
Demetri Martin - "Standup Comedian" with Skylar De Cuir
Nick and Bryan have one of the De Cuir posse on to talk about Demetri Martin's "Standup Comedian"
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Nick and Bryan have one of the De Cuir posse on to talk about Demetri Martin's "Standup Comedian"
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
SPEAKER_05Last per minute, we serve a hot take on comedy legends and rising stars. Every episode features a different victim guest serving with Brian and Nick of Armchair Comedy Critics. So lean back, lock in, or whatever it is you listeners do, while we butcher callbacks to our comedy heroes. Who's with us today, Brian?
SPEAKER_02Well, first of all, hey Nick, how are you doing?
SPEAKER_05Uh no. You're off the script. Follow the script. Yes, we have it. It's not about me. It's not about me.
SPEAKER_02This is an exciting, this is an exciting day. This is the uh this is the person that is going to be, let's see, um, once this episode is in the can, three quarters of my family will have been on this podcast. Three quarters. And I don't think we're gonna get the last quarter on there. Um, so yeah, so we have Sky here. Are you counting yourself in the I am, I'm counting myself because I'm on the podcast. Well, yeah. What do you of course? So my uh yeah, so my offspring is here.
SPEAKER_02Sky, Sky Nicure is here with us.
SPEAKER_00And his offspring.
SPEAKER_02Sky's here coming up in a different time zone down in Chattanooga. And Eastern time. Eastern time, just a few hours away from us. But we've been wanting to, he's been wanting to be on here quite some time, and I haven't been able to do it. So finally we're able to do it. So, how about this? Tell us a little bit more about yourself, maybe. Also, tell us why the comedian that you chose and the special, and then tell us why.
SPEAKER_00Well, uh I chose Demichi Martin's stand-up comedian because I remember listening to that a lot with you uh at the car when we would go to places. Um and which what else would you do with the car? Now that I say it. But um I remember uh listening to that album and his other albums, but I I have a lot of memories with this album, so I was like, I haven't listened to it in a while.
SPEAKER_00Why not uh give it a shot on the podcast?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's really good. It's uh we and I think I told you this before, but we did a Dimitri Martin special for the last record, so we're doing like almost like a two for here, which is cool because a double Dimitri. Yeah, because we haven't done that, and we haven't done that yet. It's like a new thing, and it was sort of cool to like back to back listen to the same comedian and then see if I felt differently about each of the things. I actually looked back at my scorecard and stuff to to see how I felt and like see if I felt differently about this one versus the last one that we did because it was so close in my memory.
SPEAKER_02Um, but but yeah, that's good. Well, welcome. Thank you for being here. Of course, really uh it's really exciting, and also I'm glad that you have that good memory of listening to this album.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, I liked listening to comedians with you in the car. But we didn't get coffee, it wasn't like the show.
SPEAKER_03Both of you guys at the same time.
SPEAKER_02With coffee? Did you say with coffee? Well, you guys know this, but for the benefit of the listeners, we have our scorecard that we're gonna be working our way through, and it has some of the style and subject matter and things like that. And then we've got a 12-point check-in where we just go over things, rate things, talk about things, and hopefully have some fun in the process.
SPEAKER_02So didn't notice that we're down to 12 test.
SPEAKER_00What's that?
SPEAKER_02Go ahead, Sky.
SPEAKER_00I said there's no fun allowed on the comedy podcast. We're not allowed to have fun.
SPEAKER_02No, this is real, really important. Serious business that you have to analyze the comedy at a exact information. Exact, exact information. We are extremely precise. What were you gonna say, Nick?
SPEAKER_05Um, I was keying off of the the 12-point.
SPEAKER_02Oh, the 12 check, yeah.
SPEAKER_05You know, like like it's an automotive thing.
SPEAKER_02In our revision, we lost one. We had we were a 13-point check and we revised the score sheet when we dropped one because we did.
SPEAKER_05So it was redundant. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03All right.
SPEAKER_05So I'll say it again, it was redundant.
SPEAKER_02Are you part of the Department of Redundancy department?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, adored.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Wow, this is already this is already going great, guys. Yep. All right. You're so nervous. It's adorable. I know. I am, I don't know why. Okay, so let's start with our unique style. Let's start with the subject matter. Nick, you want to start with that?
SPEAKER_05Oh, sure. I noticed a lot of one line observational one-liners. Uh I checked the satirical box. I put a little blurb, like a little dot next to improv. Like I feel like he he had some semi-prepared material for the audience. But it it was I think I think he had it the whole planned out. Like he knew what he was gonna do if they said this or they said that. Right. Yeah, they were guessing that things. That's all I really caught though for style.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. What about you want to do subject matter also? And we'll do both at once.
SPEAKER_05Okay. Uh I checked the social commentary box. Absurdist. Yes. Plenty of like conversations between letters and uh children and whatever else, or babies, you know, that kind of right. Uh and then uh ethnic slash cultural. He that's at least an honorable mention because as he said, most stick figures are black.
SPEAKER_02Oh yeah. Yeah, he he talked about Mexicans too.
SPEAKER_05So yes, he did.
SPEAKER_02That was one of the times I thought I really liked your shirt. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. All right. Sky, what did you what did you have for style and also subject matter?
SPEAKER_00Um, I put all the things that uh Nick said, but I also put musical comedy. Um, yeah. He does, you know, he tells jokes with the guitar. It's it's funny because he doesn't really use the guitar like like very musically. He just kind of plays and also tells jokes at the same time. It's almost like noodling.
SPEAKER_02Like it's almost like noodling while he's playing telling jokes, you know.
SPEAKER_00It kind of helps with the timing because you can just pause like for however long and it still fills the air and lets the last die down without it being awkward. Right.
SPEAKER_05That's a good catch. You should be on a podcast.
