Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

It Could Happen Here

It Could Happen Here artwork

That Time The Oakland Police Formed a Torture Gang

May 11, 202340 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Robert sits down with Ali Winston, co-author of The Riders Come Out At Night, a book about the Oakland police.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Welcome to It could Happen Here. This is Robert Evans, and It Could Happen Here is a podcast about things falling apart and you know, sometimes about making them better. Today, we're talking both about something that is implicated in a number of you know, aspects of what we call the crumbles here in the United States, which is the police. And we're also talking about the the tremendous difficulty that people encounter whenever they try to improve this particular aspect

Speaker 1of American society, the near impossibility of reform within the police. And to talk with me about that, and to talk with me about their incredible new book, The Writers Come Out at Night is Ali Winston. Ali co wrote this book with Darwin bond Gram and it covers particularly the Oakland Police and a scandal that kind of happened at around the same time as the rampart scandal in Los Angeles, focused around a group of Oakland police officers called the

Speaker 1Writers who Well, I'm gonna let Ali tell you about that. It's a it's a pretty pretty shocking and.

Speaker 2Bleak story though.

Speaker 1Ali, Welcome to the show.

Speaker 2Hither How are you doing?

Speaker 1I'm doing good? How are you today?

Speaker 2Lovely lovely Ali.

Speaker 1This is a great book. It's it's very deeply reported. I want to talk a little bit about kind of the the what sort of brought you into this story, because this is something that kind of happened around the turn of the last century, and it's kind of adjacent to a lot of issues that are still very much relevant in kind of the problems we have with policing, both kind of the the thin blue line code of silence,

Speaker 1the way in which police departments act in a very gang like fashion to protect bad actors, the way in which kind of ill thought out form policies targeted at kind of assuaging the fears of business owners lead to policies of tremendous violence. A lot of things that are still very much kind of at play all around the country. It's fascinating to me.

Speaker 2So we came at this book both kind of independently.

Speaker 3We came out this as two reporters who'd worked kind of handing glove together for about ten well since twenty twelve. When we signed our contract, it was twenty twenty, but I'd started reporting on the Oakland Police Department in two thousand and eight when I moved to the Bay Area for graduate school at cal Gobert's, and I'd kind of dove right into the topic of police and police conduct

Speaker 3in Oakland because I'd wanted to. I've been messing around with criminal justice reporting when I was back east in New York and North New Jersey where I was working, and there really was there were some really egregious shootings at that point in time, in the early two thousands, mid two thousands, late two thousands OPD about average, I think eight to fourteen officer involved shootings police shootings a year. Invariably there would be one or two or three or four,

Speaker 3depending on the years, maybe more that involves someone who's unarmed fleeing it was an awful but lawful shoot, or maybe just an awful shoot that the DA didn't charge or didn't properly investigate. And at that time, it was really tough to get information about police shootings in California because of a combination of laws and Supreme Court California Supreme Court decisions that intersected and kind of shut the door on any sort of record you could get from about police disciplinary action or their past histories. So you

Speaker 3kind of had to mine the civil courts and look for back doors and through the DA's offices and just kind of or source up really well to try and report out these incidents. And Darwin and I met about around twenty twelve. We started interrogating questions about power and the political economy of law enforcement. We started to raise questions about the percentage of budgetary allocation that OPD receives. It's about forty percent of the city's billion dollar budget give or takes, so we're talking three hundred and fifty

Speaker 3four hundred million dollars every year. The result, the net result for public safety is questionable.

Speaker 2At best.

Speaker 3Doesn't really tie into increase in police funding, increase in menpower, decreasing crime. Oakland is a very violent city, often ranks in the top ten or top five nationally in per capita crime per one hundred thousand residents.

Speaker 2And you know, it's.

Speaker 3Also been under this reform program forever, and this is the backdrop to all our reporting. There was always this backdrop of court ordered reforms. There's external oversight. The external oversight is oftentimes how the public and the press became aware of some very deep seated issues in the department and how they would get addressed because the politicians here, Affeckless, were inexperienced, or complicit.

Speaker 2Or all the above.

Speaker 3So we over the course of our reporting together kind of yoked together. Around a decade eight years or so, we kind of realized, Okay, we have a paragraph in each one of our stories that explains the backdrop, or maybe a little bit more, depending.

