Jewish Wisdom: What could shaking a lulav possibly have to do with creating a fair and just society? Parsha Analysis: At first glance, absolutely nothing. Yet hidden in this week's parsha is a remarkable insight into why societies fail, what makes them truly moral, and the extraordinary Jewish mission entrusted to Avraham Avinu and his descendants. Sodom was a prosperous society. It had laws, respected property rights and understood justice. So what went so terribly wrong? We all recognise the importance of fairness, compassion and doing what is right. But what if our most fundamental assumptions about what makes a society moral are incomplete? Jewish Teachings: The answer takes us from the destruction of Sodom to the very foundations of Judaism & Jewish life, revealing a surprising connection between mitzvot that seem to have absolutely nothing to do with one another, and an extraordinary insight into the mission of the Jewish People. Send Rabbi Grant Leboff a message
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Haim and Schmuel spend the entire night debating the existence of Hashem. They go through every philosophical argument, every proof, every counter argument. They argue until three in the morning. Finally, after exhausting every possible line of reasoning, they agree that they have disproved the existence of Hashem. They shake hands and go home. The following morning Chaim walks past the shaw. He looks through the window. There's Shmuel wearing his Talisanta fillin, Davenin Shachharis.
SPEAKER_00He storms inside. What are you doing? asked Chaim. Davenin Shakharis replies Shmuel. But last night we conclusively proved that Ashem doesn't exist, said Chaim. Shmuel looks at him. What's that got to do with Davenin Shacharis? Suppose I told you that you cannot build a truly just society unless people shake Lulaf? You'd probably think I'd lost my mind. What connection is there between shaking a palm branch and feeding the hungry, protecting the vulnerable or administering social justice?
SPEAKER_00In fact, we probably all know people who don't keep shabbas, don't keep kosher and don't shake Lulaf, who are decent, generous and principled human beings. So what could the connection possibly be? To be clear, I'm not talking about individuals. An individual can be a decent human being without believing in Hashem. But this week's Pasha asks a different question. How do you build a just and righteous society? What makes morality binding, especially when it becomes inconvenient?
SPEAKER_00What stops a society redefining right and wrong to suit its own interests? This week's pasha gives us an understanding of how to build a moral, just and righteous society. In fact, as Jews, that is what we're supposed to do. So let's explore in Bizrat Hashem, we can come away with a deeper understanding and some real chizok. In this week's Pasha, the Torah gives us a tiny glimpse into Hashem's thinking.
SPEAKER_00Hashem says, Shall I conceal from Avraham what I do? Hashem is speaking about the impending destruction of Saddam. Hashem is asking this question in light of the fact that Avram is going to become a great and mighty nation, and all the nations of the earth are going to bless themselves by him. Then we have a Pasuk where Hashem tells us why Avram has been chosen, what the Jewish people must become, and it identifies the Jewish mission.
SPEAKER_00The Pasuk says, Kiyadatif, for I have known him, and many English translations say, for I have loved him, because Rashi brings down and says, Hashem brought Avram close to him as a sign of affection, as a sign of that he was cherished, that he was loved. So for I have loved him. Laman Asheyat Savet Baita. For he commands his children in his household. And then it says Achar Rav. He commands his children in his household after him.
SPEAKER_00And what does it mean after him? It means all the generations after that household and those children, including us today. The Shamrudere Hashem to observe the way of Hashem, La Asot, to do righteousness and justice.
SPEAKER_00There are many questions we could ask, but I want to highlight just two. Why does the Pasak say Hashem? It could just say that he's commanded his household, La Asot, Sadakh, to do righteousness and justice. But it doesn't. It says he's commanded his household, Vashamru Dere Hashem, in the way of Hashem, La Asot to do Sadaka Umishpat, righteousness and justice. And why does Hashem say this statement?
SPEAKER_00Immediately before revealing the impending destruction of Sodom and Amorah. How are the two related? So in order to understand that, we have to examine what went wrong with Saddam. So the Mishnah in chapter 5 of Pirkeavot describes four attitudes towards possessions. And the first one it brings is a person who says, What is mine is mine and what is yours is yours. On the face of it, it seems reasonable.
SPEAKER_00I respect your property. You respect mine. Nobody steals, nobody interferes with anyone else's possessions. I've worked hard for my things. What's mine is mine. And you've worked hard for yours, what's yours is yours. In fact, the Mishnah calls it a midabenonit, an average character trait. But then the Mishnah says something unbelievable. It says, Yesh Omrim, some say it's a character trait of Saddam.
