Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Juno News Podcast

Juno News Podcast artwork

Does Canada need to abolish the Senate?

Oct 2, 202623 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

As Alberta prepares to vote on ten referendum questions covering the province’s future, one question puts Canada’s unelected Senate in the spotlight. On today’s episode of The Fighter, Kris Sims is joined by Canadian Taxpayers Federation federal director Franco Terrazzano to examine Question 7 and the debate over the Senate’s role, cost, and accountability. The Senate costs taxpayers a reported $140 million a year. Kris and Franco explore spending on senators’ salaries and international travel, raising questions about transparency and the use of public funds. Help us cover the stories the taxpayer-funded legacy media doesn’t want to touch. Support strong, fearless, independent media. Become a premium Juno News subscriber today and get 20% off! They revisit past attempts at Senate reform, including Preston Manning’s Triple-E Senate proposal, and why decades of efforts to make the institution elected, effective, and accountable have failed. They also examine alternatives for holding federal politicians accountable, including recall legislation and the role of independent journalism in scrutinizing government power. With Alberta’s referendum addressing issues beyond separation, Kris and Franco consider what meaningful accountability looks like in a democracy and whether existing institutions are doing enough to keep government spending and political power in check. Watch the latest episode of The Fighter with Kris Sims This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.junonews.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_02Welcome to The Fighter. I am your host, Chris Sims. I'm the Alberta and British Columbia Director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. Hey, first off, thank you so much for watching this show. Juno News is real journalism. It is not funded by the government. It is a free press, completely independent journalism. So if you have not done so yet, Please, if you can, go to Juno News and subscribe to it. OK, it's all based on subscription fees and supporter fees. This is how we do real journalism. We've got a very special show because right now,

SPEAKER_02Alberta, what I would argue is the center of grassroots direct democracy in all of Canada. That's the birthplace of a lot of this stuff. They're holding a big referendum. They're holding a huge referendum Monday, October 19th. It's not just about separation, though. There is 10 questions. There's 10 questions on the ballot. That's what people need to answer. So let's go through a few of them. OK, of course, there's the do you want to hold a real referendum eventually on separating

SPEAKER_02and becoming sovereign from the rest of Canada? That's sucking up a lot of oxygen. But there's other stuff, too. There's questions, things like, should we appoint our own judges in Alberta? Should newcomers who are brand new to Canada who haven't been paying into the tax system and who suddenly start using our provincial services like health care, like schools, should they pay user fees? Should we handle our own immigration in the province of Alberta? A lot of stuff like that, kind of similar to the way Quebec does things within United Canada.

SPEAKER_02So that's getting a lot of attention. But the reason why I want to talk to you right now is a very special one. Question seven. Question seven asks, should Alberta team up with other provinces and work to abolish the unelected Senate in Ottawa? Should we abolish the unelected Senate in Ottawa? Yes. And if you're in the province of Alberta and you're either on the advance voting day of Saturday or you're on the actual day, referendum Monday, get out there and vote, please.

SPEAKER_02And we at the Canadian Taxpayers Federation would encourage you to vote yes to abolish the Senate. Why? Well, a few things. One, the Senate costs you a ridiculous amount of money. It is costing you, taxpayer... $140 million this year. And they waste your money like crazy. OK, we just found through our investigative journalist, Jen Hodgson at the Taxpayers Federation, the Speaker of the Senate, for example, who's paid well over two hundred and fifty thousand dollars per year,

SPEAKER_02plus a housing bonus, plus a car bonus. She and her entourage have been traveling around the world so hard the past three years, they've racked up a million dollars, close to a million dollars in costs. And I bet you don't even know the Speaker of the Senate's name, but you're paying for her international travel. Senators themselves, okay, just backbench senators, two feet in a heartbeat, they're paid more than $190,000 per year and they get to sit there

SPEAKER_02until they're 75 years old. I went back through the budget documents. The Senate has cost you, dear taxpayer, more than a billion dollars over the last 10 years. So it costs you way too much money. Two, it is undemocratic. You, my friend, have never voted for a senator that's currently sitting in the upper chamber. Nope. They're appointed by the prime minister. How is that for democracy? That's why you wind up with the Senate full of ideologues,

SPEAKER_02party bag men and pastured broadcasters. OK, old journalists who are sitting in there, each other 75 years old, collecting a paycheck to be a rubber stamp. And three, finally. All attempts at reforming the Senate have failed. You might be sitting there thinking, but Chris, you're a fighter. How are we supposed to fight government tyranny? How can there be a stop and check on government authority and government power if we don't have our beloved Senate?

