Kokoda Is Not Broken: The Story We’re Not Being Told A recent article in The Australian questions the future of the Kokoda Track, highlighting declining trekking numbers, management concerns and the preservation of military heritage. After more than 20 years and 100 Kokoda crossings, I believe there’s another side to this story that deserves to be heard. In this episode, I challenge some of the claims being made, share insights from PNG business leader Tim Bryson, and explore the important work being done to support communities along the Track. Kokoda is more than an Australian battlefield. It’s home to thousands of Papua New Guineans whose voices, livelihoods and futures matter. We can honour the sacrifices of 1942 while investing in the people who call Kokoda home today. This podcast is brought to you by Adventure Professionals. KOKODA FITNESS PROGRAM OTHER ADVENTURES
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1This podcast is proudly brought to you by Adventure Professionals. www.adventureprofessionals.com.au For me, Mission Ridge and Brigade Hill, the whole Kokoda campaign, more people need to know about it.
Speaker 2I know everyone knows someone who's trekked Kokoda. But to actually understand the stories of what these young guys did, it's harrowing what they went through.
Speaker 3They were staunch to the end, against odds uncounted.
Speaker 4And they fell with their faces to the floor.
Speaker 1Welcome to the Kokoda Track Podcast, hosted by former soldier Glenn Azar. This is the place to hear stories from those who've trekked Kokoda and gain tips and knowledge about what to expect on the track or to relive your own amazing experiences. The Kokoda Track Podcast, keeping the spirit of Kokoda alive.
Speaker 2Hey everyone, welcome back to the Kokoda Track podcast, proudly brought to you by Adventure Professionals, www.adventureprofessionals.com.au. Today I want to talk about something that I feel very, very strongly about. An article published in the Weekend Australian last weekend, written by journalist John Ferguson, asked a very important question. He said, the future of the Kokoda Track hangs in the balance. Can it survive for a new generation? Now, I think that's a question worth asking, and I want to start by acknowledging something. John Ferguson actually got out.
Speaker 3There and walked the track.
Speaker 2He experienced the terrain, the humidity, the climbs, the descents, the discomfort, and the incredible history that makes Kokoda such a special place, and I absolutely respect that he did that. I also really enjoyed reading the reflections of the young students who accompanied him, because those young people experienced something that I've witnessed thousands of times over the years. They went to Kokoda expecting a physical challenge. And they came home with something much more valuable. An appreciation of sacrifice. An understanding of resilience. A connection to Australian history. And hopefully,
Speaker 2a greater understanding of our nearest neighbours in Papua New Guinea. So there were actually certain things about the article that I appreciated. But there were also parts of it that genuinely frustrated me. Not because I believe Kokoda is perfect. Not because I think the authorities responsible for managing the track should be immune from criticism. And certainly not because I think we should stop asking the question about its future. Quite the opposite. I think we need to be asking better questions. And I think we need to be listening to a much broader range of people when we want
Speaker 2to answer them. Because there's a big difference between identifying problems and accurately explaining what's causing them. And there's an equally big difference between expressing an opinion and establishing a fact.
Speaker 3So today I want to explore both.
Speaker 2For those who don't know my background, I've been working on the Kokoda Track for well over 20 years. Earlier this year, I completed my 100th crossing as a leader. That's 100 times leading people across the Owen Stanley Range. 100 times standing at Ishirava, Brigade Hill, Templeton's Crossing in Urabawa. 100 times witnessing Australians being challenged physically, mentally and emotionally. And 100 opportunities to work alongside some of the most extraordinary people I've ever met. the people of Papua New Guinea.
