Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Life Unscripted - Stories of Mental Health and Addiction

Life Unscripted - Stories of Mental Health and Addiction artwork

Hiding Suicide Can Mean Grieving a Loved One Twice

Nov 9, 202625 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Lisa Sugarman grew up believing her father died of a heart attack when she was 10, then 35 years later discovered the truth: he died by suicide. Lisa found herself grieving her father twice, this time suicide loss, stigma, and everything people don’t know how to say out loud. Lisa talks about what “grieving twice” really feels like, why families often carry shame and isolation, and how the belief that suicide can be “selfish”. Get Lisa's book on Amazon: Surviving: Finding Hope After Suicide Loss If you’re thinking about suicide, call or text Suicide Crisis Helpline at 9-8-8 toll-free, anytime. If you are in crisis call 9-1-1 immediately.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01I have Lisa Sugarman with me today. And Lisa is uh it's a really good time to talk to Lisa because uh we are going to talk about um suicide. So a warning for people who are listening to this, this this will be a conversation about suicide. Um Lisa is a survivor of losing her father to suicide in sort of a very different way than many of us experience, have experienced, um, and then also has taken that experience and moved forward to uh develop a website and uh and uh sort of a list and of all of resources for all types of things and dividing it.

SPEAKER_01I mean I'm not gonna go and explain all of that, I'll let you do that. So, Lisa, can you tell me about your dad? I know what what you say is you you you lost him twice, you grieved him twice.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I did. Uh so I know that's a strange concept for people to get their minds around, but first of all, thanks for having me. I appreciate you wanting to have this conversation. As far as my father is concerned, I lost my father the first time when I was 10 years old in the summer of 1978. He was 45 years old. He was otherwise extremely healthy and vibrant, and he was a tennis player and he raced cars and he was a mountaineer. And so there were no physical issues with my father.

SPEAKER_00We knew of no mental health-related issues with my father. He was just a joyful man. He was just present and a family man, and he loved me and my mother, and there was no signal that anything was going on below the surface, but clearly there was because 35 years after I was told that he died of a heart attack, I learned the truth that he had actually taken his life. So I grieved him when I was a 10-year-old girl, losing my dad by a heart attack.

SPEAKER_00And ironically, I had lost my cousin who lived right up the road a year before to suicide, and have since lost one of our closest childhood friends about five years ago to suicide. So I've had these three losses over the course of my life, and and then having to grieve my father's loss a second time through a completely different lens from a completely different perspective now as a survivor of suicide loss. And need I mean, needless to say, it just destroyed me.

SPEAKER_00Finding out the truth about his death so unexpectedly and without any indication that anything was ever wrong just really took me down. It really took me down. I've been a content creator my whole life. I've been a book author. I wrote a lot of parenting books and was it kind of in that space for a long time. And it just really shut me down completely. I just didn't feel like I was aligned anymore with the work that I was doing. I had now this lived experience, so much lived experience, and I really didn't know what to do with it.

SPEAKER_00And ultimately, after several years of kind of processing it in my own mind and kind of reconciling with it in whatever way you can reconcile with something like that, I got to a point where I felt really called to or compelled to speak about my story. I started really paying attention to other people who were talking about stories of loss and in particular suicide loss. And I found it incredibly helpful and supportive and validating.

SPEAKER_00And so listening to other people kind of paved the way for me to become one of the people who were sharing my story and getting out there and getting involved with organizations here in the U.S. I'm right, I'm right outside of Boston. So getting involved with the National Alliance on Mental Illness as a storyteller and then becoming a crisis lifeline counselor for the Trevor Project, which, if people don't know, it's the largest US-based LGBTQ crisis and suicide hotline.

SPEAKER_00And I'm involved with Samaritans and the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention and running grief groups for survivors of suicide loss, and just shifted all the work that I was doing to a place of supporting other people going through a similar kind of loss who might be a little closer to that loss. I'm now a long-term suicide loss survivor. So there are people who are going through it right now who are in the thick of it. And I felt really compelled to use my story to help those people. So that's that's really what all of the work that I do in the world is based around.