SPEAKER_00Umject matter, I think I put most of the the same things. Personal life, dark humor. There was a lot of dark humor, like sprinkled in. So just like just enough for uh for you to get that like oh, that was dark. But then like move on and begin to talk about letters right after. Right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, he does a good job of like that. I'll I'll get to that too. But like I had one-liners and observational. I I had satirical also, but like I sort of I sort of get confused and like try to figure out. So I had actually looked up set like satirical comedy just to be like, what exactly is satirical comedy? And I can tell you that I still don't exactly know. So um, but I checked the box uh anyway. I did I did uh same thing that you did, Sky. I did musical comedy, but then I put a dash ISH after it, so musical comedy-ish.
SPEAKER_02Uh, because he's not like there are other musical comedians that actually like we well, like like when Luca was on here and we did Bo Burnham, like Bo Burnham's a musical comedian, like he the whole the jokes are built into the music, like it's the songs, right? Exactly. Whereas he he doesn't do that, he just plays the you know harmonica and the guitar behind it while he's playing, while he's telling the same one-liners he's told. Um he actually did that same thing in the last special that we reviewed as well. And we I think we said exactly the same thing, it's like it was incidental to the jokes, it wasn't like part of the jokes, you know.
SPEAKER_00Very stylistic. Yeah. Like he keeps doing the same thing, but it's always funny.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00Professional comedian, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Uh and then and then subject matter, social commentary, um, yeah, dark humor, absurdist. I had a little bit of ethnic cultural there as well, um, for sort of the reasons that you said, Nick. All right. Let's start with our first one. I'm gonna start with you, Sky, for one content quality. So one out of ten, one to ten, how well written were the jokes and the stories? Where'd you where'd you come up on that?
SPEAKER_00Uh I put them at a nine. Um, because I feel like his his jokes and stories are like they're so relatable, but it doesn't feel like pandering. Like it doesn't feel like he's trying to be relatable, it they just are. And it's almost like it's almost like we could have come up with the jokes in a way, but the way that he like structures and tells them is like it it puts him above just a retelling in that way for me.
SPEAKER_00So I gave him a nine for that because I feel like that's something that's always drawn him to me, yeah or drawn me to him.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um Nick, what about you?
SPEAKER_05Oh I had eight, but that's because I stopped reading when I saw strong creative writing. I just gave him the high side of that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05But here hearing Skylar describe it, and when I read brilliantly written uncommon material, it's like, yeah, actually, that that's this, you know. So mine's a nine as well.
SPEAKER_02Nice. I came in right below that, so like an 8.5. I know get off the stage, keeping him out of the out of the nine nine whatever club. Um, no, I think I mean I'm right there with you guys. I think he uh, you know, he has just really, really strong, you know, strong material. He's a good writer. Um yeah. It remind it like uh it all plays very well. All right, performance and delivery.
SPEAKER_02Sky, you want to start us out on that one? It's one to ten. How effective was the comedian's stage presence and delivery? And that's the end of the question. Um sorry, I I mean delivery. Okay, yeah. So go ahead. Where'd you end up on that?
SPEAKER_00Uh I'll give him a nine there as well. I feel like uh he's he's very deadpan almost. It's not really deadpan, it's not like sad sounding, but he's kind of just like very objective sounding, and it almost makes like some of the absurdist stuff that he tells even funnier. Yeah. Because he's just talking about letters like it happened. He's like talking to the earth when he trips. Um and it you can totally visualize it with like the way he's telling it, his cadence.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, something's like that also drew me to him. Like his his the way that he, you know, his cadence when he's telling joke uh jokes is like I don't know, it it really, really keeps you engaged. So that's why I gave him a nine. I feel like he doesn't really like especially on this album, because it's like a CD album, uh first. There was a DVD, and I've I've seen clips from it. I I couldn't find the full special in its entirety in video, but from what I saw, he he felt like the jokes feel like very like just relaxed, like you're hearing a friend tell the joke about something that actually happened to him.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So it's very like calm and known. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Nick, how about you?
SPEAKER_05I I gauged him a bit more harshly for a couple of reasons. One, the recency bias. So, like our previous review of him, he was more polished. Yeah. And so I've I've sort of heard him after becoming more experienced.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Um and I think the other thing too is there were there were little comments that he made uh maybe in the first 20% of his set that because I'm an overthinker like he is, I know exactly how nervous he was. You know, and like I could almost hear him like shuffling his shoulders a little bit, like trying to relax and get in get into it um you know, to calm down and get confident.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05So I I put a six out of ten, which which is decent, but room for improvement. I'm probably being a little too harsh, maybe it's more like a seven, but I'll I'll leave it at six because this is all just made up anyway. Okay.
SPEAKER_02I what about you, Brian? I have a I gave uh I gave a nine there. Um because I think I felt like I could I could see what you're saying, Nick, but I felt like it was just like one after the other. Like I felt like it was just boom, laugh, boom, laugh, boom, laugh, you know, um, from the very beginning. Especially like, and I actually made mention of the bit, the very first bit, where he's like, coming to the stage is the person that's talking right now, Dimitri Martin, you know, and like that's the one of the things I'll say about this album, or whatever you want to call it, is that he knew that it was going to be mostly audio because he made reference to it like multiple times where he was like, Oh, these visual jokes, I can't really do those.
SPEAKER_02And he's like, or like, you know, hey, uh, you know, hey, for those of you don't know out there, uh, uh I'm making I'm making out with the cute girls in the audience right now. Uh I'm not doing anything awkward on stage, you know, like that kind of thing. Like he he knew, you know.
SPEAKER_05I also thought it was funny that he he see that was that was to me evidence that he was actually kind of nervous about the dead air. Making a joke of it, like he was he could recovered very well and he's very natural and relatable, but just yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, anyway, I still felt like he was a nine out of ten there. I mean, I just I feel like he's he was confident and it was just uh he was getting the result that he wanted and he was telling the jokes, and they were people were laughing about it. So all right. Diversity of material, one to five. Did the comedian keep it fresh and interesting? Uh I'll start this one. Um, I gave him a four on this wide range.
SPEAKER_02I think it's really difficult to not cover a lot of subjects when your jokes are like three to five seconds long and it's an hour-long CD. I mean, you're now some of them, I will say it was interesting when he would say certain things and then he would chain like chain them together. So like it would be like one joke and then the next joke and then the next joke, and that's like one grouping of jokes, but then he would go right back into like a one a true one-liner where it was like bam, and then he's just leaving that subject, you know, or that particular thing.
