Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Keeping Abreast with Dr. Jenn

Keeping Abreast with Dr. Jenn artwork

159 : Hormones, Menopause, and the Cost of Saying No

Oct 11, 20261 hr 14 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Dr. Jenn Simmons is joined by Dr. Louise Newson, a hormone-focused physician and menopause educator, for a wide-ranging conversation about the difference between bioidentical and synthetic hormones, why hormone fear persists in medicine, and how that fear affects women’s long-term health. They also dig into breast cancer, BRCA mutations, perimenopause, testosterone, compounding, and why shared decision-making matters more than blanket rules. Key topics Dr. Louise Newson shares how her medical path moved from internal medicine and pathology into general practice, medical writing, and ultimately menopause and hormone care. She explains why the Women’s Health Initiative and other early studies created lasting confusion by mixing synthetic hormones with bioidentical hormones. Dr. Newson breaks down the biological difference between endogenous hormones and synthetic compounds, using receptor biology and chemical structure to show why they are not interchangeable. The conversation examines why many clinicians still fear hormone therapy, including outdated warnings, guideline dependence, pharma influence, and professional ego. Dr. Newson argues that menopause is not just a “natural transition” but a hormone deficiency with real biological consequences, especially for bone, cardiovascular, brain, and metabolic health. They discuss the misconception that hormones should only be used briefly, and why some women benefit from continuing treatment based on symptoms, quality of life, and future risk reduction. The episode covers testosterone in women, including why it is underused, why it is often misunderstood as only a libido hormone, and how it can affect mood, energy, sleep, joints, and cognition. They explore how perimenopause is best approached by assessing progesterone, estradiol, and testosterone separately rather than relying on one broad label. Dr. Newson addresses compounding, explaining why individualized preparations can be useful and why “compounded” does not automatically mean unsafe. The discussion moves into breast cancer and BRCA mutations, with a focus on why hormone decisions should be individualized rather than ruled out by category. They emphasize that women need better information to make informed choices, and that refusing to offer hormone treatment can itself cause harm. Timestamps 00:00 - Why Dr. Louise Newson is such a trusted voice on hormones 01:17 - Losing her father young and the path into medicine 03:39 - From prescribing HRT to becoming a medical writer 04:04 - The WHI study and why it changed everything 05:55 - Why antidepressants were replacing hormone care 07:32 - Synthetic hormones versus bioidentical hormones 09:33 - How receptor biology explains the difference 10:32 - Chemical examples that show how small changes matter 11:30 - Why WHO classified ethinyl estradiol as carcinogenic 13:34 - Why warnings and guidelines keep the fear alive 15:28 - The vacuum created when doctors stopped learning hormones 16:41 - Training more than 33,000 clinicians in menopause care 18:57 - Why gynecologists are not necessarily hormone experts 19:24 - Why endocrinology and psychiatry often miss the issue 20:49 - Is menopause a disease or a normal transition? 22:15 - Why early menopause raises the stakes 23:34 - Why hormone therapy should remain a choice 24:27 - What happens when the body adapts to low hormones 25:41 - Why supplements cannot replace estradiol, progesterone, or testosterone 28:55 - What older women discover when they finally try hormones 29:57 - The so-called window of opportunity after age 60 31:31 - Why hormones may still help women with heart disease 33:41 - Why there will never be a big randomized trial 35:07 - Why medicine accepts some evidence standards and ignores others 37:39 - The compounding controversy and why it makes no sense 39:36 - Why testosterone can be safer as a pump or customized preparation 40:03 - Why Dr. Newson dislikes the words menopause and perimenopause 40:59 - Treating progesterone, estradiol, and testosterone separately 42:38 - Why testosterone is so misunderstood in women 44:03 - The limits of libido-only thinking 45:28 - Testosterone data in men and why it gets ignored for women 46:11 - BRCA mutations, ovarian cancer, and hormone eligibility 48:56 - Why society guidelines are not the same as facts 49:54 - The hidden harm of withholding hormones 51:52 - The woman whose life changed after starting treatment 53:09 - Why not prescribing can create real long-term danger 54:11 - Women often know more than their providers now 55:38 - The breast cancer population and refusing tamoxifen or aromatase inhibitors 56:46 - Estrogen receptor positive does not mean estrogen caused the cancer 60:06 - Risks of tamoxifen and aromatase inhibitors 61:33 - Testosterone use after breast cancer 63:05 - Why cancer and recurrence happen with or without hormones 65:26 - Who Dr. Newson would refuse to treat 66:55 - A breast cancer case where hormones supported mental health 68:09 - Why old breast cancer treatments included estrogen and progesterone 70:13 - Why hormone treatment is reversible 71:56 - The goal is helping women reach a better baseline 72:23 - Where to find Dr. Louise Newson To talk to a member of Dr. Jenn's team and learn more about working with Dr. Jenn visit: https://calendly.com/stephanie-1031/clarity-call To get your copy of Dr. Jenn's book, The Smart Woman's Guide to Breast Cancer, visit: https://tinyurl.com/SmartWomansBreastCancerGuide Connect with Dr. Jenn: Website: https://www.perfeqtionimaging.com/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/DrJennSimmons Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drjennsimmons/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@dr.jennsimmons

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Keeping A Breast with Dr. Jen. I'm Dr. Jen Simmons, breast cancer surgeon, turned to integrated physician and founder of Perfection Imaging and Wellness. I spent years operating on breast cancer. Then I became the patient. That experience showed me something I couldn't unsee. We've been treating disease and calling it health care. We've been screening for cancer and calling it prevention. Women weren't being given the information they needed to actually consent to their own care, not the full picture, not the real options, just protocol.

SPEAKER_01So I left and I built something different. And here's the thing breast health is health. So this show isn't confined to breast cancer. Here we dive deep into all the places medicine has been getting it wrong. Hormones, metabolism, aging, the whole picture. And we replace the old convention with real evidence and real choices. This is keeping a breast with Dr. Jen. Let's get into it. Stay with us. This is a conversation you won't want to miss.

SPEAKER_01Okay, Dr. Louise Newson, I just want you to know that I have been stalking you. I have been so looking forward to this time with you because you are one of the voices of reason out there. And there are a lot of people that are like maybe dipping their toe or they're so sure that you and I are wrong. But I I've never been so aligned with someone, and I just I could listen to you forever. And now my my followers and my community get to listen to you.

SPEAKER_01So here we go. Just give us a little bit of your background because I know you're you're internal medicine trained, but you're a hormone expert. So what how did that happen?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, isn't it weird? Things always happen for a reason, but you don't realize at the time. I actually, if I go straight back really, I'm the only person from my family that ever became a doctor, and I wanted to become a doctor when I was really young. And then my father Yeah, but then my father um actually died when I was nine, he had a brain tumor, he had glioblastoma. So I then thought, well, I want to do oncology, I want to cure everyone of cancer because how sad is it to lose your father when you're nine. So I was really interested in oncology, and I took an extra year out in medical school and I did a p um a degree in pathology, the study of disease, which then, like at the time I wasn't really sure why I was doing it.

SPEAKER_00I was just interested in knowing more about the body and what goes wrong. But actually, it was amazing because I learned a lot about inflammation and mitochondria and macrophages and things that you don't have time to spend on when you're at an undergraduate medical school. And then I went into hospital medicine, like you say, so I did a lot of different specialties, so cardiology, neurology, rheumatology, gastroenterology. And I met my husband um when I was 18 actually at medical school, and he's a surgeon, and it got to the time where we got married in 97, and I looked around and I still can't find a female role model actually.

SPEAKER_00And I was like, Oh, I want to, I'd love a family, but I want to be there with my family. I don't want them, you know, farmed off with a nanny or whatever. And that back then it was hard to go part-time, so I thought, well, I'll go into general practice and maybe I'll kind of be more flexible with my work, and my husband can have his career, and you know, I will be the lovely wife at home. And then I did general practice, but actually what was really interesting, Jen, was that uh it made me think more about the person and the patient. Because when I I worked in New Zealand for a year, came back, did an oncology job as a junior doctor, and I found it really frustrating because it was sort of bed three lymphoma, bed four breast cancer, bed six is is you know, theyukemia or something.