SPEAKER_00That's how I show up in the world now as someone with just an awful lot of lived experience with a thing that nobody ever wants to have any experience with. But I'm I'm trying to recycle it in a way that it gives people hope and it creates a sense of community and keeps people feeling seen and heard and understood. So that's that's really kind of what I do now in a nutshell, and that's why I do what I do.

SPEAKER_01Well, suicide is so stigmatizing for families, isn't it? And for for friends. And nobody wants to talk about it because of the guilt they feel. Why didn't I know? And like you're saying, your your dad was so active and did so many cool things and just seemed so together that thought he, you know, I'm sure your mom didn't recognize what was happening. But what I'm interested in is how do you think you would have grieved or would you have grieved differently as a 10-year-old if you had been told then than you than you did when you learned when you were 45?

SPEAKER_00That's such an interesting question, and I love that you asked it. I get asked a question similar to that from time to time, and it brings up a lot for me because I was a child the first time, living in a world where you said it yourself, people did not talk about suicide loss. They didn't talk about cancer, they talk about mental illness or depression. And so there wasn't an infrastructure in place the way that there is now a support system in place. A lot of these organizations, like Samaritans or Trevor Project, like I just mentioned, have only been around for between 30 and 50 years.

SPEAKER_00But back in their infancy, we didn't have social media. There was no way to know that they were out there in most cases. And they were just barely getting started, so they didn't have a community. So it was very isolating. And now I'm an adult. And now when it came out, I I was in a world that could better support me. I think to answer your question, if I had found out when I was a child, a bunch of things. First of all, I had a very different perspective on suicide because as I mentioned a little while ago, we had had a suicide in our family the year before my father died.

SPEAKER_00And my parents were very honest with me, telling me that my cousin's brain was sick in a way that we couldn't see. And so they they were very, very tender in the way that they explained that to me. And I got it. I understood that it meant someone took their own life. And because of that understanding, I developed a belief system around suicide that suicide was very selfish. And that's a very common belief system. I've come to understand that that is a bogus belief system and that it is completely false in every way.

SPEAKER_00Someone who has mental illness has an illness like cancer or heart disease or some kind of a treatable illness, and they need to be validated and they need to be treated accordingly. And them taking their life as a byproduct of their illness, unfortunately. Like some cancer patients can't survive and treatment doesn't work. That's similar in nature to having mental illness. And so I, if I had found out at a time in my life when I was 10 years old and it was already believing that suicide was selfish, I don't know if I would ever have felt the same way about my father, if I would ever have found my way back to my father again.

SPEAKER_00I I think it would have taken me down. It was bad enough to lose him, but to find out in that moment without any support system that he had chosen to leave, I don't know if I would have recovered from that. I I don't know what that means, but I find myself answering that question like that often. I don't know if I would have been able to live with that. And yeah, I'm grateful to God for shielding me, is is what it all boils down to.

SPEAKER_01I've had um many times in my life, especially I went through a period where I was very, very ill, where suicide was um for me sometimes, and I talk about this, I didn't want to live, but I didn't want to die, and I didn't know what to do. So I lived in this in this world where um I needed to make a decision and I couldn't. And when when I I did reach an end point in being in that sort of space, dying was what what I chose because living was way too painful.

SPEAKER_01Um I I didn't know how to live, I didn't know how to go forward. And at the time when I was in that headspace, I didn't think of it as something that would be um um leaving my my family in in selfishness and how could I do that to them? You're just in that space, and that's all you could can think of. You're just it's it's like you're in an alternate reality.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So it's it's an interesting place to do. And thankfully, I'm sitting here talking to you today.

SPEAKER_00Very thankfully, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Now, why did you learn at 45? Did uh what what was the decision? Did you just happen to learn, or was there a decision from someone in your family to say, hey, you know what? Lisa, we should tell Lisa this.

