreements. Um, but again, like the key point of this is the goal is not just to open more, open up more minds, it is to build an ecosystem that can process, refine, and manufacture these materials at scale.
SPEAKER_01That makes sense. We've been talking today with Claire Lee. She's the vice president of credit strategy and standards at Moody's Ratings. Thank you, Claire, for being our guest today. Very informative session.
SPEAKER_03Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Now let's take a look at some of the other supply chain news from the week. And thieves are becoming more sophisticated when it comes to stealing cargo. Victoria, you reported this week about how cargo's being stolen and just how these thieves are creating serious problems for supply chains.
SPEAKER_00That's right. I did. Um, and as you say, cargo theft is more sophisticated, it's also more frequent than ever. And as a result, business leaders are getting more and more concerned about the security of goods moving through supply chains. Um, this is according to a recent report from technology company SmartSense by Digi. They are a provider of IoT sensing as a service solution. So things like personalized asset tracking, monitoring, process digitization, and decision-making solutions, things like that.
SPEAKER_00The company surveyed 150 US-based LOS and organized retail crime or ORC prevention leaders for its latest cargo theft report. And they found that 81% of those respondents said cargo theft has become more organized in recent years, and 79% said their organization is more concerned about cargo theft today than ever before. And just to give you an idea of what companies are up against, the research found that businesses are facing these highly coordinated criminal networks that exploit vulnerabilities across the supply chain, and they're using increasingly sophisticated tactics as well as technology.
SPEAKER_00So this is very much a cybersecurity issue as well as a physical one. And when asked about cargo theft tactics, respondents identified fraudulent pickups and carrier impersonation, GPS jamming and spoofing, trailer theft, and double brokering as their top concerns. Double brokering is a freight scam in which a broker or someone posing as a broker secretly rebrokers a load to a third party.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Victoria, we've reported on cargo theft for some time now, and we see it as a problem that is intensifying for quite a while. Did the report say how much this problem is costing companies?
SPEAKER_00Yes. Um first of all, more than 60% of respondents said cargo theft incidents have increased compared to last year. So it's a huge problem, as you note. Um, and it's adding up to big losses. 80% of the respondents said cargo theft incidents have led to lost sales for their organization, with 40% reporting annual losses of at least a million dollars, and 28% reporting annual losses of more than$2 million. The good news is that companies are taking the growing threat, excuse me, seriously.
SPEAKER_0070% of the respondents said their organizations are investing more this year in cargo theft prevention compared to last year. And they're pretty specific about the capabilities they say will make the greatest difference in fighting cargo theft. They cited real-time location visibility, so those are tools that allow you to know just where your cargo is at all times. And also data that can be used to identify recurring theft patterns or high-risk routes. So those are the things they think will help with this growing problem.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it does help that shippers and carriers are becoming much more aware of the problems of cargo theft and the scams behind them and are increasing their prevention programs. But of course, it it requires some ongoing villigence. And these organized groups continue to find new ways to exploit vulnerabilities that are in the market and and are deploying, of course, new technologies to enable them to commit their crimes.
SPEAKER_00They certainly do. Yeah, and you're right, vigilance and resilience are the words there to focus on for sure.
SPEAKER_01Most definitely. Thank you, Victoria.
SPEAKER_00You're welcome.
SPEAKER_01And Ben, while fires in warehouses are not common, they do happen. And not only is there a loss of products that are housed in the warehouse, but there can also be environmental damage from a fire, again, depending on the products that are stored there, and of course the equipment systems that are housed within the building. But this brings up the question of who actually pays for the damage. And that's something, Ben, that you looked into this week.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the the the implications that the the ripples of some of these incidents can really spread far. Um our listeners may remember, in this case, uh a very big fire that happened in California a few months ago. This was a 500,000 square foot cold storage warehouse operated by Lineage Logistics. That's one of the biggest cold storage companies in the sector. Uh it's located just outside of Los Angeles. It caught fire on June 17th of this year, and it burned for eight days before firefighters could put it out.
SPEAKER_02Unfortunately, nobody was killed in the fire. But part of the aftermath was this thick air pollution from things like the burning batteries in electric forklifts and from the refrigeration equipment inside the building that burned. And that has since caused respiratory health problems for some of the neighbors who live uh in in the surrounding area. Uh there was also what makes sense, a persistent rotting odor caused by the decomposition of some 89 million pounds of frozen food.
