Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

KnownHeretic’s Substack Podcast

KnownHeretic’s Substack Podcast artwork

**Story, Meaning, and Sensation: A Response to Ravyn**

Nov 20, 202617 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.theknownheretic.com **Story, Meaning, and Sensation: A Response to Ravyn** Ravyn asked me something honest. People say transition is self-harm and that she should just accept herself. But she can work on these feelings and accept them, and they’re still there. That distress carries its own risks of worsening mental illness, self-harm and suicide. So isn’t doing nothing a risk too? It’s a fair question, and it deserves a real answer. I want to start by questioning the framing. What do we mean by “feelings”? An experience is made of three things*: the story we tell, the meaning we give it, and the sensation in the body. “I am in the wrong body” is a story. “Something about me needs to change” is a meaning. But underneath both of those, what is the actual sensation? Is it tightness, dread, disgust, numbness, a wish to disappear? Where in the body does it live? And then the other side: what do you hope to feel? Relief? Safety? Being seen? Being free of something? Those questions matter, because the answers point somewhere. Distress is real, and it asks for something. But what it asks for isn’t always what it first seems to. Taking hormones that disrupt the endocrine system, which the body then works to correct, is a gamble. And it’s a gamble to believe that changing your outward appearance will resolve what is emotional. If the sensation underneath is grief, fear or a sense of not being safe in a female body, then changing the body may not touch it at all. Accepting a feeling isn’t the same as understanding it. Sitting with it, listening to the body, and following the sensation back to its source is slower, but it’s the work that actually changes something. Ravyn, your distress deserves to be taken seriously. So do you. *Much love and respect to Rachel Flower for her foundational work on sensation, soma, and breath! KnownHeretic’s Substack is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Transcript below paywall:

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00I want to do a couple of things today. One, I want to read a letter that I have from a young woman who is beginning to take testosterone, starting down a transmedical path. Two, I want to reinforce what I spoke about in my coffee talk this morning, which was about story, meaning, and sensation. All of those are a way that we process So the experience is, it just is, and then we can process that experience.

SPEAKER_00Story is a descriptive narration of that event. The meaning is like the value that we find because of that descriptive narration. And the sensation is just the physical things that we feel in that experience. Now, the story that we tell, the meaning that we make of it, those are in a sense past tense and then future oriented.

SPEAKER_00The story is a description of the past. The meaning is the value that we take going forward. But those are directional. Those are happening in different directions. The sensation is the only thing that stays with us in the present. The sensation remains. Whether the sensation is the same sensation that we had in the experience, but the sensations that we are having, you know, the sensations that I am having right here, right now, having this video with you,

SPEAKER_00those are in the present moment. These sensations that I'm having Sitting, itching. My hair itched my eyebrow. I moved it. That is a sensation that is here in the present moment. So I'm going to read this letter and I want to use this letter as a way to reflect back on as an example of what I'm talking about. So this young woman, her name that we're going with is Raven. And she says, one quick question I have about this topic.

SPEAKER_00People talk about how it is self-harm to go through gender-affirming care and HRT and say that people should just accept themselves and the issues that they have. People can work on these mental issues all they want and sometimes it still doesn't work. People can accept they have these feelings and those feelings are still there regardless of acceptance or not. This distress can cause people to have worsening mental illness

SPEAKER_00and they may still resort to self-harm and suicide. People say being trans has these risks, but people who have this distress cannot do anything to alleviate it, still have those risks. This was one question that I had. Let's go through this a little bit point by point. People say that gender affirming care is Self-harm. And I would say that is accurate. You are purposefully destroying your healthy, functioning body.

