On this episode Livia and Stephen Rooney, Astarion’s original writer from the game Baldurs’s Gate 3, talk about the book «Astarion» by T. Kingfisher. A prequel to everybody’s favourite vampire spawn. What did they like about it, how did they feel while reading it and, most importantly, is it worth reading? Here are all the links for this episode: Astarion - T. Kingfisher Nettle & Bone - T. Kingfisher Thornhedge - T. Kingfisher Baldurs’s Gate 3 - Larian Studios Divinity Original Sin 2 - Larian Studios Episode with Stephen Rooney about Carmilla Blue Is the Warmest Color - Jul Maroh My bookreviews Lesenswert on Instagram Intro/Outro by Piero Niggli
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_04Hello and welcome to another episode of the literature podcast Lazenswep. My name is Livia, and every month I talk about a book with a different guest. I will always announce which book we're going to read next so that everyone who's interested can join us. Today is the best day of my life because we're going to talk about my favorite vampire diva, and I'm having the conversation with the most suitable person imaginable. Welcome back, Stephen Rooney.
SPEAKER_00Thank you very much. It is it is lovely to be back. It's lovely to be uh hugely embarrassed within the first three seconds of a podcast. That's how I love to start every every interaction. It's no, I'm really happy to be here. Very happy to chat. Come to you. Why would you be embarrassed? Just the idea that it's like the greatest day of your life. It's and I'd take it out as literally true. It's I'm assuming like there's no exaggeration, this is the best thing that's ever happened. So yeah, no. But I'm super here for it. Thank you so much for having me.
SPEAKER_04It's so nice to have you back. We have uh we have already recorded an episode once about another uh vampire diva of sorts. Today we're going to talk about lovely Astarian. As you maybe someone can tell.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you might have might have known. I feel better. I don't I don't have all of my Astarian like art up in the background, but it's uh I think I made up for it. Yeah, no, exactly. You've got us both covered, it's great.
SPEAKER_04I tried. I I tried to show like how casual of a fan I am.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, no, just casual kind of probably Gellastarian mixed up with Gail all the time, that kind of yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04I wasn't even sure what this book was about, so yeah. But I also have someone else here with us um on camera.
SPEAKER_00You have my my best skeleton boy fame there uh from Divinity Original Sin 2, which oh my god, it's a long time ago now that I was writing him. Um but he still holds such a such a special place in my heart. So it's uh I again I don't know why I keep ending up with like sassy dead people. Uh that seems to be my niche. I'm very happy about it. Um, but yeah, it's not, I promise it's not intentional like I do. I am interested in living writing living people too.
SPEAKER_04Well, that was kind of like what I wanted to start with because I I played the game Divinity, Original Syn 2. I finally finished my playthrough. It has a little less romance in it, so it took me a little longer.
SPEAKER_00Um yeah, sure, you wouldn't really be as interested, I understand. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I knew who your character was, so I I was aware, but even if I didn't, um the verbal abuse in the beginning of the game felt so familiar. So it's like, ah, that's him. Hello.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, my characters they they they like to make the worst possible first impression and then kind of take it from there. So uh lovely. Yes. No, I'm glad I have a a thing that uh a good identifying stamp that I can put on everything that I do.
SPEAKER_04They they are all very sassy though, I have to say that. So I I traveled with um the red prints as well. So I got a lot of verbal abuse uh in in that playthrough.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, yeah, no, the red the red prints is wonderful too. He's a he's a fantastic character.
SPEAKER_04So a few episodes back we had uh we had an episode about the book where um you could extract characters from books and talk to them. So my first question for you is do you think that if you could extract either a fane or a starin from the game at any stage of the game? Or let's say in the beginning, um, do you think they'd be nice to you?
SPEAKER_00Um no, I don't I don't think so. Not not at all, really. Uh but it's funny that you say that, because one of the writing exercises that I tend to do when I'm trying to get to when I'm trying to figure out a character, when I'm trying to get to know them, one of the things that I'll do is just write a little a kind of stream of consciousness conversation between between me and them. So I I had already kind of had a conversation with like Fane and with Astarian.
SPEAKER_00And they weren't particularly nice to me. It's not that would like I I enjoyed it, but I mean it's it was clear very early on that they were going to be uh awful, and especially with Astarian, knowing everything that I put him through, I think he would be he'd be he'd be pretty unhappy with me. So um yeah, I need to stop going around telling people my favorite like uh lines and moments in the game or where you can punch him or kind of kick him in the balls or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Like it's that can't that can't make a good impression. Um, but it is. I love one of my favorite things is blowing him up with in a the Gith crush with a gigantic laser.
SPEAKER_04So okay, he has a right to be rude then.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, he is he's got every right, but also he's a menace, so you know I can't really I think we both deserve it.
SPEAKER_04Oh, okay. At least he's mean to you as well, not just to us players.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, no, absolutely.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's so um that's that's reassuring, actually. I just I just wanted to include Fane in this because I think uh Fane walked so that Astarian could run. And uh we shall never forget the first undead character here.
SPEAKER_00So um that's it that's very sweet of you, yeah. No, and uh I it it's nice to have that touch because you do have what five different Astarian Funko pops in the background, and I'm like Fane doesn't even have one, which is which is a pity, but it's yeah.
SPEAKER_04Listen, if he had one, he'd be up here.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, yeah, so oh he is probably the most me character I've written. He's very just terrified of the world generally, and uh seems highly competent, but is actually kind of useless in a lot of situations. That actually describes quite a few of my characters, so that's a bit harsh, but okay. Well, yeah, fair enough.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I I hope I hope we can circle back to Fain at some point uh during this episode because there are a lot of skeletons who are getting killed in this book. So and and I thought it was a bit offensive too.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, that's that's true.
SPEAKER_04So, okay, let's talk about the book we are actually going to talk about, uh, which is who'd have thought uh Astarian, written by P. King Fisher. It has 270 pages and came out at the end of September 2026 by the publishing house Random House. The author's real name is Ursula Vernon. She was born 1977, is 49 years old, and an American writer and illustrator. She writes children's books, graphic novels, fantasy and horror, publishes all her adult books under the name T.
SPEAKER_04King Fisher, as um this one. And she has written so many books, like I can talk about them all. I have read two. I have read um Nettle and Bone and Thornhitch, which I really uh both I like both of them a lot. So have you read anything?
SPEAKER_00I'm really, really ashamed to say I hadn't read anything um by her until uh until this book. So um, but I have a lot of friends who are very into their who are very into their fantasy and kind of people whose opinions I trusted. And as soon as I heard that this book was coming out and that T Kingfisher was going to be doing it, I started kind of just just gently poking all my literary friends and just being like, hey, so just out of curiosity for no reason, T Kingfisher, like what's what's your take?
SPEAKER_00How do you how do you find it? Everyone had wonderful things to say. So it was it was reassuring uh feedback to get kind of that early on.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I I just I can just speak for the two books that I have read, but I love them both. So they're very special, special books. The plot of the book in one sentence. Um, I'm going with Astarian has to get some special blot for his master.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's that and other things. That that and other things. That that sums it up pretty nicely, yeah.
SPEAKER_04So we're going to talk about this book, like two people who have actually read it. So if you want to avoid any kind of spoilers, make sure to read the book first and more importantly, go play the game. So uh we will see you in 150 hours when you're back and ready to listen to this podcast. Uh 150 hours, or take how many hundreds of hours you need.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, 150 is maybe lowballing it for some people. I've I I know people who put in hundreds and hundreds of hours, and uh God bless you all.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, weird, weird people, weird freaks. Yeah, yeah. Don't know who those people are. And you need about, I think, 10 hours to read the book if you if you go with uh or Neil's uh audiobook. Um so yeah, 150 hours. I think you you'll do it all. You can do it all.
SPEAKER_00Easy, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So what's your general impression of the book? Let's start like from outside and um I mean I enjoyed it.
SPEAKER_00Like it's clearly it's it's a very well-written book. Um, I think like T Kingfisher, she clearly knows what she's what she's doing, um, really good control of language. Um it's it's a it's a very weird experience for me to read.
SPEAKER_04That was going to be like the next question, like how do you feel?
SPEAKER_00Just it's very hard to uh it it's difficult to kind of sum up the there's an element of happiness like to see a character handed off to someone who does a good job with them um while at the same time reading through constantly and just being like I mean I'm not sure if I would have phrased it like that if it was dialogue in the game, but but that's the thing, like the book is not the game. Um it has we have we have a beautiful cover here.
SPEAKER_00There's a great big Baldur's Gate 3 kind of thing on the cover, but it's not like written in the same uh tone as the game, like it the the book is very much its own thing, um and I think if you go in expecting it to be the book version of like the world that you play through in the game, like you're you're gonna have mixed results, um I think going through. But judging it as a thing on its own, like I I enjoyed it.
SPEAKER_00There's the criticisms, I'm sure, and uh we will definitely get into those, but uh overall I enjoyed reading it.
SPEAKER_04I actually saw the comment a lot. Um Baldur's Gate 3, and people were asking, um, where can I get the first two books? I don't know if it were trolls, but I read it a couple times, so and people answering, no, no, it's not the third book, it's just it's like the name of the things. Um you you could you didn't miss out on book one and two. It's it's fine.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no. Just go with this one. Oh, weirdly, it's true enough of the games as well. Yeah, you don't necessarily need to have played Baldur's or if you have played Baldur's Gate one and two, you you're gonna have a very different experience playing three as well. So uh yeah, but um yeah, I don't know. Like what was your what what was your take on it? I guess if you're have the idea.
SPEAKER_04As a casual fan of knowing just a few things about uh this character. What's what was his name?
SPEAKER_00It's Astarian and Sunin and Q9. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Actually, I am a huge fan, but I never understood where people found his last name. Like now I know, but in the first few playthroughs, I was like, where where's his last name? Where can I find it? Okay, people translated it from the stone. Okay, okay.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_04So I felt very um like a bad fan by not knowing.
SPEAKER_00You just need to put in a couple more hundred hours and you'll be yes, you'll you'll be there with the rest of them. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04See you later. So, okay, I think when they published the cover, and here's the loyal fan, and I didn't see your name anywhere on it. I was already it was not like a bad thing. It was just like, ah, okay. Okay, like I acknowledged it and was like, okay, so we're doing something else. And so I think I kind of like adjusted my expectations a little bit or or where where this project was going. And then when they announced the plot, and it was something like an unlikely alliance and some sort of romantic subplot, I removed it even further because not not for the romantic stuff, but the the ally, like or having sure, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Like him having a friend, an ally already didn't make sense to me. Like I was like, okay, so this is going to be something like a side quest, something separate from the game. And um, I did this very subconsciously. I didn't do it like actively sitting on my desk and writing down notes. I was just like, okay, uh, it's gonna be a little different than what I what I played in the game. And uh then when I came out, I I really read it as its separate thing, as like a version of his backstory, or just a few days of his backstory, which he really is.
