What do you do when the feedback you receive is painful, personal, and the last thing you want to hear? In this episode of LeadershipSOPs, Ed Tyson begins with a brutally honest piece of anonymous feedback he received from a colleague, an experience that stayed with him for decades and ultimately became a powerful lesson in leadership and personal development. Ed explores why leaders often focus on giving feedback and developing others while overlooking the difficult work of developing themselves. He explains why our natural response to uncomfortable feedback can include denial, anger, resistance, and even emotional shutdown, and why recognizing those reactions is essential to meaningful growth. He introduces a practical path for turning uncomfortable feedback into improvement: Explore, Clarify, Transform, and Master. Rather than allowing criticism to define you or immediately dismissing it, Ed shows how leaders can search for the useful truth inside the feedback, decide what needs to change, create specific actions, and build new behaviors through repetition. Ed also shares five practical steps for creating your own personal development SOP, including keeping a development journal, actively seeking feedback, setting clear development objectives, finding trusted accountability partners, and repeating and adjusting your efforts until new behaviors become part of how you lead. The takeaway: Great leadership development starts with the person in the mirror. The feedback that makes you most uncomfortable may contain exactly what you need to become a better leader. Enjoyed this episode? Be sure to subscribe, leave a review, and share it with someone who could benefit from the conversation. For more leadership insights, resources, and ways to connect with Ed Tyson, visit: Website: https://askedtyson.com Thanks for listening, and we'll see you on the next episode.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00If you're leading a team and you feel stuck in chaos, conflict, or constant pressure, then Leadership SOP's podcast is for you. And here's your host, Ed Tyson.
SPEAKER_01You want some feedback? Here's your feedback. The main problem is you just think you're smarter than the rest of us. And this stupid survey is just one example. Wow. Reading that response turned my stomach. I put the whole report down for two or three days, I think, after reading it. 360s can be tough. Really tough. Have you ever done one? Boy. It's your peers that'll get you almost every time. They are less afraid and more willing to share.
SPEAKER_01A few decades after the fact, and I can still remember those words I opened with and just how bad I felt after reading them. It was the early days for a new tool called SurveyMonkey, and that biting feedback had come via a custom attempt to get some anonymous feedback from about 150 colleagues I had worked closely with over the prior five years or so. The words seemed so mean-spirited, I just wanted to forget about them.
SPEAKER_01But that was impossible. I knew every single person I had sent that makeshift 360 to, and the idea that any of them felt that way was soul-crushing. I couldn't just pass it off as some mean-spirited feedback and let it sit. And that, in and of itself, made me angry. I was allowing this person's nasty quip to hurt me. I didn't want to give them the satisfaction, but I was. After a few days, I decided if I was going to continue letting them live rent-free in my mind, I needed to make some use of it.
SPEAKER_01But if I'm honest, it took me more than just a few days to do that. Have you ever gone to great lengths to seek out feedback that then proved difficult to integrate? The problem with feedback, whatever feedback you're getting, is it's just the tip of the iceberg, isn't it? As a study by Nicole Abiesber, Jennifer Abel, Juliana Schroeder, and Francesca Gino pointed out in 2022 in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, we often hold even the simplest of feedback from others.
SPEAKER_01Even feedback we ourselves would desperately want were our positions reversed. In the study, almost comically entitled Just Letting You Know, Underestimating Others' Desire for Constructive Feedback, only four people provided feedback to mock surveyors who had obviously unintended smudges on their face. Yet all, or nearly all, of the 155 participants agreed they would want to know about that smudge if the roles were reversed.
SPEAKER_01We all want feedback, but most, almost all of us, hold it back. Often because we think they won't want the feedback, we'll be embarrassed, upset, or maybe even just totally disregard it if we do. Hello, and welcome back to the Leadership SOPs podcast. I'm your host, Ed Tyson, creator of the Leadership SOPs methodology, framework, and app. The Leadership SOPs methodology carries my process-based philosophy of leadership into action by embracing the simple idea that leadership is a process and as a process is best improved by defining, measuring, and improving your standard operating procedures for leading.
SPEAKER_01My framework, which we're exploring throughout this inaugural season, simply organizes and synchronizes the work your SOPs must do. It doesn't say exactly what your leadership SOPs should look like step by step, but it does take a firm stand on the idea that this is the work you need to do to structure, operate, and perfect the communities of effort you need to succeed. And as we've mentioned in past episodes, while doing it, you should follow some general rules regarding upstream and downstream activities and how they flow together.
SPEAKER_01So the methodology suggests you create leadership SOPs, and the framework helps you determine which ones you need by breaking the work of leading into three high-level domains: structure, operate, and perfect. Episodes four and five hit on nine of those dimensions, digging into the structured domain and how to scope the work, focusing on the existential effort, aligning on the highest level why, what, and how, and the physical efforts like designing an operating model and governance structure.
