Shipping rates have dropped for 14 straight weeks. That sounds like good news for shippers, and it is, for now. But new USTR fees on Chinese-linked vessels are about to hit, and roughly 45% of the world's bulk carrier fleet is exposed, simply because China builds the majority of the world's bulkers. In this episode, Captain Andrew Kinsey, Head of Marine Risk Consulting at ISC, breaks down how tariffs are reshaping manufacturing and global trade. He walks through the three new USTR fee structures taking effect on Chinese-linked vessels: a per-net-ton fee on Chinese-owned or operated ships that rises from $50 to $140 by 2028, a fee on Chinese-built vessels of $18 per net ton or $120 per container (whichever is higher), and a separate fee for roll-on/roll-off carriers, all assessed only at a vessel's first US port and capped at five charges per year. He explains why reshoring manufacturing to the US won't happen quickly (the infrastructure is gone) and why "friend-shoring" alternatives like Vietnam and India are now getting hit with 30%+ tariffs of their own, pushing companies to consider Latin America and Africa instead. Also touched on: why short-term tariff costs are being absorbed by manufacturers and shippers before eventually passing to consumers, "blank sailings" caused by shipping overcapacity, Panama Canal draft restrictions tied to climate cycles, rerouting around the Red Sea and South China Sea tensions, and why diversifying away from sole-source supply chains (a lesson reinforced by COVID, the Red Sea closures, the Ever Given, and the Baltimore bridge collapse) matters regardless of what happens with tariffs. Have clients navigating supply chain or trade disruption? ISC's Marine Risk Consulting team is a resource for brokers and clients alike. Learn more about ISC's programs at iscmga.com. Ready to write more business? Get appointed today for fast quotes, dedicated underwriting support, and access to programs your clients need - call (760) 599-7242 or visit iscmga.com/get-appointed.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SpeakerGood morning everyone. Needless to say this is a moving target. I was just downloading, some new data I got this morning on the structure of the upcoming USTR fees, which are for the farm built vessels calling in the us. But first, let's get started on the overall tariff. impact on manufacturing and transportation. we're gonna touch on onshoring, reshoring, friend shoring, which are longer term goals, and also shorter term goals and impacts for businesses that we'll be involved with.
SpeakerNext slide, please. Okay. we wanna look at the economic versus the manufacturing impacts first on this. April 2nd. they signed the executive order, 10% tariffs on all US imports higher from, 57 specific countries. this has been a moving target so far. The deals have raised, UF Iris to 17.7% overall, but when we're looking at certain key trading partners, it's significant and changing. the uncertainty is hitting all aspects of the manufacturing process from insurance follow on supply chains.
SpeakerRaw materials. So it's wide ranging. as far as economic impacts, we are going to see a split on this. Short term. Economic impacts are being absorbed by the manufacturers. Just like with the shipping fees, most of them will be absorbed by the operating companies. That will change, once the tariff level is known. Once the business model is evaluated every economist I've been talking to states the costs will be passed on to consumers.
SpeakerSo we'll wait and see, but for right now, it's being born. Majority of it is being borne by manufacturers or the shipping companies. Next slide please. So the growth in inflation on the year ahead is, interesting. when we're looking at, the short term impact of tariffs, it is not going to lead to a. Plethora of us manufacturing overnight. It can't, the infrastructure isn't there any longer.
Speakerif you've been in the field as much as I have at different manufacturing or port locations, you can tell it just the nuts and bolts aren't there anymore. So it's gonna be, A delayed impact, if any impact at all. And I believe what we'll be seeing, rather than what we refer to as reshoring, more the impact of friend shoring. However, the friend shoring aspect of this is getting very complicated. some of the entities that we had looked to move manufacturing too, especially on the project cargo side, which I am strongly involved in, include Vietnam and India.
SpeakerThey are now being hit with much higher tariffs. So those areas that we're expecting to move manufacturing to are now looking at 30% plus. So now it's time for plant C, so you'll continue to hear more on Latin and Latin America and South America as well as Africa. Next slide please. what you're looking at on the right, that image, that is an automatic ship id. a heat map of vessels that are transiting, and those are the main, what we refer to as a great circle sailing route.