SPEAKER_02I hear you. What you're asking is a very important question because we do need to have a good check on power. But do we really need a Senate that's unelected and unaccountable costing us $140 million a year to be that rubber stamp, say, sober second thought? No. Here's an idea. Two things. One, we could have a free press again. Ever think of that? Yeah, I happen to remember, as being a longtime member of the Parliamentary Press Gallery back in the day, being a pretty darn good check on power.

SPEAKER_02Why? Because journalists weren't by and large on government payroll back then. Nope, it was just the mother corp. It was just the state broadcaster, the CBC, who was largely on government payroll. Now, unfortunately, as we know, most of mainstream media on government payroll, so they can't hold government to account. So let's get back to that. How's that for a check and balance on power? Let's have a free press. And two, here's a really good tool in the toolbox. Let's have recall legislation at the federal government level.

SPEAKER_02Yep, they have it in British Columbia. We have it in Alberta. You can fire a politician at the provincial city hall or even school board level in Alberta. It's beautiful. Talk about direct democracy. That would be the we the people check on power. We don't need this ridiculous, bloated, unaccountable, expensive, sneaky Senate that's costing us way too much money. And lastly, on the reform issue. For folks who are still sitting there thinking we could elect them and it could be equitable and effective, a triple E Senate.

SPEAKER_02The Reform Party founder, Preston Manning, himself was a guest on this show. He, more than anyone else, fought to make the Senate effective, elected and accountable. And it never worked.

SPEAKER_01Listen to Preston. Even people who support reform will vote, get rid of it just to give a signal to Ottawa that there's no support or respect for that out here. I'd be very surprised if that provoked the constitutional amendment that you actually need, but it would at least send a signal.

SPEAKER_02Joining me now is my good friend and federal director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, Franco Teresano. Franco, this is a special report. It's a special time in Alberta. We're leading up to this huge referendum vote that's going to be happening on Monday the 19th. It doesn't get more direct democracy than this, does it?

SPEAKER_00No, it sure doesn't. And Chris, I mean, you're leading the charge on one of the referendum questions, right? The referendum question on whether we should abolish the Senate. And I mean, I couldn't be happier. Yes, abolish the Senate. You know, I'll give you three reasons off the top of my head on why we go to abolish the Senate. I mean, number one, it's a huge waste of money. Okay, so like the Senate at best is a rubber stamp that costs us over $100 million every year.

SPEAKER_00Now, the second part, the second reason is, well, you might be saying, well, Frankl, I think members of parliament are a waste of money as well. And I'd be like, well, hey, I'm not getting much of an argument from me. They can also be a huge waste of money. But even though members of parliament could be a waste of money, at least they're elected. Right. So the second reason to abolish the Senate, they're unelected. They're unaccountable. They represent nobody but themselves. So insult to injury. And number three, Chris, you would know this better than better than me. Right. Because you came you kind of grew up in the political environment of the Reform Party.