SPEAKER_00You are either purposefully harming your endocrine system by taking puberty blockers or synthetic opposite sex hormones that are not in natural levels to your regularly functioning body. They are two levels that cause your body To have an immune dysregulation because your body is trying to re-regulate itself. So whenever you put your body into immune stress where your body is trying

SPEAKER_00to make up for the things that you're doing to it, that is a form of self-harm. Okay, so whether or not you go with the surgeries and then the surgeries themselves, that to me is very clearly cutting on your healthy body is self-harm. So I do say those things are self-harm. That's why many, like myself, say that those are self-harming behaviors. People can work on these mental issues all they want

SPEAKER_00and sometimes it still doesn't work. Now, I want to know... I would want to know from you, from this person, from anyone who would ask me this. This one happens to be towards Raven. So if I were addressing Raven, I would want to know what Mental issues. What is the mental issue? Now, we could make assumptions that there's some sort of identity incongruence where she may have a mental notion of herself in her head

SPEAKER_00that does not match what she sees in the mirror. But what I would want to know specifically, I don't want to assume, actually, I want to know what is the specific mental issue that you're talking about. So she's saying that people can work on it all they want and it still doesn't work. What is the work that you're doing? Okay. And why doesn't it work? And what would What would working look like if you felt like something was working?

SPEAKER_00What is proof that it works look like to you? And what work have you done that isn't working? What is the specific work that you've done that isn't working? My mentor, I said in my video this morning, my mentor often says you cannot think your way out of something that you experienced your way into. And just a really easy example, if your hand touches a hot pan and you're feeling a bad sensation,

SPEAKER_00you can't think your way out of it. You have to move your hand. You have to take your hand off of the hot pan. You have to do something. You say, people can accept that they have these feelings. What feelings? And those feelings are still there. What feelings? Regardless of acceptance or not. So let's go to the hot pan. I touch the hot pan.

SPEAKER_00My hand feels pain. I have accepted that my hand feels pain and the pain is still there because accepting that I feel pain is not enough. What is required is responsiveness. Feelings are signals. Whatever feelings are, feelings are sensations, whether those sensations are emotions or whether they are physical, they are sensations and they are asking for our responsiveness. So what is happening with my hand on the hot pan?

SPEAKER_00I don't need to tell myself a story. Well, the reason my hand is getting hot is because, you know, in childhood I Used to, you know, sit too close to the fireplace. No, it's just, it's too hot. I need to move my hand. It doesn't require maybe as much of a story as you're giving it. And I wonder what story you are telling yourself about why those feelings exist. What is the story that you're coming with?

SPEAKER_00What are the actual sensations? What are the feelings that need to be accepted? What does acceptance of those feelings look like? But I don't think the feelings just need to be accepted. The feelings are there to move you into another feeling. So what do you feel now? And what would you like to feel? Now, I think Gender-affirming care of all kinds is harming the healthy body is self-harm.

SPEAKER_00And I think it's a gamble. So I would say what sensations do you actually feel and what do you want to feel? And why do you think that taking synthetic hormones is going to help you feel a different way emotionally? What are the emotions that you're feeling? I think it's a gamble. I mean, you are taking an absolute gamble, an absolute risk. You have no guarantee that taking hormones is going

SPEAKER_00to change how you feel about yourself or about your whatever. Why do you want to gamble? What is this gamble? What are you hoping to get? From this gamble and why are you willing to risk your health on this gamble? What are you hoping to get? You say this distress can cause people to have worsening mental illness and they still may resort to self-harm and suicide.

SPEAKER_00Well, I say that that risk is still very much there if you take these drugs and get these surgeries. And we can see from the outcomes that suicidal ideation does not get relieved from gender-affirming care. That is not necessarily the case. There are many, many cases where it doesn't get helped at all. And again, I just want to question what mental illness, what is the mental illness part of this?

SPEAKER_00Again, be specific. Stay as close as possible to the sensations. I feel tightness in my chest and fluttering when I think blah, blah, blah. Or when I look at myself in the mirror, I... I have a visceral response that stay very close to the sensation and then stay

SPEAKER_00with the sensation that you desire to feel. Tell me what you're hoping to achieve. I would be very curious to know. You say, people say being trans has these risks. I don't, what is being trans? There's no trans. Trans is a thought that you are holding in your head. You are always a woman. However much you medicalize, you are always a woman. However much someone else medicalizes, they are always a man. So being trans is a thought.

SPEAKER_00To me, it sounds like you say, you know, being a Mooney. That's a kind of a cult, by the way. You know, so you're saying, People say that being a Mooney has these risks, but people who have this distress cannot do anything to alleviate it. No one is trans. Everyone is 100% man or 100% woman. Trans is a thinking thing. So you say, people say being trans has these risks, but people who have this distress, what distress? Be specific. Cannot do anything to alleviate it.

