Following All Saints Day and All Souls Day, Msgr. Don Wolf takes up exploring the Church's teaching on purgatory and argues it describes how we live, not just how we die. He builds the episode around Charles Williams’ novel "All Hallows’ Eve," whose two dead characters walk a journey of painful self-understanding, and around a man who spent decades resenting parents he had misjudged. Purgatory is an experience rather than a place, he says - not God making sure you've "suffered enough," but the searing work of being fully forgiven. Quoting Flannery O’Connor: love burns. ************ Monsignor Don Wolf is a priest of the Archdiocese of Oklahoma City. Living Catholic also broadcasts on Oklahoma Catholic Radio several times per week, with new episodes airing every Sunday.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00This is Living Catholic with Monsignor Don Wolf. This show deals with living up the Catholic faith in our time, how faith and society come together, discovering God's presence in our lives, and finding hope in his word. And now your host, Monsignor Don Wolf.
SPEAKER_01Welcome, Oklahoma, to Living Catholic. I'm Monsignor Don Wolfe, rector of the Shrine of Blessed Stanley Rother. And having passed through the celebrations of our notable feast days of the dead, it's time for us to recall the Church's teaching regarding purgatory. Now, that's one of those aspects of church dogma that's the subject of much contention. Most of it gathered around misunderstanding and misapprehension. And those are as common among Catholics as they are among non-Catholics. In fact, a great deal of what we believe and proclaim with regard to purgatory is really common knowledge among everyone.
SPEAKER_01It's only the name of this belief that elicits disagreement, not the actual teaching. So we should take the opportunity to clarify and understand it to the fullest. It is, after all, one of the elements of our faith, and beyond that, it's one of the great expressions we have of the true hope and great confidence in the blessed goodness that God has revealed to us. But let me begin with a quote from a curious novel penned by a curious author. The novel is All Hollows Eve, the author, Charles Williams.
SPEAKER_01He's part of a group of writers coming out of the environment of English Catholicism in the late half of the 20th century, especially in the 30s and 40s. It produced the notable works so much mentioned in our times. J. R. R. Tolkien and Owen Barfield were part of this group. They were joined by the very Protestant C. S. Lewis to produce stirring books we still read with great excitement and much profit today. In William's novel, in his first chapter, we come to know his main character, Lester Furnival and her friend Evelyn, who are in London at the very beginning of the Second World War.
SPEAKER_01And he concludes his opening chapter with this description. Quote, Lester shrugged. One way and another, they did seem to be rather vagrants, unfortunate and helpless creatures with no purpose and no use. She said, Well, let's go. Evelyn looked up at her. Lester, with an effort and companionship, tried to smile at her. She did not very well succeed, but at least Evelyn, slowly and reluctantly, got to her feet. The lights in the houses had gone out, but a faint clarity was in the air, perhaps, though it had come quickly, the first suggestion of the day.
SPEAKER_01Lester knew exactly what she had to do, and with an effort, she did it. She took Evelyn's arm. The two dead girls went together slowly out of the park. Unquote. As you can tell, it's an intriguing novel, one to capture our attention and invite us to follow the action. These dead girls are on an adventure to find out what their lives mean now and to find out where their journey takes them. The rest of the novel doesn't slacken in its pace or its creative approach to capturing our attention.
SPEAKER_01But the first thing to notice in the story is that their journey continues. They remain questing to know the truth of their new spiritual territory and its interaction with the world they left behind. They're creatures of this world, of this world, born and raised and functioning in it, but also creatures of this new kind of world they've entered. They're not exempted from the dynamics or the dimensions of either. As they go on, they intuit good and bad, follow the prompts they receive, and encounter the true meaning of salvation and damnation.
SPEAKER_01In the story, they've entered the purgatorial journey. Purgatory is the setting, love the dynamic, salvation is the quest, and the confusing succession of events. They are the background in which the story unfolds itself. Charles Williams wants to tell a story about the comprehensive beauty of being saved, and he does it by way of this story. And of course, there are many stories like it. The one we're most familiar with is probably the movie Ghost.
SPEAKER_01In it, the main character, Sam, becomes aware of his in-between status, in between earth and heaven, and in between life and death, as well as the in-between suspension in which he's lived his adult his entire adult life with his girlfriend slash lover. The story is compelling because the story is of a quest, and it's written into our cultural genes. The story of Quest, no matter the circumstance, and because it's a story we recognize and appreciate, it's one that seems to be inscribed in our souls.
