Send us Fan Mail Have you ever had a moment of incredible clarity? A flash of inspiration that made you see your life, your relationships, or your purpose completely differently? You felt certain something was about to change. Then a few days later, life went back to normal. Why does that happen? In Lesson 21 of Kabbalah for Everyone, Rabbi Yisroel Bernath explores Binah, the second intellectual faculty of the soul, and reveals how we transform fleeting moments of inspiration into genuine understanding and lasting personal growth. Drawing from the Tanya, Chabad Chassidut, and everyday human experience, Rabbi Bernath explains the difference between Chochmah, the initial spark of wisdom, and Binah, the patient process of developing that spark into something meaningful. Discover why intuition isn't always truth, why overthinking can prevent genuine understanding, and how our interpretations shape our emotions, relationships, and decisions. Through relatable stories about marriage, parenting, difficult conversations, spiritual growth, and even those text messages we probably shouldn't send, this lesson introduces the Three Dimensions of Binah: Depth, Breadth, and Length. You'll also learn a practical 90-second exercise to help you pause, question your assumptions, and respond with greater wisdom. At its heart, this lesson offers a beautiful perspective on love and relationships: perhaps truly loving someone means remaining curious enough to keep discovering who they are. Because sometimes the most powerful words we can say are simply… Help me understand. Download the PDF Worksheet HERE: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/z7v81y588z41fl2ixhaeh/Lesson-21-Binah-Stay-With-It.pdf?rlkey=ijobgb6pfa4iali9pk55082za&dl=0 Key Points Chochmah vs. Binah vs. Daat: Discover how wisdom begins as a flash, develops into understanding, and eventually becomes a truth we can internalize. Why inspiration fades: Understand why powerful spiritual experiences and life-changing realizations don't automatically produce lasting transformation. The Three Dimensions of Binah: Learn to develop any idea through depth (what is really true?), breadth (what else matters?), and length (how does this apply to real life?). The danger of premature certainty: Explore how quickly we interpret situations, assume intentions, and turn incomplete information into emotional stories. Understanding before reacting: Learn how Binah can transform difficult conversations, communication in marriage, parenting, and personal relationships. When thinking becomes overthinking: Recognize the difference between healthy contemplation that produces clarity and endless rumination that keeps us stuck. Wisdom and timing: Discover why even the right idea can become harmful when applied at the wrong moment, and how genuine understanding includes knowing when and how to act. Humility without becoming a doormat: Understand why bittul, the Chassidic concept of self-transcendence, does not require abandoning personal dignity or healthy boundaries. The 90-Second Binah Practice: Ask three questions before responding: What actually happened? What else could be true? What response fits this moment? Binah as a form of love: Discover why deep relationships require patience, curiosity, listening, and the willingness to understand another person beyond our first impressions. Turning knowledge into spiritual growth: Explore the Chabad practice of hisbonenus, contemplation that allows Divine wisdom to become personally meaningful. #Binah #Chochmah #Kabbalah #chassidus #Tanya #JewishWisdom #JewishSpirituality #chabad #kabala #chassidut #personalgrowth Support the show Got your own question for Rabbi Bernath? He can be reached at rabbi@jewishndg.com or http://www.theloverabbi.com Single? You can make a profile on www.JMontreal.com and Rabbi Bernath will help you find that special someone. Donate and support Rabbi Bernath’s work http://www.jewishndg.com/donate Follow Rabbi Bernath’s YouTube Channel https://www.youtube.com/user/ybernath Access Rabbi Bernath's Articles on Relationships https://medium.com/@loverabbi
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Good morning everyone. It is a beautiful morning. So happy to be back together. And we're going to continue today our conversation on the Sefirot. We're going to work on the second of the intellectual Sefirot. So I think you'll know now for the next uh I guess eight classes what the next topic will be as we go and work through the Svirot.
SPEAKER_00So last week we spent almost the entire class talking about the first of the intellectual sevirot, Chachma, the flash, the moment of insight, the opening. If you remember, we called it Koachma, right? The ability to step back from what I already think I know and ask what?
SPEAKER_00Right? The power, the power of what? What am I not seeing? What is true here? What does God want? And after the class, many of you gave perfect introductions to today's class. Someone spoke about how difficult it is in our world to find enough quiet to even ask the question with all the noise, the phones, the text, social media, business, constant stimulation.
SPEAKER_00Someone else said sometimes we have to shut everything down long enough to ask what does God want from me? Someone else said that they have begun getting better at not answering immediately when someone triggers them. They step away, they breathe, and then a minute later they realize that they're grateful, they didn't react. Somebody else said that they caught themselves in conversations waiting for their turn to speak rather than really listening.
SPEAKER_00And that noticing, it's a it's just a beautiful, beautiful note noticing. And so uh for those of you who are listening to this later, we have a beautiful class and uh the ability to have some wonderful discussions here, which I'm looking forward to today. One of the the questions that I think comes up when we talk about Chachma is how do we make room for that flash?