SPEAKER_00No, no. So I'm an only child, and I was living in a home with my mother and her mother, so my maternal grandmother, who was my best friend in the world. So it was three generations of us living together, no siblings, family all around us, but a very complicated relationship with my father's side of the family, which my mother and I believe had a lot to do with my father's mental illness and the situation that he found himself in. And you know, I it was a very difficult time.

SPEAKER_00Um I I don't I don't know my mother at that time wanted to shield me from this horrible experience. And she did that in such a beautiful way, and I'm so grateful for that. You know, I we were just living in a world where we it couldn't be addressed, it it was it was kept quiet, it was not something my mother was willing to to broach with me because she just didn't know what it would do to me.

SPEAKER_00And I ended up living with this narrative for 35 years and ended up with my husband just on a random afternoon in my hometown, 35 years after finding out that he had had died of a supposed heart attack. And we were sitting having lunch at a cafe. A cousin of mine from my father's side of the family came by who was not in my in my community often. She she used to live there, but she was visiting and she came and just locked herself right down.

SPEAKER_00And she ended up asking just you know, catch-up questions. Just how's your kids? How are your kids? How are my kids? And from there, she just it was like she pulled the pin on a grenade. It's the best way that I know how to describe what that moment was. It was such an innocuous conversation, it was just harmless. But out of nowhere, she just pulled the pin on a grenade and threw it on the table and she said, How are the girls? Are they dealing with any of the same mental illness that your dad dealt with? And I had no idea what she was talking about.

SPEAKER_00I had absolutely no idea what in the world she was talking about. And I'm kind of side-eyeing my husband, who had never met my dad but knew everything that was to know about my dad. Right. So he's looking at me like, what? What is she talking about? And you know, when you're in those moments sometimes where someone maybe says something or discloses something and you're so completely caught off guard that you just don't react to it. I didn't react to it. I I think I just reacted in the moment my kids, our kids were teenagers at the time, and I said, They're they're both fine.

SPEAKER_00And I I kind of took in what she said and I was trying to process it. And before I could even consider answering it or asking follow-up questions, like, what are you even talking about? She was on to something else. And before I knew it, she got off from the table, great to see you, gone in a puff of smoke. And I was left kind of looking at my husband, like, what the hell just happened? What was that? And my mother and I are extraordinarily close. She is my person in this world. She and my husband are my people, along with my daughters. And I didn't run to her immediately after that, which is a weird, a weird part of the story that I still can't understand because that would have been my default, was to go to my mom immediately, but I didn't.

SPEAKER_00So I think we saw each other the next day and not with the intention of asking her anything about that conversation. Just got together for lunch. And we're talking about my dad, which always came up because we always reminisced about my dad. And without even honestly, Janice, without even knowing the words were coming out of my mouth, I said, Did dad have issues with depression? And she kind of looked at me like I had never asked that question before. And I didn't know where it came from. And she didn't hesitate. She said yes. And then before the words even came out of my mouth, I had no intention of asking, it wasn't on my conscious mind.

SPEAKER_00I said, Did dad take his life? And she did not even blink and said yes. And it just in that one moment, the entire trajectory of my life changed. Everything, the work that I do, who I was, my identity, the way I show up in the world, it all changed.

SPEAKER_01Well, well, I I'm I'm trying to get my mind as well around your cousin sitting down and saying, Hey, are your kids suffering from you know the same kind of mental illness your dad did? Who says that? Nobody, right? So in the end, I guess it allowed you to learn about your dad. Um, obviously, there was a lot of grief and and confusion you had to cope with. But you you, like you said, it did cause you to, your focus in your life went in a bit of a different direction, and you started focusing on helping people who were living with uh someone they loved who had died by suicide.

SPEAKER_01And we talk about it a little bit more openly now than than we used to, and I think even in the last five years it's probably gotten better. But people who have never lived through it, who have never experienced losing someone to suicide, or have experienced those that kind of you know suicidal thinking themselves, I don't honestly think they can understand because their brain never goes there.

unknownNo.

