Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Lingo on Docs Podcast

Lingo on Docs Podcast artwork

Do You Have an Idea for a Documentary?

Sep 18, 20261 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Picking Winners Most documentaries never get made. By that I mean most ideas for movies don’t work out. Conservatively, I would say about 98% of them just completely fall apart. Actually taking a project from pitch to screen is a Herculean task that involves hard work, strokes of genius, and more than a little bit of luck. Even once you make a film, it can be a Sisyphean task just to get audiences to watch it. Let’s not even mention how hard it is to make money on it!! I’ve spent two decades making calls about documentary winners and losers. I chose films for The New York Times' Op-Docs series, decided which projects to give grants to, and picked ideas to be developed into films. It never gets easier, and I have certainly made both great calls (I have produced Oscar-nominated films!) and bad ones (I have also invested years of my life in projects that went exactly nowhere!). When Following Your Gut Isn’t Enough A few months ago, I came across a post from Adam Neuhaus, a former ESPN development executive and co-founder of the Nonfiction Hotlist, with a rubric he uses to score a documentary's potential. I immediately screenshot it and sent it to all my friends. It brilliantly breaks a nonfiction project into its real constituent parts (e.g., “What are the stakes?"), asks you to score each one honestly from 1 to 4 (are they major or minor?), in a process that forces the ultimate kicking-the-tires exercise, at any stage of a film's life. If you don’t already know Adam and the Nonfiction Hotlist, the origin story is sets it up nicely. It started with one frustrated LinkedIn post from Adam about his anguish at watching strong nonfiction projects stall out so he floated the idea of building a curated slate of the best unproduced nonfiction work, modeled on the Black List, which has helped get hundreds of unproduced scripts made over the past two decades. The post took off. Isis Masoud saw it and, in effect, said: let’s actually build this. A few months later, they did just that. (Here is my post about it: Looks Good: A Q&A With The Nonfiction Hotlist.) Since launching in 2025, the Hotlist has published its first slate, and landed a deal with Yahoo to distribute 20 short docs. Right now, their submissions for its second edition are open through 9/25 and they just announced a creative retreat for 2027. So I’m thrilled to bring you my conversation with Adam and Isis, co-founders of the Nonfiction Hotlist, about how they use rubrics like this one to pick winning ideas and the future of the list. See the whole convo above, or keep reading for an edited version of our chat. KL: This rubric for documentary ideas is so practical - I like how it’s set up so that by the end, you get a real sense of how strong your overall concept is. AN: First, I should say this isn’t a clean, fully analytical process. The reason I score things on paper is that I’m actually a romantic - I love my gut. A lot of what I follow is instinct, what lights me up. But it’s also good, in the morning light, to run an idea past that initial excitement. What Score Will Your Film Get? STAKES 4 - Major impact for individuals/community/society 3 - Limited impact for individuals/community/society 2 - Superficial impact 1 - Low or no stakes KL: How important is it for a story to have big, life-and-death stakes? What if your idea is a personal film? AN: The stakes could be very personal. But you want a story where we’re actually watching people who have something on the line. This doesn’t mean a story needs A++, hostage-level stakes to work - it’s just a way to start thinking about it from that perspective. WORLD/SETTING 4 - Unique and unexplored 3 - Well covered but compelling 2 - Predictable and unsurprising 1 - Boring and tired KL: Why is the setting for a documentary important to its success? AN: We’re interested in subcultures or places that look and feel slightly different from us and that feel like something we haven’t seen before. You’re on a fishing boat in Alaska. Or you’re chasing storms across Oklahoma. When the access you have is very novel and unique, it immediately grabs people because it feels foreign to them. KL: I’ll add that since film is a visual medium, thinking about the imagery that’s going to carry the story can be a great reason to do something - or not. If your story mostly takes place in offices, that can be a tough movie to watch. But if it mostly takes place in New York City, or on a beautiful mountaintop, that’s probably going to help get people excited to see the film. AN: It’s also a balance. If it’s set in an office, your characters better be like the actors from The Office - A++ characters. All of these criteria are just meant to give you clarity as you’re looking at your project. If the world is super intense, maybe you don’t need someone with super dynamic talent, because the world can do a lot of that work for you. Everything here is just a way of evaluating. CREATIVE TAKE 4 - Novel and absorbing 3 - Interesting but needs further crafting 2 - Straightforward 1 - No take exists KL: How does a ‘creative take’ shape a film? AN: It’s a beautiful thing that there’s not just one way to tell a story. We can tell it in so many different ways and perspectives. A filmmaker can utilize animation, first person, voiceover, archive, comedy. There’s just so many tools. There are so many ways to tell a story besides just giving a chronology. KL: A great example of the importance of creative take is the new Elizabeth Holmes documentary. Alex Gibney already made a documentary about her, yet people are excited there is another one coming because it is directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. We all can’t wait to see their take on this story, even though we all basically know it! EMOTION 4 - Potential for crying, laughing, or screaming 3 - Emotional arc exists but strength is unsure 2 - Evokes little emotion 1 - No emotion KL: This one reminds me of the Maya Angelou quote: “I’ve learned that people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel.” That applies to movies, too. I’ll never forget a film that makes me cry or laugh out loud. AN: Get out of your head and into your heart - into your gut. Those are our second minds; that’s where our souls reside. If you can feel moved that way, it’s a good indicator you’re on to something. Feel your feelings - I know that sounds like therapy, but feel your feelings. If you’re scared, if there’s humor, if there are tears, that’s a really nice signal you’re on to something. ORIGINALITY 4 - Unheard of and never before conceived 3 - Covered, but not in this specific way 2 - Well-known and well-covered elsewhere 1 - Previously covered in lots of ways KL: The next criteria is originality - which, going back to the Elizabeth Holmes example, that story has no originality left in it; it’s been made before. Talk to me about originality, because I think it’s more multifaceted than it appears. AN: Creative take and originality can be looked at in similar terms, but this one is about how fresh the idea is. Has anyone else had this angle, this access, this world? When I was at ESPN, we’d frequently make a documentary about the losing team or the losing person - that angle usually isn’t as explored. Can you offer a new way into a story people think they already know? THEMES 4 - Big humanistic and cultural resonance 3 - Elevated: subject in service of a larger idea 2 - Contained: mostly about its own subject, larger themes are gestured to 1 - Insular: entirely about its own subject, no reach beyond it AN: I’ll connect this to one of the projects on the 2025 Nonfiction Hotlist - a film called Manhood, about the world of penis enlargement and male loneliness. When that project came across, it felt like it had themes that were big, humanistic, and spoke to the cultural moment. IM: It also hits on stakes - one of the characters had a botched procedure, so … This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit kathleenlingo.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello. Welcome to Lingo on Docs. Today I have with me the co-founders of the Nonfiction Hot List. The Nonfiction Hot List is something that came across my radar about a year ago as an initiative for filmmakers to send in their projects to this mysterious group of people who were then going to help support the projects and create sort of like a blacklist of great documentary projects looking for support. When I first heard about it, I was like, is this sketchy?