Speaker 2Over those years, I've walked with thousands of Australians. I've worked alongside hundreds of Papua New Guineans. I've developed relationships with families and communities that extend well beyond trekking and tourism. So when I talk about Kokoda, I'm not talking about something I've read about. I'm talking about something I've lived. But I want to make something really clear. I don't own Kokoda. No Australian trekking operator does. The track belongs to Papua New Guinea. And that's a very important starting
Speaker 2point for this entire conversation. Because sometimes I think we Australians become so focused on what Kokoda means to us that we forget what it means to the people who actually live there. Now, one of the things that concerned me about John Ferguson's article was that he heavily relied on commentary from Charlie Lynn. Now, Charlie has been involved in Kokoda tourism for decades. He's completed more than 100 crossings himself, He's made contributions to the industry, particularly in promoting the military history of the track, and he's certainly entitled to his opinion. But Charlie has been a very
Speaker 2vocal critic of the management of the Kokoda track for many years, and I think it's important that readers and listeners understand that context. Because when someone has been campaigning on a particular issue for a long time, their claims should be examined rather than simply repeated. A strongly held opinion doesn't automatically become a fact. And when a newspaper gives significant prominence to one person's interpretation of events, I think it has a responsibility to properly.
Speaker 3Test that interpretation.
Speaker 2Now this is particularly so when the subject involves international relationships, development funding, tourism and the livelihoods of people living in remote communities. The article presents Kokoda as a place in decline, a place being neglected, a place where the future of its military heritage is uncertain. Now, there are legitimate issues worth discussing within all those areas, but I don't believe the article provides a complete picture, and I certainly don't believe the experiences and opinions of one trekking operator should be taken as representative of the entire industry. Following the
Speaker 2publication of the article, Charlie shared it on social media with some additional commentary. He described the management of the Kokoda track as, and I'm quoting here, a dog's breakfast. He criticised the government departments responsible for various aspects of Kokoda's management in both Australia and Papua New Guinea. He claimed that Australian aid funding had been redirected towards climate change and gender-based violence at the expense of military history. And he argued that management arrangements introduced in 2008 had caused trekking numbers to fall by 52%, resulting in 7,000
Speaker 2fewer jobs for Papua New Guinean guides and carriers. He also claimed that there wasn't a decent toilet along the track and then there wasn't a single interpretive memorial.
Speaker 3Apart from Isharava.
Speaker 2Now I want to unpack some of that, because these are very significant claims, and significant claims deserve evidence. So let's start with the trekking numbers. There's no dispute that Kokoda trekking numbers have fallen from their peak. In 2008, the Kokoda Trek Authority recorded 5,621 trekkers. That was a significant year for Kokoda tourism. And yes, subsequent numbers have been lower. But here's what bothers me. Charlie attributes that decline to the management arrangement introduced in 2008. Now, just
Speaker 2because two things happened around the same time doesn't mean that one caused the other. That's a fundamental principle of reasoning. Correlation is not causation. Think about what's happened in the world since 2008. We had the global financial crisis. We've experienced major changes in international tourism. Travel costs have changed. Fuel prices right now are through the roof. Consumer behaviours have changed. Adventure tourism has changed. We've seen concerns about safety, insurance and accessibility. And then, of course, we had COVID.
Speaker 2International travel effectively stopped for a substantial period. And the Kokoda trekking industry was directly affected. So should we examine whether management arrangements have contributed to declining numbers?
Speaker 3Absolutely.
Speaker 2Should we investigate whether there are better ways to administer and promote Kokoda?
Speaker 3Of course.
