Warning: Episode discusses self harm. Fergus Cameron was born to fortune, but a deadly love triangle would underline his unfortunate life. Subscribe to Crime X+ to hear episodes early and ad free, unlock bonus content and access our slate of award-winning true crime podcasts Have a question for one of our Q+A shows? ask it at: lifeandcrimes@news.com.au Like the show? Get more at https://heraldsun.com.au/andrewrule Advertising enquiries: newspodcastssold@news.com.au Crimestoppers: https://crimestoppers.com.au/ If you or anyone you know needs help Lifeline: 13 11 14 Beyond Blue: 1300 22 4636 Kids Helpline: 1800 55 1800
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1She's lifted the T-shirt up to expose Beth Barnard's abdomen and slashed a large letter A. When we have people who just go missing without trace, it leaves a black hole that is inevitably filled with speculation and spite and suspicion and often errant nonsense. I'm Andrew Rule and this
Speaker 1is Life and Crimes. Death comes to us all and recently, this month, a man died at Phillip Island whose death invites us to look into the tumultuous events of his life. Now this unfortunate fella was called Fergus Cameron. Fergus Cameron is a fortunate man who led an unfortunate life Fergus was born to a big family on the island. They
Speaker 1were big landholders, farmers, well-established people, and held quite a lot of property there. In fact, he and his family sold a large amount of land to Lindsay Fox to develop the Grand Prix track, and that is one of the reasons that the Cameron family were one of the island's biggest and best-known families. quite influential in their way, all of which didn't help Fergus Cameron when his life
Speaker 1more or less fell apart. What happened was this. Back in the 1980s, in fact 1986, in fact exactly 40-odd years ago, Fergus Cameron's name was dragged through the mud because his very young lover, a young woman called Beth Barnard, was murdered most brutally and Fergus Cameron's wife Vivian, mother of two little boys, vanished on the night that the
Speaker 1young woman was murdered. Now there's a bit of background to this. Back in 1984, two years before these events, Beth Barnard, who was then 21 years old, had come down from Melbourne where she had grown up in the suburbs. She was the daughter of a prominent QC, a barrister called John Barnard, I think. And her parents owned a property down on the island, as many well-heeled people do. And Beth decided that she wanted to work in the
Speaker 1area on farms and so on. I think she, you know, was a girl who liked animals and all the rest of it. And she came down and worked for the Cameron family on their property. I'm guessing that the Camerons and the Barnards probably knew each other. I would imagine, and it soon came about that young Beth, who was 21 when she got there, 23 when she was murdered, she formed an attachment with Fergus Cameron, who was in
Speaker 1his mid-30s, married with two kids. They had a steamy affair, and news of this, of course, rumours of this and news of this, soon reached... Fergus Cameron's wife, Vivian. Now, Vivian, it would appear, did hear rumours to this effect and then acted on them as best she could. But it turned out that, in fact, her husband and his lover continued to see each other. And one thing led to another.
Speaker 1And in September 1986, matters came to a head in a most dreadful way. And what happened on the evening of of September the 22nd, 1986, and next morning, the 23rd of September, was most probably a murder-suicide scenario. What we know for a fact is that on that evening, Fergus Cameron came home to his own farmhouse where his wife and kids were, and he had been visiting Beth Barnard,
Speaker 1the young woman, that evening. clearly had words with his wife or she had words with him about where he'd been. And one thing led to another, as we keep saying, and she threw a wine glass at him, which cut Fergus Cameron's head, I think his ear, and also his back. Now, whether Vivian Cameron wielded the broken wine glass and stabbed him, I don't know, but I guess if you throw a glass with enough force, it will cut you. She then
Speaker 1gets him to get into the Toyota four-wheel drive, the Land Cruiser that they used, and she drove him recently late that night to the local hospital where there was a nurse. And Fergus is bleeding and probably a bit upset. Mrs Cameron is not bleeding, but no doubt upset. However, when asked what had happened, they mumbled something, some excuse about you know, a broken glass door. They didn't actually
Speaker 1confide in the nurse about what had actually happened, which is not that surprising. But it goes to the Camerons. They were the sort of people that, even under duress, they were proud and private people who did not air their dirty washing in public. After Fergus is treated and gets his ear taped up and all the rest of it, his wife... Vivian drives him home to their house where they have a further conversation apparently and around midnight, I