SPEAKER_01Journeying to Understanding and Wholeness is the story. We love to hear it told. Charles Williams has a genius for telling it in his novel. And we should also note the drama of this story is as comprehensive and compelling for a king on his throne as for a janitor at his broom. Both are intrigued to know how his life will be fulfilled and where his soul will be nourished. Just because the king sits at the height of power and responsibility, and the janitor stands at the end of a polished hallway, both are equally intrigued by what might or might not lie in front of them.
SPEAKER_01Every day is a new challenge to understand and to make sense of his life, and every moment is a chance to embrace what life has for him in whatever version or possibility exists. Lester and Evelyn are simply being the persons they've always been as they begin to enter the ghostly city and begin to walk the journey that they've started. Of course, in this story, they've nothing to gain except self except self-understanding and acceptance. They can't get a hold of anything that matters.
SPEAKER_01They're dead. Neither of them can occupy a place or possess anything. They can't saddle up to power or impress anyone with their reputation. All they can do is progress forward, making their existence more complete, discovering the deficits and the confusions they endure, and finding some way to fit those into their existence. They're on a journey to complete their lives. And in the course of the story, we find out that this process completing their lives is painful. Each of them has to confront all of the chances that they've missed, all of the misunderstandings they've endured, all of the foolish choices they've made.
SPEAKER_01And in the case of Lester, the incomplete love that she's shared with her husband. All of it's hard to bear, since there's nothing either of them can do about it. They both have to endure the truth of their lives as they finally see what they actually look like and what they've truly been through, uh been throughout the years that they've been alive. It's a story of pain and difficulty, a journey through the brokenness of their lives and the pain of incompletion. A thousand times in the novel, they wish they had known that and they wished they could have done differently than what they actually chose.
SPEAKER_01But they have no choice but to go forward into the truth that is their future. After all, there's no alternative for them. They can't return to the incomprehension that was their lives before. They're unable simply to stay where they are, since they've now been grasped by this new reality beyond the common boundaries of living. They have to keep going. It's the journey of discovery, one that they undertake reluctantly but certainly. And we can also notice that in the story, there is no power or person causing them to stress or strain.
SPEAKER_01Nobody's punishing them because of their choices, and because those choices have been shallow, or because they had wasted their time pursuing foolish, meaningless things in their lives. There's no wagging finger that follows them to shame them for their silliness or to warn them about the consequences they're forced to endure. And there's no thundering voice to tell them that they've been quavering in their choices of doing the wrong thing in life. All the pain that they're enduring is the result of what they've done. If they've chosen poorly or opted for emptiness, it's the poor results with no promise, the empty embrace with no substance that pains them.
SPEAKER_01As the poet Dante would describe it, it was the pain of sin that punished them, not the sentence of a judge or the provision of a law. Their pain is a result of their choice, not the imposition of a punishment by another. But of course, this is just the imagination of Charles Williams. Nobody's asked to embrace what he's put on paper in his description of the continuing journey of these imaginary characters. And in no place does he describe their journey in terms of revelation or dogma.
SPEAKER_01We're free to ignore anything written in this vein. In fact, we can safely ignore the concatenations of his writer's pen. It has no call on our loyalties or our adherence. But you know, we can pause for a moment to consider the artistic journey. Williams' imagination doesn't come from nowhere. He's striving to describe the insights from a mind that's thoroughly immersed in the tradition and experiences of a life of faith. His characters are all positioned in the 20th-century landscape of belief.
SPEAKER_01They're not radical Christians, but they're the kind of soft, indefinite believers we all know so well. The product of a society in which belief is presumed, but not pressured, in which everyone professes the meanings of their lives with the hovering sense of the church, but that in the background. Amid the details of this sort of society, Williams is striving to tell a story that his audience will understand and be intrigued by, because the decisions and motivations of his characters all come from the deepest currents of their lives.
SPEAKER_01This author is describing a journey that we're intrigued by and so want to read and pay attention to. Charles Williams is describing the purgatorial journey. This novel is his appropriation of the insights and the teachings about the depth of faith, especially its expression in the world that we occupy now. It's especially poignant in that its setting is in England during the beginning of the German bombing of the Second World War. That is, it points to the challenges besetting the people there at that time.
