Chronic pain comes with a lot of messages about what pain means, what you should avoid, and what you need to do to get better. But what if some of those long-held beliefs are actually making it harder to move forward? In this episode, Deb and Lindsay unpack common chronic pain myths - including the belief that pain always means damage, imaging tells the whole story, stress makes pain “psychological,” rest is always best, and you need to eliminate pain before you can start living again. Drawing from current pain science and their backgrounds in nursing, physical therapy, nervous system regulation, and chronic pain care, they explore a more complete way of understanding pain - and why movement, stress regulation, mindset, connection, and gradually building capacity can all be important pieces of the puzzle. If chronic pain has left you fearful, frustrated, or unsure what to believe, this conversation may help you look at your pain - and your possibilities - a little differently. Follow Us: Website: LessStressinLife.com/podcast/ Stay tuned for more conversations to empower you to live well, manage stress, and build a thriving, healthy life!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Deb TimmermanWelcome to the Less Stress in Life podcast. I'm Deb Timberman, founder of Less Stress in Life, registered nurse, and board certified reflexologist. I help people navigate the stressors of chronic illness and understand how stress can feed ongoing pain cycles and impact overall health.
Lindsay VertalkaAnd I'm Lindsay Vertulka, a master's level licensed physical therapist. I help people move through injuries, disabilities, and chronic conditions using a holistic approach that blends movement with the mental and emotional side of living with pain. Between the two of us, we've worked with and experienced chronic illness, both professionally and personally.
Deb TimmermanThis season, we're focusing on what it really looks like to live well with chronic illness. We're here to bring you practical tools, research-backed insights, guests who are walking this path, and fresh approaches you may not have tried so you could feel more hopeful, more informed, and more supported along the way. Hello everyone. If you live with chronic pain, chances are you've heard a lot of explanations for why you hurt and a lot of advice about what you should or shouldn't be doing.
Deb TimmermanMaybe you've been told that the changes on your MRI explain everything, and maybe you're one of those people who have pain but have no diagnosis after having an MRI. So today we're going to talk about chronic pain myths that might be keeping you stuck. We'll look at what current pain science tells us about the relationship between pain and tissue damage, what imaging can and can't tell us, why movement isn't necessarily something to fear, and most importantly, cover some information about the role that the brain and the nervous system play in the pain experience.
Deb TimmermanSo this episode isn't about suggesting that your pain isn't real. Pain is always real. It's about understanding that pain is more complex than we once thought, and that understanding may give us more options for moving forward. So, Lindsay, hi, it's great to see you again.
Lindsay VertalkaHi Deb, it's great to see you and be back together.
Deb TimmermanSo let's start with probably the biggest one that we hear, and that is myth number one. If it hurts, you're damaging something. So people believe that if they hurt, something must be damaged.
Lindsay VertalkaYeah, this is one I hear a lot in the physical therapy clinic. And kind of what it can lead to is a lot of fear for people. You know, they're afraid if I have pain, something's damaged. And if I exercise or if I walk on it, I'm going to do worse damage. When in fact, yes, sometimes there are torn meniscus or injuries that are causing pain. But it doesn't necessarily, just because you have pain, doesn't necessarily mean that there's damage. So doing things like exercising doesn't always mean that that you could cause more injury.
Lindsay VertalkaPain is information. Acute pain that you have when you first injure something serves as a protective warning system.
Deb TimmermanSo it's basically your brain telling you that you hurt something, stay off of it. I think we've talked about that before in a previous podcast.
Lindsay VertalkaExactly. Yeah, we did a whole podcast, I think, on the nervous system in the brain. And certainly there are times where imaging, and I'm going to talk about this a little bit later in this part of the podcast, but imaging findings don't always give the big picture or the full picture.
Deb TimmermanSo let's talk about imaging next. So myth number two is imaging explains everything.
Lindsay VertalkaYes. So many times I have patients that come into therapy and say, I don't know why I'm doing therapy. The doctor told me I need to come here first to prove to insurance they have to pay for an MRI. And it's easy to get very focused on I need an X-ray or I need an MRI, I need a CAT scan, because we think that's going to have all the answers when in fact imaging doesn't always tell the whole story. It does feel objective. It gives people feel like they get answers.
