Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

It Could Happen Here

It Could Happen Here artwork

West Bank Takeover

Sep 21, 202616 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode Dana El Kurd talks about how the settlers and the Israeli state are working hand in hand to ethnically cleanse Palestinians from the West Bank, and how we should understand the relationship between the two actors. Sources: https://jewishcurrents.org/it-feels-like-a-death-sentence https://www.972mag.com/armed-settler-hikes-west-bank/ https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/06/opinion/israel-west-bank-settlers-violence.html https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/8/29/israeli-settlers-surround-palestinian-home-in-occupied-west-banks-qusra https://www.972mag.com/bilin-israeli-land-seizure-settler-road/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hello, everyone, and welcome to It Could Happen Here. My name is Dana Al-Kurd. I'm a researcher of Arab and Palestinian politics. And today I want to talk about the truly insidious stories coming out of the West Bank that read separately look like a spike in settler violence, but read together look like something else entirely. On August 9th, settlers surrounded three Palestinian homes in a neighborhood called Ras

Speaker 1al-Ayn on the edge of a village called Qusra south of Nablus. They didn't leave. 21 days later, at least four people were still inside one of those houses cut off from water, electricity, and basic supplies. Getting food into those people meant coordinating through the village mayor, which was a process that took three to four days. The Israeli army put up three new roadblocks, and in July, the village mosque was burned. I want you to sit with that for a minute. Because this is not a raid. This is not a rampage. It's a siege with a

Speaker 1bureaucracy attached. And that bureaucracy is the story. And that's what I want to talk about today. And I'm trying to be precise about the difference because the distinction is not academic. It determines what you think the problem is and therefore what you think the solution would look like. Here's the framing you'll get from almost every Western outlet. And of course, every Israeli official. That this is a fringe. and that these settlers are a violent fringe, and they embarrass the state, and the state condemns this fringe. When

Speaker 1settlers besieged Qusra, Prime Minister Netanyahu did issue a statement, and here I'm quoting, condemning the, quote, criminal acts of violence committed in the village of Qusra by a handful of rioters who are violating the law. And Israeli President Herzog also condemned it, and the foreign ministry condemned it as extremist and criminal violence. So let's take that framing seriously for a moment because if it's true, what we're looking at is a law enforcement failure, a state that's lost control of its most radical citizens. And if it's false,

Speaker 1what we're looking at is a state carrying out a policy through deniable means and the condemnations are not a failure at all. They're a feature. They're the part of the machine that faces outward. So let's go through what actually happened in these villages and then let's ask Which of these framings fits the evidence best? So Basil Al-Adra, the journalist from Masafi Riata, the one who you know from No Other Land, the documentary that won a bunch of awards, he published a piece in Jewish Currents on September 3rd about livestock theft in the South Hebron Hills.

Speaker 1So this isn't vandalism, it's theft. It's organized removal of livestock. So shortly after midnight on August 21st in a place called Khirbet Dir Shams, a family was attacked by roughly 15 masked settlers with sticks and stones. One of them describes it flatly. They basically opened the pen where the family kept around 70 goats, and then they opened the sheep pen where there were about 100 sheep. And as the settlers moved off of the animals, Israeli army vehicles passed nearby. And in his words, they did nothing. Nearly two weeks later, not one animal has been recovered. Back

Speaker 1in July, in another village, a settler pepper sprayed a man, and then more settlers arrived, And then a flock of about 122 sheep were targeted and taken. Soldiers did show up that time. According to one of the villagers, what the soldiers did was push the Palestinians away from their own animals while settlers broke the locks. And of roughly 227 animals taken that day, nine came back. Four residents of the village were arrested and then released. B'Tselem, which is an Israeli human rights organization, has counted 17 livestock

Speaker 1theft incidents in 2026 alone. And a flock of the size that we're talking about here, it's worth something on the order of tens, if not $ 100, 000. I'm flagging this because I think it's easy to hear sheep and these kinds of things and file it maybe under like property crime or vandalism or something. But for a herding family in the South Hebron Hills, the flock is not just an asset. It's the entire productive base of the household. It's the income. It's the reason to stay on that hillside.