SPEAKER_00And that was really, I would say, the focus of last week's class. So today, as we get into Bina, I want to continue that question, continue that conversation, and ask, what do I do once the flash arrives? So I want to give you this sentence right at the beginning. And maybe this is the line that you can remember today.
SPEAKER_00A flash of inspiration deserves attention, but does not automatically deserve obedience. I think that distinction is enormous. So you have an idea, let's say, let's say it's a big idea. I should leave my job. Okay, maybe. I should I should start a new business. Okay, great.
SPEAKER_00Maybe this is the person that I am gonna live the rest of my life with. My life partner, okay? Great, maybe this person clearly meant to insult me. Okay? Definitely, maybe not. The flash is important, but in Kabbalistic language, if you had an intuition, if you had a moment, you don't have to obey it.
SPEAKER_00The flash now needs a mother. The flash needs a place where it can grow, where it can ask questions, where it can have structure, patience, where it can develop, where it can become something that we can understand. And that faculty is called Bina. If we just end it off with last week's class, we'd be missing a critical part of the conversation.
SPEAKER_00And Rabbi Schneer Zalman defines it very precisely. He says, Chachma is the initial point of conception, and bina is when you take that point and you think about it until its details become clear, and you understand the concept in length, in breadth, and in depth. 3D.
SPEAKER_00And only after that going through the details does dot come, which dots we'll talk in detail about next week. And dot is that deeper attachment. We've spoken about it a bit before in the series, but we'll have obviously do a deep deep dive into it. So let me let me simplify it. Last week Chachma said, I see something, I notice something, I have a spark.
SPEAKER_00And Bina now is gonna say, Let me understand what I saw. And then next week we eventually come to dot, and that's gonna say, now that I saw it, now that I understand what I saw, now this has to become real to me. Chachma, I got it. Boom, flash. Now, Bina, okay. What exactly did I get?
SPEAKER_00I had a flash of inspiration, but what was that flash? And this question may save your relationships, it may save your business, it may save your friendships, and possibly your text message history. So let's slow down a bit and try to analyze this as best we can. Bina means understanding, that's generally the definition. But I don't think it's enough.
SPEAKER_00Right? If we if we leave these classes saying that chma is wisdom and binah is understanding, and dat is knowledge, which is the three English words that people usually attribute to these three Hebrew words, I would say, okay, wonderful, you now know three English words. But do you know what these sephirot are trying to teach you? So Rabbi Schneer's Ahmed says something, I think, much richer. He says, an idea begins in Chachma, like a point.
SPEAKER_00Think of a tiny dot. Everything may be hidden inside that dot, but you can't see the dimensions. Bina takes that point and begins unfolding it. What does it mean? Why is it true? How does it work? What are its parts? What are the consequences? How does it connect to the other things that I know?
SPEAKER_00What does it not mean? Can I explain it? Can I give an example? Can I give an example of the opposite? Part of critical thinking. And what follows from this idea that nobody explicitly told me. That's Bina. The Tanya describes Bina as the faculty that crystallizes and clarifies what was concealed inside the first flash until the intellectual structure became more visible.
SPEAKER_00There's also, it's associated with this idea, I'll say it in Hebrew first for those of you who appreciate it. If not, just wait for the English, which is mevin davar metrichdavar, which means being able to understand or derive one thing from another. So I want to correct one shorthand we've used in earlier classes. We said Chachma is the spark, bina is the plan, and dat is integration.
SPEAKER_00Now that was useful, but it was shorthand. Because bina, as we do a deeper dive into it, it's much deeper than a plan. A plan may come from Bina, but Bina is the developed understanding that makes a sensible plan possible. Because if you have an excellent plan for something you completely misunderstood, then some of us are very efficient at doing the wrong thing.
SPEAKER_00We have spreadsheets, we have calendars, we have color coding, and we have absolutely no idea why we're doing it. So having a good plan is not necessarily Bina. Binah is going to ask us: do I actually understand what's happening? I'll give you a classic Kabbalistic picture. Chachma is a point. And Bina gives it dimensions. Rabbi Schneer Zalman uses extraordinary language, length, breadth, and depth.
SPEAKER_00So think about that. A dot, not daat, but a dot, has almost no visible dimension. And Bina turns the dot into a world that you can walk around inside. So I want to make those three dimensions practical. What is depth? Depth is gonna ask what what's really underneath this idea?
SPEAKER_00Why? Why is this true? What is the principle? What is the real issue? That's depth. Breath, breath is gonna ask, what else belongs here? What other facts matter? What else is affected? What are the consequences?
SPEAKER_00What are the exceptions? Is there another perspective? Maybe someone else's perspective. And what is length? Length is going to say, how far can I bring this idea down? Can I explain it simply? Can I give an example? What would this truth mean in a real situation? Length is bringing an abstract idea down through explanations and examples so that it becomes accessible.