SPEAKER_00How can the Mishnah say it's an average character trait? That many people by implication have this character trait and then link it with one of the most wicked societies ever known. The Bata Nura, who wrote a most unbelievable commentary on the Mishnah, explains. Means that I don't wish to benefit you, and I would prefer that you don't benefit me. I don't want anything from you, and I don't want to give you anything from me.
SPEAKER_00The Bata Nura says that once a person becomes accustomed to behaving in this way, even in a situation where another person would benefit, and it would be no skin off my nose, I wouldn't lose anything at all. He will still refuse to benefit the other person. This was the trait in Saddam. In other words, the person believes everyone should look after themselves, but over time, a person becomes so accustomed to not helping anyone else that they refuse, even when helping them will cost them absolutely nothing.
SPEAKER_00The danger is not simply that individuals become selfish, it's that selfishness becomes socially acceptable and eventually institutionalized. No one regards themselves as having any obligation whatsoever towards anyone else. In the book of Yacheskel, Yacheskel makes exactly this point. Saddam had plenty of food and prosperity, and yet it did not support the poor and needy. Yacheskel describes a wealthy society that refused to take responsibility for those in need, even when it could have done without even noticing it was so wealthy and prosperous.
SPEAKER_00The Gomorrah in Bhava Batra in Twelve Ahmed brings down a principle. We compel a person not to behave in the manner of Sodom. And the Gomorrah brings an example that brothers inherit land, and all the land is of equal quality and value. But one of the brothers has land that's adjacent to some of this land. Obviously, it would be much more convenient for him if he inherited the land right next to his existing land.
SPEAKER_00It makes no difference to the other brothers which land he gets because all of the land is the same quality and value. If one of those brothers was to try and prevent their brother getting the adjacent land, that we stop because that's the manner of Saddam. It makes no difference to you, and yet you won't let another person benefit. Saddam was not merely a place with wicked individuals. Its moral foundations have become corrupted.
SPEAKER_00It wasn't that there were selfish people there. Society itself had normalized selfishness. Saddam recognized individual rights, but refused to accept any corresponding obligations towards other people. It was legally sophisticated, but morally bankrupt. In other words, laws, property rights, and prosperity are insufficient to guarantee a moral society. The question is, what was missing?
SPEAKER_00In order to understand what was missing in Saddam, we need to understand the difference between Sadaka, righteousness, and Mishpat, justice. Ralph Shimshom Rafael Hirsch explains that Mishpat, justice, is based on legal rights. Mishpat protects what belongs to others, prevents people from wronging others, and recognizes someone's legal entitlement. Mishpat are the rules by which society functions. Sadaka, righteousness, requires me to respond to another person's needs.
SPEAKER_00It requires me to do good. The obligation for sadaka comes from Hashem. Sadaka is based on my divine responsibility. It goes beyond legal entitlement. So let's say for example, I owe someone a hundred dollars. They have a legal right to demand payment. Paying that money is mishpat. But suppose I meet someone who's hungry and has no money to buy food. They have no legal claim against me or my property.
SPEAKER_00Yet Hashem has commanded me to take care for those in need. That obligation is sadaka. It's not simply a matter of generosity. I have responsibilities regarding the resources that Hashem is entrusted to me. The poor person does have a claim against me, but that claim comes from the duty that Hashem is imposed upon me. With this understanding of the difference between Sadaka and Mishpat, you notice something fascinating about our pasak.
SPEAKER_00It says Sadaka Umishpat. Sadaka comes first when really you'd expect Mishpat to come first. Because first you must respect the rights of others. Then you can engage in charity. Mishpat Ud Sadhaka. For example, imagine someone who steals money and then donates some to charity. They may look generous, but of course they've caused a great injustice. You cannot violate a person's rights and then claim moral virtue because you've helped someone else.
SPEAKER_00This is why you'd expect Mishpat to come first. First of all, there has to be property rights and ownership, and then you can give sadaka. Justice is the essential foundation. So why does the Pasak say Sadaka U Mishpat? Why does righteousness come first? Rav Shimshaw Rafael Hirsch explains that the problem with Saddam was not the absence of Mishpat, it was the absence of Sadaka. Saddam had laws. It had a system of rights and obligations.
