Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

It Could Happen Here

It Could Happen Here artwork

Anarchists and the Great War with Andrew

Sep 1, 202626 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Andrew talks with Mia about how anarchists approach fighting in wars through the lens of the anarchist debate on joining WWI. Sources: Matthew S. Adams, Anarchism and the First World War George Woodcock, Peter Kropotkin: From Prince to Rebel https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/various-authors-the-anarchist-international-and-war https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/petr-kropotkin-manifesto-of-the-sixteen

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Call Zone Media.

Speaker 2The drums of war are beating. Everywhere you look, people are picking sides. Governments are demanding unity. Critics are being denounced as naive, irresponsible, even treacherous. And a movement built on international solidarity has been split in the kiosk. The year is 1914. At the beginning of the First World War. Though you'll be excused if you thought I was describing today. Hello and welcome to It Could Happen Here. I'm Andrew Sage,

Speaker 2also Andrewism on YouTube, joined again by.

Speaker 3Neil Wogg.

Speaker 2To discuss the infamous split among the anarchists over World War I, of all things. So just to be clear, the common anarchist stance prior to the war was fairly straightforward. It was a stance of internationalist worker solidarity against imperialist wars, a solidarity that transcended borders and nationalities, recognizing that ordinary people had more in common with one another than with the ruling classes of their own countries. Such wars were never fought in the interests of workers, but in the

Speaker 2interests of states, empires, dynasties, and capitalists. If war came, the task of revolutionaries was not to rally behind their own government's but to oppose the conflict and preserve international working-class solidarity. However, the Great War would strain the internationalist cause, forcing splits and theoretical developments owing to the ensuing debates personified in the disagreement between Errico Malatesta and Peter Kropotkin, as well as many others, who clashed intellectually over the

Speaker 2nature of war, history, national struggle, and revolutionary change. The First World War emerged from decades of imperial rivalry, colonial competition, military expansion, and competing alliance systems among Europe's great powers. The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo on the 28th of June 1914 served as the immediate catalyst, but it merely ignited tensions that had been building for years. Within weeks, a regional dispute between Austria-Hungary and Serbia escalated

Speaker 2into a continental and eventually global conflict. On one side stood the Central Powers, led by Germany and Austria-Hungary, later joined by the Ottoman Empire and Bulgaria, and opposing them were the Allied Powers, initially consisting of France, Russia and Britain, with countries such as Italy, Romania, Japan and eventually the United States entering the war on the Allied side as the conflict expanded. Attitudes toward the First World War across Europe were deeply divided and often changed dramatically in the

Speaker 2opening weeks of the conflict. A powerful wave of patriotic enthusiasm swept through many cities, with countless people volunteering for military service under the belief that the war would be short, necessary.

Speaker 3Or even glorious.

Speaker 2Governments, newspapers, churches, and much of the political establishment promoted national unity and portrayed the conflict as a defensive struggle against foreign aggression. For socialists, trade unionists, religious pacifists, and most relevantly anarchists, the stance was deeply sceptical or openly oppositional to the war, as it appeared to be a catastrophic clash between rival empires in which ordinary people would bear the costs while elites pursued their geopolitical ambitions. However,

Speaker 2one of the attitudes that flared up as a result of the war, even amongst some anarchists and socialists, was anti-German sentiment, manifest in Kropotkin's open letter in the anarchist newspaper, Freedom. This open letter would spark the ensuing debate between Kropotkin and Malatesta.

Speaker 3As documented by historian Matthew S.

Speaker 2Adam in Anarchism and the First World War, Kropotkin wrote, I consider that the duty of everyone who cherishes the idea of human progress... For many anarchists, and even Leon Trotsky, this seemed a clear break from Kapotkin's anarchism, which would be in opposition to alignment with nation-state-based struggles. However, as

Speaker 2noted by historian George Woodcock in Pizza Kropotkin, From Prince to Rebel, quote, anti-German sentiment was probably an influence on Kropotkin long before this point, as it was a current in Russian revolutionary movements due to the German rule by the Romanov dynasty, and perhaps also because his fellow Russian anarchist Mikhail Bakunin had an infamous rivalry with the German Karl Marx, end quote. Though of course, you know, this is speculation. Kropotkin and Malatesta were both in Britain when

