The US doesn't have a single licensed manufacturer of slow-speed diesel engines, the engine type that powers nearly every large merchant vessel on the planet. It's one of several reasons a ship that costs $10 million to build overseas can cost closer to $100 million to build in an American shipyard. In this episode, Captain Andrew Kinsey, Head of Marine Risk Consulting at ISC and a career Merchant Marine officer, breaks down why US shipbuilding capacity has collapsed and what it means for national and economic security. He covers two pending (and currently stalled) legislative efforts, Executive Order 14269 ("Restoring America's Maritime Dominance") and the bipartisan Ships for America Act, and lays out the numbers behind the decline: US shipbuilding output is down more than 85% since the 1950s, from 5% of the world's commercial tonnage to under 0.2% today, while China, Japan, and South Korea now control roughly 90% of global commercial shipbuilding. Per the Office of Naval Intelligence, China alone has about 230 times the shipbuilding capacity of the US. Only a handful of American yards can currently build large commercial vessels at all. Kinsey also draws on his own deployments, including Gulf War pre-positioning missions out of Diego Garcia, Guam, and Saipan, and underway replenishment operations refueling carrier battle groups, to explain why certain military-support missions require US-flagged vessels and crews that foreign-flagged ships and crews legally can't perform. He walks through the workforce side of the problem too: there are only about 12,000 active US merchant mariners, and activating "mothballed" Ready Reserve Fleet vessels during a crisis, as happened in both Gulf Wars, means recalling crew members off vacation, sometimes into 18-month deployments. He also unpacks the Jones Act debate (which requires US-built, owned, and crewed ships for domestic trade) and why repealing it wouldn't actually fix the underlying capacity shortfall. Also touched on: the recent sale of the Kempel AmFELS shipyard in Brownsville, Texas to Singapore interests amid concerns about Chinese influence, and why rebuilding US shipyard capacity could open up real opportunity for insuring the secondary and tertiary trades (welding, pipe shops, electrical subcontractors) that would staff up around it. Have questions about maritime, shipbuilding, or national security-related risk? ISC's Marine Risk Consulting team is available to brokers and clients alike. Learn more about ISC's programs at iscmga.com. Ready to write more business? Get appointed today for fast quotes, dedicated underwriting support, and access to programs your clients need - call (760) 599-7242 or visit iscmga.com/get-appointed.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SpeakerOh, thank you very much. Thank you very much. Today we're, I got a bit of an echo here. Let's see if we can get rid of that. We're gonna be talking about, uh, shipbuilding in the United States. And on that topic we're gonna focus on what's referred to as major ship builders and under marad the Maritime Administration of the us a major ship builder is those yards that, that construct vessels over 400 feet. Um. So that's what we're gonna focus on. We're also gonna touch on smaller yards, but kind of the impetus of of of the current conversation and the bills put forth that we'll discuss here are focused around major ship builders, not repair facilities and not the smaller tug and barge.
SpeakerA next slide please. So we've got two different, bills Well, one, one Senate bill and one executive order that are both pending. Uh, the executive order of 14 26 9 restoring Americans Maritime dominance, which was nine April, and it addresses commercial ship building capacity and Maritime Workforce. Now, the, the Ships for America Act is a bipartisan bill that was introduced by, uh, by Mark Kelly. It. So a similar bill was also introduced at the end of last legislative session that stalled in committee.
SpeakerAnd so this, these are the two high profile, I guess we should call them, impetuses, that, that have drawn focus onto what has been a, a long deteriorating. Industry in the us but one of the keys to this is, is both of these, both the executive order and the bill, both address personnel as well as the shipyards themselves. Uh, next slide. Now also on those executive orders and bills, the executive order has not moved forward because the individual is supposed to be spearheading.
SpeakerIt was reassigned, I believe, and the senate is stalled in committee. Yeah. Trust me, when you've been dealing with shipyards in the merchant parade as far along as I have it, it doesn't surprise you, but so what is a US Merchant Marine and, and it's you, United States civilian Mariners. On civilian and federally owned merchant vessels, and they're managed by a combination of government and private sector. And they're, they're both Jones Act, which is navigating the, the, continental contingent waters of the US as well as foreign.