SPEAKER_04It's like I think in the span of a few days, a week maybe. It's not 200 years of of story. Yeah, so um when I did read it, I had a lot of fun with it. I appreciate the new historian content, of course. But to sum it up, I think I like it as a novel, I don't love it as a prequel. I think that was sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that's fair.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and I think what was very unfortunate are the the lore mistakes that a lot of people noticed or reading. And and that was just I think that's just a way of losing a lot of support because fandoms are very thorough, and if things don't add up, um they're gonna find out.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they are, and I mean, like I do have to hold my hand up to to to like at least a bit of this too, because I am like to to to to go back like a little bit, so I wasn't involved in the creation of the book, like I I I I heard that it was happening not when it was done, but like it more or less. There was already a full draft of it kind of done.
SPEAKER_00And Random House kind of reached out to me and they said, like, hey, would you be able to read through this, give some feedback, and like uh check the lore of it um as as best you can, and I did as best as I can. Um Baldur's Gate 3 is a very big game, and I don't know if people know this. There's a lot of stuff in there, and there are like small little details uh that I will have forgotten kind of over the thing.
SPEAKER_00So I'm sure there are kind of lore mistakes in there. Some some of them I caught and like were were fixed. Uh some of them I assume were not. Um so uh yeah, I know I know T Kingfisher, uh the team at Wizards and kind of me as well, kind of we did our best to catch what we could. Um but uh yeah, these these things these things happen.
SPEAKER_00It's it is inevitable that mistakes are gonna get made. So I don't know if you want to go into specifics. I can feel extra bad.
SPEAKER_04Um uh yeah, sure. Yeah. Uh no, I think I have played a lot of hours, let's leave it at that, in the game. And yet, like I I I haven't caught all of these things as well. Maybe I think the scars, the scars come in very late.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh yeah, there was there was that. Um I can't remember like how that I can't remember what I what I said about that. I'm sure I kind of raised it. I think it was just baked into the baked into the story. Um at that point, unfortunately. Uh I know one of the other things that like was mentioned, but I think was I think it was probably a conscious choice was that the girl were kind of removed from Astarian's origins, like the early day stuff.
SPEAKER_00I think that was a call from Wizards, but I don't, I don't, I don't know. Again, I just I saw Word Duck and I read it over a week or whatever, and uh put in the comments that I could kind of point it out whatever I thought I wasn't sure about and uh sent it back. And that is that was the entirety of my involvement. I have no idea what else what other conversations happened.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think I think there are a few things that were a bit weird when you were read when you're reading it, but at the same time, I think you can still enjoy the book and be like, okay, like you said, like remove it a bit from the game, and we have a lot of good reviews, we have a lot of bad reviews, and I think maybe some of the bad reviews could have been avoided if like those things uh it's it's not as I'm not accusing you.
SPEAKER_00No, I fully understand.
SPEAKER_04But uh I think that was uh that was what I read a lot of time, like the the lore is wrong, and yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_00That is that is the danger of picking up like uh any property, really, but especially something that is as complicated and while also being kind of as beloved as uh as as Baldusgate 3 is. And Astarian in particular has uh like I think a rightfully a very passionate fan base, um and people who care like really a lot about his story, because it's it's one that needs to be handled with kind of like care and uh it needs to be handled kind of as uh yeah uh as as well as you can, basically.
SPEAKER_00And if you misstep, people are going to uh people are going to be unhappy. Uh I do I do feel like anyone that came out and wrote an historian book, it was kind of gonna be a poison chal like a slightly poison chalice to literally anybody. I don't I don't think there was anyone that was going to like do it um that was going to please everybody with the like regardless of what happened afterwards.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think so too. Because also since his backstory is not really um like you get a lot of glimpses of his backstory, but a lot of it also happens in your playthrough and your relationship with the character, and however you play the game, you you have a a different um a version of his backstory. So it's also very yeah, with this game especially, I think it's very difficult to get it get it right. Um it's more like it's it's not that sad a book, I think.
SPEAKER_04It has its sad moments, but it's it's more like a fun heist kind of thing. And um I I kind of like I appreciated this this take on it, like not write 270 pages about him being tortured, which I don't know if I would have loved to read that. So I appreciate that the idea, but I think it's very difficult with the character that has so much trauma, and I mean he it's it's it comes up a lot in the game.
SPEAKER_04If we had two or three prequels out already, and one is a very dark one, and one is a very and this is a funer more fun one, yeah. But it's like we only have this one, so we're even more uh critical about it, I think.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I can I I can understand that as well. Um and it's it is tricky because it's you have the historian from the game who's been through all of this, these like horrible things. And if you write a prequel to that, like do you write the book about how he became the person that he is that you encounter in the game? Do you show him already in that state kind of a thing? Like it is um people aren't gonna want exactly the same thing as they got in the game, but if you give them something different, they're not really going to want that necessarily too.
SPEAKER_00Uh so again, I did feel for anyone that was going to come in and try and take this and do anything with it, basically. Um, but yeah, tonally it is a lot lighter than uh Baldur's Gate 3 for sure. And like I did find myself kind of reading through it sometimes and like, oh okay, cool. They're in the middle of a fight, and there's there's a lot of quipping happening. And I'm like, this feels like it should be a very tense moment, but it's simply not. Um yeah, so yeah, again, there's plenty of things that it's the easiest thing in the world to be like, oh, if I was writing a book, I would I would have done something differently, but like it's I wouldn't have written a book that's as good as that, I don't think, like straight off the bat.
SPEAKER_00Um, and it's very easy to look at mistakes or look at what it would have been better to do differently in hindsight. So uh yeah.
SPEAKER_04I'm finding it's not very difficult, but it is like I think I think we need to uh to turn this into um a little different direction. I think because now we I think we can acknowledge there are a few things that uh like didn't add up and um yeah but there are also a lot of fun things in this book. So uh I think we just jump right into the plot because uh yeah, like you said, it's not the game. And the good thing is your game is unharmed.
SPEAKER_04So the games, the the playthroughs you have, uh they're they're still there. Um your character is still canon in your head, and it just everything is still as it was, so it didn't change anything about the game.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_04It happens in the past or in an alternative past, and um yeah, that's kind of like like I've already said, it's like how I read the book. I was like, okay, new Astorian content, let's have a look what what's going to happen.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_04I had so much fun, and if you listen to the audiobook, I think you have even more fun.
SPEAKER_00The audiobook is a is a journey, yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_04It's so good, and I love my favorite thing is the Astarian laugh. Like his that silly laugh. I I love it. There is a compilation on YouTube with just the bits from the game though, but just his bits laughing in this very silly way, and I I love it. I'd love it to have it as a ringtone or something like that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, Neil created something like truly iconic with that laugh.
SPEAKER_04It's uh it's brilliant, it's incredible. Yeah, also all the other voices, like Astarian, of course, he's he was going to do a great job with um with Asarian, no doubt. Uh, but all the other characters, there's so many different voices in this one, and I I loved it. I somehow sometimes forgot that it was just one person reading reading all the lines.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, no, I think I think Neil did did a good job with the um with the audiobook because I don't think he's I could be wrong actually, no, I realize I don't know, but I don't think he's recorded many audiobooks before, so kind of coming to it, um, I thought was quite good. I enjoyed his uh it felt like a tour of the regional accents of uh of England at times because I'm s I'm so used to hearing him do Astorian and then he goes and does the other characters like gave young Astorian, I think, like a liver puddle accent or something.
SPEAKER_00It's I'm not sure.
SPEAKER_04Which was a surprise, but it was it was so fun. Yeah, yeah. Baby Astorian is also in here, yeah. Um so yeah, it's the first thing I noticed and that I loved is that this book this book is not a first person uh in written in first person. I was very scared of that, and it's not, and I'm super happy. I'm not the biggest fan of uh first person. I think there are books that need it, but I don't think you want to spend time in historian's head.
SPEAKER_00I don't think it's a it's a good or a healthy place to be. It's uh it I think we're all safer with a little bit of distance from it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04The book starts with him being beaten to death, um, which is is uh horrible, but okay. Uh like it catches your uh attention. So did you enjoy that part since you like to um kick him? Oh yeah, no, that was that's a horrible way to start the sorry conversation. I'm so sorry, but I still want to know the answer.
SPEAKER_00No, I thought it was I did I did think it was a good place to start it. Um because it is such a good like kind of origin point for uh where he comes from. It it's a good way of catching your attention, it's a good way of kind of like introducing your introducing people who don't know him to a character that's is like a bit sassy, that is going to kind of recount his own death really or look at his own death in a kind of a wry way still.
SPEAKER_00Um it was uh yeah, it it was it was surprising, and there were some wonderful lines in there. Um but yeah, no, it was good.
SPEAKER_04Um can I can I ask you like talking about lines, is there a line um and it's from the game now, uh that you it doesn't have to be your favorite or your best or uh the funniest, but is there a line you really like? Just like a very solid historian line that you're that you're happy with, right? Um because I think favorite also always puts a lot of pressure on the one you're choosing. So it doesn't have to be your favorite, just one that you like.
SPEAKER_00Um I'm blanking on literally every every one of like the 9,000 lines or whatever it was that I that I wrote for him. Yeah, no, it's I'm trying to remember. There's there there is like a wonderful there is there is a a line where is it after he drinks your blood for the first time? It's like I that thank you for this. This is a gift. Something like that. It's it's one I found myself Yes, that's it. It's it's one I found myself using kind of a couple of times in real life for I think I think that was probably one of the last things that I said when I was leaving Larian in like the uh the group slack.
SPEAKER_00Just yeah, this is a gift, you know, I won't forget it. Um I don't know, it's a versatile line, it felt it felt very very heartfelt, um, but also in the time kind of like a little bit sinister, I don't know, uh in the context of of how it comes up. I don't know. I I I I'm very happy about any line that I can bookend a character with. Like Estarian saying something like that, uh, or anyone saying kind of something like that at the start of a game and then coming back to it at the end.
SPEAKER_00Uh Fane actually, as he is on your t-shirt, had exactly that kind of that kind of thing. You you meet him when he's reading a book and uh learning about how stupid humanity is or something like that, and then uh you come back to it again and he's completely changed, completely different, completely different character, and the same beat has a different meaning. So I don't know anything like that where I feel like I get to be a bit of a a bit of a wanker, like snobby writer person, it makes me very happy, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um so lovely how you included Fain in this. That's exactly what I wanted.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So keeping as a reminder here in my shirt, so you can't.
SPEAKER_00He's right there. He won't forgive me, I think, if I if I don't. So yeah.
SPEAKER_04No, and he's so great. Yeah, we don't have time to do also to to do uh to give him as much love as Astarian here, but um so good. Okay, something I really liked from from the beginning was uh Astarian being a very specific hater about um different things like poetry or nautical names of things, and that those are moments I feel very connected to him, so I I I really like those parts.
