James is joined by Natali Geovia of the Water Protector Legal Collective to discuss the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) and the tremendous damage it could do to protections for the land, Indigenous people, and public health. https://www.waterprotectorlegal.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey everyone, it's James.
Speaker 2Today we're coming to you with a Wednesday episode, which is very unusual for us because we think this is very important. We wanted to get something out to you as soon as possible. I'm very lucky to be joined by Natalie Segovia today.
Speaker 1Natalie, would you like to introduce yourself to the listeners?
Speaker 3Hi James, thank you so much. My name is Natalie Segovia. I'm the Executive Director and Senior Attorney at the Water Protector Legal Collective. We're a non-profit law firm that's Indigenous-led that started at Standing Rock in 2016 in defence of the water and Indigenous peoples and allies that showed up to protect the water from a pipeline crossing across Indigenous lands.
Speaker 2Talking of pipelines, we're here today to talk about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. That's a lot of buzzwords in the name of one bill, right? Unfortunately, not as good as the name makes it sound. And we wanted to talk particularly about the way that this act strips like cornerstone pieces of legislation of their teeth, right? They protect both like indigenous people, they protect the land, they protect the water. So perhaps you could begin a little bit by explaining some of the things that this
Speaker 2bill would take away.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3So this bill known as Baja, right, but in short has been widely talked about as something that is being pushed to streamline and fast-track federal permitting processes. Part of the idea behind this is that it would fast-track things like pipelines and infrastructure projects and development and unleash the power of American energy.
Speaker 1Great, cool.
Speaker 3But the other part of that is, you know, senators on both sides of the aisle thinking about things like clean energy sources or supposedly clean energy sources. But I think the bigger question is at what cost are we trying to push through federal permitting changes? And what's really critical about this proposed legislation that advanced the Senate actually by a 73 to 25 vote just yesterday. So it's moved to advance and to open for debate in the
Speaker 3Senate is that it would it would really curtail four cornerstone laws, the National Environmental Policy Act, NEPA. the National Historic Preservation Act, NHPA, the Clean Water Act, and the Endangered Species Act. And these four laws really emerged from growing recognition that there were lasting environmental, public health, and cultural harms that were caused by unfettered development and industrial pollution. So these laws have given us the backbone to protect environmental laws, protect water, wildlife, consult with tribal nations, And
Speaker 3they really give the public a voice to express opposition or being in favor of projects as they come. They also allow us to hold agencies, federal agencies and corporate actors accountable when they violate these laws. So what we're seeing is that this law, this legislation would actually narrow these protections, would limit and completely overhaul what we know today to be NEPA, the National Environmental Policy Act. What
Speaker 3severely weakened the National Historic Preservation Act, in particular, tribal consultation aspects of that, as well as what qualifies, for example, as a sacred site for protection under the NHPA and more, right? Clean Water Act and ESA really protecting species, endangered species, threatened species, species we love and know well and others that we have yet to hear about.
Speaker 2Yeah, and I think it's wrapped up in this language of bipartisanship and infrastructure and clean energy and all these things, right? But we don't have to give up so very much if we want to get those things. And this is how Congress works, right? Specifically how certain people in Congress work. I talk about Senator Mike Lee a lot because he hates everything that I love, but they love to sneak in these things that strip away protections for our land, for indigenous people into things that they can wrap up.
Speaker 1As being good.
Speaker 2And in this case, like, Also, a bunch of think tanks have published these explainers. As you said before, it's a 400-page bill, and it's being explained away as, oh, this is fine, this is justified, that it's going to get support in Congress.
Speaker 1And as we've said, this is not okay.
Speaker 2And one of the things we spoke about is that it strips away the right to go to the courts and to be able to challenge some of these permits if they are violating NEPA or ESA or other things.
Speaker 1Is that right?
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3So one of the things that you can do currently under NEPA is, as a member of the public, provide a public comment. And we've seen a lot of this. There's been, I think, more activity in public comments in the past few public comment periods on really critical places, protecting places that are national parks, national monuments, places that we all hold dear and love.
Speaker 1What this would.