SpeakerI've actually been employed on a wide variety of these. You'll hear a term occasionally called Smar, which is a civil service employee. For military seal of command. And that is, uh, also like in the British, it's referred to as, as the, uh, the Merchant Navy. What military seal of command does is it provides support for naval vessels. So that was A-A-U-S-N-S instead of a USS military warships, or USS.
SpeakerAnd A-U-S-N-S is a United States naval ship, and that's the sigmar. They do underway replenishment, uh, both fuel and ammo, uh, diving salvage towage. And then you also have civilian contractors who operate pre-positioned and military support ships. So that role is both union and non-union employees that work on a variety of different ships. And I, I. Operated those under, under Maersk Line where we had contracts for both Marine Corps, Navy, and Army support, uh, vessels.
SpeakerNext slide please. So in peace and war, this is the, uh, the, the Merchant Marine logo actually. So we, uh, or they I'm, I'm happily retired. I swallow the anchor as we say, and I'm sure now, but the transporting domestic and international car goes in peace time. Operating deep sea merchant ships and in times of war, merchant marine can be auxiliary of the Navy and can be called upon to deliver military personnel and material. There are also pre-position ships that are contracted with civilian employees who are positioned around the globe.
SpeakerGuam, Saipan, Diego Garcia. And, uh, certain ports in the med traditionally have been pre-positioned ports where, uh, car ships, merchant ships that were loaded with cargo and on charter stayed for long periods of time and then responded when needed for either humanitarian or military missions. I dispen, uh, a fair bit of time in Diego Garcia and Guam and Saipan with MPS two and MPS three, and then participated in, uh, in both Gulf Wars as well as Somalia.
SpeakerSo as they say, been there, done that. Got the t-shirt. Okay, next slide please. So current US ship building production. There are, this, when we look today at this 20 ship builders capable of ocean going, that's actually naval vessels also included in that. If we're looking at shipyards. That can build vessels in excess or 400 feet or over, and are currently engaged in building those vessels.
SpeakerFor commercial means you're down to about four yards. That's the bad part. Most of these, of the 20, yeah. Uh, bath Electric Boat, Ingles, NASCO, Newport News. They're building Navy ships. The commercial yards. Philly's building the, uh, the national training vessels right now, and AmFELS, which is Brownsville in Texas, just recently completed container ships for Pasha and just completed the wind turbine erection vessel, uh, sha.
SpeakerAnd she, uh, she sailed last week, but the US shipbuilding output decreased by more than 85% since the fifties. And what the majority of, of yards that are in production in the states right now are building smaller tonnage, whether it be ferries, tugboats, barges. But as far as the, the large yards we're down to a handful now. Next slide please. So this is the downward trend since the fifties, and these came from Mar's own figures. They went from building 5% of the world's commercial tonnage to less than uh, uh, two tenths of a percent today measured by gross tonnage.
SpeakerChina, Japan, South Korea now have 90% of global commercial ship building, and you'll see the numbers there. The other thing you have to look at is during this time, the tonnage, the size of vessels has grown exponentially. So not only are we not building the ships, we do not currently have the technology to build the largest, most advanced ships in the world. On a commercial side, there is not a US licensee to construct a slow speed diesel engine within the United States.
SpeakerThe large 950 foot LMSR, which are, which is a large medium speed roll on roll off. And these were constructed in, uh, nineties 99 to 2004 out of Nasco and Avondale for the military. So naval ships, but with civilian crews, they were not powered with slow speed diesels. The Nasco ships had gas turbines. GE LM 2,500 gas turbines and the Avondale ships had, uh, coal peel steps, medium speed diesels because as, as part of the package, they had to be built with US components and US does not have a slow speed diesel.
SpeakerAnd if you look at what's being powered, what's powering the world's merchant fleets, it's slow speed diesels, which are also then being modified for dual fuel. So they can also utilize LNG. For a greenhouse gas reductions. Next slide, please. So why does this why does this matter? Well, we are an island nation, and when we have such a reduced capacity, we cannot have enough tonnage in our Merchant Marine to support both our commercial and our military needs.