Speaker 2On how legalistic appease it was. We need to peel all this back.

Speaker 3We need to explain to people because this is the longest running oversight regime in the country, right two decades now, over two decades since the consent degree, the negotiated settlement agreement was signed, and we just needed to explain to people why this city had gone so far, why it was an edge case, why it was an outlier. And in order to do that, we couldn't use five thousand words. We needed one hundred and twenty thousand, hundred and six.

Speaker 1Yeah, this is a dense book in a way that's still intensely readable, And I think part of what makes it readable is it goes to a tremendous amount of effort laying out things that people kind of know in broad and a good example of this would be people talk a lot about you know, the kind of concept of you know, the bad apples that you know, there's both on the side of people defending police departments that it's a few bad apples, and then kind of and you find this more on sort of people on the

Speaker 1left criticizing police as an institution, the idea that, like, well, the fact that those bad apples are supported and defended by the rest of the department kind of means that they're all but bad. You get this these kind of like broad you know, discussions about that phenomenon. What you do in this in this book is kind of get very granular with the way in which that actually functions on the ground. I'm thinking about a specific point where you've got one of the characters, you know, one of the people that is a major source kind of for this book and a major source for this scandal was

Speaker 1a police officer who effectively turned on his fellow officers and reported all of this illegal violence being done by this this gang. And there's a point where this guy, after he's kind of become thoroughly horrified and disillusioned by what, you know, he's the guys that he's writing with are doing, goes to other people in the department who are like, yeah, those guys are like messed up and it's it's bad, and you just kind of have to you should just kind of like, you know, try to try to move on, but don't make waves about it, right, And it's this,

Speaker 1it's this, the kind of the fact, the degree to which other people cannot just know in the department what's happening but be disgusted by it, and still when I'm kind of the shit hits the fan, fundamentally defend the officers doing it, right, Like the fact that they're able to warn other officers away from you know, being around those guys doesn't mean that they won't like absolutely throw down to defend them, which is, you know, something I think people are kind of broadly aware of. But the

Speaker 1kind of going into the actual personal dynamics is I think really valuable, and you do a very good job of capturing that at the ground level.

Speaker 2Well, what we wanted to do is explain how so.

Speaker 3It's not a bad apple theory I think is Yeah, honestly, it's a distraction and frankly it's an excuse. What you're dealing with is culture, right, and culture eats politics and policy. For lunch, breakfast, lunch, dinner, and all the meals in between, every single time.

Speaker 2You can't change culture unless you understand it.

Speaker 3So what we wanted to do, and we were able to do this because we had very good sourcing, not only inside and around the department, current former officers. We had reams of records. I mean we sued for I want to say, hundreds of thousands of pages of records, videos, audio files, got old court trains, scripts, cassette tapes of old internal affairs interviews backstop those by talking to the people there and involved, and we were really able to We were able to kind of reconstruct, not just the

Speaker 3initial scandal of the writers of which stemmed from this young officer, Keith Batt, who is from a city from Sebastopol, which is a bit north of Oakland, very different place, rural, a bit crunchy, quite crunchy, not nearly the real rough and tumble grit of Oakland around the turn.

Speaker 2Of the millennium. And Keith comes in.

Speaker 3He's a criminal justice major in college, really idealistic, wanted to join an active police department, applied to dozens of apartments, to several departments around the area, and the first one that took him was Oakland, and Oakland had a good reputation among police culture.

Speaker 2It was an active department.

Speaker 3The cops worked hard, they were well trained, they were decently paid, and it wasn't a you know in the Bay Area like the two departments that people look to are like are the Oakland Police Department in SFPD, and SFPD is a closed shot.

Speaker 2It is a legacy.

Speaker 3Department is run by an intense old boy network of Italian and Irish folks, some Chinese, some Asian immigrants that are kind of led into that now, but it is just it's such an insular place. OPD is actually typically more welcoming of recruits from outside, and they really like people who are hard chargers, active, willing to learn. And Keith finished the top of his near the top of his academy, excellent shot, really sharp on the uptake. His instructors liked him, and right when he was about to

Speaker 3go on the street, they one of his instructors pulled him aside and said, hey, I hear you got aside to chuck to Clarence Mabtang, who was his field training officer. He said, okay, listen, you need to keep your mouth shut and you need to keep your eyes open. You're going to see some crazy shit. But just go along to get along, you know, just keep your head down. Yeah, And Keith was like, wait, what are you talking about? Like that's that's some wild that's a wild shit, Like that's not what I'm expecting.