Speaker 2their exchange of letters took place. Malatesta wrote in his article, Anarchists Have Forgotten Their Principles, that the only war worth fighting was one of liberation, and there was no siding with national agglomerations. He said, I have no greater confidence in the bloody Tsar, nor in the English diplomatists who oppressed India, who betrayed Persia, who crushed the Boer Republics, nor in the French bourgeoisie who massacred the natives of Morocco, nor in those of Belgium who have allowed the Congo

Speaker 2atrocities and profited by them. The victory of Germany would certainly mean the triumph of militarism, but the triumph of the Allies would mean Russo-English domination in.

Speaker 3Europe and in Asia.

Speaker 2Now, Kropotkin had previously argued that modern wars were fundamentally driven by capitalist competition for markets, resources and opportunities, exploit less industrialized nations. He pointed to the imperial conquests and colonial conflicts of his time as evidence that financiers and economic interests, rather than ordinary people, were the true beneficiaries of war. And while he saw capitalism as the primary engine of modern militarism, he also condemned the state as

Speaker 2the political institution that organized and carried out these conflicts. So it was odd for Kropotkin to seemingly come out the contrary of his previous positions, and take one state's side over another when he had seen through such sides before. But, of course, people and their motivations are more complex. Kropotkin had sympathy for France and hostility toward Germany. He saw France as the heir to the revolutionary tradition of 1789

Speaker 2and the Paris Commune, and he saw Germany as the embodiment of militarism and authoritarianism. He believed the war was a poor moment for social revolution and feared that a German victory would usher in decades of political reaction, wiping out the hard-won freedoms that had been achieved in countries like Britain and France. His support for the Allies was rooted in his broader view of history, that social progress was never guaranteed and could always be reversed. that periods

Speaker 2of freedom and cooperation could collapse into authoritarianism. He also believed that national liberation struggles were a space ripe for anarchist social insertion and radicalization, and that in times of war, an anti-militarist general strike within the targeted nation would simply gift the country to its invaders, and that anti-militarists advocating such action were thus siding with the invaders and making social revolution more difficult to carry out in the future. This is, for me, a somewhat compelling argument. I feel

Speaker 2this way about current struggle. While the worker has no friend in the states of the world, and I don't think it should be framed as a matter of campism, the way we see running rampant today, it is undeniable that there are some victories and defeats that will be more or less preferable to the viability of the struggle long term. I am rooting against an Israeli victory anywhere. And while I reserve my right to criticize the politics, ideologies, and other actions of the groups carrying out that resistance,

Speaker 2it remains true that the defeat of the oppressors can open up the space for further struggles. If it was that anarchists were arguing and acting solely for anti-militarism in the targeted countries, then I would be fully with Kropotkin. I would get where he's coming from. We would indeed have a problem. but I think he mischaracterized the anarchist position, or perhaps did not give them enough credit. As for the anarchists, primary responsibility for anti-militarist ends is in agitating

Speaker 2within the invader countries themselves to disrupt the militarism within the threatening nations to the bitter end. Anything less would be an incomplete and flaccid anti-militarist struggle. Kropotkin addresses this in the Manifesto of the Sixteen, which we'll get to shortly. And yet, with the context of hindsight, I share Malatesta's criticism of the pitfalls of lesser evilism as he kinda predicted World War II. Adam wrote of Malatesta's position, quote,

Speaker 2German victory would certainly mean the triumph of militarism, but the triumph of the Allies would result in much the same. Both guaranteed the victory of the state principle. With statism delivered in both cases, and the tensions that caused the war remaining unresolved, Malatesta perspicaciously warned that with both sides exhausted, some kind of peace will be patched up, leaving all questions open, thus preparing for a new war more murderous than the present.

Speaker 3End quote.

Speaker 2In 1915, Malatesta, along with Emma Goldman, Alexander Berkman, and 32 other signatories, co-signed a manifesto titled The Anarchist International and the War, otherwise known as the International Anarchist Manifesto on the War, Manifesto of the 35, and Anti-War Manifesto. In this text, the anarchists call out the ridiculous notion that any side of this clash of civilizations had claim to righteousness, freedom, or civilization. Quote, In the current conflict,

Speaker 2the governments in Berlin and Vienna have justified themselves by producing documents every bit as authentic as those produced by the governments in Paris, London and Petrograd.