SPEAKER_00It had the rules as brought down in Pirakey Avot. What's mine is mine and what's yours is yours. Property rights were respected. Raf Shimsham Raf Hersh explains that the problem is that Saddam was all Mishpat with no Sadaka. Society in Saddam refused to recognize that anyone had any responsibility for the needs of others. If someone was poor, that was their problem. In fact, the poor were seen as a threat to individual prosperity.
SPEAKER_00It was a threat to what's mine is mine. So in effect it became a criminal act to assist the poor. Saddam was legally organized and morally corrupt. It respected property rights while ignoring human suffering. It was all mishpat, justice, while lacking any humanity. Of course, we're not talking about Mishpat in its fullish Torah sense. We're talking about a system of laws and legal rights without the moral responsibility that Sadaka demands.
SPEAKER_00It is law without compassion, rights without responsibility. This is why Sadaka comes first in our pasup. It is a warning to us that legal justice on its own is insufficient. We must have sadaka. We must create a society in which responsibility to others is a fundamental obligation, otherwise it will become morally corrupt. So how do we ensure that Sadaka is indeed a moral obligation?
SPEAKER_00The answer to this question is in our Pasuk. Hashem could have said, Avraham instructs his children in his household after him, La Asot to do Sadaka Umishpat. But it says something different. It says that Avraham instructs his children in his household, the Shamru to observe Derech Hashem, the ways of Hashem, La Asot, so they can do Sadaka Umishpat, righteousness and justice.
SPEAKER_00Comes from the Shamru Derech Hashem to observe the ways of Hashem. Our moral responsibility for others comes from Hashem. We acknowledge that everyone was made but Selem Elokim in the image of Hashem. That's why we have responsibility. We recognize that everything we have is a Hesed from Hashem. Everything we have. So how can we not give Hesed to others? That's why it's a responsibility. In other words, first comes Bain Adam La Makom, commands between us and Hashem.
SPEAKER_00It's from recognizing Hashem's authority that then we can have Baina Dam La Khavero, commandments between each other. And of course, this is exactly how the Asserat Hadibrot, the Ten Commandments, are structured. The first five are Baina Damla Makom between us and Hashem. The second five are then Bainadam La Khavero between man and man. Raf Hersh says Hukim and then Mishpatim.
SPEAKER_00It's the Hukim that teach us to subordinate ourselves to Hashem. Having recognized Hashem's authority, the Mishpatim then govern our relationship with others, which includes Sadaka. In other words, the Torah's vision of a truly just society cannot be separated from Hukim, shaking Lulaf, keeping kosher, or putting on to fillin. Of course shaking Lulaf doesn't feed the hungry. Keeping kosher doesn't make a person generous.
SPEAKER_00Putting on to fillin doesn't make someone honest in business. But these mitzvot belong to a way of life that teaches us something fundamental. I'm not the ultimate authority in my own life. My understanding and my logic are not the final arbiters of right and wrong. Hashem is. And my obligations, including Sadaka, come from what he has demanded of me. Of course, we all know kind, generous, and moral individuals who don't believe in Hashem.
SPEAKER_00But what about societies? People sometimes point to modern Western democracies as examples of moral societies that don't depend on religion. But their understanding of human dignity, moral responsibility, and justice has been shaped by centuries of religious tradition. In fact, much of what they regard as self-evidently right and wrong has been profoundly influenced by Torah. They might be secular societies now, but they've had centuries of what people call the Judeo-Christian tradition, much of which comes from the Torah.
SPEAKER_00As these secular societies continue to develop, they have an issue with which they are struggling. Who decides what is right and wrong? What happens with new scientific developments? What happens when the majority wants change and the minority does not? What happens as cultural norms evolve for some and not for others? This is what makes Derech Hashem, the way of Hashem, so important. The Torah establishes a moral authority that stands above every individual, every government, and every society.
SPEAKER_00Even the most powerful person in the world is answerable to Hashem. And that is why Beina Damla Makom, the commands between us and Hashem matter so profoundly. The Hukim, the ritual mitzvat teach us that we're not the ultimate authority in our lives. We are answerable to something greater than ourselves. And that same authority demands Sudaka Umishpat, righteousness and justice.
SPEAKER_00Of course, believing in Hashem does not automatically make a person righteous or a society just. Human beings with free will have the ability to not adhere to the standards by which they profess to live. However, the Torah's answer is not simply to believe in Hashem, it's to live according to Derech Hashem, the way of Hashem. A way of life that demands both service of Hashem and responsibility towards other human beings.