Speaker 2It's a little bit odd. And these are older officers who he respected.

Speaker 3He goes out and gets in the car with Chuck, and Chuck is this little, you know, very very intense, buzz cut Filipino dude. And he's like, all right, I'm gonna teach you. I gonna take take you out and toughen you up, like this is not the academy anymore. I'm gonna teach you how to be in the streets. We're gonna get a fight, and we're gonna get in a fight tonight. This is beast, first jot night on the job, first time stepping into a Crown of Victoria patrol car with his FTO.

Speaker 2And he's like what.

Speaker 3And sure enough, Chuck gets in a confrontation that very night with someone drunk in front of his own house, just drunk in front of his own house, threatens to shoot the guy's dog takes the guy in after beating him up.

Speaker 2And Keith is like, wait, what you shoot dogs? And yeah, they told him that.

Speaker 3You know, every now and then they would encounter somebody with the dog and they would shoot the dog and then cut the leash in order to make it seem like the dog was going to attack them.

Speaker 2And that was just his introduction to it.

Speaker 3And over the two weeks that he worked with several officers on shift, there were three other officers who kind of made up this little click of of free wheeling cops that they called themselves the Riders, and they were Jude Siapno, Frank Vasquez, and Matt Hornung And those three were kind of at the center of it, and they would they basically took it on themselves.

Speaker 2They were not in a task force. They were just patrol officers.

Speaker 3They would kind of roam around West Oakland going out and looking for people to arrest, just jumping out on random folks.

Speaker 2They were pro not reactive, they were proactive.

Speaker 3So they actually ended up kidnapping people, planning drugs on them when they didn't find drugs, beating the tar out of them, torturing them. Sap, Who's nickname was the foot Doctor because he had a habit of taking his asss retractable batime and beating detainees on the soles of their feet till they couldn't walk.

Speaker 2Yeah, their bruises were so painful.

Speaker 1For some reference, that's that was called bastinado by the Spanish inquisition, who loved to do the exact same thing.

Speaker 3Yeah, no, it's it's really it's grim. It's really really grim shit. So Keith sees.

Speaker 2All this stuff.

Speaker 3It's just like two weeks of like training day that film, it's two weeks of that, it's not just one week.

Speaker 2And he's like, I.

Speaker 3Can't do this. This can't be the way policing is. And he keeps going, you know, kind of casting around for help. And the cash twenty two that he's in is that anybody who he tells about this behavior is obligated by OPDS regulations to then report said misconduct, and if they don't, then they're guilty of failing to report misconduct. So he has to kind of hedge his words and you know, talk around these issues. And his friends who work in OPD, who work in CHP California and highway patrol,

Speaker 3and he tells about this stuff in this roundabout way. Are all giving him the same advice? You know, I don't know, like do you want to write out your career? Like can you do this? Is there a way you can switch out? Is there a way that you can thread the needle? And it gets to be too much, and so one day, after two weeks, he decides, I can't do this anymore. I can't put more I can't put in this in people in jail. I can't forge paperwork for my supervisors. I can't forge their overtime. You know, I can't help them steal money from the taxpayers like this.

Speaker 3So he goes into the you know, he confronts them in a parking garage in front of a church in right north of downtown Oakland. These guys called the light Cave that they would hang out at, and he's telling Chuck, listen, you know, I can't do this.

Speaker 2This isn't the right way. And Maven x as well, you know you have a problem. No, No, I don't think you're really getting this.

Speaker 3He's trying to like talking past it, and then Keith keeps bringing up Frank Fasquez and Frank he'd seen Frank choke people. He'd see Frank empty, can't pepper spray into somebody's mouth, puts his fingers into their eyes like a bowling ball.

Speaker 2He said, oh, well, if you have a problem with Frank, you can talk to him.

Speaker 3Fasquez comes over and you know drives over there that have a conversation about that.