Speaker 2But should we simply attribute a decline in visitor numbers... to one management decision without properly examining all of those other influences. I don't think that's a reasonable conclusion. And then there's a claim about 7,000 fewer jobs. What exactly does that mean? Are we talking about permanent employment, seasonal employment, individual trekking engagements or working days? Because all of those are very different measures. If a porter completes several treks in a season, does that represent one job or several employment engagements? If trekking numbers decline, we can reasonably expect
Speaker 2fewer opportunities for local employment. That's not in dispute. But if we're going to put a figure of 7,000 jobs into the public conversation, we should be able to explain precisely how that number was calculated. Otherwise, we're asking people to accept an impressive-sounding statistic without the information necessary to assess it. And I think Kokoda deserves better than that. Another claim that caught my attention was was that Australian aid funding had been directed towards climate change and gender-based violence at the expense of military heritage. Now, let's look
Speaker 2at the broader picture. The Kokoda Initiative Partnership has three published pillars, track, people, environment. The track pillar includes the protection of military heritage, maintaining the track and supporting its management. The people pillar includes improving health, education and livelihoods for communities. And the environment pillar includes recognises the importance of protecting the extraordinary landscape surrounding Kokoda. Now that doesn't mean every program is perfect. It doesn't mean every dollar has been
Speaker 2spent effectively. And it certainly doesn't mean we shouldn't ask questions about priorities and outcomes. But it does mean the Kokoda initiative has responsibilities extending well beyond battlefield interpretation. And I think that's important. Because when we're discussing what Australian support achieves along Kokoda, we should be looking at the full range of work being undertaken. And I want to give you a practical example. At Naduri, there's been work to improve the local health facility, including renovations and medical support. Now, this is the kind of investment that deserves attention because
Speaker 2a functioning health facility matters to a mother with a sick child. Access to medical professionals matters to an elderly villager. Improved healthcare matters to families living in remote communities where reaching a major hospital can be incredibly difficult. And these are not minor considerations. They're fundamental to the well-being of the people who call Kokoda home. Which brings me to another perspective that I think deserves to be heard. Following John Ferguson's article, Tim Bryson, who is very high up
Speaker 2at Digicel, he offered a response. And I want to spend some time on it because I think he makes some very important points. Tim is a senior business leader operating in Papua New Guinea. He understands that doing business and delivering development in PNG can involve complexities that aren't always obvious to people looking in from Australia. He starts by acknowledging the positive aspects of the article, the extraordinary beauty of Kokoda, the generosity of the landowners, the remarkable experience that people have when they walk the track. But
Speaker 2then he makes a point that I think we Australians sometimes overlook. Papua New Guinea is a complex environment. development is difficult, logistics are challenging, infrastructure is expensive, and progress doesn't always happen at the speed or to the standards Australians might expect. Tim writes, and this is a direct quote, if development in PNG was as easy as some claim it is, then so many nationwide issues would already be resolved. And I think that's an incredibly important observation because it's easy to stand on the sidelines and point out what's wrong.
Speaker 2It's much harder to work within a complex environment build relationships, navigate different priorities, and create sustainable improvements. Tim also acknowledges that there are opportunities for improvement along Kokoda.
Speaker 3Nobody is denying that.
Speaker 2But he points to the many organizations, companies, government agencies, and local leaders already working together to achieve those improvements. He also makes some direct criticism of the trekking company featured in the article. Now, these are Tim's views, and I want to be clear about that. He alleges that the company has spent years criticizing others refusing to cooperate and attempting to dominate relationships with local people in government. Those are serious criticisms, and I don't intend to present them as independently established facts, but I do think his
Speaker 2comments demonstrate why it's important to hear from different stakeholders rather than treating one operator's perspective as representative of everyone. And here's where Tim's response becomes particularly interesting. He provides specific examples of development that the article largely overlooks. He points out that in the background of footage apparently filmed at Iribawa, there is an information panel for trekkers funded by the Australian government. Now think about that. We're being told there is virtually no historical interpretation on the track.
Speaker 2Yet according to Tim, an Australian-funded information panel is visible in the background of the very footage used to support the discussion.
Speaker 2Tim also describes Australian and NGO-supported health and education training, regular Australian-funded PNG-operated health patrols, investments in school classrooms and clean water facilities, and he states that maternal and child health outcomes along the track are significantly better than in all other parts of Papua New Guinea. Those health comparisons deserve to be checked against the relevant data, but his broader point is important. There is development work taking place in these communities, work that may not be immediately visible to an Australian visitor walking for a few days. He
Speaker 2mentions more than 50 schools across the broader region, including communities in valleys beyond the track itself, And I think that highlights another important issue. The Kokoda region is much bigger than the narrow trail that.
Speaker 3Most trekkers walk.