SPEAKER_00That's the society Avraham Avenu was chosen to establish. So how do we build this society? Of course, we follow Torah, but we can also learn from Avraham because our Pasak explains why Hashem chose Avraham. Rashi explains that Hashem has a special affection for Avraham. Yadativ, I've known I've known him, is affection because when you love someone, you draw them close, you know them. But why does Hashem have this affection for Avraham?
SPEAKER_00It's not because Avram discovered Hashem. It's not because Avraham is a Sadik. It's not because of the trials that he's endured. It's because he commands his children and his household Acharav after him. Avram is not someone who just follows Hashem. He is someone who ensures that following Hashem becomes a way of life that continues after him. He's educating his children and his household for future generations.
SPEAKER_00The Pasak goes on to say that Hashem will fulfill his promise Al-Avraham upon Avraham. Why does it say that? It's not Avraham Avenu that gets to see these promises fulfilled. We don't get Erit Yisrael in his lifetime. It happens generations later. So what does it mean, Al-Avraham upon Avraham? Rashi says it should sedate Avraham upon the house of Avraham.
SPEAKER_00So Rashi brings down and says that we learn from this that someone who raises a righteous child is regarded as though they have not died. In other words, a person's achievements are not confined to their lifetime. They continue through the values, commitments, and way of life that they transmit to their children and others around them. Avram was not merely being asked by Hashem to be at Sadiq. That doesn't require a Brit, a covenant.
SPEAKER_00He was being asked to establish a culture of righteousness that would survive after him. With this in mind, we can understand a Rambam in Hilchot Matanat Anim, Gifts to the Poor. The Rambam says the most amazing thing. He says we are obligated to be more careful in observing the mitzvah of Sadaka than any other positive mitzvah. Why? Because Sadaka is the distinguishing mark of the righteous descendants of Avrahama Vinu.
SPEAKER_00And then the Rambam says the throne of Yisrael cannot be established, nor can the true religion endure except through Sadaka. It's not that Sadaka is important. It's that Jewish national life cannot be established or continue without Sadaka. Why? Because the Jewish people were not chosen simply to become a nation. We were chosen to become a particular type of nation. A nation founded on Derech Hashem.
SPEAKER_00The ways of Hashem characterized by Sadaka, Umishpat, righteousness and justice. And this is why the Rambam says Sadaka is the distinguishing mark of the righteous descendants of Avramavinu. What does that mean? Does that mean no other nation gives charity? Of course not.
unknownBut the
SPEAKER_00The nature of the charity is different. In almost all the nations of the world, charity is seen as kindness. It's seen as generosity. Oh, you're so good to give that charity. That was so kind of you to give that charity. Give whatever you can afford to give. That's not what sadakah is for Klal Ishrael. Sadakah for Klal Ishrael is not generosity. It's not kindness in that way. It's justice, it's righteousness.
SPEAKER_00We give sadaka because we're obliged to give it. It is our obligation when people are starving, when people are hungry, when people are in need. As a klal, as a people, it's our obligation to help them. It's not generosity. It's something that we have to do. Something that we've commanded by Hashen to do. And therefore it takes on a completely different character in the Jewish people than it does from other nations in the world.
SPEAKER_00So Saddam is doomed to destruction because it's morally bankrupt. It's a society with Mishpat but no sadaka, justice but no righteousness. Without answering to our high authority, the people of Saddam do not believe they have an obligation to help others. Avraham famously tries to save Saddam. And Rav Shimshom Rafael Hirsh points out two very important aspects of this. Avraham does not say if there are 50 Sadiqim in the city, that Saddam should be saved when he's debating with Hashem.
SPEAKER_00Avraham says, But if there are 50 Sadiqim, but Toh Ha'ir in the midst of the city. Rav Shimshon Rafa Hersh says that in the midst of the city means that they were not just righteous people living in Saddam. They'd be righteous people that are engaged with their community, trying to influence it, improve it, and make it better. Rav Shimshon points out that this is why it says the city should be saved.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't say, Havram doesn't say to Hashem, save the city for 50 righteous people. If there are 50 people living in Saddam, it should be saved. He's saying 50 people that are engaged in the midst of the city, trying to turn the city around, trying to make it better, and then you should save the city, Lamatan, for the sake of these 50 Sadiqim. Because the anguish it would cause them, if the citizens that they have tried to engage with and improve were all killed, would be too much.