Speaker 2And Keith at this point is so wired up and so terrified.

Speaker 3He's looking at Mabadag and looking at Fasquez and thinking to himself, Okay, can I get to my pistol before they get to theirs if they want to hurt me? And if we have a shootout, how's it going to look if three Oakland cops are bucking led at each other in uniform on shift right, He's running this calculus in his head.

Speaker 2Doesn't come to that.

Speaker 3In the end, Mabini convinces him to go in and sign a resignation letter, and when he does that at OPD headquarters, one of his supervisors from the academy gets hold of him, gets a hold of him, says, no, no, no, this isn't what's happened. This is not you what's going on? And they convinced him to go upstairs and talk to internal affairs, and then he spills the beans on the what he's seen the past two weeks, and that blows the Lid office scandal.

Speaker 1There had been a number of people who had attempted to kind of like victims of this particular gang of guys who had that's like, attempted to complain, attempted to come forward. But yeah, it's not really until this officer on the inside, with a very good record is willing to say something that anything starts to happen.

Speaker 3So you have to remember the context here. I'm sorry for cutting in, but he I was remiss on this. So the context of Oakland in late nineteen nineties early two thousands is that it's in the middle of New York style urban renewal. Jerry Brown, who later became governor of California, was kind of on his way back up the political rung, and Oakland was his first stop.

Speaker 2He was re elected mayor in nineteen ninety eight.

Speaker 3I believe on this kind of ecotopian platform where he could he was going to turn Oakland into this socialist, you know, environmental friendly metropolis. But he gets into office, he starts going to community meetings and he realizes public safety is the number one concerns. So he becomes Rudy Giuliani West, as one of his former employees put it to us, pushes a massive building program in downtown Oakland for new residential market rate housing and enlists his police

Speaker 3department to go on a clean up the streets spree by any means necessary, and he would go into the lineup and cheer them on route them on, say listen, you know, I got your back, all back your play, you know, just take back those corners from these dealers.

Speaker 2That's what those officers, That's what.

Speaker 3Mabinang, Hornoggs, Siapno, and Vasquez were responding to. They were responding to the instructions from their supervisor, from their chief, from their mayor that came down the command chain to clean up the streets and do this sort of stuff. And they were actually, you know, Maminag and Vazquez in particular, were very highly valued officers. They were proactive. They made their supervisors look good. It was this kind of one hand washes the other bit.

Speaker 1Yeah, and I one of the things that I found particularly kind of impactful is the way in which you describe both the kind the violence, the absolute like horrifying cruelty of what these guys are getting up to and how that intersects with Jerry Brown's political career, with the kind of promises he's making to clean up the city and the kind of metrics that are established, you know, to provide basically evidence that this plan is succeeding.

Speaker 2You know.

Speaker 1It's it really like kind of gives on the ground context to what this kind of broken windows style policing, what it actually means in terms of a human cost, and it's it's devastating. And equally devastating is the lawsuit that kind of comes afterwards when this all gets exposed. One of the things that was most shocking to me because I was I was only kind of broadly aware of this case at all, is when these guys, the

Speaker 1officers in this in this gang, get you know, go on trial or sort of when that process starts, one of them, this guy Vasquez, like goes on the run, steals an AR fifteen from his department and fucking disappears and he's still in the wind. No one's ever found this guy.

Speaker 2Yeah, he was most likely in Mexico. He's from Mexico.

Speaker 3He's born down there and has family around media.

Speaker 2The theory is that he I mean, you know, he was stopped by a cop.

Speaker 3That's when, Yeah, the people realized that he had been that he'd stolen a gun from the department. But he kind of badges his way out of this encounter with a cop in so which is a Delta town near where he lived and are near his house, and that was the last anybody had seen of him, has seen of him. The theory a theory that's rattled around quite often, and there's more often than there's probably some hef to it is that somebody from the either the department or

Speaker 3the police union helped him down to the border in Chula Vista and he walked across. So the odds are that he's in Mexico estensively. The FBI are still looking for him. He's a fugitive, but he's never never been found.

Speaker 1No, and he when this happens, because his buddies and the writers are all all do in fact, go on trial. And you know, you might think the fact that one of them like bounced and fled the country after stealing a gun would have an impact on things, but no, no, in court, they're not you know, the prosecutors aren't allowed to tell the jury what happened with Fasquez because there it's worried that it might prejudice them, which is wild to me.