Speaker 1don't think anything was resolved really, around midnight she drives him over to his sister's house. Now he had a sister, Marnie, who's no longer with us, Marnie Cameron as she was, and Vivian drops her brother there so he can sleep the night at his sister's house and the idea is that she will go home to be with the children, the two little boys. Well, that's all right. But when she gets home, she actually makes a phone call to
Speaker 1a friend and she says to the friend, she tells the friend a white lie. She says, look, I want you to come over and pick the kids up for me and look after them because I have to take Fergus to hospital. Now, clearly she'd already been to the hospital two or three hours earlier and she was now making up a scenario to get someone to look after her boys and this would suggest that in her head she had some half-formed plan that she wanted to go
Speaker 1out somewhere and do something. It's clear that she's driving the four-wheel drive around that night. Some people might argue that you know someone else could have been driving it and someone else did something to her and so on but it makes a lot more sense to assume that Vivian is driving the four-wheel drive around that night. So it's well after midnight. It's, you know, three o'clock in the morning or thereabouts. She's apparently driven over to Rill,
Speaker 1which is another part of Phillip Island. It's quite a big island. There are many, many farms and there are little townships or villages scattered around it. She's gone over to Rill where... Beth Barnard lives on her parents' property. And she has woken up Beth Barnard, it would appear, confronted her in bed. And it seems that she's taken with her a butcher's knife, a big knife, and that she has attacked Beth Barnard and killed her. And it
Speaker 1is a frenzied attack. It is a classic example of where the victim is the target of great anger. It is something that police and forensic people see and it's clearly a frenzied and angry attack. When multiple wounds are inflicted, when, you know, two would do but they inflict 32. What the killer does, we have to assume it is Vivian
Speaker 1Cameron that did this and all the indications are that it was her. But the killer, presumably Vivian Cameron, After killing Beth Barnard, who's in bed, I think wearing a T-shirt, she's lifted the T-shirt up to expose Beth Barnard's abdomen and slashed a large letter A into her abdomen like this. A very big A, which is done with repeated cuts of the butcher's knife. So bang, bang, bang down one side,
Speaker 1bang down the other and bang across to form the capital letter A. Now, This was a shocking thing to do, but there was method in her madness. It was clearly a symbol, which people next day realised when Beth's body was found. It was a symbol lifted directly from a very popular and well-known book, a book called The Scarlet Letter, which Vivian would have studied at school and or possibly college.
Speaker 1And The Scarlet Letter was a quite famous a book written by the American Nathaniel Hawthorne, which was about a Puritan woman who had a baby out of wedlock, a baby fathered by a lover other than her husband, and her punishment was to go about her life in a Puritan village in colonial America, in New England, wearing this A as a mark of shame and guilt. And it's
Speaker 1clear that this was what Vivian Cameron intended when she slashed that letter into the dead body of Beth Barnard, a most shocking thing to do. And it was something that you would imagine only a wronged wife might do. It doesn't seem to be the sort of thing that's going to be inflicted by anyone else, although there are
Speaker 1always people with alternative theories, rather complex theories. We know that that happened. Beth Barnard is dead. We know that the Toyota is then driven towards the bridge at San Remo. Now, the only way to get onto Phillip Island is via the bridge that comes in off the highway over, it's like a causeway, and it deposits a driver onto Phillip Island. And that bridge is quite a big, handsome piece of engineering,
Speaker 1and it spans a very fast-flowing tidal channel. It's the tidal channel that ebbs and flows into Western Port Bay and out again into Bass Strait. So it is deep and it's fast. And it is, I've read up on this, and clearly if you, jump into it when the tide is flowing, you will be swept out or swept in very rapidly, particularly out, at a rate of knots. In fact,
Speaker 1faster than a person can walk is how fast it is. So what it seems has happened is that Vivian has killed the young woman, driven the Toyota to a place near the bridge. Now, she didn't drive it up. onto the bridge and abandon the vehicle with the doors open and the lights on. Had she done that, it would have made it very clear that she'd done this thing.