SPEAKER_00And it was all about the medicines, and and also I couldn't pronounce half of the chemotherapy drugs, so I thought, well, I'm gonna be a bit stupid here. But I felt like no one was asking the people, like there were some people that came in and they probably needed to just die peacefully at home, you know, and they were going, no, there's a new study, there's a new trial, let's give them this and this and this, and then they'd have utopenic sepsis and die anyway. And I I just felt it wasn't quite me. So I thought it that's so then in going to general practice, it was really about the patient being a person, not not something with a disease.

SPEAKER_00It was just really learning about them, and it sounds really stupid now, but back in the 80s and 90s when I trained, um, I don't know about you, but it was very much about the disease, the treatment. It wasn't about the person. And so it was a really great time just training to be a GP. And I've always like enjoyed lots of things about medicine. Prescribing HRT was something I always did, but then I went part-time because of my children and I became a medical writer, so I wrote a lot of evidence-based medicine. I wrote books on um, you know, evidence-based medicine to help people pass their exams because you have all these guidelines, you have all these papers, and no one has time to read them.

SPEAKER_00So I was the geeky one who would summarise them so people could learn. And then in 2015, we had our first menopause, um, nice menopause guidance came out, and I was asked by the Royal College of GPs to summarize them. So I was like, okay, that's fine. And I read the summary, I mean, they weren't that exciting, but then I went back and reread the WHI study, and I hadn't realized actually, as a GP, I carried on prescribing HRT, despite the WHI study, the Women's Health Initiative study, because it wasn't the HRT what I was prescribing, as you know, it was all synthetic.

SPEAKER_00So it didn't really bother me, but I hadn't realized outside my work, the whole world had come off their HRT, and the whole world were worried about breast cancer and hormones.

SPEAKER_01Whereas I was Well, there was also a a study in in England at the same time, wasn't there?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, there was a there was a study, it was a nurse's study, which was um and the million women study, which actually didn't even have a million women in it. I mean, it was just crazy, and that was just uh an observational study. It was looking a woman who'd had breast cancer, and then they say, Had you ever taken HRT? And if they said yes, oh, therefore HRT caused breast cancer. I mean, they could have said to them, Did you clean your teeth every morning? Yes, you did. Oh, okay, so cleaning your teeth.

SPEAKER_01I mean, it was just Did you ever have a cat, right? Like there was absolutely no, we should have concluded absolutely nothing from that study. And yet people for years used it as evidence.

SPEAKER_00Well, they still do. I mean, it's still mentioned in the NICE guidance, and so because I've always like unpicked evidence quite quickly, for me it was just a bit, you know, the nonsense, really. And and actually I I've was more worried about osteoporosis and heart disease and breast cancer for a lot of my patients anyway, but um, you know, I didn't prescribe those synthetic hormones. So I was all more interested, but then I was, you know, 11 years ago, I was 45. Some of my friends were getting hormonal symptoms coming out of their GPs with antidepressants.

SPEAKER_00And I'm like, what? Like, why aren't you on HRT? Oh no, my doctor says it's going to give me breast cancer. And I was like, gosh, there's one thing not prescribing hormones, but there's another thing prescribing something completely different for a symptom. It just didn't make sense. So then I thought, well, I'll set up a clinic just to help my friends come off their antidepressants, go on some hormones. But then back then no one was really talking about menopause very publicly. So I thought, well, I use my skills as a medical writer and I'll start to develop a website and do some social media. Um, and then my clinic just got busy and busier.

SPEAKER_00You know, it it wasn't intentional really, but then I went into medicine to help as many people as possible, not just wealthy people. So then I thought, well, I'll set up a podcast and I'll um develop an app so with technology I can reach people with my knowledge. And it's sort of just gone from there, and now it's not even menopause, it's hormone imbalances women of all ages. But then, you know, the harder I work, the worse it's becoming for women. Honestly, I don't know. It's the same for you in the US. There's the stories I hear are just unbearable, actually, because so many people have this unfounded fear about hormone treatments.

SPEAKER_01It it's so astounding. So I I want to start to attack that and break it down. Let's start with why do you think providers are so willing to believe that hormones cause breast cancer? Where do you where do you think the logic and the reason stops for them?

SPEAKER_00So I I think about this a lot actually, and I I and I also really interested when you think about the history of hormones, because I think it's gone on right from the start. Because as you know, when they developed hormones, they could be bought over the counter and um they made them from pregnant horse women's urine. Um, and women didn't really like having other people's urine, which is fine, I can understand that, this amount of urine. The pharmaceutical companies didn't like them because you could buy it over the counter. So they very quickly made them so they synthetically processed them, um, and the pharmaceutical companies paid gynecologists to work with them.

SPEAKER_00And so there was this very close bond between gynecologists and those hormones, estrogen, progesterone, testosterone, very, very early on, actually. And then all the studies were done on the womb, and they were done with it. Well, then it came the pregnant horse's urine and the synthetic progestogens. So they called it a hormone, but it wasn't a hormone, and that is the biggest problem, I think, because then when you talk about risks and hormones, people don't then stop and say, sorry, are you meaning a hormone or are you meaning a synthetic chemical that's made to be like a hormone?

SPEAKER_00And doctors, I think a lot of them still don't understand the difference. Women are getting it quicker than doctors.

SPEAKER_01Say more about that, because I I think that there is a universal kind of acceptance that they are all the same. And we use hormones as a blanket statement to mean something that is affecting you at the hormone receptor level. Yeah. But you're you're trying to make the distinction between the inherent endogenous hormones that our bodies make and these other substances that, yes, are affecting the hormone receptors, but they're not doing what our bodies do.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I think this is a crux, actually, because in medicine, if I don't understand anything, I'll go back to the basics. And like having that basic understanding of pathology and the way our cells work is crucial for this conversation because, as you know, and I'm sure a lot of your listeners know, hormones are just chemical messengers that go in our bloodstream, they affect every cell in our body. But it's the receptor is like a lock and a key. So those hormones are like the key, the receptors, the lock, they go in, and then all these lovely, wonderful biological reactions occur in the cell, in the nucleus.

SPEAKER_00We've got receptors in the DNA, so they can change our genetic structure, go into the mitochondria, you know, help the mitochondria to work, the powerhouse of all our cells. But when you change a chemical structure, it doesn't take much of a change to really alter its properties. And I often use the example of water is H2O, two hydrogen, one oxygen. You add another oxygen and you get H2O2, it's hydrogen peroxide or bleach. You know, they might look the same, but they're very different. Or um a graphite pencil lead is carbon, it's just got carbon with three bonds.

SPEAKER_00You add another bond, keep it carbon, and you get a diamond. They're really different, you know? And so when they added this ethanol group onto estradiol, which is a really lovely anti-inflammatory type of estrogen, ethanol estradiol, the shape is different, so it doesn't go into the lock of the receptor in the same way. So it actually blocks the receptor partially. So estradiol in your body is not going to get into those cells and to the nucleus, but also it has it has properties that are different.

SPEAKER_00So it's probably damaging the cell, not working in the same way. So these hormones, progesterone, estradiol, testosterone are very anti-inflammatory, reduce inflammation, help the macrophages or inflammatory cells to work well. When we don't have those hormones, but you're also giving a chemical, it's probably worse than not having hormones at all. And the irony is that we've known for decades, actually, the WHO, the World Health Organization, in 1979 have a report out. It's on the internet, you can look it up, and it says that ethanol estradiol is carcinogenic, as in cancer causing.

SPEAKER_00Now, ethanolestradiol is in all but one type of combined oral contraceptive pill. So doctors and clinicians, when we talk about hormone treatments, should be really worried about the contraceptions, the synthetic hormones that we're given. And it's the same with progesterone. We've got one type of progesterone called progesterone. We know its chemical structure, but all the synthetic progestogens or progestins, depending on how you which country you're in, really, they're all chemically different. So modoxy progesterone acetate, the one that was in the WHI Women's Health Initiative study, actually works as an aromatase inhibitor.

