Send us Fan Mail Episode summary CPR breach, citizenship screening & Ukraine protection: Kalpita and guest Maite discuss Denmark’s major CPR data breach, the proposed screening of citizenship applicants for anti-democratic views, and tighter temporary protection rules for some Ukrainians, examining what these developments could mean for internationals’ privacy, rights and future in Denmark. Topics 01:32 - Denmark’s CPR Data Breach 11:32 - Citizenship Screening & Free Speech 27:23 - Ukraine’s Temporary Protection Rules Our team Cohosts: Maite - https://www.linkedin.com/in/maitecristinall/ and Kalpita - https://www.linkedin.com/in/kalpitabhosale/ Podcast Operational Manager: Bence - www.linkedin.com/in/bence-bodogan-b3830b5b Audio Editor: Jose Graphic Designer: Sariah - www.linkedin.com/in/sariah-romero YouTube: Ahmet - https://www.linkedin.com/in/ahmet-akkoc/ 👀 LWID Substack: English -Romanian - Polish - Spanish - Turkish - Italian - German - Hungarian - Ukrainian 🛍️ LWID merchandise: https://last-week-in-denmark.tpopsite.com/shop ❓ Email:lastweekdk@gmail.com Follow: https://www.instagram.com/last_week_in_denmark/ https://www.facebook.com/lastweekindenmark https://www.linkedin.com/company/lastweekindenmark https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC74z1nBOfol1EiPxHPHiHnw website: https://lwid.dk/ 🎵 Music,Jack Leatherbarrow @ Wizmedia: https://wiz-media.co.uk/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
KalpitaWelcome to a new episode of Last Week in Denmark. Your CPR number is probably exposed, and your opinions could affect your citizenship, if you're interested in Danish citizenship, that is. And Denmark is tightening protection rules for Ukrainians. Maybe that could extend to other people as well. Who gets to feel safe, belong, and call Denmark home? These are the topics we are unpacking this week, and one of the biggest debates on immigration I'm your host, Kalpita.
KalpitaWelcome to Last Week in Denmark podcast. Each week, we talk through some of the biggest stories and developments from the past week in Denmark, with a focus on how they affect internationals living here. So if you are an international living in Denmark or thinking about moving here, welcome home. We're so glad you're here. If you're a first-time listener, we've got five full seasons in our back catalog for you to explore, and now we are back with a new episode every week during Season Six. Joining me this week is Maite.
KalpitaHow are you, Maite? Welcome.
MaiteThank you, Kalpita. It is so nice to join you on the podcast. I've been listening to you for, um, since I arrived in Denmark and got to know the podcast, so this is an exciting meet for me.
KalpitaNice to record with you as well. This is our first episode together.
MaiteExciting.
KalpitaSo the first story, obviously, is the digital security that was compromised last week, and it's been all over the world. To think of, Denmark has about 6 million citizens, but there were 8.8 million records stolen of CPR. The CPR breach exposed information relating to registered people, including former residents and some dead people as well. But how dangerous it is really.
KalpitaThe distinction in the story is what happened, what the government has proposed, and what remains undecided. And that distinction is especially important when we speak about citizenship and also when we then touch upon the Ukrainian protection rules. This was an unauthorized access incident, which was confirmed by the authorities on the 5th of October, and it's unauthorized parties access names, addresses, CPR numbers, and other information relating to 8.8 million registered, including current residents, former residents, and deceased people.
KalpitaAnd it's basically that the CPR system holds data on approximately 11 million registered people. So that's quite a major breach. Did you read about this, Maite?
MaiteYeah, and what I thought was quite interesting was that they realized that they had harvested all this information because every company that has access to the CPR-
KalpitaMm-hmm
Maitethey pay for each search. So if I go there and I need to do a loan or sort, some sort of thing, and they say, "Okay, let me find this person's information in the CPR registry," then they pay actually to access that information. And so then the billing person realized there was a really big invoice coming from this small Danish company, and they said, "Okay, this is strange. It's out of the ordinary." And that's why they realized only at the beginning of the month, I think it was 1st or 2nd of October, that they realized, but this had been happening for 10 days in September, that someone was accessing and basically took all of the numbers that were available in there in comparison to how many there are in total and how many they were able to take out.