Lindsay VertalkaUm, but I have patients who have had pain, say from arthritis, and a doctor will say, Your knee is bone on bone. I've had many patients who have images of both knees that one looks okay and one doesn't look okay. But the one that looks okay is actually more painful. And sometimes a surgeon will make a decision about which knee to replace first based on the one they think looks worse, when maybe it should have been the other one because that's causing more pain and dysfunction, causing stairs to be difficult.
Lindsay VertalkaDoes that make sense?
Deb TimmermanYeah, it does. So I have been listening to this book by Dr. Howard Schubner called Unlearn Your Pain. And he talked about this study about people with back pain. And it's called the Jepson study, and it was published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 1994. So that's a long time ago. And what they did was they performed lumbar MRIs on these 98 people without back pain. And this is what they found only 36% of those people that had no back pain had normal disc.
Deb TimmermanSo people who were pain-free had 52% of them had at least one disc bulge, 27% had a disc protrusion, 38% had abnormalities at more than one disc, and 64% had some intervertebral disc abnormality. So that study speaks to what you just described, where you have two knees that are different.
Deb TimmermanThe one that is better is more painful than the one that looks worse on X-ray.
Lindsay VertalkaYes, exactly. And that's confusing because I think most of us think, oh, if I have a disc bulge, that must be causing all of my symptoms. When in fact, if you looked at a lot of us and did imaging of our spines, you're gonna find wear and tear and you're gonna find disc bulges, but that doesn't necessarily mean you have debilitating symptoms.
Deb TimmermanYeah, in fact, some people with all of those things never have pain at all. There's another study that they looked at 67 people that had never experienced low back pain, sciatica, and one-third of them at least had abnormal scans. So it's really interesting this whole role of how we look at diagnostics, and we think that if we attach a label to it, right, it makes some sense in our brain.
Deb TimmermanBut really, it almost adds more mix to the muddle, doesn't it?
Lindsay VertalkaIt really does. And I think the point we want to bring home for all of you guys listening is you do get a lot of information from imaging and sometimes helps them make a decision about what you're gonna do, but there's a lot of pieces of the puzzle when it comes to pain. And I would caution people to not just focus on imaging results because yeah, you might have a herniated disc that's showing, but no symptoms or very minimal symptoms. So, do you want to really jump into surgery? I think we're hoping to teach you that there is more factors that can make the nervous system sensitive, and it's important to think about the sensitivity of the nervous system, stress levels, your sleeping, your beliefs and your fears.
Lindsay VertalkaAnd we're gonna do a whole nother podcast pretty soon about the mind and the connection between the mind and the body. But just think about imaging as just one piece of the puzzle.
Deb TimmermanSo that would be like stress is another piece of the puzzle. So the next myth: stress means your pain isn't physical. And I feel like I can tackle that one. Stress does a lot of crazy things to our body and sends a lot of biomedical flags, if you will, that something's wrong. It doesn't mean that something's wrong, stress is trying to get our attention so that we can modify the factors that are causing stress.
Deb TimmermanSometimes they're modifiable, those that we have control over, right? That's the theory. Uh, but even those things that we don't have control over are modifiable with the right tools in place. So stress is one of those things that activates the nervous system. Our nervous system starts sending information out and getting information back to the brain. And when it senses that we have muscle tension or fatigue or sensitivity or any of those things, it can be a huge factor in influencing pain.
Deb TimmermanBut again, it's not proof that pain is psychological, it's part of the whole picture. One factor.
Lindsay VertalkaRight. Exactly. Yeah. Which leads to a, I would say, another myth. Some people will say to me that, so you think this is all in my head. So the myth being chronic pain is all in your head, or if the pain is real, there must be something physically wrong. And we're not saying that at all. There's nothing wrong with the brain, there's nothing wrong with the nervous system. Pain is not imaginary, and your pain is very real. But there's just a lot of factors that can affect how pain presents itself.
Deb TimmermanI heard recently that the brain's role in that is that it is trying to protect us. So when it feels that we're in an uncomfortable space, it can set up a pain flare to get us out of that uncomfortable space. So the brain is all about safety and can really skew what's going on in the body.