SPEAKER_04Um or him saying Kazidor has a horrible taste in fiction, yeah, and the core, of course, is him hating on that atrocious hat the bard wears, uh all these like very specific things that get him mad. Yeah, and I love it.
SPEAKER_00I it it is one of the core kind of facets of the character, is it does feel like he's so like he's so much better than you. He's so much better than everyone as far as he's concerned. So it's nice for him to be able to just look around the world sometimes and be like, that sucks, that sucks, that sucks. Um and of course, in the game that means it's uh ideally when you actually get close to him and he's like, Oh, you're not you're actually fine.
SPEAKER_00Uh your tab, your tab is actually okay, and I don't hate you. It feels that much more meaningful. So no, it's really good to see that that uh that his view on the world has survived. Uh made made it into the book for sure.
SPEAKER_04Yes, and that it has been there for ever. Vampirism wasn't the problem. It was him all along.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04And and I think that was also something that gets got me back to the character and felt like, okay, he feels familiar, even though he might not be the same same, but um, I know this guy. Let's let's go.
SPEAKER_00No, absolutely. It is it was one of the things that my partner said well, like after uh reading the book, it was like it's it feels like by far the best fan fiction I've ever I've ever read, and which isn't meant to denigrate the thing at all, but it's that sense you you kind of can get that sense of this is a character that feels very familiar, but isn't quite the same, but still um kind of has like the right a lot of the right echoes kind of of the of the character, even if they're not uh even if they're not pulled kind of straight from the game.
SPEAKER_00But you do still kind of hit on enough of their their points and their characteristics that it all feels very familiar. But just with a bit of a twist on it, I guess.
SPEAKER_04So though you read uh a story in fanfiction, I have to ask this now.
SPEAKER_00I I have not read a story in fanfiction. I like ever uh the the number of times I've been tempted to go onto like AO3 and just see what's out there, but um uh after having left Larry, the number of times I've been tempted to go and write a story in fanfiction and post it anonymously up there just to see how people would react, also very high. Uh but no, I haven't uh I have I haven't gone out and read it partly because I'm afraid I think uh either that it's not going to be very good, or maybe worse, it's going to be really good.
SPEAKER_00And then I'm like, oh, I'm not special. Uh turns out tons of people can do this better than I can.
SPEAKER_04And uh not that hard.
SPEAKER_00It's not that hard. You just have like a sassy little vampire kind of swish around and uh be addict to people and occasionally get punched in the face. Uh and it's it's actually real simple, real straightforward.
SPEAKER_04That's how we recognize your work then.
SPEAKER_00Pretty much, yeah. Very punchable characters is what I what I aim to go for, yeah.
SPEAKER_04That that's great. So maybe if you haven't done it yet, maybe you're going to write uh write it the fanfiction or it could could well be, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Could could could easily end up.
SPEAKER_04Anonymously so.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_04You're never gonna know. If people hate it, you're just gonna deny it forever. Like that's nothing about it.
SPEAKER_00No, absolutely, yeah. That'll be that'll be great.
SPEAKER_04So I also I I enjoyed the first part where uh we we accompany a storian where he has to go hunt for victims. And he hunts this this women beating uh guy that I think n nobody likes, like a very hateable guy. And me who's such a simp, I I can't even hurt this guy in the game. I of course was like super afraid. Oh my god, he's gonna get hurt, he's gonna get, you know, hurt by this horrible man.
SPEAKER_04And I love that he doesn't get hurt, you know. He's not a damsel in distress. This guy can take care of himself, he absolutely can, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Which is nice. I did, I enjoyed that it almost felt like a little kind of mini arc where he's um discovered by the by the the the the lady and kind of approached and yeah, the kind of basically recruited to she's like, Oh, you're someone who's uh who people disappear around, and I want you to to make this guy disappear. And I enjoyed that that aspect of it. Like Astarian as a bit of an asshole vigilante, I think works really well, actually.
SPEAKER_00Um and you're right, like he's so in control there, he's so rarely in danger, kind of adjourning that thing, and then that contrasts so well to as soon as he crosses the threshold back into the czar palace. It's not completely flipped, but very much flipped, where he he goes from being someone who's so hard to to hurt, someone who's who's hard to kind of to do any damage to to someone who is kind of helpless and will like fight back in his own little ways.
SPEAKER_00But um yeah, I don't know, it it provides a really nice, really nice contrast of what he's capable of and what he actually ends up suffering through.
SPEAKER_04Those are also like my my favorite parts in the game, or in generally the the party banter when the characters uh talk among themselves, you're just walking through the map and and they start talking. I love those moments. He gets a lot of mean comments, and especially in the beginning or later on by Mintharo, for example, with nothing that kind to say to anyone really, but yeah, um, I love her so much. And they say very mean things, and I'm like, oh, don't be so mean to it to my baby. And he claps back every time.
SPEAKER_04I love that he usually is the the the person with uh the last like the last mean comment.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, yeah, he's he's he's not helpless and always has something to say. Um always, yes, particularly yeah, if you're if you if you're pushing kind of back against him, or yeah, no, he always has uh there's there's always something like the the party banter stuff, it's some of my favorite uh just lines to write because you just get to have these tiny little snapshots that aren't important, they're not story-heavy moments for the most part. So you just get to have pure character, you just get to have pure fun with it, and to pull out the weird little um eccentricities that the characters have, and you get to explore them more as people and less as plot points that move around the the game map.
SPEAKER_00So it's a lot of fun.
SPEAKER_04How did you uh write the party band? I mean, because you need the other people writing as well. So how how does it work?
SPEAKER_00It uh normally you will have a a writer who's um normally writers will be divided up by areas or something like that. Uh so you'll have a couple of writers writing a bunch of um kind of characters in the the Druid's Grove or or Goblin Camp or whatever, kind of anywhere through the game. Uh so normally they will take like a first pass at it and just be like, okay, this is what I think people should be talking about.
SPEAKER_00Just da da da da. Um they throw in some kind of rough draft kind of lines, uh, and then the other the writers who are in charge of the characters kind of come through and rewrite them kind of as they as they need to. So there's a lot of lines getting and files getting passed around to people. Uh so it's it's mostly that a lot of spreadsheets and a lot of uh DMs just being like, hey, I got the lines in there. Can you if you can do this real quick, then I can submit it, and then we can just close off this task and it'll be great.
SPEAKER_00So uh yeah, a lot a lot of communication, a lot of spreadsheets.
SPEAKER_04That's great. I love it so much. Like when they start talking, I stop because sometimes you go into an area where it triggers a cutscene or something, and I can't hear what the characters are saying, and I'm so mad because you cannot get back to it.
SPEAKER_00Sure, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04So uh yeah, so now when when they start talking, I just stop and look at them. I know a lot of the the banter by now because of reasons. Um but I try to switch the party each time I play it again. So I love it when a new uh a new kind of dialogue appears. I'm like, I haven't heard this one.
SPEAKER_00Everybody it's always the most natural way to experience a conversation. Everyone's walking through the woods and then someone has something to say, so everybody stops dead in their tracks, and uh you have a conversation and then you carry on. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I need to listen, okay? I'm like very um I'm a good friend.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, of course.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Oh, so much. I have so much love for the game. I can't, I I struggle a bit to focus on the book. I'm very sorry.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I was I was about to say it's like, no, we're here. I feel bad. I don't want to make this about like the stuff that I've done before. It's like we're here to talk about a book. Well, I promise we'll get to it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so that's pretty much the first the the first part um where we see him in action and the entire thing that I uh had in my plot summary of one sentence, like him getting the blood. It's this more like the second part. And I feel like yeah, the first part is uh him doing his um vampiric stuff, I think. And I I have to say I really like the first part. I I thought that was um because that was more maybe like what we hear from in the game, like the stalking at night and looking for victims and um bringing the back to the palace.
SPEAKER_04So that felt very familiar, even though it's nothing like we never heard about those specific scenes, but um uh I really like that part.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No, I mean I I agree, like I was looking back through the notes that I'd made before when I kind of read the first draft, and I I remember feeling like I was having the most fun with the kind of the politics between the the politics within the palace, the the dynamic relationships between between Nestarian and the rest of the spawns, and then the relation the the individual kind of weird fucked up relationships that they all have with Kazador.
SPEAKER_00And I was like, yeah, this feels like this this feels really good. This feels like a lot of fun. This feels like you're you're getting to know some characters that we've met before, some characters that like we didn't uh you only would have kind of seen in the the circle at the ritual, kind of towards the end of the game, and you got to flesh out and explore a lot of those those dynamics, and I was I was having a lot of fun uh with that, and I was a little bit sad when it kind of turned away uh from that a bit to still go off and have an adventure and still good, still a good time, but um yeah, I do I I enjoy the slice of life stuff uh an awful lot.
SPEAKER_00It feels like that's when you have a lot of these fun little moments.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I I especially loved uh Aurelia. I think uh she would be a very good character to to follow up on and see what what her story is like. I really liked her. Also the other the other spawn, but she was my favorite, I think.
SPEAKER_00Um she's really fun, yeah.
SPEAKER_04And she's super cool. And also when they when they try to get a story in for their master plan, like to to get the the blood. Uh and and he's very suspicious why they're coming to him and they're like well Aurelia was already gone. So we came to your door. It's like, ah, okay, yeah, that makes a lot more sense.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was that was a good little moment. I like that a lot.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I I like to see see them uh interact because in the game you have he's ready to sacrifice them, but he has a bit of he's just he's a little sad, like okay, I would feel sorry about my siblings. Um yeah, and I think you'd never really see or you don't see a lot of why he'd feel sorry to kill them off, or apart from the obvious reasons for killing a lot of people. So I really like that you that you see there's some kind of relationship, maybe it's very twisted depending on on which pairing you're looking at.
SPEAKER_04Um, and he definitely does not love all of them. But when Cazidora leaves the room and they're like, okay, is he really gone or is he coming back and someone's going to check like these moments and where they forget the rivalry? Yeah, yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, moments like that landed really well for me, I think. Like you you got to see kind of that they're all in it together while at the same time having to play this fucked up little game that Kazador kind of has has crafted this happy families kind of thing. It's them versus him, but at the same time it's all of them against each other, and also just the different personalities, I think, come out really well. Violet being this absolute little psychopath.
SPEAKER_00Um Yeah. Petras just being this dumb idiot. You got to meet a couple of them in the game, like Deliria and Petras, you both get to talk to a bit. But getting to see the the different relationships play out. One of my favourite writing jokes in the book is anytime a storian is worried that something might get him in trouble, he gives his name as Petras.
SPEAKER_04Just to be sure.
