Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

It Could Happen Here

It Could Happen Here artwork

Were Macklemore’s First Amendment Rights Violated?

Sep 30, 202633 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Kevin Foster speaks with Mo Meltzer-Cohen, a law professor at CUNY School of Law, about Macklemore being booted from the Ed Sheeran tour and the First Amendment implications. Sources: https://www.instagram.com/reels/Dc_bH4_N1FN/ https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/macklemore-dropped-ed-sheeran-tour-robert-kraft-statement-1235626352/ https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/ed-sheerans-shows-stadium-owned-pro-israel-robert-kraft-cancelled https://www.instagram.com/p/DdRdsy0m2HK/?img_index=4 https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/macklemore-dropped-ed-sheeran-tour-pro-palestine-statements-1235625967/ https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/macklemore-statement-dropped-ed-sheeran-tour-1235626135/ https://www.youtube.com/shorts/ngmblAp7y_I https://www.lucasoilstadium.com/tours-stadium-info/background-history/ https://blankfamilyofbusinesses.com/company/amb-sports-entertainment/ https://raymondjamesstadium.com/tampasportsauthority https://www.tampasportsauthority.com/tsa-about https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/ye/2026/raymond-james-stadium-tampa-fl-33745801.html https://www.texastribune.org/2026/09/24/ut-texas-austin-palestine-protest-ruling/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Welcome to It Could Happen Here, I'm Kevin Foster, and today we're separating the art from the artist, specifically taking Macklemore's solid political takes and isolating them from his, let's just say, iconic bars like What Up, I Got a Big Cock. For those who aren't caught up, Macklemore was touring with Ed Sheeran not long ago before he was removed from the tour for espousing pro-Palestine statements on stage at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey. Specifically, he said Free Palestine a few times and thanked students at Columbia University

Speaker 1for kicking off the encampments movement in spring of 2024. Those students inspired his song Hins Hall, the title student protesters gave Columbia's Hamilton Hall, named after Hind Rajab, a five-year-old who was brutally murdered by the Israeli Defense Forces in Gaza in January of 2024. In a beautiful case of leopards eating faces, Ed Sheeran's entire lineup of opening acts and his backing band withdrew from the tour in solidarity with Macklemore. In his next performance, Sheeran gave a

Speaker 1sort of apology speech to the crowd, reading off a teleprompter in which he did not use the words genocide or Palestinian. Rather than focusing on that, due to the outstanding negative response to McLemore's statements from Zionist billionaires, I think it's worth listening to some of what he actually said on stage. Here's a clip from his Instagram.

Speaker 2To all of my Jewish brothers and sisters, criticism of Israel, criticism of apartheid, being against genocide in no way is a criticism of you. My message is for peace, love, for all human beings to be treated with dignity, respect, and equality. So I say free Palestine. I say free Lebanon. I say free Cuba. I say free Congo, free Sudan,

Speaker 2free all people in America living in fear over this terrorist organization ICE. None of us will be free until we are all free. This song is called Hen's Hall.

Speaker 1Some deeply frightening stuff in there, at least for Robert Kraft, the pro-Israel billionaire owner of the New England Patriots football team, and Gillette Stadium in Foxborough, Massachusetts, near Boston, where McLemore was set to appear on tour with Sheeran. Kraft was not happy with McLemore's support of Palestinian equal rights on stage, and he confirmed to Rolling Stone that he barred McLemore from appearing at the Boston shows over, quote, recent actions, material shared from the stage during Ed Sheeran's shows in

Speaker 1New Jersey, and a broader history of anti-Semitic rhetoric and imagery that we believe has been deeply offensive and hurtful to the Jewish community, unquote. Despite McLemore's clear calls for equality and peace, Kraft felt his presence at Gillette Stadium would stymie the supposed goal of providing a, quote, welcoming environment for all guests and ensuring that all events held at our venue do not provide a platform for hate speech, unquote. Funnily enough, those shows ended up getting cancelled anyway due

Speaker 1to severe weather warnings. But Kraft allegedly did not stop there. According to a post by Macklemore following his removal from the tour, Sheeran apparently said that Kraft had rallied other stadium owners with an ultimatum, quoting from that post, if Macklemore stays on the tour, you will not be allowed to play in our venues, unquote. Messina Touring Group, the promoter of the U.S. portion of Sheeran's tour, said in a statement that they were notified by venues from the upcoming U.S. tour dates that they would not allow a

Speaker 1concert to take place with Macklemore in the lineup. Obviously, this represents a serious affront to freedom of speech, something that is far from new on the matter of Palestine. As of yet, Kraft has not discussed or denied the allegations of mounting this pressure campaign against the rapper. In response to the controversy, basically everyone and their mother chimed in, including Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who pretty well lays out the real focus of this episode.