SPEAKER_00Breadth includes all the details, all the ramifications, and depth means penetrating the idea underlying its profoundness. So Bina is not just saying I have more information. Bina is really saying, can I now inhabit the idea? Here's a simple test. If I say explain it to me without using words you heard in the class.
SPEAKER_00Can you? If not, you may have heard it, you may even remember it, but it may not be yours. What the Bina process will do is you may repeat something to someone, not even realizing you heard it in the class, because it's so much part of you you forgot where you heard it. That's when Bina is successful.
SPEAKER_00One of the classic examples that Chasidut uses is the metaphor of the father and mother. Now, this is describing, the metaphor is describing the intellectual functions that exist inside every human being. Which means a lot of people say, oh well, you know, the father and mother, men, men are Chachmah and women are binah.
SPEAKER_00Everyone has Chachma and everyone has Bina. The world is fluid. Everybody has dat, hopefully, also. The Tanya itself speaks of these as faculties of the soul. So the metaphor is about the process. Bina receives that point.
SPEAKER_00It holds it, it develops it, it gives it dimensions until what was hidden begins taking a recognizable form. And that's why Chma and Bina are called the intellectual father and mother. And the Tanya says that through them the emotions can eventually be born. I think it's beautiful. Why? Because it means that understanding requires gestation.
SPEAKER_00Not every important idea should be delivered by same-day shipping. Sorry, Amazon. Some things need to sit, some things need to grow, some things that you heard five years ago, suddenly you understand today. Has it ever happened? You heard your parents say something when you were 20, and you thought, what are they talking about? And then you become 47, you said, oh, oh yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's why they're talking about their aches and pains. I got it. When you're 20, it doesn't matter as much. They didn't become smarter. The sentence didn't change. What happened is you developed enough Bina to receive it. Chasidut gives another extraordinary analogy.
SPEAKER_00I touched on it last week, but I want to build on it a little more today. Chachma is compared to sight. And Bina is compared to hearing. Why? When you see something, you receive the whole image at once. You look out the window. I'm in Montreal, so there you go. You look out the window, you see Montreal. You don't first see one brick and then another brick and then another tree and then another car, and four hours later you say, Oh, that's the street.
SPEAKER_00You see the entire scene at once. That's Chachma. A total impression. But hearing works differently. You have to listen. Word after word after word. Think about this class. If somebody tells you a story and you leave after the second sentence, then you don't have the story. Hearing takes time, it takes sequence, it takes patience.
SPEAKER_00So the way that Chasidud identifies Chachma with intellectual seeing and Bina with intellectual hearing, that sight gives the whole more directly, and hearing proceeds through analysis and integrates the matter into the listener's existing understanding. So now someone said something beautiful last week and it makes a little more sense.
SPEAKER_00They said, sometimes while another person is speaking, I'm already preparing what I'm gonna say. What does that mean? It means that the ears are operating, but maybe Bina is not. Because hearing is not waiting until the other person stops making noise. Hearing is allowing their meaning enough time to enter you, and that's Bina.
SPEAKER_00Now I want to take this out of Kabbalah. Because if Bina only helps us understand the diagram of the Sephirot, then I think we've missed the whole thing completely. It's supposed to change us. So you receive a text, four words, maybe five words, and you read it, and immediately you start realizing I know what they mean.
SPEAKER_00I know exactly what they mean. Now it's a text. So you're deciding the tone of that text. Do you really know what that text means? Maybe. But notice what just happened. There was data, and then there was interpretation. The words were, let's say. The words were fine, period. Do what you want, period.
SPEAKER_00You can read that. Fine. Do what you want. Fine. Do what you want. Fine. Do what you want. Now there are seventeen possible novels contained in those five words. And your mind writes one immediately. They're angry. They're dismissing me. They don't respect me.
SPEAKER_00They're punishing me. They're being passive aggressive. Maybe. Or maybe they're a Costco. And maybe somebody dropped a watermelon. I don't know. I don't know what's going on in front of them. So what does Bina say to me? Slow down. What actually happened? What did they actually say? What am I adding to what they said?
SPEAKER_00What do I know? What am I assuming? Assuming is a big one. Is there another interpretation? Maybe I don't know the whole story, maybe it needs clarification. What outcome do I want from this? What response would serve that outcome?
SPEAKER_00I think giving a little space is not passivity, it's not avoidance. It's allowing the beena, it's allowing that analytical part of us to enter the room. Now, Bina doesn't always tell us to be nice. Beena wants us to understand. And sometimes, it could be, after thinking carefully, you may come to the conclusion that that was inappropriate.
SPEAKER_00And maybe you need to address it, and maybe you don't. It's fine. But but now you're responding to what happens rather than reacting to the first story in your nervous system. Or that your nervous system wrote about what happened. And I think that's a very different thing. You ask that seems like a needless loop of thought energy, almost obsessive.