SPEAKER_00Just to be sure. At one point he's like, yeah, no, I'm a the I'm the I'm I'm the zombie Petrus. The uh shust made me very happy. Um no, but it's nice, it's fun getting to see the dynamics play out, and as you say, kind of that that that vibe, that energy, like when he leaves the room and it's it's just it that was a really good moment. It felt very natural, it felt very uh everyone's in this fucked up situation, and we're just gonna try and get through it while still looking out for ourselves, while still making sure that we are minimizing our own kind of misery and horror.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, no, it was it was nice. I would very happily just watch like a TV series that's just that. Yeah, the the the big big brother household of the czar palace would be great. I would have a good time.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, as long as Kazador doesn't get too um creative, I think. Yeah, that's true. He was he was this scary character, um, and you felt uh uh it's just when he enters the room and you didn't never know what he's going to do next. And the Sarian is always like, Okay, should I do this or that? What is the worst that can happen? So in a way, yes, he felt very threatening, but uh on the other hand, I think he wasn't threatening enough. He doesn't do all these horrible things we hear about in the game.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So it's a bit I think I don't think I needed more like specific scenes, but more even more of this this very um I I don't have the the correct English word for it, um, but this very like this at the atmosphere shifts as as soon as he walks into the room. I think that that could have been even even more so. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I I get what you mean. That could have felt more kind of deserved, I guess, kind of given what you see him do in the in the book. Or yeah, I mean I'd I'd agree with that. As you say, there are a couple of scenes that are awful. Um, and there is the there are a couple of like punishments that are are that are handed out, and there's a couple of bits that are implied. Um but I we could have seen a lot more, I guess, consequences of stuff that that he'd done, like someone wandering around having a hand chopped off or something.
SPEAKER_00It's just you could get there there could have been a bit more of that for sure, yeah. But it's this thing with that it's a difficulty with the book where it like you're reading through it and a lot of it's very lighthearted or has that kind of tone, and then in a world that feels like it has so much kind of darkness going on and that there's so much uh potential for just just horror. Um, but that does kind of get undercut by oh, we want a story and to say something funny here. We want uh which I I can understand, it's a very difficult line to walk to get that right, because you could very easily just fall into everything's grimdark, and this is just depressing to read as well.
SPEAKER_00So it's a tricky balance, definitely.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean, and and there is a reason uh you started his story where you did. I mean, you could have like stumbled across him like well when he was being tortured or something like that, but it's like that that's in the past, and now we move on with this character. So yeah, obviously writing the the prequel is not is not easy.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, no, absolutely.
SPEAKER_04I don't know. Maybe it's uh it was also like a a wish. Like don't don't go too dark, do it something like don't forget the dark parts, but also make it fun in a way. It's it's also very difficult to handle uh or to do something like that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, it it really is. And again, like I've no idea. And I I as I said, I haven't read T. King Fisher's like earlier, like other other stuff. I don't know if this is I get the impression that this is the tone probably that she tends to go for. Um, but uh yeah, I I don't know kind of what if any like if she had restrictions or if there were requests from from higher powers to be like, oh, we want this to be a happier book, we want this to be a grimmer book, we want it to be kind of whatever. Um but yeah, it's a difficult balance to to hit.
SPEAKER_00Like I spent literal years writing a story, and there was a lot of times at the start, particularly it, especially when I did not get that balance right, and I was like, oh, but it's better if he says a funny thing here instead of leaning into the misery.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I don't want to be too critical. I just felt like Kazidor is such a like the moment you you enter the palace uh in the game, and it's so it's such a yeah, it's it's a it's a weird feeling, and then you encounter him and you see this uh your your your very sassy historian being like slouching and being very his head a little bowed. So this guy needs need had to be very terrifying for for two centuries. So I think I would have loved a bit more of the the threat, not actual gore going on, but just like being more scared of this guy.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. How how did you like um the his his backstory, like the the baby historian?
SPEAKER_00Baby historian, so yeah, this is told in like uh I don't know if we call them flashbacks, but I mean, yeah, points where it it jumps back in the story and it shows Astorian as as a youth. Um I very consciously, I think, when we were writing the game, tried not to think about that too much, honestly, because you would have I I would have ended up trying to stuff too much backstory just um into the character, and that wasn't. It would have felt very forced and very weird.
SPEAKER_00So it was actually a lot easier for me to just be like, I don't know, the starian was probably a child at some point. I'm sure he had parents or whatever.
SPEAKER_04Um we don't care.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. So um there's there's there's something at the core of the the the backstory that I think works very well. The idea of a starian coming from a slightly poorer, like a poorer kind of background or a more simple country life kind of background, discovering the the temptation of of riches and being like, oh shit, this is I can play life on easy mode and I can have beautiful silk clothes and I can have this, and like that that that twist, that moment where Astarian finds out that actually he really wants to live a good life, that felt very good.
SPEAKER_00Um, I don't know how I felt about Astarian, the the farmer's son necessarily. I I don't know that there was something about the relationship with his mother who's like a wild shifting druid that didn't or uh that that didn't quite land for me. Um but the idea of Astarian being kind of taken away from his family, running off to like a fantastically lead a life of riches, basically. Um having this revelation of like, oh, this is great, actually.
SPEAKER_00Uh I can be I I I can be here, I don't have to work too hard. Uh I I can live in the lap of luxury, and uh that that that worked, I think that kind of aspect of the journey. Um, I don't know, I felt like I probably would have spent a little less time on it, maybe. I'm not I'm not sure. There were there were bits that didn't quite land for me, uh, I think. But it was it was an interesting take, and I think it's probably as good a take as any. Like it was curious to see what people how people imagined that he got to where he is, I guess.
SPEAKER_00Uh, because again, it was it was a thing I very intentionally did not think about. Uh but yeah, I don't know. What about you? What did you make of that uh that aspect of the book?
SPEAKER_04I agree with you that the this part of him that living the country life and absolutely hating it. Um that made a lot of sense. But I think I'm a bit meaner here. I think I I I would have cut it all of it. Just completely because I I I don't think if you cut it, I don't think it it the story, the rest of it loses anything. Like um, I I never really understood why I'm reading about his past because none of it is really important, like except the thing that he really wants to go to the city and and leave his old self behind and and everything.
SPEAKER_04That yes, uh, but I don't think I I needed so much of it. And I also I wasn't sure, is it a flashback? Like, is it because at first it was just like okay, his past, but he doesn't remember it necessarily, but then he thinks of his mother sometimes or something that happens in the past, and that was also like a bit uh I like he doesn't remember the color of his eyes. How would he remember those details from the past?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm comparing it to the game flight feathers of his mother, yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I I thought it was um like I didn't really understand uh why I have to read it. Also, I was very in in the story, and then the back story came and I was like, okay, I I will eat something now or do something else. Like it really it paused uh the story, and I I didn't like that as well. Like when I when I put close the book, every time these chapters come on, it's also a sign for me that I don't like it. I don't like to read it. I don't think it's bad. I just don't um yeah, and you have the the backstory with the the dragon lady, like his um I didn't get it.
SPEAKER_04I maybe I missed something, but it was um you can let me say the mean things, it's it's fine.
SPEAKER_00Um I should have passed you a bunch of notes beforehand and just been like, here's all the bitchy stuff that I want to say. If you can just go through all of this. I hate this.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. No, but I really was like, I think you can cut it and and nothing, you wouldn't lose any of the main story bits. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's that that's fair. Uh I don't think there's anything there that happens that is plot relevant, really. It is just and here's how we got here, kind of kind of thing. So I can yeah, I can understand. And there was a weird kind of I don't know, there was there was the thing where like his great-grandmother or whatever was very rich, but actually it turned out she had a whole bunch of debt, and then she was kind of like she was dying and she passed all of her debt on to a story, and like this doesn't yeah, this isn't particularly relevant.
SPEAKER_04We are yeah, like I said, cut it, and what are you going what are you losing? Like nothing changes. Yeah, like him inheriting all the debt is like it's not a problem in in the future, so yeah, that's the thing.
SPEAKER_00Like it we don't spend That's why he goes to Baldur's Gate.
SPEAKER_04That I think that's the right because he moves, he changes cities, so maybe it was just but I mean you could have said anything, he it just ends up in Baldur's Gate because why do any of these people creatures end up there? I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um I didn't love the backstory part, and I also didn't understand the the dragon lady, like I that she comes back in the end. I felt like okay, who are you again? I guess it's yeah, it was a bit that moment that I felt um yeah, I enjoyed the the present of the book. Uh I enjoyed that a lot more.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, sure. No, I I understand. I do wonder if it was something that like if it wasn't there, if people would would would question kind of what his earlier life was like. I don't know. Like if if it had picked up at his death and just carried on from that point. I I don't know if that was part of the logic of going back a little bit further or or what, but yeah, it did feel like probably the one of the weakest parts of the book for me. Um and yeah, as as you said, like not bad, but uh definitely not a part that I was super excited about.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but so now we have talked a lot already, but we haven't even come to the the famous or infamous uh paladin that shows up. So I think we need to make some room for the paladin and this whole storyline, uh, because yeah, but let me just check if I forgot something super important. Okay, the two gory scenes, I I I haven't talked about them, but I I don't know if I want to. Um they're horrible. Uh and yeah, I think they did what they were supposed to do, uh, to shock and give you the some of the the gory details the starian mentions um during the game.
SPEAKER_04And he's like, Well, that was horrible, and now you you get to see it, but it's very it's a very quick and one the scene with the devil um uh I'm not even sure what he was. I was like, I read it and I was like, what? Yeah, could that happen? And I went back and I read and I okay, yes, okay, it really happened. Um, and then I was uh sad and I also stopped the book for a moment. Um so I think it worked. Um I think yeah, sorry.
SPEAKER_00I I don't know, sorry, yeah, but it's I I I get what you mean. I the devil scene, the devil wizard scene didn't sit great with me. I don't I think one of the things that we haven't really quite touched on is it's a very horny book. Um like in both a positive and and kind of a negative sense, there's a lot of sex, there's a lot of the word cock comes up a lot. Um and there is there's like a big there's a big Kazador scene which again won't go into like the the details of, but Cazador is a complete fucking asshole, and it's uh it's horrible and manipulative and it's gross.
SPEAKER_00And uh I can imagine a lot of people have a lot of strong reactions to the scene where like Kazador casts an illusion and don't need to go into it, but um that was kind of a moment where I was like, this it shows very well the kind of that kind of the kind of level of fucked up that Kazidor is, and like that felt like an appropriate way to to do that, and I was like, okay, cool. I feel like we've ticked the box of dark fucked up shit here. And then the wizard thing came, I think, quite soon after that.
SPEAKER_00And I was just like, oh, we haven't we haven't we just done this? Have it could could we not I mean I don't maybe there was more space in between it or something, but it's it it it felt like it was kind of layering stuff on a bit thicker really than uh I would have done, and particularly when so much there's a lot a lot of other stuff in the book is operating in kind of a dark world, but still relatively lighthearted.