MaiteSo it really has brought up some red flags as to what other mechanisms could be implemented so the system will give an alarm, like there is some sort of action that is out of the ordinary and someone should check on this now instead of waiting for someone from billing to realize- Yeah... that a hack of this dimension has taken place.
KalpitaI mean, great catch, although 10 days late. It is a huge number of people that have been affected by this. But then again, it also raises the question of how reliable is CPR numbers as an identity of someone. It is used as an identifier, but it's not proof that the person presenting it is the legitimate owner of the CPR, right? That's why we have other IDs, like there are passports if you're a EU or a Danish citizen, and most of us have what popularly is known as the pink card, which is your opholdsstilladelse, which has your face on it, so that becomes your ID.
KalpitaOtherwise, you have your sick card, which is your insurance card, the yellow card, which has your CPR number on it, but there's no picture. It was designed to identify individuals across public administration and not to function as an ID or a password per se, which turns out it has been used as a unique password for most people. But this breach also makes it easy to impersonate easily, especially when organizations rely on CPRs quite widely and use it for all kinds of information harvesting, which is used in a legitimate way because they have permission to use it.
KalpitaBut they're also like a catch-22 with the EU data rules as well. But it also means that knowing someone's CPR number alone does not automatically affect your, say, your bank account or your MitID.
MaiteActually, what it demonstrates is that you need to have other proofs of identity, and the safer system would be the MitID. So most of the institutions or companies that just use the CPR now need to see how they can implement this second check to make sure that they are speaking to the person that they say they're speaking for. But if you were to, for example, if somebody would try to use the CPR or your address or your civil status to take a loan from you, the system itself is not as easy.
MaiteThere are other categories in there that would be required for them to contact you and connect with you directly, but they are mostly used for identity theft. So what they can do is they can contact you and use the information they have about you to make themself look like an authorized institution and try and get extra sensitive information for you that then they can use to further take advantage of anything else that they would like to do with that information.
MaiteSo it's more important really the, that the people themselves are being careful with the things that they are clicking in links or giving information over text message. And in general, I think it's better if somebody's contacting you, um, for you to maybe Say, "Okay, I will contact directly the bank myself," or, "I will call your store directly. Give me your name, give me your information," so that you can double-check really who is trying to get info from you.
KalpitaYeah. But I think we are smarter now with not clicking on links and being aware. But at the same time, I have also come across that most of the medical shops where you get your medicine, medicines, your apoteket, they are requesting that you always carry something more than just your CPR number so they can verify that you are the right person who's getting the medicine. And that, I think, is very important to be aware of, especially if you are having prescriptions for regular medication. But there's also, in the official statement, it was requested that everyone should activate their credit warning, which is Kreditadvarsel in Danish.
KalpitaYou can go on your official citizen portal, which is your borger.dk, and it's a voluntary marker attached to your CPR record. And it's a signal that lenders should take extra care to verify identity before granting credit, which I think what you were referring to, Maite. And the limitations matter for this, of course. Companies who choose to receive the warning and some need to update their systems to use it as well. So that's if you have a business and you do require or use CPR numbers, that's something to be mindful of.
KalpitaIt also makes obtaining legitimate loans and credit more difficult, but that basically means that you need to go through extra ID checks just to make sure that you are the right person to receive this loan or credit or whatever that is. Although it does not a universal block on identity fraud or a substitute for secure authentication, but given the scale of this incident, reviewing whether to activate a credit warning is reasonable, especially because you are not sure if it is really your CPR that has been compromised, so it's better safe than sorry.
KalpitaSo it is a precaution, but it's not a guarantee, but it's best that done than being sorry later that your ID was stolen and someone took advantage of being you.
MaiteAnother aspect to keep in mind also is that e-Boks has officially said that there will be no affectations within their system for people to be able to use this information to either send or receive, so that we can trustfully use our e-Boks with trust and ease And the other aspect that I thought was important is also there are people that have requested protection on their names and addresses for situations such as perhaps conflicts or harassment with ex-partners was one of the situations that I saw, and the hackers were not able to access any data from individuals who have, because of some sort of situation of vulnerability, requested to have protection of their names and addresses.