SPEAKER_00But the third reason that we just go to abolish this thing is like, look, past legitimate efforts of reform completely failed.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. So Preston Manning, the founder of the Reform Party, we played a cliff off the top of the show. He was right here on The Fighter, on Juno News. And he fought for years and years and years for a triple E Senate. He wanted it to be elected. He wanted it to be effortable. He wanted it to be effective. None of those things worked, unfortunately, despite his best efforts. And you could maybe say, oh, well, you know, Mr. Manning never became the right honorable, never became, you know, the prime minister. But, uh, Franco, there was this guy, you might remember his name, Stephen Harper.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, he was a majority prime minister and an acolyte of Manning, meaning a student of Manning. And he still couldn't get Senate reform done. So there are some well-meaning people who are trying to push back saying, well, we shouldn't abolish it. We should reform it. Guys, even Preston Manning saying this isn't working.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I appreciate their concerns, right? Because like, I mean, some people are just, I mean... They don't want to cut a single cent from government spending, but we're not talking about them. Like we've got some really well-meaning folks. We do have some tax providers out there that are like, hey guys, look, I'm behind you. They are a waste of money. They are unaccountable, but let's reform it. But Chris, to your point, like, I mean, come We've tried to reform it. And just with all due respect, what's the definition of insanity? Trying to do the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.

SPEAKER_00Look, I just think the thing has to be defunded. I think there is serious rot. And when there's rot, you just got to throw it out. So I think that's a big issue here. I mean, look... What really what really irks me, too, is just the entitlement of these unelected senators. Right. We've been breaking a whole bunch of stories. Shout out to our investigative journalists at the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, both Jen Hodgson. And we also have a new one to Simon, who's working behind the scenes, getting some of this research. But I mean.

SPEAKER_00We caught these unelected senators spending millions over the last couple of years traveling all around the world. Now, I can't think of a good reason for any unelected senator who represents nobody but themselves to be flying around the world on taxpayers' expense. We caught like, what, 65 of them, you know, billing us close to $2 million over the last three years. I mean, completely crazy, like entitled, you know?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, big time. And so I'm going to get into it a little bit more because again, Jen did an amazing job. I couldn't have told you who the Speaker of the Senate was two months ago, but now we know it is Raymond Gagné and she's the Speaker of the Senate. She is paid, guys, well over $250,000 per year. Wait, there's more. She has a special bonus for housing and there's more. She has a special bonus for her car and And she and her entourage over

SPEAKER_02the last three years have traveled around the world so much that their expenses have racked up to nearly a million dollars. And for the folks who are trying to say, oh, well, the Senate serves some function as the Royal Chamber. OK, OK, OK. Listen, I think I might be the only monarchist left at the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. The Senate Speaker was not only going to have an audience with His Majesty King Charles III. Nay, nay. She went to France.

SPEAKER_02She went to Spain. She went to Brazil. She went to Romania.

SPEAKER_00It's probably easier to say where she didn't go at this point, Chris. Yeah, you're right. You're right. Never mind. But also, too, like, okay, folks, like, if it's to go to see the king or the queen, Yeah, yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Pick up the phone if you want to pay a courtesy call. Why are you billing us six figures, you and your entourage, right? It's these kind of stories, twofold. Number one, people are struggling back home to see these entitled elite, let's call them unelected bureaucrats. Okay. Wasting our money like that. It's upsetting. It's disrespectful. But number two, I know you see the pattern and I'm sorry, I'm just going to say it. It starts to seem like some of these bureaucrats, some of these unelected senators are just looking for reasons to come up with so

SPEAKER_00that they get to build taxpayers to travel internationally.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. You can go right ahead and say it because it's bloody well true. She and her entourage also went to an African country of Benin where she learned about the sacred forest of voodoo culture. Now, again, if that's your thing and you love traveling internationally, like fill your boots. In fact, if you're making over two hundred and fifty thousand dollars already from the taxpayers, here's an idea. How about you spend the money and pay for it yourself? This is an extra catch, and we've already put out the video,

SPEAKER_02so it's okay to talk about it right now, Franco. Remember when Jen found that quote in the online Senate magazine where the Speaker of the Senate was saying how much she liked global travel? There was a quote in there, and then, Franco, we went back to link to it, and it was gone. Do you remember this part of the story?

SPEAKER_00Well, I remember you talking about it, Chris. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02I talk about a lot of things. Poor Franco. He gets phoned all the time. I just need to talk to him all the time. And so it was gone. And Jen and I like freaked out when we couldn't find the quote. So we went and checked a little tool called the Wayback Machine. The Internet is forever. And we found it. So we haven't gotten a response back from them yet to explain why this one quote from the Senate magazine. Yes, that exists and you pay for it, which is online, where the Senate speaker was gushing about her job and how much she likes it and how much she likes international travel.