Speaker 1So if you want to expel a pastoral community, you don't just expel them, you can take its animals, and then it can expel itself. And it does so in a way that produces no photograph of a bulldozer. Another incident was on July 8th, when the head of Israel's Central Command signed a land seizure order. And that order takes dozens of dunams of land from Bil'in and three neighboring villages to build a security road, six and a half kilometers long and eight meters wide, connecting the settlement,

Speaker 1of Modayin elite to an outpost called Ste Efraim. Sorry, I don't know Hebrew, so I'm going to be butchering these. But Oren Zev reported this for 972 Mag on September 2nd. So those who are familiar with Palestinian popular resistance in the mid to early 2000s, you've heard of Bil'in. Lots of documentaries about it, lots of international attention. This village basically sustained weekly demonstrations against the separation wall, for something

Speaker 1like 15 years because this wall was being built on their land and taking huge chunks of their land. In 2007, the Israeli High Court ordered that part of the wall removed and the land actually came back to the village. So in the international imagination, this was the best outcome. See, the nonviolent resistance worked. And this is the nonviolent resistance that Western commentators often point to when they want to lecture Palestinians about tactics. Now this road that they're proposing runs through the land that was returned. So Mohamed Khatib,

Speaker 1who led some of these protests, says the point is not a road, it's a settlement corridor. It's basically an eventual seizure of something like 600 dunams. And the attorney, Michael Svard, put it very bluntly. They don't think twice about co-opting the security argument for purposes that are clearly settlement-oriented. And what's really ludicrous is that this road runs through a wadi, kind of a valley, which from an actual security standpoint is a bad place to put a road. So the security rationale isn't just contested, it's incoherent, which

Speaker 1tells you that the word security here is doing legal work, not tactical work. It's this just magic phrase that converts a settlement expansion into a military necessity, and then a military necessity into a signed order from a general. A third incident or set of incidents I want to talk about is these hikes. There have been these hikes. This is a really ridiculous, insidious story. Aharon Parath and Roy Kleitman published an investigation of these hikes in 972 Mag in late August about these hiking groups, these organized settler

Speaker 1hiking groups in the West Bank. They've got really cutesy names sometimes, like hiking buddies. And they published their routes. And they go from settlement to settlement and they cross Palestinian farmland and springs and villages. So a hike near the north of Hebron, one of these hikes, ended with a, quote, civilian security coordinator opening fire and killing 17-year-old Palestinian Karim Shalalde and seriously wounding another one. So that's, I think, the whole episode in two words. A civilian security coordinator.

Speaker 1This is not a hiker who lost his temper. It's a job. It's an armed, appointed part of the chain of command. The man who fired was functionally an arm of the state, but supposedly on a hike in a village that is not his. On July 24th, near the village of Tal, west of Nablus, a hike ended with six people dead, two Israelis and four Palestinians. David Syed, who founded one of these hiking groups, basically says the quiet part in a single sentence. Wherever the hiker's foot treads,

Speaker 1there the border will pass. So he's talking about how They're going to places they haven't been to in a long time or maybe ever. And on the question of the army, he explains the relationship very precisely. We don't ask for permits, he says. We mainly notify them so we don't put the sector on alert. And this is very clear in a lot of their quotes about this issue. They coordinate with the army. They notify, but they are not asking permission. And the army isn't policing them. It's being kept in the loop so that it can protect them.

Speaker 1And the reporting traces this back over a decade. There's a 2013 hike documented with 100 hikers and soldiers accompanying them. So supposedly this recreational activity has a stated territorial doctrine, a published route through other people's fields, an armed participant base, and a military that gets notified. All right, so we

Speaker 1have four things. The livestock theft with soldiers watching, a siege of villages, seizing of land, and armed hikes with military escorts. Now let's get back to Prime Minister Netanyahu's phrase about this being a handful of riots. A riot is unplanned. A riot has no logistics. A riot does not file paperwork. What's in front of us here is very different. Because Here, I think a lot of people who are critical of the state of Israel might make the argument that the settlers are the state. But I

Speaker 1think this loses a little bit of analytical detail. So let me make this a little bit more specific, which I actually think is more damning. The Israeli state and the settler movement are not identical, but they are complementary because they perform different functions in the same project. And it's very clear that the division of labor is the point. Because think for a moment about what each half can do that the other can't. Settlers can do things the state can't do openly without incurring some diplomatic cost. For example,

Speaker 1taking a flock of sheep or burning a mosque or standing outside a house for three weeks. These are acts with no legal basis. There's no order, no minister to sanction, no policy to condemn at the UN. They produce displacement without producing a decision. And then the state can do things settlers can't do on their own. It can sign a seizure order. It can declare land state land. It can build the road that makes the outpost viable and connect it to the grid and route the bus line. And it can decline to investigate when things happen. It

Speaker 1can arrest four Palestinians instead of the 15 masked settlers, which is exactly what happened in one of these villages. And crucially, the state can supply this ambiguity that lets the whole thing keep running. the soldiers present at these incidents are not intervening because not that they're absent. It's in fact a specific posture of the state. It converts this crime into something sanctioned. And it tells the Palestinian family there's really no one to appeal to. And this is what political scientists who study this stuff in other