Speaker 3Well, in the first trial, so there were two trials. Fast forward a little bit, all three cops in their first trial. There's hung juries in them. I think there were one or two holdouts maybe, And from the reporting that we.

Speaker 2Did, the interview that we did with the.

Speaker 3ADA on the case, Dave Holliser, it seemed that these were people who were convinced that these were good cops and the ends justified the means or therefore, you know, this kind of noble noble cause corruption actually has an audience among some segments of the population around here.

Speaker 2I mean it.

Speaker 3I'm sure you see this across the Bay now in San Francisco. There's all these people who were, you know, kind of advocating the sort of vigilante violence that that former fire commissioner was committed any and so against homeless folks, unhoused.

Speaker 1Yeah, for folks who aren't aware the fire commissioner of San Francisco. This was a couple of months ago, right around the time that there was a big wave of San Francisco has collapsed into anarchy sort of stories.

Speaker 2Which happened every ten years, which yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah, and then you know, it happened at the same time that that tech CEO was stabbed to death. Turns out by another tech founder. But yeah, this story that the fire commissioner had been attacked and there's this video of him getting brutally beaten by a homeless man. It turns out he had been going around at night and macing homeless people at random.

Speaker 3One of the yeah, hairspring, it was crazy, it was awful ship. Yeah, and then someone attacked him with the homeless with a with a crowbar. But all that those facts were emitted anyway. So the bottom line is with the with Horning of Horning, Vasquez and Sap they're they're hung on the first trial, and then the second trial they're acquitted. Uh, they're Horning is acquitted of some charges and there's hung juries in the rest of his charges and those first Syap know and Mabinang. But in the second trial. The first trial the defense was, well, they

Speaker 3didn't do with Keith, did Keith's bad as lying? The second trial was well, the defense turned to a strategy of well, actually Frank Ivasquez was the leader, So it's all Frank's fault.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's easy to throw that guy under the bus because he's gone.

Speaker 2Exactly, yeah, exactly.

Speaker 3And you know, to say he was the ringleader is absurd because everyone knew in OPD and outside OPD that Mabdang was the shot.

Speaker 2Caller in that little gang.

Speaker 3What's interesting is the lawsuit, So there's a little vegary here about the criminal investigation into the Riders. The police department and the police department's internal affairs investigators and the police chief made a decision from day one from on high that the investigation would only be limited to what Keith Bat saw, that it would not expand out beyond his two weeks on the job and the incidents that he witnessed personally, and that they were able to corroborate with other people. And there was another cop, Scott Huson, who did corroborate some of this stuff. Once it came

Speaker 3out that he'd falsified some reports, he decided to save his on skin.

Speaker 2So he also caught some of.

Speaker 3The flak that Bat did, but not nearly the same sort of death threat type shit that Keith caught. So with regard to the broader, the broader lay of the land, the criminal the investigation didn't go into a broader pattern of what else was happening on these shifts, what are their cops were involved because the writers, you know, there's a ball that they actually signed for each other, and there's several names on that ball.

Speaker 2It's not just those four cops.

Speaker 3So the civil suit, there was a civil suit brought by two civil rights two attorneys in the area, John Burris and Jim Channon, who had been suing the department for years.

Speaker 2They'd actually received walkins.

Speaker 3The victims that you'd mentioned earlier over the years, alleging that they'd been arrested, beaten up, framed up, tortured by these cops in West Oakland. And when the news of Keith Batt blowing the whistle on the writers hit the newspapers, it clicked for them and they realized they'd been seeing this pattern. So they opened up their own pattern and practice investigation and did their own investigation of complaints and canvassed neighborhoods and got names from people who'd filed complaints

Speaker 3and alleged similar patterns of misconduct, and came up with one hundred and nineteen plaintiffs who who laid out a pattern of abuses that spanned much more of the city, the downtown area, other parts of West Oakland, even as far as East Oakland, and a much broader time frame stretching back almost basically to nineteen ninety five, five years prior.

Speaker 2So.