Lindsay VertalkaYeah, absolutely. Our brain is an alarm system. And sometimes we go through things in life that make that alarm system more sensitive. And it doesn't take much to turn the alarm on. And you're going to start to hear us talk about the biopsychosocial model of understanding pain and chronic illness and understanding how that alarm system works and affects our whole body is really important in looking at things like emotions and fears that we have that affect that alarm system.
Deb TimmermanSo another myth that I hear a lot is that you just need to relax. So what if you have to say about that, Lindsay? Is that true or is it a myth?
Lindsay VertalkaThat's a myth. I'll start by saying that. Boy, would it be nice if you could just turn a button off and say, I'm just gonna relax. You know, I'm gonna get over it. I don't care that I can't go do the things that I want to do because my knee hurts. It's not that easy. And I think people who don't understand chronic pain or chronic illness, they don't understand that it's not something you can just turn off and back on. Now, you're gonna hear us talk about stress management and different tools to help our nervous systems not be so sensitive.
Lindsay VertalkaAnd that is trying to turn down that alarm system so that we can help rewire our nervous system and relax our nervous system. But those are tools that have to be learned and practiced. And it's not just something that happens. We have to kind of retrain our system, which I know, Deb, you can definitely talk about that too.
Deb TimmermanYeah, and that's a whole nother piece. That's a podcast in and of itself. So another myth is if you have chronic pain, you just need to think positively. That kind of fits in the same vein as you just need to relax. Do you want to talk a little bit about mindset, Lindsay, and how it can help us?
Lindsay VertalkaYeah. So positive thinking isn't always necessarily helpful thinking. Certainly, it's good to try to find the positive and the negative feelings and thoughts, but it's important to recognize that chronic pain involves a lot of other emotions too, like grief, not being able to do the things that you've always been able to do, or feeling left out, um, being fearful of doing things and overdoing or causing more damage, just being exhausted.
Lindsay VertalkaAll of those feelings can affect your pain. And just telling myself, I'm gonna just try to be positive, it almost does yourself a disservice to not acknowledge those feelings and kind of accept them so there's not a tug and war or a tug of war with your feelings that are negative.
Deb TimmermanOkay, this is gonna sound kind of gross, but I'm gonna say it anyway. Someone once explained it to me in this way I can put a turd in a box and wrap it up in a tiny bow and put it on my closet shelf. And when I take it down, what am I going to have? And what they were trying to make me understand is that if we don't process our emotions and we put them in a box and we stick them on a shelf someplace, they're gonna come back to haunt us. Now, that was a really graphic way to describe it, but I have never forgotten that.
Deb TimmermanAnd I often share that story because if we forget about it and we put it away, sometimes we get these little what we call triggers, if you will, that will something will come up for us and we have a catastrophic reaction to something that was really, really minor. And it's because we've packed away an emotion in a box in our closet, and something recalls that from our brain and pulls that forward, and it's hard to figure out then what caused that because that emotion was buried so deeply, right?
Deb TimmermanSo to encourage you to process those emotions and to have your moments of grief and fear. It's important.
Lindsay VertalkaYeah, yeah. I think sometimes in the world these days, we're taught to just tough it out and you know, suck it up, push that stuff down and keep going. And when it comes to the world of pain, that's not always gonna be helpful. So the next myth rest is always best, or exercise will make chronic pain worse. That is a physical therapist gold mine. Yep, yep, you got it. This is this is all me.
Lindsay VertalkaYou've heard me say it before. Motion is lotion. Motion is a good thing. However, um, there are times when rest is appropriate, you know, for an acute injury, or if a doctor says you need to be non-weight bearing on your broken ankle, you need to be non-weight wearing on your broken ankle so that so that it can heal. But prolonged rest can lead to deconditioning, weakness, even loss of confidence, and then you can spiral into fear of movement.
Lindsay VertalkaThe important thing is pacing and graded exposure to movement. It can't be all or nothing. So learning, and that's what physical therapists can help patients do, hopefully, is what's the appropriate amount of movement to instill confidence, to help a patient become less fearful. But just resting, especially in the case of chronic pain that's been ongoing, can almost do more harm than it does good.