SPEAKER_00It's not a question of saving them because their lives deserve being saved. Because when you're engaged with others, you're educating others, you're helping others, the anguish it would cause to see their death and destruction would be too much to bear. Of course, there weren't 50 righteous people in Saddam. In fact, there weren't even ten. After Avram's negotiation with Hashem, Hashem agrees that if there are merely 10 Sadiqim in the whole of Saddam, the city will be spared.
SPEAKER_00But it's an amazing lesson for us. Because although they didn't exist in Saddam, it means that if righteousness still exists within a society, if righteous people can still stand up and attempt to influence others, that society may not be beyond redemption. That's the remarkable insight for us to take away. Not that Avram failed because there weren't ten righteous people in Saddam, but actually within that there's a message of hope.
SPEAKER_00That even if there had been only 10 righteous people trying to influence others, that society would not be doomed. That society could still be saved. And of course this matters. Because whether you're in a house, a village, a town, a community, a city where people need turning around, and you're a lone voice, so there's only a few of you, you still have the ability to change. There's still hope.
SPEAKER_00And of course, this matters for the Jewish people themselves. We're a tiny nation. Sixteen million of a world population of over eight billion. Only 0.2% of the world's population. But what we learn from Avraham's debating with Hashem and this getting to this final figure of 10 righteous people is numbers do not determine the ultimate significance of our actions. The possibility of changing the world does not depend on numbers, but having the courage to remain committed to what is right.
SPEAKER_00So why can't you have a just society if you don't shake Lulaf? Of course, an individual can be moral without observing the ritual mitzvot. But the Torah is trying to achieve something much bigger than producing a collection of decent individuals. It's seeking to establish a nation whose moral responsibilities are rooted in a covenantal relationship with Hashem. A nation in which Sadaka and Mishpat, righteousness and justice, are not simply matters of personal preference or social convention.
SPEAKER_00They're obligations imposed by Hashem. Every time we shake Lulav, every time we put on tefillin, every time we keep kosher, we remind ourselves that we are not the ultimate authority in our lives. We answer to Hashem. And the very same Hashem who commands us to shake Lulav also commands us to feed the hungry, care for the vulnerable, and act with justice. They're not two separate Judaisms, they are one Derech Hashem.
SPEAKER_00Hashem did not choose Avraham simply to be a good person. He chose Avraham to establish a nation. And that nation was to be founded upon Dere Hashem, the ways of Hashem, expressed through Sadakah, righteousness, Umishpad, and justice. Avraham understood that. And his greatness was not simply that he lived that way himself. It was that he established a nation that would continue living that way long after he had gone.
SPEAKER_00We are the descendants of Avraham. We inherit that mission. The Torah doesn't demand that every Jew change the entire world, but it does demand that every Jew recognizes their responsibility to make some part of the world better. And the lesson of Avraham's dialogue with Hashem when he tried to save Saddam is that even a small number of righteous people can preserve the possibility of a better future for an entire society.
SPEAKER_00Avraham's mission was not measured by numbers, but by what continued after him and still does to this very day. We never know the impact that we have on others. When we visit someone who is sick, when we pay a shiva call, when we invite someone into our home for a meal, and perhaps that's the most extraordinary aspect of Avraham's legacy. He was one man. He changed the course of human history.
SPEAKER_00We may not be able to change the whole world, but we must never underestimate how much of the world that we can change.
Being Jewish & Judaism: Bitter enemies are suddenly finding common cause against the Jewish People. Ancient hatreds are returning with a vengeance. And once again, the Jewish People find themselves at the centre of a...
Jewish Teachings, Torah & Parsha Analysis: How do you know that what you believe to be real actually is? What if everything you think you know about reality is fundamentally wrong? We live our lives with certain...
What if everything we normally associate with Judaism and being Jewish misses something fundamental? Avraham Avinu believed in HaShem. He stood against idolatry. He displayed extraordinary courage, kindness and emunah....
Torah Ethics: Before the Flood, HaShem sees the evil in mankind and decides to destroy the world. After the Flood, He acknowledges that same inclination towards evil and promises never to destroy the world in this way...
We all know how the Torah begins. Or at least, we think we do. But consider: • Why did HaShem create the world through speech? • Why ten utterances? • What is the extraordinary connection between the Ten Utterances of...