Speaker 3The reality of opd's abuses and their kind of deep corruption in that period of time was far larger than the criminal case against those four riders would have it. And I should say that these civil attorneys took up the challenge where both the state Attorney general and the federal authorities both you a United States attorney and federal and civil rights in main justice dropped the ball. They

Speaker 3did not open pattern and practice investigations into OPD. And we have it from the ADA himself, who's in the room when he presented their case, because they were cross designated as as their cross editor as designated as US attorneys during their whole investigation, and vice versa. He presented the case to the city United States Attorney at the time, one Robert Mueller, who should be familiar to your listeners as the former head of the.

Speaker 1FBI twice over swinging Bob Miller, that's right.

Speaker 3And you know, Miller flipped through the pages and was looking, you know, trying to see if any connections to Russia and.

Speaker 2Alpha Bank and so on.

Speaker 3But no, actually, I mean he's flipping through and he pulls out these files and he looks at the long rap sheet of some of these witnesses, and these were people in the street. These were people who had been arrested before, had been involved in narcotic sales, petty assaults, that robbery's, burglaries, what have you like. They were people who were not They were not kids, they were not clean sheets. And he handed the file back to Hollister, to the ADA and said, I wish you the best of luck. It's important to note that this was a different era. A CoP's word was very, very very hard

Speaker 3to impeach on the stand. There was no body camera video. There were no cell phoned videos at the time. You would maybe have a rough camcorder every now and then if somebody shooting like a little video on the street, kind of grainy digital cameras, and they were The sound wasn't great, but there wasn't much beyond eyewitness testimony. And that's why Keith's words were so important. Why his testimony was so critical is that you had a cop coming out and blowing the whistle on his department and saying, no, this is not right.

Speaker 2This is what they're doing. They should be punished for it.

Speaker 1You know, I can't help it thinking about the story that's kind of blown up right now about there's a man on the subway recently in New York City who was, you know, acting kind of erradically yelling and stuff, but had not done any violence to anyone, and a bystander straphanger restrained him, put him in a headlock for fifteen minutes, and he died. And kind of the response that I'm seeing from guys like Matt Walsh, the Daily Wire crew, you know, particularly in right wing media, is well, this guy had been arrested, you know, forty times or whatever.

Speaker 1It's like, well, that's not germane to anything that's happening.

Speaker 2Doesn't give you the right to lynch someone.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly like that, Like, the penalty for having been arrested in the past is not getting strangled to death. That's not the way the system is. That's not the way any of this is supposed to work. And it's it's interesting. There's a degree to which I guess it hasn't changed, and there's a degree to which I'm kind of worried that the sort of nature of social media means that we're a lot more open about the kind of violence we're willing to accept.

Speaker 2For I agree with it, Yeah, I agree with that entirely.

Speaker 3I mean, that's unfortunately the backlash to a lot of to both Black Lives Matter cycles in twenty fourteen, fifteen, and the current cycle is a lot more virulent then you'd have it if you just watched kind of the soft focus PBS frontline documentary versions of it. There's a lot of really naked justification and support for.

Speaker 2Extra legal violence.

Speaker 3And that is part of the issue with you know, law enforcement and holding them accountable. There is always going to be a segment, small, sometimes vocal, sometimes not, of the society that supports violence beyond the extent of the law, beyond the constraints of our system. And that's why oversight, why running the rule over law enforcement and making sure that they behave according to the laws and that they

Speaker 3are operating within the baluands of their limits. In so far as we have set them out for them and in so far as like it. Look, this book is not a book questioning whether or not police should exist.

Speaker 2It's a history.

Speaker 3They do exist, They have existed. This is what it has looked like to date. Right If other people want to make those cases and look at you know, hypotheticals or envisioned a different future, that's totally fine. What we're trying to do is lay out the ways in which people have pushed back on one of the most egregious departments in the country consistently for over a century and actually had some sort of lasting impact on it. And there have been some impacts that have really changed because

Speaker 3of Look, they don't there a there's no more public strip searching of people in the streets that happen in Oakland on the regular every day.

Speaker 2As late as.

