speaker-0: That basically writes Bayesian models for you instead using Elmer type syntax. I think that I would have never written the book for using Jags. I didn't think it was realistic for people to write very these very complex Jags models. It would take me a very long time. It would fail. I would find out a three days later, redo a little typo. so what I would say is using B RMS, the barrier for entry in for Bayesianism is so low that there's really no reason to not use it other than Potentially the slowness of the models, but that's a different issue and that's can be avoided sometimes. And people's main sticking point is stuff like worrying about prior to things like that. I think these concerns are overblown in I'll say in linguistics, the type of data we have, the priors are gonna have minimal impact on your results, and you can even check if they do or don't. I would encourage people working in linguistics, perceptual data, to give Bayesian stats a shot. What I say a little bit tongue-in-cheek is You can make your Bayesian model as terrible as any frequentist model. And by that you can make it analogous if what you want is something analogous with like uniform priors and and minimal constraint things like that. but you can make them much better. And you can get really, really useful information about what are called random effects in your data. Which when your random effects are listeners, what you're talking about is listener variation in a speech community. So these things are actually tremendously useful to know about. And so In speech research specifically, the information you get and the flexibility of multi-level models, in handling outliers, in head handling sc heterosticity, ordinal models, multinomial models, these things that are really end up being necessary for speech research. I really think once people give it a shot, they'll not see immediately the benefits. And I just hope people will be open minded and and and give a Bayesian approach a shot. And I think that they will be very happy.
speaker-1: Yeah yeah. love that. Love that call to action, Santiago. Obviously I resonate with all of that. actually I gave a talk recently at Princeton to the psychology department where I went exactly through these topics in the presentation and the workshop. I'll put the link to the GitHub repo that I set up for that. And it's actually a notebook where yeah, people can go and see how you would do a mixed effect model, because I know it's used a lot in psychology, especially the the Elmar, El Mare flavor of these models. Well, I show you exactly how to do that in the Bayesian workflow with PyMC, so in Python. That way you have VRMS, you have Python, you can choose whatever you prefer. And And you can see the effect of the priors. I see actually I show actually different different priors. And and I show that actually having a wide prior doesn't mean it's a good prior. so yeah, to to echo exactly what you said. and now it's so much easier to to start with these tools, not only because we have supercomputers in our hands and and our Personal computers now are so powerful. and thanks to open source software like BRMS tancity, we can actually sample MCMC in a matter of seconds. So that's definitely a game changer. And also now you can get some assistance if you do it well from AI agents.