SpeakerAll the way to the top, you'll see the, going to the Ians. Seattle. And then coming down on those other green bands, you'll see traffic heading for LA Long Beach and then all the way going down to Panama Canal, and then also the north South heading to Australia. And then the lower left is Singapore going down through the South China Sea, going to the Straits of Maloka and Singapore Straits. Friend sharing is that trade practice where supply chains are focused on political or economic allies.
Speakerfriend sharing has a lot of impacts We're starting to see not just economic, but it's now a leverage to be used to structure deals. most recently we were seeing some of this also start to impact. just this week there were some more nuclear projects announced in Eastern Europe with Westinghouse, Nuclear reactors that are being built by Bechtel, a US contractor with Westinghouse technology. Next slide please.
Speakerwill this be the end of globalization and trade? I had the opportunity recently to, attend a conference in Singapore from the international. Union of Marine insurers, I had a chance there to speak with, several economists who know a lot more about this than I do. I am the simple sailor, but when they're looking at, geopolitical fragmentation and de globalization, there's It's a complicated question, it's not gonna be the end to it because as we look at more and more raw materials for complex, batteries and other, systems that we would require in the data center explosion, which we're currently experiencing, and which we'll ramp up these materials.
SpeakerRequire an international or global supply chain. So when we're looking at deglobalization, it's not something that can be, undone overnight. And next slide, please. this is a rather interesting, graph that I found, regarding. Deglobalization and how it proceeded. certain key points, IE, world War I, world War ii, and then post World War II, globalization, and then the hyper globalization that we have experienced from the nineties into, two thousands.
SpeakerWhen we look at the two world wars and the book ending and the 60 years of increased globalization and then the hyper, now since 2008, there has been, what many concern is an over-reliance, on the globalization of trade. So they're looking to step back. Just keep this in mind as we also look at the tariff scenario and then the reassuring. Next slide please. So our current trade environment with the globalization, it's.
SpeakerA rollback, let's say, of globalization. the disruption in global trades with COVID-19 Ukraine, red Sea Transport has had a tremendous impact because bypassing of the Red Sea and the Transits, around the Cape of Good Hope. Have increased focus on the West African ports. We've got more large ships passing by, and when we're looking at ship operators, they're trying to see how they can leverage this new routing to support better utilization of their ships.
SpeakerSo they're looking at increased port calls in West Africa. Along the whole west African coast. The other thing is when we see an increase in Panama Canal traffic to get goods to the East Coast rather than Red Sea and Mediterranean transits, we also introduce the. Climate change scenario where reduced rainfall on the ismi of Panama creates in the El Nino La Nina climate bubbles, that progress draft restrictions.
Speakerif you get draft restrictions in Panama, you then have less cargo that you can put on ships. So this is another pressure on trade. Fees. if you can get fewer containers on a ship, it's gonna cost more per container. the confusion is, is real right now because there's so many impacts of it. And then on top of this, we have the tariff scenario adding to it. it's going to impact shipping rates, but it's also going to impact availability. And this is where next weeks are the coming USTR.
SpeakerFees on Chinese built ships can throw another wrench into this because we're looking at all different classes of ships being impacted by these fees. So this is just another pressure, another lever that is going to impact shipping rates and the availability of tonnage, to move from point A to point B. 'cause if the ship's not gonna call in the US, don't make any sense to put it on it because it ain't gonna get here. Next slide please. the carrier's pulling capacity and the rates, but the rates keep sinking, and this is a direct result of the increase in vessel building.
Speakerpost COVID shipping companies made a lot of money. rates went up, they were flush with cash, and as a result, they booked a lot of new tonnage, so they're building ships. As a result, you get over capacity. Now, with that over capacity, along with a slowdown in the trade, you have. Over capacity, then you're going to hear, what they refer to as blank sailings. So they'll skip and they'll bypass ports. this happened during COVID when certain ports were shut down due to, Lockdowns where they started to buy passports.
SpeakerAnd it's always been, it happens, you know, for a variety of reason. Weather strike, lack of trade. You can skip ports, you'll still routing. You'll go from Asia to the med, to the East Coast, Gulf Coast, or West Coast a after, Asia. But we're seeing right now. the transpacific and the Asia Europe med have the most cuts, and you don't see this level of blank sailings at this time of year.