Speaker 3Twenty nine and ten, it was common that the cops would say, look, I'm going in your ass for rocks. You'd better not have anything there, right in the middle of the morning, on a crowded street, in front of people driving by on the way to work. That sort of civil rights violation would happen all the time. The department no longer shoots shoots, maybe about three or four people a year. That's way down from fourteen to fifteen a year a decade twelve years ago. That's because they've changed their chase policy, their pursuit policy. They used to pursue people with an intent to catch them at all costs.

Speaker 3That ended up resulting in cops chasing people down blind alleys or ending up way too close to a suspect and pulling out their weapon and opening up fire, regardless of whether or not they actually had the suspect had a firearm or another weapon, or whether the cops were under threat. The change in the pursuit policy has led to more of the instruction now is to contain, don't pursue close call for backup, set a perimeter, preserve life. That's not been that change was not something in department

Speaker 3submitted to voluntarily. They are brought, they are kicking and screaming. But because there has been this outside imposition of court oversight for so long, because it hasn't gone away, because it's not overseen by the Justice Department or the state Attorney General. So you know, some of the political figure can't like they can't there can't be a deal cut in the back room between a senator's staffer and the federal Department of Justice, or the mayor and the state attorney.

Speaker 2General and their wife or whatever like.

Speaker 3That sort of thing doesn't really happen when the plaintiff's attorneys aren't hoholding to anybody other than themselves, and when the federal district court judge kind of lets the situation play out as it will and whole and both judges on this case have actually been very by the book and very stringent on how the oversight has gone. So that's why it's gone on for twenty years, and it actually has resulted in good changes. There are a lot of people who bitch about it, who cry that, oh, well, we need to be out from there. To this oversight,

Speaker 3it's hammering the police. They can't do their job as they will. Well, do you want to go back to twenty years ago? Do you really want that? Do you want that sort of abuse?

Speaker 2No?

Speaker 3And that's why there is a constituency in Oakland that did manage to change a lot of things around. There's a police commission here that now oversees the department. It's not perfect, it's very much in the infancy, but that's a body that existed to take control away from the mayor and move it more towards civilian control of a police department. And this is Yeah, it's a long arc, but the bottom line is that it's not about a one or a zero.

Speaker 2There's no linear progress here.

Speaker 3It's kind of goes in ways, but there has been progress, which is a crazy thing to say when.

Speaker 2You look at the the shit that's in the book.

Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, but it is, like, it's important both, you know, I think our our audience is definitely much more of our audiences in the constituency of you know, get rid of the police entirely, even if you're coming at it from that, I mean, especially if you're coming at from that standpoint. Actually, I think kind of one of the mistakes that a lot of people who are are on that side of things, which is generally where I find myself, is using that as an excuse to not actually understand how the police function, using their sort of distaste for the institution as an excuse to not understand how the

Speaker 1institution works, why it's resilient, and the ways in which you know, both harms can to an extent be mitigated, but also kind of just on a strategic level, how it functions to defend itself, and I think that this book does an exceptional job of going through that in a way that's nuanced and detailed, but also compelling and readable, like you're not going to have to I do really recommend your book. People are not going to have like trouble getting into it, Like I was drawn in from

Speaker 1the first page. So I really do think this is something folks should look into. No matter where you live in the United States, even if you've never been to Oakland, you will. You will get a lot out of this.

Speaker 3I would say that we didn't make an explicit attempt to make the city the main character, so to draw people into Oakland and kind of cast it in the same way that Mike Davis cast Los Angeles in the City of Courts. May he rest in peace. It was a great inspiration for us. But more than anything else, there are tons of parallels in Oakland to other places. It's not a unique plate. I mean, it is a unique place, but it's also very typical for an American city like Los Angeles and New York and Chicago are completely atypical. They're huge, they don't most American cities are

Speaker 3like four hundred to six hundred thousand people large. Oakland's racial balance is almost thirty thirty thirty white, Latino, Black, ten percent Asian, and roughly eight to ten percent Asian.

Speaker 2Then everyone else thrown in there.

Speaker 3It's really balanced out and in some ways it's very representative, and it's also you know, rust belt city in certain respects, although that's changed a lot with the tech boom.

Speaker 2We could be going back the other way.

Speaker 3Yeah, but it really there are echoes in stuff that's happened in New York and Los Angeles, in Cleveland, in New Orleans, in Portland and Seattle. It's the experience that we've had here, particularly with police oversight and reform. I mean Portland and Seattle are two other cities that have actually undergone very similar programs with departments that.