SPEAKER_00It blocks the action of estradiol in the body. So it's not just a neutral, you know, hormone blocker that just stops progesterone working, it actually stops estrogen working, estradiol working as well. And goodness knows what other other sort of detrimental effects it has on the body. Because the irony is, obviously, is when they were tested to come to market, they were only tested on the womb because everyone was thinking about periods, um, not about the women's brains and hearts and bones and everything else as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's really amazing. So I'm gonna go back to even though these studies, especially the women's health initiative, have been retracted, right? The findings have been retracted, doctors are still so very willing to believe that hormones cause cancer. So why do you think that is? Do you think it's just a tie to the pharmaceutical industry? Do you think we're no longer capable of critical thinking?

SPEAKER_01Because that retraction paper was printed in 2017. I mean, we're talking about years ago now.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think I think there's lots of things really. I mean, I don't work with pharmaceutical companies at all. So I my work comes from knowledge, evidence, and a wealth of clinical experience. But a lot of people are tied with pharmaceuticals, so that makes it very difficult to be completely impartial. But we also know, you know, your FDA, our MHRA have still got warnings. I know your some of your black box warnings came off estrogen products, but they're still there for the progesterone, for testosterone. Everyone's still scared because the warnings are coming up.

SPEAKER_00So when we prescribe, we have these warnings that are wrong. And then a lot of medicine now is very guideline driven. So if you're reading a guideline, a lot of people don't have time to go in behind the guidelines, see where the evidence is, see who's written them. So for over here, the nice guidance were updated, but they actually put together synthetic and natural hormones together because um they when when challenged, the the team, the the key topic advisor said, Oh, well, there weren't any randomized control studies with bioidentical hormones, so we just lumped it all together.

SPEAKER_00Well, that's just lazy, that's just stupid. And so there's so much confusion. A lot of the menopause societies write guidelines, but they don't distinguish between estradiol and ethanolist estradyl or conjugated equine estrogens, which is a pregnant horse's urine. They don't distinguish between progesterone, progestogen, and so then it makes it really, really confusing for doctors. But I also think a lot of doctors are quite um arrogant, they don't like to admit that they've got it wrong. And I think this is a real problem because ego.

SPEAKER_00Ego. You know, it is ego. There is also something about when you challenge something, people don't like it. And I am challenging because I will ask questions. But I also will admit that I didn't know what I know now 31 years ago when I graduated. But I don't think that's a bad thing because as doctors, we should stay curious and we should challenge and we should ask and we should evolve. And it's fine to say what I knew then was different because our patients will respect us for us.

SPEAKER_00So I think people are stuck in a rut. But I also think over the 22 years or so since WHI came out, or 24 years, there's been a high vacuum because people have stopped prescribing HRT, people have stopped learning about hormones, and so then medicine is very much more siloed and more symptom-oriented. And then we've got all these drugs. So, you know, most women by the age of 60 are on at least six medications. They're on antidepressants, they're on an osteoporosis drug, a blood pressure drug, you know, so it's actually big farmers' dream, really, because these women are medicalized with um, you know, drugs to control their symptoms and they're being misdiagnosed because no one's thinking about hormon treatments.

SPEAKER_01What about training? So I know in in the US, there is no training around bioidentical hormones. Is that is that true in the UK as well?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I mean we set up a training program quite a few years ago actually called Confidence in Menopause. And uh we trained over 33,000 healthcare professionals. It's online. We did it where we um filmed actors as well, because a lot of medicine, as you know, is an art as well. It's all very well having the knowledge, but you need to know how to talk to a patient, how do you just prescribe, how do you go through risks, benefits, whatever. Um, and so that was really good, and then it got taken down by another metaphor society reported us and said it wasn't in line with the guidance.

SPEAKER_00So it was taken down a few years ago. So we've just re-relaunched it actually with another company, and it's called Confidence in Hormones because a lot of my work is seeing women with PMS, PMDD, endometriosis, um, you know, PMOS, postnatal depression, all these hormonal imbalances that occur. So we called it confidence in hormones, um, and it's still under news in education. And so, because it's online, people can do it in any country. But it's the same over here. I mean, there are menopause societies in every country and they have various training, but they're not regulatory at all.

SPEAKER_00They just make up what they're doing, and a lot of it is based on older types of hormone treatments. It's not very practical, it's not very hands-on. I feel very strongly that a lot of hormone care should be done by general physicians. You know, gynecologists, OBG, YN, they go straight into gynecology. They don't do cardiology jobs and, you know, neurology jobs, they don't really think beyond the ovaries. And I don't really see, like, I've had a hysterectomy. I'm 56, I need all three hormones, but why would I see a gynecologist?

SPEAKER_00It's a waste of their time because I don't have any gynecological organs for them to worry about, you know.

SPEAKER_01Well, the the other thing that most people are profoundly unaware of is that gynecologists are not hormone experts. And their hormonal training is is virtually nothing. I mean, my friends who went into OBGYN and later became you know more educated and hormone literate, they they did that because they took extra training, because as in their gynecological training, they were trained to be surgeons, right? That's that's what they're trained to do.

SPEAKER_00That's why they go into it, is to be a surgeon. And I sometimes think if I had type 1 diabetes, I wouldn't go and see a pancreate pancreatic surgeon. You know, they are very specialized in what they do. It doesn't really make sense. But then sadly, endocrinologists, so endocrinologists, the study of hormones, they they don't seem to know about progesterone estradiol testosterone. I have quite a few patients who've had pituitary tumours and they they have back all these other hormones like their thyroid, they have hydrocortisone, but no one's talking to them about or they put them on the contraceptive pill and say, you've got a hormone now.

SPEAKER_00Well, it it's not. I've already said it's a synthetic hormone, it's not a hormone. So there's this sort of gap, and then GPs, you know, family physicians haven't been trained, but it's also not really a money-making specialty because in medicine you make money by procedures and operations. You know, we don't do procedures for our patients, we do a blood test, but you know, so there's a people aren't always interested. And menopause or women, women with hormonal issues, have mental health issues, right? Because it's a brain condition as well. These hormones are made in our brain, so then they're scary.

SPEAKER_00People get very concerned, and then they go to psychiatrists who have no training at all in hormones. So the drugs that the psychiatrists give, the anti-psychotics, will actually worsen hormones because they'll affect prolactin and suppress hormone production even more. So women have got no chance, sadly.

SPEAKER_01So I want to talk about why you do what you do and the importance of why you do what you do. And I want to come at it from a perspective of criticism that I get all the time is that menopause is natural. Why why are you treating it like it's a disease?

SPEAKER_00Well, it's really interesting. So my newsletter came out today, and I wrote about is menopause a disease, and I've written about it in my book, The Power of Hormones. And one person actually, only one, I'm waiting for more, emailed today to say, you've taken it too far now. What are you doing? You're never going to carry people with you. So when you look at the definition of a disease by WHO, the World Health Organization, it says that it's a condition that has identifiable physical or mental health symptoms, and um it can affect the biology of something.

SPEAKER_00Now, I've already said our hormones are biologically active and affect us every cell. So menopause is a hormone deficiency, we have low hormones. So, of course, biologically it's going to affect us. And we know there's a myriad of Symptoms. I mean they vary, but that's the same with underactive thyroid gland hypothyroidism. People vary in their symptoms, it's still a disease. So it does fulfill the uh the sort of criteria for a disease. One of the things that WHO also unhelpfully says is that it's a natural transition, so therefore it shouldn't be a disease. Whereas I would argue, not that I'm here to argue, but there's lots of diseases of aging that we call diseases.

SPEAKER_00So you could say osteoporosis or dementia or hypertension. But then also about four in a hundred women under the age of 40 have menopause at a younger age. It might be, you know, so often we don't know why, or it could be a chemical or surgical menopause. We can't ignore those women because actually their risk of diseases as they age is so much higher because they're so much longer without their hormones. So I think it's naive really to think that it's not a disease. But even if you go, well, this is crazy, it's not a disease, okay, but it's associated with diseases.