SPEAKER_02So um but I give him yeah, four out of five.
SPEAKER_05You tell them like in the next joke, like in the next one, and the next one. I've I've learned that those are called tags. Tags when you do the setup and the punchline, yeah, there's an optional third step called a tag where you like you sort of pile on to the punchline with another joke.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_05The same premise, the same setup.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05And the there was one where he just had like tag after tag after tag with the um the the shirt sizes and saying that you know there's we just got lazy after large and said extra and extra extra. Instead, we could have done wow, or yeah, it's like slow down.
SPEAKER_02Extra large. Whoa.
SPEAKER_05Quit it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_05And then like then he went to American. Yeah, American. He waited for the audience to laugh and love it.
SPEAKER_02And then he said Western American.
SPEAKER_05Western American and they'll go, ooh, yeah. They booed. It's like, oh, do you have a size in Michigan? Yeah, we always jump to Ohio in this stuff. Like he just tag, tag, tag. You know, he got reaction after reaction off the same premise and punchline.
SPEAKER_02That's interesting. I did not know that. We might need to incorporate that into our score sheet somehow. Nah, who cares? Anyway, Sky.
SPEAKER_00Um I initially gave him a five, but I feel like I'm more moved to a four. Um because I I gave him a five because he was so good at like keeping the vibe uh consistent and still keeping it interesting with so many different topics. Like he would just jump between topic, topic, topic. Yeah. Um at certain points, like there would be certain tracks on the album that would just be like five minutes of just like completely one-liners, two-liners. Yeah. And he would still keep getting reactions from the crowd despite having like vastly different subject matter.
SPEAKER_00So I don't know. I'm between a four and a five on that one, I feel like.
SPEAKER_05Okay. There is four point five is is one of those unwritten options directly.
SPEAKER_02It's unwritten and available. Okay, four point five.
SPEAKER_00Four million dollars.
SPEAKER_04You can use decimals, right?
SPEAKER_00There's one of these on the board behind me. Sorry, that's a visual thing.
SPEAKER_04It's an audio on the podcast.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. You might be suffering from carbon monoxide poisoning. Minoxide. Anyway, okay, the listeners are gonna be like, what are they talking about? Anyway, Nick.
SPEAKER_05Hey, in inside jokes or inside.
SPEAKER_02Right, exactly.
SPEAKER_05I was about to take a drink from my dihydrogen monoxide, but um what what were we talking about again? Number of three diversity of material.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Uh I also said four out of five. Wide range kept it fresh. Although I don't know what it would take to make it a five. Like, I I think I'm just kind of hedging. I didn't really notice any stagnation. Um but I didn't like end the thing thinking, man, there was no stagnation at all. It was very diverse.
SPEAKER_02It's the hard that's the hardest part about this, is like there's like this invisible barrier of like perfection where you're like, oh, if I give them a five, that means they're perfect. Like, were they perfect? Is like anybody gonna be perfect? And like, yeah, I guess in certain situations or certain um, you know, uh like different whatever it's called, like uh pieces of this scorecard, but you know.
SPEAKER_05So I can't solve the larger problem, but in this specific case, I'm gonna adjust my score to 4.8.
SPEAKER_02Okay. 4.8. That's very close. Very, very close to perfect. There was like a slight amount of stagnation for like 30 seconds, and Nick lost interest and looked at his phone, you know, or something like that. But I enjoyed those. There's that one time when I looked at my phone and I just couldn't, I couldn't. It was he went on for like 26 seconds on one joke and I couldn't do it, you know.
SPEAKER_00Like I like the moments when there was silence. At least like for a second, you know, he had to move around or something, and he was like, Yeah, take the mic off the stand, yeah, look at Justin, and I'll be like, All right, now it's gonna be funny. And he still gets like an audience reaction from literally him doing nothing. Right. They're just you know, he's good at warming up the crowd.
SPEAKER_05Oh, he did that. He had a really good crowd. Yeah, he had a really warm crowd in the audio for sure.
SPEAKER_02And then the last one, I feel like making reference to the previous episode, but like he did a bit about like he went over and like drank it, drank out of a like a glass of water, and the audience had a reaction to it. And he was like, Oh, my my water drinking bit did awesome.
SPEAKER_05It killed, you know, like well, and wasn't that the part that was over the loudspeaker too?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, like it was his right. It was supposed to be like his inner monologue, and so it's like, you know, it's like I wonder I'm really thirsty right now. I should go drink some water. And it's like, you know, and the audience like laughed about it or something, or clapped, or something like that. You know, there's a audience reaction. Anyway.
SPEAKER_05Speaking of inside jokes, now we're making references to a special that our guest hasn't seen.
SPEAKER_02You gotta go. Well, that's true. That's true. That just means other people have to watch the specials and listen to the podcast.
SPEAKER_00You know, that's I've got to catch up on my Dimitri Martin backlog.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. He's got quite a bit. He's he's like some people don't put out like aren't proliferating material so much, and he does. He puts out a lot.
SPEAKER_05So he said he has he has quite a bit. Like a bit. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02He certainly does. Okay. Impact and memorability. One to ten. How well did this performance stick with you? Sky?
SPEAKER_00I gave him eight an eight out of ten. Yeah. Um I and I I didn't go higher because I have seen some other or like heard some other Dimitri Martin albums, and I feel like there wasn't like anything that was specifically memorable about this one compared to other things that I've seen from him. Which I guess there's not a lot of that, like now that I say that aloud, just in comedy in general, I feel like most albums are pretty similar.
SPEAKER_00But um, you know, you could put Dimitri Martin on shuffle, and it would still just be as funny, but it's not as like, oh, this one was on the album stand-up comedian from 2012. Right. Um, so that's why I didn't go higher, but it was still very strong and very memorable, as it says in the seven to eight range on the score sheet.