SPEAKER_02That quote has been deleted. It's down the memory hole. So this is part of the accountability thing, right, Franco? Like not only are these senators not elected ever, nobody ever votes for them. We've gotten a little bit of chippy pushback from them when we've talked about how I'm taking these international trips.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, we did. Right. How dare the plebs complain about these very important, very important senators wasting our money. Right. How dare we? Don't we know how good we have it? Right. Must be nice having this job essentially forever. Where nobody, Alexi, you represent nobody but yourself. You only, yeah, you only represent yourself really. And you get paid, you know, uh, quite a substantial six figure salary, right? Like the base salary. So not like, uh, the speaker, but the base salary is 190,000, just over 190,000 bucks.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I do want to get back to the speaker for one sec, Chris, then you can kind of talk about it. Cause you kind of dealt with that pushback from them, but you know, even if the speaker of the Senate, um, had some reason to be traveling internationally. I mean, number one, she doesn't. Number two, why are they spending six figures on many of these trips? It's not even just one trip to Japan that it was 100,000 plus. There's a couple of these trips. I mean, so you're kind of looking for ways to rack up the taxpayer bill there.

SPEAKER_00But number three, you know, we also have an elected Speaker of the House of Commons. And over the same time period, the unelected Speaker of the Senate, what, spent like, what was it, like $100,000 more than the elected Speaker of the House?

SPEAKER_02Make that make sense. Yeah. It's because it's out of sight, out of mind, I think. And when Jen did that big story and we went across Canada showing which senator in which provinces, and I use that term loosely because they're elected by no one. The people of these provinces are not electing these people. They're just assigned a label when they're put in there by the prime minister. Okay. And we went across Canada and we highlighted some of the spending that was happening. And thank you so much to Post Media. They did a big spread on this. And some of the pushback that we were getting through through the reporters

SPEAKER_02that they were hearing from the Senate was something along the lines of this. And I'm paraphrasing Franco. Oh, we weren't traveling as senators, Franco. We were traveling as part of a parliamentary contingent, a parliamentary team. We were playing a role as part of the team while we were traveling together. To places a lot of people can't pronounce and can never imagine ever being able to afford going there by themselves ever. They weren't traveling as senators per se, Franco.

SPEAKER_00That didn't class muster with me. And you know, when I drink too much at my buddy's bachelor party, I'm not doing that as Franco, my wife's husband. I'm doing that as Franco, my buddy's buddy.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, could you imagine how that phone call would work? Yeah, not very well. Yeah, I can actually.

SPEAKER_00She ain't buying it and neither am I when the senators kind of use that type of spit. I mean, it's absolutely ridiculous. You know, like, I don't know.

SPEAKER_02Franco just got married, by the way, and I think he actually did just go to his best friend's wedding. So I like how you're working and experienced from your life. It's very good. It's very authentic. All right. So, Franco, I got to say, I have to stress, I went back through the expenses for the Senate and how much it costs, because I can still hear people being like, well, what are we supposed to do? OK, number one, you want to check on power. OK, here's an idea. Let's have recall legislation at the federal level. So if we can fire members of Parliament from the House of Commons

SPEAKER_02in Ottawa like we can in Alberta, then that would be a really good check on power.

SPEAKER_00And British Columbia as well.

SPEAKER_02Oh, good point.

SPEAKER_00They've had it since the mid-90s, right? BC was the first one to bring it in.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, fair. I keep forgetting. BC's in the middle of a snap election, by the way, here, folks. So make sure you stay tuned to that. But yeah, you're right. Excuse me. BC does have an MLA recall system where they actually did. They were this close to recalling one. Who is writing in. Fake letters to the editor of the newspaper praising the MLA in the area and he got caught doing it. So, yeah, BC does have that. Alberta has it. We need to have it at the federal level in Ottawa.