SpeakerIt's normally a stock up. A lot of this blank sailing is tied to a tremendous increase in shipments before the tariff deadline. Once the tariffs were announced, rates and shipping volumes increased because people were trying to get cargo into the states before the tariffs took hold. now it's getting rolled back as far as the amount of trade coming into the us.
SpeakerSo you got the blank sailings and you've got vessels that are being already bypassing ports row on top of this. The USTR fee's coming and it's going to be even greater impact. You're going to see less availability of slots, both container as well as tankers and bulkers. for your clients, for businesses, this could start to tighten on capacity eventually this will raise rates.
SpeakerIf there's less capacity and then volume increases, rates will rise. The other unknown in this, of course, is what level of tariffs will a cargo that's coming in on these vessels be subject to next slide please. Rates are still going down for shippers. This is good news. You can ship you, you can ship it quick, cheaper, however, you don't know what the cargo in that container is going to be subjected to with regards to tariff fees. But for one fee, the shipping fee is dropping. So we're now at,$1,913 for a 40 foot, as of, 18 September.
Speakerit's a 14 straight weekly drop. Med Asia, Europe, down 10%, Transpac five, and Transatlantic just won. So now 14 October, as we're talking about the US port fees will be coming in, shippers need to stay flexible, shorter contracts, monitoring towers closely, and locking in capacity early. These are the keys on that second bullet point. Costco, being hit hardest according to Drury. That is true. But an interesting, I, this is some of the data I just pulled this morning before the call bulk carriers are going to be exposed highest as far as, fees they, expect.
SpeakerThis is from BIM Co. They're saying bulk carriers could be exposed to an increased cost as much as 45% of their ships would be subject to the UST AR fees because a majority of bulkers are built in China. if you tuned into our previous webinar on shipyard details, China has. Been predominantly building less technologically complex ships, bulkers being some of the easiest to build. So there's more Chinese tonnage in Bulkers than any other fleet.
Speakeryou've got Bulkers at about 45% of the fleet being impacted while, crew tankers, 30%, 19% product tankers. And then, Container ships, we're looking at 20% of the ship scheduled to call. And as stated here, Costco shipping lines orient overseas container lines, and those shipping lines owned by Chinese leasing banks, once you get into this and start pulling down the layers, it's a lot of Chinese money in different shipping lines.
SpeakerSo that's what we're looking at. 45%. Of the Bulker fleet, 30% crude fleet, 19% of the product tanker fleet, and 20% of the container fleet. Now the other thing on this impact, the rate structure has finally gotten some clarity. So there's three distinct annexes for the USTR fees of that it will impact shippers. Annex one imposes a fee of$50 per net ton for vessels owned or operated by Chinese entities.
SpeakerIncreasing annually up to 140 net ton by 2028. Now, annex two is Chinese built vessels, and this is a fee of either$18 per net ton or$120 per container discharged, whichever is higher. annex three is for roll on, roll off carriers, and it is$14 per net ton. Now these fees are just for the first US port and they can only be assessed five times per year.
SpeakerSo when we say only five times per year, or first us port those vessels that call, New York, and then proceed down through the East Coast to the Gulf Coast. They'll only be charged the first time. Same thing. A vessel calls LA Long Beach and then works up the coast of Seattle. It'll only be charged for that first port. So manufacturing impacts will not be near term. As you mentioned earlier, it's independent on international boundaries. so getting the data is a little challenging, but.
SpeakerReassuring is capital and intensive. it takes planning, finance, and a long-term commitment. We deal with this a lot, Kevin Wolf with the Project Cargo side. When we're looking at infrastructure projects, these. Are years in the planning the bid processes and years in construction, so it doesn't happen overnight The interesting thing is most of the reassuring or the concentrated industrials and manufacturing, this is a new model for manufacturing it's not going to make a lot of new jobs because it's highly automated.
SpeakerThe plants we are seeing constructed have a high level of automation and robotics. It's not going to be the. General Motors plant of the 1950s. The fascinating thing about most of the machinery then that is running these automations. It's once again sourced overseas and will be subject to tariffs. even if you wanna build it in the states in order to get the nuts and bolts to build it, that's gonna come far.
SpeakerNext slide, please. So what we're talking about right now. Increased fees, increased costs are not going away. Short term manufacturers and shippers are absorbing them. Once the actuaries can look at it and figure it out, expect the cost to be shifted over to consumers. So the obstacles that we face with As you mentioned earlier, it's unlikely to derive significant increases in US employment given that, increased production.