Speaker 2Are more alike to OPD than not.

Speaker 1Yeah, well, Allie, is there anything else you wanted to make sure to get into in this conversation or Yeah.

Speaker 3I think your point about I just wanted to touch on your point about where people come out for the institution. I think it's really important, even regardless of what you believe about where we should and shouldn't be with law enforcement.

Speaker 2You've got to understand it.

Speaker 3Yeah, because it's such a huge institution in our society. It is basically the main point of contact most people have with the state now in many American cities, because we've stripped down so many other aspects of our societies. Mental hospitals are gone, our schools are failing, public housing barely exists, our healthcare system is decimated, and cops essentially catch a lot of the end product of those problems.

Speaker 2It's one of the reasons why I started.

Speaker 3Reporting our criminal justice because you can look at so many other issues of American society through that system. And also you can see ways in which like political agendas, the way that police departments lobby, and the messaging that they push out. They don't do it in isolated fashion. It's coordinated, like there are these big swings that happen on the national political stage, if you will. We were at one moment with police reform and abolishing the police, defunding them with Black Lives matters. The immediate pushback within

Speaker 3six months was there's a crime wave.

Speaker 2There's a crime wave. There's a crime wave we need to support.

Speaker 3And now we're at the point where people are taking act or basically committing acts of vigilante violence because they have it in their head that things are so out of control. In New York, homeless man's choked to death because he's he's having an episode on the train.

Speaker 2San Francisco.

Speaker 3This fire commissioner is going around bare spring people who are camping out on in the streets. This is the sort of back and forth swing that oftentimes starts with people who are trying to protect their budget line, who are trying to protect their political power, and it ends up with consequences like that where people take it to that level. And I think that looking at law enforcement as a political actor is really important for understanding how we are where we are in this society and also

Speaker 3understanding the ways in which you can try and rain them back in and keep your boot on their neck, because realistically they will if you let if there's no oversight, if oversight is pulled back. There's a reactionary at the heart of American law enforcement. It's always been there. We document it back basically to the turn of the century in Oakland in Justice one City, which is a newer city in the States. And if you don't if you let that go that core will rise up and basically take over the department. That's what happened with the writers,

Speaker 3That's what they were. They were a representation of a hard core that had existed in Oakland for decades. And I think that that's really a really I think that's a critical takeaway for readers from this book.

Speaker 1Yeah, I would absolutely agree. Well, folks, the book is called The Writers Come Out at Night, Brutality, Corruption and cover Up in Oakland. It's by Ali Winston, who you've just been listening to, and Darwin Bond Graham. I can't recommend it enough. Ali, thank you so much for being on the show.

Speaker 2Thank you so much, Robert. It could Happen here as a production of cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from cool Zone Media, visit our website cool zonemedia dot com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts.

Speaker 1You can find sources for It Could Happen Here, updated monthly at Coolzonemedia dot com slash sources.

Speaker 2Thanks for listening,

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Guests

  • Ali Winston Guest Inferred

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. CZM Book Club: "Organizing Social Spaces as if Social Relations Matter," by Cindy Barukh Milstein (Part Three of Three)

    Nov 22, 202636 minAudio

    Margaret finishes reading you some non-fiction with advice for organizers

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. It Could Happen Here Weekly 259

    Nov 21, 20263 hr 56 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Executive Disorder: Everything Breaks, Rohingya Genocide, Mamdani Disbands SRG

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    The gang chats about all the many tech outages this week, the ICJ finding Myanmar guilty of genocide against Rohingya, corporate executives pocketing tariff refund money, protests in Bangladesh over working conditions,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Repression in Iran

    Nov 19, 202642 minAudio

    James is joined by Gordayeen to talk about the Iranian state’s repressive tactics and the failure of the USA and ISrael to diminish the capacity for state violence Sources: https://hengaw.org/ https://www.theamargi.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Organizing Agricultural Workers

    Nov 18, 202644 minAudio

    Mia talks with Lindsey and Brady of the IWW about what we can learn about organizing agricultural workers from efforts abroad and organizing outside of the National Labor Relations Act

    Credit the people on this episode