Speaker 3It is for.

Speaker 2Whoever on each side who will produce the most unchallengeable, most telling documentation to prove their bona fides and portray themselves as the unblemished defender of the right and of freedom, the champion of civilization.

Speaker 3Civilization?

Speaker 2Who stands for that at the moment? Is it the German state with its redoubtable militarism, so powerful that it has stifled.

Speaker 3Every vestige of rebellion?

Speaker 2Or the Russian state, whose only methods of persuasion are the Naut, the Gibbet, and Siberia? Or the French state, with Espiribi, its bloody conquests in Tonkin, Madagascar, Morocco, and forcible conscription of black troops? The France whose prisons have housed for years past comrades whose only crime was to have written and spoken out against the war? or England as she exploits, divides, starves and oppresses.

Speaker 3The peoples of her huge colonial empire.

Speaker 2No, none of the belligerents has any right to lay claim to civilisation, just as none of them is entitled to claim legitimate self-defence. The truth is that the root of wars, of the war currently bloody in the plains of Europe, just like all the ones that went before it, is located exclusively in the existence of the state, which is the political form of privilege. The state is born of military might, it has grown through recourse to military might, and logically, it is upon military might that it must

Speaker 2rely if it is to retain its omnipotence. Whatever the form it may assume, the state is merely oppression organized for the benefit of a privileged minority. The present conflict offers a striking illustration of this. All forms of the state are embroiled in the present war. Absolutism is represented by Russia. absolutism mitigated by parliamentarism and by Germany, a state ruling over very different peoples by Austria, constitutional democracy by England, and the democratic republican system by France.

Speaker 3End quote.

Speaker 2Malatesta rejected the idea that anarchists should support one state over another because it was supposedly the lesser evil. Doing so, he argued, placed the struggles of some workers above those of others and an abandoned international working-class solidarity. While he accepted that anti-colonial wars and social revolutions could be justified, he maintained that anarchists should oppose wars between rival capitalist and imperialist states, refusing to become complicit in their violence and exploitation. Later, in the brief manifesto, No matter where

Speaker 2they may find themselves, the anarchists' role in the current tragedy is to carry on proclaiming that there is but one war of liberation, the one waged in every country by the oppressed against the oppressor, by the exploited against the exploiter. Our task is to summon the slaves to revolt against their masters. Anarchist propaganda and anarchist action should set about doggedly undermining and breaking up the various states, cultivating the spirit of rebellion and acting as midwife to

Speaker 2the discontent in the peoples and in the armies. Going on to describe how anarchists might convince the soldiers... the factory workers, the peasants, the outcasts, the women, and to quote, capitalize upon every stirring of rebellion, every discontent, in order to foment insurrection, to organize the revolution to which we look for the ending of all of society's iniquities.

Speaker 3End quote. Powerful words. Yeah.

Speaker 2And indeed in line with what anarchists had long proclaimed. But Kropotkin, and Kropotkin was not alone, mind you, he took a different position on the war. He and 14 allies published in 1916 the Manifesto of the Sixteen as a reply. It was not 16 of them who signed that manifesto, it was 15. It just got called the Manifesto of the Sixteen because the home address of one of the contributors was mistaken for another contributor. Incredible stuff! Yeah,

Speaker 2and so that's what was known today, but it's like he was living in some Town in Algeria, I believe.

Speaker 3And they thought the name of the town was a person's name. Oh my god.

Speaker 2Publishing mistakes are Taylor's oldest time. In the Manifesto of the Sixteen, Kropotkin and the other signatories reaffirmed their opposition to militarism and wars of conquest, but argued that peace could not simply be declared while Germany continued its invasion and expansion. They contended that German workers had failed to resist their own government's imperial ambitions and leaving no meaningful internal opposition to militarism. Although they maintained their commitment to internationalism and the eventual abolition of borders, they concluded that

Speaker 2the defeat of German militarism was a necessary precondition for a just and lasting peace, believing it would ultimately benefit both the German people and the cause of human liberation. So, I get where Kropotkin is coming from too, as I see parallels to the situation today vis-a-vis American imperialism and.