Speaker 2There are villages and communities beyond our immediate view. Families whose lives are connected to the broader region. And we talk about development, we need to understand that wider picture. A health patrol reaching a remote village. A school receiving clean water. A classroom being built. A mother having access to health care for a child. These things may not make for dramatic headlines about a battlefield in decline, but for the families who live along Kokoda, they can make an enormous difference. And that brings me to what I
Speaker 2consider the most important part of Tim's response. He writes, and I quote, That's it. That's the message. We don't need everyone to agree on every issue. We don't need to pretend that management is perfect. But surely we can recognise that cooperation will achieve more than constantly undermining the people and organisations trying to make progress. And Tim finishes with a message I wholeheartedly support. He says, go and
Speaker 2visit Kokoda. Because every visitor creates economic opportunities for people living along the track. And that's something I see firsthand. Every trek creates opportunities. For guides and carriers, for families selling food and supplies, for landowners and communities receiving camping fees. for people whose livelihoods depend directly or indirectly on the trekking company. And that's why I believe we need to be particularly responsible about the narrative we create around Kokoda. Because this isn't simply an argument between Australian trekking operators.
Speaker 2It has real consequence for Papua New Guinean families. Now I want to explore something I feel particularly strongly about. And it's something that I think gets overlooked far too often. Kokoda is not just a battlefield.
Speaker 3It's a home.
Speaker 2It's home to the descendants of the people who helped Australian soldiers during the war. It's home to families who have lived in those mountains for generations. It's home to people who face the challenges of limited infrastructure, difficult access to healthcare and education, and the realities of living in a remote mountainous environment. When we visit Kokoda, we're visitors in their country, and I think that should shape the way we discuss its future. We absolutely have a responsibility to honour our military history. but surely we also have
Speaker 2a responsibility to respect the people whose land carries that history. I find it difficult to understand how we can speak so passionately about the Fuzzy Wuzzy Angels and their contribution to Australia, yet fail to give equal attention to the wellbeing and aspirations of their descendants. Those two responsibilities should sit alongside each other. They shouldn't be competing priorities. And I will say something else. I don't believe we should be deciding the future of Kokoda from officers in Australia
Speaker 2without meaningful involvement from the people who live there. Their voice matters. Their priorities matter. Their aspirations matter. And their ownership of the land matters. There's another group of people who don't get nearly enough recognition in these conversations. The Papua New Guinean guides and carriers. These are extraordinary human beings. And I don't say that lightly. I've spent over two decades working alongside them. I've seen their strength, their patience, their humour, their generosity. And I've seen their willingness to
Speaker 2help complete strangers through some incredibly difficult situations. They're not simply employees moving backpacks through the jungle. They're fathers, they're brothers, they're sons, they're community leaders, they're people with ambitions, responsibilities and families who depend on them. And many of them are descendants of the very people we celebrate when we talk about the Fuzzy Wuzzy Angels. I think about the men I've worked with over the years. The relationships we've built, the challenges we've shared, the laughter, the difficult days, the
Speaker 2moments when they've stepped forward to help someone who was struggling. And I wonder whether those people feel adequately represented when we discuss the future of their industry. Because I would love to see more journalism that sits down with the local guides, the carriers, the landowners and the families in the villages. Ask them what they want. Ask them what has improved. Ask them what still needs work. Ask them what they believe Kokoda should look like in 10 or 20 years. Because their answers matter. And if we're genuinely interested in building a sustainable future for Kokoda, those answers
Speaker 2should help guide the conversation. Now one area where I absolutely agree with the article is the importance of protecting Kokoda's military history. I've stood at Ishirava, Brigade Hill, Templeton's Crossing, Eora Creek and Eora Bower more times than I can count. And those places never lose their significance. I've watched grown men cry at Brigade Hill.
Speaker 3I'm one of them.
Speaker 2I've watched young Australians stand silently at Isharava, beginning to comprehend the courage and sacrifice of people not much older than themselves.
Speaker 3I've watched trekkers arrive.