SPEAKER_01Is this like an AI company trying to steal our ideas? Is this a production company that's going to steal IP? But when I reached out to Adam and Isis, I found out it was anything but. It was a community-led initiative to just support great projects. Adam and Isis, hello. How's it been going the last year?

SPEAKER_00Thank you for overcoming your skepticism and actually just having a meeting with us and chatting. We had to do a lot of those calls and chats with filmmakers and executives and people who rightfully so are very protective of their work and of their agency.

SPEAKER_02Well, I just want to say a big thank you to you because you were one of the first who said, OK, this is legit. We trust these people. We trust them. Thank you. Thank you. Well, in a time of darkness, your idea is such a good one and such a necessary one. And I really want to get into the hot list and everything that you've achieved. But before we get there,

SPEAKER_01I want to talk Have a fun conversation about creativity and ideas because at the end of the day, the nonfiction hot list is a list of projects that are well conceived,

SPEAKER_01that are great ideas for films, have great teams. And oftentimes when we're coming up with ideas for films, you know, We all have more ideas than we can possibly make. And how to really know when you have a good idea and drill down into it can be a tough call. And a few months ago, Adam posted this great rubric That I saw on LinkedIn about how to evaluate if your idea for a movie, and honestly this could apply to a book, to anything creative, about whether or not it's worth pursuing.

SPEAKER_01So I thought before we get into all the news on the list, let's just talk creativity and how to even assess what ideas are worth pursuing. So, okay. So let's start out. The first criteria is talking about the stakes of the story. Adam, do you want to tee this up? And I'm going to, before I start on screen, something.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And first of all, it is not a clear cut, fully analytical process. The reason I use these rubrics where I put it down on paper and put scores next to it is because I'm a romantic and I love my gut. And a lot of times I follow my gut in terms of what projects feel aligned with me and feel like they light up my soul. But I also know that in the In the morning light, it's also good to run an idea past the excitement phase

SPEAKER_00and really just get some clarity for yourself as well about the strengths of your project and how it really – if you're really being honest with yourself. And so I've made lots of different rubrics for different parts of my life. This one I use as a kind of general documentary lens of which there is much nuance and particularity, whatever it is, and specificity that you would use on your own projects for your own situation. But it's a nice place to start.

SPEAKER_01So I will post the list so everyone can see it. But here is the first question to ask yourself. And I will say there are numbers, as you'll see. So the idea is to go through these 10 creative filters and come up with a score for your idea, which is, I love gamifying it. So the first creative filter is stakes. So Isis, Adam, what are stakes for a story?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, this is truly, and again, as you see, it's not just where something changes a law, you know, the stakes could be very personal or human, but where you feel invested, where it's like, oh, these people, they wouldn't, you know, who cares if they were doing this or not doing it, if there's a camera there or not a camera there, but actually we're seeing them with something on the line. And I think that's really important for storytelling is when you feel like your characters are deeply invested in something and that that investment is leading to something in their lives that's very important and

SPEAKER_00that something is the reason that people are following that. And so I think it's just very important to understand. And again, and Isis, you could talk to this part, does not mean that something doesn't have A++ hostage level stakes is the only type of story to do, but it's just a way to start thinking about it from that perspective.

SPEAKER_02Nothing to add. I mean, I think that's perfect. It's personal stakes or it's stakes of making a big change in the world and both have equal value. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So the next criteria for the creative filter is thinking about the world or setting of the story. This one is a little more inside baseball. So do you want to explain what that means?

SPEAKER_00Sure. I mean, you know, when you're competing to get a story made or to have a story that's out there, we are all as entertainment folks and consumers. We're interested in understanding subcultures or places that look and feel slightly different than us, that feel like something we haven't seen before. So a lot of time, you know, this is a little bit I brought this over from my background in reality television. Because you'd be looking for things like where the world was really interesting.

SPEAKER_00Like I think about survival below zero. Or like you're in Alaska on a fishing boat. Or you're with a storm chaser across Oklahoma. Like, wow, I've never seen a camera in this spot. I've never followed that. Those types of things, especially when the access to that world or the world itself is like very novel and unique, immediately grabs people because it feels very foreign to them.

SPEAKER_01Definitely. And just in my own experience, I'll add, you know, since film is a visual medium, thinking about what is the imagery that's going to carry the story can be a great reason to do something or not do something. For example, if the story you're telling mostly takes place in offices, that can be a tough movie. If the story you're telling mostly takes place in New York City or on a beautiful mountaintop, That's probably going to help get people excited to see the film.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but I think it's also a balance, right? If it's in an office, then your characters better be like the actors from the office. They better be A++ characters where it doesn't even matter what the world is. You want to follow this. So again, all of these things are meant to just give you clarity as you're looking at your project because, yeah, if the world is super intense, then maybe you don't need someone who's of super dynamic talent because the world can do a lot of that carry for you. So everything is just a way of evaluating it.

SPEAKER_00And I think what people don't do for this part of it is They don't spend enough time doing their own research on their world. So for every idea I have, I spend another 20 hours watching content from that world that already exists. So that's just on YouTube, finding old docs, reading articles. Who's covered this world before? Is it a cool world or is it cool and unexplored? And that's why that's the top score in this one because it's not just about identifying a cool world. It's also that like, oh, we haven't seen this in a lot of popular storytelling.

SPEAKER_01Such good advice. And the next creative filter is creative take. So what do you mean by creative take, Adam?

SPEAKER_00I think this is where it's a beautiful thing that we have these amazing directors who all look at a story and say, there's not just one way to tell this story. We can tell it in so many different ways and perspectives. You know, people utilizing animation, people utilizing first person, like voiceover. There's just so many tools that the filmmakers use. Discretion, that this is the thing that feels to me like we've moved a little bit away from in

SPEAKER_00the current landscape where it's been based on, do you have access to the famous person? Do you have access to this world? Cool, let's do a thing. And like, what's the take on it? How is the director and the storyteller entering into that? And how are you going to showcase that story? If it's an old story, how are you going to bring that older story alive? Is this all archival? Is it all of those types of things? So when we're Looking at stories where I'm looking at something, sometimes it's about the way in which we're going to tell stories feels very fresh or interesting or new.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and one example that just pops into my mind is the Rapinoe doc that just premiered at TIFF. I interviewed Tom Powers, the programmer, and he mentioned how when the project was coming together, Megan Rapinoe said she wanted an up-and-coming director of Who would have a take that she would like on her story. And another great example is the Elizabeth Holm doc that's coming out. I mean, Alex Gibney made a doc on her. Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim are going to have a very different creative take.

SPEAKER_00Correct. Yeah. And that's the beautiful thing. I mean, I worked at 30 for 30. We did an American Gladiators documentary directed by Ben Berman. And that had a very Ben Berman comedic take. And there was many ways to tell a story. And it goes beyond the chronological a lot of times. And so that's really where I get excited about working with a director or somebody who has a take that feels different and fresh.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. So the next filter is emotion. And I love this one because there's this great Maya Angelou quote, no one remembers what you say or what you do. They remember how you make them feel. So Adam, take it away. Tell us about emotion when you're evaluating an idea.