SPEAKER_01The question, what happens when we die, was pressing on everyone, especially as they endured this relatively new experience of the contemporary technology of war that threatens civilians as easily as soldiers. The quest, prompted by the question, made the answer a popular topic. It was his chance to explore the meaning of faith as well as the meaning of life. And most of us imagine purgatory to be this kind of place, quote unquote, between heaven and hell.
SPEAKER_01Somehow there's this third option for the afterlife, which is neither up nor down, but an alternative destination. We imagine it as an alternative, it's something that we have to somehow account for and prepare ourselves to endure. Not only that, since it is part of what we believe its place in our teaching, is also something that we have to defend from its detractors and his critics. And these include both of those who think that any description of the afterlife is pure fantasy, as well as those who believe in the stark realities of heaven and hell with all fierceness, but believe in nothing else.
SPEAKER_01Among us, then, purgatory has this peculiar position. It's a position all the more cantankerous because there's so little so little support for it in the scriptures. Now that's not an automatic disqualification. There is very, very little in the scriptures about heaven or hell, especially considering that the book is a thousand pages long and it deals with the initiative that God has taken to save his people. But laying all that aside, adding up the verses about our destination in the afterlife, there isn't very much said about exactly what goes on or what the actual process of coming to see God face to face might be like when we die.
SPEAKER_01Oh, there are lots of things said about these things, and many people have written a great deal about them, but we ought to be cautious about what we can actually defend. They're like what C.S. Lewis said about devils and angels, which was that most of what we believe actually comes from John Milton, not the Gospel of John. The Bible is surprisingly sparse when it comes to all of this. But the Catholic teaching about purgatory is a teaching about how we live, not just about how we die.
SPEAKER_01That is, the story of purgation is one that's consonant with what we know of ourselves and how we go about being human, rather than a story about the machinery of God's interaction with us after we stop breathing. That's the important part of the teaching to focus on, that purgatory is an experience much more than it is a place. That's why the vaulting imagination of Charles Williams the novelist is so informative when it comes to this subject. His story is about the human experience, which is why we're so intrigued by it and why the novel speaks so loudly to us.
SPEAKER_01Because the experience of purgation is that when we die, we close the parenthesis on our lives. What our lives will be is summed up in our action. All that we've done, the sum of our being, is now present to us when we die. That's something new because always before then we had more time and more options. But when we die, the options for what we might be able to do in life are taken away. But as we die, we also see God face to face and know God in a way we never could have known the divine previously.
SPEAKER_01There'll be no material interference, no questionable misunderstanding, no complicated misinterpretation that will stand between us and the fullest expression of God with us. And according to the revelation that we've received, the language of, in the language of Pope Francis, the name of God is mercy. God offers the fullness of grace and forgiveness and mercy to us. These things have been present to us all through our lives in the revelation of the person of Jesus, then it will be present to us with all immediacy and certainty.
SPEAKER_01In the parable of the prodigal son, we get a hint of what that encounter would be like. It would be like a son who comes dragging home. The Father will come to embrace us in the fullness of our lives, then. If we have lived completely apart from the gift of Christ, whose life and death and resurrection has transformed the sum of our hope, then the human response will be to push away the gift of God's forbearance and forgiveness. That sounds harsh, but it's constant in the human condition.
SPEAKER_01We who have refused the gift of forgiveness our whole life long and have built a life which is intolerable and unacceptable will be unable to receive the forgiveness that's offered. And as a side note, that's what the horror of hell is. Not that the soul facing hell has somehow been tricked into doing something he didn't think about or was fooled into. It's that having lived a lifetime apart from forgiveness and charity and hope, that the person will, when facing God in all the fullness of God's glory, he'll say, I'd rather be someplace else.
SPEAKER_01Broken and deformed people every day continually choose those things that further their misery. And it could be like that eternally. As C.S. Lewis wrote, all the gates in hell are locked from the inside. But those who do encounter and embrace the forgiveness of God, they'll be challenged to wrap their arms around all that God offers. And it won't be easy. And it won't be easy because our embrace will be small and stunted. It's going to be hard to put our arms around all that we've been given.
SPEAKER_01And that's the suffering that we'll have to endure, the purgation of the experience. There'll be so much mercy and joy and forgiveness and forbearance, we'll have to endure its weight as we encounter it. Think of how difficult these things are in our lives right now. Think of a man who spent his life resentful about his parents. They always seem to be distracted and distant from him. He may not thought about them very much, but he dwelt a long time in what they didn't give him, including withholding the support and the affirmation that he really needed when he was growing up.