SPEAKER_02That is also interesting, too, because there's a there are certain comedians who you can put on shuffle, like, and there's other comedians that it wouldn't like there's so many callbacks or so many references, or like it's a uh it's a grouping of jokes that goes in a specific order, and like his, you can put him on shuffle all day long, and it's like you're okay, you know.
SPEAKER_00Um so you know, and that's kind of skipping ahead to the next the next category with the callbacks, but yeah, I know I I feel like that um that that is like shuffle ability in a way. Yeah, not calling back to the the rest of the set because when we get to the next one, we'll call back to this conversation, okay?
unknownNice.
SPEAKER_00I'll put it in the notes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Okay. Um Nick, what about you? Impact and memorability.
SPEAKER_05I also put an eight out of ten. That's and in fact I had it at six, but as we're recollecting on it, like, oh yeah, and I'm like, I'm ri recalling different pieces. So it there are some standout moments, right? So um strong memorable set.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Oh, actually, standout moments was six, four to six range, but still it's much stronger and memorable than I thought it was.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but everything in seven, everything in I mean a seven to eight includes everything in one to three and four to six, and then it also includes strong memorable set. That's how it works.
SPEAKER_00So it's both strong memorable and it's what performance.
SPEAKER_05What performance? Oh yeah. Oh wait, hold on. I I remember strong and memorable.
SPEAKER_00It's in standout moments.
SPEAKER_05In fact, it was unforgettable, highly impactful.
SPEAKER_02All right. I what about your score, Brian? I ended up as an eight there, strong memorable set. I think that there are a lot of jokes as we get into it later. Uh a lot of jokes that I would I don't know if I would retell, but I'll steal. Like I'll I'll just throw them out there in in conversation.
SPEAKER_05And like the bathroom.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, you know, try to wash your hands like some crappy magician.
SPEAKER_02Yes, exactly. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. You know when somebody moves a millimeter, you know. Uh yeah, so eight, eight out of ten. I thought it was memorable. But also, he is tough to if you like listen to all of his things, it would be really tough to like say, oh, what what album was that from? Because it's so all of them are so like similar, and like not the jokes aren't similar, but the joke the style and everything else, it would be just really, really difficult to like single out, as opposed to like a storytelling comedian like Pat and Oswald or something like that.
SPEAKER_02Like you know, there's specific stories. Sometimes the stories are like tagged to times and things like that. So anyway.
SPEAKER_05I I think it's also a function of your fandom of the comedian. Yes. If you're such a fan that you're d deliberately pulling out certain albums or specials, and you know, you've listened so much that you can tell them apart.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. It also might be my own bias because I have like a playlist of like ever since I mean, for a long time, I've had a playlist of comedy that I just play on shuffle. So I hear things all out of order all day long. And so I don't connect them to an album per se, just because I don't rarely will. I mean, except for this podcast, like I'll I won't listen to an album like from start to finish. Sometimes I do because I feel like I want to feel the flow of it, you know, like a Pat and Oswald album.
SPEAKER_02I'll listen to a Pat N Oswald album from front to end because like front to back, front to end, beginning to end. That's how you say that. Um from beginning to end. Because it end to back. You know, from end to back. That's a saying, right, Nick? Anyway.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, you made it. Congratulations.
SPEAKER_02Those words have now been shown together. It's in use now, it's in the lexicon, it's in the zeitgeist, it's in the whatever else you want to call it. But no, yeah, I think I don't even know what my point was. Let's go on to the next thing. Callback effective. Callback effectiveness one to five. How well were the jokes referred back to? Nick, since it's your favorite subject, I'm gonna let you start on this one.
SPEAKER_05And I I did a disservice to Dimitri this time. I only counted one callback that I noticed, and I didn't go back. I I didn't go back and figure it out. I didn't write it down.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I just maybe Sky can save us then.
SPEAKER_00Maybe can I catch that callback if you caught one? Because I unfortunately did give him a one. Um, which I made up for in the the personal bonus points at the end. So it didn't spoil. I know. Well, okay, yes. Sorry. I assumed your your podcast fans would be familiar with the score sheet. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05But we're gonna get so many new listeners from you know your clout and yeah, stardom. All your all your friends and such that they won't they won't know. But they do now.
SPEAKER_02So Nick, did you what did you rate him?
SPEAKER_05Because I'm pretty sure there was the one, I put a 3.5.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_05Some effective callbacks slash well executed.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_05It's like right right there. The the one that he used, I remember liking it. I just don't remember what it is.
SPEAKER_02I I give him I also gave him a one. And because I could not find one. I could not, I like I listened to the album multiple times before we did this podcast, and I've listened to every bit multiple times for years, but I listened to the album in order, I'll say three and a half times before we uh before I filled out my card, my scorecard, and I can't think of one. And I was lit, and at one point I listened to one specifically because I'm like thinking of this question in my head, thinking, okay, there's gotta be a call.
SPEAKER_02Like, there's you can't be a comedian and not use a callback. Like, come on, there has to be a callback, right? But I do remember in the last one that we reviewed, he only had like I want to say there was only one that I counted in the last one as well. So he's he just sort of he sort of I don't think is a callback comedian. Like one-liners don't lend themselves to that because and I think it's because the subject matter so like as we already said, diversity of material, like it's so widely varied that it's difficult to like tie back to a specific joke for anything because it's you're like you're on to the next subject.
SPEAKER_02He's he goes over so many, like, like I can count. Let's see. Sorry. I mean just like looking at some of the one-liner things, anti-aging cream on a baby, telemarket calling out sick, rice nipples, bungee jumping being born, ex-girlfriend to an XL girlfriend, battle of the bands, blind wearing blindfold, deaf, what is this?
SPEAKER_05Deaf deaf eating with their hands full of deaf talk with food in hands.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, deaf talking with food in hands, separate but equal, passive, aggressive versus aggressive, passive. I mean, how do you make callbacks to those?
SPEAKER_00Like, you can't like what there's no story for those to tell me.
SPEAKER_02It would be so hard. It's alteration. You can try to. I bet Nick could, but you know, you know, other people I will find it.
SPEAKER_05I will find it and text you.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm sure you will.
SPEAKER_05But there would there was someone in the comments will get it.