SPEAKER_00Why not read and release? Yeah, that's possible. That's possible. Somebody wrote me something this morning, and it was it was not nice. And so my response was, now, the first thing I did was stop.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_00The first thing I did was, and this is what I'm saying, is that you I'm we're not gonna get into that endless cycle. I'm gonna stop, but I'm not gonna react. Because at first I wanted to be defensive, and I wanted to, and defensive would have continued a very useless conversation. And so I said, tonight, when I do the forgiveness prayer before I go to sleep, I will have a little extra kavana. I'll have a little extra focus on it because of you. That's my response.
SPEAKER_00I can't control their business and what they're getting involved with and what they're obsessing over. And so that's where I think what happens with that endless loop is we we get focused and we focus on their part of the story. If we take back the pen and focus on our side, then what m what am I doing? What can I control? What can I analyze? So I think that there's there's a fine balance here, and I thank you for that question. Imagine you're in an argument with someone you love, and in the middle of the argument they say a big a big statement.
SPEAKER_00You never listen to me. Now, your immediate response is that's ridiculous. Because Wednesday at uh 927 in the morning, I've been listening to you already for 27 minutes. What do you mean you never listen to me? Congratulations. So you won the court case, but you may lose the relationship. So Bina is gonna ask a different question.
SPEAKER_00When you say I don't listen, what are you experiencing? And that's a very different question. Maybe they don't mean my ears literally fail to detect sound waves as you speak. Maybe they mean I don't feel considered. I don't feel like what I say changes anything.
SPEAKER_00I feel that when I'm talking, you're trying to solve. Trying to solve me. I feel that as I'm speaking, you're not listening, but rather you're preparing your defense. Okay, that's a very different story. It's a feeling. Now we have something to work with. So Bina is hearing the sentence behind the sentence. It's not magically, it's not pretending that we can read minds, but we're asking, we're listening, we're we're clarifying, we're allowing another person to explain what they mean.
SPEAKER_00How often, at least in my life, do I receive a comment or a text or a judgment, and someone is assuming something without asking me. They have no idea what happened. They they saw something or they or or or they read something, and as a result, or they heard me talk about something in a class, and as a result, they assume something. So here's a very practical bean of practice for relationships.
SPEAKER_00Before responding to something emotionally important, try saying something like this. Can I invite you to tell me what you what you mean by that? Or or let me see if I understand you. If I understood you correctly, I want to just make sure I understood you correctly. And then you can tell them what you think you heard, and then they can say, no, that's not what I said, or that is what I said.
SPEAKER_00And it's not what you think they should have said, it's what you actually heard. And that also, that confirmation is a beautiful thing. If I understood you correctly, that validation is wonderful. And it's it's extraordinary inner work to get used to doing this. And of course, to get used to doing this in a relationship and them not thinking that you're a psychologist to them in the relationship. But to actually, it's not, it's not, oh, tell me what you mean by that, like in a in a therapy setting. It's I want to make sure I understood you correctly.
SPEAKER_00Now, I think there's something even deeper here. I want to go back to what Tanya says. That Chachma and Bina are the parents that eventually give birth to the midot, to the emotions. The idea is not that every emotion is voluntary chosen or that human psychology is simple.
SPEAKER_00I think here the Tanya is showing us that the way an idea is understood, the way an idea is contemplated, can deeply shape the feelings that grow from it. So imagine. Imagine your friend doesn't return your call. So what's the fact? No return call. Now Bina begins building version one.
SPEAKER_00They don't care about me. What feeling grows? Hurt, anger, shame. Version two could be maybe they didn't see the call. Maybe they did see the call and they're overwhelmed. So let's say we go with they're overwhelmed. What feeling grows? Concern. I'm concerned for them. Because they didn't return my call.
SPEAKER_00Version three, I don't know why they haven't called. What feeling grows? Maybe maybe uncertainty. But without the entire uh emotional avalanche. Now, I'm not saying that if you have painful feelings, that you simply thought incorrectly. That's not what I'm saying here. Our emotions come from many places. They come from history, they come from temperaments, from the body, from little T trauma, from big T trauma, from current circumstances, from relationships, from habits.
SPEAKER_00And I don't think it's a good idea to use Kabbalah to blame ourselves for having a human nervous system. But the Tanya here does give us an enormously powerful place to work. And that is what meaning am I building around what happened? You may not choose the first feeling, but maybe you can become curious about the interpretation that keeps feeding it.
SPEAKER_00That's Bina. Let's take something completely ordinary. Something goes wrong at work. Client is angry. There's an impossible deadline. Somebody is accusing you of something. So the animal soul is gonna say, defend yourself. Explain why it's not your fault. Shift the blame.
SPEAKER_00Find someone to blame. And then perhaps a flash. Wait. What if there's another solution? What if there's another way of doing this? I've always done that. I've always gone into defense mode. That's my natural response. What if I take Chachma and I'm gonna say, nope, stop? Let's try something different than I usually do. Wonderful. But that's not the solution yet.
SPEAKER_00Because Bina now has to be, okay, well, what do I actually do? How do I find the solution? Let's say you're talking about, I'm thinking about that example of, you know, they all the installers are busy, so I have to go find an independent installer. So, okay, well, independent installer, are are they competent? Are they insured? Are they available? What's the cost? Can I trust them with my clients?