SPEAKER_00You know, you've got this whole debate, is obesity a disease? And I'm not here to discuss that, but if you're obese, you're more likely to have heart disease and diabetes. So if you're menopausal, you're more likely to have every single inflammatory condition. So we should be looking at it with some urgency because the incidence of chronic diseases is going up. Life expectancy is increasing, but the last 10 years of a woman's health is often in poor health, often because they've got no hormones in their body.

SPEAKER_00So we can't keep ignoring it and thinking it's just a few hot flushes and sweats.

SPEAKER_01What about the people that that say that you can take the hormones for a period of time to get through that like adjustment, but then you should stop? What's your what's your response to that?

SPEAKER_00So, firstly, the most important thing about taking hormones is that it's a choice. So someone the other day said to me, you know, you seem so liberal with hormones, who would you absolutely never give hormone treatment to? And I would never ever prescribe hormone treatment to women that didn't want it. So the first thing about taking hormone treatments is a choice. But the second thing is that our hormones are designed to work on our every cell in our body, and we have receptors for progesterone, estradiol, testosterone. Our cells don't change as we get older.

SPEAKER_00So they're still responsive, whether we're 22, 62, or 92 to those hormones. But also, we know that we give hormones or prescribe hormones for symptom control, but also for future benefits to health. So I could stop my hormone treatment tomorrow, and I might or might not get symptoms. My body will accommodate. Like if you don't eat for a while, you'll be hungry initially, and then your body will forget telling you that you're hungry. So our body does adapt, but it's it's a new like reset.

SPEAKER_00Like when you talk to people who seem very anti-HRT on with the effects on the brain, they'll say the brain adjusts and changes. Well, I don't want my brain to adjust and change. I want to stay working, I want to be able to multitask, I want to be able to read academic papers, I don't want to sit on the couch and just stare at the four walls. But also, even if I had no symptoms at all, I would have increased bone turnover without my hormones. I would have this increased incidence of osteoporosis, I would have more inflammation, more risk of metabolic conditions and cancers.

SPEAKER_00So as a menopausal woman, I weigh up the benefits and the risks of not having hormones, and I decide to take them because I'm taking bioidentic hormones, the same structure as our own hormones. So my those cells respond in the same way as they did when I was younger.

SPEAKER_01I still continue to heal. Well, you can balance your hormones without taking hormones. So how do you feel about that?

SPEAKER_00So this is interesting, isn't it? Because I was talking to someone yesterday who runs a very large supplement company and he was posting and telling me that his new number his two main products he sells or makes the most money of is probably what he was trying to say, was a menopause supplement and a perimenopause supplement. So I look on the website and it's telling me that it balances your hormones. And I said, Well, firstly, what's the difference between perimenopause and menopause? He said, Oh, well, we've added some more ashwagandal or something because brain fog is worse than perimenopause.

SPEAKER_00I said, Oh, is it really? That's interesting, because in my experience it varies in women. And I said, But how does it balance your hormones? He said, Oh, when it's got phytoestrogens in it. So I said, Okay, so where why would someone take that instead of HRT? He said, Well, those women that really don't want to take HRT or hormones or and those women that can't, I said, okay, well, if they really can't or really don't want to, why are they taking a phytoestrogen? Because I don't understand how a phytoestrogen is more beneficial or less risky than oestradiol.

SPEAKER_00Where's your evidence? And he sort of paused a bit. So I think, you know, if I was if I was deficient, like, don't give me vitamin D. You know, you could give me a cup of tea and I'm tired because I've got low iron and I'd feel better for a little bit having a cup of tea and a chat, but it's not actually going to replace my low iron stores. Right. So do you see what I mean? It's sort of it's also quite patronizing, I think, for women to expect us to live with a hormone deficiency and be expected to have some other treatment.

SPEAKER_00You know, I I mean we can take I take supplements, but I don't take them because I'm menopausal. Because it's a hormone problem. So it's really, it's really simplistic medicine. Like I don't I don't really see when I when I get away from all the emotions and all the toxicity, I don't really understand why it's so complicated. Because it's a really simple thing to address in my mind. I might be missing something.

SPEAKER_01But so for some people, like I just think that's their shtick, right? Like I'm gonna be the aunt the, you know, there's some estrogen-free someone out there. Like I just think for some people, they just decided that that's gonna be the mask that they wear out in public. And I also think that some people are just blindly proceeding and living in just denial because they're asymptomatic, because their bodies have adjusted.

SPEAKER_01And there are some women who truly sail through menopause. I didn't happen to be one of them. I had every single imaginable symptom on steroids.

SPEAKER_00But there are some people who sail through. So it's funny you say that. When you say, um, and I'm not gonna mention any names, but there are various people on social media who say they've sailed through. And I look at their posts, they look so miserable, they've put on weight, they've got frizzy hair, they just they're convincing themselves they're not weight, you know? And kidding themselves. Yeah. But also I see we see quite a lot of women who are in their 70s and 80s, so they're they're they're mothers of our patients who then come to us and say, Can we have hormones?

SPEAKER_00We've missed out. And we're like, Yeah, sure, you can try them and see, you know. And then they say, Gosh, I get up in the morning, I get up really quickly, I don't have that awful joint pain. I'm not going to the toilet three times overnight. I I'm happier. And I thought all those symptoms were just part of being in my 70s and 80s. I'd never have thought it was hormones. Right, so they've just normalized it. Precisely. So the women that sail through, like, are they really have I've never really met a truly asymptomatic woman.

SPEAKER_00But it's so hard to know because until you take hormones, you don't know what your symptoms were that were related to hormones. So these women will never know, really.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Back up and talk about is missing out a thing. Because there is still this belief that if you hit your 60s or you hit 10 years past menopause, that your that your window has closed. So can you talk about that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so this is this window of opportunity that really came out from the ill-fated WHI study, because when they gave women the synthetic hormones and started them over the age of 60, they had a slightly higher risk of or incidence of heart disease. And so people were then going, Oh my goodness, if you give people that've got heart disease already a synthetic hormone, you might then increase their risk of a heart attack or stroke. And so let's, and then the earlier you take it, the better.

SPEAKER_00So then people now say, Well, you can't start HRT over the age of 60. But if you see the evidence it's come from, it's come from the synthetic hormones, which we've already said are completely different. So I would never prescribe madroxy progesterone acetate to anyone because I just think it's a horrible drug and we've got evidence. Yeah, like why would you take it? And so when I give hormones and prescribe them and start them on women over the age of 60, I'm prescribing the bioidentical hormones. We don't have big randomised, we don't have any randomized control studies that are worth looking at.

SPEAKER_00We never will, because how can you randomize someone to a placebo when you know it's a good treatment? Like it's just not ethical to do so. But we've got basic biology and we know that our cells work in the same way, whatever our age is. Like we don't get to our 60th birthday, and then our cells suddenly go, no, we're going to be really anti-estrogen, we're not going a progesterone. People, when I really quiz them, which I do, and that's why I annoy people, like, how, why are you so worried? They say, Well, if we've if the woman's got an unstable plaque, and then you give them oestradiol, and they get relaxation of their blood vessels, it might dislodge the plaque, and then they might have a stroke.

SPEAKER_00So, but then I've done a lot of cardiology at heart medicine, and people who come in with a heart attack who have got a thrombus in in one of their arteries, we used to give them nepedopine or amlodopine, calcium antagonists that really dilate the blood vessels. And no one's worried about those women having a stroke or men having a stroke. So that doesn't really add up. We know that estradyle, progesterone, and testosterone are very anti-inflammatory on the endothelium, the lining of the blood vessels. And so we want to reduce inflammation, even if people have got heart disease.

SPEAKER_00So those women that have had heart attacks can still take bioidentic hormones. So again, it's if people are saying you can't have HRT over the age of 60, we have to be really careful with our language. Which hormone are you talking about? Are you talking about the bioidentical, like for like, or are you talking about synthetic? And that's the really big difference.

SPEAKER_01There is still so much resistance to bioidentical hormones for the reason that you talked about, because they they say that there are no big studies, you know, no 65,000 women studies. I I actually deal with this all the time with QT because people say, well, I'll use it after, you know, there are 65,000 studies. But a lack of evidence does not equal danger, first of all.