Speaker 1But for whatever reason, and we have to remember that this is a woman under enormous stress, she was not thinking particularly straight and it's funny what works on people's minds when they're under great stress. She actually parked the car back about 400 metres from the centre of the bridge over on the island side. And she parked it near some streets and houses near a particular street called,
Speaker 1I think, Forest Street or Forest Road. And it was parked on a grassy verge where it sort of blended into the landscape fairly well and didn't stand out in any way. The doors were shut. It just looked quite normal. Now, next day when the... Alarm is raised. Beth Barnard's body is found. People start looking around for Vivian and they start looking for the vehicle or whichever vehicle they think she might be in. I presume there was more than
Speaker 1one vehicle in the Cameron family that she could have used. The Toyota is not actually spotted and identified and opened up and looked at until just before four o'clock in the afternoon next day. It's sat there all day on this grassy verge without anybody actually spotting it. It's just one of those things. They overlooked it. When the police come to look at it, what they find inside, I would suggest, is fairly conclusive. They found two packets of
Speaker 1Claridge cigarettes, the ones that Vivian smoked. These matched the butts of cigarettes left at the murder house, at the murder scene. It looked as if, having killed Beth Barnard, she's Smoked furiously while washing herself, washing blood off her hands and so on. And left butts at the scene. So the cigarettes match. They also find in her handbag a large butcher's knife. And it has signs of having
Speaker 1been used. I think probably still damp from being washed. They also find a face washer that's got blood on it. She's used it to wipe herself down. So there's blood. There's a knife and there's cigarettes, all of which link her, Vivian, to the murder. But there's no sign of Vivian. It would appear the police conclude, and I have to say a coroner later agreed, and you can see why they agreed,
Speaker 1because it was the most simple and obvious explanation. It was agreed, the police concluded that having driven there, parked the vehicle, she walked toward the bridge, walked up onto the bridge and then threw herself into the tidal stream running out to sea at that point. Now, between, say, 3am and dawn, the tide was ebbing quite fast and if she'd done that, she would have dropped into something
Speaker 1like 16 metres deep water, very deep water really, and been swept out fairly quickly and It is a place that is frequented by sharks, and not only sharks but white pointer sharks. It's quite well known for it. There are also, of course, in Bass Strait, barracuda, which are flesh-eating fish, which will clean up bodies if you let them. And there are sea lice. Sea lice are tiny things which millions of them can strip a body back to
Speaker 1bones within a day or two, they say. Now, this, of course, is what the experts said, actual experts who know what they're talking about, said when Prime Minister Harold Holt went missing off Cheviot Beach at Portsea back in 1967, that if the body is lodged under a rock or caught or somehow on the bottom and not floating, in no time the scavengers and the sea lice will strip
Speaker 1the flesh away and then of course there's nothing but bones and it's never going to float and you're never going to find it, probably. So it makes absolute sense that that is what happened to Vivian Cameron. But because no sign of her body was ever actually found, it has left open the door for speculation. Now the missing, when we have people who just go missing without trace,
Speaker 1It leaves a black hole that is inevitably filled with speculation and spite and suspicion and often errant nonsense. Some people are never happy to accept the most obvious conclusion. If it seems likely that A murdered B and then walked off a cliff, That's too easy. They want it to have Martians involved or, you know, some sort of
Speaker 1complicated plot, some conspiracy to have, you know, lots of people involved, not just one and so on and so forth. The other thing that often happens with suicides is people say, but, but, you know, so-and-so, they wouldn't have suicided. I saw them two days before and they were talking about running a birthday party for their child or, they were planning Christmas or they really loved their family, they just wouldn't do this. Now, these are just broad assertions which, of course, when made
Speaker 1about suicide victims are 98 times out of 100, they're wrong because the reality is that suicide victims are exactly that. They have committed suicide and regardless of how normal they seem to be in the recent past, The reality is that people sometimes take it into their head at very short notice to kill themselves and that they are very good at disguising their intentions and their motives until they
Speaker 1actually do it. Now, on the knight in question, remember, these two people, this husband and wife who have gone to war, one has thrown a wine glass at the other. She's then driven him to the hospital, but neither of them have said anything to the nurse that would indicate that they are essentially tearing each other apart, that they are fighting and that there's a lot at stake. They maintained a facade. I would suggest that in the case