SPEAKER_02Right, exactly. Smash the like button, guys.
SPEAKER_00Leave a comment down below. Leave a comment down below. Your favorite Dutch Martin callback.
SPEAKER_02Right? All three of them in his entire Instagram, LPM pod, and DM us. Slide into our DMs, okay? All right. Okay, so callback effectiveness medium. Uh, how about style quality? One to ten. How effective was the comedian's style? I'm gonna start with Sky.
SPEAKER_00Uh, I thought you were gonna start based on the start of that sentence. Um I I gave him an eight. Um he was he was uh clearly a professional. Um but you know, there was there was obviously those moments where uh like Nick was talking about, where it was like you could kind of feel what he was feeling for a second before he looped it back in. It wasn't like flawless. Um so that's why I I didn't go into the the nine to ten range. But maybe that's just because his style is so casual that it doesn't really feel like there's much more to go.
SPEAKER_00But anyway, I gave him an eight. Okay. Nick.
SPEAKER_05So to me this felt like one of his earlier specials, like in his career. Um and I but at the same time, like he he did really well with for all the points that I made. So I I couldn't pick between style still developing and clearly a professional. Like I didn't just felt like he was in between those two. So I I gave a six and a half uh you know, the sixth out of style still developing and the seventh were clearly a professional.
SPEAKER_02Six, seven. Six seven, six, seven. Okay. Every every single that's isn't that that should be on the bingo card for our podcast. I think we do say that pretty much in every podcast, you know, episode.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, it's it's my goal to use it so much that it dies, yeah, and then I will continue to use it so much because I'm the one keeping it alive.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, obscurity and rarity. That's how you make things funny, you know? All right, like a snake. Right.
SPEAKER_03Exactly.
SPEAKER_02I I ended up as an eight with that. Um, clearly a professional. I was with Sky on this one. I love Dimitri Martin. I think he's really awesome and he makes me laugh. Uh no matter how many times I listen to him. Um and I think his style is very effective, just not absolutely perfect. So yeah. All right. Let's see, how are we doing? We're like halfway through and we're halfway through our time.
SPEAKER_02I mean, we're halfway through our time. So timing and pacing is important. Look at that. Look at that. You see that segue that I did? Segue. Seg C'est. I think it's pronounced. So timing and pacing one to five. Was the pacing effective for humor delivery? It's an interesting choice of words, whoever wrote this. All right. I'm gonna start this one.
SPEAKER_02I I thought strong, well-timed delivery for his style of comedy, timing is extremely important because it has to be delivered in like a boom, boom, boom kind of thing. You have to be able to like listen to the audience, and even those ones where you're talking about the tags, Nick, it was like almost like he'd do it and then he will wait like the exact amount of time. So he was like, he would do it, and then he would like listen for the audience to like start to like trail off a little bit and then do the next one, and then list the audit for trail off and do it again, you know.
SPEAKER_02So I think he had strong, well-timed delivery. I gave him a four out 4.5 out of five, so not quite a five. Sky, what about you?
SPEAKER_00Uh, I ended up with a five with like similar reasoning. Like, I feel like it it takes a lot of like audience awareness to be able to provide the the pacing that he did. And like sometimes it would just be the funniest thing about the joke is is literally the timing of it, like the way he said it in what context, based on you know what the audience vibe is on the bell curve of laughter. Yeah. Um so I give him a vibe there.
SPEAKER_00I feel like that's an area that he shines, at least for me.
SPEAKER_05Nick four out of five. Okay. I don't have a lot to add there, just strong well-time delivery. And I think the only reason I didn't give him a five was because of those kind of awkward moments. Like he he sort of had things to say and he knew how to recover or sort of keep keep it up in the air, but you know, there was just a touch of choppiness there that I figured I could honor with a a dean.
SPEAKER_05The most most I don't disagree with Skylar at all.
SPEAKER_02Most awkward was the uh when he was like, Hey, how you doing to the person in the audience.
SPEAKER_05Oh yeah, and like I imagine there was a fist bump, and he's like, There was my crowd crowd work or something like that.
SPEAKER_02And then he's like crowdworking like yeah, that was it. It's the best. But I had to imagine it. Yeah, exactly. You had to use your mind's eye. Uh all right, good. Physicality and expressiveness, one to five. How well did they embody their material? This one was a little bit difficult because obviously we're doing this in audio format, but I think you can get from the audio somebody embodying their material. So, Sky, what do you think?
SPEAKER_00Uh I I said like a well, I initially didn't know that there was a 0.5 system, but I feel like now retroactively, I'll I'll say a 3.5. Um, you know, in between some physical, but the the physical, you know, elements and vibes that he drew out were strong and well used when he readed them. Um and honestly, it with the the previous category, the the the timing of his jokes, you could kind of it gives even a a CD listener or an audio listener like the time to envision what he's doing on the stage.
SPEAKER_00Um, even if he's not really doing anything super physical comedy, he you know, you can kind of imagine how he's moving about the joke in a way. Yeah. Even just vibes alone. So I feel like that's like 3.5 material.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Okay. Nick.
SPEAKER_05Sky talked me into a four. I had him at a three. Um just knowing how much I was able to visualize thanks to some of the, I guess the sound engineering or also his descriptive qualities. Even the audience engagement, like the the kind of laughter and the timing of their laughter, like I could picture what was going on. Almost like a bat that can see in the dark.
SPEAKER_05Weird and satisfying.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_05I'm a flying mammal. I'm flying mammal.
SPEAKER_02I'm I uh I'm gonna go right between you guys at a 3.75.
SPEAKER_05Hey, this is our moment. 3.75. You don't have to edge in.
SPEAKER_02No, 3.75. I'm going right between you guys. You could have your distinct number. It's okay. 3.75. I'm doing it.
SPEAKER_05Here we are, Skylar and I just sitting side by side on the couch, and Brian sits on our laps.
SPEAKER_02Like I'm like a crazy, crazy golden retriever that just sits wherever they want, you know, and just let me in. 3.75. So some physical elements well used, but also close to strong physical performance. And I didn't have the benefit like Sky did of doing the seeing the visual clips because I actually looked for some, but I couldn't really find any. And but I imagine that it's similar to the last one that we did.