SPEAKER_01And second of all, there is inherent danger in waiting for the studies because in the meantime, we are letting women die. We in in the in the area of breast cancer screening, we are in the meantime exposing them to radiation, right? So we're actually harming these women while we are allegedly waiting for the big study.

SPEAKER_00So, well, firstly, let me really disappoint everyone who's listening because there will never be a big study. Because for two reasons. Firstly, studies are usually funded by pharmaceutical companies, right? There's no big pharma interested in natural bioidential hormones because you make your money by having a new drug with a new so the the contraceptors every few years make a new synthetic progestogen, that's where they make their money. So there's no drug companies going to be involved. But secondly, how can you design a randomized control study with something that has evidence that it reduces incidence of osteoporosis?

SPEAKER_00So hormone treatment is licensed to reduce osteoporosis, which affects one in two women. So, say for example, you have this study, randomized control study. Now it's very hard to give a placebo, you'll know quite quickly it's placebo because HLT will help with symptoms. But that aside, say I was in, you were designing the study, I was one of the recruits, and you and I got, you didn't know because it's double-blinded, a placebo. And then 10 years later I get an osteoportic hip fracture. It's not going to look very good for the study designers when I say, but you've given me placebo, yet you knew that if you were giving me HRT, I could have had less risk of osteoporosis.

SPEAKER_00So that's why ethically you're not going to get a randomised controlled study. But I not everything in medicine needs a randomised controlled study. So when they when they designed and discovered penicillin, which is probably the next biggest discovery to I think hormones, penicillin and and um uh and hand washing are the three things that have made the biggest difference, really, for medicine. But when they discover penicillin and they realize that it worked and they could understand how it worked, they're never going to give someone with sepsis a placebo to see whether which is better.

SPEAKER_00You know, if you're designing a new parachute, you're not gonna do a randomized controlled study and give someone a placebo on their back and get them to jump out of a plane. I mean, that's an extreme example. You know, we don't always see when you know how these hormones work. Like when you look at the physiology, so we're talking about these bioidentical hormones, which are the same structure as our own hormones. And then often in medicine, double standards, because if I said to you, right, where are the studies that show that SSRIs, antidepressants, are beneficial for postnatal depression and postnatal psychosis?

SPEAKER_00I can't find any really good randomized control studies because they're not being done. But no what worries about that? And when I was asking some psychiatrists recently, they said, Oh, but they're on the guidelines, Louise. But the guidelines are not randomized controlled studies, but it we don't always have to have randomized control studies. Often in medicine you have to have some common sense, and the common sense about hormones has just seemed to be gone, and that's where I find it's it's almost like embarrassing, actually, that clinicians, policymakers are being so stupid about this because it's not difficult when you understand the biology.

SPEAKER_01And when you come up against the societies who the societies are generally not recommending bioidentical and the criticisms are crazy. I mean, I know that Avram Blooming, and believe me, I love this man and respect what he has done for the hormone replacement movement, but when he updated his book and he trashed compounding pharmacies and bioidentical hormones, like why we're we're on the same team, and why are you fighting with us?

SPEAKER_01We're we're just trying to help. And to go out there and make compounders the the enemy and and make it like they're the wild, wild west or you know, cowboys, it's crazy.

SPEAKER_00You see, I think I was talking to someone actually earlier today about compounding because when I went, I don't go to any menopause society's um conferences now, but when I did 10 years ago, one of the lectures was about compounding and saying how dangerous it was, how bad it was. And and I sat there and thought, gosh, okay, because I'm a doctor, you learn by osmosis, and you know, you think what people tell you is right. And and then I sat back over the last few years and thought, hang on a minute, like when I was doing oncology and we were making up chemotherapy, that was compounded, it was individualized for people.

SPEAKER_00When I was doing pediatrics and people couldn't swallow tablets, they would compound a liquid of the the you know the preparation. A lot of dermatologists I know compound different face products or or skin products for the patient. So our NHS compound a lot. So then also when we prescribe easter dial through the skin as a patch or gel, we're really limited in our products. And lots of people know because a whole panorama documentary was made about me not um absorbing very well through the skin.

SPEAKER_00So I've been using a higher than licensed dose of patches. The gel floats off my skin, so you could put me in a bath a bit and it wouldn't make any difference. The patches don't stick very well. So then I've been using a compounded preparation, and it's been like genius because I don't need nearly as high a dose, and it's very personalized because we know the structure, and a lot of the compounding pharmacies really understand pharmacology well, they understand absorption. It it seems a bit crazy. Um, so again, it all depends who you work with, what the pharmacy's like, what the product's like, but they're all regulated.

SPEAKER_00It's um highly regulated. Yeah, well, they they really are, and um, you know, it gives people more choice. The other thing with testosterone is we can prescribe it as a pump, so it's a lot easier that you can say give them a pump of testosterone rather than a sachet that's slippy slidy gel that you don't know how much you're giving. So it's actually can be safer as well.

SPEAKER_01You touched on perimenopause a little bit, and this is like the next emerging front. So, can you talk to me a little bit about your approach to the perimenopausal woman and how you meet her where she is?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so so do you know what? I hate the word menopause, and I really hate the word perimenopause because it's not explaining no, no, no, and it's because it's not explaining anything, is it? Hang on, sorry. No worries, it happens. Uh let me just switch that off. Sorry. So I'll go back. I actually really don't like the word perimenopause or menopause because it's not really explaining what's going on in the woman's body. Menopause stopping periods for a year. Like, what the hell? How does that help someone?

SPEAKER_00And then perimenopause, peri is around the time of. So around the time of something that's going to happen in a year's time, like it's like clinically it's nonsense, and actually describing to people doesn't mean anything. But also, I think we need to use language really well, and so I much prefer looking at those three hormones separately and thinking, has my patient or the woman, has she got a progesterone deficiency, an estradiol deficiency, a testosterone deficiency, or does she have all three? And as you know, testosterone tends to decline in the late 20s, early 30s.

SPEAKER_00So I see a lot of women who have regular periods and they have a testosterone deficiency. I see a lot of women with PMS or PMDD who have progesterone deficiency for a few days maybe before their periods. So then they only need progesterone for those few days. And then in the so-called perimenopause, we've got up and downs of estradiol. Progesterone tends to be low, and testosterone is often low as well. So then we bespoke, it's really lovely you prescribe those hormones separately.

SPEAKER_00Some of my patients, I give testosterone and progesterone, maybe not estradyle, especially if they've got histamine intolerance or muscle activation. And other women might just need a little bit of estrogen and you know, different dose of progesterone, it really varies. But I think when you strip it back, it's a lot easier because the perimenopause is like you're trying to chase a moving target, you don't know the levels, it's all a bit over, up and down. So using the hormones separately and balancing those three hormones can make a big difference.

SPEAKER_01It's amazing to me. I find I come across a lot of people, and I think this has to do with the education in the US, and I'm sure you you have the same thing. They're perfectly willing to prescribe estrogen and progesterone, and there is this like complete and utter block with testosterone. Well, what do you think that's about?

SPEAKER_00So I think it's a lot about ignorance, medical misogyny, bitter gastriting, and just stupidity. I'm really sorry to use those words. But you know, if I'd spoken to you 12, 13 years ago, I wouldn't have even known women had testosterone in their bodies because no one taught me. So I would have gone, oh, I'm not really sure what you're talking about. But when testosterone was mentioned in the NICE guidance, and I was like, hang on, testosterone women, what's going on? So rather than thinking that's ridiculous, I go back to basics and I look at the physiology of ourselves and realize how stupid am I because when testosterone was discovered in the 1940s, it was a female hormone as well, and they used to prescribe it for women in the 40s and 50s with very good effects.

SPEAKER_00So then I realized that actually when they commercialized testosterone and made it synthetic, the whole water and hydrogen peroxide thing comes into play with testosterone. So this anabolic steroid that everyone's worried about, and the risk of clot and side effects and risks is all with the synthetic testosterone. So I never prescribe. I prescribe bioidentical testosterone, usually as a cream or a gel. So then I'm not worried about all that stuff. But I think people confuse what they're talking about when they talk about testosterone.