SPEAKER_01And that's that whole idea of someone who is who has suicidal ideation isn't thinking, oh, you know, today I think I think I'll think about suicide. It happens and you can't control that. Um but you also, my understanding, um, and I haven't lost anybody in my family personally, thank goodness. But the I want to talk to you more about the effect on families still, because they don't understand, unless there's been some indication, can cause people to just withdraw.

SPEAKER_01And they don't want to talk about it because they don't want to be asked the question. They don't want to have to explain it because it's it's just one of the most shameful parts of mental illness. When you're talking to families, how do you walk them through this sort of process, different process of grief? We know there's, I don't know, seven stages of grief or whatever they call it now. That process of grief must be very different.

SPEAKER_00It is very different because suicide, just by nature of the act of suicide, it has elements to it that generalized grief and loss just don't have. I mean, you already said one of them, which is shame, and stigma comes right alongside of shame. And there are the questions of the why and the what could I have done. We've touched on those already. And then the the there's an even bigger piece, too, that can affect some families, which is the actual trauma of potentially finding their person and being the person to experience that kind of trauma.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, we all we all know that those images are images that, you know, are with you for the rest of your life. Whether whether you're someone who has experienced it or not, anyone who understands what that situation could potentially be like automatically will understand why that's something that stays with you forever. So you've got all of these complex parts, moving parts of a suicide loss that just don't exist when someone dies of a heart attack or someone goddripped and gets hit by a car or has cancer and has treatment and it's unsuccessful.

SPEAKER_00So I think the the biggest thing, now keep keep one thing in mind, and it's I I like to clarify this, especially when I'm I'm chatting about what I do. I am not a clinician. I am not a clinician, I am not a therapist, I'm not licensed to counsel. What I am is a certified attracting crisis counselor on a crisis lifeline. I'm certified to be on the 988 crisis lifeline and I'm on the Trevor Lifeline. I also moderate a grief group for Samaritans here in Boston called Safe Place for Survivors of Suicide Laws.

SPEAKER_00So those are the things that I am. And so I don't do a lot of necessarily counseling of families, but I have a lot of contact, whether it be on lifelines or in groups, with parents who are dealing with what do I tell my children? How do we navigate this? I've just lost my partner. And I think the most important thing right away is to just validate what someone is experiencing and and acknowledge how different what it is they're going through is from what most people around them are probably going through.

SPEAKER_00And because you can't take the pain away. There's nothing I can say. There's nothing I can possibly say. There's no magic pill or YouTube video I can show someone or book I can give someone. It's it just it all comes down to validating someone's experience as something that is very unusual and extraordinarily traumatic and very isolating because when when you're walking around having that kind of lived experience and you're the only one in a room who's lost someone to suicide loss, you're on an island all by yourself.

SPEAKER_00And so once once I try to validate how intense and traumatic something is with someone that I have a conversation with, the next thing I try to encourage them to do is just is find community, find support. Who do you have to lean into, whether it be a therapist or a counselor or a group or a platform or a friend support network or or circle? Because inevitably when you kind of go outside yourself, because it's we've already said this a number of times, it's so isolating, when you go outside of yourself and you find community, that's for a lot of people where they find hope again, where they find connection, where they find more validation that they're not the only ones out there going through it alone.

SPEAKER_00So that's that's how I handle that. And I also say, look, you're not gonna have the answers. You know, that's one of the things that I say time and time again. You're just not going to have all the answers. And like in my own case, in terms of the why, we don't know why. We don't we don't know all the reasons. We suspect certain things, we knew certain things that were going on. My father did leave a note, it was very brief. It was more of an I'm sorry, I can't go on, I love you both, goodbye. And that was the extent. So we don't really know.

SPEAKER_00And it's really just walking someone through the fact that they're they may never know, which is I can speak from personal experience, is a it's a really, really hard piece of it when that is a piece you have to navigate.