Speaker 1contexts as outsourced or deniable repression by paramilitaries or militias or unknown gunmen, quote unquote, We recognize it instantly when it's in other places, and we understand kind of the analytical move here because you don't ask whether the state ordered it, you ask whether the state built the conditions under which it happens. And by that test, this is not ambiguous at all. But for some reason, when we talk about Israel-Palestine, things get a little bit more ambiguous. I also want to point out something really crucial, which is that every one of these incidents, and they've been

Speaker 1happening for a while, but they've ramped up in severity, but every one of them produces a permanent gain. The animals that are stolen don't come back. The road that's built can't be unbuilt. The hiking route, you know, once walked with an escort becomes a corridor, then a security zone, then a place that Palestinians can't farm. And the siege doesn't need to end in a formal expulsion. It ends when the family decides they can't raise their children under these conditions. They can't stay under siege. And there's a phrase for what's coming when all of this happens all

Speaker 1at once, which is annexation. And People talk about it as if it's a future event that's awaiting some sort of vote from the Israeli Knesset or something. But I'd suggest that framing is itself part of the problem. It invites us to wait for a declaration and treat everything before that as some sort of tension or spike. The declaration of annexation is the least important part. What's happening on the ground is a territorial reality that's being produced by signature and by theft. And then maybe later on

Speaker 1the paperwork will ratify it, but it's not necessary. Israeli writer and analyst Marev Zonzin actually made a version of this argument in the New York Times on September 6th under a headline that I think is worth reading. The headline of the article is, it's not just the West Bank settlers, it's Israel. So hopefully this analysis doesn't seem fringe anymore. At the end of the day, if we consider settler violence a fringe problem, then the remedy... which the Biden administration toyed with half-heartedly, is sanctions on individuals,

Speaker 1a visa ban or an asset freeze. And we've run that experiment. That didn't really work. The violence kept going up. But if it's a state policy executed through deniable proxies, then the remedy has to address the state. And every actor with leverage over that state, which, you know, we're talking about D.C. here, understands this, but they've chosen the fringe framing precisely because it permits condemnation without cost. So

Speaker 1Netanyahu condemning a handful of rioters in the same week that the Israeli Central Command signs a road through Bil'in's returned land, this is not a contradiction he failed to notice, it is the design of this policy. So I'll leave you with this detail from the reporting on Qusra that I can't get out of my head. It was that six people were attacked on while trying to install metal bars and window shields on their homes. They were attacked by both Israeli soldiers and settlers together in the same action. And then the six of them were arrested. So they

Speaker 1weren't fighting. They weren't protesting. They were fastening metal on their own house to protect themselves. And they were being arrested for it by the same army standing alongside the people they were shielding themselves from. So if you wanted kind of a single image for this division of labor, I've spent this episode describing, that's it. Because the thing that's not permitted in the end is not that they're resisting. It's that they're staying. The families in the South Hebron Hills are still there. And Bil'in is contesting the order

Speaker 1of the seizure of their land. Qusra's residents have installed some shields anyway. And a number of Israeli journalists and lawyers and researchers are documenting this in Hebrew and in English. And then, of course, Palestinian journalists are putting themselves on the line to document this as well. That's not a hopeful note exactly. It's just the accurate one. Unfortunately, what's missing is apparently anyone with power willing to act on understanding this reality. That's it for me. Thanks for listening.

Speaker 2It Could Happen Here is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can now find sources for It Could Happen Here listed directly in episode descriptions. Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. CZM Book Club: "Organizing Social Spaces as if Social Relations Matter," by Cindy Barukh Milstein (Part Three of Three)

    Nov 22, 202636 minAudio

    Margaret finishes reading you some non-fiction with advice for organizers

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. It Could Happen Here Weekly 259

    Nov 21, 20263 hr 56 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Executive Disorder: Everything Breaks, Rohingya Genocide, Mamdani Disbands SRG

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    The gang chats about all the many tech outages this week, the ICJ finding Myanmar guilty of genocide against Rohingya, corporate executives pocketing tariff refund money, protests in Bangladesh over working conditions,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Repression in Iran

    Nov 19, 202642 minAudio

    James is joined by Gordayeen to talk about the Iranian state’s repressive tactics and the failure of the USA and ISrael to diminish the capacity for state violence Sources: https://hengaw.org/ https://www.theamargi.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Organizing Agricultural Workers

    Nov 18, 202644 minAudio

    Mia talks with Lindsey and Brady of the IWW about what we can learn about organizing agricultural workers from efforts abroad and organizing outside of the National Labor Relations Act

    Credit the people on this episode