SpeakerUnder the Office of Naval Intelligence, the People Republic of China, became the world's top shield building and shipping nation with 230 times more building capacity than in the us. The interesting thing about this, if you, uh, if you, uh, keep an eye on anything that goes on out in the Taiwan straits periodically. The Chinese will get their merchant fleets together. 'cause a lot of their merchant fleets have been modified to support military operations. Similar to what we do with some of ours, but on a much larger scale'cause they have a lot more vessels.
SpeakerThe other thing about the Chinese and their ship building is the autonomous vessels, uh, in the South China Sea. China currently has the largest autonomous shipping testing facility in the world. So they are actively taking that shipyard building capacity and then also marrying it with their autonomous vessels cap technology. Uh, next slide please. So the economic exposures maritime is international trade. That's what we do. So 80% of the US goods are imported by sea.
SpeakerOf which 98% on foreign undocumented vessels while 2% under US flag vessels. So you can see this is a disproportionate with dependence on ocean going trade from foreign nations. It's gotten a lot of press lately, but it's actually been this way for quite some time. China has continued to expand shipbuilding the more technologically advanced ships. Are still built in. L and g ships are predominantly South Korea. Your high-end cruise ships out of a lot of Italian construction, but that's changing too.
SpeakerMost of your bulkers are built in China and just your basic container ships are built in China and they have the capacity to expand and they are expanding. So they, they continue to, secure orders. The order book in China continues to grow. I, I just returned from Singapore where I was at the International Union Marine Insurers Conference, and yeah, it's, there's no slowing down. It's continuing. There is, uh, there is some questions now about tariffs and things that are on, on, on the table to, impact Chinese built tonnage calling the us.
SpeakerBut they can, uh, there there's workarounds to that. So we are faced with, if we wanna change this, it's gonna have to be done on our own dime. Uh, next slide please. A fleet of commercial shipping vessels in the United States, crews with citizen mariners competitive in domestic and international trades. Great idea. It's been proven to work. It definitely helps, but even if you build the ships, uh, the people to man them are not there. For Jones Act compliant US flag vessel, it has to be either US nationals or naturalized citizens.
SpeakerSo at present, there are just 12,000 merchant Mariners operating ships. And where this impacts us, and it happened during both Gulf Wars is there are the RRF Ready reserve fleet, which is maintained by marad. And these are ships that are mothballed. Some kept in what's referred to as reduced operating status. So it can be activated within five year, uh, five days, five years, five days. There's a sliding scale. Some of'em are seven days and they have skeleton crews on board.
SpeakerYou'll have like five people on board just getting systems that are maintained long term so they can activate quicker. But what happens is when you break these ships out of mothballs, you have to man them. And what happens then is the people who are on vacation, because you rotate the crew that's off the ship to the crew that's on the ship'cause. Trust me, Crudo members don't like to be there for 12 months. For normally US flag you're dealing with at the longest, 120 day, a full month rotation. But even that can be difficult. So a lot of companies will go to a 90 or 60 day rotation to retain personnel.
SpeakerSo what happens is when you break these ships out in the time of national defense, then you have to man them with people who are on vacation. So you get called back to work and you work until it's over. It creates a lot of pressure on crew and you'll see a lot of people leaving the industry as a result because it's a tough lifestyle. You're away, four months and then when you're home, then you have to go to training and upgrading and things like that. And then you get the call and you gotta go back out. Wow. Yeah. Lo and behold, you'll find yourself out there for about 18 months straight.
SpeakerAnd, and that's, it's good for the bank account, but it's not good for the home life. Uh, trust me. Next slide please. The headwinds for us shipbuilding, we just talked about manning shortages at sea, but there's also workforce shortages in the US actually in the yards in the outdated facilities, uh, supply chain. If we're trying to build a Jones Act ship and we wanna use US source components, which is a requirement, well you have to have the additional infrastructure for those secondary and tertiary industries to manufacture those components.
SpeakerIt currently doesn't exist anymore in the states, and it didn't happen overnight, and it's not gonna get repaired overnight. So it's hiring and, and keeping skilled labor. Once they get their welding certificates down, they'll go somewhere else. You know, they'll work on building power plants, LNG plants, and then the yard capacity being limited and long lead times, which build schedules. If you also look at some of these yards, they're, they're in hurricane areas. Eastern ship building, a perfect example, got hit very hard, and as a result, their build schedules then slide, move to the right.