SPEAKER_00Who might know someone? What are the risks? What are the time? What's the timeline? So now what happens is that spark, that shift, which is beautiful because it's not the same defensive way that I've responded, it becomes a workable idea. And eventually, we'll get next week to dot, we're going to enter when the conclusion becomes settled enough to commit and to act on it. So here's the progression.
SPEAKER_00Bina develops possibility, and dot eventually binds me to a new reality. And I think that if I can use the Tanya's words, it makes precisely that distinction. That Bina elaborates and clarifies what appeared only in a concentrated form in Chachma. And then dot then attaches the person to what has been understood so it can exert genuine emotional force.
SPEAKER_00I'll tell you why I think this is so powerful. And for today, for our generation. I feel it strongly. I feel it. I hear, I mean, at least in my world's a lot of feelings. Okay, fine, that matters. But strength is not the same as truth.
SPEAKER_00I have an intuition. Wonderful. Now examine it. I know it. I know this person is my soulmate. Great. Maybe you're right. But what do you actually know about them? I feel like I must quit my job now. Maybe. But what are you really responding to? Is it defense mechanism? Is the job wrong? Is the environment unhealthy? Maybe you're exhausted.
SPEAKER_00Maybe you had one terrible Tuesday. Or are you being called towards something? Or are you running away from something? Beena is not killing the spark. Bina is respecting that intuition. It's respecting that spark enough to investigate it. And I think that is a crucial distinction. Some people are afraid to examine inspiration because they think analysis will destroy it.
SPEAKER_00So many couples have come to me and they said, oh, we didn't want to destroy a good thing, so we didn't talk about such and such and such. Like, how can it be that you're that that you're dating for a year and a half and you've been engaged for six months and you haven't spoken about how many kids you want? Oh, we didn't want to destroy a good thing. My opinion is, this is just my opinion, is that if truth can't survive a question, then we have to ask what kind of truth it is.
SPEAKER_00If truth can't survive a challenge to it, then what's going on here? Real Bina is that I'm not interrogating this because I hate it. I'm trying to understand what it actually contains. I wanna I wanna add something, I think, a little more subtle to this conversation. Because Bina does have the opportunity to go wrong if you just kind of use this interpretation.
SPEAKER_00And I think this may be where a lot of intellectually sophisticated people get stuck. Including some people who attend a Kabawa class at 9 a.m. on Wednesday mornings. So remember what we said. Chachma receives, Bina develops, but there's a danger. The moment something new enters my mind, I can immediately translate it back into everything I already believe.
SPEAKER_00So somebody tells me something and I say, Oh, I know exactly what you mean. Do you? Maybe you know what you mean. And that may be especially dangerous in relationships because your partner says, I'm overwhelmed. And you say, Oh, I know. You need me to do more around the house. Maybe, or maybe they mean I don't want you to fix anything, I just want you to sit next to me.
SPEAKER_00So you heard one sentence, and your bina immediately shoved it into an old file folder. And I think there's a beautiful tension in Kabbalah that Chachma and Bina are different, but they need one another. The Rabbi Rashab explains this idea. This and I spoke about this beautiful Maimer of Echaltsu, one of my favorite discourses.
SPEAKER_00So he he quotes this phrase there from Sefer Yetsira. Having the Chachmah Chacham Bibina, which means understand within Chachmah, be wise within Bina. I'll just explain it simply for you. Bina must develop the original insight, but Chachmah must remain alive inside the analysis so that all the details remain faithful to the essential point rather than replacing it.
SPEAKER_00Okay, I'll simplify it even more. I think this is profound. You need Bina, but you also need to keep asking wait, what was the original point? How easy can Bina devolve from the original point? So many people have the great ideas, and all of a sudden, when they're analyzing it, they end up in an endless loop. And what was that idea initially? It had nothing to do with it because we kind of moved and shifted from one thing to another. And that's why when you're writing or when you're teaching or when you're solving a complicated problem, you can spend four hours developing something and then look at it and say, how did I get here?
SPEAKER_00What was I trying to say? How did this start? Bina has built a beautiful shopping mall. And the original idea is somewhere in the parking lot. So I think this is how I would I would I would remember this. If I had to really simplify this and simplify this again. Good Bina develops the point. Bad Bina replaces the point.
SPEAKER_00So if Chachma is a seed, Bina is a womb and not a blender. Its job is to develop the identity hidden inside the seed and not to puree it into something unrecognizable. There's another kind of bad Bina. The animal soul wants something.
SPEAKER_00And Bina can become its research department. You want to send an angry email, the animal soul says send it. And what does Bina say? Let me construct a 13-paragraph philosophical argument explaining why this is not anger. This is integrity. And careful, you want recognition. But Bina explains that this is important, and it's important that my contribution be properly documented for organizational transparency.