SPEAKER_00Just get out of your head. Get out of the computer in your head. Get into your heart. Get into your gut. Those are our second minds. That's where our souls reside. And so if you can feel moved in that way, it's a really nice indicator that you're on to something. If you can get out of just information and analytics and really just sit with an idea or see something and feel something Feel your feelings. This is real therapy, but feel your feelings.

SPEAKER_00And if you're scared, if there's humor, if there's tears, it's just like a really nice signal that you're on to something very human.

SPEAKER_01I also want to highlight... The criteria where it says emotional arc exists, but unsure how strong. Talk to me about emotional arcs because I think that an under-discussed force that's necessary for choosing a story is that there's an emotional arc. So dig into that one a little bit for me.

SPEAKER_00I think it's, you know, there are so many projects that get made and it's a bell curve. And so there are projects that are good but not great. And so there can still be an emotional arc. There can be a story. But for some reason, that character doing that emotional arc doesn't bring you to that other place, that place that makes you feel. Remember it for the next months on end.

SPEAKER_00The thing that makes you go into action based on it. And so a lot of times, again, it's not saying that these things don't exist. It's about being very clear about how strong it is. Did the emotion just pop up like a little bit or was it an overwhelming emotional thing? So the arc, again, it doesn't say that like you have emotion or no emotion. It's like, okay, I see what this is going for, but I didn't feel it. All the way. And by the way, some people are going to feel on certain films and some are going to feel

SPEAKER_00on other ones. But trying to find something that can kind of cross all intersectionalities for that type of emotion, that's the bar. And so to me, emotional arc basically acknowledges that it exists and that it's well put together, but maybe it's missing some magic.

SPEAKER_01Definitely. Okay. So the next criteria is originality, which going back to the Elizabeth Holmes example, I mean, there's no originality in that one. The story has been made before. So talk to me about the criteria of originality, because I think it's a little more multifaceted than it appears. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And again, I think the key takeaway for folks is make your own rubric around stuff that matters for you, because I think you're right. Creative take and originality is They can be looked at in similar terms. I think this one is just a little bit of like how fresh is the idea? Like, oh, you've done your research and you haven't seen anybody really with this angle or this access or this world or whatever it is. So it feels like this is something brand new.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And some stories are just you could keep going deeper and deeper inside of the story. And it's almost impossible in one hour or 90 minutes to capture the depth of the story. So in the case of the Elizabeth Holmes doc, I mean, I think that's a great example of like, you know, and then there was the series dropout that about her story. But I think there's always more in that case to dig for. And some some stories, you know, don't have that depth.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think you're right. When I was at ESPN, you know, frequently we would make a doc about the losing team or the losing person. And so, like, again, that angle not as explored usually. And so, again, can offer you a way in on a story that people know from one perspective. And so to Isis's point, there's just the great stories truly have lots of different perspectives in. And so the originality is a little bit of a culmination of those things.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. When you get a pitch for something you've never heard of before, as someone who's read thousands of pitches, sometimes it's really, really exciting. And then sometimes you're like, yeah, I've never heard about this, but who's going to care? It's such a small story. Yeah. So there's that balance between, you know, maybe highlighting something that is unfamiliar, but then also thinking about the stakes of it. Is this something that is unfamiliar, but that's going to grab a lot of people's attention and they're going

SPEAKER_01to be interested or they're going to feel like they care about this issue as well or not? So originality can really cut both ways. So the next one, In the creative filter is themes. So the themes filter I wanted to ask you about because on the one hand, themes can be general like love or justice, but themes can also be very specific in terms of what is the topic of the film.

SPEAKER_01So talk to me about

SPEAKER_00I'll connect this to one of the projects on the 2025 nonfiction hot list is a film called Manhood, which is about kind of the world of penis enlargement and male loneliness. And so when that project came across, that felt like a theme that was prevalent across different things. Big and humanistic and cultural to the moment. You might say, you know, people who are telling a story, you know, talking about AI would do a similar thing or longevity or whatever else is in

SPEAKER_00the real buzz of going on. So I think a lot of times, and again, this one, maybe this is about commercial documentaries. There are lots of ways to make, again, the theme of love Will hopefully be forever in lots of different ways and is the evergreen topic. And then sometimes the themes are about something that hits at the right demo in terms of getting that big splashy release or getting a business decision to be made on a doc to buy or commission or distribute.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I'll just add on this specific project, Manhood, it's like if you go back to earlier things we talked about, it hits on stakes. There's one of the characters there that had a botched situation. So it was like very high stakes for that character. And then the take and the originality, it's like top score there because you think it's about penis enlargement, but actually it's a much larger and broader category. Theme about what's happening in our world. And then again, like the access and originality.

SPEAKER_02This is a world that I don't think anyone has been inside of before. So it really ticks a lot of boxes.

SPEAKER_01And also, I just want to remind me that project had some pretty big players involved when it hit the hot list, right?

SPEAKER_00That one didn't really have – I mean it was a very accomplished filmmaker, Daniel Ambroso, but they premiered at South by Southwest and are now like deep into their distribution conversations. So a real big win.

SPEAKER_02But no, I don't think there was – I mean Penny Jupiter was on board. Oh, was Penny Lane on board? Yeah. There you go.

SPEAKER_00I apologize, Penny Lane. Yes. Yes.

SPEAKER_02But then after the hot list, they had some additional very well-known EPs. You can check out the hot list.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, Sheila Nevins. Randy Barbato.

SPEAKER_02We don't know how deep in those conversations they were at that time. So we don't really want to take credit for that because we think they're extraordinary. But in terms of timeline, yes, that got locked after the hot list came out.

SPEAKER_01I guess the point I want to make is that When you see a project like Manhood where it's checking all these boxes in terms of creative filter and then you see that a production company like World of Wonder and Sheila Nevins and Penny Lane and Gabe Sedgwick are involved, it's like, It shows directionally that people who know about story and what's going to work are involved. And I think that is a really good just case study to look at is

SPEAKER_01when you're coming up with an idea and you get people at that level to say, hey, I think that's a good idea too. That's like another reason to pursue it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think validation and recognition and I think we're trying to become that with the nonfiction hot list that some of these projects have been backed by foundations and grants and we're just another person on the bandwagon saying this is great. And for other projects, we're the first ones to get on that bandwagon and yell at the top of their lungs.