Speaker 2At the end of their journey with a completely different appreciation of Australian history.
Speaker 3And that matters.
Speaker 2And I absolutely support finding better ways to interpret and preserve the military history of the track.
Speaker 3But here's something else worth considering. Kokoda is not Gallipoli.
Speaker 2It's not a battlefield in France with roads, visitor centres and established infrastructure. It's a remote jungle environment in Papua New Guinea. And the terrain is part of the history. The difficulty is part of the experience. The remoteness is part of what helps people appreciate what the soldiers endured. So yes, let's improve interpretation. Let's protect significant sites. Let's make accurate historical information more accessible. But let's be thoughtful about how we do that. Because I don't want to see Kokoda... turned into a sanitised tourist attraction that loses
Speaker 2the very qualities.
Speaker 3That make it extraordinary. And here's another thing.
Speaker 2Historical interpretation doesn't always have to come from a sign. Sometimes the most powerful interpretation comes from standing on the ground, listening to the story and understanding what happened in that very place. I've watched people stand at Brigade Hill in complete silence. No phones, no distractions, just the history, the environment and their own thoughts. And that can be incredibly powerful. We should improve the experience without losing that connection. Now I also want to acknowledge something that I think John
Speaker 2Ferguson captured beautifully. The effect Kokoda has on young people. The students in his article spoke about the physical challenge, the emotional impact, and their growing appreciation of the soldiers who fought there. And I love that because I've seen the same transformation countless times. Young people arrive thinking they're going on a difficult hike. They leave with a deeper understanding of service, sacrifice, resilience and what they're capable of. They also leave having experience and generosity and warmth of Papua New Guinean people and that is something we should
Speaker 2be encouraging. I would love to see more schools and youth groups taking young Australians to Kokoda. I'd love to see more educational partnerships, more opportunities for young people to learn the history, challenge themselves physically and build genuine relationships with their nearest neighbours. But to achieve that, we need to be presenting an accurate and balanced picture of the experience. Not one that suggests the entire place is falling apart, because that is fundamentally untrue. Because the reality is that thousands of people have had extraordinary, life-changing experiences on Kokoda.
Speaker 2And there are many dedicated people working to ensure that continues. Myself, other tour operators, the local guides and connections, everything that we all do. And I want to finish with a thought. I believe criticism... has an important role to play. We should hold governments accountable. We should ask how money is being spent. We should expect transparency. We should push for better outcomes. But criticism should have a purpose, and ideally that purpose should be improvement. When we repeatedly describe something
Speaker 2as broken, dysfunctional or beyond repair, we need to consider whether we're actually helping to solve the problem or simply reinforcing a negative narrative. Kokoda faces challenges, of course it does, But there are also dedicated people doing very good work. There are Papua New Guinean communities building better futures. There are guides and carriers supporting their families. There are trekking operators delivering life-changing experiences. And there are young Australians discovering the history of Kokoda.
Speaker 3For the first time.
Speaker 2Those stories deserve attention too. And I think we need to ask ourselves a question. Are we genuinely trying to improve Kokoda? Or are we simply trying to prove that our own opinion about it is correct? Because those are two very different objectives. One requires cooperation. The other can become an endless argument. So is the future of Kokoda in the balance? I think the future of any significant historical and cultural place deserves ongoing intention and investment. But I don't accept that the only way to advocate for
Speaker 2Kokoda is to present it as a failure. I think the way forward involves listening. Listening to the communities. Listening to the guides and carriers. listening to the people managing the track, listening to operators with different perspectives, and listening to the young Australians who will become its future visitors and advocates. We need to protect the history. We need to improve the experience. And we need to make sure the people of Papua New Guinea benefit meaningfully from the industry that operates.
Speaker 3On their land. Because here's the thing.