Speaker 3This is about how just a handful... of stadium owners and the elite can prevent an entire massive issue, in this case the genocide in Gaza, but it doesn't stop there.

Speaker 4It could be speaking out about AI.

Speaker 3It could be speaking out about any issue.

Speaker 1Here's where things get interesting. Rolling Stone lists seven stadium venues that allegedly objected to McLemore's inclusion in the tour and and of those seven, five are publicly owned by either the city, county, or state in which they reside. I could spend quite a lot of time talking about how I think Ed Sheeran is a coward, how it is a political statement to fold in favor of genocide deniers, but what I'm far more interested in is the First Amendment implications of Kraft's alleged actions and the ways in which billionaires are able to wield authority over our right

Speaker 1and capital. To discuss this in depth, I've interviewed friend of the pod Mo Meltzer-Cohen, a law professor at CUNY School of Law, experienced in defense of people targeted on the basis of First Amendment protected beliefs, identities, and association. Let's dive right into that. I'm kind of wondering if you can just tell me from what you know about this case, what do you make of a billionaire kind of organizing a censorship campaign like this? Have you seen

Speaker 1similar things in different contexts around free speech?

Speaker 4Well, certainly. And there are all manner of ways in which coercive social or economic pressure is brought to bear on different people or different events or forums in order to constrain the expressive conduct of different people. or different groups, there's certainly nothing at all that is unique or unusual about that. I think what's important to recognize before we really get too deep into this is when we're talking

Speaker 4about free speech principles, we can talk about free speech or free expression as a shared cultural value, but the First Amendment only applies to the government.

Speaker 5Right?

Speaker 4So when we're talking about censorship, we need to be clear about whether we're talking about a private individual or company refusing to platform particular speech, which is certainly censorship, but it isn't government censorship of the kind that the First Amendment is concerned with. Right? Yeah. The First Amendment... as a legal principle, a set of legal principles, is

Speaker 4a constraint on the power of the government to censor political speech or to censor free expression, right? It's a constraint on the power of the state to restrict people's ability to speak, to associate with each other, to believe freely. And so I think what's interesting about this particular situation that you've raised is that an event planning company or

Speaker 4a private theater or Robert Kraft himself as an individual are certainly at liberty to decline to give a platform to any speech that they find offensive. Robert Kraft takes umbrage. at somebody's music, he is under no obligation to subsidize it, to support it, to give it a platform. But you've pointed out that some of these stadiums at which these

Speaker 4performances were scheduled to occur are owned by cities, are municipally owned, or are owned by the state.

Speaker 1I Yeah, so I can dive into a little bit of the details on that. There's specifically the stadiums that are in Philadelphia, Atlanta, Tampa, Indianapolis, and Arlington, Texas. They're not all operated by public entities, but they are all owned by public entities between city, county, and state. But in the examples where they are privately operated, it's like the Atlanta Falcons or the Philadelphia Eagles. But I reached

Speaker 1out to these different groups, and in some cases, they tried to push it on to the operators. Like in Philadelphia, they told me to reach out to the Eagles for Lincoln Financial Stadium. They did not respond to my emails. And then I had this in, I think it was Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis. They did actually respond, but that was from the Capital Improvement Board for Marion County, Indiana. And They said, quote, we can confirm Messina Touring's announcement that Macklemore will not be performing at the upcoming show. And then they said Lucas Oil Stadium is a public

Speaker 1facility and as such is content neutral, which, you know, I had to follow up and ask about that. And they didn't respond to that. But it's a bit silly when they're sort of barring a performer. But like you said, where I feel like this was especially sort of troubling was in Tampa. They're both owned publicly. and it's operated by the Tampa Sports Authority, who did not respond to my request for comment. And that seems to create this sort of complex situation. I don't know exactly what all

Speaker 1the contracts are behind the scenes and who gets to control these things. But if it's a publicly owned and operated facility, I mean, does that raise some concerns?

Speaker 4It sure does. And so it's interesting that they reached back out to you that Lucas Oil Stadium said, we are content neutral. So that's a legal term of art. So let's keep them out a little bit.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4So as I said, the First Amendment is a constraint on the power of the government to dictate It says the government cannot be the arbiter of expression. And so if you have a stadium that is owned by the government, presumably that forum is a public forum in the same way that a public park would be considered a public forum.