SPEAKER_02Sorry to interrupt, but also just to give another example, there was a project, and Manhood was already in production and they were pretty far along, but there was another project, Movement, which hadn't even begun filming, but it was Diane Kwan and Zach Manuel, and it's about behind the scenes of choreographers, and they already had some major choreographers attached, but hadn't shot a thing, but we knew based on the people involved, and I had a long career in dance and choreography, so knowing who these choreographers were, It said a lot, even though maybe it didn't check any of those other boxes around stakes,

SPEAKER_02for example, because they're still very much at the beginning. So it becomes a little bit of a balance.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think that's actually another something else to say about that project is Zach Manuel. Was a cinematographer first. I met him because he was a cinematographer on Alone, which was an op doc that Garrett Bradley directed and then on Time. And when you have a director, going back to the creative take criteria, who's a cinematographer doing a highly visual story, it's like all those dots connect beautifully. Exactly.

SPEAKER_00That's exactly right. So everything is, again, the rubric is not meant to create some cold analytical way of doing it. It's meant to be a Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But I have to say, as someone who's been across many, many documentaries, when I read this, I was like, this is brilliant. I'm using it on every project going forward. It's so good. Okay. The next criteria is characters.

SPEAKER_00I mean, this one is like this comes from my reality TV show background, to be honest. This was just always the thing that was the most important. How do you find your housewives? Right. I mean, they're literally just going from patio to patio and you can't take your eyes off them. And they've launched, you know, businesses and empires. And so, you know, thinking about and what I love about this this particular slide is you see the difference between three and four. Three is a single dynamic character and a single character can carry a lot of a project.

SPEAKER_00But the truly great projects have multiple dynamic characters. And it's that interplay between them that really, I think, takes something to another level. So I think a lot of times you get saying, well, this person is amazing and I love following them. But who are they playing against? Who else is there? And I feel like that's the kind of leveling up. But it's just this is the one where, again, can you not take your eyes off them? That's really the if you were to break it down into into regular speak.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I'll just chime in to say it also depends. Are you talking about a feature, a series or a short? You know, for a short, a single dynamic character is just enough. I think about Shanti rides shotgun or the Mole Man, which are both on the Yahoo curation. And, you know, Shanti is just like undeniable. People cannot get enough of her. And it's really, yes, the teens that are in the car with her are also interesting, but it's really about her. But for a feature film or anything longer series, agree, Adam, 100%.

SPEAKER_00And I agree with you. Yeah. Beautiful about a short.

SPEAKER_01Yes. So right on. I saw this with Op Docs. With a short, you can just have one interesting character. There's this great Op Doc called The Bull Rider, and it's about a guy who rides bulls, and it's beautiful cinematography, and you hear him talk, and everything he says is interesting. And for a short, it's a wonderful, wonderful experience. But nobody wants 90 minutes of that, right? To evaluate if that would be a feature, it's like, Who, you know, who's around him and what relationships does he have?

SPEAKER_01And it also speaks to what is the creative approach. If you're trying to make a verite film and there's a great cast of characters, like that's going to work. If you're trying to make a verite film and you really only have access to one person and the people around them either aren't willing to participate or aren't good on camera, like it's going to be tough. It's going to be real tough.

SPEAKER_02I mean, Adam, can you add that to your rubric? Like, should, does this, is this story a short, a feature, or

SPEAKER_00a secret? Yeah, this was for FeatureDocs specifically. I think if I were to make a short, and again, I want to just... Make your own rubric, people. Use this one, rip it up, make your own. I have one for my own personal production company where it's 20 questions that are one through five. And some of them are all about, is there a business to be made around this? Or one of my questions for my own rubric is, will I like talking about this at a dinner party? And if I don't like talking about it, then I should know what that score is.

SPEAKER_00And so I think, again, you can come up with all these things as a way of getting the questions out of racing around in your head and instead putting it on paper and being able to look at it in the light.

SPEAKER_01I love the dinner party thing. That is so true. If you're working on something and you can't quickly and clearly explain it to someone in a social setting, like say you're at the doctor's office and they're like, hey, what are you working on? If you can tell your doctor in under two minutes and they're like, oh, that sounds cool. You know, you have a good idea.

SPEAKER_00And if you want to. If you want to be telling your dentist and your dental hygienist about your project, that means you are overflowing with excitement about your project. And that's a good sign, but it's not the only sign. It's just one of the rubric questions.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. Exactly. Okay. So the next one is access. So, I mean, it seems so obvious, like don't make a movie about something you don't have access to. So let's get into that one, break it down a little bit.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but there are a lot of ways to tell a story, right? There are stories that can be told through no access to characters, but you have an archive. And I think, again, this is leaning towards a film type way. And again, it doesn't mean just because it's a four doesn't mean it's necessarily worse. You're just assessing it. So access to characters with some restrictions. It could be like this person's dead, but they have journals and they have audio recordings of them. And so they're not alive to do a fresh interview, but there's a lot of stuff here.

SPEAKER_00And so, again, it's just a way to look into it. But this does feel obvious. You know, the first two, I think, are quite a bit if you haven't thought about how you're going to tell the story. People would come pitch us at ESPN stories about athletes and we would just say like, OK, cool. Like you talk to them like, no, no, no. It's just like an idea for it. It's like. Okay, well, that doesn't really mean anything here. So if your story is truly access-based, have you done the work or at least shown yourself the pathway to getting that access?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and with sports, that's another piece of that just to underline, which I know you both know well, is it's not just access to the characters, but if there's copyrighted material, for example, if you want to make a doc about a musician and they don't own their music, This has happened to me before where I had a musician who really wanted to do a doc, great story, but they didn't own the rights to their music and their label, they didn't have a great relationship with the label,

SPEAKER_01which is why it was a great story, but the label was never going to let the music be used. So yes, access to people, but also to whatever archive or images, that is such a key part. And that really organically fits into the next story Criteria, which is feasibility. Can you actually make this thing? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And that is something that you see in a variety of ways. That could be somebody submitting like having a full budget where like and it seems like the budget lines are well equipped to actually do what they've done. That could be seeing the previous work. Okay, they have delivered projects at a very high level. So it's all of that. It's understanding the logistics around your project in a way, especially if you're sharing it with other people,

SPEAKER_00that you understand the time, you understand the restrictions, you understand where the budget's going to be played, and you have a plan on it. It does not mean we all know that you can plan as well as you want in a doc and then Magic or accident or hopefully happy accidents will happen along the way. But it's an understanding of where you're starting from and understanding of where you're going and what the boundaries are. And that's the type of thing that I think. Some people fall short on. They get very excited about the story. They get very excited about the access, excited about the character.

SPEAKER_00But then they don't really think about, okay, how many days am I going to need? What kind of edit am I going to need? All of those things. And it does not mean you have to have all the answers, but I would want to see that you have some of those answers and that you've thought about them.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And also a couple of things fall into this, which are, you know, access and the creative team, which we touched on before, which is like, is this a first time filmmaker set out to do something really ambitious? Or is this someone who's like very seasoned and done it a bunch of times and maybe they haven't gotten started yet, but they really know how to get things done and they've got a great track record.

SPEAKER_00And it doesn't mean it's a no. That is perfect. Yeah. I'm sorry. Go ahead. Go ahead.