SPEAKER_02Like his his dead panty way uh is like sort of patented for him, you know what I mean? Like, I think the only thing he's done is he's probably gotten more confident and he's probably got richer um in the last whatever 15 years since this was since he made this. So all right. How about personal appeal? Is this comedian your cup of tea? Nick?
SPEAKER_05He got a nine out of ten on this one. I I gave him a seven out of ten previously. Okay. The overthinker one.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05But just his what's his I want to be best friends with him. I don't know if it's just kind of the thing that builds or I relate more with the past Dimitri than the present Dimitri.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05But just some of the observations I've and and the way he thought about things and delivered them, I relate to even more than his more current material.
SPEAKER_00Excellent.
SPEAKER_02Sky.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I also give him a nine out of ten. Because I I think that his style is so like personal, like it's just like he's a dude telling jokes. His this the special is literally called stand-up comedian. Right. So it's like it's it's like casual self-awareness in that way.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00Like, I I think that contributes to you know the the parasocialness that I you know I want to go uh uh driving a car with him and maybe get coffee like the show.
SPEAKER_05Right. Wait, we need to add parasocial to the bingo cards. Parasocial.
SPEAKER_00That is parasocial.
SPEAKER_05That's the word in the Zach guys.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it is. In the lexicon.
SPEAKER_05When he was talking to the people from the future, I was like, oh, he's talking to me now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, right, exactly. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_05And it's like we have far fewer robots than you do.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_05And space travel is not as prevalent as it is in this. You know, pretty close.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. He's like, I don't even know if it's a CD. And you're like, and I'm like, it's not. It's not. We're streaming it. We're streaming it right now. It's not even a CD. That's pretty awesome.
SPEAKER_05You don't own me thing, and we're happy.
SPEAKER_02I was only from 2012, too. I give him a nine out of ten in this category. I want to be best friends. Actually, what's funny to me is when he tells jokes, I feel like I started thinking about other people in my life because there are people that I've met throughout my life that are like this in regular life. They're not comedians. They just say weird stuff. They'll just come up and they'll be like, you know, they'll just like, you know, you ever notice there's a line that where the like I don't know, just random things that where you're like, it's not fun.
SPEAKER_02funny but like he's turned those things into being funny whereas like you've known somebody like this that says weird facts like you ever notice that we build houses for birds and they're the one of the only animals that birds that builds houses for themselves like isn't that pretty arrogant like you know that's like actually wait Nick you're that person for me you're the you're you're that person mildly amusing mildly amusing that's as high as I can get I can't get no i guess I didn't mean mildly amusing I was saying I was saying we saying weird stuff every once in a while just like you ever notice this or whatever anyway uh yeah still nine out of ten because like I feel like if you hung out with him all the time you would just be cracking up all the time like wait what what did you just say you know and that was interesting so yeah he's cool um all right how about innovative techniques did the comedian bring something new or unique one to ten is the score I'll start this one I gave him an eight out of ten uh you know it's weird because like there's been other people who are like one liner there's been other comedians who are like one liner comedians and things like that.
SPEAKER_02I just think that he's done it he's packaged it and done it in a different way in a better way than a lot of them have. So um because as I said even though subject matter like moved along the tracks and everything changed you didn't feel like you felt like this was a cohesive thing like that was put together like in one album even though it w and other one liners you don't feel like that you feel like oh that was a good joke. Oh there's a completely separate joke oh there's another separate joke and like I feel like they're less cohesive in the one-liner approach and I feel like that's where he brings innovative or like you know something that is a new technique to this one liner type delivery.
SPEAKER_00So eight out of 10 Sky Yeah I I agree with all that I I ended up giving him a seven because I feel like um you know it's it's all similar in that way and it's still in the highly innovative bracket. But I went with a seven because it it does feel like people you know the the fact that people have done this before and and other people still do this uh you know in this specific bracket it doesn't shine well in the scorecard but I feel like part of his appeal is that he is telling the jokes and in the way that he tells the jokes uh and not as much the actual techniques and and you know joke telling abilities in a vacuum.
SPEAKER_00So I ended up giving him a seven there but that doesn't detract from his you know personal appeal and the excellence in other categories.
SPEAKER_02I think also I mean I didn't mention this before and then I'll go to you Nick but um I feel like just like there are certain people who have certain things like for instance like Michael Jordan was like specifically built to play basketball. Like he had he had he not only did he have the talent and he practiced but he has he had the thing right and Dimitri Martin I think is specifically built like he sort of looks like he would deliver these kinds of jokes like he looks like his demeanor and the way his like in the Dimitri demeanor the Dimitri demeanor you know and I don't know if you if Sky remembers this from one of the other albums but like he had um Will Forte on there like Will Forte was the guy one of the guys yeah and he had this whole bit with Will Forte and so like uh but one of the things that he had it he had like a bat sort of bad haircut or whatever and he said yeah I just went to my um I went to my barber and said yeah can you give me the gay beetle look um because his hair was sort of like cut like the beetles but like he said yeah gay beetle please you know like and it's just like stuff like that like I'd feel like other you know other comedians make fun of their appearance but like I don't know his just like his like the way he is like he looks like he would make these kinds of jokes I don't know if that makes sense but anyway Nick what about you on innovative techniques I also gave him an eight partly partly favoring him because this is earlier in his career so like this would have been fresher you know before he sort of established the the style yeah and I think he he does have his own little niche for the the one liners and the observational in that he he has like observations he kind of gravitates towards like he's very much a a word nerd yeah and a bird nerd that which it would include the trees so you know like the tree houses the ultimate power move you're you're making the tree carry its dead friend you know or you're um or like you were talking about the bird houses yeah um maybe it has to do but even like he with his nose and he talked about his nose and yeah he made drawings that that implies that his nose is like a bird beak.
SPEAKER_05Yeah I think maybe there's some trauma he's working through being called a bird something when he's oh you think so I think so that's interesting that's that's my psychoanalytical hat that's not that's not the podcast.