SPEAKER_01So whenever he thought of them, he thought so much of what they didn't do and what they didn't say. Now he's made his well his way through life well enough. He's not stunned or monstrous, but he carries that chip on his shoulder all his life. And then when he begins to examine his life a bit, he has a revelation. Talking with his parents, he begins to see that they're not the in-control, confident adults who mapped out the pathways of life and pushed the buttons to make things happen in their household as he always imagined.
SPEAKER_01They, instead, he begins to understand that when they became parents, they were terrified of their responsibilities and they didn't know what to do. They made mistakes constantly because there were no maps to follow or guarantees to trust. All they knew was that they had taken on the burden of life, the weight of kids and work and faith and home, and in the in with all that burden, they had done what they could. He wasn't always as best as they could do, but it was what they could do when it was theirs to do.
SPEAKER_01In fact, this 50-year-old man sees that his parents were a lot like he's always been: tentative, uncertain, afraid, mistaken, with success mixed with failure in about even measure. What happens is he begins to see his parents as real people. And in coming to see them for the first time, as they really have been, he not only sees them in a new way, he begins to see how many times he's missed the chance to make their lives better or to bring a dose of healing and hope to them.
SPEAKER_01Not only would their lives have been better if he had been more understanding and forgiving, if he had extended even a meager portion of charity to them while he was judging and condemning them the way they lived and worked, their lives would have been so much better and they would have been happier, but his life would have been better too. In sum, when this man opens his eyes to see the world as it is, he's suddenly aware of all that could have been better and all the time that he's wasted in making things worse.
SPEAKER_01He could have forgiven them and received their forgiveness for his own faults, and all would have been good. Instead, he's left with regret and the pain of knowing the price of his resentment and anger. He suffers because of what he's done. His parents suffer too because of what they've done and their mistakes and errors and sins. But he can't change what his life has been up to that moment. It's in the past. He looks back at how he's lived, at what he's thought and said, of what he's thought and said, and at all the bitterness he's carried around, and he knows that it's been destructive.
SPEAKER_01He's left with its taste in his life. And we know his realizations to be all the more bitter if he knows that his parents, they've forgiven him for what he's done and failed to do. Their happiness and their willingness to hold him close, despite his mistakes and misunderstandings, would actually make his awareness of his life even more painful than otherwise. Or, in the words of a character from a Flannery O'Connor short story, love burns.
SPEAKER_01It does indeed. Knowing another's forgiveness and love can be a searing experience. And so it is with purgation. Encountering the truth of forgiveness in the midst of the reality of the meanness and foolishness of our lives is hard. Imagine we stand before the infinite mercy of God and look at our lives in every detail, seeing what we could have done with what we had, and then seeing what we did do, there'll be real suffering, especially if we see what we've done along with the pain that we've caused to others.
SPEAKER_01Knowing we're loved and forgiven, despite all the ruin and rack of our decisions and sinfulness, will be hard to take. In the deepest inside of our humanity, we know it will be searing and painful in every way. And all the more so because the veil of our flesh will be wiped away and we'll know the pain intimately and fully. He goes without saying, the more destructive our lives have been, the more painful the awareness of the wages of destruction will be. The more we've turned away from love and forgiveness in our lives, the more the pain of receiving forgiveness will hurt.
SPEAKER_01We can also note, given how our lives are in the everyday, this pain becomes even more intensified and amplified, the more it is a surprise to us. How much more painful will it be to open our eyes on the truth of our lives, only to find that our foolishness and insensitivity caused pain and destruction in places we never knew and we never paid attention to. Imagine we find out the traces of the history of our lives will be like the wake of a boat passing across a placid lake.
SPEAKER_01The wake will spread out behind us, amplifying more and more as the waves propagate across the surface. The wake will be the destruction we've caused and the pain we're responsible for, disturbing the world that we've walked through. It'll be like a burning fire to know. We've caused all this to happen. That's purgatory. The catechism doesn't describe it as a place, but as an experience. It's the process of encountering God's total mercy and God's fullest forgiveness. Purgatory isn't imposed on anyone as if it were a meager punishment for the less than guilty, or as if it were God's last chance to make sure we suffer enough to qualify for the endless glories of heaven.