Speaker 3Introduce would be a heightened requirement to submit substantive comments that would put a party on notice, right? That we don't like what you're doing and we're going to sue you eventually. And to allege an actual or imminent injury in fact, what that means is that anybody that doesn't do that and is a potential plaintiff later on, their claims will be barred. So they're limiting judicial review. The other thing that they're also limiting is the kind of remedy that courts can actually provide. Usually a court can
Speaker 3vacate an unlawful approval, like a pipeline permit, a water crossing permit for a pipeline. That was the case in the Dakota Access Pipeline. And they can issue permanent or temporary injunctions based on NEPA violations. This legislation would basically get rid of injunctive relief. Oh, shit. for the vast majority of cases, and specifically for NEPA violations, which means that a pipeline company or a data center, right, even
Speaker 3if there's a successful legal challenge under NEPA, the court would have no recourse or no ability to stop the project while they fix the problem and come into compliance. That threatens the underlying rule of law that we you know, is part of the nation's origin story and mythology of what we tell ourselves, right? That we are a nation of lots. And I'd like to say as a lawyer that we are, but the reality is that what we are seeing here and push forward as legislation is something
Speaker 3that will impact on the ground in more ways than legislators in D.C. that are so far disconnected from what we're seeing on the ground will actually happen. Yeah.
Speaker 2And I think this is particularly nefarious in that we've seen waivers for all of these things and more at the border, right?
Speaker 1Even the Bolden Golden Eagle Protection Act, right? Like our national bird.
Speaker 2But that came from Kristi Noem and people were upset about it, but there wasn't much they could do. Here, you're seeing bipartisan support for this. And yeah, it's wrapped up in like, we're going to have more windmills and solar panels. But as I understand it, this would also mean we get more data centers and pipelines, right?
Speaker 1Exactly.
Speaker 2A couple of other things that I wanted to talk about. It seems to double the lengths of some permits, right? So they get a decade without review, if that's correct, which is a wild amount of time to do a lot of damage.
Speaker 1That's right.
Speaker 3So currently there is less time for review of this kind of infrastructure. They're seeing under this legislation that it would essentially provide less overview of these kinds of projects. So, for example, under Section 404 and 401 of the Clean Water Act, it would narrow the scope of water quality certification, limit the authority of states and tribal nations there. And I think that's what you're talking about, right? Ten years
Speaker 3is usually the time. It's a significant period of time for watersheds that are already experiencing pollution and drought and flooding and habitat loss and other environmental changes. Yeah. It would extend the maximum duration of nationwide permits from five years currently to 10 years.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1Which should give them a lot more time before we realize we'd screwed up.
Speaker 2Yes. Finally, I wanted to talk about, like, it seems to have some provisions for tribal historic preservation offices that, like, it would let feds punish them if they don't. There's something that's like a 30-day window in which they have to respond to stuff if that's right, and they could strip funding from them.
Speaker 1Is that correct?
Speaker 3Yeah, so just quickly on Title III of this bill is particularly egregious to all tribal interests, tribal sovereignty, and the protection of sacred sites. So currently under the National Historic Preservation Act, Section 106, it provides protections for tribes, for historic sites, for sacred sites, for cultural sites impacted, right, including burial grounds that are impacted by any federal undertaking, major pipeline project, infrastructure project, etc., So similar to states,
Speaker 3tribes also have historic preservation offices, and they're the ones that hold the tribes' knowledge on, often work with tribal elders and knowledge keepers to protect tribes' cultural resources. Under this bill, what Title III would do, it would fundamentally restructure the entire structure of what are the protections for tribal consultation, are the protections for these sacred and cultural sites protected? It would completely change actually the way that
Speaker 3they define sites that are eligible for protection. So essentially redefining what is or what is not a sacred site or qualifies as a sacred site. They would have to tie it to an identifiable geographic location. or an event of continuing religious or cultural significance to a living community. And for many tribes and for many Indigenous peoples across the world, not just in the U.S., this type of test would completely fail because many Indigenous spaces, places, sacred
Speaker 3sites are not tied to a specific historical or cultural moment in time. So things like mountains, right? Mauna Kea, Haleakalā in Hawaii, Chaco Canyon, Mount Graham, Barabute or Matapaha in the Black Hills, these places would be potentially left without protection under this. And when it comes to the actual tribal historic preservation offices, If they fail to consult on any one of these projects or impacts to any one of these projects within 30 days, and there is
Speaker 3just a repeated lack of contact with the federal government through the Secretary of Interior, what this legislation allows is for the Secretary of Interior to actually take over the Tribal Historic Preservation Office themselves and provide oversight. It also creates a very paternalistic aspect here of federal evaluations of tribal historic preservation offices at least every two years, including compliance and consultation deadlines. So what tribes across the nation
Speaker 3are saying is this is an affront to tribal sovereignty of tribal nations. It is something that will weaken the safeguards to protect cultural knowledge and sacred sites and the ability of tribes to self-govern and to protect their sacred places by tribal historic preservation officers and the tribal governments themselves.