Speaker 2You cannot genuinely honour the people who helped save Australian lives in 1942 while overlooking the lives of the people who call those same mountains home today. For me, that's where the future of Kokoda begins. Not with competing agendas, not with personal grievances, but with respect, evidence, cooperation, and a shared commitment to doing better. And I'll finish with something Tim Bryson said in his response. Go and visit Kokoda. I couldn't agree more. Go and experience the history. Go
Speaker 2and challenge yourself. Go and meet the extraordinary people of Papua New Guinea. Go and discover what this remarkable place has to teach you. And when you return home, Share the story, not just the story of the people who live there today, but also the people and the communities that you get to visit, the history from the past, because I think both deserve to be remembered, both deserve to be respected, and both deserve a future. That's my perspective after 100 crossings and more than 20 years working alongside the extraordinary people of Papua New Guinea. I want
Speaker 2to thank you for listening to the Kokoda Track podcast. I really hope you find benefit. I wanted to give a balanced argument I know I don't have the same reach as the Australian newspaper, but if you believe what I believe, if you understand what I'm saying here, if you've been on these experiences with me or someone that has this same belief and advocacy, that Kokoda is not falling apart.
Speaker 3It's not in ruins. It's not a shambles.
Speaker 2The most recent post I saw from Charlie just yesterday, days after that article came out, was that the Kokoda industry is on its knees. And I think that's a terrible thing to be saying because it's not true. And the negative effect it has on the local populations in Papua New Guinea is profound. I think we deserve more than that. I think they deserve more than that. I think the Kokoda Track itself deserves more than that. I find it actually disrespectful and dishonouring to the diggers that fought there that we would treat it this way. And yes,
Speaker 2I'm very passionate about this. If anyone wants to have a discussion with me, feel free to reach out, glenwith2ends at adventureprofessionals.com.au or hit me up on WhatsApp 0438 364106 because I'm more than up to have this conversation. I'm more than up to offer a different perspective and I'm more than up to champion the cause of the Kokoda Track, of the Papua New Guinean people and of all of those of you that are going to get to experience it in the future.
Speaker 4Oh, arise all you sons of this land. The bond between Aussies and the people of Papua New Guinea was forged in war and it endures in peace.
Speaker 2We've felt that friendliness, that special connection, in the comforting presence of our porters and in every small community along the Kokoda Track.
Speaker 4Papua New Guinea We are independent, we are free Papua New Guinea.
Speaker 3Okay, guys, thanks for tuning in.
Speaker 2It would be awesome if you'd share this with anyone you know that's going to the Kokoda Track or that has been and has a keen interest in the track, its people, and those that choose to trek it. The pillars of Isharaba say courage, endurance, mateship, and sacrifice. Great words to live by, and this podcast will offer mateship and a place for those that live and love the Kokoda Track experience. Until next episode, live a life that inspires you and those around you.
Speaker 3And remember to take time out to think. about what's really important.
Speaker 1Thanks for listening to the Kokoda Track Podcast. To get in touch or stay up to date, go to Kokoda Track Podcast on Facebook or email glenn at adventureprofessionals.com.au. Don't forget to subscribe and share with your friends. Let's keep the spirit and the stories of Kokoda and the PNG people alive.
This is a deeply personal episode of the Kokoda Track Podcast, honouring my friend and mentor, Allan “Al” Forsyth OAM. A former Regimental Sergeant Major of the SASR and inaugural RSM of 4 RAR Commando, Al was an...
When the Track Gets Tough: Drawing Strength from John Arthur Metson Every Kokoda trekker can face moments when the hills feel endless, fatigue sets in and self-doubt creeps in. In this episode, Glenn Azar draws...
The Kokoda Track is one of the most iconic and challenging treks in the world, but it's not just about the physical challenge - it's about the history, the culture, and the people. In this episode, Glenn delves into the...
The Kokoda Track is one of the most iconic and challenging treks in the world, but it's not just about the physical demands - it's also a journey of discovery and connection with the people and history of Papua New...
In this powerful episode of the Kokoda Track Podcast, tGlenn shares a heart-wrenching story of a young soldier who fought in one of the most pivotal battles of World War II. The story of Private Joseph Rovkin, a...