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, the the reason that I wanted to interview you was the fact that you're not a therapist, right? I mean, it's uh uh it's hard sometimes, and and especially when it comes to suicide, to find someone who does want to talk so openly about it because you and I are in the same position. One of the things we want to do is reduce stigma, make it a safe place, make the world a safe place for people to talk. That's not always going to happen, but what I do notice is that there are more people who are saying, My loved one died by suicide.

SPEAKER_01There are people who are putting it in an obituary, um, a celebration of their life, and they um, you know, they don't know. Some of them say we don't know why. But my son or my husband died by suicide, and we're so happy that we had the years of joy and and um uh so the work that you let let's move now to taking all of that experience that you have and talk about some of the work you do.

SPEAKER_01And the website, I love your website, so I want to ask you about that. And I believe it's the hub.co. It's yeah, it's called thehelpub.co. Yeah, thehelpub.co.

SPEAKER_00Yep.

SPEAKER_01And I went on there and it's literally resources and and it be uh broken into categories. And I was so happy to see that in the you know, the first row was Canada, because that's where I am. And so I clicked there right away, obviously, and you had some of the you know major places where people could could reach out for for helping just and get information that a lot of a lot of times people just need to read about it and try to understand and talk to or read about someone like you who is sharing their experience so they don't feel that they're the only person.

SPEAKER_01But let's talk about the because you've divided it up into so many um segments or or demographics. And how did that come about?

SPEAKER_00So, first of all, I appreciate you asking about it because it's like my little baby. Um, I've been growing this platform now for the past two years. It will be, I think, two years since I relaunched it. It was my website. It started off as Lisasugerman.com, which no longer exists. And it was just a place, I as I mentioned, I'm a writer and that's what I do, and so I create a lot of content. And so I it was kind of a parking lot for all the content and that I create. In case anyone was ever curious, the archives were there. That was all my website ever was.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I mean the in the moment part, people who are in the moment or even just you know down the road, still trying to deal with stuff, they're not gonna know Google what. Right. Google what, and then Google AI said you get what you think it might be, and then you check that, and that's not it, it's checks that, and that's not it. So, so um, I appreciate so much that you have put together the helphub.co. And I really appreciate you coming on and talking about suicide.

SPEAKER_01It's people like you talking about it who are going to make it easier for the rest of us to talk about it. So thank you.

SPEAKER_00I sure hope so. You're so welcome.

SPEAKER_01That's the ultimate goal. If you or someone you know is struggling or in crisis, help is available. You can call or text 988 in Canada and the United States to reach the suicide crisis helpline. If this is an emergency, please call 911 or go to your nearest hospital emergency room.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Drinking at 13 can Wipe Away Awkwardness but It Never Lasts

    Nov 13, 202630 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Novelist Laura Van Wormer grew up with parents who liked to party. She was a shy teenager. Her first drink at 13 helped mask the awkwardness and made her social life easier. She began a successful...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Flood Trauma Is Real And Your Body Remembers It

    Sep 17, 202624 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Three catastrophic rain storms and massive flooding in Niagara this summer left residents stunned, scared and reeling with the pressure of cleaning up. In the days the after the flood, even a little...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Willow Arts Is So Much More Than Art Therapy

    Aug 17, 202623 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail The Willow Arts Community may seem like "art therapy" but rather than a clinical approach with a therapist it provides a free, peer-led creative experience and connection for people across Niagara...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why Teens and Young Adults Struggle to Build Self-Worth

    Aug 10, 202625 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail For many teens and young adults thoughts Are Not Facts. Getting out of bed can be the hardest part of the day, and for a lot of teens, that struggle stays hidden behind jokes, grades, or silence. Youth...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Get a Prescription to Nature for Better Mental Health

    Jul 21, 202623 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail It’s not a joke when a doctor or other health care professionals gives you a prescription to nature to improve your mental and physical health. Dr. Melissa Lem, a Vancouver family physician and...

    Credit the people on this episode