Speaker 2Yeah it's very bad as we said like There are reasons to impose this for environmental concerns. There are reasons to impose this for tribal sovereignty concerns. It's not that we can pull one out and make it okay. This thing just has to go die. We can perfectly easily work our way to have power from windmills without stripping away tribal rights and destroying protections for land and water.
Speaker 1And endangered species. How can people do that? People want to be like, hey, this is bullshit. Why did it pass? It was two-thirds in the Senate, three-quarters. What can they do?
Speaker 3Yeah, I think as often as people say and hear, call your senators, call your state representatives, that might not always be comfortable. But then write to your senators, write to your state representatives. The reality is that this is being pushed as a bipartisan effort because there's a bipartisan consensus that permitting is too slow, that NEPA is too slow, that these things take too much time. But they take too much time for a reason. And I think the legislators in D.C. really need to hear this from their constituents.
Speaker 3We don't want less process to know what's going to impact or how a project is going to impact our communities and our future generations. Our water sources are sacred and historical places. We want to know how are we going to be able to protect these places. And that's why these laws exist.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3So weakening those laws is not the way to go about getting cleaner energy or windmills or wind farms. And it's definitely not what we're looking at. I think there is a massive outpouring of opposition to data centers that we're seeing. People need to hear this on the ground. So contact your state representatives. It's still in the Senate. So there's still time. Yes, this was passed 73 to 25 yesterday, think the ones that have actually said no already, right?
Speaker 3There's a short list. But if they're one of your senators that have said no, this is what we need to turn the tide. And we need to hold the line before the new Congress is inaugurated in January 2027.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think it's fundamentally ridiculous to say that the consideration of all our children's future and the planet and the water and sacred places is too slow. It's getting in the way of capitalism. Like, That's how we got to this situation in the first place. And if we can't see how flawed that logic is, it doesn't look good for us.
Speaker 1That's right, James.
Speaker 3You know, NEPA and many of these laws, there was bipartisan consensus to pass these laws, right? There was a moment in time when these laws were passed because people were choking on the air they were breathing. The waters they were drinking were contaminated. Flint, Michigan was happening in every household. Right. We can't go back to a time when that is the norm. And this bill would fast track us back to that time.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah. Nixon did the essay, right? Like it's.
Speaker 2Yeah, we can we can get back to that. Natalie, thank you so much for your time. We will get deeper into this in a full episode, but I wanted to get this out so people could do something right away.
Speaker 3Thanks, James. Thank you all so much.
Speaker 4Natural Causes is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can find sources for Natural Causes listed directly in episode descriptions.
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...
The gang chats about all the many tech outages this week, the ICJ finding Myanmar guilty of genocide against Rohingya, corporate executives pocketing tariff refund money, protests in Bangladesh over working conditions,...
James is joined by Gordayeen to talk about the Iranian state’s repressive tactics and the failure of the USA and ISrael to diminish the capacity for state violence Sources: https://hengaw.org/ https://www.theamargi.com/
Mia talks with Lindsey and Brady of the IWW about what we can learn about organizing agricultural workers from efforts abroad and organizing outside of the National Labor Relations Act