SPEAKER_00Maybe. True, yeah? Okay. You want to buy something. What does Bina say? You're not really buying it. It's not an impulse buy, it's really an investment. It's long term, long term. It's very interesting. You already have seven of them. It's a long-term investment.
SPEAKER_00The Tanya's structure makes room, I think, for precisely this possibility. Because intellectual faculties are not morally self-certifying. The natural or the animal soul possesses intellect too. So what does Bina need? And how does Bina know whether it's animal or it's not? It needs honesty.
SPEAKER_00Not only can I produce a reason, I can justify anything in the name of anything. I mean, a human being can produce a reason for almost anything. So what is the question here? The real Bina question? Did the reason lead me to the conclusion, or did the conclusion hire the reason? One more danger. We touched on it earlier because somebody asked this question, but I think this is a very important danger in Bina.
SPEAKER_00Overthinking. Analysis, analysis, analysis, analysis. Rabbi, I am really, really good at Bina. I haven't slept in three days. Well, that may be something else. Bina does not mean endless rumination. Bina has a purpose, it's clarity. If I'm thinking and thinking and thinking, but there's no new information, and I end up in an endless loop, no new distinction, no greater clarity, no more accurate understanding, and I'm simply traveling around the same mental roundabout, I may no longer be doing Bina.
SPEAKER_00I maybe I'm I'm I'm stuck. The Rebbe once wrote a letter to someone about this and said the person was um the person told the Rebbe that they are overwhelmed by constant analysis of their own inner state. And the Rebbe advised less analysis and more simple, healthy, sincere action.
SPEAKER_00And I think that's important to hear, especially in a class of. Albina. Because Kabbalah Chasidut loves thinking, but we don't worship thinking. Thinking is meant to reveal truth. When thinking becomes a hiding place from life, it stopped doing its job.
SPEAKER_00Here's how I analyze it in my mind. Healthy Bina moves toward clarity. Overthinking goes in circles. Healthy Bina asks a question and allows the answer to emerge. Or allows the clarity to emerge. Overthinking asks the answer another question. And then asks the question whether it trusts the answer and then creates a committee to investigate the original question.
SPEAKER_00And at some point, Vizahu, enough. I want to one more thing. I see that I could see from your faces one more thing that I think is important here. There's an even deeper danger that could happen. Analysis without humility. Because the smarter I become, the more convinced I may become that everything fits inside my intelligence.
SPEAKER_00And I'm the greatest thing that ever happened since sliced cala. But mature Bina should produce the opposite. The deeper I understand something, the more I recognize its complexity. The more I genuinely know a person, the less likely I am to reduce them to one label. The more I deeply learn, the more I realize that I know nothing.
SPEAKER_00So shallow knowledge is gonna say, oh, obviously. Deep understanding is gonna say, whoa, whoa, whoa, this is really like wow. And I think intellectual humility is so important, right? What did we say last week? And someone asked me, how does Bittl, how does humility get into Bina? Right? We said that you can't have the initial flash of chachma without enough openness to receive, without Bittl, without humility.
SPEAKER_00Binah cannot lose that humility while developing what was received. The Rebbe Rashab in that beautiful Maimer Echoltsu stresses that Bina needs to retain an aspect of chma within it, even while expanding into particulars. And that's why the smartest person in the room is not always the person who talks the most. Sometimes it's the person who asks, can you explain what you mean?
SPEAKER_00Now I want to make this extremely practical. Wonderful. This should be a university class. And then somebody cuts you off in traffic, and all ten Sephiroth leave the vehicle. So we're gonna practice Bina.
SPEAKER_00I want to give you a simple model. We're gonna call it the three dimensions of Bina: depth, breadth, and length. First, preserve the spark. Write the chachma in one sentence. One sentence. Couple words, not nineteen. Make sure that when you're analyzing something, in a couple of words, you can see what you're analyzing.
SPEAKER_00What was the flash? Um I need to slow down. I need to repair this relationship. Uh this job is no longer right for me. I want Shabbat to become real in my home. Uh I shouldn't send this message right now. I think I need to ask for help. One sentence. What is that spark? What is that initial chachma? What is that initial flash of insight? Because Bina is going to wander.
SPEAKER_00It's great. Let it wander, but it needs to remember what it's wandering from. We have to remember what we're developing. Bina must retain the concentrated point of chachma within it. So the details have to remain connected to the essence. So first, what was the point? Write it down. Then, what's really here? What's really underneath this? This is the beginning process of Bina.
SPEAKER_00Why does this matter? What truth did I glimpse? What problem am I trying to solve? What do I really want? What may God be asking of me here? What answer would make me comfortable? What's really going on? So let's say the flash, the chachma is I need a new job. The depth is going to ask why. I hate my boss?
SPEAKER_00Okay. Why does that matter? Because you feel constantly diminished? Great. Now we're getting somewhere. So is the real insight I need a new job? Or is the real insight I need to work in which I can function with dignity? It's very different. They're related, but they're not identical. Maybe leaving is right, or maybe a conversation is right, or maybe a transfer is right, or maybe you need to change how you respond. We don't know yet.