SPEAKER_01I was just going to say the next the final criteria is the strength of the storyteller. So that is always really key.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think again, but it does not mean it just means that you're balancing it. So if you are early career or haven't done anything, but you have a fantastic sample of Or like you've gone out and like really shown that you know this project inside and out. Then people are very excited to back a first time filmmaker. But it means you have to have had put a lot of time to showcase why you're that person if you don't have the credit. Meanwhile, Martin Scorsese can walk in and off a one liner.

SPEAKER_00Sell a movie, right? He wants to do something. You're like, great. I know this is going to be awesome and delivered in that way. And so it's just a balance of understanding where you're at in that process. And if you have less experience and there's more of an onus on you to show it in all these other categories.

SPEAKER_02And also just to say this, you know, filmmakers are getting younger and younger. You know, when I was in college, it was like they were still we were still using razor blades, you know, to edit and you were making your first film in college. And then 10 years later, you had three, four films under your belt before you started college. And now my like kids started making stop motion at seven years old. So you have some very seasoned filmmakers that are like in their 20s with the Yahoo curation we got on. Zoom calls with all 20 of these filmmakers. And I'm always like, oh, my gosh, everybody is so young and doing so much amazing work.

SPEAKER_02And this really speaks to both the democratization of tools over the past 20 years and how and how documentary can sometimes be a very easy world to enter.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I'll also say just because someone hasn't made a doc, maybe they've done a ton of online video that knows how to draw audiences. And then that becomes more. So again, I think I would, you know, this is a general rubric. I think if I were really identifying projects right now in this way, we would probably add filmmaker enthusiasm or audience building potential among the things I'd be looking for now in a project.

SPEAKER_01Definitely. And one piece of advice that someone gave me a long time ago is if you're looking at a project that has a first time director, look at their producer. Because if I've got a great producer, then it should make you feel more confident about taking a chance on early stage director.

SPEAKER_00And that's like a little bit what this rubric is. It's like you're just picking something up and looking at it from every angle. So, oh, wow, the access is amazing. But, oh, the storyteller, maybe not. So all of those things is just giving you a clear picture from all those different angles. And, again, if something is low but is very high in a couple categories, like if your overall number is low but like the access is so crazy and original, it's probably worth doing regardless of the other things that it's lacking.

SPEAKER_01So as you can all see, Isis and Adam have amazing experience assessing projects and looking at them from so many different angles. And that really leads us into talking about the nonfiction hot list. So the hot list was started last year. Adam, it was your sort of initial idea and As a way to sort of lend a hand to the field that felt like it was sputtering with the slowing down of streaming and

SPEAKER_01the shrinking of financing options. So just to quickly rehash, what was the origin story of the Hollis and how did ISIS get involved?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there certainly was. It felt like a backlog in the industry where there was lots of great projects, but a diminished kind of buying demand from the streamers. And so I was having that personal experience as a producer. And I shared that experience on LinkedIn. And I think it just caught a lot of people in the right moment in time. And this idea that we've kind of all been hoping for is they're just a place that says, these are great and promote it, not looking for anything. People, they resonated with that message.

SPEAKER_00And then the first person who commented on that post was Isis, who we were not connected previously before. And she was the first one. I didn't respond in like a day. And she's like, well, what are we going to do about it? And it was like this call to action about what we can do.

SPEAKER_02Well, just to say, like the post had already gone sort of mini viral. And when I looked at the numbers of people that had circulated or commented or excited about it, I was like, You already have enough people here to do the thing. So we just reach out to all these people that have given you the thumbs up and we get started. And since I come from a casting background, I know how to find people and gather submissions and pick people. And so I just quickly set up that infrastructure. And then we, through Adam's relationships, very quickly got about 20 other people involved.

SPEAKER_02And it was kind of a magical time because All of these people were in a similar boat, either creatives or EPs or producers, or they were in different aspects of the industry being impacted by the same thing that Adam was talking about. And because it was an all volunteer-led initiative, people were generous and trailblazers and excited to just volunteer their time. It was a really exciting moment.

SPEAKER_00And I think filmmakers were frustrated as well and fed up and they were willing to like try a new thing. And we ran a film festival style review process where we had all the projects reviewed by multiple people and we created a new rubric for it. And by no means did we think this was going to be the only projects that were strong enough or, you know, if a whole other group of people looked at it, they could pick 23 other projects. But we felt very strongly about showing a diversity of projects that across all of nonfiction.

SPEAKER_01So now that the list has been released and out in the world for what, six months? How many months? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00No, about a year and a couple.

SPEAKER_01About a year. It's been a year since the first list came out. A year and a half,

SPEAKER_00I think,

SPEAKER_01yeah.

SPEAKER_02A year and a half since April. We put it out April.

SPEAKER_01I'm sorry. Where does the time go? It was like it wasn't that long ago. So talk about the impact of the list. Tell us about how projects have been changed by being part of it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, sure. You know, I'll start, Isis, then you can jump in. You know, We took projects at all phases. It's a works in progress initiative. So there were things that were in early stages of development that are still in development. There are some that are just shooting that are still shooting. And there were some projects that were at rough cut and close to the end. So we had six projects come out this past year, a mix of features, shorts and podcasts. Some of the features like Earth to Michael and Manhood and City in

SPEAKER_00the Forest have all been very pedigreed documentaries. Playing at Telluride and South by Southwest and Sheffield and having really amazing premieres. The shorts, the two shorts that we focus on both got completed. One, Thank You for Listening. Another one called Screw Lucy all like had their festival runs that are in the mix on the awards. And then the one podcast we chose, When We All Get to Heaven, Ended up getting a distribution deal with Slate and winning a Peabody Award.

SPEAKER_00Wow. Those are just the six that came out year one. We now have about six or seven that are now just finishing their fine cuts and entering into the festival space. And so we're anticipating next year, 2027, to have a whole bunch of films that are really strong as part of the first hot list. And then beyond that, there's still another 10 projects that are in motion. So this is really a multi-year scenario. And what we really provide is momentum and attention.

SPEAKER_00It's still taking people. It's not like, We put you on the hot list and then someone showed up with a check the next day to solve all the things. We just started creating community around these things and just providing them with help along the way.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'd like to ask each of you, what is something that happened that was totally unanticipated or surprising or shocking in terms of something that happened to a project or something you learned just from working on the project? Isis, do you want to go first?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, I mean, I think when you ask a filmmaker what they need, which is the first thing that we always do, it's like, where are you at? What do you need? And the first thing they always say is funding. And I always say that you don't get funding from your first ask being about, like, I need funding. You actually get funding by building connection, by building a relationship. Even though we recognize the ask and we help them move towards that, that's not the thing that we're doling out. We're not like the people writing checks, but we are making connections. We're giving them access to conversations, rooms that maybe they didn't have access to before. But it was unexpected when Thank You for Listening closed their funding gap.