SPEAKER_00And then because the only data is of a randomized controlled study is looking at libido, everyone is so literal and thinking it's just a hormone for libido. And then a lot of menopause societies have got this term HSDD, hypoactive sexual desire disorder. And you know, if you read the criteria, women have to be severely psychologically distressed with their. Reduced libido for at least six months. Like, what the hell? How am I going to look at my patients for five and a half months and say, oh no, sorry, come back in two weeks of time?

SPEAKER_02Time is not up yet.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And how do I assess whether they're severely psychologically distressed or just moderately psychologically distressed or mildly? Like it's just rubbish. And then, like, it's almost embarrassing that people think that this hormone only works on one area of our brain. And in women, there's only one area of our brain that affects libido. Like it just seems so nonsense, actually, when you when you actually unpick it. And then most of us that prescribe testosterone or or women that take it find that it's not just the libido, it's mood, energy, concentration, stamina, migraines, joint pain, sleep.

SPEAKER_00And it makes up like absolutely just just like enjoying life. You know, it's not a bad hobby. So, and also, you know, as you know, so much data that we learn from medical school is based on a 70 kilogram man. So all the benefits of, you know, blood pressure drugs, whatever. But somehow we've got loads of data about testosterone in men, showing it reduces incidence of heart disease and diabetes and so forth. Yet we have to ignore that when we're talking about testosterone for women.

SPEAKER_00So it doesn't make sense actually. So, but again, it goes back to choice. You know, a lot of women that I see in my clinic really want testosterone and they improve. And I sorry, I do not believe it's a placebo effect.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, I agree with you. All right, I want to move into the shark-infested waters. So this is the pool that I swim in. I know this is a pool that you swim in. Let's start with the woman that came to me last week. She is um in her late 30s. She had a very early ovarian cancer in her family. She has the same braca mutation that her family member had, her mom had.

SPEAKER_01And she went to the gynecologic oncologist and he said, Yes, we should absolutely take your ovaries out. And she said, Okay, what about hormone replacement? And he said, You are not a candidate for hormone replacement because you have a BRCA mutation. How do you feel about that?

SPEAKER_00There's lots to unpick that, but I feel like first thing is where's the evidence for that statement? Where is the evidence that women who have a BRCA mutation can't have hormone treatments? Because I tell you what, there isn't any.

SPEAKER_01There's actually evidence to the contrary. Of course there is.

SPEAKER_00Of course there is. So with ovarian cancer, there's no evidence that our natural hormones, the biodential hormones or our endogenous hormones, will increase incidence of ovarian cancer, or if we've had ovarian cancer, that will worsen outcomes. So, and and and having bracky, yes, there might be an increased incidence of breast and ovarian cancer, but that's irrelevant of hormones. And like you say, there's some evidence that women who take bioidentic hormones are less likely to have breast and ovarian cancer.

SPEAKER_00So it's wrong.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, like in the in the area of breast cancer, a 30% reduction. Reduction. Yes. And even the even the gynecologic oncologists, because it's usually those people or the oncologist or the gynecologists that are getting them started, because the oncologists across the board tell them that they can't have hormones. They're all insisting stopping sometime between the age of 51 and 52 at the time of normal menopause.

SPEAKER_01Like across the board. These are the recommendations from the societies. And so I I want people to know and let them hear it from you. We have to stop confusing the recommendations from the societies as fact. And we also have to stop confusing them with based on scientific scientific evidence, because most of the time it's just dogma.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I think this is really important when we talk about guidelines, actually. Um, firstly, guidelines are what they say, they are a guide. But secondly, we have to be really careful who's written them as well. So usually these ones like like these are from menopause societies. Now, menopause societies have no regulatory status at all. And it's really important people know that I recently took the British Menopause Society to court and had to have a high court judge in London at the court saying that they are nothing more than a membership society and they have no regulatory status was really important, and it's in the public domain, so but it's really important that people know, and that's the same for your menopause society, the International Metapolis Society.

SPEAKER_00I'm I'm not being rude about them, I'm just saying they are a membership society, they have no regulatory status. So, in the court of law, working out of those guidelines means nothing. What we have to do in medicine, and the first thing we're taught pretty much at medical school is first do no harm. And I think this is really important because a lot of people think harm is if you prescribe something or you do the wrong operation, you're doing something harmful. But actually, in the conversation of hormone treatments, there's more harm to women of avoiding hormone treatments than giving them.

SPEAKER_00Because for women, for example, a young woman with a brachogen, she doesn't have hormone treatment. She has, in its fact, an increased incidence of all inflammatory conditions. We've talked about osteoporosis, heart disease, other cancers, autoimmune diseases, Parkinson's disease, motor neuron disease, inflammatory brown disease, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. These will all increase without hormone treatment. That incidence of diseases will continue after the so-called natural age of menopause 51, 52, whatever it is.

SPEAKER_00And so we shouldn't be stopping because you're still harming women by not allowing them to make the choice. And I think when you talk about making the choice, then that's better than saying you have to prescribe, you have to not prescribe. Because, you know, we've all had patients, for example, who are Jehovah's Witness. We know if they're bleeding to death, they need blood, but they don't want it. We respect their decision. And that's the same with hormone treatments. You know, if women don't want hormone treatments, firstly, don't come and listen to me on social media.

SPEAKER_00Secondly, don't even enter the conversation. But thirdly, don't use your own experience to dissuade people to have an evidence-based treatment. And I think it's really important that we take all emotion out and allow women to choose based on their future health as well. Because you see these women, and I see a lot of them who just say, My life could have been so different if I'd started this 10 years before. And it's really quite sad. I remember the first, like the first review patient I saw in my clinic, and it was a lady who was 38, and I wasn't very confident then, and she hadn't had the raised FSH blood test because I've always thought it was a bit stupid having this blood test to make diagnose POI premature ovarian insufficiency.

SPEAKER_00And I and I just did a history and she had all the symptoms under the sun. She'd stopped her work, she was a psychotherapist, and she just couldn't concentrate with her work. She's having several showers for her flushes, she couldn't take a dog for a walk, she started walking with a stick. And I just said to her, Look, it I feel it's related to her hormones, the blood test isn't very helpful. And I gave her hormone treatment and then she came back three months later. And I remember she started crying, and I thought, oh my gosh, what have I done to this woman? And she started crying because she said, I've realized now how my life could have been for the last 10 years.

SPEAKER_00I walk without a stick, I'm walking my dog, I'm now working part-time, and I just thought, gosh, this is so cruel. It's not about, you know, making people's lives better. It's about women's lives being worse without this treatment that is just an evidence-based hormone treatment. And I think we have to look people more in the eyes and say, are you really happy not prescribing this treatment for these women? Yeah. Because that's what's happening for most women.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, we we have to at the same time acknowledge that there is an inherent danger to not putting women on hormones. There is an inherent danger. They are more likely to have cardiovascular disease, neurodegenerative disease, osteoporosis, osteoarthritis, psycho, psychosocial dysfunction, sexual dysfunction, neurogeneral, neuro. These things are very, very real. And there is an inherent danger.

SPEAKER_01So when we when we look to these guidelines, right, or when we when we think that we are keeping women safe, we're actually putting them in danger. Now, I I believe that everyone should be able to make their own decision, but they have to be able to make an educated decision. And right now, they are not given the information in order to give, to make an educated decision.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that's and that's really, really difficult. But actually, I feel like over the last eight to ten years, women are getting hold of more information actually than the healthcare professionals. And you know, with like the balance app that I created, lots of people are finding out information that they've never had before. But that's the almost worse in some ways. I was doing um an education event in Glasgow in Scotland in a very deprived area for a charity last weekend, and you know, there were so many tears in the room, and these women know about the benefits.

SPEAKER_00They really want testosterone, they really want biodentrical hormones, and they're being prescribed antidepressants and antipsychotics, they're being turned away. And I think, God, it's 2026. Like, what are we doing? If these women didn't want their hormones, I wouldn't bother work getting up in the morning, I wouldn't bother working because you know my job is really just to empower women to have choices. But the side effect of my work is that women are just pleading for hormones. Like, it's easier to get hold of cracker cane, heroin, meths than it is to get hold of testosterone.