SpeakerLabor costs are a primary concern deterring most sectors from reshoring, and those companies that do end up shoring will likely to offset associated cost via automation of production lines. So the greatest shift in production is not into the us but alternative low cost, Southeast Asia, Mexico. the labor issue is also another driver of this next slide, please. while we're dealing with all this uncertainty, and long-term plans on reshoring, how do we deal with our clients and advise them to make sound decisions?
SpeakerRemember that tariffs are not the only impetus for reshoring and insuring. And so even if the tars disappear, the thought of reassuring should continue to be there. One of the keys to rethinking the supply chain is getting away from the sole source supplier. We saw sole source supply chains create havoc during COVID, and we've also seen it occur with the Red Sea closures. These are all things that we need to understand the interconnected nature of these supply chains.
Speakerthe current Red Sea situation highlights the impact that political instability can have, as well as the, Ukraine situation at the Black Sea. the recent draft restrictions on Panama Canal highlight the impact that climate change can have on global supply chains. the ever given, incident in the Suez Canal shows that even if the Red Sea is clear in the Straits of Bab in the south, it's still at choke point, and that can be easily impacted by just one ship, running a foul.
SpeakerThe Port of Baltimore also highlighted the importance of having secondary and tertiary port options. Bottom line, don't put all the eggs in one basket. single routing of critical materials has always been a bad thing, and it'll continue to be a bad thing. next slide please. what are we looking at for the future? short term as in the 14th of this month. We're looking at the USTR fees, which as we said, is going to lead to, a change in capacity and probably vessel routing, to get around choke point issues to get around some of the environmentals with the canals to get around some of the political instability.
SpeakerExpect to see more North-South Ocean Basin and vessel routing. if you're looking at Gulf Coast or East Coast, rather than Panama or Suez, expect increased activity along the West African ports or the South American trade routes. Brazil would be an excellent trading partner, except right now, they seem to be. Quite cozy with the Russians, Chinese, and Koreans, along with South Africa. politics comes into play.
Speakermanufacturing shifting to South America or West Africa to eliminate the need for Panama or Suez Canal transit and bypass the Red Sea, south China Sea will continue to be an area of concern. This is China with the Raley Islands, and you've heard a lot about China and the Philippines in the Raleys, but Vietnam is also involved in this area, as is Bruna. it's a large area of concern because, for the last over 30 years, China has declared the South China Sea as their territorial waters, even though international, law.
SpeakerWould differ. expect to see more disruption in the South China Sea and the potential for, increased hostilities and not just involving the Philippines, but also involving, Vietnam. And then the sole source supply models need to be reexamined. We're seeing more reasons to avoid the sole source supply chain given the, you know, what we learned from COVID, but now we see even more issues with it. Next slide, please. So we covered a lot and there is a, there's a, a lot of moving parts to this, so hopefully I gave you some insight.
SpeakerIt's complicated. I am a subject matter expert when it comes to maritime. I am not a subject matter expert when it comes to economics, but my role is when we see changing in supply chains, how are we going to adapt and make sure that it can get from point A to point B? next slide please. this is how you get ahold of me. Any questions Are there any questions now that we might help you with? That appears to be it. Thank you very much for joining us today.
Captain Andrew Kinsey, ISC Marine's loss control specialist, covers lithium-ion battery risk from two angles: underwriting cargo shipments containing lithium batteries, and safe use and handling once devices are already...
Marq, an underwriter with ISC Marine (three years underwriting cargo at Allianz, then a decade as a national cargo broker at Willis before joining ISC), walks through general cargo - also called general marine cargo or...
There's a tariff penalty on the books right now that Customs and Border Protection cannot reduce, waive, or negotiate under any circumstances: a flat 40% ad valorem charge, applied the moment CBP determines a shipment...
Most shipping containers that leave a US port for Asia go back completely empty. It's a simple, visible symptom of the US trade deficit, and just one of several ripple effects Captain Andrew Kinsey walks through in this...
Captain Andrew Kinsey, ISC Marine's loss control specialist and a former risk engineer on nuclear waste treatment projects at Hanford and Savannah River, gives a global tour of nuclear power's current state and where...