SPEAKER_00There's a lot of lighthearted kind of moments and a lot of lighthearted um stuff happening in the book, and then you get hit by the heavy stuff, and that needs to be paced out really carefully, I think. And yeah, I don't the thing with the wizard just felt like it was um it it was a bit much kind of uh all at once. I was like, I really would have liked more of a conversation with the talking seagull or something like that. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04There was yeah, or yeah, yeah, yeah. I also liked uh like is a weird weird word for this, but I I think I liked this the first scene also more because it was more fucked up in a different way, yeah, exactly. Like playing with it was like to teach him not to to bite uh humans or thinking creatures, and it was like the worst way possible to do that, and also having Aurelia coming in and he's like, Oh, she's judging me, and no, it's not that.
SPEAKER_04It's she just knows more than you do. Yeah, um, and and I think that one was just very yeah, very sick, but in a in a very casidore way. So I thought, okay. And um yeah, I didn't love the the the the second scene though. Yeah, also like I kind of stumbled through it and was like, uh have I really read this one? Is this really happening? Yes, okay. And I think that also shows that I wasn't even like if you don't pay attention for two sentences, you're gonna miss it, probably.
SPEAKER_00Pretty much, yeah. Just like a lot of what happened over the course of like half a page or a page, it went very, very quickly. Fraud, there was a very rapid escalation kind of to it.
SPEAKER_04And it also happens while he while he's having a conversation with Kazador, and that also didn't work in my imagination. I was like, how this is horrible, but how like are they looking at each other talking? Like, what what are what are the other spawn doing? Are they watching? Are they what is happening?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's yeah, yeah, it it it felt uh it's not that you would have wanted to dwell on it more, but because really not. But I mean, like if it was going to happen, surely like a bit more build-up or a or not, just I or I'm I'm gonna be able to do it. Ideally not ideally, just remove it completely, yeah. Um but uh yeah, no, sex comes up a lot, and it's obviously it's a very important uh part of a starian story, like it's a very important part of his his character and also the trauma that he's gone through.
SPEAKER_00Like it's um and I think T Kingfisher like did probably make a I think she was she was probably quite conscious with um how she was approaching it and didn't and probably tried her best to to treat stuff as um with like respect and with a bit of care, but that doesn't always land, I think, necessarily. There's uh definitely kind of a few bits in the book where I would have pulled back and just I don't know, tried to have those moments land with the emotional depth and the emotional weight that they should have, just like kind of once or twice you have big, heavy emotional moments that the reader can sit with and kind of like dwell on and feel uh bad about, but still have the emotional space to process it.
SPEAKER_00Um and when you have little snappy kind of little moments of misery like that in the uh in the book, it's yeah, it's harder to pace that well. So it's uh yeah, I don't know. I I I can I I can understand the definitely not for everybody.
SPEAKER_04Is it the scene we we have already talked about or or later on? Like the ones you mean now, like you were talking about now?
SPEAKER_00They're I'm thinking about the ones we're talking about, like the the the the the with the with the wizard thing and stuff. There's there is more stuff later too which would have have similar kind of uh criticism of yeah, but we can get to that in time.
SPEAKER_04It's gonna be the longest episode.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, sorry. I can speed things up. I've I waffled about Fain for a a good while at the start. You should see.
SPEAKER_04Oh that but that was planned. That was like sure, yeah. That was very important and suggested with the shirt. So yeah, that I was just going through the notes and checking, okay, what happened to the first part that we haven't talked about at all. Um oh, I have one when he had to get the the unicorn blood, and it is this heist kind of uh thing. And it's really like this DD um adventure, but as a book, as a story. And I had a lot of fun with that, with that part. I actually really felt like oh, somebody's throwing the dice while he's doing certain things, and depending on how the dice land, uh, he's gonna succeed or or not.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. So I like that. I don't know how much in character it was if you compare it back to the game, but just as a part of the book, I had a lot of fun. Um also with him like with the magic law uh lock that he wants to pick, and he's like, Okay, I can't pick this because it's magic, so I need to find another way. That felt very DD um like it did, yeah.
SPEAKER_00No, that that that felt really good. Like as uh um as you say, it it it felt exactly like the kind of scene that you would have in in a DD game. Uh and yeah, there's magical locks. There's uh again like a little there's a talking seagull that if you bribe him, like you can I keep saying talking seagull. I think the bird is kind of indeterminate.
SPEAKER_04Um but yes, we don't know what we don't know what exactly his name is uh rooftop Henry or something?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I haven't written it down, but I think yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no. I d I I agree with you. Like it that was a I enjoyed the I enjoyed how that felt. There was a thing when I was like reading the stuff with The conversation with Rooftop Henry in particular, where I'm like, this is it feels like it's trying very hard to be Terry Pratchett. Like it's that that that conversation in particular like really had such Pratchetty vibes. And this is a a thing that I would hit kind of again and again in the book.
SPEAKER_00Like you would have that lightness, that unseriousness, um which is good, can can work very well. It can uh it can like lessen the peril and like lessen the seriousness kind of of the um of any scene, like it lessens the tension, like basically, and it's it's a lot of fun. Um it can be difficult again when uh you have scenes like that and then the next chapter or whatever you are on something very heavy, um, and it's a little bit whiplashy tone-wise in places.
SPEAKER_00Um but yeah, I don't know. It was one of these things where I was reading it, and I'm like, I'm enjoying reading this. Again, it doesn't feel like the game it did. I I think that's kind of where you feel the the distinct the separation nearly the clearest. Um you're like we never would have got away with this tone in the game, we never would have got away with this level of like quippiness uh kind of stuff. But I don't know, there's there's definitely places in the book where it works.
SPEAKER_04I think here it actually works. I I uh I think later on when he comes back, when um spoiler, he loses the blood he worked so hard to get, and then it falls into the water and rooftop Henry's back with the blood, and I was like, okay, well I forgot about this character a hundred pages ago. What is he doing back?
SPEAKER_00I didn't forget about rooftop Henry, the uh the icon, the legend.
SPEAKER_04He wasn't my favorite. I have other favorites. I I didn't like the weird seagull. Um, but I think here it works, it works very well. Yeah, and also he tries to get this unicorn blood for um Deliria, and the stakes aren't super high. Like, yes, you don't want him to get caught because he could get hurt, or I don't know what, but it's not he's not gonna die or it's just gonna it's very inconvenient if something happens, but it's not the end of the world.
SPEAKER_00It is it's a weird, but it's a curious kind of plot point thing where he like he goes off to get the unicorn blood because Deliria is hoping that it can be used as a cause, as a cure for vampirism or something like that. Which feels quite stakesy, but then they get caught with it, and it kind of just serves to inspire to get Kazador thinking about blood and inspire him to send a story enough to get him some blood to drink, which is kind of like the plot of the second half of the book, I guess, maybe two-thirds, whatever.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. It just it felt like uh I was expecting that we would get to kind of that feels like the main plot, and I was expecting we'd get to it a lot sooner, and that it would be kind of kicked off by something like a bit more bit more meaningful, or that it would the unicorn thing wouldn't just be dropped in the way that it was. But yeah, I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, absolutely. I read a lot of reviews on this book, and somewhere like it's it's it's um they don't like how it's written or it's badly written. I don't agree with that. I just think that the the plot is very weird. I don't think it's like I I have a lot of quotes that I actually like. So I think and I love how T. King Fisher writes. I really like her style, and I think it's a it's well written. I just think that the story is a little bit. It's all over the place. I am and also this part, it's it's super fun to read, but again, cut it, and the only thing that you're gonna miss is the inspiration for the second half of the book.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_04Which also amounts to oh god, I I'm very mean in this. Uh it amounts to nothing really. Like the first time I was just reading, I was having a lot of fun, and then I started talking to a friend who asked me, uh how do you like it? Like you're you're as a big fan, do you like it? And then I was like, Yeah, I liked it. And I started talking about it and was like, ah, I don't like it. But not but not for the reasons maybe other people disliked it. It's more like, what is going on in this? What's the story about?
SPEAKER_00It does feel like um, I don't I don't think it was again, I don't know anything about the the the process of how the story was come up with. But you could see something like this happening with kind of like design by committee or something like that. It feels like a bunch of people were like, hey, so we need to tell the story of uh young historian, you know, we need to because it's a prequel, so we have to know what he was like as a kid, and also we need to see him doing the hunting stuff uh because that's important from the game, and we need to see the other spawn because we see them in the game, but also we need to have like something completely different, we need to have this whole uh thing with the SMR.
SPEAKER_00We need uh we need a romance plot to it. We need and like I was I agree with you, I think it's very well written. I I think that it I was having like a bunch of fun reading the start of the book, and then it felt like it wandered off and just nearly a different story started. Um, and again, it's connected, one thing leads to the next, leads to the next, but not in a way that feels particularly important. Um so yeah, I don't know. It I definitely I would have liked for if it felt weightier, like if if stuff had had consequences.
SPEAKER_00And I know it's difficult because you have to end the book with nothing having changed so that it leads neatly into the game. I mean that's not true, things could have changed, but just then you need to start with a different historian. So the change is fundamental, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and people already know how the book is going to end. That's also something that you usually don't have when you write a book, but now we we know uh where it's going to go. Um yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's kind of like the the Rogue One problem in Star Wars, or it's like the Titanic problem, because you know how that movie ends. I'm like, no, not not quite, but I mean it it has to end at a certain one. Yeah, yeah, rogue one's a better, a better analogy for sure. Um, but I just wasn't sure what kind of nerd you were, so what I was like, maybe maybe not a Star Wars nerd. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Um never seen Titanic, so go with Star Wars.
SPEAKER_00Okay, yeah. Well, I hate to break it to you, but it doesn't go well for the ship.
SPEAKER_04So without a spoiler warning, that was I know.
SPEAKER_00I'm so sorry for anyone who hasn't seen uh 1997 James Cameron's Titanic or ever heard of the most famous boat ever. Um no, but you're right, like the plot feels a bit unfocused, it feels like it jumps around a lot, it feels like it's trying to tick a lot of boxes. Um and by trying to cover all of its bases, it doesn't really land any of the big heavy uh hits that you'd you'd like it to. Um that's not quite quite true.
SPEAKER_00There are some great moments actually in there, particularly towards towards the end. There are some really good moments in the second half of the book, but it doesn't necessarily have the weight that you'd like it to because you're just a bit all over the place.
SPEAKER_04So yeah, so uh this is the entire build-up for for this uh the heist to get the the blood of an undead god. No, from a dead god. The god is dead, the god is dead, I think. The blood is still here, yeah. Yeah, the publisher focused the like I said, if you just read uh the back of the book, it focuses very heavily on this, and I was also confused. Um, where's this paladin? Yeah, where is he?