SPEAKER_00I don't really understand. And I tell you what, people are going to these drugs, they are becoming addicted because they can't do that. Yeah, they're self-medicating. Absolutely. And that's, you know, the medical system, you know, yours and ours and in other countries is failing women. And I don't know why people aren't seeing it as a priority, actually.

SPEAKER_01Let's segue to the breast cancer population. And before we got on air today, we started to talk about women who were coming to you, and they're coming to you and saying, not only do they want hormones, but they are actively refusing tamoxifen. They're actively refusing aromatase inhibition. And these are the women that are coming to find me too. So why how do you approach these women and how do you handle these conversations?

SPEAKER_00So it's and it's difficult. It's a really hard conversation because everything we do in medicine is personized and individual. And the the most important guidelines I think we have are the shared decision-making guidelines where women, the patients, and physicians can work together. So the important thing in the first aspect is educating women what it means by having an estrogen receptor positive breast cancer. Because I hear words estrogen-driven, estrogen-sensitive, estrogen, what, like, what the hell?

SPEAKER_00Like, I think, you know, when people know we have estrogen receptors on every cell in our body, and yes, of course, you're going to have estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone receptors if you have breast cancer, unless it's become mutated and it loses its receptor status and then becomes estrogen receptor negative. I think people think it's the other way around. It's all estrogen receptor negative, and then it grows its receptor and its estrogen causes it. So I think that's one thing that's really important for people to understand. The second thing is that there are different types of estrogen.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, there's estradiol, which we've talked about, there's oestriol and there's estrone. Estrone is the inflammatory type of estrogen that actually more women have as they age because their estradiol declines. And so if you're looking at any type of estrogen and you're picking the baddie, you would go for estrone, not estradiol. So I think that's an important conversation, regardless of whether someone's going to take hormone treatment or not, because so many women are actually feel really guilty for taking if they if they've been on a hormone treatment, biological bioidentical hormones, and then they get cancer, the number of women who are told because you took HRT, you've got breast cancer.

SPEAKER_00So I think it's important for people not to blame themselves because I'm not aware, and you will tell me differently if there is, but I'm not aware there's any evidence that estradiol causes breast cancer.

SPEAKER_01There's absolutely no evidence. In fact, there's evidence to the contrary.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Right. So that's but that's really important for women, regardless of whether they take hormone treatment after breast cancer or not, that they should never be feeling bad for taking hormone treatment.

SPEAKER_01And let's add in that exactly no one who is on hormone replacement is being replaced with estrone.

unknownRight?

SPEAKER_01That's exactly no one.

SPEAKER_00No. Yeah. So so then when I have a patient in front of me, it's all so much is about, firstly, what they want, but also the type of cancer, how long ago it was, what other treatment they've had, what their concerns are. All of this needs to be taken into consideration because oncologists are often on a conveyor belt, it's very conveyable medicine, tick box medicine, really. You've had this breast cancer, so therefore you have this treatment, you might have this hormone blocker, you might have da da da. And these women are just like, of course, it's very emotional when you've had a cancer diagnosis.

SPEAKER_00So that, yeah, give me everything, give me everything. And then they leave the room and they don't really know. And when I sit down and say to people, have you looked at the predic score? Have you gone through the real benefits for this treatment that you're given? And so a lot of women who are given aromatase inhibitors, you know, every single cell of estrogen is squeezed or estradian, is squeezed from their body. They're like a dry sponge, they're screaming at nighttime with joint pain. They've got such bad vaginal dryness and soreness they can't sit down. They can't think.

SPEAKER_00Like they're they're, you know, and this is a generalization. Some people don't have such extreme. And then I saw someone yesterday.

SPEAKER_01But there are some that are even worse than that, and they can't move and they can't sleep, and it they're they're absolutely miserable.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I saw someone yesterday, and she was told to stay on her rheumatase inhibitor. You might as well stay on it for life, is what her oncologist said. And she's 60. Like, why? So the first thing is is looking at the treatment that they've been offered and given, because I think that's really important just to go through that with them. A lot of people are given tamoxifen. I saw somebody on Instagram yesterday talking about tamoxifen to prevent breast cancer, and she was talking about low doses of tamoxifen and making it sound really quite lovely.

SPEAKER_00But there are risks with tamoxifen, there are risks of cancer of the lining of the womb, there are risks of clot. The risks are small, but we need to be talking about risks as well so people can weigh that up as well. Because if their if their percentage benefit from taking one of these drugs is small, it has to offset the risks. So the the risks with tamoxifen, with aromatase inhibitors, there's risks of to the future health of osteoporosis and heart disease and dementia. So that needs to be really taken into consideration.

SPEAKER_00And then also when you're talking about giving HRT after breast cancer diagnosis, we have to be really careful again with our language. Are we talking about testosterone? Are we talking about estradiol? Are we talking about progesterone? And we we published a series where we were giving testosterone on its own to women with breast cancer, and a lot of their symptoms really improved, so we didn't even have that whole estrogen conversation. Sometimes people just take progesterone. I saw someone in my clinic um a couple of weeks ago who'd been diagnosed with estrogen receptor positive breast cancer 12 years ago.

SPEAKER_00She'd had some aromatase inhibitors, she felt dreadful. Now she was on nothing apart from bisphosphonates because she's got osteoporosis, of course, and she's feeling absolutely dreadful, like so awful. And I said, Well, we can start with testosterone. She goes, No, no, no, I want all three. And I also want pedagogical hormones because I keep getting UTIs. I've read everything, I've listened to your podcast, I've read books, I've read papers, and I want this. And it's like, that's great. And I said, but what about your oncologist? What did they say? And uh she said, the oncologist said to me, Are you stupid, even thinking about hormone treatments?

SPEAKER_00Get out of my room. Like, I'm not talking about to you. So, like, if she can't engage with the oncologist, then it's crazy. But the other thing I wanted to say though, I see a lot of young women who've had a diagnosis of breast cancer in their 20s and 30s, they've been on whatever treatment, and then their periods come back. And the oncologists go, oh, you'll feel a bit better, your periods will come back. And then they go through menopause at that, you know, in their late 40s, maybe, periods stop, or their symptoms are feeling dreadful. And then the oncologists say, No, you can't have hormone treatments, but then they've had their periods.

SPEAKER_00And like I can't, I don't know if I'm missing something, but I can't quite understand why they're allowed to have their periods, but they're not allowed to have biodential hormones. It feels a bit weird.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I I just want to interject a little bit in this space because like this is the stuff that makes steam come out of my ears. Women who take hormones get breast cancer. Women who don't take hormones get breast cancer because it's not the hormones. Women after breast cancer who take hormones have recurrences. Women after breast cancer who don't take hormones have recurrences because it's not the hormones. And until we admit that it's everything else and has nothing to do with the hormones, and when I say we, we as a collective caregiver, as a collective provider, as a collective society, we need to abandon this narrative that it's somehow the hormones.

SPEAKER_01Now, when I'm talking hormones, I mean the same thing that you mean. I mean bioidentical, because there is pretty good evidence that when you use things like madroxy progesterone or the progestins, there is good evidence that they they are mutagenic, they are carcinogenic, and we do reliably see increases in primary breast cancer and increases in recurrence in those populations that we don't see with bioidentical.

SPEAKER_01But again, we're never gonna have that big study because who's paying for it? Because the pharmaceutical companies, the last thing they want is more evidence that bioidenticals are safe and their products are not, so they're not paying for it. And who's paying for bioidentical hormone replacement studies? No one, exactly no one. But we have to we have to remember, and we talked about this a little before, that a lack of evidence is not evidence of danger, and there is a cost to not treating these women, there's an absolute built-in cost.

SPEAKER_01So I I want to be respectful of your time. I want to ask you one last question. Is there someone who comes to you for hormone replacement and you say no to?

SPEAKER_00So the only person that I would say no to is women who don't want to take hormone treatment, but they wouldn't come to me. So there is no one that I wouldn't give hormone treatment to because I don't see any absolute contraindications for taking a hormone treatment. You know, the the most extreme, if you like, is someone I I met eight years ago who had she'd just started her HRT. She'd had awful, awful mental health symptoms, you know, close to ending her life. And she came to see me three months after the first concept.