Speaker 4And that's legally significant.

Speaker 3Hmm.

Speaker 4Why is that legally significant? Because in what's called a traditional public forum, land, an area that is owned by the government, well, the government is permitted to impose constraints on the time, place, and manner of expression. Those constraints, first of all, they have to be reasonable constraints, right? And those constraints may not be imposed on the basis

Speaker 4of content or viewpoint discrimination, right? So that's what they're saying when Lucas Oil Stadium says, Lucas Oil Stadium is content neutral. It's a very inelegant way of saying we aren't discriminating on the basis of viewpoint. So constraints may be imposed, but they have to be content neutral. They can't be based on viewpoint discrimination, right? They have to be narrowly tailored to serve a significant government purpose or

Speaker 4a significant government interest. And there are a range of things that are understood to be legitimate or valid significant government interests, right? They are things like public safety, making sure that school children's educational activities are not disrupted, right? Making sure that people have access to and from public buildings, right? These would be considered valid government interests. Now that issue

Speaker 4sort of points up the fact that with respect to stadiums in particular, there are frequently events held at stadiums where in the wake of those events, typically sporting events, There are threats to public safety. There are very often extremely foreseeable incidences of boisterousness, shall we say, after, you know,

Speaker 4the Super Bowl or the Stanley Cup. You know, publicly owned stadiums are not exercising their right to impose reasonable constraints on the time, place, and manner of expression by... shutting down the Super Bowl, right, in anticipation of what they could reasonably expect to be rowdiness.

Speaker 1I think Mamdani would be recalled if he tried to stop the Knicks games over public safety concerns.

Speaker 4I don't think Mamdani would ever do such a thing.

Speaker 1No, I know.

Speaker 4They won. Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 4In any event, it is really important to understand that it is permissible for the government to impose constraints on expression. They have to be reasonable constraints. They have to be content neutral, right? Not discriminating on the basis of viewpoint. They have to be narrowly tailored, meaning they can't just be, okay, we're going to shut down everything because we have some concern, some speculative concern that like maybe there's going to be some rowdy behavior. And finally, and critically, those constraints have

Speaker 4to leave open what are called ample alternative channels of communication, right? So absolutely canceling a performance would not leave open ample alternative channels of communication, right?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 4And it's not clear what the public interest is in this case because... you know, there are exceptions. There are things that fall outside the zone of First Amendment protections. And there are things like fighting words, you know, hate speech, true threats. But it's very clear that criticism of Israel, support for Palestine, solidarity with Palestine, those things are not hate speech, right? Criticism of the political ideology of Zionism.

Speaker 4These are not instances of anti-Semitic hate speech, right? Yeah. And so it's, you know, however offensive Robert Kraft or anyone else might find solidarity with Palestine to be, it is not speech of a kind that is exempted from the protections of the First Amendment. So, you know, if Again, if there's a private event company or a privately owned

Speaker 4stadium that says, we don't want to have Macklemore play, they're at liberty to do that, right? They can make that decision.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4What we can't have, or at least what deserves interrogation, what deserves a serious inquiry, is a publicly owned, government-run entity shutting down speech at the behest of a wealthy individual powerful individual, not on the basis of needing to impose a reasonable constraint or a reasonable restriction on the time, place, or manner of expression based on a content-neutral analysis that

Speaker 4is narrowly tailored to serve some significant government interest while also leaving open ample alternative channels of communication, right? I am concerned about a public stadium bowing to that kind of pressure, particularly in light of the fact that Kanye West can perform freely. And Kanye West is pretty openly anti-Semitic.

Speaker 1This is a sort of a, not even really a side note, but Kanye West performed multiple times at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa at the end of June. And, you know, while the setlist FM doesn't say that he performed his song, Heil Hitler, that I guess came out in 2025. It's hard to believe where we're at sometimes, but it's the the the open hypocrisy of that is just astounding.