Speaker 3The flawed actors that resist it.

Speaker 2Even though I generally share Malatesta's sentiment, and Malatesta was ultimately correct in his assessment that maintaining a consistent stance is necessary for the clarity of the movement, and also that this war's outcome would be nothing but a precursor to a further war and would not advance the class struggle and in fact worsen its conditions. All that being said, I think there's room for a more sympathetic appraisal of Kropotkin's position. As for responses and just the overall outcome of this rift, for one, the Bolshevik party had something

Speaker 2to say. Lenin condemned the supporters of World War I as anarcho-chauvinists. Stalin and Trotsky dismissed Kropotkin's pro-war stance as evidence of anarchism's failure. despite the fact that the majority of the anarchist movement remained opposed to the Great War. Malatesta, responding to the Manifesto of the Sixteen with his article Pro-Government Anarchists, accused its signatories of abandoning anarchist principles by siding with states in wartime. He also pointed out that

Speaker 2in the name of defeating German militarism, they had instead strengthened militarism, authoritarianism, and nationalism across Europe. including in the countries they were siding with the governments of. Alexander Berkman, echoing this criticism, argued that Kropotkin had wrongly treated nations as if they were their governments, when in reality the war was being driven by ruling elites, not ordinary people. Malatesta maintained the position that anarchists should capitalize on the

Speaker 2imperialist war for class war by encouraging workers to resist their own governments and revive genuine international solidarities. Although wartime repression made revolutionary activity extremely difficult, he believed the crisis created new opportunities for insurrection rather than justification for supporting any state. The anarchist movement emerged from the other side of the Great War fragmented. Some of its adherents forever stained by their inconsistency of principle. The war forced anarchists

Speaker 2to reconsider strategy and revolutionary tactics and, alongside the economic devastation and political instability it unleashed, helped create conditions that fueled revolutionary upheavals across Europe, most notably the Russian Revolution and the wave of labor unrest that followed the war. Though the revolution was initially carried out by a diversity of forces, the Bolsheviks claimed it, and with the seeming success of the Marxist model in Russia, it appeared anarchism would be on the downturn. Though disillusionment with that model

Speaker 2would follow, and as many anarchists have highlighted, the metrics of success between the respective movements were in many ways different, it wasn't all bad news coming after the war. The collapse of old regimes inspired experiments in workers' self-governance, such as the German Revolution of 1918 and the Bavarian Council Republic, where anarchists like Gustav Landauer and Eric Moussam sought to build a federation of workers' councils, rather than a new state. Similar anti-authoritarian currents appeared in the Kronstadt Rebellion of 1921,

Speaker 2where rebels called for free Soviets independent of Bolshevik control. Despite the growing dominance of state socialism, anarchist ideas continued to shape revolutionary struggles in the aftermath of the Great War. Though the war marked a shift in the movement, that some would argue anarchism has never fully recovered from, anarchism has persisted, continues to reach people worldwide, and has the potential still to intercede in the diversity of struggles and places today. What is needed is a clarity and consistency

Speaker 2of principles and and analyses across contexts that can encourage initiative and responsibility and solidarity and revolutionary achievement. It's easy, I think, to reduce this story to Kropotkin standing alone, betraying anarchism. While ultimately I end up aligning more with Malatesta's position than Kropotkin's, I do think that Kropotkin deserves a bit more credit than he has sometimes been afforded in retrospect. While his prejudices played a role, he did

Speaker 2seem to genuinely believe that German militarism posed a unique threat to freedom that British, French, and Russian powers did not. Whether he was right is another question, but I think he was still coming from an anarchist place, colored as he may have been by his anti-German prejudices. I think the whole incident revealed the liveliness of the anarchist movement. as one that was constantly questioning and adapting and conflicting and refining its ideas. Something that I hope that we

Speaker 2will be willing to carry on today. But what were your thoughts on this bit of early 20th century drama alert?