SPEAKER_02We weren't necessarily saying like, oh, we're going to hand you money, but we made a connection that helped them. Closed their funding gap to get the film completed, which is Texas Monthly came on board for them. And then the other thing that was completely unexpected and surprising was a through line. I love a through line, but thank you for listening was on the original hot list. And then because they reached completion, they submitted for the Yahoo initiative, Which was completed short documentaries. And everyone who judged that, not judged, but reviewed that project for the initial hot list was not assigned to review

SPEAKER_02that process for Yahoo! Because we would of course have a bias after supporting that project for a year. But we were thrilled when all of the new reviewers Lifted that project right up to the top. So that was really surprising, really exciting, really validating from our end to be like, oh, we got it right. And this project gets to participate now in both of our initiatives. So that was really surprising and exciting.

SPEAKER_00I will say like the nonfiction acts like uncredited and unpaid executive producers for your projects. So whatever that means for every project, we kind of showed up To help, as Isis said, wherever they needed help. And that could be screenings and rough cut notes. That could be connections to EPs. That could be helping people rewrite their grant applications. We really tried to not be one size fits all.

SPEAKER_00But as Isis said, show up with kind of our hearts open and just say, how can we be helpful for you right now?

SPEAKER_01Did anything surprise or shock you about the process?

SPEAKER_00I think I'm just really proud of the curation. I think as we get another batch into the festivals, I just think the level is very strong of the stuff that we push forward. I, yeah, nothing surprised. I mean, I think I've been in documentary and, you know, These things, it takes a while and things circle back in interesting ways. So I don't have a perfect anecdote for you yet about the thing

SPEAKER_00that is most shocking, but it's still playing out. I think that's part of it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I guess what I'm trying to get at is oftentimes, especially for those of us who've been in this for a long time, you sort of feel like you know how documentary works and Oftentimes you look at a project and you think, oh, that's never going to happen or that's never going to work. And then it does. And for better or for worse, outcomes are never guaranteed. And that's something that I've definitely learned having reviewed many projects over

SPEAKER_01the years, like There was one short that I can't say what it was, but that I worked on that I thought, I don't think that's a good idea. It's never going to work. And it went really far. So yeah, it's always the behind the scenes making of documentaries is as twisty and entertaining oftentimes as the films on screen. So yeah. Thinking about kind of where things were when you first started this initiative to now, do you see any changes in terms of just the sort of atmosphere of distribution or

SPEAKER_01the types of projects you're getting in? Like, are the conversations you're having this time around different than the ones you had the first time around? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Go ahead, Isis. You want to?

SPEAKER_02Well, I was going to say, this kind of ties into the last thing you were saying, Kathleen, is there's something about magical timing with which a story meets the world. And I really believe strongly in that because there are projects, for example, that we're urging to submit again because we loved them the first time around. They didn't make the list for one reason or another. But the world has changed so much since we put out that first list a year and a half ago. And we know those projects have moved as well. And we have a new group of reviewers. And so... I think there is this kind of magic for when a project is supposed to become public

SPEAKER_02and engage with the outside world. I don't know if I'm answering your question well enough or not, but I think that that's exciting.

SPEAKER_00I also say it's obviously easier. People have heard of us now. So there was a little bit of that. And then we kept showing up for the community. So we're proud of our Instagram that serves as like a bulletin board for the industry. One of the other things that we think is very important for us is Is to try to find new pathways for film. So like when you say we understand how documentary works, I think for a lot of people, they're just frustrated that the world has gotten like kind of insular. And now we're looking for people who are trying new things. Can you give me an example of what you mean?

SPEAKER_00Uh, yeah, um, I think what's most important for us is that we,

SPEAKER_00as Isis said, well, let me think about the Yahoo thing. We've just partnered with dozens of organizations in their meetups, with their social, to push out their initiatives. A lot of time, as Isis said, it's like, Filmmakers are trying to stay up to date on what opportunities are even existing and trying instead of all of us trying to keep our own organization to make enough money to survive next year. Instead, share those opportunities across the industry.

SPEAKER_00And just because there were a lot of projects as part of the hot list or part of the submission for the first hot list that didn't make the list that got distribution. There were projects that got into huge festivals. And that wasn't surprising to us because there's lots of different ways. But I think we can all be helping each other out a little bit more.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I think in terms of new pathways forward, it's not that we're the first to think about things in this way. But I think about like finding your very specific community and just to connect the dots to the last conversation we had around the rubric. It was like, you know, the democratization of tools opened up access for filmmaking. Now anyone can be a filmmaker. Well, guess what? Now everyone is a filmmaker, right? It's like I talked about my nine year old kid who's like making films. So, but that creates another problem, which is how do you get these films out in the world? How do you get them funded? How do you find your audience? And so I do think we are doing some things that are pulled from my world as

SPEAKER_02a casting director, which is like, let's build out a spreadsheet of all of the communities with which you think this film will resonate with, right? And many of the great documentaries aren't just for one specific audience. There's a lot of overlap in terms of like, who's going to connect with a specific film And then finding that audience from the beginning to both audience build as well as fundraise simultaneously. And then people can engage at whatever level they want. So if they want to just dip their toe in, maybe they just sign up for your email list and follow you on Instagram

SPEAKER_02and that's it. We love your film and this is a Jewish story and they want to screen it at their synagogue. Right. And that becomes a way to both build your community and potentially fundraise. Right. Because I think, again, it's about seeking connection first. And then once you have the connection, then the money will come. And when you talk to a lot of filmmakers, a lot of times they're like, well, You know, when you ask them, how did you get the money? There's no real magic bullet. It's like, I went out into the world and this person connected me to that person. I did this thing. And it's a little bit of a web, right?

SPEAKER_02Of how things come to you. And we just like to call it magic.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'll suggest in terms of new pathways, I think that is something that we, from the very beginning, we thought was very important for us. And so we're very proud of our Yahoo initiative because they were not in the documentary shorts game. And so now they license 20 films and paid filmmakers. And that didn't exist a year ago for filmmakers. And so we're asking ourselves as the nonfiction hot list, what other brands, platforms, places don't have any documentaries and should have some documentaries?

SPEAKER_00And where can we go find new audiences as opposed to just funding the infrastructure that we already have?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And just from the branded perspective, as I said, I work a lot casting doc style projects. But in these doc style projects for major brand campaigns, the brands control 100 percent of the editorial within the vision of the director that they choose to hire. And one thing that we're talking to brands about is like, listen, every story that you could possibly want to tell has already been told. You just have to find it. Right. And if it's a brand aligned story that you're on board with, It is it is so we think it's excellent for a brand to not have any editorial control.

SPEAKER_02And these are like independent voices, which is what we love about the Yahoo thing. Like nobody did a reedit on their films. These are their stories that they honored. They they honored the subjects and they told them in the way that they wanted to tell them with their subjects. And for a brand to get on board with that, we think is really exciting. And we actually hope that more brands follow suit because brands in general have a lot of money and could be doing good with that money.

SPEAKER_01And are you so deep? Is that something that you guys are starting to get into, pairing brands and films?