SpeakerAnd cost building a vessel in the US costs on a, a function of 10. If it's 10 million foreign, it's gonna be closer to a hundred million in the us It, it's not a function of two or three. It's, it's tough because the cost overruns and just workforce and materials and then also foreign subsidies. The Chinese yards operate under a lot of subsidies. So it's tough to compete and the US yards are outdated as far as layout, uh, automation and tooling.
SpeakerWhat we talk about when we talk about the layouts, us shipyards, traditionally were stick-built. You're laying the keel on the ways you know inclined ways, and then you're building up from there. Modern shipbuilding in the last two decades has changed completely. It's modular now. You are building the modules in blocks and then you're lifting and then welding together. That's not how us larges are. Yards are laid out, and quite honestly, most of the yards that had been in production, sparrows Point being a classic example, no longer exist.
SpeakerI was one of the last, uh, ships to come outta Sparrows Point when we converted the A class from Maersk. That would've been 95 in that era, somewhere around there. And by the time we pulled out of Sparrows Point, they closed the doors and I was back there, uh, a couple of years ago discharging Project Cargo and you wouldn't have known the yard was ever there. It's just a huge, super fun site now, unfortunately. So even if you wanna build the ships, the yards that you used to build them at are now going condo.
SpeakerAnd next slide please. So the Jones Act debate. What the Jones Act does is it requires us built, owned, and crude ships to operate in domestic trade. Critics, especially those people in Guam, Puerto Rico, and Hawaii, claim that it raises and inflates costs, but it supports shipyard demand. But adds friction to the domestic logistics and drives political division. It's always a pinata. So eliminating the Jones Act is, it's not gonna solve it, it's gonna just mask the problem. It, it will bring in cheaper tonnage, but it'll also bring in foreign nationals.
SpeakerAnd I don't think a lot of people want a 30 barge tow going down the Mississippi with foreign crews when it's loaded with. Potentially volatile cargo. So it's, uh, this blueprint is an interesting from a think tank. Uh, it gives some interesting insights into it. But for right now, we'll, we'll go on next slide please. So why does this matter? Why does it matter if we have us ships with US crews? Alright, next slide. These are just some of the, uh. Some of the support that vessels you.
SpeakerMerchant crude, civilian crude, charted vessel support. On the left, you have what's called Lolo lift on liftoff cargo, going into a multipurpose vessel. This actually is the Alex Bondman. We were loading out during the first Gulf War. So what you're doing is on the stern of this vessel, you had a stern ramp. So you're driving cargo on, on the, in the tween decks here, midships. You were lifting cargo on, and then there was a side port that you were driving more cargo on. So you're trying to stuff as much in as quick as you can, PO as you can.
SpeakerThis was Wilmington. We were loading Marine Corps stuff, if I remember correctly. Now, on the right, that shot is an M1, A one tank rolling up the stern ramp of an LMSR. Now, the reason this is an important consideration here is commercial roll-on roll-off ships cannot support this kind of weight. Commercial roll-on roll-off ships where you see the big box ships or you know, they look like a floating shoebox that have cars on them, are designed to support the weight of a car or a truck.
SpeakerThese stern ramps on the LMS R that you see on the right with the embarker giving signals are designed for 160 ton weight, and that is one M1 A one tank towing. Another M1 A one tank up that stern ramp, and that's what it's designed for in the event that we have broken. Damaged cargo, which on the return trips, trust me, you do, I've, you call it roll on, roll off row, row on the way there, and dodo drag on, drag off on the way back. So these vessels, not only can they support the needs of the military, they're also designed to support those needs.
SpeakerSo that's critical. Uh, next slide please. Uh, on the left, uh, APCs. That are chained into a tween deck, railroad deck on an LMSR. What I'd like you to focus on here is look at the height clearance between those overhead beams and the A PC top that is designed to support those types of armament. On a commercial row, row vessel that wouldn't fit.
SpeakerIt's too high. So your tween decks, your rolling, rolling stock decks, not only can they support the weight low where those tracks are, that decking there is heavier than a normal commercial roll on roll off vessel that's delivering new Hondas or Toyotas. Also those chains that are securing that. In a crossed fashion with the turn buckles, the lashings on a commercial standard commercial vessel would not properly secure those.