SPEAKER_00She had this big lump in her breast, and it was obviously a breast cancer. It was, you know, lots of skin tethering, it was craggy, it was hard, and it literally just appeared. And I looked at her and I said, What are you gonna do about your HRT? And this was eight years ago, I wasn't as experienced as I am now. And I said, Well, we haven't got the diagnosis, have the diagnosis first, and then we'll see. Anyway, she had this very aggressive breast cancer, and so I spoke to her oncologist, and I said, Look, I'm quite worried about her mental health. Like she's got this big diagnosis, and and he said, Well, we're gonna give her neoadjuvant chemotherapy, so the chemotherapy before surgery, then she's gonna have surgery.

SPEAKER_00He said, To be honest, we're gonna give her such strong drugs. Her hormone treatment is gonna make no difference at all. And I was like, What? You're an oncologist, you've said so. She's carried on her hormone treatment, and um, eight years later, she is just living the best life ever. And I've done a podcast with her actually, because I was really scared at the time, but it was very much shared. And then about four years ago, she tried to reduce it because she changed GP. She said, What are you doing? You've had breast cancer. She didn't tell her husband, and then she went down this black hole and he was really worried. And then he said, You've got to tell me, have you stopped your hormones?

SPEAKER_00And she said, Yes. And you know, the risk of death from suicide is 100%, your risk of death from a recurrence of breast cancer. Is thankfully not 100%. So again, it's looking at that harm. I could be criticized for giving someone a highly aggressive breast cancer hormone treatment, but I would be more criticized by not giving it to her when it was saving her life from her very intrusive thoughts. So, yeah, so there's no one that I would not give hormone treatment to.

SPEAKER_01That's that's so interesting to hear. And I and I love to hear that story. And that's kind of the hill that I will die on as well, in that I don't think we're serving people by having these templates, right? And if you have breast cancer, you need X, Y, and Z. And the conventional medicine has completely abandoned what the woman can do to help herself heal. And they've also denied how we used to treat breast cancer before we had these medicines.

SPEAKER_01So before there was tamoxifen, what did we use? We used progesterone and we used high dose estrogens. That's what we used to treat breast cancer with response rates that are well beyond what we see with modern drugs.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01It's amazing, isn't it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. I mean, there's some great pictures of these big fungating cancers that shrink away with high doses of estadiol. So yeah, I think when we don't know anything, it's very easy to retreat and say no when we think we're doing a good job. But I really urge clinicians to just think and consider. And are they doing the best thing for them patient for saying no?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And and remembering that there is an inherent danger to saying no, right? We are we are exposing these women to dire consequences, long-term dire consequences, and not living life to its fullest. And I think as as providers, we all have to remember that. And that is that is our burden to bear. And I love that you said we have to maintain curiosity. And we have to know that there are better ways to do it than to treat everyone the same and to allow for suffering.

SPEAKER_01To allow for suffering and to wait for a huge study that's never coming to be able to offer women the opportunity to live long, healthy lives and in the words of D Dr. David Rosensweet, keep them out of wheelchairs, nursing homes, and adult diapers. Like this is our responsibility. This is what we should be doing. And if going against convention is how we have to do it, I'm all in.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I mean, one thing I'd like to just end actually and say is that taking hormones is reversible. You're not pinned down and you don't have to take them forever. So the second consultation when I've seen someone who's had breast cancer is often the most important consultation. Because I always say to women, you don't know how you're going to feel until you've taken it. And a lot of women, you know, if I see a woman who every day is worrying about recurrence, she can't sleep, she's so worried because of taking hormone treatments, then it's probably not the best thing for her to do.

SPEAKER_00But when women come back and say, Do you know what, Louise, my mental health is improved, my sleep's improved, my quality of life is improved, my relationship's improved, my ability to exercise is has improved. Like this is a quality of life I didn't have before. I'm not even thinking about recurrence, and if it happens, I'll deal with it. But I'm, you know, and so it's for them to decide. But if they stop, the hormones will be out of their body in the 24 hours or so. So it's a reversible decision. And I think when I say that to people, I can see their shoulders go down a few inches, and then I, okay, so and I think that's important.

SPEAKER_00They're not judged for trying it or thinking about it, and then maybe coming back to the decision after a few months. It is absolutely fine as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And you know, I think we should think that way about most things, in that we try them, we see if they work for us, but just don't assume that anything is forever. And I find that with hormones, everyone is a little different and everyone responds a little differently. And it it might take some time to get the person on their right combination, but when they arrive there, they know they know a state that has been missing in their life for so long.

SPEAKER_01And that's what fuels me, that's what fuels you. And I just hope that more providers learn, become hormone literate, and allow women to live the life that they deserve to live. Yeah, absolutely. Dr. Lewis, how can people find you? How can they get more of you?

SPEAKER_00Thank you. The easiest way is just to go to my website, which is dr for doctor, drluisenewson.co.uk, and then people can springboard to my podcast, to my balance app, to the clinic. You know, there's lots of information. What's your what's the name of your podcast? Dr. Louise Newsom.

SPEAKER_01Amazing, amazing. And you have awesome social media. So make sure that you're following Dr. Louise Newsome. And thank you so much for coming on here today and for sharing your mission and your wisdom with my followers and with my community. I'm so, so, so grateful. And if you saw yourself today as someone who wants to be part of this conversation, please do reach out because having a BRACA mutation, coming from a breast cancer family, even having a history of breast cancer is not a contraindication to hormone replacement.

SPEAKER_01And as we learned today, hormone replacement has benefits for everyone in every stage of this menopausal journey. It is a disease in and of itself. It is a deficiency, it is very real. You're not gonna get, you're not gonna get relief from taking these supplements or eating a certain way or anything like that. And just know that there are people out there who are committed to helping you. And if you're looking for help in this area, please reach out to me at perfectionimaging.com.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for joining me today. Know that I will be back next week, same time, same place. It's Dr. Jen. Bye for now. So that's it for today's episode of Keeping a Breast with Dr. Jen. Wherever you are on your breast health journey, screening, a new diagnosis, navigating life before, during, or after treatment, you don't have to figure it out alone.

SPEAKER_01That's exactly what we built perfection imaging and wellness to do. Go to perfectionimaging.com to find real answers and real support, whatever stage you're in. Remember, perfection is spelled with a QT in the middle. If this conversation gave you something to think about, share it with a woman who needs to hear it and leave us a review. It helps more women find this show. I'm Dr. Jen. I'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 171 : Rethinking Breast Cancer Screening: QT Imaging and Prevention with Dr. Jenn Simmons

    Nov 16, 202622 minAudio

    What if breast health means looking beyond imaging for disease and paying closer attention to individual risk and prevention? In this episode of Keeping A Breast with Dr. Jenn, Dr. Jenn Simmons explains QT breast...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 170: Could Chronic Infections Be the Missing Link in Breast Cancer?

    Nov 8, 202656 minAudio

    Lyme, Bartonella & Hidden Inflammation with Dr. Casey Kelley What if the reason you're exhausted, struggling with brain fog, experiencing night sweats, or dealing with unexplained inflammation has nothing to do with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 160 : What Is a QT Scan? The Breast Imaging Technology Changing the Conversation

    Nov 1, 202617 minAudio

    Beyond the Mammogram: Why Dr. Jenn Simmons Believes QT Imaging Is the Future of Breast Cancer Screening What if breast cancer screening could give women more information without radiation, painful compression, or...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 158 : IBS, finding and treating the root cause of irritable bowel syndrome

    Sep 28, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Dr. Jenn Simmons speaks with pharmacist turned integrative health author Dr. Isabella Wentz about the hidden drivers of IBS, why so many people get mislabeled without answers, and how gut issues can connect to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 157 : Why Functional Medicine Went Mainstream After Being Dismissed for Years

    Sep 12, 20261 hr 19 minAudio

    Dr. Jenn Simmons talks with Dr. Robin Berzin about her path from an unexpected pre-med background to conventional medical training, then into functional medicine and entrepreneurship. The conversation covers the roots...

    Credit the people on this episode