SPEAKER_00Yes. I think we're just looking for partners, partners who want projects and we can help source and curate projects to put in front of them, both projects That are in motion. So they can see the end line of where they are. And projects, to Isis's point, that are already done. And they can look and choose among projects. And because documentary shorts specifically don't really have a marketplace, we think it's a very undervalued spot for both reach and storytellers, for both the filmmaker and the brands to find good deals for both.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I... I mean, I feel like the story of let's get brands to fund documentaries has been sort of in the ether for years. And as we know... There are certain people who are very well-known professionally for doing that, like Brian Newman. Here's what I would

SPEAKER_00say, though. Instead of funding Docs, I think that's the thing that we think there are a lot of people trying to do that. And it's very hard for brands because it's like, see you in a year and a half when

SPEAKER_02you're doing it.

SPEAKER_00What we want to do is also as part, they should still make stuff and do branding, but as part of their media diet, they should also just curate ones that are already done. Ones that are like shorts that are out in the world that they can roll out immediately on their brand and don't have to wait a year and a half just to put all their hopes and dreams on one doc to go to a festival. We think it would be better if the brands put more bets on the roulette table with stuff that's not just in motion that they can do,

SPEAKER_00but stuff that's already done.

SPEAKER_02And for them, it's really smart because it's a quicker turnaround, which they love, and it's a cost savings, which they also love.

SPEAKER_01Do you find that that works particularly well for certain types of subject matter and not for others?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think for sure. And I think it's like for up to a brand and I'm not even sure. We're trying to figure out if we can make this a thing that brands want. We are clear. And it takes a brand willing to do that and, like Isis said, to remove a little bit of control and say, like, these thematically feel right for us, even if they're not a perfect fit in hitting all of us. We think there's a lot of lanes for documentary.

SPEAKER_00There's docs that need impact. There's docs that are just witness to atrocity. And then there's docs that are fun and funny. And there's just a little bit of everything. And I think we need to showcase all sides of docs to the marketplace and have people support.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And when we talk about pathways, new pathways forward, I'm not just talking about partnering with brands, but also like, is this film mission adjacent to a very specific nonprofit? And I think that like businesses and nonprofits need artists and artists need businesses and entrepreneurs. And together there can be real magic because these nonprofits and these businesses actually need story to push whatever their mission is. But they may not know how to find these stories.

SPEAKER_02And I believe that when we get a story in front of them that is so mission aligned, they are thrilled because they might not necessarily have the skills to be able to tell a story like this from scratch. And wow, you just delivered this short film on a silver platter that resonates so much with our community. We could have never made this ourselves. And then they get thrilled to stand alongside this filmmaker to help push the story out in the world through their community.

SPEAKER_00That's our hope. And also we recognize that a single film is very hard for brands. So we want to talk to brands about, again, a slate of films. I mean, the hot list is 23 projects. The Yahoo initiative is 20 films. Like I bet if you look through those projects and those films, you will find something that aligns with whatever taste that you have. And so again, more bets on the board is also a part of this.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And The bottom line is, even with all the challenges in funding documentaries, still more documentaries than ever being made. As we see with film festival submissions, 800 documentaries applied to the TIFF lineup. I mean, that's incredible. So, and having talked to other film festivals programmers, I've heard similar numbers. Sundance got a record number of short submissions. I think it was like 13,000. So there's certainly an abundance of things getting made and figuring out ways

SPEAKER_01to create a marketplace where filmmakers can get paid is like the million dollar question that everyone is trying to solve. So you guys are at the forefront of that, which is so exciting and awesome. And I think the more innovation there is in trying different things so that a few years out, we have a new documentary landscape. And there's new opportunities and new pathways that none of us can even think of right now. Because looking at the media landscape as it is,

SPEAKER_01you know, it's very hard to get a film on a streamer. Even if you get a film on a streamer, it's probably not going to get much promotion. So people won't even know it's there. You know, there are stories of people putting their films on YouTube like Lister's that have done well, but it's few and far between. So I'm excited to see how much you can push this idea because the Yahoo, the new strand at Yahoo for shorts is obviously a huge opportunity for filmmakers and it's going to be exciting to see what you can do beyond that because it's

SPEAKER_01so needed. And I guess like, Taking a step back and thinking about everything you've seen over the last year and a half, both with the business and all the creative energy out there. The million dollar question is how can filmmakers make a living doing this? So I'd like each of you to now answer that question. What do you think the pathway is for filmmakers to be able to make a living making documentaries?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think the frame – we have to frame it not in a binary where you're making a million dollars or zero dollars. And what we really need to do is put some money into filmmakers' pockets to start. One of the things that is very important to us for the hot list is we paid reviewers for the Yahoo thing. And so there was a bunch of filmmakers in between gigs – Who got themselves a little bit of chunk of money that pays for groceries, that does stuff. Or we're talking about a license fee for Yahoo.

SPEAKER_00All the films got $5,000, which is not a lot. But for some of those films that have been sitting on their hard drive for two years and then they're there and getting $5,000, that's great. And so I think the problem is the industry is not focused on picking up those nickels and dimes on the filmmaker's behalf. Because it's a lot of work to do those types of things. But I think there is more opportunities in community screenings that you charge for using the platforms that exist. Going to the nonprofits who might have a little bit of money and are willing to pay

SPEAKER_00for a screening for a night. So it is unfortunate that it's not maybe in one fell swoop. I don't know, I don't know, I don't know. And so if you're doing a project, not a project, you're showing your film to that community, maybe there's a brand in that niche who might then need a commercial

SPEAKER_00or whatever it is. And so if you're just staying in the niche and being in front of people, we hope that those types of things as opposed to I made it in a festival and now it's up to HBO or whoever to like promote this out so I get a phone call with another way to make money. That I think is very challenging, but there are ways to do it. But also it's a little bit like the system helps who's helping themselves. And so being in action, setting up these things is a lot of work and it can feel like not a lot of money,

SPEAKER_00but also it could create the magic to lead to a thing overall.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I will say it really depends on the person. It depends on the artist. It depends on what they're willing to do. Like, are you a person that's like, I solely want to make films and I want filmmaking to be my only source of income? That's a different answer than someone who's like, Okay, I can work on a film, but I also want to follow my curiosity as an artist. And so some people might make a commercial, as Adam said. Some people maybe have their hand in other things creatively.

SPEAKER_02Maybe there's merch or there's another business attached to what it is that they're making. So I think there's a couple different ways to do it. As an artist, I'm proud to say I've only ever made money with my art. I do consider casting to be part of that, but I'm also an actress and I auditioned for film and TV. I've also, you know, made films on my own and it's like, I have like maybe four or five different ways that money comes into me. And from those four or five different ways, education being one of them, I end up making a living.