SpeakerThis is a marshaling yard. On the right, you can see the M1 A one tanks, and then you see what's normally loaded on commercial vessels, which are all those containers. On these multipurpose vessels, you're loading the heavy armament, but then you're also loading ta uh, containers as well. Those containers normally. Contain ammunition. So it's a class one container. There are requirements for class one carriage, so you have to have them separated from accommodation spaces and other things. And once again, normal commercial vessels will not have all that, uh, capacity.
SpeakerAnd next slide. So in, in addition to having the hardware that can support the military support missions, you also need personnel and foreign flag crews will not, or cannot, in many cases, go in harm's way where a US flag crew can. On the right, you have a US flagged commercial tanker. That is doing what's referred to a console fueling operation for a carrier in the carrier carrier battle group.
SpeakerNow Unre is when the ship coming alongside the naval asset has the gear and sends it over. Console is is where the merchant vessel has a securing point on deck, but it doesn't have the hoses or gear. Uh, the span wire is passed over from the naval asset tensioned, and then the hoses are passed over and then the merchant ship pumps. But this is a highly specialized. See cargo transfer. This has been utilized quite a bit in the last eight months because there was a grounding of an MSC underway replenishment ship in the Gulf of Oman that took that underway replenishment asset out of service.
SpeakerAnd as a result, they had to bring in the merchant ships for console ops to keep the carriers and the battle groups fueled. Now on this particular carrier, it's a nuclear carrier. Why do you need jet fuel? The planes, so carriers, when you're in a battle group and they're flying sorties, you've gotta refuel the carrier about every three days to give it juice, to fly the planes, and then the rest of the escorts you're refueling about every other day. On, so I spent time on ary replenishment.
SpeakerThe, they stay busy now on the left. This is an LMSR large median speed roll on roll off, and it has lighter edge sections on the left. That A-frame is what's, the barge with the A-frame is a powered causeway section, and it's referred to as a side loading warping tug. So in this particular scenario, that stern ramp goes down, goes onto a floating causeway section, a stern of the vessel and the. Armor is rolled off, secured on these barges and then sent ashore.
SpeakerYou're not gonna get a foreign crew to be able to do that. They won't do it. You can also see on this shot on the left, the cranes are also at work. So you're doing low, low ops as well as the rower ops off the, uh, off the stern ramp. And this is the say which was, uh, one of the Bob Hope class built outta Avondale. Uh, next slide please. Little blast from the past for me here. This is aam Saudi Arabia, and you're looking at two in the foreground, two of the watermen class ships that are discharging, uh, Marine Corps cargo.
SpeakerAnd then on the back corner, that's a, uh, amps C, which were built in Quincy Mass. One of the last ships classes to be built in Quincy before the Quincy Yard shut down. This is First Gulf War. The AM Mc ships came out of Guam and Saipan, where they were prepo. The Waterman ships were pre POed in the Mediterranean and the Maersk line ships, which are not pictured here'cause they'd already discharged and were back to the states for a back load, came outta Diego Garcia. So we've sailed outta Diego Garcia. We are up in the Gulf discharging in Saudi.
SpeakerWithin four days, uh, the AMC and the Waterman ships followed us in. Discharging after us, and then we returned to the US and fell. It was called into the common user pool. We discharged our pre-position cargo and then went back and brought over Air Force and Army cargo. But this was, uh, the initial deployment during the first Gulf War and Hadam, you'll see in the, in the upper right, the helos that had already been discharged and, uh, were being prepped. The first Gulf War actually gave the military some really bad ideas because they thought every country they were gonna go to would have these huge ports ready to roll into that weren't currently in use.
SpeakerThe Saudi Arabia had built these ports for a 25 year plan. They're currently fully operational today, but at the time they had been built and were mothballed so we could pull in and use them, and it was state-of-the-art facilities. After this, we ended up in Somalia, which was a different story, but you could see here the amount of pier space we had in aam was impressive. Uh, next slide please. This is the second Gulf War, and here we have the LM srs, a converted LMSR in the foreground.
SpeakerAnd on the other side of the pier. That's a new build, LMSR. These LSRs were what the Army came up with after the Marine Corps had pre-positioned tonnage that we just saw in the first Gulf War. Well, after the first Gulf War, the Army said, whoa, we want this too. But being the Army, they wanted it bigger than Marine Corps. So instead of the 750 foot Prepo Marine Corps, you got the 950 foot LM srs. So these are, uh, discharging in, in Kuwait during the second Gulf War.