SPEAKER_02That's for our other podcast called the psychoanalytical channels of stand-up comedians it's very niche it's avant garde like really highly innovative it's high really it's super innovative psychoanalyzes per minute PPM right you know the P in psychology is one of those silent words it just likes to sit in there I won't say anything with the others well let me come along we'll mess with foreigners you know let's see that gee I'm in the middle right there that's so as promised we're butchering callbacks to our comedy heroes exactly right okay this one I have a big question mark for this so I'll say I'm gonna I'm gonna throw this one to Nick first because uh I don't know exactly what to do with it so cinematic quality usually we're we have a visual aspect so one to five how well was the performance filmed and edited um Nick what what do you want to do with this one um I gave it a three out of five the filming and editing was not a distraction um I suppose I also enjoyed the way that it looked even though it was just uh tiles on a smartphone right cycling through but the album cover was nice to look at while listening nice fine yeah I think I think the edit like the sound quality though was really good like you could hear the audience I felt like I was in the room um I was having it was easier for me to have a good time because I could tell everyone there was having a good time it it put me there you know so yeah that's that's counts for something I think if not half the points maybe uh four fifths of the points yeah sky yeah I I dig the uh the warmth of like the venue and and the the way it was recorded um that it like stood out to me it felt like a small crowd which is interesting because I I saw some clips um and he was actually in like kind of a huge room oh um which surprised me maybe the CD and the the DVD were recorded at different uh different times um but it it was interesting like he he made all those comments at the beginning in the album and uh in the the clip that I saw of the intro and the in the DVD version he didn't make any of those um which is interesting so that's something to you know touch on but I still I still put him at a three point or a three out of five middle middle of the road wasn't a distraction you know he's uh dude telling jokes on a stage yeah to a bunch of people laughing this for me it was one of the like mind's eye kind of things like I've listened to this album so much in order out of order whatever like I have a visual it's like when you read a book like where you're like you're visualizing how that might look or what that you know what's happening while the person's doing especially if you know what the person looks like and so to me that's how I treated this and so I said I gave him a three out of five um filming and editing was not a distraction basically uh you know he did like well on stage everything was the way they're supposed to do the the venue was a fire hazard so it was really good for stand-up comedy um yeah and I did agree with him that stand-up comedy on a beach was probably not you know not as good you know but all right now to our psychology there too namesake right exactly laughs per minute which is not literally laughs per minute but so that because literally laughs per minute would be L L PM not just LPM so this is just so this is just LPM guys and this is out of 15 uh how frequently do you feel that the comedian generated laughs and I'm gonna go with our guest for Sky what would you say I uh I gave him a perfect 15 honestly nice um I I feel like there wasn't even like uh a point where I felt like the the crowd wasn't at least ready to laugh and he took advantage of that too um you know even before he got out on stage he was telling jokes and and making the crowd laugh and uh I I think even in those like silent moments awkward moments like I said before it was like he he found a way to continue getting the audience to laugh even though he was between segments or between jokes.
SPEAKER_00He's like scrolling through his little like idea panel he was like yeah I'm on the CD I can't tell a visual joke wait here's one and then he'll go he'll just like tell a joke. Right. And you know even the act of doing that so candidly is is funny and it was to the audience too. So I feel like you know that could have very much been like a an awkward moment if he freaked out a little bit about it. But that's that's why I gave him a a perfect 15 because I feel like there wasn't a single moment where I like even I as a listener wasn't like ready to laugh at something he was about to say.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Nick Yeah my my score's pretty high too um there were plenty of times where I I laughed out loud which is kind of rare for me I'm I'm often mildly amused or I have tried my own hand at being funny so much throughout my life that I I can kind of see where the joke is going and you know get to it maybe before the comedian does but plenty of times where I was laughing out loud and like like we've said before the the crowd was very warm which made it warm for me.
SPEAKER_05And just just because there were like those few almost awkward moments not quite awkward I took it down one notch so it's a 14 out of 15 for me. But it it's still about like a 93 point three three three three three percent I wouldn't know don't do I don't know I don't know math.
SPEAKER_02I did the math oh okay you did it okay yeah look at that okay I'm with you on that I no it was my smartphone I did same thing Nick I was at a 14 out of 15 for that exact reason same same exact reason I think um with this kind of style of comedy it's if you're not getting almost constant laughter then you're doing it wrong like this type of like short bam bam bam bam punchline punchline punchline punchline like approach I mean that's the whole album like there's no he didn't tell one story in this whole thing like he didn't like slow it down and even actually in the other one I think that he did I think there was actually some stories that he told um if I remember correctly but in this one none it was just like joke joke joke like it might be like joke tag tag but it's like literally it's meant to get a quick laugh right after the last laugh you know so that there isn't a chance for the audience to recover really and so um but again there were a couple moments in there where he had some slow things and he even recognized him as so as we've mentioned so 14 out of 15.
SPEAKER_00All right now for the fun stuff oh look at we're for we're 57 minutes in we get to do the fun stuff guys aren't you excited anyway it's 57 minutes you know what that means let's have some fun yeah 57 minutes all right uh I'll go with I'll go with Sky first what was your favorite joke or bit in the special um I did like the guitar jokes I feel like that always like stood out to me when I think about Dimitri Martin I was like just telling jokes with the guitar.
SPEAKER_00But one thing that I I really enjoyed now like when revisiting it was like when he would make a mistake or something would happen in the audience and he would just like immediately draw attention to it and just like like it was part of the you know part of the special part of the script. Yeah I think my my favorite moment honestly in the whole special was um where he was like I wish there was a smoke detector shit. Yeah he like forgot the the T in the word and then and he like did a whole bit with like him missing the T was like so confident in the middle of the word that was good.
SPEAKER_00I really liked that part so I feel like that was honestly my favorite like specific joke in the special um that that's probably what I'm gonna think of now when I think of that like yeah in addition to the guitar jokes nice Nick what about you I I I liked two two things.