SPEAKER_02And I feel really proud of that. And I think I would honestly be bored if I had to choose just one thing. And OK, this is the one art that you're going to do because each one helps to inform the others. And that feels really exciting to me. And I also just want to last thing I'll say about this is like even if you look at like big celebrities that are making a living, they have their hand in a bunch of different things, too. It's like. You know, you've got a celebrity that's got a perfume brand, but then they also have a clothing line and they're also starring in their films

SPEAKER_02and they're producing. It's like, I think this model of doing a handful of different things that are all adjacent as an artist is a good one.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I also think going back to the creative filter that you put your ideas through, Another criteria that I would add is what are your goals? Because if your goal, for example, is financial, then picking a subject that is commercial, that a lot of people are interested, commercial, and I'll break that down, a story a lot of people want to watch, you're more likely to make money on it than if you do a story about something

SPEAKER_01that isn't as instantly interesting to everyone else. And a lot of times I think that is, I talk, obviously I talk to a lot of filmmakers and I always ask them like, what are your goals with this project? And it's very rarely financial. I mean, most of the filmmakers that I talk to who reach out to me for advice, like through the Substack, are people who are professionals and earn a living doing something adjacent.

SPEAKER_01And they're making this documentary because it's their passion project. And they don't really have the expectation that it will be a financial success in terms of paying the mortgage. But for those that do, and I definitely also know filmmakers, documentary filmmakers that make a lot of money. And usually the types of films they make are things that a lot of people want to watch, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that's perfectly said. You have to look at my rubric for Newhouse Ideas is about financial. So there is questions in there that are about that. And a lot of times the rubric is not just for the yes, it's for your no. It's for like, oh, this is a B, actually. It's not an A. And I find like that is a key part, at least in my evolution and maturation as a creative, which is to like lay down the B. And let somebody else take that story.

SPEAKER_00And even though it could be made, it's going to take attention and time and energy away from something that lights me up more or is more in line with what I need as my goals in that moment.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I'll just say that like I think that people telling stories or making films because it's healing for them. Is a totally valid and important reason. And I actually think if everybody had their basic needs met and could make art, we would have world peace. And so I think that everyone, I think stories are such an important part of our culture. I think documentaries specifically, as many other people have said before, it's like the most reliable news media actually that we have right now, because these are independent voices not owned by any mega corporations.

SPEAKER_02And so I think I'm also looking for ways to uplift these filmmakers because when you don't put the financial pressure on yourself when you're telling your story, you can sometimes have the most incredible, most amazing, most fulfilling outcome for you and the one that connects most deeply to the person who's watching.

SPEAKER_00Beautifully said. Yeah, I mean, yes, should have leave it there. But we're in the fight too, basically. All I wanted to say is we have not figured this out. We are also trying to make a living and do this and uplift people and be a part of it. And it's better together type thing. And that's kind of what the Nonfiction Hot List is about.

SPEAKER_01So finally, how can people submit? What are the deadlines? Can they submit for the Yahoo series? How can filmmakers work with you?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, the nonfiction hot list, 2026 nonfiction hot list is open right now until September 25th. It's for works in progress. So I would say rough cut and below, not kind of fine cut, just looking for color on your film. Like rough cut and below could be development, could be in production. Also nonfiction. So it could be a feature doc. It could be a short documentary. It could be a series. It could be a digital series. It could be a podcast. We're really also interested in kind of having all of those forms bump up against each other.

SPEAKER_00I think that's really important for the industry. And so we're taking submissions right now. Review process has begun. Got about 40 reviewers. And then the list itself is Which will be a public list. So you can go on the website, get the submission. You can go on the website and sign up for our newsletter. And we're going to publish this deck of these projects to everyone we know in the industry. And so this is a little bit about getting the stuff out there too in a big way and hopefully gaining momentum. So right now that's for that.

SPEAKER_00And then hopefully we'll have some new submissions in the new year for other projects.

SPEAKER_02And the last thing I want to say about the 2026 nonfiction hot list that is new from last year is that if you submit your project, you're automatically in consideration for our first ever artist retreat. We're doing a three week nonfiction hot list storytelling retreat at Atlantic Center for the Arts, which is coming up on its 50th anniversary. It's 60 acres of land on a compound in New Smyrna Beach, Florida. So you'd be if you're selected, you'd be in Florida during February for three weeks, meals and housing provided. This place is iconic. I'm very passionate because I've been there twice and I've had magical experiences

SPEAKER_02that have shaped the trajectory of my work. But they've had, you know, Christine Vachon, Andre 3000, Allen Ginsberg, Edward Albee, just like icon upon icon has been there. And so this this place has it's just extraordinary. So if you submit to the 2026 nonfiction hot list, you're automatically in consideration for this.

SPEAKER_00And it's free and it will always be free to submit to the hot list.

SPEAKER_01Amazing. Well, every time I see you guys, I always say, you work so hard. And it's so commendable, because I know that this is not, let's say, a fully funded position that you guys have at the hot list. So thank you for all that you're doing to support Documentary film, filmmakers, our whole industry. My hat goes off to you and everyone working as part of this.

SPEAKER_01It's something that makes me feel happy whenever I see your posts or read about your initiatives. It's really a ray of light. And I love the spirit in which you do everything. So thank you for all your hard work that you're putting into this. And I can't wait to see what projects you pick next and what cool new opportunities that you'll be launching in the months to come. So definitely appreciate your time.

SPEAKER_01And for all of you who are listening to this or watching, check out the post where we will have a summary of the interview along with the rubric and all the email addresses so you can reach out and submit to the hot list. So thank you so much, Adam and Isis. I hope you enjoy the rest of your day and we'll be in touch.

SPEAKER_02Yes, it was a gift to be here. Thank you, Kathleen.

SPEAKER_01Take care. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Toronto’s Thom Powers: Submissions Are Up, Sales Agents Are Ready, and Audiences are Showing Up.

    Sep 10, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    The Toronto International Film Festival in mid-September is one of the most closely watched marketplaces for documentaries in North America, and as we know buyers are not snapping up films like they used to. But that...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Freedom Has a Price. Can an Owl Named Flaco Afford It?

    Jul 27, 202650 minAudio

    * Watch my live conversation on ‘Wild Inside’ with Penny Lane above. * Read on for my fan favorite “P.S.” section w/notes on why journalism will survive AI, how to win an Oscar, Letterboxd updates, & what Netflix and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. One of Us is Trying to Buy Letterboxd

    Jun 25, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    A few months ago I noticed a post here on Substack by one Elizabeth Joyce about a project to save indie film. I didn’t know her, but I DM’d her anyway. She told me she was building a platform called Community Center...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Don't Wait For Money, A Deal, Or Permission

    Apr 16, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Jeanie Finlay’s approach to making and getting her films to audiences has never followed the usual playbook. She does not chase stories with mass appeal. “I believe that the world would be better if the mic was handed...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 'Cutting Through Rocks' Takes Imagination: On Women and Power in Iran

    Feb 27, 202653 minAudio

    Today I spoke to Sara Khaki and Mohammadreza Eyni, the co-directors (who are also married to each other) of Cutting Through Rocks. The film premiered at the 2025 Sundance Film Festival, where it won the World Cinema...

    Credit the people on this episode