SpeakerYou could see in the upper left, there's another LMSR, they're discharging on the other side of the pier. And then in the, in the top right there's another LMSR discharging. So we dropped a lot off in Kuwait for the second one. But you can see on this shot, you've got containers, you've got rolling stock, you've got break bulk, everything going into theater. So there's a lot moving in a very short time. Uh, next slide please. So we've touched on a lot here. We've touched on the, the decline why it's important.
SpeakerWe haven't really discussed the. Next step because that remains to be seen. There is at present, changing on a, on a weekly and daily basis, a lot of talk about Korean investment in yards. You have the Kempel AmFELS yard that just sold this week. It was announced. It, that was a Singapore interest. That had been a lot of pressure that they claimed to have Chinese influence. The government was not happy that they were, uh, building US ships down in Brownsville, Texas. And that sale was just announced I think three days ago.
SpeakerSo it's, it's, you've got the Korean interest in Philly. Where they're, uh, where they're currently building ships. So it's a changing, rapidly changing environment right now. Landscape and how it plays out. I don't know. We'll find out, but, uh, I definitely hope something changes because we are seriously understaffed right now under the deep sea tonnage arena for the us and we need this infrastructure to support. Our national interest and also to support maritime interest.
SpeakerThere's a lot of potential for investment and there's a lot of potential for business interest. There's a lot of, a lot of potential for insurance because as these lar yards are lar yards are built up, all the support to keep them running in the secondary industries will require coverage. So whether it's the welding, the pipe shops, the electricians, all that, and all the support, because they're not going to have 10,000 people on the payroll.
SpeakerThey're gonna be bringing in subs as they, as they start up. So this is something where. There's a tremendous potential for insurers. And I, I hope we start to turn it around, but if there's any questions, please feel free to ask. And next slide. Just get our contact information up there. Oh, back one. There we are. If you have it, any questions or concerns about this or any of the maritime matter? If you just wanna bounce it off somebody, please feel free to reach out.
SpeakerI'm always available and, uh, kinda live and breathe this stuff. So happy to discuss it with you further. And Andrea, I'll pass it back to you.
Speaker 2Okay. Well thank you for taking the time out of your day today to meet with us. Um, if you have any Oh, looks like we have one more question there.
SpeakerUh, how much, what was that funding from the ships act?
Speaker 2Yes, is coming into the ships Act,
SpeakerRight now. Nothing. It's unfunded. That's kind of the question. Traditionally every year Marat has been announcing small shipyard funding grants, which has been traditionally under 10 million, broken up into smaller yards. But right now both the, um. Both the ships act and the the bills are, are stalled. So there is currently no funding that I have seen and no concrete action plan has been developed.
SpeakerHope that answers it for you, Ralph.
Speaker 2Yes. Thank you, Ralph. Um, if you have any other questions, please feel free to reach out to Andrew at Andrew Ken dot kinsey@iscmga.com and then be on the lookout for a follow-up email with today's recording of this session or one of our sessions from today. And if you have any feedback or topics, please reach out to marketing@iscmga.com. Yes, I will please send. I will send this recording to your email.
Captain Andrew Kinsey, ISC Marine's loss control specialist, covers lithium-ion battery risk from two angles: underwriting cargo shipments containing lithium batteries, and safe use and handling once devices are already...
Marq, an underwriter with ISC Marine (three years underwriting cargo at Allianz, then a decade as a national cargo broker at Willis before joining ISC), walks through general cargo - also called general marine cargo or...
There's a tariff penalty on the books right now that Customs and Border Protection cannot reduce, waive, or negotiate under any circumstances: a flat 40% ad valorem charge, applied the moment CBP determines a shipment...
Most shipping containers that leave a US port for Asia go back completely empty. It's a simple, visible symptom of the US trade deficit, and just one of several ripple effects Captain Andrew Kinsey walks through in this...
Captain Andrew Kinsey, ISC Marine's loss control specialist and a former risk engineer on nuclear waste treatment projects at Hanford and Savannah River, gives a global tour of nuclear power's current state and where...