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean, I think in a lot of ways, this is the anarchist version of a debate that played out throughout the entire socialist movement and effectively ended up destroying it. in the sense that the logic that Kropotkin is operating from, to some extent, makes sense. But it's also the logic that was taken by every single individual side in the conflict, where the German Social Democratic Party ends up supporting the war because they think that if they don't, they're going to be annihilated by the reactionary

Speaker 4forces of the Tsar. But then the French think they're going to be destroyed by the reactionary forces of the Germans, and so on and so forth. And so everyone ends up operating from this logic of like, it's going to be really bad for us if like the other side of this wins this war. And it ends up squandering this moment of possibility. And instead, everyone just gets sort of fed into the meat grinder. And I think the struggle playing out this way was effectively the worst possible

Speaker 4thing that could have happened. because it meant that some of the only people who were left resisting it were people who shouldn't be running a dog kennel, much less controlling the fate of the socialist movement. And also it meant that the war was allowed to continue. And so I think from a theoretical perspective, it makes sense why people took the positions that they did, and also supporting this war was so catastrophically wrong that basically every subsequent

Speaker 4horror of the 20th century can be laid upon it.

Speaker 3But I don't know.

Speaker 4The other thing I'll say about it is like, it's not clear to me if Kropotkin acting differently would have like changed anything. But the sort of general failure of the socialist movement to actually grapple with this moment was this sort of apocalyptic moment in the history of class struggle that we have never recovered from.

Speaker 2Yeah, I definitely don't think that the blame for World War II and all subsequent wars in the 20th century, which can in some way be connected to that World War I. I don't think we should lay the blame on the feet of Kropotkin or on the anarchist movement or the socialist movement.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 3All we can really do is speculate the what if, you know? Yeah.

Speaker 2And what if there was a unified front, a unified stand across all these countries, a commitment, a solid commitment to We will not cooperate with our respective states. How might the course of the war turn out differently? How might history have played out differently? I guess we'll never know.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2But we are in a position to shape the course of history here and now. Yeah. As the title of the podcast goes, you know, it could happen here. It kind of is happening here. By here, I mean on this planet across the world we are dealing with. was we're dealing with interstate conflicts, diplomatic, economic, and military. And despite how interconnected we are through the internet, it certainly

Speaker 2doesn't feel like we've come any closer to the kind of international solidarity that the Great War demanded, let alone the many wars being raged across the world today.

Speaker 4Yeah, but even, you know, The bleakness of the past and the bleakness of the present does not mean that the future need necessarily be as big. As I've said before, the definitional quality of modernity is that today is not like yesterday. And so we don't actually have to live through yet another round of imperialist butchery where different parts of the working class slaughter each other. We don't have to live in a world that's defined by endless status

Speaker 4and capitalist war. We can build something else. But that's something that is the responsibility of not the state, because the state will never choose to abandon its privilege and abandon its wars. And it's not up to, you know, capital, because capital will also continue fighting its wars. The only people who can do it is us.

Speaker 2As usual, all power to all the people.

Speaker 4Peace.

Speaker 1It Could Happen Here is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can now find sources for It Could Happen Here listed directly in episode descriptions. Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. CZM Book Club: "Organizing Social Spaces as if Social Relations Matter," by Cindy Barukh Milstein (Part Three of Three)

    Nov 22, 202636 minAudio

    Margaret finishes reading you some non-fiction with advice for organizers

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. It Could Happen Here Weekly 259

    Nov 21, 20263 hr 56 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Executive Disorder: Everything Breaks, Rohingya Genocide, Mamdani Disbands SRG

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    The gang chats about all the many tech outages this week, the ICJ finding Myanmar guilty of genocide against Rohingya, corporate executives pocketing tariff refund money, protests in Bangladesh over working conditions,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Repression in Iran

    Nov 19, 202642 minAudio

    James is joined by Gordayeen to talk about the Iranian state’s repressive tactics and the failure of the USA and ISrael to diminish the capacity for state violence Sources: https://hengaw.org/ https://www.theamargi.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Organizing Agricultural Workers

    Nov 18, 202644 minAudio

    Mia talks with Lindsey and Brady of the IWW about what we can learn about organizing agricultural workers from efforts abroad and organizing outside of the National Labor Relations Act

    Credit the people on this episode