SPEAKER_00We're never rushing. So let's say the insight is I need more Judaism in my life. Beautiful. Depth is going to ask, what do you mean by that? More knowledge? More prayer? Maybe you feel isolated. You need a community. Maybe you need Shabbat, more purpose, more God consciousness. What is the longing underneath that sentence? Now we're starting to understand. That's depth. Now breath. Breath is going to ask what else is true?
SPEAKER_00What else belongs in this picture? Maybe the most important question for emotionally charged situations is what facts have I not considered? Who else is affected by this? What might the other person be experiencing? What consequences follow? What obligations already exist?
SPEAKER_00What's the opposite argument? What would somebody wise who disagrees with me say? And I think here Beaner protects us from tunnel vision, from getting into a bubble. You get into an argument with your child. You think they need discipline. Okay, maybe. But what else is true? Maybe they're exhausted. Maybe they're hungry. Maybe they're anxious. Maybe you're exhausted.
SPEAKER_00Now the behavior may still be unacceptable. And they may need a consequence, but they also may need a hug. They may need connection. You see what happens? We're not erasing discipline. We're broadening the understanding. You're considering a relationship. And Chachma says, this feels different. Beautiful. It's beautiful. Okay. What feels different? Bina is going to ask. Do our values align?
SPEAKER_00How does this person treat people who cannot do anything for them? How do we handle disagreement? Do we have a compatible idea of our future? What do we think about money? Community, responsibility, growth. Is there attraction? Is there friendship? Can we talk? Can we repair? I know it's a lot, but you haven't murdered romance. You're giving romance somewhere to live. A relationship can't survive on a spark alone.
SPEAKER_00Try heating a house in Montreal in January with a spark. You need infrastructure. Then there's length. What is length? How does this idea travel into reality? How does this come down? What would this truth look like today? What would it look like next week? What is the first realistic expression? What is the appropriate form?
SPEAKER_00Is this the right time? Timing is a big deal. Is this the right time? Like the idea, right? I need better boundaries. That's an idea. The length is gonna say what sentence am I actually gonna say? Not I'm embarking on a journey towards self-preservation. What are you saying? Maybe I can't help you Thursday, I can do it on Sunday.
SPEAKER_00You see, there's Bina. I want to be more present with my partner. Okay, great. What does it actually mean at 6 o'clock tonight? Maybe 15 minutes where the phone isn't physically with me. It's physically somewhere else. Not upside down on the table. You know that trick. Phone the phone for 15 minutes is gonna be in a different room because I am gonna practice presence with my family.
SPEAKER_00Okay, let's try to distill this into 90 seconds. Right? We did it last week with Chakma. I want to do now the 90-second peena. Because you're gonna always have 45 minutes, and that's that's great. But what about the emergency version? Something activates you and you're about to respond. 90 seconds, what happened? Not my interpretation, what actually happened? Next, what else could be true? Next, what response fits this moment?
SPEAKER_00That's B990 seconds. What happened? What else can be true? What response fits this moment? And if you want to notice something, if I may, you can notice this development that we we've been working on now for several weeks. In lesson 16, we asked, where's my 101st time? Right? Let's go out of the out of the regular. Then 17 and 18, we said, how do I bring my whole inner team, the godly soul, the rational soul, the animal soul, into that moment?
SPEAKER_00Then in lesson 20, we said, how can I become quiet enough for chachma for new possibility to appear? And what are we saying now? How can I stay with that possibility long enough to understand before I react? What happens is, and what I saw this in my own life, is that Kabbalah often becomes, or any ideas that we learn, become this disconnected vocabulary. We are building a human being here. That's the point of this.
SPEAKER_00We're building a better version of ourselves. Let me try this as an exercise that we can do right now. Okay, I'm gonna give you an exercise right now. I want you, I want to invite you to think of a situation in your life right now that feels unclear. Not the most traumatic thing in your life, just a situation. You got it?
SPEAKER_00I don't want to solve your entire existence before breakfast. Just one little thing. Okay. Something real, a conversation, a decision, uh, a relationship tension, a work issue, a habit, something you're considering. Okay. Now, what is your current one sentence chma? What do you think you see?
SPEAKER_00How about completing this sentence? Maybe and continue. Maybe I need to speak, maybe I need to stop, maybe I need to wait, maybe I need to help. Maybe I need to change the way I'm approaching this. Maybe I need a boundary. Maybe I have to give this another chance. Maybe I have to let this go. Good. We got it.
SPEAKER_00Got the maybe? Okay. Now depth. Why? What is the deeper truth underneath this? What are you really trying to protect? What are you really longing for? What what actually matters here? Give me a thumbs up when you're ready to continue.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_00Another one? Another one? Okay, great. Now let's go to breath. What else is true? Who else is in this story? What might you be missing? What I'm just giving you ideas here.