SPEAKER_01Then episodes six, seven, and eight explored how to set the pace with planning, accountability, and stakeholder engagement mechanisms that match your context, bringing our total count to 12 dimensions covered and four to go. And today, with episode 9, we start our exploration of the perfect domain, as in the verb infinitive to perfect, not the adjective referring to a state of being perfect. In the leadership sense, this is all the activity associated with a leader's effort to develop the might.
SPEAKER_01M-I-T-E, another crafty misspelling used to remember the four primary types of development I must always pursue to strengthen my community of effort. My personal development, the individual development of those under my charge, the team development of my core team, and the broader enterprise development, M-I-T-E. So my individual, team, and enterprise development. Today's discussion, as my opening indicated, is about personal development, meaning how do you, as a leader, take charge of your own development?
SPEAKER_01Before looking out the window at the members of your community of effort, how do you drive self-awareness and personal improvement? I open with that personal story to drive home the fact that real development is sometimes very uncomfortable. Critical information comes to us in both unexpected and unwelcome ways, and true growth is often uncomfortable. As leaders, we often think about feedback from the giving perspective.
SPEAKER_01We think about how and when we should give it. Many of us also consider the change curve when we need to do so, but we often forget to start and think about it when it has to do with ourselves. Change is difficult, not because our people, others, are more difficult than other people out there, but because people are, well, difficult. At least when it comes to meaningful changes they do not understand, agree with, or control.
SPEAKER_01This includes changes in expectations, perceptions, and self-picture. When this topic comes up in large sessions, small groups, and even one-on-ones, I often ask leaders if they like change. Many actually say they do, to which I say, go ahead and start writing down every word I say with your non-dominant hand. This challenge is mostly met with a knowing smirk. Few have ever actually engaged in the activity because they realize it would cause an immediate reduction in productivity, some personal embarrassment over the results, and general frustration.
SPEAKER_01And besides, why would they do it? This isn't even an important ask, isn't it? Didn't I just mean it rhetorically? Well, of course I did. But really think about that for a second. Can you imagine the pushback I would receive in those moments if I really insisted? No, this is critical. I recognize you don't understand its importance, but I really must insist. And actually, your lack of engagement will have to be reported to HR. Wow. Many of our leaders and our individual contributors, of course, feel that way about the things we're asking for.
SPEAKER_01And often the truth is we feel that way about changes and feedback proposed to us. I mentioned the change curve moments ago, but I didn't really explain myself. The change curve generally refers to the applicability of the Kubler-Ross grief cycle to how we approach change. That grief cycle tracks the impact of death and dying on the human psyche. It turns out it's not too different for other undesirable changes that we just can't control.
SPEAKER_01For our purposes today, there are two important concepts here. One, the phenomenon applies to the normal and natural response of the human psyche. And two, you yourself are human. This does happen to you, even though you're a leader. We need to start with ourselves when we think about development versus racing to others for this very reason. By centering ourselves on the process and its difficulties, we often can unlock how we can help others through it as well.
SPEAKER_01If we track my own prolonged movement through this dynamic, you can see I first denied that feedback I got. I denied there was any usable information there. And then, in many different ways, I started to resist it. I don't understand it, I understand it, but I don't like it, I understand it, I don't like it, and I don't like the sender. These dynamics reflected a dip in my well-being as I attempted to cope through various methods. Often, at the very bottom of this dip are bouts of depression.
SPEAKER_01For that reason, many refer to this low point as the valley of despair. In work and at home, this dynamic is dangerous to the individual and the organization, since, as humans, our executive functioning, our forebrains are easily hijacked by these kinds of stresses. In cases where a healthier dynamic, again for the individual and the organization takes hold, is when an individual is able to push through this initial discomfort and begin to actively engage in the change, first by exploring it, then by clarifying priorities and plans, and then by taking action or transforming from the current state to the future state.
SPEAKER_01And lastly, by seeking a new level of mastery or performance. Kubler-Ross called the early stages immobilization, denial, anger, bargaining, and depression. I simply summarize them as forms of resistance, whether through cognitive dissonance, active resistance, or emotional collapse. This part of the change curve is marked by a failure to engage in healthy ways, whereas the positive, active, and productive engagement in change generally follows the path of explore, clarify, transform, and master.
SPEAKER_01And so this is the path I encourage you to follow while guiding yourself through growth. Let's go back to that really difficult feedback I received. When I began to explore it in a healthy way, I could see the following fact pattern emerge. I asked only people I knew well and had worked with frequently. One such person provided feedback that suggested my behavior conveyed a sense of superiority, and I could presume that it was the strength of those feelings that they had that led them to share the feedback in such a strong way.