SPEAKER_04And um yeah, he he comes in now when historian uh needs to uh go and get that blood from an the undead cult. What is it? What is it with the undead? I don't know. I I think I'm mixing up.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. They're wax mummies or something though, which is which is fun. It's a weird yeah, and I really like there's a really detailed description in there about the process of creating like a wax mummy. I'm like the somewhat you spent a day on Wikipedia and you really wanted to tell us about this. This was a hyperfixation for a day, and like I'm here for it. This is great by all means.
SPEAKER_04So a lot of things happen. Like uh I'm a cut cut cut this short a bit, but it's like Deliria and Houston decide to um team up with Astarian and get him to go and get that blood of of this god, of this dead god, and um because all of the spawn need to go and get blood, and Delirian and Housen are like, we can't do that, we're gonna fail either way. So let's put our bets on Astarian because uh he's gonna like, yeah, he's not helpless, as we've um determined already.
SPEAKER_04Let's help him out because they know about this cult and and Houston can get him there. He first checks all the things with the guild, which is also something that I'm a bit um, I was a bit unhappy about. I felt like Astarian has a lot of connection in this in the city, and I that again was something like I I wasn't really hurt by the romantic stuff because I feel like T. King Fisher really makes sure to tell us he's not in love, don't worry, your your love story is the only one that matters. Really, but yeah, it was it was more like his connections, kind of kinds of friendship, and I think um that doesn't really make sense with everything that he's he's has such a hard time trusting anybody.
SPEAKER_04If he had so many friends and connections, allies, even people who are being nice to him for no reason really, or nice, yeah, it's not nice, but it's being like, okay, I help you out, you help me out, and that's like a concept he does not understand throughout the entire game. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00So um, yeah, yeah, no, I do I I get what you mean. The I probably wouldn't use the word friends. I don't like it. There's very few people I think in the book that you meet where you're like, oh yeah, Astarian and this person are are buds. Yeah. Um it's it it is a difficult thing because, like, as a kind of covert vampire thing, he needs to be a little bit anonymous, but at the same time, he does have this element of kind of criminality about him at some ways. Like, I liked that he had people that he knew at Rat's Run at the at the tavern.
SPEAKER_00That felt good to me, like that felt kind of quite local, and um I I could see him having kind of a small inner circle of people not that he trusts, but that he knows that their interests align enough that they're probably not gonna rat him out or or whatever. Um yeah, going into like the guild, uh the Thieves Guild kind of place, mentioning Nine Fingers, kind of there's that's a little bit harder to square, I think, with the historian from the game, someone who's because he's not like a big figure in Baldur's Gates, Baldur's Gates like underground kind of crime scene or anything like that.
SPEAKER_00Um so yeah, it it does I I can understand it clashes a little bit with a starian who's so so guarded and so like reluctant to trust anybody or to put himself out there at all. Um I didn't flying with me too much, I think. It was a little bit felt like a little bit of a detour that we didn't necessarily need. Um I think because I think they literally I think he literally says he's going off into the the undercity or whatever it is with uh with his with his brother, and he's like, okay, we're going over here now first.
SPEAKER_00I'm like, okay, this is again it's a possibly a fun opportunity to show off some characters and to to get some information. It feels like a scene you might want to see, but again, didn't feel fundamentally that important. It didn't feel like it had consequences, particularly.
SPEAKER_04So yeah, it was just to to to fact check what they were already telling him, and yeah, it turns out the facts are true.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, pretty much.
SPEAKER_04As soon as as far as he could tell, and uh they they go to this uh to this cult and run uh into a lot of skeletons. Violet is involved in getting him caught also, uh, but in the end he ends up in this cell with the paladin. I think we just jump in there, yeah.
SPEAKER_00No, absolutely.
SPEAKER_04If if that's okay with you. Yeah. Um and then uh the paladin appears. And uh, how did you like the paladin?
SPEAKER_00I oh it's tricky. I like the idea of a story getting locked up in a cell with a paladin who doesn't know he's in dead. I had such a good time with all of that element to it. Uh I enjoyed that the paladin is that as so many paladins kind of are sometimes like a bit lawful stupid. Uh no guile about the guy whatsoever. He felt like a good foil to Astorian in in a lot of ways.
SPEAKER_00Um the I didn't I didn't buy necessarily like I didn't buy the kind of them falling for each other like in the the way that they did. Like that felt like it didn't have the time to grow into like an unlikely friendship and or unlikely romance or unlikely hot sexy thing. Um I I don't know. I I liked the yeah, I like the Paladin character a lot. I liked a lot of the interactions with Astarian.
SPEAKER_00I don't think I bought him as the driving plot emotional kind of thing that he that that he became. Um I mean what about what about you? How did you find the very all all the horny paladin scenes?
SPEAKER_04Oh, that's a different question though.
SPEAKER_00Okay. How did you find him as a character?
SPEAKER_04Thank you. Let's start light.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04I I like the paladin. But uh yeah, maybe maybe it could have been more fun if they're just like uh yeah, they need to get out of this cell so they're gonna work together, even though they their interests don't really align generally, but they need to get out of this cell. Um I think she wrote a very, very funny character here, and I like him. But um yeah, it got it got very intense very soon. But I I I don't ru I never read it as a as a romance.
SPEAKER_04I I just read it as something both of them were looking, like he was looking for someone to save, and the star was looking for someone who saves him, something like that, or helps him out. And uh again, like somebody helping him doesn't really make sense with anything that happens next. But that aside, I thought, okay, that's fun. Um what I would have loved is actually the version that Astarian thinks is going to happen, that that the paladin is is made up by Khazidor and was just sent to get all his secrets.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but I would have gone with that one because that would have destroyed every hope and and trust that he mustered up with this uh paladin.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Or or that he just gets killed. You know, that he he wants there's the scene where he runs into his death pretty much because he he wants to attack a thousand skeletons at a time. Yeah, and uh Sarian looks at it and is like, okay, he's not gonna survive because he's not gonna survive that. Yeah, and I thought, okay, now leave. Because that would have been the Astarian thing to do. And he doesn't, and I was super sad.
SPEAKER_04I I I wanted a meaner Astarian throughout the book. He's very heroic, not in in big gestures, uh a few big gestures, yes, but it's more like the little things getting the blood for deliria, doing this, doing that. Why? Why would he do any of that? He's like, I mean, uh very famous scenes from the game. You help out a kid and he disapproves. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, so why on earth would he go back to help the paladin?
SPEAKER_04It yeah, yeah. No, I mean I like the character, I just yeah.
SPEAKER_00I but the thing is, I think you're so right, like, because there is that idea seeded that that the paladin might have been sent from by cat from Cazador, and that that that works, I think, as a way of showing how paranoid a storian is and how he questions everything, because this is what Kazador has has done to him. This is what that kind of like mental torture does. Um you start questioning every reality.
SPEAKER_00But it would have been so much better if that was what had happened. Like it just oh, it would have been yeah, no, if if that was actually how it had turned out, or if Kazador had turned up and and like killed the had had killed the guy in like some awful, gruesome way, or forced a story into kill him, like that's that's the level of evil that I I want from Kazador. That's the the big grand scheme puppet master that I want to feel that we're dealing with.
SPEAKER_00Uh because then everything else makes sense. Then all of the the paranoia makes sense and the fear and the idea that like he's he's a he's a vampire. He could play out schemes over years just to fuck with people if he felt like it. He's got the time. Um and you're right, one of the big things that didn't uh one of the things that I didn't love about the thing, and we hit it nearly immediately actually at the start of the book, is a story and is quite nice.
SPEAKER_00Um right at the beginning when Astarian has he hands down his the the judgment when he's still alive, when he's a magistrate, someone is caught poaching, and Astarian's like, well, I could give this person the death penalty, but like I'll give them a lenient sentence and just put them in prison or whatever. Um, and he's a bit indignant that he's not being recognized for his kindness and for his thing. And he's like, No, but I I did the good thing, I did the thing. I'm like, Astarian would not give a shit about doing the good thing.
SPEAKER_00He's not gonna be nice to you for the sake of being nice to you, even like alive. Like you said, him being a vampire is not the problem, him being a selfish asshole is the problem. Um, so yeah, there there are definite moments kind of throughout the game where or throughout the book, uh, where a story where Astorian uh is just a bit more selfless and a bit more heroic than uh than game historian would have been.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I wanted him to be a lot meaner.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think.
SPEAKER_04Because that that's that's what's great about this character. Like people who try to um to to convince me that he's not a good companion, and like he's such a hypocrite. Yes. And yeah, that's that's what's your point? You're just you're just naming things I love about him. What did you where are you going with this? So um him being uh so nice or even consider thinking about others is not really um like not really, it doesn't add up with the game, but I think it it takes away a lot of his personality.
SPEAKER_04If you if you cut his um selfishness, then he's not an anti-hero. He's I mean, even if you have like the the romanced version, good guy endings, keep him a spawn, and he's like, Oh, I'm so happy, our our party is happy as well. He says that because he's happy himself.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, sure.
SPEAKER_04He's he has a great life now, or yeah, the best he can get as a spawn. So of course he's happy other people are happy. This is not him turning out to be a good guy. He's not just like, oh, if I'm happy, if I'm so happy, they can be happy as well. Who cares? I that's how I understood his character, and um seeing him actually caring about this guy, why?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, it is again, it just it feels very fast. I could you you if it was something if if they were if it was a character that was introduced at the start of the the book and you had the entire book to get to a point where a storian cares about someone and is going to do something selfless, just This once and ideally it backfires horribly and then reinforces all of the negative shit, and then that makes sense for the character that we see in the game.
SPEAKER_00It makes sense that he's been burned this badly by like the one time he tried to care about somebody. Um someone that he meets halfway through a game and they fight their way through a bunch of skeletons, and then yeah, he's he he's emotionally kind of attached, and it doesn't feel as believable a journey, I guess. And I don't think it has the the emotional impact that you would hope that something like that would have. Um so yeah, I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Again, I would love to have seen like the early earlier notes and early drafts and love to know kind of why certain decisions were were made. Um but yeah, you're I mean you're dead right though. Like it's I so want that the the he was a plant by Cazador thing to be to have been the story the whole time.
SPEAKER_04When they announced a plot like with the ally, I was I think I I said to a friend, if this guy doesn't turn out to be a fraud, then I'm not gonna love it. And I'm yeah, I had fun with the book. Like it I this conversation seems very negative. And I think it's a bit more negative than I planned it to be. Um, but yeah, I I I don't think there can be any light or happiness, trust.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's kind of things.
SPEAKER_04Without it backfiring, yeah. That would have been great though. Like, okay, I but it I think it should have been early on, not not so late. I trust one of my siblings, maybe, or I trust uh, I don't know, someone, and uh something horrible happens, and that's why people never trust again. Something like that also would have been very interesting to read.