SPEAKER_00What fact does not fit your preferred conclusion? What would somebody who loves you and is emotionally not emotionally inside the situation? What would they say? And then length, what would this mean in one realistic next step?
SPEAKER_00And is it the right time now? You don't have to necessarily decide right now, just notice. Did the idea become clearer? Did it change? Did it become more nuanced? Maybe you discovered that the original spark was right. And that your first interpretation was too narrow. That's Bina.
SPEAKER_00That's exactly Bina. I think Bina is the love that stays long enough to understand. I care enough about the situation to actually understand it. We're gonna get into dot next week.
SPEAKER_00Some of us have already discussed dot. But for me, dot is like one of the most amazing ideas, one of the most unique ideas in Kabbalah, and has totally changed my life. So we're why I'm saying this is that we're really only half, you know, the Bina is only part of the process. There's another part of this process, but I'm just hyper-focusing on this particular part of the process. But the process is not complete. I just want you to understand this process as best possible, which is why we kind of slowed down and tried to analyze it.
SPEAKER_00So let's just summarize. Last week we learned how to make room for the flash. Today we learned how to honor the flesh. And honoring an insight doesn't mean immediately obeying it. It means staying with it long enough to understand what it's asking from you. Chachma says, I see. Bina says, look again.
SPEAKER_00Chachma says, something is here. Bina is going to ask, tell me more. Chachma will say, I think this is true. Bina says, What does truth mean? Chachma gives you the seed. Bina says, I will not abandon you as a seed. I will give you somewhere to grow.
SPEAKER_00And maybe that is true not only of ideas, but it's also true of people. Of our partners, of our friends, of ourselves. Maybe you don't need to decide so quickly who you are or who they are. When you say, Oh, I'm an anxious person, that's binary. Maybe, but tell me more. I'm bad at relationships. Maybe, but tell me more. I always fail.
SPEAKER_00Always absolutes. Really? Okay, great. Tell me more. I can't change. How do you know? Bina challenges the sentence that has become too small for the truth. It says, look again, stay, stay with this, stay with me here. Look again, listen again. Ask again. Understand.
SPEAKER_00That's what Bina is. As what's become traditional in our class, I like to end with a blessing. May God bless us with true Chachma, with the humility to receive a truth that we did not already know. And may God bless us with deep bina, the patience to develop that truth without rushing it, without distorting it, without forcing it into what we already wanted to believe.
SPEAKER_00And may we have the wisdom to know the difference between inspiration and impulse. Between analysis and rationalization or patience and avoidance. Or between a beautiful idea and a beautiful idea whose time has come.
SPEAKER_00May we learn to listen before we answer. May we learn to ask before we assume. To understand before we judge. And to pause before we make a move. May we be able to say to the people we love, help me understand. And may we be able to say, be brave enough to say the same thing to God. God help me understand what you want from me here.
SPEAKER_00May the ideas we learn not remain beautiful words. May they grow roots. May they become rivers, may they enter our homes, our relationships, our work, our decisions, our phones, and eventually our hearts. May our understanding make us not more arrogant, but more humble, more discerning, more passionate about what is true, and may Chachma become Bina and Bina become dot and dot give birth to holy feeling and holy feeling become holy life until the truth is not just something we glimpse, but something we understand, and something visible and lived throughout this world in our lives and in lives of others.
SPEAKER_00And please, before you send any difficult text this week, give Bina ninety seconds. Your relationships may thank you later. With that I wish you a beautiful week, a beautiful Shabbat. Until we meet again, and my invitation to you is to please send me your questions. A lot of these classes have been formed and thickened by your challenges, your questions, your wanting to understand, you're wanting your beena, you're wanting to live with this.
SPEAKER_00And that's what's beautiful. These classes have literally been a beena experience of really understanding and and and allowing us to take these really deep ideas which are not easily understood, and to understand them to the best of our ability. So continue sending me your questions, continue uh your interest and your curiosity because it's it's a beautiful thing. And uh I can't wait to hear today from you what uh what's hitting and uh what your nugget is.
Send us Fan Mail Can you love someone so much that you actually give them too much? Can generosity become exhausting? Can saying yes to everyone eventually mean abandoning yourself? In this deeply personal lesson of...
Send us Fan Mail What if kindness isn't really about what we give, but about how much room we're willing to make for another human being? In Lesson 23 of Kabbalah for Everyone, Rabbi Yisroel Bernath takes us on a...
Send us Fan Mail We all know things we don't actually live. We know we shouldn't respond when we're angry. We know we can't control everything. We know that our worth isn't determined by other people's opinions. We know...
Send us Fan Mail What if wisdom does not begin with having the answer, but with creating enough space to see something new? In Lesson 20 of Kabbalah for Everyone, Rabbi Yisroel Bernath takes a deep dive into Chochmah,...
Send us Fan Mail Why is it that we can know something is true, understand it perfectly - and still struggle to actually live it? In this lesson of Kabbalah for Everyone, Rabbi Yisroel Bernath explores the three...