SPEAKER_02Lineage said that it finally completed a$100 million cleanup job on September 5th, which is, of course, uh going on three months after the fire. So this is you know, the scale of this incident is is uh pretty enormous. Another outcome of the fire was that the state's legislature drafted two bills in response. Uh and on Sunday, the California governor signed the two of them, their uh uh Assembly Bill 817 and Senate Bill 716, that's how they named them.
SPEAKER_02And the idea is to strengthen the accountability uh of corporations to help communities respond for future emergencies. Uh more specifically, AB 817 uh establishes new contingency fund requirements for certain descriptions of large cold storage facilities. And SB 716 uh uh strengthens uh enforcement tools uh by increasing the fines for violations uh for certain types of industrial real estate.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, 89 million pounds of frozen food. I can't imagine what that was like, but it does seem reasonable to make businesses responsible for paying for damages of that kind of scale.
SPEAKER_02Uh well it does. Uh having said which, one logistics trade group uh agrees with that point, but they say that these bills don't go about it the right way, and so it's uh continuing to actually push back against these uh these twin new laws, uh, which as it stands now, the laws will go into action on January 1st of the coming year. So the group in opposition is called the Global Cold Chain Alliance. Uh it has actually pushed back on the bills since they were introduced in August. And their thinking is that uh they agree that the warehouse fire offered an opportunity to strengthen emergency preparedness and response efforts at industrial sites statewide.
SPEAKER_02But in this case, this solution, they say, rather than directing new resources or support to communities affected by industrial incidents, the group says that these two new bills primarily add financial and regulatory burdens on the food and pharmaceutical cold storage supply chain. And in turn, uh they say the domino effects that could raise costs for the everybody involved, the growers, the processors, distributors, manufacturers, and ultimately retailers and consumers.
SPEAKER_02So the group is still planning to work with the California legislature to build an alternative policy that in the alliance's words genuinely strengthens emergency preparedness without pricing responsible businesses out of California. Uh much work left to do.
SPEAKER_01That's always the risk of pricing businesses out of California. And as we've seen in the past in a number of instances, when California adopts a law that's often copied around the nation. Of course, this would only refer right now to California, but a lot of other states copy those kinds of uh legislation that California does. So it does seem to be a tricky balance establishing responsibility, but also at a reasonable cost that makes it affordable to do business in the state or any other states that adopt these kinds of regulations.
SPEAKER_02You're exactly right. And that that's one of the reasons that we do try to cover what happens in California, um, even if it doesn't affect uh some businesses specifically, not in the state. But like you said, uh it can very often lead to similar legislation across the country.
SPEAKER_01Right. Thank you, Ben. Glad to we encourage listeners to go to dcvelocity.com for more on these and other supply chain stories. Also, check out the podcast notes for some direct links to read more about the topics that we discussed today. And we'd like to thank Claire Lee of Moody's Ratings for being our guest. We welcome your comments on this topic and our other stories. You can email us at podcast at agilebme.com. We also encourage you to subscribe to Logistics Matters at your favorite podcast platform.
SPEAKER_01Our new episodes are uploaded on Fridays. And a reminder, Logistics Matters is sponsored by ID Label. Planning a warehouse expansion, WMS rollout, or relabeling project for the end of the year or early 2027? Well, now's the time to get your labeling and installation plans in place before schedules fill up. ID Label manufactures and installs durable warehouse labels, signs, palette labels, and floor marking solutions built for real warehouse environments.
SPEAKER_01Request your free sample pack today at IDLabelInc.com. When IDLabel does the barcodes, you can do more. We'll be back again next week with another edition of Logistics Matters. Be sure to join us. Until then, have a great week.
Our guest on this week's episode is Maxime Darmet, senior economist at Allianz Trade. With the determination earlier this week of the Alaska Senate race, the midterm elections in the U.S. are now in the books. It was an...
Our guest on this week's episode is Taivo Pungas, chief information officer at Pactum. Every company is wrestling with the need to incorporate artificial intelligence into their processes. But how do you balance those...
Our guest on this week's episode is Rupal Deshmukh, Kearney partner and global lead of the Kearney Supply Chain Institute (KCSI). The midterm election is over and the people have spoken, signaling what could be dramatic...
Our guest on this week's episode is Rebecca Brewster, President & COO, American Transportation Research Institute. The trucking industry has recently faced several rocky years, from an ongoing freight recession to the...
Our guest on this week's episode is Vikram Sekhon, CEO and co-founder of Piston. Diesel fuel costs have nearly doubled this year, largely driven by the impacts of the war with Iran. Whenever costs get more expensive,...