SPEAKER_00But uh Yeah, something like that would have been great.
SPEAKER_04Um But there is um my favorite scene or the favorite moment of of the book is is happening when nearly make it out, but but they try to flee, but then doesn't work, and they are in in the room locked together, the paladin and starion, and and the paladin knows that a starion is uh undead. They think it's because he can pass the that threshold or something that was magic and only undead can pass or something.
SPEAKER_04And um now he has I think it's there, I hope. And uh now he knows okay, I have a paladin who has sworn to kill the undead. And I still need to uh persuade this guy not to kill me. Something like that. And um T. Kingfisher uses this puppy analogy scene where he's like, okay, the the easiest way to uh make uh uh paladin compliant to what you want to do is tell him somebody's kicking a puppy, and he will follow immediately and have a look and help you out.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04And then you have uh dialogue scene where he talks to the paladin and tells him about his horrible past and la la la. And you kind of forgot about this whole puppy thing, and then he says something like become the kicked puppy you want to see in the world. And that I thought was so good because he used his own tragic backstory to make the paladin sympathize with him and be like, Oh, he's okay, he's undead and a vampire, and he has killed a lot of people, but yeah, look at this poor kicked puppy.
SPEAKER_04And I I mean I was a sold customer already, and I fell for it again. And I felt I really noticed, I think afterwards he's like uh feeling he doesn't like how he feels that he used his his memories to persuade this guy. But I think I would have loved it was if if it was all very planned, like, okay, I I'm just becoming the kick puppy, and um but she she goes through through with it a bit because he's he says a bunch of times like ah he wanted to say something mean, but he needs to be a tragic figure, so he he's not gonna say it.
SPEAKER_04And I love that because again, he is not helpless, and he will use every single thing he can use to get out of bad situations, more of that, and I love that part, and I think it's my favorite part of the entire movie.
SPEAKER_00That's that's such a good part, and I mean the thing as well is that like he's because when he first meets the the paladin, like he's he's lying about stuff and he's hiding a ton of stuff or whatever. Once the paladin realizes that he is undead, he casts like the zone of truth or something like that. So a story and can't lie anymore, and that's when it gets really fun because he has to manipulate the paladin only telling him stuff that is true. He has to present his tragic backstory with such intention, and like that felt great.
SPEAKER_00Like I I agree with you, that felt really, really good. Um my favourite part of it came a little bit after that, which is because Astarian continues to reveal more and more of his tragic backstory, and just like how how how awful his life has been. Um and there's a line somewhere where a Astarian just kind of talks about being a vampire spawn and how awful it is, and how no one would choose this life if they knew what it was like.
SPEAKER_00Then I pity you, the SMR drew himself up, but I would rather kill myself than live such a life. And then you have from a historian, do you think I haven't tried? And I remember reading that um in like the earlier draft, and I have a comment that I left here, all caps, yes, this is the perfect historian moment. White hot anger and pain bursting through the smug and joking joking facade, revealing some fucked up secret. This is so core to who he is, and these two lines show it beautifully.
SPEAKER_00And just I don't know, it was a weird, a weird kind of feeling of going through the book with this character that felt so like a stallion in so many ways, but then you just got this moment of like, oh shit, there he is. There's the guy that I knew, there's the guy that I spent like five years sitting with. Um and just I I don't know, the there's it's so rare in this book, I think that a storian's anger really comes out, like really comes out, and that was one of those moments I was like, fuck oh, that's really good, actually.
SPEAKER_00Okay, yeah, that's absolutely nailed that moment. It's brilliant.
SPEAKER_04And also, also afterwards, if he that the Paladins offers to kill him, and he's like, No, I want to live.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Also that one, because I like that part.
SPEAKER_00I think it's in the same scene, or or um just I think so. Yeah, it's that's why I want to live. It's been over a hundred years. If I simply drop dead, what's the point of all that agony? So the idea that everything he's been through will have been wasted, and by living he gets revenge on Kazator. But that's there's a beautiful kind of hope in that. Um, like even though everything is awful and has been awful for a hundred years or whatever, like just the idea that it can be better and that by living a better life it it will have been worth it.
SPEAKER_00Whereas if he dies now, it's kind of meaningless. That was yeah, no, it was a it was a really good moment. And I I like the Paladin like so much because I like those little conversations that they have where they're able to tease out their different their different worldviews, the different relationships that they have, kind of with the lives that they lead. Because, you know, they're both kind of miserable in in a sense. They're both they're they're both missing something, they're both a bit lost.
SPEAKER_00Um and I really enjoyed those moments, the kind of the quieter moments where they got to dig into that. That was a lot of fun.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I think they they kind of it it works in a way, but I think it was just I mean yeah, the the the book has so many pages, so if I don't think you can build if you start the paladin story in the middle of the book and then you need to wrap it all up with with friendship and and some stuff. Yeah, yeah. I don't think it's I don't want to call it love. It's more like you said both are missing something and then completing that with each other, whatever, for for just that moment. Also didn't love I didn't like that he comes back another I I I thought okay, he's gone now.
SPEAKER_04Great, yeah, his story is over, and he comes back like go away. And now if Cassidor could kill him, that would be amazing.
SPEAKER_02No, yeah, that didn't had a lot of that.
SPEAKER_04I don't know, I I felt like the moment that Astarian like comes out of the door in his what feels like his pajamas and the the paladin is there at the door. It really felt like a 90s rom-com, like in front of the parents' house. Sure. No, we can't be together. I'm sorry. My life is too hard. You cannot join me in my horrible life.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Go save yourself, do something better, go off to college. I don't know. It felt like it felt like uh something like that.
SPEAKER_00It felt like there were a lot of different ways that scene could have gone, and a lot of them very interesting and very tragic, and we didn't we didn't quite get those. We didn't really, yeah. I felt the same. Like I was like, okay, he's he's gone. I can see him coming back, but I think he was gone for just long enough that I was like, oh okay, well, I guess he's I guess he I guess he is gone, I guess he's not coming back, and then he did, and it didn't feel satisfying. Like, uh yeah, I don't know. I keep feeling like I needed to be like very well written though, but just pacing wise, plot-wise, uh some choices were made.
SPEAKER_00Uh yes, exactly.
SPEAKER_04And and we have an entire bit of his sore turning into a bat and uh jumping and flying. That yeah, that also happened in between the scenes we just mentioned. He manages to get the blood, he even gets they they get out pretty much unharmed. Um, then you have the the romance or or sex scene, and uh Sarion leaves and uh he brings the blood to Kazidor, and that is also like one of the the lore problems from the beginning.
SPEAKER_04Like they know about the ritual room, which was very felt a bit weird since in the game it's like this whole secret uh part of the palace, and it's also called the ritual room. I have to say, I while while reading, I didn't um I just thought it's a room. I didn't question like ritual room. Ah, okay, it's some weird room of Kazidor's, and then I saw oh okay, the ritual room is the thing where you have the big boss fight in the game. Okay, that doesn't make sense.
SPEAKER_04That's true.
SPEAKER_00No, yeah, that does not make sense. I it is it's very confusing. I'm not sure how to how to read it. I had kind of assumed that Kazidor's ritual room was kind of like you said, just like a room in the house that you would explore normally. Um I I don't know which one really. Um, but yeah, I I had assumed it was like maybe the room because I think I'm trying to remember the game now, but I think you go in and you can into he has like an office type place that's yeah, yeah, yeah, away from the rest of the place and secret passage, something, something, something that leads down.
SPEAKER_00I had assumed it was like the office kind of room that they were talking about, rather than because the absolutely the whole thing underneath is meant to be crazy secret and no one knows about any of it.
SPEAKER_04Um he mentions it three times, like what I never knew about this place. And in it Yeah, yeah, exactly. Oh the ritual room and delirio just goes in and steals the blood.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Also with the the spawn having their own rooms. I didn't, yeah, I I thought, well, I don't think there were bunk beds when I played the game.
SPEAKER_00There were there were bunk beds and stuff in them.
SPEAKER_04Um but I didn't that's a detail that, yeah, it it's it's wrong, but I wasn't um very bothered by it. But the ritual room felt a little off because it's like, oh okay, but how can she know about how do they all know about the ritual room?
SPEAKER_00It's confusing for sure. I'm still not sure if it's I I I I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Uh I'm not sure if in the book they have the same name in the end, if it was intentional or not, it's just unfortunate. No, absolutely. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So uh Deliria steals the blood and uh uses it for her projects that don't amount to anything again. Yep. Um and she gets punished for it by uh goady.
SPEAKER_00It was nice to see goadi, like it's honestly like it's kind of genuinely like this. I was reading through it and he pops like blades right at the end, like, oh hey you, yeah.
SPEAKER_04I kill you every time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, rightly so. Um yeah, that's it.
SPEAKER_04I mean, nobody uh we never said that. The one that brings the best blood was uh promised to become a vampire. Of course, it doesn't happen.
SPEAKER_00Of course, it doesn't happen yet.
SPEAKER_04And uh they also kind of thought it would not happen, but uh they had to try because if they didn't, yeah. That was fine. I think yeah, everybody knew it's not going to happen, but what if and if we don't play his stupid little game, he's gonna torture us uh for weeks, so let's just go with the silly little plan. Pretty much, yeah. And nobody wins, and uh we just um wait for the game to start. We had I I like the moment between him and and Aurelia.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, like the the last kind of conversation they they share, being friends, but not really, because if you're too good of friends, um then Kazador is gonna use it against you. So yeah, I like that. I really like that interaction. And I I'm fan of Aurelia, so I'm kind of a biased opinion here.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think it's um it's good. And there's a couple of good, like good interactions, I think, towards the end. Like Astarian has one with Deliria as well, where he kind of uh kind of like completely shuts her down as like I was always using you, I was always he's he's like intentionally an asshole to to to to to drive her kind of further away. And basically he's a dictor to kind of save her, which again, nice, nice Astarian, whatever, and um yeah, and then the conversation with earlier there's there's a couple of nice character moments again that feel like they set up where Astarian is going kind of uh reasonably nicely.
SPEAKER_00Um but yeah, I don't know. It's delirious things feel so high stakes in a lot of ways, uh, that it's it's like what are you doing, girl?
SPEAKER_04Just give up. Astarian was right. Your research is worth nothing. Yeah, stop what are you doing? You're wasting everybody's time. I felt like, yeah, that's that's true. I agree. I agree with Angie's.
SPEAKER_00I don't know, for something kind of a bit punchier to to happen than the way that it played out. I think I think it was good, but you you're trying to pull together so many different threads, like at the end, it feels like there's a lot that needs tying up, and it's difficult to have that land in a really solid, emotionally satisfying kind of way.