Speaker 4But well, it's never been about anti-Semitism.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 4I mean, just as a as a side side note. There are more Christian Zionists in the United States than there are Jews in the entire world, and they are explicitly motivated by explicitly anti-Semitic goals, right? One of which is to create a mass exodus of Jewish people from the so-called global north. Oh, God. And the other of which is to hasten the apocalypse, at which point, according

Speaker 4to the Christian Zionist eschatology, some Jews will become Christian and remaining Jews will go to hell. So this is not and has never been about anti-Semitism. It is about criticism of Israel. It is about solidarity with Palestine. Now, you know, we're looking at this very sort of niche and narrow issue of what are the implications for the First Amendment in when we have a municipally owned or

Speaker 4a government owned event space and a performer is prevented from or forbidden from performing in that space, clearly on the basis of what would typically be understood to be protected speech. Why does it matter? I mean, just to clarify, I am not an expert certainly in whatever kinds of leases or contract arrangements there are between these cities or

Speaker 4states and, you know, third-party event planning companies, which, you know, if there's enough space in between, you know, the stadium and the decision being made potentially by a private third party, that might vitiate some of those First Amendment protections.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 4I don't know because I don't know enough of the facts on the ground there. And nevertheless, I think it is really important for us to address ourselves to this question. Am I a Macklemore fan? I, you know, not particularly. I mean, he's fine. But my concern is not with a wealthy and powerful recording artist. My concern is that we look at this situation with Macklemore, and I think

Speaker 4it is obscuring a whole range of threats to free expression for the rest of us, right? Because, you know, is anyone going to be real worried about Macklemore's welfare? No, he's fine to his credit by his own admission. He's not suffering. My concern is not with Macklemore not being allowed to play a show. My concern is with the

Speaker 4implications for the rest of us when we're allowing these kinds of incursions into First Amendment protections. And I think this is such an interesting case because the fact that it's Macklemore is actually functioning, I think, to camouflage what those threats are, right? Because we're also focused on the fact that it's this wealthy, powerful guy that we're missing

Speaker 4the fact that the First Amendment protections can't be mobilized to protect his free expression, how else might we see these end runs around constitutional protections for the rest of us? I think there are a lot of things that are protected by the First Amendment that aren't necessarily legible to us as First Amendment protected beliefs, associations, or activities.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 4Because we often will think about things that are First Amendment protected as being like the right to go to a particular kind of religious institution or the right to go to a protest. Right. But a lot of the most important First Amendment case law deals with things like are multiple adolescents allowed to hang out on the public sidewalk together? without getting arrested, right? Does it constitute probable

Speaker 4cause of unlawful conduct for there to be more than two Black children hanging out together on the stoop? Yeah. Right? That's not the kind of First Amendment protected activity that most people think about. It's not the top of mind when you say First Amendment, right? I think people are thinking about, you know, people like marching against the war in Vietnam.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 4But we do many things every day that are protected by the First Amendment, not just, you know, posting on the internet, not just, you know, having privacy with respect to who we're calling, right, being permitted to make phone calls to anyone we want. Like a birthday party is a First Amendment protected gathering, right? Our right to assemble. our right to free association, right? And so having an

Speaker 4incursion into those protections, any incursion into those protections has implications for all of those other things. And if we stop paying attention and we say, oh, this is sort of a punchline, right? Oh, Macklemore's being canceled by the rich right-wing, stadium owners, and we don't look at the fact that there is a public performance that is being

Speaker 4canceled by potentially the government, we're missing a whole range of risks. Because what's at stake is not Macklemore's career. What's at stake is the ability of all of the rest of us to freely associate, to petition the government,

Speaker 4to believe the things that we believe without being censored, without being punished for doing so. So one of the other things that deserves to be said here is one of the reasons that this is a little bit confusing and that the waters are so muddied is this issue

Speaker 4that I referred to a minute ago with respect to these publicly owned stadiums, leasing out digital authority to these third party companies, right? Yeah. Or private and which are, as non-government entities are not subject to the constraints of the First Amendment. That's not a problem with the First Amendment. That's a problem with the privatization of public life.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4And I think we're seeing that in a lot of other realms as well. So for example, as we see traditional government functions being more and more assumed by private utilities, we have a situation where what, you know, 40 years ago might have been people petitioning the government not to build a pipeline, right? That would have been a First Amendment protected gathering, right? We might have a protest at

Speaker 4a government building. That would be protected by the First Amendment. Now, if you have a group of people who want to protest, for example— a pipeline, that whole process beginning to end may be so controlled by a private corporation that there's no government building to protest that anymore, right? And so what would have otherwise been a First Amendment protected protest is now a bunch of trespassing charges. Yeah.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 4Because the place that people are going to do that protest to carry out that protest may be private property. Right.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 4You know, we're no longer petitioning the government. Now we're petitioning, you know, energy transfer partners.