SPEAKER_01Now, because I have access to my thoughts and feelings, I knew there was a big gap between my actual self-regard and my higher regard for the expertise of others. The trick for me, though, was not letting this knowledge negate the truth of the feedback and get in the way of me learning and improving as a result of it. Ultimately, I decided it behooved me to take this feedback seriously because doing my work well relied on tapping into the expertise of others, not shutting it down.
SPEAKER_01Therefore, even if only a small percentage of people felt as this person did, it was feedback worth considering. This was my big conclusion, that my natural personality and style does impact some people in a negative way, and that I find that unacceptable. Even if I can't control it, I can control some things. But my exploration, that endless thinking about this issue, needed to result in some clarifying.
SPEAKER_01And so I decided to develop a clear path forward that didn't include changing who I was, but did include changing some key leadership SOPs. I decided to start referring to my process improvement partners as experts during project scoping meetings with executives, during participant recruitment, and throughout the execution of projects and their results. This was a set of changes that showed up in my project charters, orientation decks, project status reports, and final presentations.
SPEAKER_01Furthermore, I decided to increase my self-deprecation and the amount of smiling during meetings. To help me transform, I asked my boss and a few team members to be my accountability partners. All of them, to a person, suggested I might be just a little bit too sensitive here by making some changes based on some one-off feedback. But when I shared the journey and I told them what I wanted to do about it, they also liked the interventions and really just could not disagree that they were enhancements either way.
SPEAKER_01I relied on repetition and mentoring others over the years to really lock in my mastery of these new leadership SOPs. And if I'm honest though, the one thing that keeps getting me today is the smiling thing. I tend to look very intense the more engaged and more excited I am. I have grown accustomed as a result to doing face checks every few minutes where I think about what is my face doing. I often fail them, but making these adjustments at least ensures that some of the time, even when I'm excited, even when I'm intense, I'm smiling.
SPEAKER_01If I were to suggest a leadership SOP to your leaders and you with respect to personal development, it would have less to do with this specific case and more to do with that explore, clarify, transform, and mastery arch with just a few surrounding enhancements. Number one, start and maintain a personal development journal. Use it like a typical journal if you want. But what I really mean at base is use it as a place to capture development assumptions, feedback, objectives, plans, achievements, and setbacks.
SPEAKER_01Number two, explore key issues quarterly. If there is no current feedback, generate some and recognize that you might need to work really hard to get to the truth. Number three, clarify your feel, know, do development objectives and strategies to achieve them. Number four, seek transformation partners you trust and offer to reciprocate if they need it. Choose someone who gave you the feedback if you can, and determine your proof sources for your attempts to change.
SPEAKER_01So there are facts regarding the plan and execution, even if your ultimate objectives are not met. You'll know it was not because you didn't implement what you set out to do. Finally, number five, repeat and adjust your efforts and skills until you succeed. Lock in that mastery through repetition and passing on your learnings to a mentee. And speaking of others, how does all this apply to developing your team members?
SPEAKER_01How do you sift through the differences between training and coaching needs? That, as you may have guessed, is exactly where we're going next on the Leadership SOPs podcast. Don't forget to subscribe to the podcast where you listen, and find, follow, and engage with me on LinkedIn or the Leadership SOPs app. And as always, lead on.
SPEAKER_00So that's it for today's episode of Leadership SOPs. Head on over to Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen and subscribe to the show. One lucky listener every single week that posts a review on Apple Podcasts will win a chance the grand prize drawing to win a$25,000 value VIP Day with Ed Tyson himself. Be sure to head on over to Leardefensor Peace Podcast.com and pick up a free copy of Ed's gift. And join us next time.
What happens when the people responsible for motivating your workforce become disengaged themselves? In this of Leadership SOPs, host Ed Tyson, leadership expert, author, and organizational effectiveness consultant,...
Are today's leaders so focused on results that they're overlooking the very thing that drives success: their people? In Episode 16 of Leadership SOPs, host Ed Tyson welcomes Dr. Scott Paine, industrial-organizational...
What happens when your career takes you away from the work that made you successful? In Episode 15 of Leadership SOPs, host Ed Tyson welcomes Dr. Mayssa Attar, Senior Vice President of Pharmaceutical and Consumer R&D at...
Flattening an organization sounds appealing: fewer management layers, lower costs, faster decisions, greater autonomy, and less bureaucracy. But what happens when the leaders who remain suddenly inherit a much heavier...
How do you effectively lead people when you can’t see what they’re doing, how they’re performing, or when they need your help? In this episode of LeadershipSOPs, Ed Tyson explores multi-site leadership and why leading...