SPEAKER_04I would have loved if whoever wins gets humiliated a lot. Like this is what you want, and then something horrible Cazador like happens.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04And it's like, even if you do win, you don't. Like you lose, you lose no matter what you do. That would was also something I was hoping for, but yeah.
SPEAKER_00Army something, it's some fun like twist. Like he does, he does make whoever wins an actual vampire, and then they end up being like locked in a cage literally forever, or they're something like that. They're killed, they're sacrificed. There's something that means that winning is so so much worse than than than than losing ever could have been. It would have yeah, yeah, it would have been nice.
SPEAKER_04But it's that was yeah, no.
SPEAKER_00But I did enjoy it. I feel like I'm coming out and saying so much stuff. I'm like, I had fun reading the book though, I promise.
SPEAKER_04Yes, yeah, well, me too. But it's really like if you read it or listen to it, um, it's a lot of fun. And I think only when you start really questioning every like the plot or or what what happens exactly, you're you're big you get confused. But it works very well while you're reading it, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I think. Moment to moment it's a good it's a good time. Um as you sit down, uh kind of like you said with your friend, as you sit down and you try to explain it to somebody else, it gets more difficult. Um like yeah.
SPEAKER_04I really like when you you heard his thoughts. I didn't love the dialogue as much. I was I was uh yeah, because you're so used to him talking from the game, you you hear that voice a lot. I think I felt more like, oh, would he say that? Nah. But with the thoughts, I think she really nailed him. Like what he's um I think there were some very good moments.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, there there really were. And it is again, particularly kind of within the household. I really, really enjoy getting to see the cogs turned where he's like, okay, well, like if this thing is going to happen, we're all being summoned down to dinner for Khazador, so this and this this might happen. But what if okay, I'm gonna sit here in the middle so that I don't get punished. Like a lot of that was a lot of that was fun. And again, some really fun kind of moments interacting with the other with the other spawn, uh, at the point where he he's chatting to Deliria, and I think uh Violet is he notices Violet is listening at the door or something, and he goes over with a bit of wire just through the keyhole, and it's like, oh, I'm so sorry, I didn't know you were there.
SPEAKER_03How horrible. Yeah, yeah. No, but exactly like these moments, yeah. Uh I also love them. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I felt like a lot of fun.
SPEAKER_04But yeah. You just think you need to read it like a separate thing, and some some fun side quest he did somewhere in his past, and uh you just you can tag along and yeah um then I think then it works really well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. No, I think I think it does. I think if you take it as its own thing, um and you can separate it a little bit from kind of the experience of of the game. I mean, I I haven't looked at much in the way of reviews. I have, um, but friends who who have done have told me like reviews that are primarily seem to be like T Kingfisher fans or are just talking about the book, reviews from people who haven't played the game are generally very positive, and reviews from people who who bring the game up a lot are not negative, but I mean they skew a bit more that way.
SPEAKER_00Um so you need to kind of just separate them a little bit in your own mind, and I think you'll have a much better time reading the book. Just don't take it too seriously. I think that's I know it's difficult. I know he's a character that means an awful lot to a lot of people, and they want to see that that that honoured, which I appreciate so much. Um, but also it feels I don't know to to to to go out and to read something and for it not to be not to match exactly the character that you that you played, uh the experience that you had.
SPEAKER_00It's a very good way to make yourself unhappy. Um it's a very good way to make yourself angry and end up posting on the internet, and uh yeah. I don't know. I I enjoyed reading the book. It was again very weird experience for me personally, but I I think T. Kingfish is a wonderful writer, and when the book lands well, I think it lands very well. So yeah.
SPEAKER_04In in the end, I always try to like is it listen to that, is it um worth reading, and who should read this book? And I think, yeah, know yourself. Are you a purist? Do you enjoy the a very truthful adaptation of your character or uh you're looking for like some some extended version of of the game you played so many times, or even just once that you had so much fun with, and then I think no, don't read it, uh, because like you said, you're just gonna be unhappy.
SPEAKER_04But if you see it as some maybe even some alternative universe kind of thing going on, um where he's just where he has a a good week in 200 horrible years where he has not friends, but maybe some form of allies, and um he's having a bit of fun.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, then yeah, go for it. Exactly. And I mean the thing is this is the this is the first time that Astarian has been that we've we've seen a different take on Astarian. It's not gonna be the last. There's there's gonna be more.
SPEAKER_04It's their comics coming up.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Oh, I'm sure there's So much stuff that I have no idea about. Um, so it's I don't know. I'm I'm curious to see where he goes in the future. It it's a little bittersweet to see him going out into the world and being so successful, um, and like not to be the the the person writing his stuff, but also that's if people were like waiting on me to do anything. Basically, if people were waiting on me to to write an entire book or do anything like that, they'd be waiting a l a long time.
SPEAKER_00It's probably I think better that a starting is is out there and is in the hands of other very talented people, and I'm I'm excited to see what the future brings for them, really. But again, very weird experience.
SPEAKER_04If you have if you have maybe more versions of of the character, and then you can pick like okay, I really like I don't like the book, or I love the book, but I don't like the the comics or or whatever. And I think now it's she's she was the first with stuff. Yeah, yeah, exactly. It's it's very difficult.
SPEAKER_00I'm excited for it to go the other way. Like for in a couple of months, people who read the book and loved the book, and then they went back and they played the game are like, who the fuck is this guy? Who's this? What's his problem? What's his problem? This guy's an asshole. This isn't my historian.
SPEAKER_04What the hell? I I hope people who have read the book and like, okay, I like the character. I want to spend uh hundred and forty hours with him. Um let's go and they they start playing the game. I mean that would be wonderful, actually.
SPEAKER_00That would that would be worth it.
SPEAKER_04Hopefully they like him in in all his in all his colors.
SPEAKER_00No, but I think I think I think there are I'm excited because there are a lot of people I think for who are going to discover a starian through through this book. And I think there's a lot of people who are going to really love this version of him, and that's that's fantastic. Like I'm I'm very happy. Anything that creates more nerds in the world and ideally gets more people playing DD, that's ultimately what I want. Just to spread the gospel of being a gigantic nerd.
SPEAKER_04A book stirring up so much, you know, or a book about a character from a game, it's even more niche and and and causing so much conversation between book nerds, game nerds, both. Um that's fantastic. Yeah. More nerds and more people reading. That's what that's what you want. Yeah. And people being very invested in lore and stuff like that. It's it's fantastic. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely.
SPEAKER_04So we've only talked for like two hours, so anything else to add or um God.
SPEAKER_00I feel oh the thing is, I feel like they're probably we could probably get another hour out of talking about it.
SPEAKER_03Oh, trust me, no problem. That's that's the problem.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, but I think that's more more than enough. Uh yeah. I would, I I would, as you say, I I would encourage people to to read it, like uh to go out and buy the book as long as you're not gonna take it too seriously, as long as you're not gonna get upset if it doesn't match the historian like that you've uh that you've come to know. But um, no, I I like I said at the start, it would be impossible, I think, to write a book that's gonna make everybody happy.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, and ultimately not a perfect book, but I think T. King Fisher has written a very good book. So again, better than I would have done, I think.
SPEAKER_04And again, your game is safe.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_04Nothing happens to the game, no matter how many prequels, sequels, uh, adaptations. Wasn't there talks about a TV show?
SPEAKER_00So talks about a TV show, which I I have no idea what's happening with that, but I I I hope it's still happening. I'd be so curious to see.
SPEAKER_04Oh, I can see the the haters from the books and like the people joining again for to hate something else, so maybe sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's the thing though, like if something else comes out and it's really bad, the book is gonna look so good by comparison. People might have a second take on it, they might might reevaluate their book.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, yeah. I haven't prepared any book recommendations, I just uh noticed now. So, do you have anything you want to recommend?
SPEAKER_00Oh god. Um no. I've I feel so bad. I have not been reading anywhere near enough books. Um God.
SPEAKER_04That's fine. I think um maybe some other like yeah, the two Kingfisher books that I really enjoyed, uh, which was Thornhedge and uh Nettle and Bone uh fantasy books. So if you liked it, and even if you didn't like the book, maybe check out some of her other stuff. She has a lot of cool and interesting books, and so many I haven't read yet.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, I am actually genuinely very excited to read some of uh T Kingfisher's other stuff because I'm so curious to see what she does with her own world, somewhere where she's got complete creative control. And yeah, no, I think uh I'm I'm looking forward to that.
SPEAKER_04So if you didn't know what to read next, and now you have, well, a few ideas, or like I said, you just go and play the game. You're gonna be occupied for a long time. And then you can always start again, which is uh which is great. Or you can read the book uh that we will be discussing next, which is a graphic novel called Blue is the warmest color by Jules Marot. Thank you for listening. Thank you, Stephen, for coming back uh to this video.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for having me.
SPEAKER_04For anyone who wants to listen to even more bookish talk uh between us, we made an episode about Carmilla, the vampire classic. Um, go check that out as well. It was so nice. I mean, perfect person to talk to about this book. So um that was uh that was super super great. And I think, yeah, like you said, one, two more hours easily. I mean, I haven't even talked about a lot of the game yet, so yeah.
SPEAKER_04Endless content.
SPEAKER_00Endless content, absolutely.
SPEAKER_04Uh thank you so much for for being here again. Okay, I really appreciate it.
SPEAKER_04Um, you'll find all my book reviews on bookcircle.ch. The link is in the description, just like all the links to the books and topics we discussed today. If you'd like to see more of my podcast, you can follow me on Instagram. Uh now that you have it. Now that you've had enough inspiration. Um I'm done talking. Oh. Now that you've had enough inspiration, go and buy yourself the book. And if you can't decide which one, just go ahead and get them both.
Live aus dem Kulturlokal Werkk Baden besprechen Livia und Schweizer Rapper MzumO das Buch «fundamentalös» von Dr. Nussaibah Younis. Eine politische Satire über ein UN-Rehabilitationsprogramm in Bagdad für Frauen, die...
In der sechsunddreissigsten Folge besprechen Livia und Ada das Buch «Frankenstein» von Mary Shelley. Ein Monster-Klassiker, den wir alle kennen, aber decken sich die Verfilmungen mit dem Original? Was hat ihnen...
In der fünfunddreissigsten Folge besprechen Livia und Leo das Buch «The Love Library» von Sarra Manning. Eine romantische Sommerlektüre, in der eine junge Frau die Möglichkeit hat, die Charaktere aus ihren...
On the thirty-fourth episode Livia and Sahar Tavakoli, Iranian writer, publisher and translator, talk about the book «Abeng» by the Jamaican-American author Michelle Cliff. A forty year old book about colonial history,...
In der dreiunddreissigsten Folge besprechen Livia und Demian Cornu, Autor von «Einmachglas», das Buch «Geordnete Verhältnisse» von Lana Lux. Zwei vermeintlich Seelenverwandte, die sich das Leben gegenseitig zur Hölle...