MaiteSo that is also something important to keep in mind if it is something you may be worried about and you haven't done it, maybe something you can do in the future. But if you have already done it, your information is safe.
KalpitaI didn't know that, so that's interesting piece of information. I do have this… In the breach announcement, the finance ministry has also shared a hotline number that one can contact just in case your website is not working. The number they have published is 33-37-00-37. That is 33-37-00-37. So maybe it's an idea to call the hotline. It's called the Cyber Hotline for Digital Security.
KalpitaHopefully, that should be helpful and you are able to find out if you are compromised and then what you can do to not get your ID stolen. Speaking of IDs and where you belong and where you don't belong, there is again this debate, which I briefly discussed last episode on citizenship and democracy, where I think, Maite, with you and your expertise can give us more insight into. The government has announced a new screening initiative.
KalpitaIf you didn't know, the parliament has opened for the season with a big ceremony in the church and so on and so forth. And of course, the biggest news was immigration related to citizenship and also immigration of people coming from affected areas, so that's basically your asylum seekers. So the Ministry of Immigration and Integration said that the government intends to develop a model to screen citizenship applicants for anti-democratic statements and attitudes.
KalpitaIt also announced that it would reintroduce the earlier citizenship bill after reviewing applicants' eligibility again. The ministry expects that bill to be re- introduced in the first half of 2027. And if I remember from the news this morning, it said that they were already ready with some 2,000 applicants to get their citizenship and to be reviewed on immediate basis. But Maite, over to you.
MaiteI think sometimes it's really important for us to carefully look at the wording that is being used. So when we say an anti-democratic views screening, what does democracy mean? Can we say even that there is one version of democracy for all of Denmark, and not perhaps different versions of how that democracy looks depending on what political affiliation you have?
MaiteSo I think it's really dangerous to coin a term as homogeneous when we do not have homogeneous politics in Denmark today, and we do not have a homogeneous society, even though it may have been very homogeneous for many years. But their democracy has a responsibility to serve the whole while safeguarding minority populations.
MaiteAnd this is the areas in which I think, okay, we can say that there is a anti-democratic perspective screening that is being done for immigrants particularly, because of course it does not, uh, have the same influence for Danish citizens. Even though there has been in the past some political parties considering the idea of reviewing citizenships that have been given up to three decades before. I think this was one of the ideas that was floated around at the beginning of the year.
MaiteBut also depending on what parties are able to coalition and get into power, how can they then change that screening? What will it mean for them to have a democratic or anti-democratic views? And what is dangerous or not dangerous for them? And it is just so subjective and historical, and I don't mean historical as in, like, looking back through Danish history, but also as we individuals, citizens of today, that we are making history in Denmark today.
MaiteHow are we shaping this discourse? And how can this new interactions with immigration be misused or abused in the future because of how vague the term can be? For me, this is where the difficult debate comes into practice, is how can other people abuse this in the future? Because of course, we all say, maybe not all of us, but, um, many of us will say, "No, we want to live in a me- democratic system. We want to be able to vote for people that are going to make sure that they are taking care of the whole or they are taking care of these uh, areas or rights that are maybe not receiving as much influence as they should be for some groups." But in the future, right, this can look very different if political parties coming to Denmark are saying, "No.
MaiteWell, democracy for Denmark means that you are a Christian. Democracy for Denmark means that you do not support these type of cultural behaviors." And how can we read that in in the constant miscommunication that is happening when we are discussing between different cultures in one place? This is where I feel like it can be quite dangerous. I don't know if in the future I'm gonna have to go through this process or not, but I think as a human rights advocate, I tend to be very critical of the government, and I wonder if in the future criticism of the government will actually be a justification for them to say that I have anti-democratic values because I do not support everything the government says, and I'm constantly critical about what they do and what they do not do.
KalpitaI totally see your point, and this is what I know and partly my opinion as well. I have read and experienced in India if you speak against the government, not particularly on social media, but if you are publicly giving an opinion as a popular person, especially because people are listening to you and you are talking against the government, then you have repercussions. You will either get a visit from somebody and put you right, or you will have to just face adverse consequences for having an opinion against the government.