SPEAKER_01Purgatory is simply the experience of being loved by the omnipotent God in all of our sinful selves. Now there are other things to notice. The first is that we are not punished for our sins in purgatory. That is, God doesn't open book of measures, look at the files of what we've done, and then portion out how much pain we're going to suffer in order to make it all balance. We're not punished by God, we're punished by way of our sins. The second is that all of this happens in a spiritual mode. There's no measure of time passing in this realm.
SPEAKER_01We often talk of years and intensity as if a clock or a calendar were involved, but those are only metaphors, pictures of the depth of pain and suffering as we try to explain what we mean. No doubt the pains we endure are sharp and penetrating and seem as endless as the awareness of our faults. But it's not possible to measure the passage of days and nights and weeks and years. The third is that the purgatorial journey is of endless joy. That sounds paradoxical, but to endure the pains of purgation is because it is the entryway to heaven.
SPEAKER_01God is embracing us to the fullest possible extent. Everyone who's cast into the truth of God's forgiving love in the midst of sin and limitation of his life is entering heaven. The pains of purgatory are what it means to enter heaven. So purgatory is the experience of encountering all of the love that any human being could endure. And finally, the fourth thing is that love accompanies us as we walk this journey. The more we've known the love of another, the more we're aware of the invitation to receive God's love.
SPEAKER_01Another who loves us, even as this journey is taking place, augment the joy we experience, which means those who remember us and pray for us on our purgatorial journey are helping us. Prayer for the dead, after all, is one of the oldest traditions of the Christian faith. Our prayers enable the dead to endure their purgation on their journey to heaven, just as they enable our friends to endure their own pains on their journey to healing. In William's novel, this character, Lester, is sustained by the love of her husband.
SPEAKER_01She remembers his sincere and deep love for her, a love that she fumbled and resisted in her life. But as she begins to see clearly, she suffers in knowing she was so afraid of it and so unworthy of it, but she's also sustained by it. She comes to know what we all know. The love in her marriage was a version of the great love everyone is offered. Purgatory is our great hope. It's the promise of God's endless love poured out to us.
SPEAKER_01Purgatory is simply what it takes to receive what we've been offered endlessly in Christ. Purgatory is the gateway to heaven. Back in just a moment to our final segment, Faith in Verse.
SPEAKER_01We have a poem today called Timely Rows. Stones lie evenly planted in timely rows, never to sprout there even as the grass grows. Each is inscribed with the requisite names, and dates following each making their claim. On the plot they're assigned and laid out, measured, constrained, and trimmed thereabout, and as we enter and go down the rows reading, we recall their phrases, their faces, their names in greeting. Just so these are never very far from us, even if they have by now become dust.
SPEAKER_01The real truth is that when we remember them, they are alive to us, they and their kin. We engrave names on the unyielding granite, so when the memory's embers fade, they fan it, need not depend too much on fragile recall, so honor them even as we their faces redraw, and honor the truth of they having been us, lived and then died, as indeed we must, remembered by those who come after them, who read their names when their memory dims.
SPEAKER_01That's timely rose.
SPEAKER_01Hope everybody has a chance to uh continue to open their hearts to memory and especially to pray for those who have gone before us in faith. Hope that in the weeks to come you can join us in what it means to be Living Catholic.
SPEAKER_00Living Catholic is a production of the Archdiocese of Oklahoma City for Oklahoma Catholic Radio. To learn more, visit okr.org.
In this episode, Msgr. Don Wolf argues that gratitude depends on recognizing what is already around you, and that most of what we’d be thankful for stays invisible to us. He works through a man misdiagnosed with ALS who...
In this episode, Msgr. Don Wolf argues we are blind to the regular order we live inside because we have never seen REAL disorder. He draws on S.C. Gwynne’s account of the Comanche, a Nigerian priest’s perspective on...
In this episode, Msgr. Don Wolf takes up AI with this observation: nobody opens the window shade on an airplane anymore. From there he traces what happens when we expect to see nothing and stop looking - students eating...
In this episode, Msgr. Don Wolf walks through the three major days of remembrance for the Church and argues that laughing at the monstrous is how we put evil in its place - the devil hates being laughed at. He turns to...
In this episode, Msgr. Don Wolf makes the case that the Liturgy of the Word is not a warm-up for the Eucharist but half of the encounter itself. He traces the creative power of words from Genesis, where God speaks and...