Speaker 1This sort of, you know, raises this question. On the one hand, I'm like, oh, I'm not as worried about, you know, Robert Kraft getting to say, oh, Macklemore is not welcome at Gillette Stadium. I'm thinking about the ways in which he's able to use his wealth and capital to sort of manipulate the situation with government entities or call on his NFL buddies to kick them out in other places. But there is also a consideration around the concentration of wealth and the ways in which privatization is

Speaker 1rapidly happening in various different instances across the country. And at what point do you see the shrinking of the public square just generally across the board? And the ways in which billionaires are then able to control the narrative through that ownership.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 4I think one of the other things that is worth pointing out is a lot of times when we're talking about First Amendment retaliation or, you know, what we're seeing here, right, where you see an organization, public or private, engage in this kind of really obvious way censorship on the basis of viewpoint, we usually do not see the kind of smoking gun, but you know, the putting it in an

Speaker 4email and saying, I don't want to see this individual being allowed to perform for the following reason, which is that he expressed solidarity with Palestine, right? we usually see at least a little bit more, well, usually we don't have a smoking gun email.

Speaker 1Yeah, or talking to the press about it.

Speaker 4And I think that one of the things that's actually unusual about this situation is that maybe just due to wealth and power, Robert Kraft didn't have any compunction or concern about very publicly saying, I don't want this to happen because I am offended personally by... the political content of his speech. Yeah. And I would say, you know, typically people who are at least in government who have the kind of power know better than to say the

Speaker 4quiet part out loud. Yeah. And I think it's sort of interesting, I guess, just that the billionaire class has become so comfortable with their own strength, I guess, that they're not concerned about being publicly very honest about their disabilities. to censor certain people. And so, you know, in this instance, it may actually be an interesting opportunity just because some

Speaker 4of these stadiums are publicly owned. And so to the extent that those stadiums can be shown to have canceled the show or under pressure from this private actor. And on the basis of that private actor's sort of personal convictions, it does create an interesting opportunity. You had said something about not being clear on what the leases were and the,

Speaker 4you know, the arrangements and contracts. And I am also not clear on what those contracts are, how they might implicate First Amendment concerns or undermine First Amendment rights. But if there were to be, for example, a lawsuit filed about it, some of that stuff would come out in discovery in the process of turning over evidence. And so if nothing else, I kind of hope that, you know, one of the impact litigation outfits does file a suit

Speaker 4not because I am concerned about vindicating Macklemore's First Amendment rights, but because I think we need to really be vigilant and alert to the actual legal mechanisms by which the government is performing an end run around constraints on state power.

Speaker 1To wrap this episode up, I just wanted to highlight again, although it may feel a bit silly to talk about all this in the context of McLemore, a multi-millionaire, I think the point is that this sets a bad precedent. Notably, we've witnessed crackdowns on university students over Palestine solidarity protests. There was a new ruling against a student from the University of Texas Austin just last week. There may still be open questions about these stadiums and their complicated contract arrangements, But either way, the wealthy are wielding influence over the

Speaker 1public square. With all that said, here is Mo with one final note.

Speaker 4I would just like your listeners to be alert to all of the ways in which our daily lives are frankly made possible by First Amendment protections that we don't think about very often. And I would like to plug the concept and the practice. of not talking to law enforcement until you have had an opportunity to consult with counsel.

Speaker 1Yeah, always good.

Speaker 5It Could Happen Here is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can now find sources for It Could Happen Here listed directly in episode descriptions.

Speaker 1Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Guests

  • Mo Meltzer-Cohen Guest Inferred

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. CZM Book Club: "Organizing Social Spaces as if Social Relations Matter," by Cindy Barukh Milstein (Part Three of Three)

    Nov 22, 202636 minAudio

    Margaret finishes reading you some non-fiction with advice for organizers

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. It Could Happen Here Weekly 259

    Nov 21, 20263 hr 56 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Executive Disorder: Everything Breaks, Rohingya Genocide, Mamdani Disbands SRG

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    The gang chats about all the many tech outages this week, the ICJ finding Myanmar guilty of genocide against Rohingya, corporate executives pocketing tariff refund money, protests in Bangladesh over working conditions,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Repression in Iran

    Nov 19, 202642 minAudio

    James is joined by Gordayeen to talk about the Iranian state’s repressive tactics and the failure of the USA and ISrael to diminish the capacity for state violence Sources: https://hengaw.org/ https://www.theamargi.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Organizing Agricultural Workers

    Nov 18, 202644 minAudio

    Mia talks with Lindsey and Brady of the IWW about what we can learn about organizing agricultural workers from efforts abroad and organizing outside of the National Labor Relations Act

    Credit the people on this episode