KalpitaAnd we're also seeing that through the news in places like the Americas and the UK as well, where your social media is monitored, what you say, what you don't say, and you have to be very careful of what you say and what you don't say. I mean, it is a paradox, isn't it? Because Denmark is very big on freedom of speech, and we've seen that through COVID times as well with a lot of discourse among the Danish population and internationally. So what is Danishness and who is Danish enough and who is not Danish enough?
KalpitaAnd this conversation is so old, but then again, like you said, who decides that and how are those parameters set, and how would that be used and abused by the next government because right now we have something that's working and maybe later it doesn't. And then who decides that, right? Also, then what's the point of democracy? Democracy is not defining and putting people in a box and saying this is right and that is not right.
KalpitaIt is being inclusive, it is being diverse, and then creating a sovereign society, which is what has worked for democracy over the years.
MaiteWhat worries me a little bit is the pretense of democracy that can take place when we are using this type of discourse. And so we are behind the desire of the government to attempt, perhaps, to be able to filter through individuals that may be, quote unquote, considered radical or anti-democratic. There is also this constant, uh, reproduction of a discourse where immigrants are criminals and immigrants are, they, God knows where they come from, but they don't know how to live in society.
MaiteThey are inadequate, they are deviant. And so even today in the news, for example, that was talking about the proposed finance bill for the next year, the last section, it was a big phrase, immigrants, and in the bottom, Mette's new jail is not gonna be done until four or five years from now. And people are not happy with this, with comments from party leaders saying, "These people are dangerous. They should be locked up, or they should be left, they should be removed from the country." And it just says, this is the title, immigrants, and then the jail.
MaiteAnd so we're constantly reproducing also the discourse. Immigrants are criminals. They are dangerous. And then again, oh, we have to have this screening because they are criminals and they are dangerous, and they come here to create chaos and to disturb our Danish values, right?
KalpitaYeah.
MaiteBut at the same time, then we have a piece of news for two days ago or three days ago where, for example, a party, political parties denied the implementation of a LGBTQI+ pamphlet that includes inclusive language. They are bothered about the inclusion of they, them, and so on in language that is being used together with human rights organizations and LGBTQI organizations in Denmark for the health professionals.
MaiteAnd they shut down this pamphlet because they say, clearly, there is only two genders. So when we are talking about this pretense of democracy for all, who is included in that? Who is actually a citizen and who is a human deserving of rights within that pretense of democracy? Because what I'm seeing is not so much a pretense of democracy, it's more of a push for a homogeneity. And that historically has been heteronormative, and patriarchal, and dominant in the way that it imposes its views upon other people.
MaiteAnd historically, women and all the other different sectors that are not … Women as a majority because we are equal majority in society, but all the other minority groups have had to fight tooth and nail to open that version of democracy, right? So that it actually includes all. And what I see behind this concept is this idea of a homogeneous society now is being used against the immigrants, but tomorrow is … Or not even tomorrow, it is also being used against trans people in the country for example, so who else-
KalpitaYeah… Maite: doesn't get to be Yeah. This is not law. I just want to make sure we clarify that. So the Immigration Ministry who's made this announcement and shared information clearly states that it is a proposal under development, so it is not law yet, and it obviously requires a legal establishment. It has said that it wants to model this in a legal, technical, and practically feasible way. The announcement does not establish a final screening procedure, so there is no procedure in place yet.
KalpitaIt's just an idea or a concept right now. A complete list of disqualifying opinions or a settled system for reviewing social media also is not in place. So the intention is there, but there are no precise rules or safeguards to determine whether you are Danish enough or not, which also, like you rightly pointed out, Maite, raises many, many questions. for example, is my social media post where I criticized Lars Løkke when he was the president, or spoke something about something that I didn't agree with but was a very pro thing within the society, then does that affect my application if I were interested in being a citizen?
KalpitaAnd then as a citizen, my opinion and question is also then what about the Danes who are anti-democratic? What about the Danes who are, I don't know, atheists, because Denmark is a big Christian country and very proud of their church culture as well, even if they don't go to church. So where do we draw the line, and how do we determine what is Danish values?
MaiteAnd it's punitive, right? Because I think most importantly is we will have different opinions and views on even the same word. We may have conflict. How do we create the spaces where we're able to dialogue with that conflict and understand or perhaps create bridges between where my understanding of this is, where your understanding of this is, and how we can both live in peace with one another. And I don't see so much these as spaces of dialogue when we are talking about just the general description of the projects and how some politicians feel about the immigration in Denmark.