SPEAKER_02And lastly, the expense. The expense. The Senate itself is costing taxpayers $140 million this year. And I went back over the last decade or so. Franco, it's racked up more than a billion dollars in costs for people.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I don't know. But if you ask me, do I want a brand new hospital or do I want the Senate for like 10 years? I'm taking the hospital.

SPEAKER_02Yep. Yeah, exactly. Because again, folks, the Senate simply functions as a rubber stamp. That's all it is. And that's a pretty expensive rubber stamp. Franco, I'll give you the last word here and then I'll get to the the closing of the show. We wanted to get the show on the road here for this weekend. So for the Juno News viewers, for the tax fighters out there, for the everyday Albertans who are watching this this weekend, thank you. But the next thing you got to do. You've got to go vote. So on Monday, October 19th, get out and vote.

SPEAKER_02Now, the separation question, Franco, is getting all the glitz and glamour. It's the sexier question. But there's nine other questions on those ballot sheets. Question seven, Franco, is do we work with the provinces to abolish the Senate in Ottawa? We're encouraging people to vote yes. And I'm hoping for a good turnout on Monday.

SPEAKER_00Well, I'd be voting yes to abolish the Senate if I was in Alberta. You know, I wish I was so I can vote yes to abolish the Senate. I mean, for three reasons. Number one, huge, huge, huge waste of your money. Number two, they're they're unelected. They're unaccountable. They represent nobody but themselves, which makes that waste of money really insult to injury. Number three, you know, with respect to people out there, look, past reforms have failed. Right. So the only option now to fix this is to abolish it. Huge waste. Franco Terrazzano, Federal Director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for joining us. Thanks, Simmer.

SPEAKER_02You bet. So once again, folks, it is get out the vote time. If you're watching this on the Saturday, you might have a little while left for the last day of advance voting, but then everything is shutting down for Sunday. That's where everybody's revving up for the big day, Monday, October 19th. Is the referendum day. If you don't know where to go vote, Elections Alberta has got your back. Just click on it, enter in your postal code, enter in your town. They will tell you where you can go vote. And this is the big one for the tax fighters.

SPEAKER_02OK, we know there's lots of questions on there. There's separation. It's, you know, should Alberta appoint its own judges? Should Alberta be able to charge user fees for newcomers who use our schools and hospitals? All sorts of really important stuff like that. But question seven is, should we work with other provinces to abolish the unelected Senate in Ottawa? Yes. We are encouraging everybody. Don't just go yes or no all the way down the ballot. You got to read each question. OK, because there's 10 really important questions on there.

SPEAKER_02Question seven. It's about the Senate. Vote yes to abolish the Senate. Send a strong message to Ottawa. Thank you so much to Juno News for being a fighter for a free press. If you have not done so, make sure you go to Juno News and subscribe to it. It is not government funded. It's truly free and independent journalism, which is why you're getting messages like this. And if you haven't done so yet, make sure you like this video,

SPEAKER_02subscribe to the channel, and hey, especially right now, because there's a big vote coming, share this show with people who need to know. [music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Organized crime takes over Canada’s airports

    Nov 22, 20261 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.junonews.com Canada’s public safety crisis is spiralling out of control. Organized crime is exploiting airport security to smuggle drugs, while the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Canada is importing more immigrants as crime spirals out of control

    Nov 13, 20261 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.junonews.com Mark Carney is pushing ahead with an immigration agenda that would bring 622,000 new permanent residents to Canada by 2027, even as...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Canada’s broken justice system is failing its own people

    Oct 27, 20261 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.junonews.com On today’s episode of Sonduren Uncensored, Sonduren exposes the failures of Canada’s justice system, examines some unbelievable parole...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The BC NDP’s 10 biggest failures since 2017

    Oct 22, 20261 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.junonews.com The BC NDP came to power in 2017, promising to make life more affordable and improve services for British Columbians. Nearly a decade later,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why is Canada letting these dangerous offenders walk free?

    Oct 18, 20261 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.junonews.com Why are dangerous offenders being released back into our communities while victims and ordinary Canadians are left to live with the...

    Credit the people on this episode