Deb TimmermanYeah, and I'll add a little bit from the nursing standpoint. I think one of the things we learned in the first semester of nursing is that immobility is the kiss of death because we have to be moving our intestines, everything inside our body depends on movement. So when we're not moving, that can lead to other issues like I just mentioned constipation, uh, blood clotting, all kinds of stuff.
Lindsay VertalkaYeah, but it has to be you know graded and you have to find the right amount of movement.
Deb TimmermanThat's so the last one, you have to just live with it. You have to fix your body before you could live your life. True or false?
Lindsay VertalkaOh, definitely false. So I do think sometimes people, when they become injured and it feels like their lives have been maybe turned upside down and they're not able to do the things they used to be able to do, and that that causes people to be very angry, frustrated, sad, and it's easy to get stuck with those emotions and just stop doing things because sometimes the mindset becomes, I can't do them, so I'm not gonna do them, or I can't do them the way I used to, so I'm just gonna stop doing them, which in fact is one of the worst things we can do for ourselves.
Lindsay VertalkaI want to encourage people to think about other ways of doing things. Sometimes we have to be open to maybe I can't walk as far as I used to, but maybe I have to be willing to sit in a wheelchair and have somebody push me, or I have to use a walker in order to go the distance I was able to before. It's different for sure, but I'd hate for people to miss out because they're not willing to change how they do things because it is different.
Deb TimmermanAnd they do miss out because they become isolated. And one of the things that has been proven is that we heal better in community and when we're around people that love us and that we love. So when we choose to stay home, we don't get that opportunity, maybe.
Lindsay VertalkaRight. Yeah, you miss out on life.
Deb TimmermanSo why do you think all these myths still hang around? What perpetuates these things to come up again and again?
Lindsay VertalkaWell, I think yeah, a lot of it is just, you know, the whole no pain, no gain. I think back to years ago, like athletes, you just push through. Who cares if you're injured, tape a motin into it and keep moving. It's that's just kind of a mindset that you're tough if you push through. And that's not exactly the case. I think it gives simple explanations for very complex problems. It's easier to just come up with something simple.
Deb TimmermanYeah, that's a really good point. Well, as we wrap up today, I think the biggest takeaway we want you to know is that chronic pain is rarely as simple as one structure, one scan, one diagnosis, or one solution. And the quick takeaways, again, pain doesn't always equal damage. Consistency and moving slow, graded exposure, much better than being immobile. Imaging doesn't always tell the whole story. Stress can have an effect on pain.
Deb TimmermanUm, and you don't have to eliminate pain before you can start living. There are tools that can help you moderate pain, and we would encourage you to look at some of our other podcasts and blog postings for what those are. So, in closing, it might mean that you move a little differently, build your capacity gradually, learn to support your nervous system, and find other meaningful ways to engage in your life.
Deb TimmermanLindsay, anything you'd like to leave our listeners with before we close?
Lindsay VertalkaI just want to encourage everyone to kind of think about some of these myths you've heard and be open to thinking about them a little differently.
Deb TimmermanThanks. Catch us next time when our podcast talks about the mind-body relationship. Thanks for tuning in. The Less Stress in Life podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Listening does not establish a provider-patient relationship. Always consult your physician or qualified healthcare provider with questions about your health or before making changes to your care.
Deb TimmermanDo not delay seeking medical advice because of something you heard here. If you are experiencing a medical emergency, seek immediate care or call 911.
What does it mean to care for a child with special needs when caregiving continues into adulthood? In this episode, Deb and Lindsay welcome Barb Maring, a teacher and mother of three, who shares her family's 25-year...
When you think of chiropractic care, do you immediately think of back or neck pain? There's more to the conversation! In this episode of the Less Stress in Life podcast, Deb and Lindsay welcome Dr. Carly Sorrell, owner...
Nicole Hutton Shannon, Ph.D., joins us to discuss holistic wellness, accessibility, and the many ways people can support their health and well-being. As the owner of HSB Crossbuck LLC, a holistic wellness boutique in...
What happens when life changes in an instant - and pain becomes part of your everyday story? In this episode, we talk with Dr. Esther Combs, educator, therapist, and founder of The Alternative Counseling Center. Esther...
Living with chronic pain can make it difficult to truly rest. Even when the body slows down, the nervous system may remain on high alert - watching, anticipating, and responding. In this episode, Deb and Lindsay are...