MaiteThere is no space to create other visions of immigration that most of us are trying to change that view and demonstrate that just like Danish people are diverse community and there is possibility for them to become violent, there is the same possibility for us. And so how can we create communities of peace in each of the spaces that we are in instead of imposition of punishments, because that doesn't really support that much for a society either.
MaiteA society that becomes punitive is a society that it becomes quite strict and unable to transcend and to see bigger possibilities to implement democracy on a different level, for example.
KalpitaIn some way it scares me because there are many countries, especially within the EU, that l- are looking to Denmark to implement their own immigration laws. So it's scary to see what it might become if it at all comes into, into shape and legislature, which also makes me wonder if then free speech just gets tossed out of the window because for all you know, we are talking about something right now and someone in the government who has some kind of power decides,"I don't like what Kalpita and Maite saying," then you and I are sitting with, we didn't really say anything wrong.
KalpitaWe were just reading out facts, and it's all out there in the public forum.
MaiteYeah, and if this government had always not allowed different opinions to take place, it wouldn't have as many groundbreaking positions in regards of human rights as it has had. It is not perfect. No, I don't think there's any government that it is, but it is because it is able to meet different standing points with a possibility of saying, "How can we transform this space or this society or this law so that we are not imposing or oppressing anyone," for example.
MaiteSo it needs to continue in that line, um, and trying not to fall with the rise of authoritarianism that is happening all over the world. Because we also have democracies in place now that are authoritarian, so again, what type of democracy-
KalpitaYeah… Maite: are we talking about? Yeah.
MaiteI think it's more important as a society for us to really dive deep into what that means, or if everyone can come to a referendum of, okay, this is the Danish democratic values, boom, boom, boom, one by one. But if not, the vagueness of the concept can be misused by other people in the future, and that's the worry there.
KalpitaYeah. I totally agree with what you're saying. There's just one last thing I think is this is such a paradox because this is also a Danish value where we have a trust society, and people have freedom, and everyone has the opportunity of making something in life. And then when you put a lid on it by making something like this legislature and putting a definite box around what Danish values are, then it's doing the opposite of what Danish values actually are. But that brings me to our most likely last topic.
KalpitaAs I mentioned, the parliament opened for the season, and one of the proposals that came out or introduced in the parliament was the bill concerning restrictions on access to temporary residents under Denmark's Ukraine Special Act for people from less war-affected areas, alongside changes to employment-related obligations and special conditions in education and integration. It is a bill and not an enacted law.
KalpitaSo what is Denmark exactly proposing? The bill official title refers to three broad areas of change: residence permits, employment and benefits, education and integration. So residence permits is restricting access to the special temporary protection arrangement for people from parts of Ukraine classified as less affected by the war. Again who decides what is the less affected areas of Ukraine and who decides which is not, which is gravely affected and less affected?
KalpitaEmployment and benefits, changing rules relating to employment measures and work-related obligations for certain people receiving benefits is part of the proposal. And education and integration in ending certain special conditions introduced under the Ukraine arrangements. It confirms that these areas and detailed provisions must be checked against the actual bill, um, that has been proposed. But the regional restriction would not automatically cancel existing permits.
KalpitaThe stated focus is on access to the special arrangement for people from the designated regions rather than retroactively withdrawing protection from all Ukrainians already living in Denmark. So this is also, again, let me, let me find a small pocket where I can make change, and then I can move money from this protection and benefit-receiving part of society to something else where I can use it supposedly in the most effective way, which is a bit discriminatory, I think.
KalpitaIt's also strange to read and understand that, oh, there are some parts that are less affected and some parts that are not, uh, coming under this rule because they're so gravely affected, and people are homeless, and they really need help. But then this other area, people are not that affected, so they don't need really that much help. And then what is to say that if it is now applying to Ukraine that it won't apply to other parts of the world where we are actually trying to help people and not decide, hmm, maybe you do need help, and then maybe you don't need that much help from me, which is a bit of a strange thing to say in my opinion.
KalpitaWhere do you stand, Maite?