Speaker 1of Vivian Cameron, she maintained that facade almost to the end, that even in parking her Toyota Land Cruiser in a normal way, closing the door and walking off to the bridge and basically not making a fuss, basically choosing a quiet and discreet exit in the quiet and still hour before dawn when no one's around that she was doing
Speaker 1the very thing that her character told her she should do that is not to make a fuss, to exit quietly, not to make a scene, and not to make a spectacle of herself. And it seems to me that that is by far the most likely scenario. Now, other people have reasons to speculate along other lines, and one of the reasons is that, of course, when you've got a
Speaker 1love triangle, a prominent landholder, a QC's daughter and a very angry wife, you've got a very interesting piece of voyeurism that works very well when somebody's retelling that story elsewhere because this isn't a drunken argument down at the caravan park on pension night. This is people with money
Speaker 1and position and property and all the rest of it. who are behaving badly. And of course, they are always a much bigger story, which is just the way it goes. And the fact that one of them, the presumed murderer, has vanished off the face of the earth is catnip for those who want to exploit the story and sell it as a story, as a book or whatever it
Speaker 1might be. Now, there's nothing wrong with that. True crime books are a staple diet for a lot of people. I've had a lot to do with producing them. There's no law against true crime books, and a good thing too. And there's no law that says they have to be really, really high quality and reach some level of forensic excellence. They don't have to. They can be virtually anything that their authors want them to be, providing they don't actually
Speaker 1defame the living. It seems to me that a book written about this case back in the early 90s, it nailed the public's interest in this case and fostered public interest in the case, because that book, which was co-authored by a pretty handy journalist at the time, and later it was reissued by the main author, several times, updated editions. It has stoked an interest in this case that has
Speaker 1lasted 40 years. And I know that now on the 40th anniversary, with the death of Fergus Cameron, that that book will be reissued in the very near future, between now and Christmas, and it will find a lot of new readers, as well as probably a lot of old readers. And for the very good reason that people are fascinated by this case, not only in Victoria, not only in Australia, but some of them overseas. They're fascinated with this case
Speaker 1in the way that they've become fascinated by the Mr. Cruel case and the Carmen Chan part of the Mr. Cruel case. And the way that people have become fascinated, not only across Australia, but overseas in the mushroom case. In South Gippsland, some stories, particularly of wronged women seeking revenge, seem to have a resonance that lasts long after the
Speaker 1victims are buried. And the Phillip Island murders is at the top rank of those sort of stories. It's about jealousy. It's about revenge. And at heart, it is still a mystery because although it seems fairly plain to the police and to the coroner, and really, I suspect to most journalists, it's pretty plain what happened here, that is, the killer
Speaker 1jumped off the bridge and was never seen again, the mystery lingers and that makes the story hang on all the longer. It is one of Victoria's most enduring stories. What won't be said at Fergus Cameron's memorial service could fill volumes, and indeed it already has. It has filled the volumes of the non-fiction book. But it has also inspired,
Speaker 1at the other end of the literary scale, the very fine author Chloe Hooper, whose debut novel in 2002, was called The Children's Book of True Crime. Now, that book was notionally set in Tasmania, but it clearly echoes the Phillip Island case. And it shows you just how much this story grabs some people's imaginations. Thanks for listening. Life
Speaker 1and Crimes is a Sunday Herald Sun production for True Crime Australia. Our producer is Jonty Burton. For my columns, features and more, go to heraldsun.com.au forward slash Andrew Rule, one word. For advertising inquiries, go to newspodcastssold at news.com.au. That is all one word, newspodcastssold. And if you want further information about this episode, links are in the description.
Donna rejoins the show to discuss the world the men who assaulted her inhabited and the circles of criminals they associated with. Subscribe to Crime X+ to hear episodes early and ad free, unlock bonus content and...
Matt Dillon patrolled Melbourne's streets for decades. He joins the show with a warning. Crimestoppers: https://crimestoppers.com.au/ If you or anyone you know needs help call Lifeline: 13 11 14 Beyond Blue: 1300 22...
In the first of a four-part special, Andrew Rule talks to a woman, Donna, who after a horrifying assault, has fought for half a century for justice. Subscribe to Crime X+ to hear episodes early and ad free, unlock bonus...
WARNING: DISTURBING CONTENT. Narelle Fraser joins the show to recount some of the worst criminals she investigated. Find out more about the documentary The Policewoman at: https://filmquarter.com.au/thepolicewoman...
WARNING: DISTURBING CONTENT: Former cop Narelle Fraser joins the show to talk about her remarkable career going up against some of the worst crims in the state. Find out more about the documentary The Policewoman at:...