SPEAKER_05I'm putting a page from Brian but I'm only gonna go with two there was the the script breaking in um the dressing room like when when somebody'll ask you doing okay in there and like all the different things he's at times thought to say yes and like one of them's like no I'm not doing okay at all do you you got a belt? Yeah yeah you know like whoa that was some super dark humor. Yeah yeah um and then the other was I feel like there was some potential there but he just sort of let it be that it it's sometimes hard to know what is and isn't gay um and and it was the boxing he then he went into boxing because like you got two dudes but touching each other in their underwear fighting over a belt.
SPEAKER_00Right yeah which may have been the callback no that wasn't the callback right um so those those were the ones that stood out to me that we haven't already covered I'll say yeah barely my favorite okay what about you mine was uh another dark one actually ironically a suicide joke the murder suicide uh where he's like people that are people that uh do a murder suicide aren't thinking about the afterlife and then it's like bam you're dead bam I'm dead oh shit this is gonna be so awkward forever like oh hi oh no that just like I don't know that just that makes me crack up all right um most retellable yeah most retellable um Nick I'll start you with start with you on that one it it's interesting the things that you can say during sex like you can say yes and you can even also you can also say yeah but yep is off the table you know there's so many things affirmative things you can't say like affirmative or adequate you know it's yeah that's my retellable okay that's as good as I did that's as good as you did all right yep Sky see I had a actually wait hold on a second I think we should do this Nick sorry to interrupt I think we should do this like when we do the most retellable that you actually have to yes like you should just launch into the retelling of the joke not just say this is my favorite anyway I won't make you do that Sky you go what's your what was your favorite retellable joke see I didn't even pick one so I would have ruined your bit immediately but um I I literally just said like there's so many one liners that I feel like could rattle off but I liked the one that that that you like rebrought up the the retellable like uh the the bathroom one oh yeah like why don't these things yeah why don't these things tell you uh when they're not working it just look like a crappy musician and the bathroom for a few minutes I definitely will use in different contexts I definitely will use yeah that is a um solution to a problem that doesn't exist like literally I could people will say stuff and I'll just be like yeah that's a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.
SPEAKER_02What are you talking about? Like you know what I mean? So um yeah no I love that bit though because he that one's good because he ties together like multiple things. So he'll be like like he it's like and also he personifies it because he's like hey you know um you know how like when somebody needs a paper towel in the bathroom and he's like yeah they reach out and they get it and just take it and he's like yeah we're gonna change all that like just like yeah he's like we're gonna use lasers and you know all this stuff I just anyway you know I I always love that bit.
SPEAKER_05Um my my honorable mention retellable would be the when whenever I am surrounded by flies is when I most feel like shit.
SPEAKER_02Yeah exactly all right mine is uh and this is just because I think I could use it a lot is I was reading the back of a package and it said made with natural and artificial flavors. I'm pretty sure that's all the flavors you could just drop the natural and artificial just say flavors at that point. Made with flavors. Yeah and he's like what else do we have like supernatural flavors? Like what the so I really really like that and I'll steal it um and then I'll give credit afterwards when after I get the laugh that is the way um I'll do a couple of honorable mentions though um saying your age before something versus after something like I'm 43 years old I want a sandwich I want a sandwich I'm 43 years old uh we got an idiot up here idiot up here that wants a sandwich I just did the same thing as DTC I couldn't say idiot what the anyway um if wait what does that make you exactly is that a true idiot test you can't even say idiot please also for from now on from now on not for now on from now on you guys should every sing every single opportunity you get just say yeah how long has the word anniversary been around seems like something we should be keeping track of you know just like say that to people randomly and just look just see what awkward stares you get you know so anyway that is that is it that is the good is why I couldn't pick one because it was just like there are so many like that where it's just like you could just slip those into a conversation to be honest.
SPEAKER_02Like it's so conversational in tone and in vibes like oh and then the the last one same thing is like I'm a man of my word and that word is unreliable I think that's part of the guitar yeah bit yeah exactly all right let's do the final tally uh do you have a final tally Sky uh yeah okay tell us break it down for us is it like uh uh summarize yeah I mean I I got my score out of a hundred uh I gave him a uh eighty nine um okay that's uh that's 82 from my score sheet and then a plus seven in in vibes because I just enjoy him in his in his album and his yeah uh comedy content nice Nick looks like he's still calculating so I will go first uh I gave my points calculation from the sheet was a 77.25 and then I added five and I said because he's cool so eighty two point two five is what I gave him as a final score okay Nick what about you I had 75.8 yeah but because of vibes I added six seven points so it's 81.8 and 82.8 simultaneously yeah six seven I was I was gonna add 20 points because I like them so much but I I just love the the bit I guess I could add 67 points that's six oh jeez true yeah I give them 146 the uh the leaderboards and comedians that you'll have right the wiki's gonna go crazy about that yeah no no well highest rated comedian ever on last for a minute podcast that tracks yeah well that was awesome anyone mate yep what else anything else I think that's it I think that's all we have good job raising Skyler good job raising me thank you dad straight up straight up uh straight up on comedians you know what I mean just that's what I did to my kids is like they were just in the car in the car seats and I'm just like listen to this you know just you didn't have an iPod to listen oh I did have an iPod we did have iPods back then I said iPod I meant iPad oh okay I'm sorry yeah we probably had an iPad too but anyway all right that's it thank you Sky for coming and visiting us and thank you for having me on the on the last for minute trademark podcast trademark I'll promote the episode and everything yeah you gotta get listeners to see yeah get some get some get some of your get some of your college friends to come on board for like two middle aged men that talk about comedy you know I saw Nick Nick Nick's face when I said middle aged he's like what shut up changing the world with comedy right exactly exactly all right well in the uh tradition I don't have to end so until next time we're out until then like subscribe yeah bye
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
Nick and Bryan welcome Brian Metzger to discuss Nanette.
Nick and Bryan welcome Marshall Couch to overthink Demetri Martin!
Dorey Nolan checks in to talk Jeff Dunham hilariousness
Nick and Bryan welcome Matt Pryor to talk "Raw" with them!
Bryan and Nick chat with fellow Toastmaster Tabatha Marks about Jerry Seinfeld's special "23 Hours to Kill"