MaiteParticularly in regards to the designated less affected areas, I'm always wondering about the concepts that people come up with. So we have concepts like re-immigration and less affected war, and everyone takes them in. But if somebody wants to be called they/them, all of the sudden it's a big problem, right? So which concepts are they okay to be accepted and which are not? But it is a little bit disconnected with the reality that people living in areas of violence and conflict experience.
MaiteSo how are we able to assess person to person the experience of living in war and then determine or limit their possibilities to be able to seek asylum in a different area and get away from the war? I think this is the difficult management of pre-selecting certain areas and having people to prove that they were in those areas last before they come here, because that's just not how war works, and that is not how asylum seekers' experiences have been telling us for years.
MaiteThey don't work this way. It's usually moving from one place to the other and then trying to find when the situation is horrific enough, a situation that they can move to another country or another place and be away from the war. But that doesn't mean that they're not still affected by it if they, they had, had to do this inner country migration to remove themselves from the so classified hot zones of the war. So this is conflicting really at best, and I think it's just, again, like a nice phrasing to justify not taking in or not bringing in people that may really need it.
KalpitaYeah. This made me wonder what is temporary protection and how is it different from permanent residence, because that's what asylum would be, right? So Denmark's Ukraine Special Act is basically providing a distinct legal route for temporary residence for eligible people displaced by the war. It is a completely separate thing from the general process of obtaining permanent residence or Danish citizenship, which would include asylum as well, I think.
KalpitaThis creates a difficult policy balance where the government can treat the arrangement as temporary as for as long as they like, but it also gives protection to people to build jobs, language skills, obviously then the social aspect of it, school and school routines for people who have children, and of course, your general family life and friendship in Denmark, which creates a conflict in integration, right? Because integration takes time, and this creates this temporary protection remains dependent on changing conditions in the country.
KalpitaAs we know, in the previous year, there were people who were sent back. There were wars that came to an end, or the local government of different countries were now finally coming together and making a democratic decision and welcoming their citizens back, so people were sent back and stuff like that. So all of that would affect this temporary protection that right now Ukrainians have. So that's also sort of living your life in sort of a half balance. I think there's nothing permanent, so you always are in this limbo of at some point you're going to be sent back home or you have to go back home.
KalpitaBut does less war-affected area mean that you get to return? But it does not mean that these less war-affected areas are safe to return. So it could be infrastructure damage, it could be whatever else, but then that's also something that the Danish government and/or the parliament here is going to decide and then make rules on. So the first reading of this is going to begin on the 13th of November. So as of today. It is a proposal and not passed in the parliament, so there's going to be debate and there will be a lot of discussion, thankfully, on this proposal and all the other proposals we have discussed so far.
KalpitaBut on that note, this has been an incredible session with you, Maite. Thank you very much for sharing all your inputs and insights.
MaiteThank you, Kalpita. It was so nice to sit with you as well.
KalpitaI'm glad, and I hope to do this again with you. And to our listeners, thank you for tuning in. If you like this episode, please leave a like or leave your comments and feedback. Even if you don't like this episode, please share feedback and we can make it better. And if you have more information to share that'll benefit other people, our comments are open, our DMs are open. You can always reach out to us. Thank you, and see you in the next episode. Bye-bye. Bye.
Send us Fan Mail Episode summary Tax cuts, Danish Christmas & a changing population: Dom and Maite discuss Denmark’s new 11 billion kroner tax agreement, why Christmas celebrations begin so early, and how the...
Send us Fan Mail Episode summary Danish Parenting, Family Abroad & Cultural Identity: Meroe and guest Marcela discuss raising children between Mexican and Danish cultures, from building a support network far from family...
Send us Fan Mail Episode summary Danish citizenship, November traditions & Cyber risks: Julia and Fionn discuss calls for tougher Danish language requirements for citizenship, the traditions behind J-Day and...
Send us Fan Mail Episode Summary Host Narcis George Matache and guest Coryn, creator of Dane-ish, discuss the record economic contribution of international workers, the growing challenges of feeling at home in Denmark,...
Send us Fan Mail Episode summary Danish dating, cultural clashes & legal protection: Ophelia and Marcela compare dating expectations in Hong Kong, Mexico and Denmark, from splitting the bill and navigating different...