SPEAKER_00Still have these risks. But people who have this distress and cannot do anything to alleviate it still have these risks. I don't know what you mean, can't do anything to alleviate it. There's like a million things to do. What have you tried that didn't work? If I were you, I would fight for my healthy body.

SPEAKER_00I would fight not to destroy my immune functioning. I would fight not to put my immune system into overdrive, trying to correct for the purposeful distress that I was doing to it. I would fight to stay in my healthy body because especially as we age, our health, our healthy immune system So I would do a lot not to destroy

SPEAKER_00that healthy functioning. So what did you do to alleviate it? And here's the thing. You are numbing yourself out. You are dissociating from those sensations. As you take gender-affirming care and HRT and go down a medicalized path, it's like dissociating. So you're basically saying, I want to keep Touching the hot pan, and I want to ignore the hot pan, and in order to ignore the hot pan,

SPEAKER_00I'm going to cut off my hand. Instead of responding to the hot pan, you are simply cutting yourself off, or I want to numb my hand so that my hand no longer feels sensation, so I can keep my hand on the hot pan. My staying with the sensation is to To respond is to go through the pain, to go through it, to go through the moment of discomfort, to ask the discomfort,

SPEAKER_00what are you trying to tell me? What is this signal? When I was in my own trauma, I know yours may not be about trauma, but when I've had trauma and I was dissociating or wanting to dissociate, dissociation was not the answer. The answer was to Be with my feelings to ask them, you know, shame, why are you here? Pain, why are you here? Fear, anxiety, why are you here? What are you trying to show me about my experience?

SPEAKER_00What are you trying to teach me? So, you know, I think that the stories that we tell ourselves about our experience are not always accurate. The meaning that we make from the stories that we tell is not always helpful. So I don't find the story of I was born in the wrong body and the meaning

SPEAKER_00that I make from it is that I am trans, I don't find that a very useful story or piece of meaning and I think it is leading a lot of people down a path of Self-harm rather than, I don't know that I would say self-acceptance because you are in a relationship with yourself. We are all in a relationship with yourself. So I don't think it's ever like maybe like

SPEAKER_00a full self-acceptance. It is a relationship. It is dynamic. It's never finished. You're always working on it, just like any relationship. And notice, by the way, that trans also has a narrative of going no contact. I mean, again, they are always trying to cut people off from relationship, including relationship with yourself. My relationship with myself is always ongoing. There are always, at any given time, At any given time,

SPEAKER_00there's going to be things that I love about myself. There's going to be things that I don't like about myself. And that is being in relationship, being patient with the things that I don't like about myself, working on them slowly. I also think that trans is like a quick fix scenario. And I think it is just absolutely a gamble. Because there is no guarantee

SPEAKER_00that changing your external appearance is going to change anything about your interior emotional experience. Alright, I am going to leave this all here. Thank you to Raven for the message. I hope that you will continue being in conversation and sharing about your experience. And I hope that you will ask yourself honest questions about what are you actually feeling? What are the sensations? And what do you hope to feel?

SPEAKER_00What sensations do you hope to feel? Thank you so much.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Coffee Talk: Story, Meaning, and Sensation

    Nov 19, 20264 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.theknownheretic.com When the Story Gets Ahead of the Body Puberty is one of the most intense stretches of sensation a person ever lives through. A girl’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Secure Connection vs Dissociation

    Nov 16, 202620 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.theknownheretic.com Relationships are where we grow. I grew up in a family whose patriarchal Christian teachings I deeply disagreed with. I rebelled, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Coffee Talk: Manufacturing Consent and Propaganda Wars

    Nov 16, 20265 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.theknownheretic.com Coffee Talk: Manufacturing Consent and the Asymmetric War of Ideas In 1988, Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky published Manufacturing...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Coffee Talk: Public opinion leads. Policy follows.

    Nov 13, 20264 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.theknownheretic.com Coffee Talk: Public opinion leads. Policy follows. That’s the order - and it’s the whole game. In this Coffee Talk, I’m pulling back...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A conversation with “Jay” a young trans identified male

    Nov 13, 202623 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.theknownheretic.com “Jay” is a young trans identified man. He is the tenth or twelfth young person who has come to me with honest questions about his...

    Credit the people on this episode